2024s “Call Of Duty Killer” FAILED - But How?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 фев 2025
- Why Did 2024s Call of Duty Killer Fail?
Today we are going to look at yet another game touted as "The Call of Duty Killer" thankfully there is a bit more to the story this time.. instead of the name being stuck to something that doesn't make sense like Splitgate or Titanfall for example.
Hopefully today we can get to the bottom of this!
In this deep dive, we break down the much-anticipated *Xdefiant* and explore its struggle to dethrone the legendary *Call of Duty* franchise! With hopes high and expectations higher, what went wrong for this supposed contender? From gameplay mechanics to community feedback, we dissect the key factors that led to its downfall. Join us as we analyze player reactions and analyze the fierce competition in the FPS landscape. Don't miss our hot take on what could’ve made it a success! Like, subscribe, and let us know your thoughts in the comments!
Congratulations for finding the AI description!
Before Xdefiant was known as "Tom Clancy's: Xdefiant", people really hated on the game due to how generic it looked as this had Tom Clancy's name in the title of the game, in which it was milking his name to the grave in hopes of gaining some traction
Damn, i never knew that, how wild and fucked up that is.
That game is great now, it might not be the cod killer, but it is amazing with the last update. I hope another company buys it and takes over. It’s a shame.
I thought it was a fun game for what it was, the only bad part is having to wait 10-15 minutes to find a match
@ if you pick quick match, it starts instantly. I play xdefiant and bo6. At least until they close the servers of xdefiant.
man this was one of the rare games where ubisoft cooked but they had to shut it down
The game wasn’t bad- I think it just got propped up way more than it should have honestly.
COOKED, LEGIT, ON THE DOWN LOW. REAL TALK, WHO HURT YOU?! YEET!
Something to add to your analysis, some people had weird technical issues. A friend of mine plays on a laptop and the game had issues identifying his GPU and kept defaulting to his iGPU. No feedback was given on this issue and there seemed to be no clear fix. So ultimately the issues with xdefiant was its technical issues and overall ubisoft.
I loved xdefiant but recognized it was still a hollow game. But if this game released earlier it mightve been able to pose some more competition. Xdefiant was announced almost a decade ago and released 2023.
Really? When I played I didn't have any technical issues shockingly. The only problem I had was me stuck waiting 10-15 minutes to find a match.
Released earlier????
It was released too early on a game engine that was meant for MMOs.
Always look to the suits. They force things for their benefit despite the product they're making, and they are released xdefiant too early to see returns on their investments. You'd wonder how 'smart businessman' be so dumb...because they still win at the end of the day. They make a profit while killing the games industry. Once they've bled that dry, they'll just move onto something else
This is a surprisingly good video for such a small channel. I didn’t even realize it was a small channel until i saw there were only like 5 comments. Good job 👍
Thank you GhostRamen! I appreciate your kind words! ❤️
Blah blah blah, you all write the same inane comments.
@@prezidenttrump5171 are you okay?
This is a solid video and I'm honestly shocked that you don't have more, 6 figure, high sub count because imo the quality is top notch. Got a new sub!
That socks joke had me spittin out my whiskey on the screen. Thanks man xD
Titanfall and especially titanfall 2 was a genuinely amazing game and could have easily been a top contender for a call of duty rival, but EA decided apex had to be made to take a stab at the battle royale genre. Still hate EA for killing the titanfall franchise for that game
I think Titanfall should be considered a completely different game honestly, rather than lumping it against Call of duty.
I was gonna say marvel rivals but that's two different game genres you can enjoy together besides the zombies mode ofc
Yeah unfortunately I don’t think anyone was calling Rivals the call of duty killer
Brother this video is Amazing keep it up 💪
Thank you Coach
Dang XDefiant was fun until Ubisoft announced it gotta be shut down
You can still play it until early June (if you installed it before December 3rd 2024)
I was basically forced to quit the game back when it came out I played 4 matches had a blast then after that the matchmaking just broke I couldn’t find a game and when I’d join friends they couldn’t either i wasn’t banned or anything I even came back after months on a completely different network and yet same problem.
