Personally, i am completely shocked letting in one million young men from North Africa and the middle east with little to no vetting led to an increase in crime
It wouldn't change much. Southern Germany is one of the regions with more immigrants in all of Europe and it's one of the safest regions as well. The real problem isn't migration but gang proliferation in Northern and Eastern Germany - many of those gangs are actually related to Latin America and the Eastern mafia, and not the Middle East. Unless you kill the drug trade the crime rate won't decrease. But of course you won't do anything because those criminals are mostly Catholic.
@@fryphillipj560 Look up what happened in Cologne, Germany 2015 on New Years Eve. Also look at why Norway had to make women's rights classes compulsory to Muslim migrants. Should be enlightening for you.
@@ickebins6948There is no one in Poland who wants to create a caliphate, the police and army are active.Cities are clean and safe, but German cities are huge toilets
@@Mr.DalekLK I've seen alot of cities in germany and the ones that are kinda dirty were like that for the last 30 years. So nothing new. Btw. crimerates decrased after 2015 and just recently gone up again... Looks like ukrainians have something to do with that?
We now have demonstrants openly advocating for the creation of a caliphate in Germany. As well as an Islamist party (DAVA) that formed very recently. Thinking about moving to the other side of the Oder/Neiße if things continue like this.
They are letting in too many engineers and talented businesspeople who make money! Not enough disreputable types. In a more serious answer, the usa (it can be whatever example not only the usa) had big public works projects to get people going and get a variety of business going
@@mrmr446 Sweden went from one of the safest countries in the world to the second worst in Europe in regards to violent crimes. Do you think this is normal? Just because the US is worst it does not mean this is OK.
@@markdowding5737 So you haven't been then? Second highest in Europe according to whom? Have seen some very poor reporting on this is why I ask. Do I think it is normal that crime rates fluctuate?
Remember Germany never really had an empire. It and its culture institutions have never historically had to deal with immigration. The UK is one of if not the best countries in the world when it comes to immigration integration. So wonder they have 99 problems and immigration one.
@@the80386 I think you missed his point. The UK suffers from integration problems despite having a history of immigration, due to it's empire. The USA also suffers from similar problems, despite being a country of immigrants! Germany doesn't have the benefit of such experience, yet decided to allow in a large number of immigrants over a relatively short period of time, so perhaps it's not surprising that they're also having integration problems, as are Sweden.
@@Toodyslexicforyou The UK has the same issues of an explosion in crime, terrorist attacks, mass r*pe of its women by Pakistani men, the immigrant community aggressively asserting themselves over the natives. There is no integration. Multiculturalism is fundamentally not integration...
Yeah like when some dusky son of Somalia invariably commits a violent sexual crime in the UK and gets described as "Bristol man" or some such gaslighting BS.
Swedens is because of failed government policies to integrate foreigners to swedish society, africans and middle easterners especially. The new right wing government isn't any better at it either
Former UK police officer here, I did a training course with the Germany police in 2018 in Koln, their crime stats were shocking, especially burglaries, in a siilar size area they had in a day what we had in in a week. The stats they showed us said it was all down to immigration, and those "German" offenders were nearly all Turkish, Albanian or similar descent.
Suspects, not offenders. The majority of burglaries are never resolved, so there’s no reliable data pointing to migrants being responsible. The fact that most that are caught are migrants could also be linked to the way the police investigate.
@@nom_nom_nom_ No they don’t. Only a small portion of suspects are charged, as in most cases there‘s insufficient evidence, i.e. because those suspected turn out to be innocent, and of those charged, not all are convicted. *In the end the overrepresentation of some groups is decreased in the judicial statistics compared to the stats provided by the police.
@@RichelieuUnlimited Think you're clutching at straws here mate, there may be a small differential between suspects and charged/convicted offenders, but it's negligable.
If you bring people into a country without integrating them, you get a bunch of unintegrated people... immigrants are not the issue, how the country is handling the immigrants is...
@@monkeeseemonkeedoo3745 Immigrants are not the issue if they are actually integrated (for which too little has been done). The real issue are refugees who are actually forbidden from work and given limited resources while having no legal avenues to better their situation as well as a lot of boredom in a country of vastly different culture. What do you expect them to do if not causing problems under these circumstances?
I am from Prague, just couple of hours from Berlin, and I never see police with automatic weapons here. Having to have so heavily armed police is not a good sign.
In Canada, it’s with the government letting in many Punjabi gangs with ties to the Khalistan movement. The government actually gives asylum and later citizenship to those whose names are listed with the Interpol.
Sweden has a lower homicide rate than Finland, which has taken in far less migrants (not to mention neighboring Baltics, who took in practically no non-European refugees at all). In fact it’s lower than it was in the 80s! Gangland shootings and bombs make for riveting news in international media that are always looking for clicks and love the narrative of a “lost utopia” in Sweden, but this is just not born out by statistics.
A disturbing trend involves attacking and harrassing emergency medical, fire and rescue services at large public events like New Year's Eve celebrations. That sort of thing was all but unheard of a decade ago.
It is not like endtime started in Germany. There are many right wingers in Germany who became paranoid because they spent too much time on right wing platforms. In the cities, where most of the migrants live there is no real opposition to migration because these endtime scenarios due to migration do only exist in the head of xenophobic right wingers. 🤷
@@maxman4948 oh yes, it is totally the government that stops you from speaking your mind. News flash, freedom of speech doesn’t protect you from consequences, if the things you say get you in trouble all the time, start looking for resources to support your points, because that’s a clear sign your points are filled with hatred rather then facts.
or that your points make people uncomfortable and therefore are not advertiser friendly. Almost as if RUclips et al want to sell ads for profit or something...
Yeah? And You remember the recent uptick of immigration, which "caused" the uptick in the crime rate? Yeah, it was 2022 and almost all because of Ukrainians, but in the crime rate they don't account for much, now do they. But something else happened, which corelates better with crime: economic slowdown
@@norude Sweden has been totally fucked up by mass migration long before any economic slowdowns, the same applies to all major European cities in the last 20 years. I'd say economic stagnation will only make it worse.
What is completely forgotten to mention here is that the german crime statistics are not statistics about crime in germany per se, but rather statistics about german police work. I'll try to explain what I mean by that now. At the beginning of each year, the police set certain priorities, e.g. more focus on left, right, migration-related, internet fraud, etc... Logically, the statistics on recorded offenses go up when the focus changes. This cannot and should not be ignored. That's what pretty much every scientist who studies these statistics says. Again, these statistics are not a direct representation of crime in Germany, but rather a testimony to the police work carried out in Germany. The whole thing is called Police Crime Statistics (PKS in germany), but for some reason people in Germany believe that these are actual crime statistics, which is simply not the case. Incidentally, these statistics also include cases that were reopened, i.e. a crime could have happened in 2010 but is only now listed as solved. In addition, many crimes are missing from these statistics, such as crimes such as state security offenses, administrative offenses, traffic offenses and offenses that are not part of the police's remit, such as financial and tax offenses. For this reason, customs and tax crimes, which are usually reported and processed directly by the public prosecutor's office, are also missing from the PCS. Another very important point is that the PCS does not reflect the number of crimes committed in a year, but rather those that were investigated by the police. This means that every year the PKS contains numerous cases that may have occurred the year before or even earlier. Even a crime that could not be solved because no perpetrator was identified is included in the PCS. If, on the other hand, it turns out in the course of the police investigation that a suspicion cannot be substantiated, i.e. that there is no crime at all, the report will not be included in the PCS. Overall, only around 30 percent of all suspects are convicted. However, all of these results are no longer included in the PKS. It cannot therefore be compared with statistics from the judiciary, such as the criminal prosecution statistics from the Federal Statistical Office. I think this information is important to really understand these statistics.
That is an excellent explanation. Ex If Germany used the Swedish method to measure crimes, the crime rate would at least be around 30 percent higher in Germany.
It's not just mass migration in general. We're not seeing young men from the Philippines, Thailand, Brazil or Ukraine topping the crime charts - those tend to come from Islamic countries: North Africa, Afghanistan, Pakistan, etc. And it's particularly scary, because any interracial marriage with those group means that a German girl assimilate into their culture, and not the other way around. So the social incompatibility issue will likely protract generation after generation. And the same pattern is copypasted in almost every other Western European country: the UK, Sweden, France, the Netherland, Belgium... now even in Italy, with still relatively low number of muslim migrants (4-5% of the population), we have them constituing almost 40% of incarcerated.
Yeah obviously it is when they all came before the spike. Could never have anything to do with Ukrainians whose arrival coincided with it, that's just a coincidence
Obviously it's because of immigration. I don't know why the host even hesitates here, the data is absolutely clear, and he showed some of it. What he failed to mention is that not only are immigrants without German citizenship overrepresented in violent crimes, but among the German citizens committing violent crime, a disproportionate number of them are also immigrants or their descendants. Denmark has data on the origin of criminals, and as you would expect, Danish people and most European immigrants have a low crime rate while Muslims and Africans have an extremely high crime rate. This is the same pattern throughout Europe. Regarding the absurd talking point that this is due to lack of integration. No, it's not. It is due to the lack of selective immigration. If you select your immigrants well, then you can avoid having a criminally inclined immigrant population, but if you don't select your immigrants well, because you let anyone come and live in your country, then you are going to have problems with criminally inclined immigrant populations. Sweden is the best example of this, they let huge numbers of low quality immigrants into their country, and now they are suffering the consequences. Think of it like this, which country has been successful in integrating large numbers of unselected Africans and Muslims? The answer is none. No country in Europe or the rich world has done this, the US has different immigrants and more selective immigration. No one even knows what integration would mean in this situation. How is a country supposed to integrate such alien populations in such large numbers? There's no way to do that.
