whoever came up with the idea of "scrawny boy runs from chainsaw-wielding, psychopathic killer in corn field with instructions from radio host" needs an immediate promotion
Man. Carrie was so heroic trying to help everyone who just pranked her. And in the end she could've been killed and chose to tell everyone to go to save themselves
It's also nice how after the epilogue, it must've been Dawn there. And it was most likely that she saw herself in her skin there, and decided to spare her. I doubt Henry would spare Carrie.
@@МихаилБганко yea it seems that Henry was the more aggressive one. If you go and watch a video of them all dying and where we know which killer is which henry is very aggressive
@@davo_daniel9199 I have a small guess that Dawn killed Sheriff Matthews because of the fake report, and Henry came back for seconds (Leslie and Deputy Martinez) because he's not as picky as Dawn. Also, he might just be more violent in general. His confirmed targets (Maurice & Murphy) are a bit more physical. Toppling over furniture just to block Maurice's escape, and setting up an entire waste plant in flames just to kill Murphy.
@@scopicaplaysHenry and Marie might teamed up in order to take down Matthews. One to be a distraction due to the fact he has a gun so the other one will take him down by a sneak attack. Marie's other confirmed targets are Eugene, Teddy and Roller Rickey. She was also at where Carrie and her friends are and presumably killed Clive in the tutorial. Henry might attacked John and Virginia but I guess that falls on Marie as well.
@Captain Huntank true. Now I can't watch any walk through where we hear these people.get murdered without being triggered, this is the only walkthriugh for me
Because it doesn't officially release until June 1st... only people with early access can play it right now...agree about the immersion though so many people talk through all the important dialogue in these types of games and miss 90% of the clues lol 😂 I loved this too.
This is the best game I've seen, and would ever get the chance to play. It's story is magnificent, never seen anything better. There are also funny details in this game. I create killers in my story but they are all male, so far from what I know Dawn is the killer so for me, this broke that trend. Even more surprisingly, I share a name with one of the victims, Jason.
John Hedges is such a cool guy. He wakes up to a call at 2 in the morning, gets called in to do something he hasn't done for 10 years, and does it unquestionably.
Spoilers about every rescue: Leslie tasered the whistling man to save Martinez inside their police car. 20:50 Sandra did some car wires moment and turned on the car without keys. 36:36 Maurice thought he trapped the whistling man but it was unexpectedly in vain (useless.) 58:50 is the trap 1:06:55 is whistling man escape Virginia was saved by Plunker’s party, the whistling man ran away and this increased sanity, with a party at Virginia’s House. 1:29:23 Eugene escaped the maze, riding his bike home to escape the whistling man. 1:39:45 Murphy escaped such cruel dumpster, he was locked in it but fortunately Katherine saved his life. 1:49:10 Carrie was not a victim, the whistling man spared her for no reason and the other teens escaped in a vehicle, all the teens. 2:11:13 Chuck escaped his station, with other people inside it, thanks to Forrest mentioning his danger which the evidence was found by Clive’s hideout. 2:34:43 Ricky was alarmed by a break in, looks like Dawn was tricked because she was the whistling man who almost got shot by Ricky’s Rifle. 3:13:02 Jason was aided by Casey, healing him with remaining cloth and sources while John came to give medkits. 3:39:50 Last but not least, Teddy went unconscious and Peggy came in, Marie was gonna kill her but Forrest mentioned a birthday card, Marie was surprised but suddenly got ambushed. 4:13:42 Peggy is a witness 4:16:50 Saving Peggy Ending: *Henry was arrested and Marie fell off the Gallows Creek point, unsure if she died.*
Carrie herself wasn’t a target, given the current killing spree is motivated as vengeance for a prior prank that got someone killed. Her friends were likely targeted due to engaging in that same kind of prank responsible that kicked off the game’s murder spree. (Eugene was targeted for being the child of two deceased people affiliated with the prank. In general the planner was utterly vindictive and cruel, ignoring the pain caused to others and taking out their murderous desires on people whom didn’t even take part in the incident, as well being utterly cruel in their murders.)
