It isn’t the same situation though. Vader was the Jedi’s creation. None of what he had done was Luke’s fault bc he had nothing to do with Vader’s fall. Kylo was luke’s creation and responsibility though. Luke foresaw his turn and knew that the death and destruction Ben would cause would be his fault alone. That’s why he briefly considered killing Ben (but he never would’ve actually done it as he says). And don’t forget he almost kills Vader anyway even after the events described in this video
@@JAMISRAexcept he doesn’t kill Vader because he is a true Jedi and realizes he can switch his father. The fact that he can’t change kylo a young man is absolutely stupid and terrible writing. That’s why last Jedi is so hated because it’s alien to Lukes character.
The reason Luke is such a powerful Jedi, is that he is fueled by empathy and love. It’s that love that allows him to even use some force abilities which would be deemed as exclusively dark by many, but doing them out of love changes the very nature of them. He turns dark to light within himself, his family, and the very galaxy.
Out of universe comparing that dual to the one that Luke had with Vader he would actually realize that he stood no chance because the movies made in the '70s and '80s they moved way too slow
I picture Luke in the corner “losing his religion” and becoming addicted to the violent po*n genre and tries to make it in the adult movie world but with his ridiculously tiny micro genitalia he gets ridiculed by all the people who he then force chokes them and his chicken achieving the ultimate apex and lives the remainder of his life in exile knowing why old Ben did the exact same thing
Luke and Obi Wan would have strikingly different vantage points. Kenobi saw all of Anakin’s pettiness, arrogance, ego, and jealousy that led him to the dark side. His decision on Mustafar was correct: Trust in the Force. Luke came into the relationship without fully grasping the flaws of his father, so it was easier for him to see the good.
Luke’s ability to relate to Obi Won in the moment he left Vader to die, but still have pity/sympathy for what his father had become is probably the most important aspect of his capacity to redeem Vader. Knowing that his son still had love for him after everything he had done gave Anakin the impetus he needed to turn on Palpatine before the end.
Luke is his mother's son and believes that their is still good in his father and use the massive amount of compassion and empathy within himself to redeem his father, particularly even more so upon learning how vader became whom he was now, more machine than man.
Luke acted how the force would have wanted him to it's not a matter of deserved because when it comes down to it no one deserves anything. The thought of deserving something is just that a thought made up by us living beings a hope that we will get something for every action we perform or don't perform.
@@joshkrause2977 He was at first but was later manipulated by Palpatine to go down the wrong path he was to bring balance and have balance of the light and dark within him. But he was lead a stray and to far down the darkside to do things he shouldn't have and that the force didn't and wouldn't want to happen. As for a force ghost anyone can learn to be one but not all will make it through the trials of the path to becoming one and in Anakin's case he most likely would have been one weather he learned about it or not sense he was the choose one and the most power being with the force to date with only his son Luke rivaling him. The only thing that kept Vader from reaching his full power wasn't his injuries but the conflict within him, if he had gotten through it Palpatine would have been but a flee to him.
This is very touching. True Jedi. Beacon of hope,light. Luke is the light side. He's like Padme. Leia is like Anakin :) Maybe he could be more angry at Obi-Wan. May the Force be with you too. See you in the next video :)
I always liked how Luke handled pulling his father back to the light. As Vader escorted Luke to Palpatine, he grabbed his lightsaber and ignited it. Even as an evil lord, you could tell Vader was so proud to see his son wielding a Green saber. Vader came back to the light side right before he died. It was a beautiful moment if you’ve ever watched the original movies. I know they are old and hard to keep up on but so worth the watch. He may have been Darth Vader, but he was born as, and died as Anakin Skywalker.
Luke is truly an amazing character. The fulfillment of what Anakin was supposed to be. He did what Yoda and Ben could not do. Then Disney went and shit all over his character and legacy and for that I will never watch anything disney makes under the " disney star wars" banner. Star wars will live on in this channel and other true fans who make fan fiction films.
Tbh the way Obi Wan left Amakin there was very strange considering the damage Anakin had caused and what he could (did) cause if left alive. If he waited, made sure he was dead, or saved him then things could have been different but he just walked away.
Yeah it was Obi's greatest failing imo, by not killing Anakin he indirectly killed millions, maybe billions. I don't think Obi would ever fall to the dark side, it's just not in him to embrace it for anything more than a fleeting second. I think it was just an excuse he created because he really didn't want to kill Anakin and deal with the absolute shame and guilt he'd have to endure after. It was already bad enough that he left him for dead.
