China's EU Diplomacy: The View from France, Germany, and the United States

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 май 2024
  • May 7, 2024 - Asia Society Policy Institute’s Center for China Analysis (CCA) hosts a discussion about Chinese President Xi Jinping’s visit to France and other European countries this week. Participants include Philippe Le Corre, CCA senior fellow on Foreign Policy and senior advisor of Geopolitics to Asia Society France; Nadine Godehardt, senior associate at the German Institute for International and Security Affairs; and Neysun A. Mahoubi, director of the Penn Project on the Future of U.S.-China Relations at the University of Pennsylvania. Lyle Morris, CCA senior fellow on Foreign Policy and National Security, moderates the conversation. (1 hr., 11 min.)
    Subscribe for more videos like this: AsiaSociety.org/RUclips
    ---
    Support Asia Society today: AsiaSociety.org/Donate
    ---
    Subscribe to our newsletter to stay connected: asiasociety.org/email-subscri...
    ---
    Facebook: / asiasociety
    Instagram: / asiasociety
    Twitter: / asiasociety
    LinkedIn: / asia-society
    #asiasociety #asiasocietypolicyinstitute #china #europe
  • НаукаНаука

Комментарии • 172

  • @jklee5419
    @jklee5419 20 дней назад +108

    Asia Society should be renamed as the US society. These western "Asia Experts" know no shit about Asia.😂😂😂😂

    • @mizanrahman5194
      @mizanrahman5194 19 дней назад +13

      They know and tell what they are paid for, by mighty lobby groups.

    • @gvoyagerlee
      @gvoyagerlee 19 дней назад +5

      totally!

    • @user-yq1fl7uf2r
      @user-yq1fl7uf2r 19 дней назад +5

      100% agree with you !

    • @skshum
      @skshum 19 дней назад +6

      poor guests choice

    • @jiachen7865
      @jiachen7865 19 дней назад +5

      shhhh!!! Stop saying it out lound, let them believe what they believe, they will be fine.

  • @LL-rm8xt
    @LL-rm8xt 20 дней назад +69

    More I listen the more I have concluded this is a propaganda channel.. So many hypocritical comments

    • @mizanrahman5194
      @mizanrahman5194 19 дней назад +1

      They are closed to be termed as perverts.

    • @junizhao
      @junizhao 19 дней назад

      From the Chinese strategic point of view, the more the West misunderstands China, the more advantage China has. If the West didn’t misunderstand China 20 years ago, China would have no chance to rise to the height today.

    • @junizhao
      @junizhao 19 дней назад

      From the Chinese strategic point of view, the more the West misunderstands China, the more advantage China has. If the West didn’t misunderstand China 20 years ago, China would have no chance to rise to the height today.

    • @junizhao
      @junizhao 19 дней назад

      From the Chinese strategic point of view, the more the West misunderstands China, the more advantage China has. If the West didn’t misunderstand China 20 years ago, China would have no chance to have risen to the height today.

    • @junizhao
      @junizhao 19 дней назад

      From the Chinese strategic point of view, the more the West misunderstands China, the more advantage China has. If the West didn’t misunderstand China 20 years ago, China would have no chance to have risen to the height today.

  • @LL-rm8xt
    @LL-rm8xt 20 дней назад +79

    First guy has a very selective narrative...
    1. US via NATO DID bomb the Chinese embassy in Serbia, it was admitted by the US - not as he says, 'china is accusing NATO', what a joke.
    2. He seems to conveniently omit Russia didn't just decide it wanted to invade Ukraine, it was provoked !!!
    3. Fact is China is probably the ONLY country who has worked hard to make the Paris accord happen. Adopting green tech, the rest of the countries just make sound bites but no action.
    Look forward to seeing what happens in Serbia and Hungry..

    • @sarahye3529
      @sarahye3529 19 дней назад +7

      看到越来越多人认清美西方的真实嘴脸
      不再被他们欺骗
      真的很开心
      祝好

    • @user-cy7ej4yr6w
      @user-cy7ej4yr6w 19 дней назад

      One of the programs in DW channel, the host claimed that the US "mistakenly" bombed the embassy but China doesn't accept. Seems like if you "mistakenly" beat someone and doesn't receive a friendly acceptance, the fault must fall on the victim. Arrogance of these people has no end really.

