FS2020 vs X-Plane 11 vs P3D｜Price, Graphics, Performance...
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 янв 2021
- Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020 vs X-Plane 11 vs Prepar3D｜Price, Graphics, Performance, Aircraft selection...
----------------------------------------------------
In this video I am comparing Fs 2020, xplane11, and P3D
I am comparing the Price, performance, graphics, aircraft selection, scenery, weather / weather settings, and bugs.
Fs 2020 vc X-Plane 11 vs P3D
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join my Discord: / discord
-----------------------------------------------
DONT CLICK THIS: bit.ly/31J8LoQ
-----------------------------------------------
If you like this video you can support me here:
www.tipeeestream.com/flugzeug...
---------------------------------------------------------------
And support here: www.patreon.com/user?u=26969366
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Thank you to:
South Korea Boy 10 euros
gloabalaviation 5 euros
---------------------------
#Fs2020 #P3D #XPlane11 
Игры
We need a updated version of this video because I think all of them but an update
Thanks for that comment, I will try to make one.
@@4viator ok
@@SUSSYNEGGOR ok
@@daarkoo ok
@@mwafr ok
the most important category for a flight sim: realism of aircraft...
the actual most important category for a fs: depends on your fps
@@afreakingcommenterorsmth2708 Person Who see fps on a simulator must pay the double a GPU 🤣
Prepar3D only ?
@@RobertoMandrile i would definitly go cry because yea difficult to have a good pc i mean why u even talk about it or play it if u know u cant play with ur pc stats
@@afreakingcommenterorsmth2708 lp
Prepar3D is a refined version of Flight Simulator X - which came out in 2006.
Lockheed Martin purchased the non-consumer rights for it, while Dovetail Games has (or had?) the consumer license.
Yep, it is and there's no option of giving Prepar3D in YT while uploading in a video so ppl give FSX
Honestly, if FS 2020s graphics and visuals were taken and imported into X-plane 11, that would be a dream come true.
X-Plane sucks though.
@@thecomedypilot5894 Not very bad.Msfs can be only played in pc but xplane can be downloaded on any device.@The comedy pilot,though xplane graphics are not as good as msfs but it is enough.
@@soniooriapadickal FS2020 is on X-Box too.
@@thecomedypilot5894 Ok
Agree, me and my uncle (who's a fighter pilot, 13th Squadron Indonesian Air Force) have played MFS2020 and the P3Dv5, we compared their flight dynamics to x-plane. and the result was, X-Plane is the closest thing we can get to feel the real flight dynamics (not including dcs because its not a commercial flight simulator. but if we can compare them, we give them an equal score, DCS = X-Plane, in terms of flight dynamics). MSF2020 has good flight dynamics but still X-Plane is better
If they all combined , that game would be awesome
its not game
@@alirosi7381 If it is not a game, what is it then?
@@letsplajyoyo9380 simulator
@@pirxn_5280 still a game
@@pirxn_5280 P3D is the only real simulator
Thank you for taking the time to make this video. One area you forgot to review was flight dynamics. In this category X-Plane wins hands-down which for me is the most important category for a realistic simulator.
Thanks for the info!
Can u make a video including FSX? (I use FSX myself, and I’d love to see it being included in ur video!) And congrats on 1.5k subs! (Ik I’m a little late)
it wouldn't win any of these
I can't get the cracked version for FSX because I use Windows 10
@@cupofjoen lmao i use cracked fsx gold acceleration with aerosoft and iceai in windows 10
@@TRR23123 where did you get the cracks?
@@cupofjoen In a spanish video, the title it's like "tutorial detallado de instalar fsx" or something like that and it's 30 minutes long, Aerosoft was on a brazilian vid and ICEAI another spanish video.
Nice vid, but I would have included the topics Addons and Flight Dynamics and Realism, because that are the biggest downsides of MSFS atm. I am a Pilot IRL and I can say, that the Flight Physics are very weird in MSFS. Also the Icing is the biggest Problem for me. Completely unrealistic. For me, the best sim without paying to much is XP11, because of the great amount of freeware Addons. But only for realism, P3D is my Top 1. And btw., XP11 has an option for real weather as well and it work very good for me.
Thanks for the tips!
@dylan bowes ?