Was it a shadow ban on the Ubisoft account possibly?
3:45 yeah that’s the only reason I quit the game plus after the update and all that annoying jumping was the last straw for me I’m sad it died instead of being fixed a defiant had a lot of potential
The hit detection even now is not the greatest, it’s much better than when the beta was around but it’s still really rough.
nothing will ever be a “cod killer” lmao
The only thing that will kill CoD is itself
I think no killstreaks really hurt the game. I never noticed how important they were to me until they were gone.. I just felt so bored not having anything to work towards.
I've seen this complaint a lot, shockingly it didn't bother me. I don't see this as a "call of duty" type game so maybe it just depends on the mentality going into it.
I thought i would have an issue with it too, but noticed xdefiant rarely had any campers in return because of it.
They banked on a brain dead stupid audience that falls for SBMM is killing cod videos that are annoying but the algorithm loves that stuff. But they didn’t realize the cod player base have no discipline (or brain function) and can’t resist buying call of duty. That’s such a Ubisoft move.
I really do wonder how the game would have done if it was never marketed with "No SBMM"
Really good video alot of great points 🤙🏻
Now for 2025, there is Marvel Rivals
Has anyone ever called Marvel Rivals a call of duty killer?
But they are two different shooter genres...
Becomause obnoxious people called it cod killer and they came over and say itwas more of a simple game for people to get away from manipulation
Contrary to popular belief the "class customization" aspect of putting an ungodly amount of attachments doesn't actually had depth to Call of Duty since everyone ends up making *the exact same class set up* on their guns. Which defeats the purpose of so-called depth and diversity in the game. BO1 & 2 didn't need many attachments on the guns to have depth. Ironically, the lesser attachments available the more depth the game has because the game depends on it and not what attachments on to be used on a gun. All in all, it is to say that if XD put more effort in the specialist-like abilities it would have been better than the alternative of 20 attachments on a weapon.
Everyone that i know who played MW3 just dresses up their gun and larp.
The guncorn in that game was unmatched
I think cod is so weird for allowing even console players to plug in a keyboard and mouse and then ban it on CDL. Cod would grow so much if keyboard would be allowed in CDL not only in viewers and players but also skill will go up controller players will need to adjust to mouse opponents and we can really see the best cod players instead of watching the best controller players.
Big reason why fortnite is so populair is because the people know they can become pro and make money on both mouse and controller wich motivates them to play and even start playing. Now a lot of mouse and keyboard players wont even try cod because there is no competitive future for them.
Also i hate sbmm too that needs to go asap
You've earned my sub, I love this game alot and you made a really good point. I probably would not play it at all if it was a tom Clancy game
Also it takes around 30-40 hours to get level 500 on a weapon (i love my lvl 500 mp5)
There was a solid ground work here, unfortunately it's all going to waste.
(Insert I didnt realize this was a small channel! here)
Exactly. It's gotten so lame now. Only people with brains notice the pattern.
What is the pattern? bots?
@@VerieZestie realistically i think it's definitely that but more-so people who have become accustomed to the idea that "low views/likes/interaction = probably bad or low quality" and lately youtube has been pushing these videos out a lot more whereas before channels like yours really never had a chance. Thus you have all these people who regurgitate the same statement. It's like they feel like they were fooled into watching the video instead of ignoring it and want to give you a GG of sorts.
Suits released the game too early to see returns on their investments.
They said development was finished for all year 1 and were moving onto year 2 development.
'Bomb' got pushed forward to then get pushed back.
Pretty much no content. (Grinding is a biproduct of enjoying the game. No, im not an adhd give me content brain.. multiple og cods had playerbases for years without any content updates.)
They listened to complaining babies.