@@tbk2010 That has been done for decades now. We can keep trying to make up scenarios of "could/should/would" be something else and hope everything changes by itself, but the reality is pretty clear and its the same with every single country.
I think the US is a horrible example for low crime rates 😂 Glad we don't have US style crime and poverty rates here in Europe. That said, there are as mentioned in the video only two options: 1. Humane but costly integration 2. Inhumane but cheap exclusion The middle ground of cheap integration is obviously failing, leading to poor, unemployed young men without hope doing what they always do. With the many costly challenges coming towards us (e.g. climate change, population aging), most people will not opt for option 1...
If you come into a foreign country, it’s YOUR JOB to integrate, not the state’s. How is “migrants being poorer and younger” an excuse to insane crime rate hike?
It isn't the state's job, but it is the state's job to not actively make it harder to integrate. I worked at a convenience store that also handled immigration papers (just Finland things) during the start of the 2022 invasion of Ukraine during which time lots of Ukrainian refugees came to my city. The city shoved all of them into a suburb that was an hour bus ride from the actual city with no resources, no hospital, no bank, and an already extant drug crisis among the locals. If you put a large amount of people into the exact environment that locals become criminals too, don't be surprised when the people you shoved into the criminal factory also become criminals.
that's like letting a random man inside your house and expecting him to know the laws of the land. You're a host nation, so fulfill the tasks of a host.
"it’s YOUR JOB" no? Integration is a 2 way lane, we want something from them, they want something from us. Acting like we are better just because we were born here is the most stupid thing i could think of.
@@lemmyboy410790% of this conversation is just nationalism, most of these people see higher crime and need a boogieman, that’s how nationalism works, whatever the issue is, it’s never the native populations fault (even if the majority of the world is experiencing the same due to, the pandemic, increase in poverty which increases crime overall)
If you bring people into a country without integrating them, you get a bunch of unintegrated people... immigrants are not the issue, how the country is handling the immigrants is...
@@elwoodzmake You cannot integrate people if you bring them in by millions. If you bring them few at the time, you are forcing them to speak the language and interact with germans. If you import millions at the same time they will form their own communities, speak their home languages and will not integrate with the rest of society. There is no way to handle integration when the numbers are so incredibly large.
@@elwoodzmake Integration is about the cultural aspect. That doesn't have anything to do with violent crime. You don't have to integrate someone to make them understand attacking another person is wrong.
All you need to do is look at what happened in Cologne, Germany 2015 on New Years Eve. Should be enlightening. Don't forget about Sweden either with its gang crime
And those who stand the most to lose (women) where out in Cologne, parading for tolerance like 2 days later. The fact that they tried to paint it as a male problem that has nothing to do with culture was the icing on the cake. Backstabbery.
Probably all those poor migrants, such as the Montenegrin people, Armenians, Vietnamese, Thai, etc., we all know poor = crime, definitely nothing else!
Same trend in crime across Denmark and the Netherlands. It's important to not conflate all immigrants with being criminals though, it's *certain* countries which are disproportionately over represented in crime statistics, majority come from countries which follow the religion of peace.
maybe these countries should take a note on how islam handles crime and welfare. i.e.; Harsher punishments and better welfare programs for poor people. But you people only like to blame islam when something goed wrong, not when things go right.
Regarding that "crime in Spain fell" bit; As someone personally affected by crime by the usual suspects in Spain and with a few acquitances in the police force, I can tell you that's just because they simply stopped reporting or investigating anything regarding certain demographics, with the possible exception of drug traffiking....... If anything, crime has gone higher in my city in northern Spain with a really high fraction of certain demographics, and I assure you, no native thinks crime has gone down, no matter how much makeup they put on the statistics.
As a German, this drives me beyond mad and has shifted my views from very left-leaning to more conservative. Unfortunately, I don't know what to do. No party in Germany at the moment seems capable of tackling this issue. AfD and Wagenknecht would just make it worse since they are populists, and I am very pro-NATO/EU, so I cannot vote for them under any circumstances. SPD, Grüne, Volt, Linke, etc., just won't admit the problem since it goes against their views on migration. CDU/CSU allowed so many unskilled migrants into the country, and now they are complaining, but under Merkel, they were the ones who did this! I love Germany very much, especially Munich, but I absolutely hate the fact that this issue is likely to get worse. I wish the SPD would find someone like Helmut Schmidt again!
We need a secular party that understands that an unsafe country can never be a free country, and that understands that we like our cultures and values, we want to keep our hard won social freedoms and will stop the peacefulization of our societies. In every European country. It's so frustrating to have nobody I can vote for anymore. I'm a secular social democrat and both the right wing and the left wing now are at the beck and call of clerics. It's maddening. We have no voice in Europe anymore.
Merkel is no longer in charge so you can vote for CDU alternatively you might consider AFD but they suck I get it. German politics suck, I get it. I'm Polish, it isn't much better over here. We can vote for corrupt socialist which is PiS, your loyal dog Donald Tusk, the Left which is obviously the worst, Third Way which is essentially voting for Tusk, or confederation which is kinda like AFD but not quite. I'm voting confederation cause they got a few good leaders and I'm done with other parties but I see that they're deeply flawed as well.
Merkel is no longer in charge so you can vote for CDU alternatively you might consider AFD but they suck I get it. German politics suck, I get it. I'm Polish, it isn't much better over here. We can vote for corrupt socialist which is PiS, your loyal dog Donald Tusk, the Left which is obviously the worst, Third Way which is essentially voting for Tusk, or confederation which is kinda like AFD but not quite. I'm voting confederation cause they got a few good leaders and I'm done with other parties but I see that they're deeply flawed as well.
In Germany the government is more concerned with repressing the average citizen with exorbitant taxes, bureaucracy and over-regulation than repressing criminality
Well said @kreight. Germany is one of the EU countries where its most difficult to build wealth if you are doing honest business cause they want to take everything away from you...
They are busy creating a music friendly environment. That's why they plan to increase the tax on meat - starting with pork. The generated tax is supposed to be used to better the living conditions of all farm animal. Increasing the quality af halal meat with no muslim contribution. That is dschizya-light
I mean a rise in migrants and a dip in the economy can both contribute. I know the left and right like to only blame 1 or the other but they're not mutually exclusive
But the reality is clearly in favor of the left wing explanation. Studies have clearly shown that migrants are more likley to be in poverty, studies also have shown that poor people are more likley to commit crimes, the data shows that crimes are going up even with germans. Everything points to more people falling into poverty resulting in more people doing crimes. It is actually more likley that migration is slowing down that process, but that is not really proven by studies so im not using that as an argument.
Since a non-zero amount of people in general commit crime, immigration from *anywhere* technically increases crime But when right wingers say it they only say black and brown migrants are to blame
Some perspective, I lived in Munich from 2018 into 2022, and the absence of crime was so noticeable coming from the U.S., it was like living in an alternate world. One could leave their things out in a park or at a lake and not worry about theft, and no one worried being out late at night. Frankfurt, where I live now is a different matter. The area around the Hauptbahnhof is a disaster. Lots of immigrants involved in the drug trade and the area is simply not safe late at night when foot traffic ebbs. The problems are obvious, but the government is doing nothing to address the issue. I do not doubt that voters will respond.
So personal sorry, I myself have come to Germany as a legal immigrant, I was coming from a place and thanks to DB my last train was cancelled and next train was at 6am. Thinking Frankfurt is a safe city I went outside to get a casual walk , Jesus Christ the stuff I saw that night I can't forget ever in my life. I simply ran back to the station and sat on a bench near the police, I was scared to the core and made a note that I will never cross Frankfurt city borders after 10pm 😂😂
Frankfurt a.M. has a major drug epidemic, centered around the Hauptbahnhof. I don't think it has anything to do with immigration. I stayed in Frankfurt for one week in 2011, and I remember how shocked I was by the amount of homeless people openly camping there. I recall these people as being almost all Germans. I have not been to Frankfurt since, maybe the picture has changed. But to my knowledge the drug problem of Frankfurt a.M. predates the recent immigration.
This is what happens when you fill a country with Europeans! 🤪. That's why Pakistan, Algeria, and Syria all collapsed, Europeans flooded those countries!
@@arnonym5430 By "sharing their beds" I was refering to Germans welcoming illegal immigrants into their country and even paying them as refugees, thus sharing their money and their country with the illegal immigrants. Relating to the top comment of this section, Germans made itself a nice bed (their country), but they made the mistake to share that bed (their country) with the illegal immigrants whom they welcomed and who messed up their bed (their country). I was not refering to the actual meaning of "sharing a bed" by any means.
Olaf was never someone to try solve Something with hugs. Because that would imply that he did Something at all. His special skill is to do absolutely nothing and when asked about things, to answer "I can not remember".
@@ickebins6948 Then you have the first graphs. Crime index 27,1 until 2015 and 32,6 from 2016. Why are you omitting it? Not fitting your narrative I guess..
@@violet_green4335 Because to my knowledge, the "crime Index" is an estimation of crime levels in a given country or city. And the graph at 2:12 are the exact numbers for crimes (per 100000) for Germany. I could not really find anything about how exactly the "crime index" is estimated. It's a strange metric (0-100 scale).
