It was such an unfortunate event that happened to BB, so sorry for your loss. As a final year vet student, I have to admit that it is very disappointing to learn about the veterinary scene in Hong Kong. Like Dr. Chen said, we earn our degree through expensive education and years of hard work. I was once told that vets do not earn a salary proportionate to their working hours and effort, and I can tell you that it is true for many vets I know. However, just like any other industry, there are certain vets who do not live up to professional ethics. Clearly, legislation plays an important role and it is a matter that should be dealt with, so that the vets who made a mistake will face legal consequences. Despite of these unfortunate events, I hope owners will not lose faith in vets, since there are many vets who works with passion and compassion in the industry that deserve to be respected and applauded.
Hi Munwai - thanks a lot for your condolences. Absolutely agree with your comment - Owners and vets should not work against, but together to help our pets live better lives. Despite BB having a tragic outcome with Dr. Yip, vets and aspiring vets like Dr.Chen and yourself have instilled our faith in the overall veterinary scene again. Wishing you all the best in graduating!
By reading ur comments below, seems like the vet only wanted to try her best to save ur cat and she seems like a nice person to me. Did u properly communicate with her beforehand?
多謝陳醫生同100毛🙏🙏
多謝100毛報導,多謝陳醫生講出真相!! ❤️ #希望香港有毛孩權益保障
真係好多謝毛記同陳醫生,我都同我嘅寵物睇左一個原先好有心好愛動物嘅醫生7年,佢由受僱於一間診所到自己開診所,呢幾年真係開始著重於邊啲賺到錢,邊啲係無咁賺錢,由原先100%嘅專業,用心,到而家得番50%,50%係為賺錢,真係好失望同心痛,好嘅獸醫真係唔多,不過近呢兩年再遇到個,真係會站喺主人立場同埋動物立場去比佢專業嘅意見,會詳細講晒如果相應嘅treatment做定唔做會分別有咩過程同結果,等主人因應番自己寵物情況再決定
而家呢個政府唔好話對保護動物嗰方面冇任何好嘅法例或安排,就算對人都冇,只要唔傷害人已經好難得啦!
唉。。。
講得好,因為現在有疫情,根本資源不足,入左醫院行得番出來,已經好叻叻,唔係讚醫護叻,係本身個病人底打得好,係無什麼人照顧下仍能生存,你睇下死大部份係年紀大極需要人照顧那種,你就知有幾惡劣
Yes lar!
多謝100毛,多謝陳醫生為動物發聲🙏🏻
希望快D多D毛孩權益,不過香港現在人權益都開始消失😓無論怎樣小生命更需保護
@@AppleDailyFriends 都唔好望特衰正苦係正視動物問題
It was such an unfortunate event that happened to BB, so sorry for your loss. As a final year vet student, I have to admit that it is very disappointing to learn about the veterinary scene in Hong Kong. Like Dr. Chen said, we earn our degree through expensive education and years of hard work. I was once told that vets do not earn a salary proportionate to their working hours and effort, and I can tell you that it is true for many vets I know. However, just like any other industry, there are certain vets who do not live up to professional ethics. Clearly, legislation plays an important role and it is a matter that should be dealt with, so that the vets who made a mistake will face legal consequences. Despite of these unfortunate events, I hope owners will not lose faith in vets, since there are many vets who works with passion and compassion in the industry that deserve to be respected and applauded.
Hi Munwai - thanks a lot for your condolences. Absolutely agree with your comment - Owners and vets should not work against, but together to help our pets live better lives. Despite BB having a tragic outcome with Dr. Yip, vets and aspiring vets like Dr.Chen and yourself have instilled our faith in the overall veterinary scene again. Wishing you all the best in graduating!
我都好感同身受,我養左11年既貴婦狗前幾個禮拜無啦啦突然之間好唔舒服,要睇醫生,跟住發現原來係要做手術先解決到嘅問題。
我都猶豫咗好耐,驚有咩事就失去佢,又唔知信唔信得過個醫生,好唔好睇多幾個醫生先決定。但因為隻狗實在太唔舒服,唔可以再拖,所以決定做手術。好彩信啱咗個好醫生,隻狗最後冇事。我完全明白陳太嘅感受,如果隻狗有咩事我都會成世人唔安樂。
其實已經唔係第一次聽到有咁多醫療事故,最後都係因為法律太落後,縱容一班無良醫生,令到所有試過不了了之。如果香港再唔update保護動物法例嘅話,情況不堪設想。
有養寵物的人就會知道 寵物離開係幾痛,希望bb主人保重!bb會用另一個身份再回來你身邊。
多謝毛記電視的優質製作!感激Dr. Chan 的勇敢揭露!BB 主人,請不要太自責!他這生得到你們的悉心愛護,是個幸福的毛孩子,也不枉無憾了!
