THE MURDER OF MELANIE HALL | Unsolved Sunday | Caitlin Rose
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
- A discussion of the murder of Melanie Hall.
Disclaimer: by creating this video I am simply covering facts I have believed to be the most reliable from conducting my own research online. If there are any other details that I did not cover or if there are any inconsistencies with my video and the real case then I apologise deeply and feel free to leave them in the comments to correct me.
Thanks for watching, I hope you enjoy!
xoxo Caitlin
Special thank you to the wonderful Harry for making my lil intro thingy, follow his insta (he's pretty cute): @harry98_sharp
Follow me on:
My second channel: / @caitlinrosevlogs
My snapchat: floralscene
My themed Instagram: @caitlinroseyt
Personal Instagram: @planetcaitlin
My Twitter: @caaitliiin
Check out the other Caitlin ;) / caitsplace
For any business enquiries please contact ellie@ascensionpromotions.com with Caitlin Rose in the subject line.
What I am wearing:
top - primark
Arabic name necklace - namefully
FAQ:
How old are you? - 19
What editing software do you use for your videos? - Magix movie edit pro 17 plus
What camera do you use? - Nikon D3100
Where are you from? - Essex, UK
What do you study? I'm studying Psychology at university.
Music:
Great Days by Joakim Karud / joakimkarud
Music provided by Audio Library • Great Days - Joakim Ka...
Mystery - Gosoundtrack
I do not own this music. All rights go the original artists.
All images displayed are not my own, all rights go to the original owners.
xoxo
Thank you to everyone who has shown some concern over how I seem in this video, I can promise you all I am absolutely fine! I'm not sure what's made this seem so different, I think I am just showing my feelings about this case a lot more in my facial expressions etc. than usual. I hope it's not too distracting, and hope you all find it somewhat comforting knowing that I am fully invested in the discussion of this case! xxx
Caitlin Rose I was worried while watching this too. Glad you’re okay 💖
It’s distracting that you keep looking at yourself in the mirror and losing track of your sentences
This is actually my first time watching one of your videos & will say, I feel like you seem very empathetic & personable. (In comparison to a few of the other cold case file youtubers I follow). I very much enjoyed your take on this & look forward to catching up on all your videos!! 💗👍🏻
Seem distracted.
Omg dark hair looks soooo good on you, way more flattering/striking than the blonde!
i think both look gorgeous on her... but ok😐
You cover so many cases that I’ve never heard of and that no other RUclipsr does, I love this channel!
There’s not much information on it right now, but a girl in oshawa Ontario went missing in August, her name was Rori Chantel Hache. In September a dismembered torso was found in Lake Ontario in Oshawa, which yesterday was announced that the body was identified as Rori, it’s clearly a murder, even though the Toronto sun tried to imply she killed herself. She isn’t the only person that has gone missing this year, and she’s the 8th murder in the city this year not counting people who were written off as no foul play, even though everyone else disagrees. I’m hoping that one of the people I watch that do mystery videos will make a video eventually about her, because she deserves justice and so does her family and community. She was 18 years old and a lot of Canada was aware she was missing and actively looking out for her
I'm from Ontario, Canada, and its insane that the Sun implied she killer herself!!! like wtf, how is that even possible???? Oshawa is sketchy to begin with and the fact that 8 people have been murdered in the city should wake OPP up to think "wow, we may have a problem here". Justice needs to be served for her and her family, because this is clearly more than a suicide.
How does one kill themselves and dismember their own body?? It's obvious murder. From what you say it sounds like a serial killer at work unless the other murders were solved. I'm not going to definitively say that because I'm only going off what you are saying. It's definitely worth researching, though.
Brooke Hamilton what ? I never heard anything after the torso was found! Didn't earlier this year a man went jogging in oshawa or whitby and hid leg was found in the lake or something ?
Mickayla Parnell wait 8 people were murdered in oshawa ?
I'm in Ontario as well & I honestly don't really remember hearing anything about this?!
