Dublin Poverty - Mount Pleasant Buildings (Part 1 of 2)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- A Documentary on the mount pleasant building flats in Dublin during the late 1960s. These buildings were one of the most run down, tightly cramped, poverty stricken areas in Dublin at this time. Many people who lived here could not afford to pay their rent in their previous homes so their only alternative was to move into these accommodations, for the others these flats were merely all that they could ever afford to live in.
the 2nd last lady is MY MOTHER IAM PROUD TO SAY IT A LADY TO BE PROUD OF
dickiedocker jetski same for mine
It's pretty amazing with your mum survived with all of you kids nobody could live in those conditions now days and it's hard to believe that when I was young girl people were living like that, but you were raised very well and your mum was a great woman
dickiedocker jetski which Family?
I hate to say it but Dublin’s a kip now
My mum grew up in the buildings and as a child I remember running round the washing lines. My granny was one of the last to leave. No money, but plenty of love.
Completely off topic, but that lady @ 3:00 is seriously good looking
sorry Ken Doherty lived NEAR here
i remember playing there as a kid a real hole but the people were ok we use to have battles with the local kids,
all great fun. we tend to forget how poor Ireland was but it was a lot better than today a lot less serious crime
we had respect for the old. Dublin is a real crime city today at least it was safe to walk around at that time
One problem was the church being dead set against birth control.
This.
Great job catholic church, birth control a sin
No having all those kids squashed into one room is a sin as far as im concerned...
i must seem out of place to say this, but my family used to live in the buildings (no 149) in the 60's and 70's, and my gran must have been lucky as she had 2 bedrooms and a toilet. maybe im looking thru rose coloured glasses, but i have nothing but happy memories whilst there!! we lived below "mrs dunn" who had 2 sons, one was a musician and the other went onto write scripts for rte!!
that Dunne chap wrote a few books as well, funny man.
Your experience is your own, never let anyone take that away from you. Great to hear a positive story
This is why I stopped having children after one. It was too hard keeping just one fed and clothed.
Yes, exactly...I suppose they believe, children are God's gift, so they don't believe in birth control....The Devout Irish Catholic thinking back then.
My mum.is irish and her mother had 8 children I don't know how they fed all these children with little money having 1 child is enough. I haven't any children and I am happy that way no way I was going to follow in my Gran footsteps having lots of children. You have to think first before having kids can I afford to feed and cloth the child.Too many women having children to get benefits.
I agree 100%, I am an only child and we were poor (non-Irish) but at least what resources we did have weren't as thinly spread. Better to have just 1 child if you are not in a good situation.
@@dianecarman1979 contraception was actually illegal in Ireland then
Abortion and contraception was illegal abortian was legalised recently bc catholic
Powerful stuff. I'm a Dub too and seen such tough times in the '60s.
God Bless the poor people
God help the poor people, no blessing is going to feed them.
@@wildwildItaly stop having children ,when they cannot afford the ones they have already brainless stupid irresponsible behaviour bet they drink and smoke as well....rubbish.
The Catholic Church wouldn't allow them access to birth control
Which god ? Thousands have been worshipped. 0 have replied .
'the only way out is to keep having children' says the guy. lol
During the 1950s and '60s huge amounts of money were collected weekly for the African missions in all parts of Irelandwhile poverty was widespread throughout the Irish state.
What about our Irish sisters and brothers?
Typical church
Now there turning Ireland into Africa.
do you believe now the money went to africa,
@Joe Frazer Joe Frazer, not it isn't a stupid thing to say, it's a valid point to make. people should be made aware that the begging bowl for africa was doing the rounds even among impoverished white populations. and we're yet to receive a thank you. perhaps africans today can contribute to the ethnic irish lying on the streets in their ancestral homeland, because non-natives (including africans) are taking up the social housing there
I remember bare-footed children begging on O'Connell Bridge back in the sixties.
***** And your point?
i've lived in nottingham for over 60 years , can't remember seeing any beggers in the city back in the 70s now there's beggers in every other doorway
The thing is Dublin was the most prosperous part of Ireland during this time, if you'd had a camera crew going to Donegal, Kerry, Mayo during during this time period you would have seen far worst poverty. A lot of people in Ireland in the 60s didnt even have electricity yet
I blame england.