No, we should get away from that "integration" story altogether. What we need is assimilation. If as a second or third generations migrant (i.e. Germans whose parents/grandparents were migrants) anything other than the skin/hair color or last name makes you seem like a foreigner we have an issue.
I wouldn't say "fewer migrants" but maybe "fewer migrants from global south". germany's low birthrates makes her reliant (in the long term) on migration but I believe if every middle eastern migrant was replaced with spanish migrant, and every north african with polish, although not perfect, germany's situation wouldn't be that dire (at least in crime rates or polarization). I don't mean to offend people that come from global south but I believe that cultural differences are too big, and russian threat too high, for (most) of them actually adapt and become members of german (or any european country for that matter) society.
The traditional big countries of Europe have been Germany, France, the UK and Italy. Population and economy wise... Poland with less than 40 million people and a GDP of $1,801 trillion (less than half of the population of Germany which currently has a population of almost 85 million and a GDP of $5,700 trillion) is not anywhere near those aforementioned.
Yeah WE Had a funny Case in Germany where a rich liberal neighbohood got a Refugees Center....and Now suddelny there are Protests against it....because ITS in their neighbohood 😂
Besides the “usual suspects”, the police is also a problem. I heard a great quote from a long time ago: “The police is like a ghost. When you need them, they are nowhere to be seen; when you don’t need them, they are everywhere.”
Same for the Netherlands I guess, most crime is done by people with a Dutch passport, but they are a certain group of Dutch people with a North African background. Mostly Moroccan
We have too many immigrants. And I'm speaking as an immigrant myself. It's so crazy if you think about it. When we came to Germany we were only a few but after 2014 the amount of immigrants just exploded.
The west shouldnt have bombed their country, city, neighborhood, street and house 😅 what did you expect? The west only know how to destroy these immigrants would have never migrated if it wasn’t the usa and eu
Graph @2:12 : After 2015 it went down quick, just recently it going back up again. Why? Maybe the ukrainian refugees? Not fitting your narrative I guess..
Sweden and Germany have allowed their own citizens to face all sorts of terrible turmoil. Now they need to pay for their terrible decisions. There is no integrating those who don't want to be integrated, rather, want to make their new homes like their former ones; utterly destroyed and in ruins. Thank God that is not my problem.
The elite making decisions that it profits from, while the common people suffer the consequences. A tale as old as time. In the 20th century our elite chose for war, in the 21th century our elite chooses for mass-immigration.
Yeah, but it just really sucks for normal people who were against that from the beginning and a culture, where you get called a Nazi just for saying logically we cannot take in a limitless amount of people while having limited capacity.
Fun fact: The percentage of people supporting democracy as the best form of government is 81%, when you ask Muslims in Germany. When you ask the total population, it's only 70%.
@@_jpg Yeah true... many people see Muslims as a bunch of uncultured simpletons who love dictatorships. They should visit cities like Algiers, Baghdad or Cairo for a reality check. And those who move abroad are even more progressive.
It truly is a question for the ages, what POSSIBLY could cause such a thing? I don't think millions of people could've predicted this, gotta save the GDP from demographic collapse right? At the expense of everything else. Because the most important thing is that precious GDP number that must go up forever. Who cares about the petty social concerns of the people/resources
Just that after 2015 it went down. So your reason is even by the data shown completly wrong. Shoudl save the world by people like you trying everything to force their ideology
@@lemmyboy4107 "those without German passports are now responsible for nearly 60% of all violent crimes" - 5:20 Tell me more about the ideology i'm "forcing", keep in mind also that when he says that those individuals are still a vast minority compared to the ones that do have passports, so the over-representation is massive. I ask sincerely, why the constant denial? Are you all just waiting until it happens to you before you admit it's a problem? And is the pursuit of ever-growing GDP and taxes really worth all this trouble and suffering? Are we really all just resources of the state or do our culture, history, language and common traits matter?
@@detdeet Are you just ignoring that they are rhe majority in low income households. Thats where you force your ideology. you completly igmore that with same circumstances germans are just as likley to commit crimes.
Ah yes.! The Great Immigration Ponzi scheme..! We need more and more immigrants and then as they get older we need more to replace them.....and so on....etc etc..
Hahah how ignorant can you be. Maybe it's the fact that other nations pillaged them and their resources for decades, using them for their own growth. And often leaving them in chaos when deciding colonialism is bad. Also then causing wars and general chaos in those regions to still further the interes of rich people. Tell me, how is it the people's fault they were born in and live in a poor region, without a way to enrich themselves???
People use the word “RACIST” like a sword. If something doesnt go their way they use the word “racist.” After so many uses a sword becomes dull and not as effective, same with calling someone racist.
Its mostly women who will use the Nazi and Racism insults, guess they were already blacked or browned by these guys before - makes it easier to avoid them
We all know why, immigrants, it's the same reason it's increasing here in Spain. We've gone from a rate of 3 rapes per 100k in 2015 to a rate of over 10 rapes per 100k last year.
As i german prison warden.... I see a.... pattern in the people I control... and its mostly both reasons. Foreigners and econemy. Both are the 2 biggest partys.
As an American that lived in Germany I've never lived in a more violent area. The city I lived in was small with a population of about 100,000 . During my 3 years there I saw multiple murders in the news and I had two friends assaulted in the center of town. from what I saw 60 to 70 percent of the crime was Arab and the rest was committed by traditional germans.
The EU actually wanted to expel Orban..!! The Euro elections in June will hopefully destroy the liberal left pro immigration lobby within the EU. Too late for Germany and Sweden probably...
@@soundscape26nope, extremism and a sick cult of death like Islamism does. Naive Neo Marxist. You’ll find yourself like communist Iranians once the cards are down: either unalived by the Islamist hand once you’ve served your purpose of propping them up into power or forced to live under their oppression like the poor people of Iran do today
@@martinjnagy it's a corrupt oligarchy thats in bed with China and Russia. However, it has been extremely against letting immigrants in since 2015. As a result crime has not risen like in most of the continent
@@martinjnagy Well, we have a hybrid-authoritarian system, our healthcare is in ruins, but in terms of crime, I would say its better. However, we also have our own "migrants", called gypsies. North-eastern Hungary is filled with them. And it shows in the crime statistics in those areas.
@@martinjnagy They got a corrupt power hungry dictator as president but at least he doesn't allow Budapest to turn into Islamabad and that's a big plus.
Too many are still sleeping. This is about migrant crime rates exploding in Germany, and in Germany still more people vote for the parties promoting mass migration than for the ones actually trying to restrict mass migration. There's no real change and nor real hope in sight yet.
Proud german here. There is only one reason and it is called migration. Deport to Afghanistan, Lebanon, Syria, Chechnya, Nigeria, Tunisia, Eritrea, Algeria, Morocco, Albania and Turkey and most of the problems will go away immediately. Did I forget an country? And it will start inevitably. There is no way around anymore.
This is why we need crime profiling for origin of birth, gender, religious/political background. And yes, it makes me as uncomfortable to say that as it is for you to read this. But here is the problem. If we don't, people start generalizing wildly. And it becomes ammunition for racist propaganda. The reality is that its very likely certain groups of people who are over-represented. We must treat the people who are doing their best to live up to our standards fairly and not use such a broad term as "immigrants are the problem".
I don't think the current political systems are able to have nuance. You either get brainrot lefties decrying racism for every little criticism, or racist af rightoids making it only about race and nothing else. Oddly, the two are made for each other, they justify each other's existence. It's sad tbh
@@socialistrepublicofvietnam1500 The difference is that in Australia we get to select people. In EU they don’t have a moat to keep the undesirables in Nauru.
why do we have to go through strict security at the airport? It wasn't Buddhists hijacking planes and flying them into buildings. why do we put extra bollards on pedestrian streets? it wasn't Hindus mowing people down with their cars in the name of Shiva. We got 100k Hongkongers in the UK recently but we don't have Hongkonger grooming gangs. Not all cultures adapt easily to our values.
I’m all for supporting human rights but turning a blind eye to checks and balances in immigration especially for folks who refuse to assimilate is plain daft. It isn’t about skilled or unskilled migrants, it’s about letting in folks who don’t respect the culture and are plain resistant to integrating. There’s enough data from multiple studies to show that immigrants benefit the economy overall but that isn’t possible unless the sort of people a country lets in is actually interested in participating in the economic system which can only happen in conjunction with linguistic and cultural integration. Neither political faction is entirely right but they aren’t entirely wrong either.
White collar crimes annoy people, sure, but the relative annoyance of having some rich fuck embezzle 2 million company euros versus getting fatally stabbed by a 19 year old Yemeni in a mugging aren't really on the same level are they
@@soundscape26 White collar crime doesn't involve a physical confrontation. If you're attacked or robbed or you have your property destroyed, there is a physical threat to your person and there's always a risk of violent escalation whenever "blue collar" crime happens. White collar crime usually involves embezzling from a company.
The figures from Spain only look that good because A) squatting and smoking weed doesn't count as a crime. B) black work and corruption aren't registered in the first place. C) selling forged Gucci in the streets is generally looked upon with a blind eye. D) For many small crimes (like adding another floor to your house) you just confess to the police, pay the multa, and walk away. No criminal record.