In the book, he basically has the same thought process as described here "killing him would be merciful, and I have no mercy for him" but he also mentions seeing the Emporer's shuttle and senses him, and says that if he goes down to kill Anakin, he wouldn't have time to escape and save Padme
@@ericm5315Not true. Without Vader being left alive, Palpatine's reign would have never ended. You need Vader to kill the unsuspecting Emperor in RotJ.
Man it's stuff like this that makes the sequel trilogy no sense at all especially Luke's attitude towards everything, Luke didn't give up or fall even when Caedus killed mara Jade...Luke still refuses to kill his own nephew who just killed Luke's own wife and aunty of Caedus himself....I couldn't do that.😢 My nephew kills my wife....I fear what I would do to my nephew...Luke's definitely a light of hope forever
I don't know what i think about what he thought. All I'm thinking about is how neither Yoda, nor Kenobi were exactly covering themselves in glory during the final acts of their lives. Both of them egging on Luke to kill his father.🤨 What exactly is The Force's view on patricide? That look on Yoda's face when Luke asked him wasn't compassionate concern for Luke, it was him thinking "F*CK!! Who told him?! Great, now WTF are we going to do? Kenobi: he made sure Luke was watching when he let Vader cut through him right when he jumped through the Force glory-hole into the great beyond, or whenever he went. The point was so that Luke would think that Vader killed him. He even smirked right before he did it! A shit eating grin that i might add, that looked not unlike Palpatine's when he was on his back with Windu over him. It was that "I'm going to manipulate this idiot kid," grin. 😏 Dicks
I think Luke made the right call but should be a little bit more angry at both men, Obi-wan and even Yoda in a way was just dobging the problem which in the long run only made things worse. And Luke should have pity for his own father but should be more willing to hold him accountable for his own action both before and AFTER Mustafar, for the emperor’s willing pawn or to save Padme does not justify his crimes against the galaxy.
Luke didn't understand the power of the Dark Side, so it is understandable that he would fall back on jedi dogma to try to save Vader, even not knowing for certain he was his actual father. But he knew. And he loved his father, as any good son does.
Haha You put me like Obi-Wan, take don't Anakin yesterday. And you sound way happier to day like Luke. I learned a lot! Thanks for making my night, before I go to bed, like you have the past 2 month. Or I have just watch night time two weeks 😅 and day time before.
@@tallonmetroids271 HAH. SORRY THOUGH, i'M PRETTY SURE THAT'Z NOT HOW U WANTED YOUR RELATiONSHiP WiTH HiM TO GO TRUE FREEDOM JACK, WE KAN ALWAYZ CHOOZE WORZE TO THE LAZT BREATH [NOT YELLiNG, JUZT LiKE TYPiNG iN CAPZ]
Striking down an unarmed (literally) opponent is not the Jedi way. Given his actions in Palpatine's office regarding Mace Windu, Anakin surely must have at least respected Obi-Wan's decision to abstain from striking him down. In ROTJ, Luke does the same: he defeats Vader, but will not strike him down because, "I am a Jedi, like my father before me." It is not the Jedi way.
Luke had no reason to question ObiWan. He left Anakins fate up to the force. That's the heart of the true Jedi Way. Not doing just good, but simply obeying the will of the Force. That's why Palpatine was terrified of Quigon. He was the last true Jedi left.
Obi-wan leaves Anakin's fate up to the force and Luke embraces the true nature of the force. In so doing, Vader destroys Palpatine. It was the actions of those two that ultimately led to Palpatine's defeat, much like Bilbo's mercy for Golem leads to the ultimate destruction of the ring and saving Middle Earth.
Obi left Anakin to die. As if Anakin wasn't trying to kill him or slaughtered younglings. Anakin deserved to live forever with the consequences of his actions and he did.
Maybe the realization that if Obi became evil he would become the most powerful Sith Lord in history! Remember attack of the clones count wanted to recuit Obi... The fact that he was able to defeat young Vader and vader obi show really tells you he could have defeated the emperor in combat!
He felt pritty for both them. They were like his brothers. Luke can understand that ben had no intention of killing his father. He realized that he failed anakin as master Even allowing the emperor to take him away from him. That goes for anakin, aka darth vader, as well... And losing everyone he cares, even killing them. It was really tough for him to come back to life. Even having the emperor tortured him in pain knowing that He's under his boot. You have to know where to run. Do the emperorwhat he says
Kenobi was wrong for doing that to Anakin . He went against the will of the force and the empire still rose to power even though the jedi tried to stop it . Anakin could have always turned back to the light . Palpatine didn't create the monster vader became . The Jedi did . Anakin was insecure and the Jedi amplified it . Anakin was angry and hurt over his mother and the Jedi did nothing to bring comfort to him . And palpatine was there building Anakin up and showing him compassion when he needed it . Although it was for palpatines own nefarious reasons . If the Jedi would have had a little more compassion and believed in Anakin more the empire would have bever been ..