  • @user-dp4oj1hy2y
    @user-dp4oj1hy2y 20 дней назад +31

    Chinese cars account for only 4% of the European market.
    German cars account for more than 20% of the Chinese market. In addition, there are American Tesla, Japanese Toyota, etc. Even the terrible French Renault and American Ford have a place in China.
    By the way, Chinese car sales in the US are about 0%.
    China has an advantage in new energy vehicles, which is a good thing for combating global climate change!
    Unfortunately, since China's new energy vehicles surpassed Tesla, Biden and von der Leyen have hardly talked about the "climate warming issue". Even the German Foreign Minister Berbock of the Green Party has not mentioned it. What they talk about every day now is “Overcapacity”-a word invented in the United States.

    • @junizhao
      @junizhao 19 дней назад +3

      Hypocrisy! Hypocrisy! Hypocrisy!

    • @rickychang2893
      @rickychang2893 19 дней назад +7

      Germany export 75% of the cars she made, Korea 70% & Japan 55% but are not considered Overcapacity. China currently export 15% & 85% for domestic consumption, it is Overcapacity !!!

    • @chongsewaun930
      @chongsewaun930 18 дней назад

      They are scare and worry about almighty China.

  • @Tom-vg8ts
    @Tom-vg8ts 20 дней назад +14

    It really bothers me to see all three speakers smiled when they talked about the Belgrade bombings. The embassy is an extension of a country. In addition, people died. I wonder if they still smile if China bombed their countries.

  • @policiasando4358
    @policiasando4358 20 дней назад +37

    We are just ordinary people but it dosent mean we are doltish. please dont fool us.

  • @bobcat6751
    @bobcat6751 20 дней назад +36

    The title saids it all! "The View from France, Germany, and US". No point of view from China or the rest of the world. I think the west will be better served by hearing more points of view if not from China how about the rest of the world.

  • @HeatherHaymeer
    @HeatherHaymeer 19 дней назад +8

    The comments section paints a clear picture that this is one of the out touch propaganda outlets. I am not going to waste my time.

  • @QuietJagung
    @QuietJagung 20 дней назад +30

    1:05:30 This guy and the lady have no clue about Chinese politics.

    • @miroperinich2495
      @miroperinich2495 19 дней назад +3

      And what should they know?

    • @QuietJagung
      @QuietJagung 18 дней назад

      @@miroperinich2495 Leaders in China get to their position on merit rather than popularity. Watch CGTN if you want to know how the China political system works.

  • @edwinhuang803
    @edwinhuang803 20 дней назад +49

    Does that old guy have any shame when he reiterates the ridiculous overcapacity accusation?

    • @Antiwumao
      @Antiwumao 20 дней назад +1

      It is well established that China uses over capacity to destroy foreign competition, this goes back decades.

    • @zhugeliang3905
      @zhugeliang3905 20 дней назад +4

      Shameless 😕

    • @willengel-vs8ht
      @willengel-vs8ht 20 дней назад +3

      there is no such thing as "Overcapacity" the truth is Chinese EV makers have the battery tech and related software firmly in hand. you do not hear that from the Germans because they decided to partner with Chinese counterparts.

    • @zhugeliang3905
      @zhugeliang3905 19 дней назад +1

      @@willengel-vs8ht
      Yes you have a point

    • @rwksasc
      @rwksasc 19 дней назад +1

      Overcapacity? Prove it? Well, the U.S. says so. So I parrot.

  • @desmondho9567
    @desmondho9567 20 дней назад +33

    The world 🌎🌍🌏 has 8 billions of people.
    U ash has 330,000,000 citizens.
    Europe plus allies has 600,000,000 citizens.
    China is trading with the other 7 billions population around the world. Like in Latin America, Africa Union countries, Middle East countries, Central asia countries and Asian countries. So, what how China overcapacity. ❤❤❤

  • @brainwashington1332
    @brainwashington1332 20 дней назад +26

    Asia Society but not even one Asian, nevermind an actual Chinese. These people have no shame

    • @jackreacher8858
      @jackreacher8858 19 дней назад +1

      I hear one of speakers has a chow chow for pet dog . However dont quote me on that