So P3D is totally worth it?
@@emotionaloveracorolla5274 Depends on what you want. As a hardcore flight summer, P3D is my favorite sim, because all available aircraft are extremely realistic. Also, most planes I like (for example B787, B777 and B747 (-400)) are only available for P3D in good Quality. The only con is, that it’s way more expensive than X-Plane. If you are only looking for a sim where you can fly nicely from A to B without investing a lot in Addons (Planes, Scenery and other), use xp. I have around 4000 hours in xp11, but I just like P3D more.
@@waschmaschinenfreund ok, but I have a flippin potato so I can't dream of any of them 😆😭
Wow awesome video man! Thanks for the review. This was definitely worth all the time u spend on it 👏
Thank you😊
The one thing you didn't mention about MSFS 2020 is it requires a very fast high speed internet connection with an unlimited data plan because scenery data is retrieved from a remote server, so if your connection speed is under 120 MBPS you will experience slow FPS and stutters, even on a very fast computer with lots of RAM. Also, if you have others around the house who use the internet connection to stream TV programs, you'll experience slow frames and stutters as well, so you'd have to make sure nobody else is using the internet connection when you're on the simulator.
You are right.Because it has high graphics,it needs a lot of data
You dont need 120 mbps lower is ok
I'm not sure about the 120mbps but yes, it requires a high bandwidth, even if your connectivity is quite good and stable! Thinking of whether I should get a gaming router.
So you can't play the sim when you have no wifi?
I fell I'm the driver in this Plane, thanks for showing lk52.
My favorite is P3D because I really enjoy flying the PMDG B747-400 with it's fully functional flight deck EFIS and fully programmable FMS-CDU.
I actually love FSX because yeah, I have an amazing 737 and I think I'll come to love FS2020 much more than X-Plane once the PMDG comes out for FS2020. For sure FS2020 has an amazing CRJ, much better than X-Planes so I think overall, FS2020 is by far, my favorite.
Yes! I love the 737!
I spent over 1000 $ on P3D aircraft, tools and scenery. Very happy. But out of curiosity, I want to try X-Plane as well.
Try it, I moved from FSX and never looked back since. Realism is top notch here, you feel like you're flying an actual aircraft
@@tommegg8486 I've bought X-Plane 11 a few days ago and immediately modded it, bought all the good aircraft. Wow! The flight characteristics are really great. And if you mod the sim, it looks really great.
@@maltimoto that's cool man! I mod my Xplane with some reshade, ortho, and good scenery, it looks absolutely beautiful
FSX and 2020 are far different products apart from the brand "Microsoft".
P3D is closer to FSX, considered that they both have almost the same background.
@vaccaro1966 - P3D is the improved version of FSX. From what I understand, Lockheed bought the code from Microsoft a few years ago and modernized it. It's a 64-bit version of the old platform that initially came out in 2006.
I feel like you missed a huge subject that MSFS 2020 gets completely destroyed by X-plane 11 in. X-plane 11 has proven to have a more realistic feel at the controls of the aircraft. MSFS is still in development, but that is more of something that takes forever to fix. In fact, X-plane 11 is the base for most training flight simulators for major airlines like Delta, United, American, basically anything you can name. Good video, but you went more for the bells and whistles, not the actual simulator itself.
PS: I subbed for effort :)
MSFS it not completely destroyed by X-plane 11, never it was dude haha. In terms of overall realism MSFS have the edge now. Live sync google maps and live weather, you can't beat that. Once pmdg and other developers release their study level aircrafts, msfs might completely takeover X-plane 11.
@@tranquilohomie2248 I've heard things that say MSFS has problems with unrealistic aircraft systems and physics. I agree do disagree though
@@coopermack8406 their not on top unless ur a pilot or need best phsysics. most of people just want a good looking sim with study level planes which mfs2020 provides. and mfs2020 can only get better after all. so mfs2020 might be the future unless x plane 12 does something.
@@fiftyphonkartist For the time being, Xplane is better since it has less bugs and there are addons to Xplane that have had time to develop that make it look just as good if not better than the base mfs2020.