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
Imagine taking Luke and his character from that to killing your apprentice in there sleep then wondering why it’s not well received
Exactly - because they dont understand!
It isn’t the same situation though. Vader was the Jedi’s creation. None of what he had done was Luke’s fault bc he had nothing to do with Vader’s fall. Kylo was luke’s creation and responsibility though. Luke foresaw his turn and knew that the death and destruction Ben would cause would be his fault alone. That’s why he briefly considered killing Ben (but he never would’ve actually done it as he says). And don’t forget he almost kills Vader anyway even after the events described in this video
@@JAMISRAexcept he doesn’t kill Vader because he is a true Jedi and realizes he can switch his father. The fact that he can’t change kylo a young man is absolutely stupid and terrible writing. That’s why last Jedi is so hated because it’s alien to Lukes character.
Luke being out of character was done purely to force undeserved sympathy for Kylo.
These Legends stories are remarkable. I can’t get enough of hearing them, and would love more. This is the universe we deserve.
and we still actually have it. Disney cannot actually take it away.
The reason Luke is such a powerful Jedi, is that he is fueled by empathy and love. It’s that love that allows him to even use some force abilities which would be deemed as exclusively dark by many, but doing them out of love changes the very nature of them.
He turns dark to light within himself, his family, and the very galaxy.
Imagine if Luke watched a recording of anakin vs obi wan
I believe he did.
@@darthvader77813ya i think.
Out of universe comparing that dual to the one that Luke had with Vader he would actually realize that he stood no chance because the movies made in the '70s and '80s they moved way too slow
He would shoked by stupid and crazy battle over volcanos and lava post apocalyptic world 🤣
I picture Luke in the corner “losing his religion” and becoming addicted to the violent po*n genre and tries to make it in the adult movie world but with his ridiculously tiny micro genitalia he gets ridiculed by all the people who he then force chokes them and his chicken achieving the ultimate apex and lives the remainder of his life in exile knowing why old Ben did the exact same thing
Luke and Obi Wan would have strikingly different vantage points. Kenobi saw all of Anakin’s pettiness, arrogance, ego, and jealousy that led him to the dark side. His decision on Mustafar was correct: Trust in the Force. Luke came into the relationship without fully grasping the flaws of his father, so it was easier for him to see the good.
"Well, one might say that, and even think it wise, but only from a certain point of view"
Luke’s ability to relate to Obi Won in the moment he left Vader to die, but still have pity/sympathy for what his father had become is probably the most important aspect of his capacity to redeem Vader.
Knowing that his son still had love for him after everything he had done gave Anakin the impetus he needed to turn on Palpatine before the end.
Luke is his mother's son and believes that their is still good in his father and use the massive amount of compassion and empathy within himself to redeem his father, particularly even more so upon learning how vader became whom he was now, more machine than man.
from the title i was like "did luke watch revenge of the sith?"
That pfp is insane
@@Popobefastonyoass changed it cuz im actually scared of losing my account lol
Lol
Luke’s growth between empire and Jedi and his path to knighthood is one of the most interesting parts of the story to be explored.
Luke acted how the force would have wanted him to it's not a matter of deserved because when it comes down to it no one deserves anything. The thought of deserving something is just that a thought made up by us living beings a hope that we will get something for every action we perform or don't perform.
Yoooooo.....
Technically you could say Anakin acted how the force wanted him to. Why else would he become a force ghost afterwards?
@@joshkrause2977 He was at first but was later manipulated by Palpatine to go down the wrong path he was to bring balance and have balance of the light and dark within him. But he was lead a stray and to far down the darkside to do things he shouldn't have and that the force didn't and wouldn't want to happen. As for a force ghost anyone can learn to be one but not all will make it through the trials of the path to becoming one and in Anakin's case he most likely would have been one weather he learned about it or not sense he was the choose one and the most power being with the force to date with only his son Luke rivaling him. The only thing that kept Vader from reaching his full power wasn't his injuries but the conflict within him, if he had gotten through it Palpatine would have been but a flee to him.
If more people would practice understanding and forgiveness this world would be a better place.
This is very touching. True Jedi. Beacon of hope,light. Luke is the light side. He's like Padme. Leia is like Anakin :) Maybe he could be more angry at Obi-Wan. May the Force be with you too. See you in the next video :)
Mans knew, he took the high ground in ROTJ.
But vader was like naw son not this time.