    • @thewaterway6347
      @thewaterway6347 18 дней назад +1

      You are right, what the fools they are. 😂😂😂😂

  • @attentionarapeller
    @attentionarapeller 19 дней назад +8

    What have you against the Bell and Road? If you ask the countries of the Global Southe they don't think that there is a problem of overcapacity. On the contrary they need cheap wares coming from China. So as always you speak from a very egoistical point of vieuw. There is no problem of overcapacity. The USA have a problem of competition.The same thing when you are speaking about human rights. You are not ashamed to speak about human rights after what happened against the poor Palestinian population without any condamnations from your side. Where were your protestations when the human rights of the russian minority inside of Ukraine was literaly bombed between 2014 and 2022? And now you are already preparing the next proxi war between China and USA in Taïwan, by bringing your weapons to the Indépendant party of Taïwan. What would you say when China would bring weapons to the Indépendant movement of Hawaï ? So please reflect about your own hypocrisie.

  • @desmondho9567
    @desmondho9567 19 дней назад +6

    US hack and spy on Macron and Merkel Handphone conversation.😅

  • @junbaosu8031
    @junbaosu8031 20 дней назад +8

    is there any real professor who know Asia to talk about it

  • @jacintochua6885
    @jacintochua6885 20 дней назад +9

    Serbia and all Eadtetn European countries were ignored by western Europe after the endbof Warsae Pact.
    They were treated as defeared countries . No economic assistance were provided.
    Aside from seducing them into NATO , no help was provided.
    Name one highway, rail line or bridge that western Europe completed for Eastern Europen countries ih the past thirty years.

    • @jackreacher8858
      @jackreacher8858 19 дней назад +1

      There's one rail- line in Slovakia It call NO WHERESKY LINE haha

    • @miroperinich2495
      @miroperinich2495 19 дней назад

      So what do you care when you are not part of Europe and you never will be.

  • @FC-vp9ej
    @FC-vp9ej 20 дней назад +6

    They must've regret they didn't deactivate the comment section as usual🤣🤣

  • @user-xl1wr9wm4f
    @user-xl1wr9wm4f 20 дней назад +16

    The western leaders at all levels require to change their mind-set & understand China & all other countries in the eastern world, which have a right to grow, develop & lead.
    Co-operation & coexistence are necessary.

  • @chriswong9158
    @chriswong9158 20 дней назад +5

    1:03:00 On October 17, 2023, China and Serbia signed a historic Free Trade Agreement (FTA), solidifying their economic ties. The agreement is expected to enhance trade and collaboration in sectors like automotive, technology, agriculture, and commodities. China is looking in a 30 Bn import from Serbia in 2024 trade.

  • @magnaviator
    @magnaviator 18 дней назад +5

    The All White Society is a better name. Not a single asian or even asian-american face. how legitimate can this discussion be?

  • @annaguidone7123
    @annaguidone7123 20 дней назад +7

    Why is nobody talking about the Israeli aggression in the Gaza Strip in this picture?

  • @JooMike-Hi
    @JooMike-Hi 19 дней назад +4

    % of the cars produced are exported.
    Germany: 75%
    South Korea: 70%
    Japan: 50%
    China: 15%
    U$ : China has overcapacity.
    
    Cars per thousand people (from Wiki)
    USA >900
    Australia, France >700
    Japan, Germany >600
    Korea ~500
    Malaysia, Brazil >400
    Mexico, Russia >300
    Thailand, Turkey ~270
    --->> China ~238
    U$ : China has overcapacity.
    
    People are disgusted double standards.

  • @chriswong9158
    @chriswong9158 20 дней назад +4

    53:00 China of 1.5 Billions consumer market vs EU. Only a fool would walk away from 1.5 Bn consumer.

  • @mssv19123
    @mssv19123 19 дней назад +4

    General De Gaulle favor an independent France policy, not lead by the nose of foreign country...

  • @keren7
    @keren7 20 дней назад +10

    So why are they only crying?? What did china really do? Any negative things?..just specify ..

    • @miroperinich2495
      @miroperinich2495 19 дней назад

      Your products are usually cheap government subsidized garbage.