Right wing argument: the crime is caused by the migrants. Left wing argument: the crime is cause by migrants we don't do enough for. Well, well, well... what do these two trains of thought have in common?
Immigration and a lack of integration are effectively the same issue: Foreign born entering Germany (often illegally) who are not able or willing to integrate to German culture and adhere to German laws. So both are talking about the same problem, however it cannot be argued that if immigration is reduced, both of these issues are also reduced accordingly. How much to do that is the only question that is left to be decided. It is also worth noting that adding to the population increases the competition for jobs and increases downward pressure on wages
i dont really see the difference in wether it is related to migration or lack of integration. As there simply is no way to integrate millions of people every year.
@@lemmyboy4107The problem isn't a lack of welfare state. Our pension system survived two world wars, global pandemics, economic crises, etc. It possibly could even survive conservatives and neo-liberals trying to dismantle it through privatisation and separation of certain workers.
@@lemmyboy4107 Than what? Universal healthcare? Social aid for people without work or a roof above their heads? Encouraging and supporting students' education by preventing them from having a mountain of debt like in the US? We all got that here.
![[#2024MAMA] ROSÉ (로제), Bruno Mars - APT. | Mnet 241122 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dgGqD28J6aQ/mqdefault.jpg)
"Those without a German passport are responsible for 60% of all violent crime."
That is probably an important issue 🤔
"Those who are poor are responsible for 80% of the crimes" 🤔🤔🤔
And a lot of the time many of the ones with German passports aren’t even German.
@@norude Why import millions of poor people who have few/no skills?
@@norude you can be poor and still be civilized 🤔🤔🤔
Take it from an American- we know; shut the whole thing down asap or you'll have to deal with criminal immigrants AND criminal fascists.
Personally, i am completely shocked letting in one million young men from North Africa and the middle east with little to no vetting led to an increase in crime
Which happened since ... 2015? But yeah, it's the brown people. I am sure. 🙄
@@fryphillipj560 2015 was the big year of the migrant crisis
It wouldn't change much. Southern Germany is one of the regions with more immigrants in all of Europe and it's one of the safest regions as well. The real problem isn't migration but gang proliferation in Northern and Eastern Germany - many of those gangs are actually related to Latin America and the Eastern mafia, and not the Middle East.
Unless you kill the drug trade the crime rate won't decrease. But of course you won't do anything because those criminals are mostly Catholic.
@@fryphillipj560 Look up what happened in Cologne, Germany 2015 on New Years Eve. Also look at why Norway had to make women's rights classes compulsory to Muslim migrants. Should be enlightening for you.
How the fuck are you shocked?! It’s been like this for years now are you blind or just live in an upper class area?
I would like to remind you that Scholz and Merkel criticized Poland for not accepting refugees from Africa and the Middle East...
And?
@@ickebins6948There is no one in Poland who wants to create a caliphate, the police and army are active.Cities are clean and safe, but German cities are huge toilets
@@Mr.DalekLK I've seen alot of cities in germany and the ones that are kinda dirty were like that for the last 30 years. So nothing new.
Btw. crimerates decrased after 2015 and just recently gone up again... Looks like ukrainians have something to do with that?
We now have demonstrants openly advocating for the creation of a caliphate in Germany. As well as an Islamist party (DAVA) that formed very recently. Thinking about moving to the other side of the Oder/Neiße if things continue like this.
Yeah and the EU still does, trying to force them to accept illegal migrants. Its quite ridiculous watching these idiots.
Those damn doctors and engineers!
They are letting in too many engineers and talented businesspeople who make money! Not enough disreputable types. In a more serious answer, the usa (it can be whatever example not only the usa) had big public works projects to get people going and get a variety of business going
@@g4m3life86In US they need more lifeguards 😂
"61% of violent crime". Let that sink in.......
@@Bleu03251as a US lifeguard, what does this mean
@@grasstoucher274 NY mayor said illegal immigrants are good at swimming. They can fill in the jobs as life guards.
It's probably all those damn Japanese Shintō migrants
Some of them are secret Ninjas
who rip off banks so very easily.
Damn those " peaceful " ninja japanese 💀
@@rickbhattacharya2334 Nah, it's the Amish.
My only issue with this comment is that i dont trust people to catch the sarcasm
Probably all those poor migrants, such as the Montenegrin people, Vietnamese, Thai, etc., we all know poor = crime, definitely nothing else!
Copy the Swedish model, get the Swedish results.
Have you ever been? Still much safer than most of US.
@@mrmr446 Sweden went from one of the safest countries in the world to the second worst in Europe in regards to violent crimes. Do you think this is normal? Just because the US is worst it does not mean this is OK.
@@markdowding5737 So you haven't been then? Second highest in Europe according to whom? Have seen some very poor reporting on this is why I ask. Do I think it is normal that crime rates fluctuate?
@@mrmr446because people just look at what other people post and parrot it. They don’t look at it themselves
Import African people.
Get African problems.
Same for Afghanistan
Somalia etc.
It is that simple
Let's not forget about all unreported harassment and assaults that happen on the streets, it looked to me like people are getting used to it.
Yup, happened to my gf a lot
@@starfox300 And ofc you did not report it...
DAMN!
@@ickebins6948 Berlin police do nothing, I reported multiple things, including my GFs phone being stolen
Mass immigration, that's why. And the unwillingness of the blind progressive status quo to deal with that will only fuel the far right
Remember Germany never really had an empire. It and its culture institutions have never historically had to deal with immigration. The UK is one of if not the best countries in the world when it comes to immigration integration. So wonder they have 99 problems and immigration one.
@@Toodyslexicforyou while germany didn't have an empire like UK or france, they did have several colonies and the usual exploitative practices.
@@the80386Germany was also the source of millions of migrants into the colonies.
@@the80386 I think you missed his point. The UK suffers from integration problems despite having a history of immigration, due to it's empire. The USA also suffers from similar problems, despite being a country of immigrants! Germany doesn't have the benefit of such experience, yet decided to allow in a large number of immigrants over a relatively short period of time, so perhaps it's not surprising that they're also having integration problems, as are Sweden.
@@Toodyslexicforyou The UK has the same issues of an explosion in crime, terrorist attacks, mass r*pe of its women by Pakistani men, the immigrant community aggressively asserting themselves over the natives. There is no integration. Multiculturalism is fundamentally not integration...
Why is Sweden's crime rate soaring? Why is Dutch youth crime rate soaring? Etc.
Yeah like when some dusky son of Somalia invariably commits a violent sexual crime in the UK and gets described as "Bristol man" or some such gaslighting BS.
Same with London and most the uk
Swedens is because of failed government policies to integrate foreigners to swedish society, africans and middle easterners especially.
The new right wing government isn't any better at it either
Van der Leyen as just announced
the setting up of a new EU Committee to enquire into the problem . They should report their findings by 2038......
@@2msvalkyrie529That was a good comment.
You didn't have to do a 9 minutes video to explain the reason why, we all know why.
Once you get past 8 minutes they get an extra bump from RUclips for advertisement pay so they needed filler
my thoughts exactly
Yup said the same thing
I appreciate a more detailed looking into it than just shouting "migrants!"
Importing followers of certain religion of peace
Former UK police officer here, I did a training course with the Germany police in 2018 in Koln, their crime stats were shocking, especially burglaries, in a siilar size area they had in a day what we had in in a week. The stats they showed us said it was all down to immigration, and those "German" offenders were nearly all Turkish, Albanian or similar descent.
Suspects, not offenders. The majority of burglaries are never resolved, so there’s no reliable data pointing to migrants being responsible. The fact that most that are caught are migrants could also be linked to the way the police investigate.
So basically your interpretation of the stats is plain wrong. Leave it to those that specialize in analyzing these statistics.
@@RichelieuUnlimited Suspects and Offenders ends up being statistically the same big brain
@@nom_nom_nom_ No they don’t. Only a small portion of suspects are charged, as in most cases there‘s insufficient evidence, i.e. because those suspected turn out to be innocent, and of those charged, not all are convicted.
*In the end the overrepresentation of some groups is decreased in the judicial statistics compared to the stats provided by the police.
@@RichelieuUnlimited Think you're clutching at straws here mate, there may be a small differential between suspects and charged/convicted offenders, but it's negligable.
As the "The Special One" said: "I prefer not to speak, if i speak, I'm in trouble, big, big trouble"
Are you saying "germans are specialist in failure". 😂😂
If you bring people into a country without integrating them, you get a bunch of unintegrated people... immigrants are not the issue, how the country is handling the immigrants is...
@@elwoodzmake It's both
@@elwoodzmake Well numbers is still a big part of the integration process.
@@monkeeseemonkeedoo3745 Immigrants are not the issue if they are actually integrated (for which too little has been done). The real issue are refugees who are actually forbidden from work and given limited resources while having no legal avenues to better their situation as well as a lot of boredom in a country of vastly different culture.
What do you expect them to do if not causing problems under these circumstances?
We all know why.
And we know it goes against the status quo to speak about it.
Germans should start voting for the AfD unless they want their situation to get worse
@@Hardcore_Remixer The usual sus...
You know what.
Ukrainians
@@ljubisaknezevic9040 I have family in germany and it is definetly not ukrainians
Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.
Именно. Европа играет в глупые игры пока весь остальной мир меняет мировой порядок
Россия и Китай не играют.
Они серьезны
Right wing idiots causing political violence
Very good slogan.
Do make a T-shirt.