I always liked how Luke handled pulling his father back to the light. As Vader escorted Luke to Palpatine, he grabbed his lightsaber and ignited it. Even as an evil lord, you could tell Vader was so proud to see his son wielding a Green saber. Vader came back to the light side right before he died. It was a beautiful moment if you’ve ever watched the original movies. I know they are old and hard to keep up on but so worth the watch. He may have been Darth Vader, but he was born as, and died as Anakin Skywalker.
Luke is truly an amazing character. The fulfillment of what Anakin was supposed to be. He did what Yoda and Ben could not do. Then Disney went and shit all over his character and legacy and for that I will never watch anything disney makes under the " disney star wars" banner. Star wars will live on in this channel and other true fans who make fan fiction films.
Tbh the way Obi Wan left Amakin there was very strange considering the damage Anakin had caused and what he could (did) cause if left alive.
If he waited, made sure he was dead, or saved him then things could have been different but he just walked away.
Yeah it was Obi's greatest failing imo, by not killing Anakin he indirectly killed millions, maybe billions. I don't think Obi would ever fall to the dark side, it's just not in him to embrace it for anything more than a fleeting second. I think it was just an excuse he created because he really didn't want to kill Anakin and deal with the absolute shame and guilt he'd have to endure after. It was already bad enough that he left him for dead.
In the book, he basically has the same thought process as described here "killing him would be merciful, and I have no mercy for him" but he also mentions seeing the Emporer's shuttle and senses him, and says that if he goes down to kill Anakin, he wouldn't have time to escape and save Padme
@@ericm5315Not true. Without Vader being left alive, Palpatine's reign would have never ended. You need Vader to kill the unsuspecting Emperor in RotJ.
lets start a petition to make this guy creative director of disney's star wars
Kenobi didn't leave Anakin to die, he left him to for the force to decide his fate
Couldn't let the senate decide his fate on that one.
Man it's stuff like this that makes the sequel trilogy no sense at all especially Luke's attitude towards everything, Luke didn't give up or fall even when Caedus killed mara Jade...Luke still refuses to kill his own nephew who just killed Luke's own wife and aunty of Caedus himself....I couldn't do that.😢 My nephew kills my wife....I fear what I would do to my nephew...Luke's definitely a light of hope forever
thaniks for the video, another fun one
You are an incredible story teller
“Don’t play with someone who bisected your faja”
THIS IS OUTRAGEOUS
It's UNFAIR!! How can you be on the council and not be a master?
Take a Seat Young @@itstjharris
NNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
@@theforcedragon3781No u know what F**CK U *kills mace windu*
“The healing power of the light is the only thing that can truly dominate the destructive powers of the dark” - Truly poetic and so true!
I don't know what i think about what he thought. All I'm thinking about is how neither Yoda, nor Kenobi were exactly covering themselves in glory during the final acts of their lives. Both of them egging on Luke to kill his father.🤨 What exactly is The Force's view on patricide?
That look on Yoda's face when Luke asked him wasn't compassionate concern for Luke, it was him thinking "F*CK!! Who told him?! Great, now WTF are we going to do?
Kenobi: he made sure Luke was watching when he let Vader cut through him right when he jumped through the Force glory-hole into the great beyond, or whenever he went. The point was so that Luke would think that Vader killed him. He even smirked right before he did it! A shit eating grin that i might add, that looked not unlike Palpatine's when he was on his back with Windu over him. It was that "I'm going to manipulate this idiot kid," grin. 😏
Dicks
It's a shame that Luke fell into the hands of the mouse
I think Luke made the right call but should be a little bit more angry at both men, Obi-wan and even Yoda in a way was just dobging the problem which in the long run only made things worse. And Luke should have pity for his own father but should be more willing to hold him accountable for his own action both before and AFTER Mustafar, for the emperor’s willing pawn or to save Padme does not justify his crimes against the galaxy.
Luke didn't understand the power of the Dark Side, so it is understandable that he would fall back on jedi dogma to try to save Vader, even not knowing for certain he was his actual father. But he knew. And he loved his father, as any good son does.
Haha
You put me like Obi-Wan, take don't Anakin yesterday.
And you sound way happier to day like Luke.
I learned a lot!
Thanks for making my night, before I go to bed, like you have the past 2 month.
Or I have just watch night time two weeks 😅 and day time before.
Notification gang LET'S GOOOO BRO!
1:53 we're all gone, carry on!❤
Very instructive on how to forgive our own fathers
Nah, I'm good. I've seen what mine is like if you forgive him, and everyone is better off if he's left alone to rot.
@@tallonmetroids271 HAH.