Fun fact that not a lot of people know: There are even more hints to save Roller Ricky than Dawn sounding suspicious. First of all, and most obviously, there's no whistling in Dawn's phone call. The Whistling Man sure loves his whistling. Second, and more obscurely, in Dawn's phone call, there is a train mid-call. Then there's a dog howl and then disco music playing. Maxy greets every train with a howl, and everyone knows Roller Ricky is the only one who plays disco. This means she was trying to get into the rink, not the apartment. You may be thinking "Well what if the apartment is right next to the rink?". Look at the map in the radio office. Wood Side Apartment is nowhere near a train line. If she actually was trying to "get into her apartment", the train that blared would've been silent, if not, much quieter than it was.
Another even more OBVIOUS hint that Dawns story didn't check out is that, on the order form for the Starling 4000, it wasn't even INSTALLED at Wood Side yet. Forrest mentions this once you pick up the form.
@@memehunter2476 If only she had gotten her son Henry to whistle in the background (he has an identical whistle), then her story would've been at least somewhat believable. Thank goodness she didn't and Roller Ricky was the easiest to save. He's too good to die.
i had a thought dawn was infact the killer she was too sus but my suspicions were dispelled about certain things i thought she just knew more than things so the killer was after her, at this point i lost a few context with the entire story so my only thought was to keep her alive until i just face palmed cause at this point i ralized there could be 2 its a weird way to know there where 2 whistling men after failing to save cool roller ricky
Yeah he was just forgotten about after Forrest finally wished the Whistling Man would get rid of him, would have been nice if Marie mentioned that as a possible reason why she thought Forrest would help her.
@@Bluestone775 Given that he nor his family was not directly involved in the incident, Henry would be the more likely suspect, Marie might have her reservations since Ponty wouldn't be aware of the whole situation
I love the little moments of self expession hidden in here, playing the Teddy Gallows Jr. ad right after he was a self-centred jerk, a couple sassy replies to the non-emergency callers, very funny.
I was looking for someone to comment this 🤣 I started cracking up when after all that with Teddy, the ad picked was HIS. Just… *chefs kiss* beautiful irony lmfaooo
As heartless as it is to say, jimmy (i think) had it coming. He made fun of a day relating to a serial killer like peoples deaths are a joke and was scaring people on a night when a killer was on the loose like he was invincible.
I dont think someone being an asshole as a teenager means they deserve to die. Very little people deserve to die and I wouldn't say someone like that is one of them
@@homoerectos1110 considering the killer at the time was Marie ( the person who spared Carrie), she got so offended at Jimmy's prank since that's how George got killed. "It's just a prank bro" gone wrong.
She killed Jimmy cuz she got reminded of Teddy doing a "prank" that got her boyfriend killed Jimmy is at fault for being stupid and got himself killed for the "prank"
Spoiler alert: I think one of the reasons why the killer spared Carrie regardless of ending is because she remembered George being pranked in the same way years ago? Anyway Carrie is best girl.
I think you should probably not just put the spoiler alert and the spoilers in the same line.... But yeah, Carrie was probably spared because she was a victim of the type of prank that caused the killings at the same time Peggy better girl
Oh for sure, they actually go out of their way to save her since if she gets trapped under the car if you assign the wrong driver and it crashes, the killer will free her leg and then walk away. They were serious about sparing her.
Gotta say that was a hell of a game. I remember seeing this the first time and man what a change it went though. Props to the makers. And nice job saving everyone, I don't think I could do that
I found out about this game because of a friend and god do I love it. I love the storyline and all the unique characters. This is a textbook example of how not everything needs to be shown in order to be horror.
Ponty was hilarious. And it didn't take me too long to figure out Teddy was involved and was covering it up. And that epilouge, so history repeats itself. I have a feeling that we will see him again. The one thing I don't get is why Murphy was attacked. Wait, the garbage plant was owned by Teddy, ohhh he was just in the wrong place at the wrong time
He told Henry to come and fight him and told him where he will be at so he can kick his butt with some moves from Master Robbie (or at least try to). Dude had me crying😂
@@BallinCollin1 This is mentioned in the game when Peggy burst in and Marie was about to kill her. Eugene's parents were at the party and she was gonna kill them. Since his parents died in the bus accident, she went with the next best thing which was him.