  • @kmich7660
    @kmich7660 19 дней назад +3

    European Society, where art thou? 😊

  • @prasitclinic3058
    @prasitclinic3058 18 дней назад +4

    The program organizer chose to invite like-minded people to express their opinions.They are not real China expert. Too bias.

  • @rwksasc
    @rwksasc 19 дней назад +2

    Wanderliondidmt have her own talking points. They were provided by Blinken.

  • @liwang4022
    @liwang4022 18 дней назад +3

    it's difficult for them to see a strong China

  • @loao9875
    @loao9875 16 дней назад +2

    How many times did these experts visit China or Asia per year? Their money is easy to achieve.

  • @xkli106
    @xkli106 19 дней назад +2

    If China had taken the views seriously(China never do it),China would follow the west seventy-five years ago.

  • @charlesyang4923
    @charlesyang4923 16 дней назад +2

    Two reasons stood out to make me believe why Macron invite Von Der Leyen to join meeting with Xi. Firstly, Macron would like to make believe he still have EU as its backer and can play an important role leading EU future forward. Secondly, be done with all anti-China issues (overcapacity, EV subside investigation ..etc) while Von Der Leyen is at theme to ease out some hardliner EU member state and US for posturing purpose only before France and China can work out serious business deals beneficial to both countries. Besides, No one would consider she is a figure after both Scholtz and Macron oppose Von Der Leyen re-election at European parliament election scheduled June 2024.

  • @liujunming
    @liujunming 16 дней назад +2

    the us man is jealous of the china-france good relationship.

  • @cristinaximera9663
    @cristinaximera9663 17 дней назад +1

    The US a "benign hegemon" ... what a bunch of stooges!

  • @user-vj4sn1hk3n
    @user-vj4sn1hk3n 14 дней назад +1

    One side love affair need to be avoid and realized.

  • @user-ue1hu9nk6j
    @user-ue1hu9nk6j 17 дней назад +2

    All the commentaries below are opposite to these people from asia society . You can fool people some of the time but not all of the time. Most people are well informed these days and they are intelligent enough to make their own conclusions. These people are mouthing their own bigotted opinions with political intend.

  • @michaelmarchal4004
    @michaelmarchal4004 19 дней назад +1

    What about the view from China

  • @SazalibinkamsirSazali-zu5yo
    @SazalibinkamsirSazali-zu5yo 14 дней назад +1

    im from singapore 🤵🌊🔑🏇🗝🌊im follow the Low in my County.

  • @QuietJagung
    @QuietJagung 20 дней назад +3

    4:10 mother is always tagging along.

    • @sparkyfromel
      @sparkyfromel 20 дней назад

      it's not mother , it's the chaperon to Macron , Washington doesn't trust him at all

    • @basanttyagi7516
      @basanttyagi7516 20 дней назад +1

      exactly. macron needs a babysitter at all times! maybe his teacher-wife was occupied so aunty ursula had to come nanny him!

  • @Roy-uj1kx
    @Roy-uj1kx 17 дней назад +1

    BS, you need to go to China and use your own eyes to look at Xinjiang if there is genercide.

  • @chriswong9158
    @chriswong9158 20 дней назад +1

    56:00 China strategies to Nation State: after China’s Century of Humiliation, China's non-interference directive of others

  • @chriswong9158
    @chriswong9158 20 дней назад +1

    1:04:00 Hungarian foreign minister Szijjártó stated in 2023 that Hungarian-Chinese trade was over $10 billion. China wishes to sign up a 35 Bn $$$ trade relationship in 2024 alone, thanks to NATO support. mostly thanks to France & Germany alone.

  • @chriswong9158
    @chriswong9158 20 дней назад +1

    1:07:00 16 plus one mechanism no more: Thanks again to US America, Goldmans Sachs of New York 2001 letter idea of BRIC This is the vehicle with all members of equal standing join for the better of their citizens. This year alone, BRICS+ summit will welcome other Nation State in the city of Kazan, October 2024. Motto: Don't look back to Europe leadership

  • @qingshanyipian1936
    @qingshanyipian1936 19 дней назад +1

    Your first guest is full of it. He needs to get new sources for information

  • @Qiushishuo
    @Qiushishuo 19 дней назад +1

    16:39 What are you laughing at? Shame.

  • @jackreacher8858
    @jackreacher8858 19 дней назад

    Was VDLeyen there ? Could have fool me !