@@coopermack8406 plz stop dont even try to compare 1999 graphics. the only reason x plane is barely surviving is because of of their phsysics and addons. everything else, horrible. i have been a x plane user for 3 years, and i talk from experience, x plane has very nice phsysics and i do miss them. but i had to switch because it didnt give me good vibe when flying, it was just so bland.
6:41 X Plane 11 and P3D also have Live Weather option dude!!
fs is cooler dud
No p3d doesn't have live weather in default
@@alton4357 Yeah I forgot that. To get live weather in P3D we need active sky. My bad
@@Ethere4lx111 its not
you should add "addons" to the rating. cince xp11 has TON of free ones, almost all in msfs are payware. im not sure about the p3d tho
MSFS gives you way better performance as well. You can get way better graphics and fps with the same hardware and they haven't even switched to DirectX12 yet. I don't understand why X-Plane got the point here. Overall a fair video I think. You could have maybe also compared the flight models but that's more complicated so I understand why you didn't.
Thank you for you opinion, I know that you can get better performance, that is one of the best things in the simulator but at least for me and other peolpe i know who own it, it is very unstable at the moment. I am sure that will become better but at the moment at least from my experience X-Plane 11 is performing better.
You deserve a sub bro!
That southwest A320 looks awesome
SWA? they don't fly A320
I know
@@qiitxxsmitj3491 in the thumbnail lol it’s the reason I clicked on the video lol
Graphics : you have to buy a new PC
FPS : you have to buy a new PC
Realism: you have to buy a new PC
Stability: you have to buy a new PC
Scenery variety: you have to buy a new PC
Weather selection: you have to buy a new PC
Planes included: you have to buy a new PC
Final price: you have to buy a new PC
Bugs and crash counts: Didn't you buy a new PC yet?!?
in my opinion eight PCs are not enough!
@@morpe UHAUHAUHAUHA no, they aren't!
FS 2020 is also a work in progress...the developers even tell you that. And will be a very long work in progress. I started back in mid 90s on Microsoft Flight sim. FS 2020 yes, has its bugs. The lack of study level aircraft as well. I'm really only into GA aircraft. But have logged thousands of sim hours over the years. Microsoft/Asobo has done an amazing work so far. A project this big deserves time.
Which would be best for installing under Linux ? 😊
One thing to mention the live weather isnt accurate in mfs 2020, The winds and visibility are always off
What for tts are you using?
Very interesting video.
I agree with you
The only problem with this video is the robotic narrator, but still a good comparison!
Seems like MSFS 2020 has really come a long way in fixing those bugs, can't say haven't encountered some of them, but they are quire rare for me now!
As a subscription service, isn't P3D more expensive in the longrun?
You can also chose live weather in x plane 11
Do you want me to do the Voice over for ya?
In my opinion xplanen is amazing
how come you didn't talk about flight physics modelling while comapring the flight simualtions?
I want Xplane 11 tho cuz I love it. And I subbed
Kids in 2050 be like: What is this trash you gave me dad?
kids in 912658127621607216: dad what the hell did you bought me it looks more than a potato pc
You should compare physics too, I think that x plane has the best physics
Fs2020 they added a new flight model I think it's better than x plane.. x plane has a poor physics in the ground it feels so wierd
@@alton4357 I agree. Aircraft seem more smooth on the ground then in x plane.
@@alton4357 I mean the bouncy landings in X Plane 11 are better than solid landings in FS 2020
@@alton4357 P3d is actually very realistic. People say it’s flying on rails but the fslabs feels exactly like the real thing. Xplane still has the edge in flight dynamics compared to msfs
@@majoraviatior1611 fslabs found a way around it, they are not using the sim flight model system thats why its the only plane that have a good flight model , x plane is good but msfs is getting really close and even better in some areas
Rhetorical question: when will we see A320 Toliss/FlyFactor, B737 ZIBO at MSFS2020? Then it will become the best, now except CRJ and A32NX there are no normally modeled aircrafts (except GA).
I cant really say that, cause im not developing them but it can take untill 2022.
They won't. They only make addons for XP 11.
Never
Nice vídeo. No need coments. Give some more years and we talk again. What i dont anderstand is, wy P3D and XPlane never Invest in gráfics like msfs2020, we cannot forget that xplane and P3D have to Many years and Microsoft allways update, like, fs2000, fs2004, fsx and now msfs. P3D and XPlane are blocked in time. But how they Will Invest...... 😃
You can actually use real world weather in X-Plane 11
i play msfs but i think x plane has more realistic planes, thats why its a licensed pilot training software
For me the most realistic flight simulator is X-plane 11. Everything looks amazing and very realistic.