They clearly didn't try to broadcast this enough
As I personally know Melanie’s family, I am so thankful that you’re talking about the case. I absolutely love these videos and it’s so nice that you’re bringing light to so many of these cases. X
@@mercedesblack7828 if you have information about the case you should tell the police...
@@muls9571 I already have. Trouble is, my local force has been on a mission to discredit me for years. Who does that benefit.?
The truth will come out in the end...
Yellow vest style, if need be....
@@mercedesblack7828 aren't you supposed to tell the force who are working on the case? Not just your local force?
@@muls9571 I am aware of that too.
Hi Heather, thanks for sharing your info.
Can you do a case that was unsolved for a while that is now solved
Really like the colour of your hair
It's none of my business and maybe I'm wrong but you look like you are not ok ...
Just know you have people that love you :3
Hope everything gets better ^^
Your new hair looks lovely! Is the blonde or brown natural?
That lip colour is so so perfect on you, girlie!
I know this may seem a little insensitive, and believe me i came here to watch the case, but i HAVE to ask first, what lipstick are you wearing? Crossing my fingers you will answer!
Please consider doing the case of kyron horman from Portland, Oregon USA. He went missing in 2010 from school when he was 7 and has never been found. A lot of people think it was the step mom. Its a sad case..
You kind of look like Leighton Meester ( blair from gossip girl ) with brown hair :)
Romy-Christ yessss i agree 100%
I find this such an odd thing but she really does, even though leighton is a natural blonde
It would be so great if a channel like this covered cases in countries like Pakistan, where honour killings and children being murdered happen often with the suspects getting away with it. I am from Pakistan and would love some coverage on cases like this to give some awareness. There have been two very popular cases recently, such as the case of an 8 year old girl being killed by an uncle, her name was Zainab. And another case of an honour killing of a woman called Qandeel baloch, who was killed by her brother. Would be great if you considered this!
Love your channel.
Why isn’t the boyfriend a suspect? She could have gone home and he was waiting on her. It’s something to think about.
Sarah Mccreary that's what I was wondering
the way it sounded, he left and she was still in the bar and people said she was there after he had left.
dahmer xoxo yeah I just wondered maybe he could have been waiting on her down the street, or came back angry... there’s really no telling what happened. I don’t think he should have been ruled out
Sarah Mccreary I thought that too at first but so many people saw him that I feel like they would have said if they'd seen him hanging around
Amy C It’s just one of those situations that no one will ever know for sure what happened.
I definitely think it was someone she met in or just outside the club after getting into the argument with her boyfriend.
BooksByMarbles how wouldn’t ppl have seen though?
Your voice is so calming and I absolutely LOVE your uni videos because even though I started year 7 this year I still find your tips useful 🤗🤗
i LOVE your mystery videos so much omg
Love the new hair!
I love these videos so much - keep it up gal. X
This case looks like it got to you,more so than any of the others?
Thatssopaigey I noticed that too! Maybe it didn’t get to her necessarily, but this one seems different from all her others. She looks out of it/not interested in this one. No disrespect though, just an observation. Still love her though
+Thatssopaigey ahh i can see why you think that! recently i've been getting a lot of people saying i need to stop looking so 'happy' in my mystery videos as they find it disrespectful, so i think i'm just trying to avoid offending people! thank you for your concern though ☺️
Caitlin Rose
Oh i see ,I can understand where your coming from , but I don’t think you looked overly happily in your other videos particularly (like not out of place happy) so I’m glad your not majorly upset !
Can you look into the murder of Damien Nettles? He went missing and was murdered on the Isle of Wight in the 90’s
What products do u use for your brows
I live in bath, the Royal United Hospital is where I go to see the orthodontist! So freaky
I love these videos, they’re so interesting! Your new hair looks lovely too!☺️
This case is so interesting, thank you for doing these videos! also your makeup looks stunning x
I feel like she was maybe stalked by someone at the club, who saw the argument and became interested in her. The killer had the advantage of introducing himself & getting her to feel comfortable around him. Unfortunately led to her murder.