多謝 Karcy Li, 陳醫生, 100毛
感謝陳醫生為動物發聲🙏🏻亦希望陳太唔好太傷心、自責💪
曾經朋友養過隻貓未夠一歲, 當時唔知咩事, 想嘔但嘔唔出, 有時地下會見到嘔出黎既口水有帶血絲, 做主人自然會擔心,
去左太子某間24小時動物診所, 醫生check 完, 怕佢有頭髮會翹住D腸, 所以話要開刀.
當然最後無比醫生咁做, 去左港島區一間有名的貓診所, 留醫半日,最後因為吐唔到毛, 所以佢吐左血絲出呢,
而家已10歲, 非常建康有活力。
香港市面睇獸醫, 好似撞手神, 真係睇下好唔好彩遇到有無醫德的寵物醫生
開刀 收你多D錢呀嗎,當然咩事都開刀啦,佢都痴筋
係呀!仲要睇埋你當日的幸運指數
就算唔開刀,一出口就係驗什麼什麼,最賺錢的借口,又唔駛辛苦,睇報告找答案,同政府一樣,不過政府咁做唔駛錢,要你們排隊等,等得到就等,等唔到死左唔知咩野事囉
Dr. Chan 好勇敢👍🏻
其實呢位陳醫生好有問題,我隻貓貓就係俾佢醫死咗,仲駛咗幾萬蚊,佢根本係吊住住貓條命,嚟屈錢……
不單指獸醫連到診所姑娘一啲愛心都冇。只求一份工作。
我家爱犬比姑娘打針,剃毛剃到見血,幾個月都生唔番毛😑
我第時會養狗狗,如果狗狗有需要我都會考慮搵呢位醫生睇,覺得佢係有heart 既人。
辛苦了,謝謝你為香港既寵物付出。❤️🙏🏻
多謝陳醫生,100毛,同埋所有有良心默默付出嘅獸醫。
之前佢喺IG Story度問人邊個獸醫好 我諗好多人都有介紹到俾佢, 但冇諗過最後會揀咗葉XX😔
香港政府醒醒啦!請重新修例,正視保障毛孩和主人的權益啦😤
做獸醫真係好辛苦(只限有heart)
真係難過做人嘅醫生😢
多謝你為這些無辜動物申訴和尋怨
陳醫生好有心!
多謝陳醫生同毛記! 動物真係好需要被保護
真正的獸醫❤有愛心的好人
多謝毛毛同所有良心獸醫
醫生冇良心 = 殺手冇分別! 網友識做喇, 自行black list 個位殺手!!! Support 💪💪💪 CLS! BB RIP
These incidents are absolutely heart breaking! 😭😭😭
多謝毛記同陳醫生為動物發聲
其實講到尾就係個政府制度攪成咁~
睇到喊...rip BB..
Thank You dr. Chan
所以話,制度好緊要。一個健全既制度,可以透過制裁一啲無良心既醫者,令業界警惕唔可以輕率,亦令好醫生唔會被壞醫生既惡行拖累。
香港仲講制度已經係一個笑話
@@ekrkikc 港共治下無,唔代表永遠都無。我總唔信雜總同呢個千蒼百孔既中共国可以玩多十年。作為香港人,今日做唔到唔代表唔需要學習,而家就好似當年既三年零八個月,捱過之後總會有重光之日,到時我哋需要重建返一個文明同有秩序既社會。
感謝香港醫護
香港人加油💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻
靠政府就算把啦,又依樣個樣。我覺得診所依類其實都好需要類似openrice咁既平台,整合哂所有資料,有評分有comment,所有資料集中,有心既可以諗下
我好想知道陳醫生嘅診所嘅地址邊,我要介紹俾人
多謝你地
She is a true good vet. I also hope those bad vet got their karma soon.