Thanks so much for the video!! I love a good suspenseful mystery and watched it all in one sitting this evening! It was wonderful experiencing it with no one talking over it and no mistakes, meaning the plot kept moving instead of someone going back to correct their errors. The story kept me on edge wondering what was coming next! I love the inspiration for when I one day write my own story! And it’s really nice getting something like this without it depending on showing gore or gross things, but keeping things intense and with a creepy atmosphere, even having you go outside at one point! The twists too! This was amazing to watch and I would love to see more games like it! Now I’ll probably watch some typical let’s plays and see how things go. Thanks again!
I was wondering who we were playing as in the prologue. That certainly makes sense due to Clive being implied to have died. Although now I’m wondering who we’re playing as in the epilogue?
@@Lizuma it makes sense, since the last thing we see is the Whistling Man, and Clive expects to be dead in his tape, since he looked to be the Gallows family fixer.
@@eyeofsauron1502 I had a stupid hunch that it either could be the police lady we talked to on the phone earlier or it could be either Henry or Marie (which is highly illogical tbh). Honestly, out of the two, which do you think was the one that got caught and which one jumped?
Yeah it's Clive If you pay really close attention you'll notice the mattress and gate where you find the record Dawn wants you to play and since Clive is the janitor who works at KFAM it'd make sense for him to be the one you're playing as in the prolouge (along with hin throwing away the bottle you have to throw away which makes sense for his job but is a big stretchL) You also see the whistling man outside the gate when you have to grab Dawn's record so i think Clive's murder is just a little bit before you grab that record
the story line of this game is just...SO AMAZING I hope they make a part two on this game everything is like "what" "wow" and "how" this game is just amazing!!
I think its hilarious how Marie's grand plan for revenge ended up with only two (maybe 3) dead (one not even linked to George), a blown up gas station and waste plant, and her kid getting arrested, all because of some disc jockey
It just came out so I don’t expect tons of people to be posting it,I’m glad I got into it early tho it’s such a cool game bro. Especially the design and graphics to it (I really love Forrest voice too) I was so shocked there was already a full gameplay too! Just came out 🎉
DAAAAAAAAAAAAmn, I just thought, Ricky says that Maxy loves the trains as they go by his apartment, and then when dawn calls, a train flashes past. That's super cool to me. How they let you know (Don't trust, this, person.)
And this came out from creators of Worms shooters and the Escapists. Team 17 are really well-versed in different genres. Albelt Dawn as killer got spoiled a bit stupidly from her side, as she said about how Peggy threw the record out of window. She couldn't have heard it since Peggy said it post-fact, after she hang up. So it either she was eavesdropping in the alley, or Henry was, and he told her afterwards
Actually, if you pay attention during that segment where Peggy talks about throwing the record out the window, they're still showing as ON AIR. So if Dawn was still listening to the radio station then she would've heard Peggy mention throwing it out the window after hanging up.
@@shaelynmartin1996 That actually clears so much up. I always wondered the first time I noticed this, "How the HELL do you know that? You weren't even in the area to hear that!"
I love the tone that plays when you save someone. It's much more subtle than the whistle of a doomed caller, but it seems like something that would play at the end of one of those campy B-movies when the killer is defeated. Which...fits this game, honestly.
This is amazing especially timing the ads super funny! Also JOHN IS A GODDAMN HERO reminded me of a few people Ive had the honor of knowing and i was fist pumping when he went into "work mode"
you know many simpathy Marie but objectively speaking she is even worse then Teddie. After her lover died, she: 1 Ruined the life of her child raising him into antisocial bloodlusted maniac 2 With his help kills 2 to 24 (Clive, Matthews and all people whos photos are at the end titles) people at minimum 3 Her grudge is so huge her kills are almost as good as random (Eugene case, prankster teens might have been more) also to add that she probably was planning it for around 20 years even waiting for a whistling night, just to spread more terror
Poor Eugene, Peggy, Murphy, and those kids, they had literally nothing to do with what happened but Marie was obsessed with her own catharsis so she'd kill anyone that wronged her, even their children just to feel like she was avenged or they picked a fight with her and her kid. And poor Henry, of course, they could've had a happy childhood but Marie cared about nothing but vengeance, not happiness or closure.
This was great to watch through. Thank you, but can I just say, I really appreciate that you kept the studio so clean XD I would also put away all the paper and tapes.
I HAD to watch someone get these calls right! I stopped watching two other playthroughs cause they frustrated me when they missed obvious choices 😭 thanks!!