I was in Berlin in April. The amount of police I saw with automatic weapons was crazy. Even to me, and I’m American.
I am from Prague, just couple of hours from Berlin, and I never see police with automatic weapons here. Having to have so heavily armed police is not a good sign.
Europeans would rather be replaced then be called racist
You maybe see armed police but actually we don't have much killings here like in USA.
@@amarmrkulic1389instead you guys got loads of rapings
@@amarmrkulic1389 yeah. That’s for sure. My school in America almost got shot up twice this year.
It's the god damn Swedes >:(
The French again
1 german women show the truth rape statistic of muslim. she was sued 😂😂😂
@@eohqyuck, French!
Those Norwegians and Finns always stealing my bike 🤬
those damn south swedes
Pretty much what has already happened here in Sweden and is starting to happen in Norway.
Or here in France, to a much more advanced degree in fact
In Canada, it’s with the government letting in many Punjabi gangs with ties to the Khalistan movement. The government actually gives asylum and later citizenship to those whose names are listed with the Interpol.
This is also happening in Norway now?!
Sweden has a lower homicide rate than Finland, which has taken in far less migrants (not to mention neighboring Baltics, who took in practically no non-European refugees at all). In fact it’s lower than it was in the 80s! Gangland shootings and bombs make for riveting news in international media that are always looking for clicks and love the narrative of a “lost utopia” in Sweden, but this is just not born out by statistics.
@@fn-ixSadly factual comments don't activate bots
A disturbing trend involves attacking and harrassing emergency medical, fire and rescue services at large public events like New Year's Eve celebrations. That sort of thing was all but unheard of a decade ago.
where is that? It's been increasing in Italy and I was wondering if that happens somewhere else too
It has been happening all over Germany for a couple of yers now.
@@Ralphieboy after covid maybe?
@@alby46intro it started before COVID but has gotten worse since
It is not like endtime started in Germany. There are many right wingers in Germany who became paranoid because they spent too much time on right wing platforms. In the cities, where most of the migrants live there is no real opposition to migration because these endtime scenarios due to migration do only exist in the head of xenophobic right wingers. 🤷
TLDR: immigration.
They can not say this. only Denmark allow freedom of speech
@@maxman4948 oh yes, it is totally the government that stops you from speaking your mind.
News flash, freedom of speech doesn’t protect you from consequences, if the things you say get you in trouble all the time, start looking for resources to support your points, because that’s a clear sign your points are filled with hatred rather then facts.
or that your points make people uncomfortable and therefore are not advertiser friendly. Almost as if RUclips et al want to sell ads for profit or something...
Yeah? And You remember the recent uptick of immigration, which "caused" the uptick in the crime rate?
Yeah, it was 2022 and almost all because of Ukrainians, but in the crime rate they don't account for much, now do they.
But something else happened, which corelates better with crime: economic slowdown
@@norude Sweden has been totally fucked up by mass migration long before any economic slowdowns, the same applies to all major European cities in the last 20 years. I'd say economic stagnation will only make it worse.
What is completely forgotten to mention here is that the german crime statistics are not statistics about crime in germany per se, but rather statistics about german police work. I'll try to explain what I mean by that now. At the beginning of each year, the police set certain priorities, e.g. more focus on left, right, migration-related, internet fraud, etc... Logically, the statistics on recorded offenses go up when the focus changes. This cannot and should not be ignored. That's what pretty much every scientist who studies these statistics says. Again, these statistics are not a direct representation of crime in Germany, but rather a testimony to the police work carried out in Germany. The whole thing is called Police Crime Statistics (PKS in germany), but for some reason people in Germany believe that these are actual crime statistics, which is simply not the case.
Incidentally, these statistics also include cases that were reopened, i.e. a crime could have happened in 2010 but is only now listed as solved. In addition, many crimes are missing from these statistics, such as crimes such as state security offenses, administrative offenses, traffic offenses and offenses that are not part of the police's remit, such as financial and tax offenses. For this reason, customs and tax crimes, which are usually reported and processed directly by the public prosecutor's office, are also missing from the PCS.
Another very important point is that the PCS does not reflect the number of crimes committed in a year, but rather those that were investigated by the police. This means that every year the PKS contains numerous cases that may have occurred the year before or even earlier. Even a crime that could not be solved because no perpetrator was identified is included in the PCS. If, on the other hand, it turns out in the course of the police investigation that a suspicion cannot be substantiated, i.e. that there is no crime at all, the report will not be included in the PCS.
Overall, only around 30 percent of all suspects are convicted. However, all of these results are no longer included in the PKS. It cannot therefore be compared with statistics from the judiciary, such as the criminal prosecution statistics from the Federal Statistical Office.
I think this information is important to really understand these statistics.
Thanks for the context
That's way too many big boy words I fell asleep half way through
Anyway brown people bad Aryan people good please upvote
That is an excellent explanation. Ex If Germany used the Swedish method to measure crimes, the crime rate would at least be around 30 percent higher in Germany.
They should probably pin this comment tbh.
I've been looking for this exact comment. Without this context, the video is absolutely misleading
It's not just mass migration in general. We're not seeing young men from the Philippines, Thailand, Brazil or Ukraine topping the crime charts - those tend to come from Islamic countries: North Africa, Afghanistan, Pakistan, etc. And it's particularly scary, because any interracial marriage with those group means that a German girl assimilate into their culture, and not the other way around. So the social incompatibility issue will likely protract generation after generation. And the same pattern is copypasted in almost every other Western European country: the UK, Sweden, France, the Netherland, Belgium... now even in Italy, with still relatively low number of muslim migrants (4-5% of the population), we have them constituing almost 40% of incarcerated.
I live in Germany, this is so true
Islam literally has death penalty for drug dealing.
Religion of peace again?
Sure they are not criminals because they are Muslim.
Yeah obviously it is when they all came before the spike. Could never have anything to do with Ukrainians whose arrival coincided with it, that's just a coincidence
Peace sells, but who's buying?
What does religion have to do with this?
@@eminhasanovic7070 Everything. Their prophet was a violent thug, so are his followers
Usual suspects
?
Young males of lower than average socioeconomic status? Yes, they are the most likely group to both commit and become the victims of crime.
@@Öylesine-u2y Are you an usual suspect too?
Good movie.
Obviously it's because of immigration. I don't know why the host even hesitates here, the data is absolutely clear, and he showed some of it. What he failed to mention is that not only are immigrants without German citizenship overrepresented in violent crimes, but among the German citizens committing violent crime, a disproportionate number of them are also immigrants or their descendants. Denmark has data on the origin of criminals, and as you would expect, Danish people and most European immigrants have a low crime rate while Muslims and Africans have an extremely high crime rate. This is the same pattern throughout Europe.
Regarding the absurd talking point that this is due to lack of integration. No, it's not. It is due to the lack of selective immigration. If you select your immigrants well, then you can avoid having a criminally inclined immigrant population, but if you don't select your immigrants well, because you let anyone come and live in your country, then you are going to have problems with criminally inclined immigrant populations. Sweden is the best example of this, they let huge numbers of low quality immigrants into their country, and now they are suffering the consequences. Think of it like this, which country has been successful in integrating large numbers of unselected Africans and Muslims? The answer is none. No country in Europe or the rich world has done this, the US has different immigrants and more selective immigration. No one even knows what integration would mean in this situation. How is a country supposed to integrate such alien populations in such large numbers? There's no way to do that.
I think they did fairly well presenting both sides (which they should) without bending over backwards to make them both seem equally plausible.
The truth goes against Jack's narrative. 😊
The US is entirely made up of immigrants from every corner of the planet.
@@tbk2010 That has been done for decades now. We can keep trying to make up scenarios of "could/should/would" be something else and hope everything changes by itself, but the reality is pretty clear and its the same with every single country.
I think the US is a horrible example for low crime rates 😂
Glad we don't have US style crime and poverty rates here in Europe.
That said, there are as mentioned in the video only two options:
1. Humane but costly integration
2. Inhumane but cheap exclusion
The middle ground of cheap integration is obviously failing, leading to poor, unemployed young men without hope doing what they always do.
With the many costly challenges coming towards us (e.g. climate change, population aging), most people will not opt for option 1...
If you come into a foreign country, it’s YOUR JOB to integrate, not the state’s.
How is “migrants being poorer and younger” an excuse to insane crime rate hike?
It isn't the state's job, but it is the state's job to not actively make it harder to integrate. I worked at a convenience store that also handled immigration papers (just Finland things) during the start of the 2022 invasion of Ukraine during which time lots of Ukrainian refugees came to my city. The city shoved all of them into a suburb that was an hour bus ride from the actual city with no resources, no hospital, no bank, and an already extant drug crisis among the locals. If you put a large amount of people into the exact environment that locals become criminals too, don't be surprised when the people you shoved into the criminal factory also become criminals.
that's like letting a random man inside your house and expecting him to know the laws of the land. You're a host nation, so fulfill the tasks of a host.
"it’s YOUR JOB" no? Integration is a 2 way lane, we want something from them, they want something from us. Acting like we are better just because we were born here is the most stupid thing i could think of.
@@lemmyboy410790% of this conversation is just nationalism, most of these people see higher crime and need a boogieman, that’s how nationalism works, whatever the issue is, it’s never the native populations fault (even if the majority of the world is experiencing the same due to, the pandemic, increase in poverty which increases crime overall)
@@junodeer Fully agree with you. Nationalism makes me sick. Just ignore all studies and facts and hurt other people nice gj.