I highly doubt the devs and Mark Rubin overlooked these things... they just simply weren't able to due to ubisoft suits
Titan Fall had more Success than any “CoD Killers” After it
Edit: 10:55 yes, it was Overhyped by Brainless Idiots just Hating CoD and has to compare it. Game could have Survived & Fun Arcade Type Alternate without a Comparison & Following CoD
Possibly, the comparison to CoD gave it life, but also was the death in the same breath.
Overhyped is crazy to say about titanfall
@ TitanFall didn’t need buzz words for it to be Hyped, simple Trailer and Fun Gameplay is all it took. Where was that for XDefiant as the whole Marketing was “No SBMM” and nothing else
@@GamingSpider115 it didn't have hype to be honest, if anything it was under marketed didn't help that the first game was a Xbox exclusive and the second game had to deal with Cod:IW and BF1 a week apart from each other
@ it did have Hype, the Second one was Overshadowed by EA Stupidity with BF1 Releasing Window but still enough for a Stupid BR to be Made
19:30 warface mentioned 🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳
As soon as i saw endless amounts of videos of people running THE SAME HEALTH CHARACTER i knew this was doomed. Meta right? 😂😂😂
No one can escape meta in anything sadly.
XDefiant absolutely did not use a lack of SBMM as its biggest selling point, what are you talking about? You picked up on that because it's the center of CoD's controversy, almost no media outlets even mention it as a feature. Official ads definitely do not.
XDefiant in fact advertised itself as an explicitly *competitive* shooter, with many non-players assuming it was more in-line with CS or Valorant.
Some sources AFTER launch did say it was an "arcade shooter" a la CoD, but even then, it was primarily compared to CS or Overwatch 2 even. At best I can find places saying it has "low skill requirements" (I did actually put in the time to research this because I can remember nobody mentioning SBMM myself) and I can see that it explicitly HAD SBMM. It actually had it up until May 2024, and only dropped it then, announcing a shutdown only ONE MONTH LATER. The game was announced and advertised as soon as 2021, and you are acting like the lack of SBMM, the thing it removed for ***ONE MONTH***, was its biggest selling point? It was a last ditch effort to remedy an already dropping player count.
SBMM does suck, and yeah it is detrimental to CoD's experience. Acting like XDefiant never had it and was proof that it isn't bad is really silly considering it had it and was hemorrhaging players up until it removed it, which active player counters show actually worked in slowing the loss. Really just comes off as you being in denial about it at best and just lying about it at worst.
Yes XDefiant WAS advertised as so, but the amount of traction this game got from them exploiting the "no SBMM" to the CoD community was astronomical- especially after the initial backlash, which forced them to remove Tom Clancy's name from it.
Players ended up pitting this game against Call of duty when it shouldn't have been in the first place, because of how it was marketed to them.
The grander gaming community obviously understood this, hence the comparisons to Overwatch 2, CS etc.
but in this context I'm speaking from "Call of duty Killer". To the CoD community "No SBMM" is a major selling point that was exploited.
it was being talked about numerous times after the first XDefiant beta.
Went wrong thinking anything could be a “COD killer” nothing could ever pull CoD cult members from COD, not even COD itself being trash now.
You are correct on this one.
People aren’t going to like what I have to say but I think the lack of SBMM played a part in the games demise. SBMM keeps casuals coming back. Hate it or love it SBMM is used in Cod for a reason- player retention.
To be honest people hating on SBMM are either streamer/content creators wanting to farm big kills matches for content,tryhards that want to abuse new players (cause the "but sometimes i want just a chill match and relax" is bs,if you are getting tryhards with sbmm is because you are tryharding) or people that have no argument and blame the game problems on it (without mention cod had softer or harder sbmm since bo2)
Sbmm right now has it problems but removing it just make it worse
SBMM has to be one of the most interesting topics for gaming in recent years.
There are so many arguments for and against it.
But for XDefiants sake, they capitalized on that market to bring traction to their game (which clearly worked initially) sadly the game itself was mediocre at best.