Ireland was at roughly the same standard of living as Portugal up through the Sixties!
I remember been in roscommon in the 1980s and too get water you had to walk to the stream. But it was fantastic. Mushrooms by the sack. Real old school
Rural people were able to grow vegetables and had their own dairy products..
And they done seasonal farm work in England
There was no sense of entitlement down the country
My Father was from Dublin. My Mom from Tipperary. They didn't have such harsh times but were nevertheless proud working class. I so hope that these wonderful people gained a decent environment in which to live and rear their family. ❤❤❤
My father's from Dublin are my mother from Tipperary and I was born in Mount Pleasant buildings good honest hard-working people I agree with you 100%
That was such a tough life for those women. No one should have had to live in those conditions.
On one of these parts it showed a mother who had 20 children sitting outside watching them play. It was the only pleasure she got by smoking. I know I would too if I had all those children to take care of. Nowadays we are pretty fortunate to have the things we need but it comes with a price. Disobedient kids, no manners, etc. They want everything handed to them yet doing nothing to earn what they received. I am sure these children appreciated everything they had.
I lived in this place from 1966 to 1978, it was mad, crime was huge in the 1970's
the over riding lesson to be learnt from this video is that lack of condoms only condemned these people to perpetual poverty...
Heartbreaking 💔 my mom and dad were from Dublin, she followed him to Canada to get married in 63 and had 6 kids! Can’t imagine that was only 50 years
@Donnell Okafor SMH 🤦♀️ TO ME!!!!!!! It’s heartbreaking because we never grew up in that situation!!! And others had to live like this!!
Even though they may not have had much material things, I bet there was plenty of love in their homes. I hope all worked out good for them all. Thanks, John, Indiana.
i lived in mount pleasent it was the best the laugh everyone used to have with each other everyone looked out for each other
It certainly don't look like much of a laugh from were I'm standing .
My mother is irish and from waterford they had a bungalow in the country I don't know how these people fed and clothed their children with little money the Catholic Church has a lot to answer for banning the pill.
Theres a book called Dublin tenement life an oral history, that is mind blowing..
This is so very sad. I wonder what happened this family, what became of the children. And I have to say I find the music overlaid on this film clip to be very patronising and annoying. And I simply refuse to judge families for the number of children they have. If they had a smaller family, their circumstance would have still brought them to the predicament they are in. To criticize is to distract from the system which has failed them. And nothing has changed!
Z
@@levieenrose7646 😅
The real point is, don't have kids until one is reasonably, financially and emotionally ready. It's not fair to the kids and government/church resources may already be overtaxed. Why is it ( it seems) too many people have kids (because it's "their right", or "their faith dictates", or "they love children" or "they have to continue the family name", or, or, or) and think it's the government's responsibility to give them housing and the churches should help to feed and clothe them? The music is patronizing, it's sardonic which is why they used it. Again, it was to make a point.
Emer Fox Great comment!
The second last lady is my Nana and with her is my mam and 2 uncle's. They moved away and had a fairly good life. Unfortunately my Nana passed away 6 years ago but she was the strongest, kindest and most caring woman you could ever meet. She had 7 children and they worked hard to ensure they never went without.
Terrible how people were living ,there should have been more support
This is so fascinating and sad at the same time.. Some of you below, say that these people had so many children as there was no birth control allowed or available. I dont want to be judgemental but the question about so many children in these circumstances still pops into my mind. I am from eastern europe, where in this era we were terribly poor, also very catholic coutry and most families had no more than 3-4 children (and these were considered big families). Birth control was unheard off, at least among the lower classes, yet ppl managed to control their births through natural ways. I still remember my grandma talking about the times when she would push my grandad off her if he wanted 'some loving'. She was to exhausted from the hardships and the 3 kids she already had. So from what i remember listening to the older generation, the hardships, tiredness, lack of intimacy was the contraception for the era. I would like to know why was this so different in Ireland. I am trying to imagine myself, being stressed, exhausted, probably hungry, surrounded by my kids, or parents or siblings, there is no way i would be in a mood for sex. what my gradma was saying made perfect sense.. Its so strange that ppl thought and behaved so differently despite such similar circumstances..