It's never easy task to talk about these things. It's ok to show emotions,your human and have compassion for this young lady who ultimately met her murderer in the club that night, thank you for at least trying to find Justice for her which too often does not happen...✝️
I really appreciate you making these types of videos! I wanted to say a couple constructive criticisms but I rly do enjoy these videos . U seem to say "um" or "sooo yeah" a lot, or ramble on about things that aren't relevant really to the case, have you considered EVER editing your videos so that it flows together much better? Also u never explained why the boyfriend wasn't a suspect. Anyways thanks for doing these types of videos n bringing awareness to the cases !!
Alexandra Indseth not all her videos are like this. She is way off in this video.
Kayla Kanvas she does say so yeah allot though, it doesn’t bother me.
Oh my gosh, my entire family is from Bradford on Avon, I live in the US but I go there frequently. That’s crazy, I had no clue that this happened!
90% of comments are superficial fawning re: her looks. It's absolutely maddening.
great video! this is a new case to me. love your hair btw. 💜
There won’t be any DNA from the killer to resolve this case since her remains were exposed to the elements too long.
She had already graduated from uni the year prior. She planned to go back for her PhD, but she wanted to take the year off. Her mother had gotten Melanie a temporary job as a clerk at the hospital where mom worked. Melanie had been working there for about a year. Melanie had plans to move into her own place in 6 weeks but she disappeared first.
Today, the “boyfriend” would be under much closer scrutiny. 99% of the time it’s the boyfriend/partner who commits these murders. The fight was over a minor incident - it tells us how controlling & jealous he was. I don’t know what alibi he gave, but his interview a few weeks after her disappearance was very suspicious. The confessions are no surprise - there are often confessions when there’s a high profile case. No confessions are viable without corroborating evidence.
(Suzy Lamplugh is
pronounced lamp-loo.) The police thought Lamplugh’s disappearance was linked to John Canaan. That’s a pretty likely scenario since Canaan strongly resembles the photo fit and he was in the area at the time.
I like your content but I feel like you aren't trying to CAPTIVATE your audience enough (just my opinion obviously you're doing really well) with certain facts/pieces of interesting information. Again, I like your content so keep up the good work!
This is so strange, Bradford on Avon is only a 10 minute drive from where I live and have lived for 20 years and I've never heard of this case before...
Love your lipstick! What color/brand is it?! Also love your murder mystery videos just found you!
Please keep doing strange mystery videos that aren’t already made by other youtubers! I can’t stand repeats and I love that you do less known cases on RUclips
absolutely love your hair and makeup!!
What lip colour are you wearing? Looks lovely
your hair looks beautiful!!
Kurlbaum is one of my doctors and I only heard about this a few months ago. It’s so weird as I’ve known him since I was a child!
Yazmine Same he’s my GP
Mine too and an excellent GP
The other couple didn’t see anything?
Hey great video, but could you please look at the camera more, it's hard to maintain concentration without it:(
ahhh and I've been to this club! It's shut down now though
It's horrible to think, but logical that predators will hang outside a bar and watch for drunk women who are obviously alone.
where is your top from?
Could you do a video talking about the Batman rapist in Bath or the other missing girl, Suzie Lamplough (sp?), that people think Melanie's case could be linked to?
Really love your videos 🤗😝 x
Loving the hair !
This hair colour suits you so much!
love you so much💓💓💓
If there is a prettier girl on RUclips, I wish someone would show her to me. Caitlin Rose 🌹 is a true beauty. If you were my bride I'd beg you to read me a story every night at bedtime. Your voice is so sweet and calming.
You seem really off in this video, makes it so distracting to watch 😔
This is so sad. That poor girl.
Yay! Love your hair!
Your hair looks gorgeous this colour! I just found your channel! I do mystery videos too!