靠口碑。。希望主人企出嚟
你真係講得很對,可惜我可能睇得你這個節目太遲,我前天帶隻狗仔去沙田圍獸醫診所看病,這是新帶去看病的診所,因為近自己屋企,又看見網上評論得不錯,我隻貓唔肯食野一天,本身又有腎病,所以打左幾間無位,剛好這間有得看,就帶牠下午去這診所,隻貓入到診所還識叫,識行,精神還可以,當時果位男醫生話我隻係腎病老貓,基本要驗好多血液分析、尿液分析,才能知牠發生什麼事,但這些都是好表面知道佢的情況,粗略估計要2000幾元,因為救貓深切,所以應承照做,他說一小時後取貓,又無得睇住佢做,真係唔知佢將隻貓點樣做,一小時過後,他解釋報告都係好多野未如理想,咁我都諗住帶牠回家開開心心安樂死,都未完全講解完份報告,突然有護士抱住隻貓話要急救,我都未察覺係自己隻貓,後期先通知我,但他們就急不及待要做cpu搶救,佢解釋係其中一位助護,見到佢突然無左呼吸同心跳,已經即時通知醫院生搶救,我好懷疑同唔滿意該診所有有以下幾點? 因當時該男醫生已經聽過我隻貓幾次話佢個心臟無什麼雜音,應該無什麼事,2. 雖然隻貓係有病唔舒服,但當時帶入去識行識叫,係精神較累,無死亡的徵兆,但點解攪完照這些東西後突然死亡,我相信剛才這位陳醫生講都有些關係,因為這男醫生解釋份報告時好強調我隻的肝功能指數,照極都找不到,話係爆晒燈的原故,所以當中我懷疑因為強行硬照,引致我的貓貓死亡,3. 點解無左呼吸.心跳唔問下主人還要急救嗎?自行處理,做左2次CPR, 你知我意願嗎?還要收我搶救物料錢,佢話醫生無收我搶救費,我完全唔會感激囉,我隻貓已經很老,我帶牠去看醫生係作最後的救援,即是有得醫就一定醫,無就帶牠回家安樂死,你現在還令牠死後還要辛苦,只有一樣野,就係因為驚要揹禍,立即想搶救隻貓回來,所以無通知我就CPR, 我同這位女仕一樣唔帶佢睇好過
所以我好明白這位主人的心情,一定好難過,我都喊左2日,駛左幾仟元,雖然比起其他主人,已經算駛得少,但結果係令隻寵物步向死亡得更快更辛苦,真係好內疚,係香港做寵物主人好慘,好無助,當你隻寵物有事,就好似俾寵物店做提款機,任何一間都係,係唔係都驗什麼什麼?驗親唔少野,無幾仟元都救唔到,有時好似我們咁,駛左錢仲要無埋隻動物的生命,本來想救佢變左害佢,但政府完全莫視,唔會有監管,完全無保障我們,陳醫生好似你咁有醫得嘅醫生少之又少,敬佩!
Thank you
希望有關當局 正視無良獸醫問題
暴力咁摙死隻貓又使鬼你醫
帶佢過黎,比錢佢,摙死自己隻貓,屌佢老母痴撚線
一個國家嘅文明程度就係睇佢點樣對待動物同小朋友
黑店醫生應該要立法管制 😤
感動!
呢個係一個好獸醫咩, 聽講佢已經好多黑歷史, 好多苦主搵緊佢喎
係呀講緊你呀學人講良心, 你開嘅 元朗康X動物醫院, 做過啲乜嘢壞事呀唔知肚明啦。
獸醫真係唔代表愛動物Q_Q
4:34 錯個個唔係你 bb都唔會怪你的!加油
我都試過..其實我懷疑架
但點啊?死無對證>"
係,只有谷气
可以報導柏雅件事
睇到一半睇唔落去, 愈睇愈嬲😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡
呢位陳醫生,你估係好東西,又唔係屈錢,劏貓又劏人
病人出事都難追究 更何況寵物
香港獸醫管理局跟本做唔到野
太子城大入邊有個女醫生都輕易建議安樂死,拎報告仲要即刻改入邊既內容!獸醫管理局董事會入邊全部都係自己人,又點會有人做嘢?再睇返過往紀錄就會發覺佢哋接受投訴個案少之又少,就算接咗,後續係咩?得幾多單有跟進?
救,變咗殺
提防十大獸醫黑店,劏人又劏狗,醫死動動無命賠。
大圍就有一間。
元朗都有一間,就係呢位陳醫生主診嗰間,我隻貓就係俾佢醫死咗
香港做人做動物,正苦都唔當係一回事... :(
SUPPORT
獸醫嘅人工絕對唔會係『一點點的錢』呀?