COD players hate a wide skill gap. Sure SBMM could be better but even in a no SBMM environment, the moment bhopping and air strafing was starting to be understood in XDefiant they complained, and omni-movement complainers are kinda everywhere right now. I honestly don't mind SBMM. I'd rather not play in a lobby that is half filled with new players or bad players. But disbanding lobbies does kinda suck for casual play as it doesn't allow the algorithm to rebalance the teams so that you get a second try or more time playing around with people who are entertaining in voice chat or have a fun playstyle. Going from a fun fast paced lobby to one full of campers sucks. Bad audio engine, console aim assist being inhuman in certain scenarios and forced crossplay all dumb down the skill gap. Movement is the only real distinction tbh and even then it's a bit too forgiving in BO6.
No it didnt the amount of my friends that i could finally play with for the first time in like 3 years cuz the matchmaking wasnt strict make it way more fun and they were still struggling sbmm itself isnt a problem at all its the sbmm with all the manipulation thats the problem look at the info out now it's actually disgusting
@@-foxwint-3140no please stop 😂 sbmm in its current state is manipulative theres no actual way to say its good if you actually understand sbmm you would never ever say its good sbmm itself isnt a problem its the manipulative matchmaking stuff after it that cod puts into their game where they know how much you move buy shoot throw grenades hir shots aim what region theres so much that goes into it its disgusting and on top of that they make sure u loose or win when they want please dont say stuff like this when u dont understand it
yeah what a shame... Ubisoft u F up with me... And Im not going to buy ur AC Shadows. Bye, also not Buying another Warzone DLC like BO6, bye
Go to their studio and let them know
Xdefiant only died because cod players wanted Ubisoft to make it like cod like remove abilities add cod game modes and add kill streaks
they killed it too early. that's all. if they gave it a little more time for black ops 6 to be as awful as it is all those console kids with no other games would play would maybe try that again but now they don't want to knowing it's losing support. cod says eomm retains players testing by turning it off randomly lol of course players that are conditioned to think they're good and realize suck are going to get off. the fact you're saying skill based instead of engagement based says you have no clue how messed up cods matchmaking really is tbh you should watch primepete he goes over patents that activision has made and talks about how they are implemented it's really corrupt stuff to do to paying customers. it's crazy people even want this. it's all nostalgia. cod is an embarrassment to gaming in 2025 it's the most brain dead rudimentary game on the market and the fact they have the same gameplay as 2007 with less immersion is literally insane. cod gamer is an oxymoron as cod is playing you lmao keep playying and getting manipulated
I mean blame truth always meat rides Xdefiant in his vids
He does, he's also the spearhead of the "I hate Call of duty" content. I think he played a massive role in pushing this narrative about XDefiant.
XDefiant could never be a COD killer because it played like overwatch with a COD skin it was just another trash hero shooter if theey would have made a real shooter with no BS hero junk it could have been ok also it needed gamemodes like TDM and free for all and the snipers like most fps games were stupidly overpowered if you want snipers to one shot kill it needsd to be by headshot only not body shots make noobs have to get good no fps devs get it right
XDefiant wasn't even designed to compete with it, the game just ended up being picked up by the community because of how it was marketed.
Xdefiant is very good imo. It's just not for todays players. Im playing fps since mw2 2009 and I was very happy about this game that feel like old school cod. But the majority of the fps community have like 12-20 years old so they grew up with fortnite, apex, warzone etc. these games always have a lot of contents to offer so its always overstimulating the brains of these young teens/ adults. Like Xdefiant Laked of contents for todays standards. For an old school player like me I didn't mind that much
Was*
Oh it's not for todays players? WOW, WHY DIDN'T THEY THINK LIKE YOU? OH WAIT, THEY'RE NOT 20 YEARS OLD AND LIVING WITH MYMMMMYMYMYMYMYMYMYYMYMYOYOMMYMYMYOYMYOMYOMYOMYOYMY
@@prezidenttrump5171 I don’t understand your point
@ Not understanding is a life skill you're best at.
@@prezidenttrump5171 ok, and I guess your skill is being funny 😜🤡
Black ops 4 but free lmfao