What a song, my chest swells with pride just from listening. It reminded me a lot of the German poem/song "Trotz alledem" (literally "For all that") by Ferdinand Freiligrath, with different versions beautifully performed by Wolf Bierman or Hannes Wader. The lyrics, the core message, the melody was so similar. A bit of research just turned up that Freiligrath wrote the German poem for our own German revolutions for unification, during immense struggles for early democracy and representation in the 1840s, and he based it heavily on Burns' poem (effectively translating most). I suppose these are struggles that transcended borders, and struggles that still do, as we still face them, and judging by these comments, the Scots amongst ye are just as moved by these brave ideas of freedom and brotherhood as this German lad is.
Adam Creech, Versailles Kentucky, U.S. Descendant of William Creech, one of Robert Burns' publishers. This song SPEAKS to me! ABSOLUTELY beautiful piece, soulful in expressing that there is great character and integrity in FOLKS from all walks of life. The WORLD would do well to celebrate this.
I have been blessed to see Ed (along with Rich, along with Brian) two times, and am very grateful for those evenings. Wherever a great song can be found, Ed will take it and make it even better. God bless you Ed.
A great song and a fine performance - I decided to watched the Scottish Paliament opening on the strength of his statement that the whole of parliament stood up and joined in the last verse. Disappointingly they all remained seated.
Equality and liberty are great virtues. Ironically people look to the government for answers that best come from themselves and their own communities. All that states can do is appoint someone whose role by its very existence diminishes what equality stands for and, through a convoluted system of laws and taxes, takes away more direct means of solving problems and leaves people financially disadvantaged, thus creating a vicious cycle. The corruption that is created is systemic when accountability is disjointed from power. Once there's enough power over people, then people can't peacefully dissent from authoritarianism. For all the noble sentiment, democracy is a tool for the corrupt to create the illusion of choice and manufacture consent where it does not exist. It's a long dark road of crushing liberty and prosperity when people can be convinced to vote against their own interests and treat their neighbors as opposition.
Liberated people have to be very cool. Otherwise, in a society which doesn't believe in equality and cannot possibly practice it, they would be considered extremely subversive - Alan Watts
My heart swells as my tears break ,Robert burns my namessake for all that and all that,,,
What a song, my chest swells with pride just from listening. It reminded me a lot of the German poem/song "Trotz alledem" (literally "For all that") by Ferdinand Freiligrath, with different versions beautifully performed by Wolf Bierman or Hannes Wader. The lyrics, the core message, the melody was so similar. A bit of research just turned up that Freiligrath wrote the German poem for our own German revolutions for unification, during immense struggles for early democracy and representation in the 1840s, and he based it heavily on Burns' poem (effectively translating most). I suppose these are struggles that transcended borders, and struggles that still do, as we still face them, and judging by these comments, the Scots amongst ye are just as moved by these brave ideas of freedom and brotherhood as this German lad is.
Adam Creech, Versailles Kentucky, U.S. Descendant of William Creech, one of Robert Burns' publishers.
This song SPEAKS to me! ABSOLUTELY beautiful piece, soulful in expressing that there is great character and integrity in FOLKS from all walks of life.
The WORLD would do well to celebrate this.
Agree that this is the best version of this strong and moving song
AWESOME tears in eyes. best song poem ever written
me too can't even sing along for choking up.
fantastic, I love this, a Mans a Man for all that! I love this! Love, Yolanda from Hungary, the land of Freedom, 1956!
One of my favorite Scottish singers, the national anthem of Scotland
A genuine singing of this wonderful song and Ed Miller lets us know how important this song is for humankind.
I have been blessed to see Ed (along with Rich, along with Brian) two times, and am very grateful for those evenings. Wherever a great song can be found, Ed will take it and make it even better. God bless you Ed.
Powerfully sung and played
An eternal song representing beautifully an eternal struggle
That was a beautiful song.
This is the BEST version I’ve heard o this classic
A great rendition. Thanks for sharing
Lovely!
A great song and a fine performance - I decided to watched the Scottish Paliament opening on the strength of his statement that the whole of parliament stood up and joined in the last verse. Disappointingly they all remained seated.
They did join in though!
🙋♂️a yes for me, let us control the future, leave the pomp and royalty behind, let the people sing
very strong version
Wondery❤❤❤❤❤❤
So mote it be...
Well hopefully Scotland is going too Revolt , and Gain its Independence 🏴
👋💓
Beautiful version by Ed, but he never sings a bad version of anything.
Daily we sink deeper into oligarchy and despotism here in the USA. I guess the struggle for justice never ends.
Equality and liberty are great virtues. Ironically people look to the government for answers that best come from themselves and their own communities. All that states can do is appoint someone whose role by its very existence diminishes what equality stands for and, through a convoluted system of laws and taxes, takes away more direct means of solving problems and leaves people financially disadvantaged, thus creating a vicious cycle. The corruption that is created is systemic when accountability is disjointed from power. Once there's enough power over people, then people can't peacefully dissent from authoritarianism. For all the noble sentiment, democracy is a tool for the corrupt to create the illusion of choice and manufacture consent where it does not exist. It's a long dark road of crushing liberty and prosperity when people can be convinced to vote against their own interests and treat their neighbors as opposition.
The price of liberty is eternal vigilance...
Liberated people have to be very cool. Otherwise, in a society which doesn't believe in equality and cannot possibly practice it, they would be considered extremely subversive - Alan Watts
Great song - not the best rendition but not a better song.
Just sing the fuckin' thing for Christ sake.
You came here for his singing and he did? are you daft lad?
"the common man.." i don't think that is the accurate meaning