SORRY THOUGH, i'M PRETTY SURE THAT'Z NOT HOW U WANTED YOUR RELATiONSHiP WiTH HiM TO GO
TRUE FREEDOM JACK, WE KAN ALWAYZ CHOOZE WORZE TO THE LAZT BREATH
[NOT YELLiNG, JUZT LiKE TYPiNG iN CAPZ]
Ado ends at 00:46
Is this a sneaky reupload? Could've sworn I watched this exact video with the same story a month or two ago.
Even harder to imagine luke trying to kill ben after watching this
Fantastic.
I’m sure I’ve seen you post this video before. I love the effort you all put in and have watched countless videos, but I’m seeing a lot of repetition.
Striking down an unarmed (literally) opponent is not the Jedi way. Given his actions in Palpatine's office regarding Mace Windu, Anakin surely must have at least respected Obi-Wan's decision to abstain from striking him down. In ROTJ, Luke does the same: he defeats Vader, but will not strike him down because, "I am a Jedi, like my father before me." It is not the Jedi way.
I thought this was going to be about the high ground.
He deserves to be angry but the thing that always stands out about Luke is that he is far more compassionate than every other Jedi who came before him
Luke had no reason to question ObiWan. He left Anakins fate up to the force. That's the heart of the true Jedi Way. Not doing just good, but simply obeying the will of the Force. That's why Palpatine was terrified of Quigon. He was the last true Jedi left.
He is like comic storian of star wars
Imagine if luke just watched episode lll
So what if Luke lost both hands 😆🤣🤣
Luke would be asking who has #TDBank card? 🌎💘💰
Luke and padme what was their interaction.
What if Obi had attacked and Anakin had used his pain and anger to skip Obi into the lava
It is crazy that George Lucas is coming back
George Lucas is the force
So I hope that he gives John Hamel
AKA Luke Skywalker
A redemption trilogy
Luke was / is a stoic I do believe
Was this from the Expanded Universe or is this from Disney?
Obi-wan leaves Anakin's fate up to the force and Luke embraces the true nature of the force. In so doing, Vader destroys Palpatine. It was the actions of those two that ultimately led to Palpatine's defeat, much like Bilbo's mercy for Golem leads to the ultimate destruction of the ring and saving Middle Earth.
Day 475 of asking for a part 3 of what if anakin was trained by qui gon
Obi left Anakin to die. As if Anakin wasn't trying to kill him or slaughtered younglings. Anakin deserved to live forever with the consequences of his actions and he did.
Maybe the realization that if Obi became evil he would become the most powerful Sith Lord in history! Remember attack of the clones count wanted to recuit Obi... The fact that he was able to defeat young Vader and vader obi show really tells you he could have defeated the emperor in combat!
720p video? bruh get with the times lol
He felt pritty for both them. They were like his brothers. Luke can understand that ben had no intention of killing his father.
He realized that he failed anakin as master Even allowing the emperor to take him away from him.
That goes for anakin, aka darth vader, as well... And losing everyone he cares, even killing them. It was really tough for him to come back to life. Even having the emperor tortured him in pain knowing that He's under his boot. You have to know where to run. Do the emperorwhat he says
What if Obi-Wan killed anikin and fell to the dark side?
Why didn't Luke just watch Revenge of the Sith? It would have explained everything
Kenobi was wrong for doing that to Anakin . He went against the will of the force and the empire still rose to power even though the jedi tried to stop it . Anakin could have always turned back to the light . Palpatine didn't create the monster vader became . The Jedi did . Anakin was insecure and the Jedi amplified it . Anakin was angry and hurt over his mother and the Jedi did nothing to bring comfort to him . And palpatine was there building Anakin up and showing him compassion when he needed it . Although it was for palpatines own nefarious reasons . If the Jedi would have had a little more compassion and believed in Anakin more the empire would have bever been ..
No views?
NO VIEWS IN ON MINUTE?
oh you what the deal is man
No life?
Nothing better to do?
Oh touch grass lil bro
@@Wolfyvibess seems like someone is on his high horse. as you had nothing better to do yourself but reply to this comment um "cough cough lil bro"
i think notifications are like 2 minutes late
@@felixortiz257 my comment still stands 💀 *cough cough* just prove me right
@@Wolfyvibess so does mine
Hi
Oh but I thought kenobi had nooo idea vader was alive. Jfc kenobi was such garbage
No way I let anakin stay alive. He's dying. Quick and clean
First 😂
KingShadow was first, we lost😅
Im gay
whoop de f**king doo
all these star wars channels are grifters
luke is wack
Yes. This actually makes a lot of sense. Normally these summaries are full of sh*t but this makes sense.