I have Xplane but I will start with P3D. Because almost all the airliners to Xplane suck compared to PMDG 747/777 for example.
I have P3D and wanted to buy X-Plane, haha. Why do X-Plane aircraft sucks? Might save me money....
@@maltimoto Why? hahah oh boy. 1. some have default fmc that have many bugs. the zibo is free and it's better than planes for 80+ dollars. Physics is tho good but yeaa
@@maltimoto only a320, a340, a319 and 737 are the planes that have good add ons.
@@maltimoto don’t! P3d has more realistic systems and less limitations. That’s why prosim isn’t available on xp12.
Even tho im very satisfied in crash animations which has X plane 11, i still prefer MFS2020 just because of the graphics. But MFS2020 needs a powerful pc and i dont have one of those (I think). I dont really know what should i get. I kinda like X plane 11 but the graphics arent that good. But MFS2020 doesnt have any crash animations and i dont think i have a powerful pc. I might need help with choosing. Please reply cause im not sure what should i get.
For a normal PC I would recommend Xplane it will be the best option for most people at the moment.
@@4viator Like i got a gaming laptop but i dont think it has a powerful disc.
@@FrogCtv Xplane is a very realistic and well made simulator I think you will be very happy with it, but you can buy whatever you want.
@@4viator I dont really know yet but i think Xplane now idk
Which is the best for a student pilot needing to simulate flying as best as possible for familiarity before beginning training.
probably X-Plane 11
@@4viator thank you
P3d or xplane if you have a lot of money P3d if not xp12
Me i think that xplane11 and p3d is better beacause you dont need a super pc for it works
Nobody should have FPS problems x plane 11. I have 1050 ti and get 40-60 FPS in default scenery
You also have to realise that xplane and p3d are multiple years old and mfs 2020 doesnt even have 1 year since its launch...
isnt scenery and graphics the same thing?
Well, mfs 2020 realy looks great, but the planes fly very unrealistic so Is just a very expensive planes game, Is new, but Asobo Is doing nothing, they are just doing work for the scenary, they dont care about planes, they are just waiting for others to fix the planes dinamics so untill that happend we have a $120 buks plane game, Is realy a shame
you obviously have no clue about whats going on...maybe you look into a q&a with microsoft before posting such comments
@@peter-mv5gk link?
@@killernoob1000 just type q&a with microsft (: hahahah
@@killernoob1000 ruclips.net/video/0aWqB5n_lM0/видео.html but for you...thats what i meant...;)
Asobo are only responsible for providing the default aircraft which is never study level. That's the same as in X Plane and P3D. If you want study level aircraft, YOU HAVE TO PAY FOR THEM. You don't get study level aircraft by default, in any sim. Your expectations are completely unrealistic ( I own Xplane and MSFS).
i flew for a long time in xplane11 and you have the option to youse real life weather and this is not a addon!
Uhm.... x-plane has live weather... And you forgot to go deeper on vehicles quality and realism...
@Fabio Franco - Vehicles, are you referring to ground vehicles or aircraft? One thing I can't stand in MSFS 2020 is airport vehicles on taxiways and in some cases get in your way while taxiing.
I will buy p3d or X-plane
make the video with fsx included :)
P3D is basically FSX
@@ethanfletcher91 Well yes, but actually no...
I would choose xp11 than msf2020 since we can play it in laptop having 16gb ram and a graphics, and later with some freeware addons xp11 will look good with decent fps and that too in a laptop.
I play MSFS2020 on a laptop with 16 gigs of ram with a few settings on high.
@@brndn2208 how much fps you get while playing MSF in laptop cause I have the same specs 16gm ram and nvidea mx330 graphics card.
@@delta25k73 he gets 2 fps
@@delta25k73 mx330 is not enough for fs2020
@@luckyme5063 ye ik 🥲
P3D have submarine?
yeah maybe
4:57 discord sound XD
Think flight models should have been a factor
DID you know p3D was actually an offshoot of MSFS? FSX to be precise….