撐!
封鎖人哋留言 , 賊喊捉賊, 請大家認清真黑白, 搵錢搵到盡, 無良至極, 大話連篇, 什麼好獸醫呀, 攞個良心出嚟睇下先啦!
衰嘅點只10個8個
加油啊
😢😢😢
有冇啲好獸醫診所推薦?
FB有group
真系塭個好醫生都難
一句說話:賊喊捉賊……
加油💪100毛
解散獸醫管理局 @@@
想知男醫生個名,好衰
葉灝X
www.babydiscuss.com/t/topic/32990
啲股東都要起底
下次係咪應該帶定把刀去睇獸醫?
什麼一位獸醫的告解!!叫佢告解一下自己做過嘅壞事把啦,大把苦主揾佢呀, 冇良心嘅人喺度講良心簡直係笑話!!!
7:54 百萬….
香港政府真係好無能 睇到好嬲
呢位陳醫生其實好冇醫德,我早幾日帶隻貓去佢度睇,隻貓開刀劏肚留院,話要乜乜黃金七十二小時,點知三日之後,貓貓一啲好轉都冇,又同我講話隻貓可能係乜乜病,想試藥,又話要隻貓留院兩,三日,要知道住一日醫院,要伍仟幾蚊埋單,但係又醫唔到隻貓,感覺佢係想吊住隻貓條命,屈錢……,其實由佢幫隻貓開刀,話發現佢個胃同腸臟都唔識郁動,我已經知道隻貓係好難救到,我太太當時就話要求醫生幫貓貓安樂死,點知呢位陳卓姿醫生話,俾 72 小時貓仔,點知 72 小時之後,又話再俾兩,三日時間,隻貓住咗 5 日醫院,用咗 三萬幾蚊,佢仲想叫我隻貓住多兩,三日,我同我太太決定,叫佢幫貓貓打針……
咁刀得😓
💪💪
💛💛🧡
搵果啲啲?🤔🤔
我隻兔食左「荃灣享和珍禽異獸」7日藥,就死左。
明白主人失去心愛的寵物是很痛心的事情。但客觀一點,影片中主人沒有提及BB本身有心臟問題,所以是藥物問題還是狗狗自身問題,是需要第三方專業人士去調查。
【動物專訊】一隻本身有心臟問題的12歲芝娃娃「BB」,上月中有天突然倒地,旺角一間診所獸醫判斷為抽筋,並開出抗抽筋藥,怎料狗狗服藥後呼吸困難,獸醫卻指是正常反應,狗狗終在當晚猝死,體內發現肺積水。狗主Bonnie極傷心,質疑獸醫斷錯症,坦言後悔相信了獸醫說法,枉送BB性命。涉事獸醫診所指,對BB死亡感到沉痛,會協助獸醫管理局調查,現時不會評論事件。
Source from:
www.hkanimalpost.com/2020/10/18/10181/
🥰🥰
今時今日香港……算啦
點解要算⋯生命黎
support tvmost
你地識唔識莊柏堅醫生
爭取動物權益,先係首要任務,奈何呢個垃圾政府,根本唔會為動物發聲
來留言CLS
CLS
唔好彈一年前嘅留言,出嚟遮蓋你嘅惡行啦, 你嘅無良 通曬天㗎啦. 想把我留言沉底, 大把苦主搵你呀!
As if she is much better than the others😂
害人竉物嘅醫生正仆街。真係上天要有眼
學人告解 ,批判其他獸醫, 其實你喺度賊喊捉賊, 最無良嗰個大賊咪係你囉。 人在做天在看 ,生命皆平等, 動物都係人命嚟㗎, 冇良心嘅人喺度講良心, 請大家分清楚黑白, 唔好再畀佢嘅語言藝術 欺騙。
政府真係仆街
比撚番港澳管治 領導人都廢糸黎
对啊,D獸醫好貪錢。
cls cls cls cls
cls
1
佢喺元朗開咗間(康x, 動物醫院) 揸乾揸淨 啲客人, 自己做過咩自己心知肚明啦。 仲喺度廢噏!!!
By reading ur comments below, seems like the vet only wanted to try her best to save ur cat and she seems like a nice person to me. Did u properly communicate with her beforehand?
私了班黑醫,快恨中。人渣唔洗客氣!