In essence; "breed them out" from the pulpit. The minority ruled due to our history and we had enough...they had less of a say as we grew the Catholic population.
From.speaki g with older Eastern Europeans, they assumed me that there was a HUGE market for black market condoms and back street abortions were common place but never spoken about
You are a real grumpy. I have respect for these people. Work was a big issue for these people. I was born in Dublin and I was lucky.
We saw poverty that''s what makes the Irish have beautiful hearts!
Actually, I'm not a real grumpy. I'm frustrated by those claiming ignorance and pverty as self-imposed, without any reference to the religious separatism and tensions still manifest in Ireland. As I said above, my closest friends are Irish and I have worked with many Irish people, collectively fantastic. Poverty en masse has a cause, calling out the victims enables the cause whilst trapping everyone else. My argument is definitely not with the Irish themselves (see comment about how the mothers deserve medals) its with the political and religious leaders who use people as pawns. Every Irish person I know was/is affected by these divisions; my family were directly affected. Its sad, because the Irish ARE wonderful people. If I'm grumpy for calling out organisations that prevent those people for improving their lot, then so be it. The combination of no birth control and prejudice preventing Catholic employment put an impossible strain on people, creating obstacles which needn't be there.
@@randomhumanoidblob4506 you are right, and let me say, I'm sick and tired of the church telling people what to do, how to believe, etc.
@@wildwildItaly You have to understand that when yoiu have nothing, religion is your only "escape". It is like buying a lottery ticket, you know you are not going to win and yet you keep buying it, dont you.
@@wildwildItaly Especially while they're filling their own pockets with silver and gold !
@@randomhumanoidblob4506 well said
Question?..why on earth do they keep having children?
Gollyfats no birth control allowed ...
Gollyfats birth control was illegal until 1985 also the pull out method does not work, the pre cum is the most fertile.
Even when birth control became available the women needed their husbands permission to use any.
church in those days was really, really strict about birth control, mortal sin.
They had children because there was no contraception available,,and you can thank the Catholic Church for that,,they were too busy hiding away and protecting their paedophiles!!
All that white privilege.
Same today, you need to have lots of kids to get a council house..
If they only had one room then what else could they do but procreate. It was a sin for a woman to refuse and she had to do whatever he wanted. 😅
The utter ignorance of the comments is staggering.
How is using birth control going to clean the toilets? Or build liveable flats?
Was the Catholic Church to create jobs in a country with a limited infrastructure?
So read and think before you judge the abused too harshly. If you don't, you simply look foolish.
Finally, would you make these same comments about a single inner-city American mother with 11 children by 11 different men?
I didn't think so.
Absolutely, The past 20 years Irish history has been rewritten with a lot of historical inaccuracies by people who weren't even around at the time.
It's going to help protect more children from living a hellish existence but other than that, it's the responsible thing to do when you know you can't properly provide for them. Be responsible until one can provide for kids. The days are gone of "....go forth and prosper.." to fill the world with more people of one religion than another. This goes for all religions condoning reproduction to populate the world and make sure there's more of "us" believers than "them" believers.
@@jenniferwilcox9759 Except that contraception was illegal
Dear God how on earth did they survive with out going mad
I wonder what became of them in later life
god remember them we live there for a fews years gra live under us our flat went on fire we had to rooms a cross from each other
What's with people keep having kids they cannot afford to raise
Educate yourself.
Contraception was illegal
There where worse off families than this, many wouldn't have had that TV it's have been in the pawn shop, many families lived on much less than this, Liverpool 1950's was dreadful for so many families
clare massey .so was London in the 50's
Why have any kids if one knows they will live like THAT?
Becuase they couldn't access contraception-- OBVIOUSLY
@@ciarapoleon7245 I guess you are correct.
We lived there.I was only a baby.God help the people then.Why should anyone be exposed to that.God Bless all those people who put up with all the nonsense.
having 10 children must have been hard my mums mum had 9 children my mum is irish and i was born in the uk i havent got any children
Some of the best people came from the buildings . I was born there in 1968 one of four and Mam Dad , good hoenst people . My Ma was from Tipp and my Da was from the cottages at the back of the buildings . Dead and gone now. I loved those days
It's still the same nowadays nothing changed just keep the people with very little money... Keep them DOWN 💔
Why why why do poor people keep having kids
Frances Van Siclen cause they latch on in needing love and don't think.