  • @serasichongchinliong3450
    @serasichongchinliong3450 18 дней назад +2

    A bunch of lousy guests. Blabbing and beat around the bushes.

  • @aftabnahvi8454
    @aftabnahvi8454 19 дней назад +1

    What about war on iqra and liba you old man

  • @mgs9735
    @mgs9735 19 дней назад

    BS. How do you call yourself the expert on the foreign relationship. If your government or president listens to your advances, your country is screwed.

  • @user-vj4sn1hk3n
    @user-vj4sn1hk3n 15 дней назад

    Thank you for an informative talk. May be more decisive words could promote better desirable result?, perhaps. EU leaders are kind of so modest. For the first time Xi toned down after recent internal economic situations or not?

  • @howardhan2101
    @howardhan2101 19 дней назад

    You are counted as friends as well

  • @milaong9618
    @milaong9618 20 дней назад +4

    Is this society still around? 😂

  • @user-vj4sn1hk3n
    @user-vj4sn1hk3n 15 дней назад

    Language barrier by itself could be reduced by more straight forward ideas and wording. Expect 2much from Xi is 2much.

  • @amiigose
    @amiigose 20 дней назад +10

    they talk about china but no chinese 😂😂😂😂

    • @NaijaOracle
      @NaijaOracle 20 дней назад +2

      They are China experts. They know everything there is to know.

    • @amiigose
      @amiigose 20 дней назад +3

      @@NaijaOracle 😂😂😂 🤣🤣 like gordon chang 🤣🤣🤣🤣, lol

    • @user-xu4oi9lv8n
      @user-xu4oi9lv8n 19 дней назад

      @@NaijaOracle *No, they are not China experts, but anti-China experts.*

  • @thomaslau1214
    @thomaslau1214 17 дней назад +1

    Three guests without clues on facts. On the other hand, they need to make a living anf are paid by US NGO.

  • @chenlingjie6982
    @chenlingjie6982 20 дней назад +1

    ha~pretend to discuss. you guys really independent and with dignity?

  • @chriswong9158
    @chriswong9158 20 дней назад

    With all is going on around Europe, how France was offer the moment with open hand, lost a 240.1 billion U.S. dollars yearly trade partner for the United States of America and NATO partner. God bless them. By the way, guess whom have the 240 bn China trade 2023. Also guess how much USA trade with France in 2023.. somewhere about 23 bn yearly alone. Oh well...

  • @user-xe9qq4wn7v
    @user-xe9qq4wn7v 19 дней назад +1

    They are bunch of veg

  • @SazalibinkamsirSazali-zu5yo
    @SazalibinkamsirSazali-zu5yo 14 дней назад +1

    Thank you so much have nice Talking, about horse Racing🏇👍🤵im not so clever person ,just im share my Leaning more deep by number Tip.🔑🌊🏇🗝🌊👀im look want public bring out the Tip.must done Tiece and Quartet.+/or Throw -

  • @ziaohaha
    @ziaohaha 19 дней назад

    Ha-ha! Come on, every video on RUclips channel is a propaganda in one way or another, depending on your mindset, ha-ha! and Cheers!🍺🍺🍺

  • @QuietJagung
    @QuietJagung 20 дней назад +4

    Vote up here to vote down for the video.

    • @Antiwumao
      @Antiwumao 20 дней назад

      look at all the chinese spam accounts in the comments here even though youtube is blocked by the oppressive regime in china

  • @pfl3436
    @pfl3436 19 дней назад +1

    You can discuss among yourself but dont broadcast to the world. Your group is not qualified to speak for the people of the world.

  • @lomotil3370
    @lomotil3370 20 дней назад

    Oh no! China's little pinks have found this video! The West is dooooomed!

  • @jc9109
    @jc9109 20 дней назад

    Where is Asian? Wont be watching

  • @zhangmike1308
    @zhangmike1308 20 дней назад +11

    Free Gaza!

    • @Antiwumao
      @Antiwumao 20 дней назад +1

      Free Tibet, Xingjang, Inner Mongolia and Hong Kong from chinese dictatorships modern colonialism

  • @user-lx1re3fn2u
    @user-lx1re3fn2u 18 дней назад

    Ridiculous guys.