I remember the beta for this and it's *completely* changed now! I just finished watching it all and I just say, what a riveting story! They definitely improved 20x over with the story. Truly a class of its own in suspenseful thriller story. I must say however it was pretty easy to see that Dawn was trying to break into the roller rink because while the S4000 could be anywhere, the "neighbor" is a male, has a dog, and is blasting music. All things Ricky mentions in his call to the station. Even without the chapters, it was pretty obvious. Other than that, and putting the pieces together myself before the game did, kept me entertained. Edit: speling
Agree. Also there are a lot of games if you make them in a Movie they are gonna come out as a best selling horror movies. Anyways as I'm a gamer and also have a gaming channel, I truly love this game and soon could play and record too.
I can see that working. I don't think we get a clear idea of who got captured & who escaped, so it could be Henry? Though I do have a feeling it was Marie who got away unless I missed something.
@@WanderingSorceressI saw someone say Marie was the one who fell off the cliff and her son was the one who was captured, but I don’t know how they knew this. Maybe because at the end the cop says Marie got away but the cops are closely pursuing her.
@@BananaWasTakenif you pay attention you can hear the cops arresting Henry right outside the station, while the cops on the phone tell that Marie ran away and is currently being chased, since whistling point is near the school she was likely the one who jumped.
That's what I was thinking! My idea, instead of Forrest trying to save everyone threw the radio, it's him who is trapped and needs to be saved by the radio (Like Peggy could be guiding him threw traps and such with the help of the towns folk while the cops try to locate where he his being kept.)
This is such a wonderful and unique horror game, saving people though the radio station when you can't see the situation but need to imagine it in your head since you can only hear it, it adds to the scary factor. And what a wonderful story, the vibes are absolutely amazing! I loved it, thanks for the walkthrough!
This game has easily become one of my comfort games, the art style, the amazing audio and voice work is astonishing. I love especially the characters, we don’t know anything about these characters when we dive in besides from Peggy asking the occasional question. just from the voice acting we can tell that Forrest obvious disdain for Gallows Creek, he isn’t the biggest fan of Peggy either but we feel them warm up to each other as the night goes on and we try to save more and more lives, we even eventually find comfort in the banter with her. All in all a beautifully done game
Thanks for this, because Jay, did not want to save that grinch guy, I think the one where he said he had a wall or something, Jay did not care about the man lol😢 44:46
He also doesn't pay attention to the clues, talks through the dialogue, and spastically moves his mouse around so much it makes me motion sick. 😂 he did go back and save the people he lost in his new upload. But again, by brute forcing it, not actually paying attention lol.
@@UnfazedPhoenix Yea I noticed that Jay doesn’t really pay much attention to detail, especially after his sally face play through. But I still enjoy his content its entertaining imo but he can be difficult to watch when it comes to puzzle solving type games lol
@@DARKANDGRIDDY1984 They don't make horror movies like they did back then, well they do, sorta. But recreating 80s horror cheese isn't easy let alone make it tolerable for the modern age
Wow this game is so well written. Taking such an awesome premise and absolutely running with it for so many different scenarios and gradually building the tension with more and more pressure and twists all leads to that awesomely earned ending where your only chance is to stall while all control is stripped away from you.
Why do I want to see a bunch of comics showing how the all the characters go about their lives after the this story? We do have rough ideas of what they look like and they all have distinct personalities. We could see Forrest skating with Ricky while Peggy plays with Maxy. There would be funerals for Sheriff Mathews, Jimmy, and Clive. Murphy would take proper lessons in self defense so he can protect himself and his kid in the future. Virginia and Plunker would go out for casual drinks at a bar. Sandra and Forrest might even get together and have a relationship thanks to the slight flirting that was tossed between the two. Sandra would also do her best to get Forrest into jazz. I don't know. But these characters interacting with each other in a non horror setting sounds wholesome and is cool to think about the possibilities of each character surviving the experience.
This game reminds me of the movie Scream. There's two killers. They kill people in the town because of something in the past. All I need to figure out is who killed who, Henry or Dawn/Marie.
Henry was likely the one attacking Jason if you want to start mapping their movements. He didn’t have his knife when he was sitting in the studio. And attacked Murphy since he was taught to never walk from a fight.