I don't think there is a simple answer to that. There are many factors involved including access to women's health/birth control, culture and religion. I think it is a very deep subject.
Much like Africa today were the average family size is 12 kids,
No access to family planning, contraception and, inadequate education among other things that you are lucky enough not to understand 🙄
Ignorance
Why do you compare the people with "lice"? Then, these people are 10 times better than you, if so.
As hard as it is to believe, there are people who have enough faith that they follow the leader without question. While that is sad, it is also the way of many Catholics. The problem lies with the church and it's teachings. If you could see the gold leaf and extravagant way churches are decorated in Ireland, it would amaze you. All I could think when I entered one was, "What about the people?" It's a sad commentary that the trappings were more important than the people. However, I love Ireland.
The Answer regarding Garrett Fitzgerald.....home....yes....he lives (lived) half way up Palmerston Road...a.which, is about 2 minutes walk from Mountpleasant .......
and in 2018 theres still nearly 50 thousand familys classed as homeless #wishyouwereanortherner
@Kevin Mason oh wait to 2020/2021 there will be but not for the poor, the poor don't seem to matter, so sad
Fast forward to said time..... 😲 I'm pyshcic
My ma and da live 119 my brothers and sisters say it was poor place
I was exactly the same in URSS even worse. Just look at one of RUclips videos. Was the same everywhere. In germany in 50 wasn't great. After the war country was in bits. Italy the same and greece. But URSS WAS EVEN Worse. BUT I WAS BORN THERE in 85 and I appreciate in this days everything I have.
6 people living in 1 room 10'0" x 12'.0".....the average size of a stable is 12'.0"sq. this shocked me!
Boyne street had no showers or a bath til 1993
Why do they jave so many kids they cannot afford?😊
😢
History is repeating itself
In a few years the world will be worse than that.
Rod McKuen poetry was and is terribly depressing
Another problem caused by the Catholic church and too much fucking.
There was 9 of us children in a 3 ROOM house. It was packed.
Look. The government is committed to providing good social housing and are helping private developers to build houses. Costs of building are escalating and cost-effective materials such as mica are a good alternative to keeping costs down and profit margin as wide as possible. Good value homes are available to people at affordable and realistic prices starting only from €875, 000 rising to € 2.89 million , now come on you can't argue with value like that can you ? Estate Agents will advise you of your options once you give them a full list of your mortgage approval documents and full sources of all income. That is only right in order fair distribution of accommodation is regulated. They government will provide at least 4 or 5 new house builds over the next 50 years so the children in this video can look forward to homes when they are in their 90s by which stage they will need to hand them over to the state for their nursing home care plans. You see a united Ireland will ensure homes for all if only the British were out of Ireland. Thank goodness for EU regulations we would be worse off without them.
The Church banned contraception.
The man at 2 minutes in must have had a job or was he living on welfare???
God Bless them....I was a kid in the fifties it wasnt easy.....but as a kid you adapt to anything...
I hope the mother in this had things better in time...
Thanks for uploading.
My parents left Dublin in 1958 with eight children. I was the baby. At first it was hard but the Catholic church were very good to us and our cousin's who also came out. I was shocked to see the cramped living conditions of Dublin in 1981. I was an adult and had plenty of money. I felt as if I was in a third world country. I thought the clergy were different to the Australian clergy, at least in the diocese I lived in.
It was a third world country, officially up until the 80s
🎶 A mother’s love is a blessing………………………………………
So awful,poor parents and innocent children.😁😁😁😁
It is not normal in capitalist countries to get a roof if you cannot afford a normal rent. They did. And if they knew they had only 1 room available, with no beds, why did they decide to have 6-7 children? Their choice.
CRAP. They had children because Contraception was illegal
This is how Lorna Byrne must has feel like in 60s
the writer Lee Dunne lived here (Goodbye to the Hill) , also some actress (forget her name), Ken Doherty lived here also
Lee lived in the flat above my gran, with his Mammy and brother
Constance Smith, film actress.