Hmmm I wonder why...
Everybody knows why...
If you bring people into a country without integrating them, you get a bunch of unintegrated people... immigrants are not the issue, how the country is handling the immigrants is...
@@elwoodzmake the problem is that letting them even adapt and live in Germany is not financially efficient either, they are a burden for german ppl
@@elwoodzmakeyou just can’t integrate them. Idk why it isn’t obvious yet.
@@elwoodzmake You cannot integrate people if you bring them in by millions. If you bring them few at the time, you are forcing them to speak the language and interact with germans. If you import millions at the same time they will form their own communities, speak their home languages and will not integrate with the rest of society. There is no way to handle integration when the numbers are so incredibly large.
@@elwoodzmake Integration is about the cultural aspect. That doesn't have anything to do with violent crime. You don't have to integrate someone to make them understand attacking another person is wrong.
Are you not culturally enriched?
Yes, food from the Middle East is great.
But just think of all the food 🤮
We are, there are pros and cons.
@@soundscape26I like bacon better and a glass of wine.
@@nbgoodiscore1303 That's legit... it's always a matter of preference.
All you need to do is look at what happened in Cologne, Germany 2015 on New Years Eve. Should be enlightening. Don't forget about Sweden either with its gang crime
And those who stand the most to lose (women) where out in Cologne, parading for tolerance like 2 days later. The fact that they tried to paint it as a male problem that has nothing to do with culture was the icing on the cake. Backstabbery.
And yet they left doenst care
Hmmm i wonder what it could be… such a mystery 😂😂
They really think we don't know lol
Probably all those poor migrants, such as the Montenegrin people, Armenians, Vietnamese, Thai, etc., we all know poor = crime, definitely nothing else!
That's 5.5% more than the economic growth. 😂
it helps watching the video past the intro, you could make a stronger point actually
Maybe the crime rates are high
But their governors are higher 🔥 🔥 🔥 🔥
@elwoodzmake it's a joke, geez,
Germans really don't have a sence of humour.
@@lunkycultist5519 not german... what kind of joke is that supposed to be?
It’s A joke. Are you serious.
Same trend in crime across Denmark and the Netherlands. It's important to not conflate all immigrants with being criminals though, it's *certain* countries which are disproportionately over represented in crime statistics, majority come from countries which follow the religion of peace.
*piss
Despite being a minority, they represent the majority of the crimes.
@@Steve_Gatesgot anything constructive to say?
maybe these countries should take a note on how islam handles crime and welfare. i.e.; Harsher punishments and better welfare programs for poor people.
But you people only like to blame islam when something goed wrong, not when things go right.
@@zekkiybetter welfare? Where are they doing it (without oil money)?
Regarding that "crime in Spain fell" bit; As someone personally affected by crime by the usual suspects in Spain and with a few acquitances in the police force, I can tell you that's just because they simply stopped reporting or investigating anything regarding certain demographics, with the possible exception of drug traffiking....... If anything, crime has gone higher in my city in northern Spain with a really high fraction of certain demographics, and I assure you, no native thinks crime has gone down, no matter how much makeup they put on the statistics.
As always Spanish people being harder on themselves than others on them. ❤
Fuente: trust me bro.
Same in Germany, they Report the crimes of people with two Passport as crimes commited by Germans 😂
As a German, this drives me beyond mad and has shifted my views from very left-leaning to more conservative. Unfortunately, I don't know what to do. No party in Germany at the moment seems capable of tackling this issue. AfD and Wagenknecht would just make it worse since they are populists, and I am very pro-NATO/EU, so I cannot vote for them under any circumstances. SPD, Grüne, Volt, Linke, etc., just won't admit the problem since it goes against their views on migration. CDU/CSU allowed so many unskilled migrants into the country, and now they are complaining, but under Merkel, they were the ones who did this! I love Germany very much, especially Munich, but I absolutely hate the fact that this issue is likely to get worse. I wish the SPD would find someone like Helmut Schmidt again!
Same dilemma here in France, only to a much more advanced degree
We need a secular party that understands that an unsafe country can never be a free country, and that understands that we like our cultures and values, we want to keep our hard won social freedoms and will stop the peacefulization of our societies. In every European country. It's so frustrating to have nobody I can vote for anymore.
I'm a secular social democrat and both the right wing and the left wing now are at the beck and call of clerics. It's maddening. We have no voice in Europe anymore.
Be a man, vote for the right
Merkel is no longer in charge so you can vote for CDU alternatively you might consider AFD but they suck I get it.
German politics suck, I get it.
I'm Polish, it isn't much better over here. We can vote for corrupt socialist which is PiS, your loyal dog Donald Tusk, the Left which is obviously the worst, Third Way which is essentially voting for Tusk, or confederation which is kinda like AFD but not quite. I'm voting confederation cause they got a few good leaders and I'm done with other parties but I see that they're deeply flawed as well.
Merkel is no longer in charge so you can vote for CDU alternatively you might consider AFD but they suck I get it.
German politics suck, I get it.
I'm Polish, it isn't much better over here. We can vote for corrupt socialist which is PiS, your loyal dog Donald Tusk, the Left which is obviously the worst, Third Way which is essentially voting for Tusk, or confederation which is kinda like AFD but not quite. I'm voting confederation cause they got a few good leaders and I'm done with other parties but I see that they're deeply flawed as well.
In Germany the government is more concerned with repressing the average citizen with exorbitant taxes, bureaucracy and over-regulation than repressing criminality
Useless bureaucracy and unnecessary regulations
I pay the highest possible (normal) tax tier and I feel like I'm getting a good deal.
Well said @kreight. Germany is one of the EU countries where its most difficult to build wealth if you are doing honest business cause they want to take everything away from you...
Anarcho-tyranny
They are busy creating a music friendly environment.
That's why they plan to increase the tax on meat - starting with pork. The generated tax is supposed to be used to better the living conditions of all farm animal. Increasing the quality af halal meat with no muslim contribution. That is dschizya-light
I mean a rise in migrants and a dip in the economy can both contribute. I know the left and right like to only blame 1 or the other but they're not mutually exclusive
You can’t solve the problem that the left blames, there are ups and downs in economy. But the problem the right blames can be solved really easy
But the reality is clearly in favor of the left wing explanation. Studies have clearly shown that migrants are more likley to be in poverty, studies also have shown that poor people are more likley to commit crimes, the data shows that crimes are going up even with germans. Everything points to more people falling into poverty resulting in more people doing crimes.
It is actually more likley that migration is slowing down that process, but that is not really proven by studies so im not using that as an argument.
Since a non-zero amount of people in general commit crime, immigration from *anywhere* technically increases crime
But when right wingers say it they only say black and brown migrants are to blame
I mean yeah importing a poor underclass to keep growth going hurts when the economy slows down.
@@urubissoldat5452especially when your housing market is unaccessible to lower incomes
Some perspective, I lived in Munich from 2018 into 2022, and the absence of crime was so noticeable coming from the U.S., it was like living in an alternate world. One could leave their things out in a park or at a lake and not worry about theft, and no one worried being out late at night. Frankfurt, where I live now is a different matter. The area around the Hauptbahnhof is a disaster. Lots of immigrants involved in the drug trade and the area is simply not safe late at night when foot traffic ebbs. The problems are obvious, but the government is doing nothing to address the issue. I do not doubt that voters will respond.
So personal sorry, I myself have come to Germany as a legal immigrant, I was coming from a place and thanks to DB my last train was cancelled and next train was at 6am. Thinking Frankfurt is a safe city I went outside to get a casual walk , Jesus Christ the stuff I saw that night I can't forget ever in my life. I simply ran back to the station and sat on a bench near the police, I was scared to the core and made a note that I will never cross Frankfurt city borders after 10pm 😂😂
Frankfurt a.M. has a major drug epidemic, centered around the Hauptbahnhof. I don't think it has anything to do with immigration. I stayed in Frankfurt for one week in 2011, and I remember how shocked I was by the amount of homeless people openly camping there. I recall these people as being almost all Germans.
I have not been to Frankfurt since, maybe the picture has changed. But to my knowledge the drug problem of Frankfurt a.M. predates the recent immigration.
Munich IS a conservative ruled City, rember that
@@rickbhattacharya2334 are you Male ?
Jeeeeeeez..... i wonder why
Hm only someone with a phd in criminal justice can figure out this tough tough problem..
@@Antiluls yes. And I'm sure the obvious answer which we all know to be true is just "right-wing propaganda"
How you explain 2:15 crime rate plummeted in 2015 after one million immigrants
@@jaska-jalmarixvi5757 casing a joint you queef
Wdym crime rate plummeted in 2015?!?! Its so clear it rose that year till 2016
Germany - the newest member of the "You-Made-Your-Bed-You-Sleep-In-It" club.
This is what happens when you fill a country with Europeans! 🤪. That's why Pakistan, Algeria, and Syria all collapsed, Europeans flooded those countries!
If only they wouldn't have shared their beds with the illegal immigrants.
No dirty joke intended.
let the migrants sleep in their own beds in their own damn countries.
@@Hardcore_Remixer Enough native women doing so on a regular basis, hence why i dont look their way anymore, your joke is genius tier though
@@arnonym5430 By "sharing their beds" I was refering to Germans welcoming illegal immigrants into their country and even paying them as refugees, thus sharing their money and their country with the illegal immigrants.