@@zoeynightshade5550 I think Marie attacked Jason because the Whistling Man asked him something along the lines of "How does it feel to be stabbed for real?" and Marie saw Jason get faked stabbed during the prank
What a hidden gem this is! I found this game on PlayStation Access live stream recently and I wanted more. Thank you for this, such amazing game, this would definitely be one of my top games this year.
just finished the game and got the bad ending... the game was pretty fun tho took me some hours to beat it and i love the concept of it its just one of the MOST underrated horror games of all time
I noticed a few things, Sherrif Mathews, Leslie, Carrie and Jimmy aren't on the killers list of targets shown at the end of the game, what it could mean is that Carrie, Leslie, and Jimmy weren't the killers targets, Marie or henry killed him because he was orchestrating a prank similar to the one that George died in, and they reminded her of the people who got George killed, so they killed jimmy, but then why was Forrest on the list, he had nothing to do with the incident, I feel like Marie/Henry wanted to kill him last as a punishment for trying to save the victims. The second that I noticed is that we don't know who we play as in the epilogue, but I have a theory, since one was arrested and the other jumped into the river. it can't be the killers, it COULD Be, however, an investigator, Peggy, or Leslie investigating the killers hut.
They're not listed for gameplay reasons, not plot ones- the people on the list are the ones whose fates you control. The Sheriff and Jimmy will always die, and Leslie and Carrie will always survive.
You could take the audio from this game and with minimal editing turn it into a GREAT audio drama. The question really would be, you can't have a slasher situation without SOME deaths, so who among the potential victims would be best to die for the story? Due to probably them not wanting to record endless amounts of situational conversations, a lot of the deaths aren't acknowledged throughout the game. Martinez: It was Matthews who covered up George's death, hence why I think she was knocked out when he was murdered instead of killed, so her being killed after wouldn't make much sense. It seemed like the killer was more so making sure no police would be around to help rather then a vendetta against Martinez. Sandra: While she is 'involved' in George's death, most of what she adds is just that she saw the body in a different place, which is kind of implicated in the reports and Clive's notes Forest Finds so I don't think her surviving adds anything to the story. I think she could be a potential unfortunate victim. Virginia: I think would need to survive as she's pretty crucial to solving the mystery behind George's death. Maurice: Since there isn't a lot of evidence of the paper covering up George's death (only really Marie mentioning it to my knowledge) and Maurice doesn't really bring it up, I think Maurice could die without losing anything to the story, although his going back with his friends to find the killer gone helps set up that there's two killers. Murphy: isn't really involved in the plot with George, probably also why he was knocked out and was more so a unfortunate victim of them destroying the Gallows Disposal Facility and him living does add evidence to that there's two killers so I think he should live. Ernest is kind of hit or miss, him being targeted in general is explained with Marie targeting kids of those who were involved so it seems his survival isn't necessary to the story. Murder House Kids:....it's kind of uncertain if they are being targeted because they are pulling a Whistling Man prank or if the kids involved are kids of those Marie wants to target. Eh, It's kind of a toss up on if they need to live. It does seem unnecessary as Marie's primary focus is those involved directly or indirectly with George's death though. Roller Ricky: while he's a nice guy, him being killed would be a nice set up for Dawn being painted as the sole killer at the moment in the story as well as her being remorseless and a manipulator. It also shows that while she sees herself as 'justified' her plot is involving killing people who weren't really responsible. Eh, I think it would be ok for Ricky to live if then Chuck Brody gets killed. Chuck Brody: he doesn't add a lot of evidence so I think if you needed another 'body' he would be ideal. He was also the 2nd Whistling man when George was killed so it would seem like Marie would want to make SURE he's dead. Jason: Jason provides a lot of evidence regarding the first Whistling night and his situation is pretty harrowing so I think him living would be ideal. Teddy Gallows JR: While the guys is a jerk I think Forest figuring out where Marie is with him is a nice cap on the story so if he survives as a result, ah well what can you do. Peggy: Peggy only being targeted due to Marie's beef with her parents is kind of a relatively weak motive, only really compounding Marie's deteriorating mental state, so I think her dying doesn't add anything.
@@eliza_rad Hold on. At the end, it sounded like an officer knew the whistling man duo. Think that might be material for a sequel? Or maybe they'd bring back the original whistling man, following the local legend of Gallows Creek?