Ken doherty NEVER lived in the buildings , and thats a 100% fact
Great historical video Rasher .I knew one of the women being interviewed
Up to their plaza we did go
I rather suspect that most of these people were so very poor because they were supporting over-many of children on their meager income. I had a meager income for most of my life, but I was never so poor because I refrained from pro-creating children that I could not adequately support. I supported myself and my cat to a healthy level on cheap-wage agricultural and proletarian jobs. I eventually married a beautiful crone whose children were grown and flown.
Sounds Shit
Maybe you could access contraception. These people could not legally do so
With respect, sadly I truly don’t understand why they kept having so many kids / such large families, when they couldn’t afford a decent roof over their heads , seriously 🤦♀️
The men should have spent more time on other activities or work rather than keep producing children they can’t afford 😢
common sense plz guys 🙄
And yes , I am inclined to think it was ( in those days ) more of the responsibility / protection of the male 😬
ANY knowledge of the reality of the time and time know why.
The toxic grip of the RC church made contraception illegal
This brings ghetto to a whole new level.
Part 2 up now
@bargeanimal Thanks for that. Garrett Fitz lived or lives on Palmerston Road. There must be more famous people from there. Does Eamonn Dunphy have a house on Mount Pleasant Square? And did Benjy Riordan (Tom Hickey) live on Mount Pleasant Ave. Or am I clutching at straws?
Memories of Summer 1967 return ,another world
Nice good talk English
her husband isn't bad as well.
Shocking poverty...very sad.
My family lived in No. 175 Mount Pleasant Buildings in the 60’s. Traynor was their name.
James Clark, are you serious? My family was called Traynor and lived in 175 Mount Pleasant Buildings. I went to see them there and had to sleep on the floor. I remember them cooking pigs trotters.
Bloody hard times then it was hell for them
Watch the true life movie:
Angela's Ashes.
Yeah looks like things didn’t change much from 19030’s to the 60’s
lousy movie and it was all lies the author hated his dad because his dad was a kind man
What a terrible way to live!
This is heartbreaking.
This was the 60s the 60s FFS ....they treated us like shit
The solution is ???? MORE KIDS .........
@twist_nyger_headsoff your a absolute idiot.
@twist_nyger_headsoff no because your ignorant...
Your still ignorant if you believe more starving kids is the answer to poverty
Astounding ignorance. Contraception was illegal
There seems to be quite a few older people with very out of date and insensitive remarks in the comment section
The day we emerged from being hunter gatherers was the slow decline into evolution of the human race.
This is RTE, fuck me I wish they'd tell the truth nowadays.
Jaysis that first line about the younger kids not having a bathroom for a bit of privacy during menstruation. holy shit.
What is the title of this video? It can't just be 307 comments.
She said she wouldn't put a dog in them but keeps having kids and putting them in them!!!
Educate yourself.
Contraception was illegal
@@ciarapoleon7245 Educate yourself miss rude.There is such a thing as not having sex when you are fertile!!!
God bless these people, but why do you have kids if you live in poverty? C'mon now.
soldier person hahaha
No birth control.
Donna Bridges exactly!
They had no birth control they had no idea how to avoid having children.
It was a sin to use birth control back then. They were forced to have numerous children and one every year almost by the Catholic church.
Please for heavens sakes why do they breed like rabbits and know they cannot the children they have already ?so annoying.
What ignorance. Because contraception was illegal
Who's here because of blindboy? 👋
John Lennon?
kstef1975 Yea That’s what I was thinking lol!! He looked very similar.
actress name lived thire irine Dunne
So.....is heaven full of victims?
anyone know the title of this documentary or the presenters name?
My grandparents lived at 175 Mountpleasant Buildings.
Hi Davina did the building face the main playground or was it facing Mount Pleasant Avenue Upper...Thanks in advance
Stop haven children
Astounding ignorance. You realise that contraception was illegal
Why would anyone continue breeding when they can't feed themselves, never mind what they already have. This was not a bad time in Ireland. I always thought, you would have a good job before you would even consider anything like this.
well the people that lived in those buildings werent able to pay the corpo for the houses/flats they previously lived in so they hardly had money for drink