I hope that wasn't a Southwest A320 NEO in the thumbnail....
It was lol
Where is the physics category?
Thats a hella a320 southwest on thumbnail?
nahhh xplane 11 is optimization king i managed to run it on a laptop with stable 30 fps
you need to add realism and the point goes to P3D
Why don't you investigate the flight model? Because the real reason why we're still using Xplane is flight model. FS2020 is extremely arcade and nothing close to realistic flight model.
FSX is better than FS2020 P3D and XPlane are on a same level
I HATE Microsoft Flight SIm from the windows store. Want to know why? There's this stupid bug in the xbox live which says "Your not connected to the internet. ha ha, you can't play since we can't log into your xbox account" Even IF you ARE connected to the internet. Smh. Sometimes theres a bug that goes " Please insert disk #1 to start playing. THANKS MICROSOFT. Also, Microsoft Flight Sim lacks performance. It has nice graphics but is designed WRONG. Instead of using all 10 cores of my pc. (i9-10850k) AND use 100% of my gpu (RTX 3080) the game only uses 50% of the gpu and 20 % of the CPU. THANKS A LOT MICROSOFT.
you compare games with Xplane ?????????
P3d is not a game. It is made for pilots to train on and is not sopossed to be used as entertainment. The raaf and military train on it and is by far the most realistic sim in terms of systems modeling and capabilities. Some motion sims run if it. Prosim is not available on xplane so it’s not a game lol. 1 livense of p3d cost over 2500usd lol. Xplane is realistic though. Msfs is just for entertainment
mount everest be like: 6:02
someone surely checked their discord XD I sure did lmao damn it.
I just bought the Xbox game pass!
cool
now expire it
@@afreakingcommenterorsmth2708 lmao
How about flight physics?
use your own voice next time bro
is a320 available in xplane 11 by default?
No there is no A320 usable by default you need to buy a 3rd party addon for a lot of money. I think more than the actual game costs.
@@4viator too bad.. since im eyeing on xplane since i think its a mid range pc friendly..
5:45-6:07 your PC is broken I don’t get them bugs on my Xbox series X
what about flight model?
I could have done that but I already spend 6 days on the video and I did not want to not uplaod for that long.
@John Doe FS2020’s physics are pretty bad in comparison to the real world, on the other hand, they should’ve talked more about addons. I use all 3 but P3D would take the cake
@@ethanfletcher91 P3d flight model is underrated. I’d say P3d is the most realistic sim available with addons of course then xp12. Msfs is more for entertainment
@@majoraviatior1611 I would have to disagree, the P3D model has a lot to be desired. I like P3D because of the addons but X-Plane is the closest in terms to the real world
@@ethanfletcher91 well it might be but my instructor said the P3d is the most accurate representation of a consumer grade sim and that’s why they use it. P3d flight model is always underrated. The default aircraft are pretty bad though
which p3d license is 60$
I am not an aviation student
P3d is mostly for pilots and non consumers. Xplane 11/12 and msfs are for entertainment purposes. Lockheed Martin said they are selling it not for entertainment.
Are you German or English
German
@@4viator warum machst du dann Video auf Englisch wenn ich fragen darf ?
@@flugzeugmanager Weil es viel mehr Leute gibt die englisch sprechen, also auch mehr die meine Videos schauen können.
@@4viator ah ok
Geil viele gute RUclipsr sind deutsch
Good lord whatever bot you got to read your script has some real uncanny valley inflection and speech patterns. Just get a mic and record yourself talking!
The scenery for fs 2020 is just your game lagging
U forgot physics
You barely touched P3D 😂😂😂
dude i almost subscribed until that damn robot voice gave me a headache right before the end of the video. get rid of that stupid voiceover...
Fs2020 is better
X-Plane 11!
P3d V5 is/and aways has been better than Xplane.
He left out flight sim 2020 even with good gaming computer it still lags
@@mariettadashcam6857 Sounds like someone with a shit PC problem
@@paulgarrett9322 yes
i get 45 fps to 50 fps on xp11
What are your PC specs then
conclusion: xplane 11 is p3d
p3d v5.2
P3d🤔
Aj
NINIEY¹
xplane graphics a$$ 😂