XXOO
I love your hair💕
Why would the police have not conducted a postmortem/dna identification before confirming the body was Melanie??? They weren’t just gonna look at a years old skeleton and know it was her.
And Wiltshire is a county.. not a town
When Melanie disappeared, the police would have obtained a copy of her dental records for comparison if & when remains turned up. The primary method for identification of remains is still dental records. They are extremely accurate and they don’t delay identification. DNA does. People watch true crime & assume a DNA sample is submitted & the results are available instantly. DNA can still take days to weeks. A comparison with dental records literally is instantaneous. If teeth are present for comparison, that’s definitive confirmation of whose remains you have. Once dental records are confirmed that’s sufficient to notify the family their loved one is no longer missing.
Don’t forget, a skeleton tells us a lot about its owner. A forensic anthropologist can determine age/height/gender/race, etc just by looking at the skeleton and the skull.
How many missing women Melanie’s age/height/race/gender do you think were missing in that geographic area? Once you have a ballpark idea of those characteristics, you narrow the field considerably. (If there are no dental records for comparison.)
I was torn between paying attention to the case and admiring how visually stunning your hair looks. It's absolutely perfect.
I don’t know if you have ever been told, but you look a lot like Blair Waldorf from gossip girl!! 😍😍
You look so much better with brown hair!
You seem so different in this video,so unfocused and upset 😅xxx
you look gorgeous in this girl!! xxx
Halliwell or Bellfield. Bellfield MO is all over this. Whack on the head,near a motorway,ties up,blonde,no sex assault,
Yay! Love the hair
If she’d met someone in the club loads of ppl would have seen.
Lookin so gorgeous today girly😍😍
You look sooo pretty
Insanely early, love your vids and hair!
Everytime I watch your videos I get butterflies in my stomach because of the excitement❤❤💓💓💓💖💖(am I the only one)
Btw I LOVE LOVE LOVE your new hair💓💕❤❤
Hi 💞
Local to this and locally it's highly known and talked about...... there is someone who most believe it is round here!
Hi there, thanks for sharing this info. Sorry for the random comment but I'm a TV producer making a doc about the Melanie Hall case. Would you be open to speaking with me about the impact of the case on the wider community in Bath? my email is on my About section, or I can contact you directly.
you look absolutly gorgeous😍💕
Great job
Ok I’m not normally critical of ppls videos- but please check pronunciations before you record! It’s simply good manners especially for the family of the bereaved!
You look like your preoccupied. .?
I've been binge watching your videos and enjoy them but if I could give a small piece of feedback it's please slow down, it's so hard to keep up with you when you talk so fast. Also extremely distracting when you keep playing with your hair! X
yo9u are so beautiful, and your videos are so informative but some terror or suspense background music would be fine, then there is some kind of background melody besides the environmental sounds of the cars or wind, that undermines a bit your video, i mean the way you put forward your into, about the cases, because you sound as if your were talking about a romantic story with a happy ending. dont take it badly but that is my humble opinion.
you do seem off.. lots of pauses and stops in the middle of sentences.. just an observation.. hope all is well.. love your videos
I think it was the batman rapist look it up
Love these videos
U are so prettyyyy 😍😍😍😍😍
What does your necklace say?
Jacinta Vine it’s her name in Arabic
Romy-Christ thank you
🧡
Jack the ripper would be a cool idea
Becca Jean yeessss
hey girl 😍i adoooore cases
Don't give up your day job . Absolutely the worst presentation I've ever seen . Unwatchable .
seems you don't enjoy doing this and it's not just this video either. I would do videos on what you're passionate about, then your viewers will enjoy it too
You look absolutely beautiful
I loved ur blonde hair suited u better btw love ur videos ♥
You sound like you have no idea what you're talking about.
I'm sorry to say this but I've tried to watch your videos many times but I can't subscribe because you cut your videos so much it kind of breaks the story in a strange way and it's difficult to follow. Maybe try rehearsing before-hand? Otherwise really good job.
Don't watch her then...