Relating to the top comment of this section, Germans made itself a nice bed (their country), but they made the mistake to share that bed (their country) with the illegal immigrants whom they welcomed and who messed up their bed (their country).
I was not refering to the actual meaning of "sharing a bed" by any means.
Why is it that everyone here connects the crisis from 2015 with this rise in crime 9 years later...
Olaf has learned that not everything can be solved with warm hugs no matter how much he loves them.
Olaf was never someone to try solve Something with hugs. Because that would imply that he did Something at all.
His special skill is to do absolutely nothing and when asked about things, to answer "I can not remember".
@@J.Crime123 Our happy anthropomorphic snowman has truly fallen far.
Wasn't Merkel the culprit? That russian doll fucked up Europe economics, Germany's nukes and let it the migrants.
Maybe Olaf will grow a 2 inch wide moustache just below his nose soon
@@Rowlph8888 That would be an interesting look for a snowman to have.
Muslims easy explanation.
Why is the crime rate falling after 2015 @2:12 ? Care to explain?
@@ickebins6948 Then you have the first graphs. Crime index 27,1 until 2015 and 32,6 from 2016. Why are you omitting it? Not fitting your narrative I guess..
@@violet_green4335 Because to my knowledge, the "crime Index" is an estimation of crime levels in a given country or city.
And the graph at 2:12 are the exact numbers for crimes (per 100000) for Germany.
I could not really find anything about how exactly the "crime index" is estimated. It's a strange metric (0-100 scale).
No its not muslims , its poverty. Poor people commit crimes. So lets make it so they arent poor
It’s not Germans’ responsibility to integrate people who willingly entered Germany.
Define "willingly".
@@my_dear_friend_ choose.
@@bluegoka - Is running from danger and for your survival something you choose to do? Or might such an action feel forced on you?
It is
@@veemo8605 It’s the responsibility of the people who chose to move to Germany to integrate into German society.
Germany is in dire need of three things.
- A new Government
- Fewer Migrants
- A better system to integrate Migrants
Deportations would work better than attempts at "integrating"
And ballsy citizens
@@AnotherMartinez What are you suggesting they do?
No, we should get away from that "integration" story altogether. What we need is assimilation. If as a second or third generations migrant (i.e. Germans whose parents/grandparents were migrants) anything other than the skin/hair color or last name makes you seem like a foreigner we have an issue.
I wouldn't say "fewer migrants" but maybe "fewer migrants from global south". germany's low birthrates makes her reliant (in the long term) on migration but I believe if every middle eastern migrant was replaced with spanish migrant, and every north african with polish, although not perfect, germany's situation wouldn't be that dire (at least in crime rates or polarization). I don't mean to offend people that come from global south but I believe that cultural differences are too big, and russian threat too high, for (most) of them actually adapt and become members of german (or any european country for that matter) society.
Job opportunity is a way better indicator of crime rates.
1:40 Poland is also a large country in Europe. Strange to not include it
Poland doesn't have millions of Africans & Asians.
😂
"Largest countries by GDP"
The traditional big countries of Europe have been Germany, France, the UK and Italy. Population and economy wise... Poland with less than 40 million people and a GDP of $1,801 trillion (less than half of the population of Germany which currently has a population of almost 85 million and a GDP of $5,700 trillion) is not anywhere near those aforementioned.
@@robbyh.8165 Yes, Russia & Ukraine are the largest, but in terms of GDP it's Germany, then the UK, France & Italy.
Im shocked that the liberals are shocked. I guess crime started to reach them too and thats when they press the breaks
I don't think anybody is shocked, but hey...
They "press the breaks" because they are losing voters and not because of the consequences of their actions
@@soundscape26 Maybe we have been naive?
Yeah WE Had a funny Case in Germany where a rich liberal neighbohood got a Refugees Center....and Now suddelny there are Protests against it....because ITS in their neighbohood 😂
Obviously they're both right
Yeah, and one problem fuels the other and vice versa.
Besides the “usual suspects”, the police is also a problem.
I heard a great quote from a long time ago:
“The police is like a ghost. When you need them, they are nowhere to be seen; when you don’t need them, they are everywhere.”
Man if only every western nation didn't defund them 😞
@@SamFromItalia you should tell that to the Yanks
@@SamFromItalia Ah yes, that thing that definitely happened
@@xenotiic8356 I-It did?... are you 3 or did you just forget that 2020 happened?
I never needed a ghost
Risky move from Olaf. People are already moving to the right and downplaying it like that wont help him.
"Doesn't matter what they are voting for, only matters who counts the vote. "
Lol, are you a Russian that cannot cope with other countries having real elections? :D
@@konigstiger3252 so you think we have no democracy at all anymore? Like in China and Russia?
@@nBomF Our democracies are a lie and they always were.
@@konigstiger3252 The people count the vote...
But hey, details right...
The community of peace
?
Like the Germans back in the day
@@eminhasanovic7070 your mean the 1400 of conquests and wars and millions of people died by spreading a religion by sword so peaceful 😂😂😂
What could be a reason for this... A cant think of anything... No idea
Ukrainians
Same for the Netherlands I guess, most crime is done by people with a Dutch passport, but they are a certain group of Dutch people with a North African background. Mostly Moroccan
We have too many immigrants. And I'm speaking as an immigrant myself. It's so crazy if you think about it. When we came to Germany we were only a few but after 2014 the amount of immigrants just exploded.
Immigrants from muslim countries. That's why.
The west shouldnt have bombed their country, city, neighborhood, street and house 😅 what did you expect? The west only know how to destroy these immigrants would have never migrated if it wasn’t the usa and eu
Although crime rates went steadily down 2004 - 2020
no more muslim. they dont.have same value.
Graph @2:12 : After 2015 it went down quick, just recently it going back up again.
Why? Maybe the ukrainian refugees? Not fitting your narrative I guess..
@@ickebins6948 yeah sure there's never any other factors than immigrants you brainiac
Sweden and Germany have allowed their own citizens to face all sorts of terrible turmoil.
Now they need to pay for their terrible decisions.
There is no integrating those who don't want to be integrated, rather, want to make their new homes like their former ones; utterly destroyed and in ruins.
Thank God that is not my problem.
The elite making decisions that it profits from, while the common people suffer the consequences. A tale as old as time. In the 20th century our elite chose for war, in the 21th century our elite chooses for mass-immigration.
Yeah, but it just really sucks for normal people who were against that from the beginning and a culture, where you get called a Nazi just for saying logically we cannot take in a limitless amount of people while having limited capacity.
I'm sure once the Muslim caliphate is established in Germany everything will be a-ok.
Actually though unironically.
Fun fact: The percentage of people supporting democracy as the best form of government is 81%, when you ask Muslims in Germany. When you ask the total population, it's only 70%.
Not even modern day Muslim majority countries are caliphates nevermind Germany.
@@_jpg Yeah true... many people see Muslims as a bunch of uncultured simpletons who love dictatorships. They should visit cities like Algiers, Baghdad or Cairo for a reality check. And those who move abroad are even more progressive.
@@_jpg lmao sure , we all know about their sharia plans worldwide
It truly is a question for the ages, what POSSIBLY could cause such a thing? I don't think millions of people could've predicted this, gotta save the GDP from demographic collapse right? At the expense of everything else. Because the most important thing is that precious GDP number that must go up forever. Who cares about the petty social concerns of the people/resources
Just that after 2015 it went down. So your reason is even by the data shown completly wrong. Shoudl save the world by people like you trying everything to force their ideology
@@lemmyboy4107 "those without German passports are now responsible for nearly 60% of all violent crimes" - 5:20
Tell me more about the ideology i'm "forcing", keep in mind also that when he says that those individuals are still a vast minority compared to the ones that do have passports, so the over-representation is massive. I ask sincerely, why the constant denial? Are you all just waiting until it happens to you before you admit it's a problem?
And is the pursuit of ever-growing GDP and taxes really worth all this trouble and suffering? Are we really all just resources of the state or do our culture, history, language and common traits matter?
@@detdeet Are you just ignoring that they are rhe majority in low income households. Thats where you force your ideology. you completly igmore that with same circumstances germans are just as likley to commit crimes.
Ah yes.! The Great Immigration Ponzi scheme..! We need more and more immigrants and then as they get older we need more to replace them.....and so on....etc etc..
immigration is a good thing if done correct, just stay the hell away from menapt immigration !
Unstable family life and economic struggle, it's not complicated. Every study that has ever been done on crime proves this.
This is what happens when politicians act like activists instead of leaders. They should have listened to their voters instead of calling them names.
What makes a third world country is it's people. Not the dirt and trees.
Hahah how ignorant can you be. Maybe it's the fact that other nations pillaged them and their resources for decades, using them for their own growth. And often leaving them in chaos when deciding colonialism is bad. Also then causing wars and general chaos in those regions to still further the interes of rich people. Tell me, how is it the people's fault they were born in and live in a poor region, without a way to enrich themselves???
art schools shouldn't reject any applicants these times...
I agree
This is important in the present political era. 😊
Except when they come from Austria…
We all know why, but too many people are afraid to say it, because other people might call them R.
Or I 😂
People use the word “RACIST” like a sword. If something doesnt go their way they use the word “racist.” After so many uses a sword becomes dull and not as effective, same with calling someone racist.
Its mostly women who will use the Nazi and Racism insults, guess they were already blacked or browned by these guys before - makes it easier to avoid them
Short answer: illegal immigration
We all know why, immigrants, it's the same reason it's increasing here in Spain. We've gone from a rate of 3 rapes per 100k in 2015 to a rate of over 10 rapes per 100k last year.
Well well well...
...if it isn't the consequences of my actions?
@irispaiva right, how dares Europe force islam onto the middle east and north africa😢
I refuse to believe all those unchecked, unvetted engineers, scientists and doctors could be responsible for all of that crime.
Always the same demographic but pattern recognition is racist.
As i german prison warden.... I see a.... pattern in the people I control... and its mostly both reasons. Foreigners and econemy. Both are the 2 biggest partys.
As an American that lived in Germany I've never lived in a more violent area. The city I lived in was small with a population of about 100,000 . During my 3 years there I saw multiple murders in the news and I had two friends assaulted in the center of town. from what I saw 60 to 70 percent of the crime was Arab and the rest was committed by traditional germans.
Arabs and migration. I don't need to watch the video xD
Yep, but particularly muslim arabs.
Christian arabs are actually pretty decent
@@PeaceToUsAll 100% correct
100% correct.
That's what happens when you assume you don't need extensive assimilation but multiculturalism is ok without any effort.
@@PeaceToUsAllWished Islam never existed in the first place
It seems to corelate with liberal policies relating to compassion.. cultural enrichment.. etc etc.
And Hungary is in the wrong for building a border fence to prevent this. lol
To be fair, fences do not work
The EU actually wanted to expel
Orban..!! The Euro elections in June will hopefully destroy the liberal left pro immigration lobby
within the EU. Too late for Germany and Sweden probably...
It is the least bad thing that the Hungarian goverment have done in the last decade.
I mean, Hungary isn't doing very well regardless lol
Yeah Hungary, the beacon of freedom and free speach in europe...
You're so dense 😆
Short answer: DIVERSITY!
Having diversity doesn't turn people into criminals, poverty and exclusion does.
@@soundscape26nope, extremism and a sick cult of death like Islamism does. Naive Neo Marxist. You’ll find yourself like communist Iranians once the cards are down: either unalived by the Islamist hand once you’ve served your purpose of propping them up into power or forced to live under their oppression like the poor people of Iran do today
diversity=100% middle east, wish we had some japanese or korean immigrants for example but instead we get flooded with those neanderthales.
@@soundscape26 people from islamic states have no place in europe.
europe is made for europeans not some poor muslim nationalists
@@soundscape26 Just stop importing people who are poor and don't fit into society. It would ease problem.
Who would've thought letting tens of thousands of young men from crime ridden countries into Germany would increase crime?
one of the very rare moments im proud to be hungarian
What's the story over there in Hungary? We don't hear much about it over here in the UK?
@@martinjnagy it's a corrupt oligarchy thats in bed with China and Russia. However, it has been extremely against letting immigrants in since 2015. As a result crime has not risen like in most of the continent
@@martinjnagy Well, we have a hybrid-authoritarian system, our healthcare is in ruins, but in terms of crime, I would say its better. However, we also have our own "migrants", called gypsies. North-eastern Hungary is filled with them. And it shows in the crime statistics in those areas.
@@martinjnagy They got a corrupt power hungry dictator as president but at least he doesn't allow Budapest to turn into Islamabad and that's a big plus.
Polak Węgier dwa bratanki
🇭🇺🤝🇵🇱
Moral of the story: Sweden is a bad example :)))
The comments section gives me some hope. People are finally waking up.
Too many are still sleeping. This is about migrant crime rates exploding in Germany, and in Germany still more people vote for the parties promoting mass migration than for the ones actually trying to restrict mass migration. There's no real change and nor real hope in sight yet.
Proud german here.
There is only one reason and it is called migration.
Deport to Afghanistan, Lebanon, Syria, Chechnya, Nigeria, Tunisia, Eritrea, Algeria, Morocco, Albania and Turkey and most of the problems will go away immediately.
Did I forget an country?
And it will start inevitably.
There is no way around anymore.
The most maddening thing about sources of crime is the inclination to oversimplify the causes.
Nah, it's actually pretty simple.
This is why we need crime profiling for origin of birth, gender, religious/political background. And yes, it makes me as uncomfortable to say that as it is for you to read this.
But here is the problem. If we don't, people start generalizing wildly. And it becomes ammunition for racist propaganda.
The reality is that its very likely certain groups of people who are over-represented. We must treat the people who are doing their best to live up to our standards fairly and not use such a broad term as "immigrants are the problem".
Exactly. Here in Australia, almost 30% of the population are immigrants (including me), yet most crimes have been getting way less common or frequent
I don't think the current political systems are able to have nuance. You either get brainrot lefties decrying racism for every little criticism, or racist af rightoids making it only about race and nothing else. Oddly, the two are made for each other, they justify each other's existence. It's sad tbh
@@socialistrepublicofvietnam1500 The difference is that in Australia we get to select people. In EU they don’t have a moat to keep the undesirables in Nauru.
why do we have to go through strict security at the airport? It wasn't Buddhists hijacking planes and flying them into buildings. why do we put extra bollards on pedestrian streets? it wasn't Hindus mowing people down with their cars in the name of Shiva. We got 100k Hongkongers in the UK recently but we don't have Hongkonger grooming gangs. Not all cultures adapt easily to our values.
@@socialistrepublicofvietnam1500 Australia has a control over who enters, Europe does not
The highly skilled workers Europe needs
I’m all for supporting human rights but turning a blind eye to checks and balances in immigration especially for folks who refuse to assimilate is plain daft. It isn’t about skilled or unskilled migrants, it’s about letting in folks who don’t respect the culture and are plain resistant to integrating. There’s enough data from multiple studies to show that immigrants benefit the economy overall but that isn’t possible unless the sort of people a country lets in is actually interested in participating in the economic system which can only happen in conjunction with linguistic and cultural integration. Neither political faction is entirely right but they aren’t entirely wrong either.
Diversity is our strength
"old rich people commit fewer crimes than young poor people" I guess if we're talking about only blue collar crime, sure.
If you steal a dollar, you go to jail, if you steal 2 million dollars, you get a fine so yeah, depends on what you count as "crime"
Yes, white collar economic crimes never seem to bother people that much.
White collar crimes annoy people, sure, but the relative annoyance of having some rich fuck embezzle 2 million company euros versus getting fatally stabbed by a 19 year old Yemeni in a mugging aren't really on the same level are they
You have a pooint
@@soundscape26 White collar crime doesn't involve a physical confrontation. If you're attacked or robbed or you have your property destroyed, there is a physical threat to your person and there's always a risk of violent escalation whenever "blue collar" crime happens. White collar crime usually involves embezzling from a company.
Everyone knows why but are afraid to say it!
It's in the video.
I'm not. It is the muslims. Come after me, I don't care. I've already survived one dictatorship in Portugal, I'll survive another one from the left.
The answer is simple: what has changed in the last 40 years? Immigration
The figures from Spain only look that good because
A) squatting and smoking weed doesn't count as a crime.
B) black work and corruption aren't registered in the first place.
C) selling forged Gucci in the streets is generally looked upon with a blind eye.
D) For many small crimes (like adding another floor to your house) you just confess to the police, pay the multa, and walk away. No criminal record.
1:22 this is FIREARM homicide rate, not total rate.
By total rate, Germany or the UK do worse than Italy or Spain.
the rise in SA offences has climbed at a total staggering rate
Too many doctors and engineers.
And too many people who are actually fixing the decling birthrate crisis
Right wing argument: the crime is caused by the migrants. Left wing argument: the crime is cause by migrants we don't do enough for. Well, well, well... what do these two trains of thought have in common?
Everybody ignoring the elephant in the room ☪️🐘
Poverty. The answer is the rising poverty.
Immigration and a lack of integration are effectively the same issue: Foreign born entering Germany (often illegally) who are not able or willing to integrate to German culture and adhere to German laws. So both are talking about the same problem, however it cannot be argued that if immigration is reduced, both of these issues are also reduced accordingly. How much to do that is the only question that is left to be decided. It is also worth noting that adding to the population increases the competition for jobs and increases downward pressure on wages
let's stop pretending we don't know why...
I can do it for YOU in few words: IMMIGRANTS FROM ISLAMIC AND/OR DEVELOPING COUNTRIES WITHOUT THE SAME/SIMILAR CULTURE 💥💥💥
i dont really see the difference in wether it is related to migration or lack of integration. As there simply is no way to integrate millions of people every year.
Yes, it's a problem of scale. Europe has always received migrants but not on this scale.
Well you just ignore that the problem is lack of wellfare state which would hit us even if we dont have migrants.
@@lemmyboy4107The problem isn't a lack of welfare state. Our pension system survived two world wars, global pandemics, economic crises, etc. It possibly could even survive conservatives and neo-liberals trying to dismantle it through privatisation and separation of certain workers.
@@_jpg welfare state is not only pensions.
@@lemmyboy4107 Than what? Universal healthcare? Social aid for people without work or a roof above their heads? Encouraging and supporting students' education by preventing them from having a mountain of debt like in the US? We all got that here.
The rich politicians and other elites (global or domestic) live in high-security gated communities, along with their well-paying, cushy office jobs.
Let's check if those criminals eat ham.
Do they have carpets?
Or Bacon 🥓
@@nbgoodiscore1303 If have carpets and eat ham.
So?
@@ickebins6948 Oh, look! A pdf.file worshipper