@@eliza_rad Glad you like it. Though I wonder... What drove the original whistling man to go psycho? He must have had some reason to become a serial killer, whether it was revenge, not-so-temporary insanity, etc.
Marrie's reason to killing everybody even though justifiable, is extremely PATHETIC, sure there’s probably no innocents but I don’t think killing people who was blackmailed into covering up doesn’t mean they deserve to die. But the only victim through out all of this…is her son she made him into a killer.
Hey let's not forget about Eugene and those kids like Jimmy. Eugene had the almost COSMIC misfortune of his parents being involved. And Jimmy, well Jimmy's case is more of a matter of natural selection than anything karma related. But, Marie was also out to kill HER OWN SISTER simply because HER OWN parents weren't around anymore.
Remember that Marie did not know the full picture, and could only see the cover-up and the subsequent betrayal of everyone turning their back on her when she had a child out of wedlock. It’s not pathetic in the slightest - tragic, sure, but nobody gave Marie ANY reason to believe in them. NOBODY spoke up. They were guilty, just not as guilty as Marie thought they were.
@@michaelrhodes3285 argh, I had a feeling that was the case, f that guy. Also wow, didn't expect a reply from a months old comment so fast, thanks for the info~
Good game but of course the final questions left over is which of the suspects was apprhended and which one jumped and if the jumper died when they did? Probebly answers that will be fulfilled if this game gets a sequel.
Marie was most likely to be the one that jumped and killed herself since Whistling Point is close to the school and Henry was the one who got caught since the police most likely surrounded the building. Plus if you think about it, Marie would want to be with George. Also it really didn't imply that the jumper died. The last thing said was that the suspect could not be found.
I really loved watching people play this and I just loved the story and how Forrest pieced it together. I really hope another game like this is made! Honestly, I kind of hope that Henry and Dawn aka Marie survive..
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
whoever came up with the idea of "scrawny boy runs from chainsaw-wielding, psychopathic killer in corn field with instructions from radio host" needs an immediate promotion
Now we need a game like this except we are the one running and the radio host is never guaranteed to be correct
@@FinalGirlEra780now this is something I am up for
Sounds like Dead by daylight but with an annoying announcer.
@@massgunner4152 oh yeah... never thought of that, dwight being scrawny boy and hillbilly being the psychopathic killer
The concept is similar to Pontypool (2008); not a bad movie; better than this, because this is pretty much a visual novel, so not really a game;
Man. Carrie was so heroic trying to help everyone who just pranked her. And in the end she could've been killed and chose to tell everyone to go to save themselves
It's also nice how after the epilogue, it must've been Dawn there. And it was most likely that she saw herself in her skin there, and decided to spare her. I doubt Henry would spare Carrie.
@@МихаилБганко yea it seems that Henry was the more aggressive one. If you go and watch a video of them all dying and where we know which killer is which henry is very aggressive
@@davo_daniel9199 makes sense that henry would be aggressive... he seems to be raised on the intense revenge mentality of her mother
@@davo_daniel9199 I have a small guess that Dawn killed Sheriff Matthews because of the fake report, and Henry came back for seconds (Leslie and Deputy Martinez) because he's not as picky as Dawn.
Also, he might just be more violent in general. His confirmed targets (Maurice & Murphy) are a bit more physical. Toppling over furniture just to block Maurice's escape, and setting up an entire waste plant in flames just to kill Murphy.
@@scopicaplaysHenry and Marie might teamed up in order to take down Matthews. One to be a distraction due to the fact he has a gun so the other one will take him down by a sneak attack.
Marie's other confirmed targets are Eugene, Teddy and Roller Rickey. She was also at where Carrie and her friends are and presumably killed Clive in the tutorial. Henry might attacked John and Virginia but I guess that falls on Marie as well.
I love how the doctor is saved by the player convincing an entire party to move to her.
Oh totally. Nothing scares off.killerd like a fretting boy
bro didnt wanna get rocked by an entire group of ticked off frat boys
@Captain Huntank true. Now I can't watch any walk through where we hear these people.get murdered without being triggered, this is the only walkthriugh for me
imagine being the killer at the front door and suddenly an army of drunk frat boys armed with pizza and beer shows up
@ameliakyle7054 Rofl like this scene from Golden girls.
"I'm sorry, Rose. Next time I head into a room, I'll send a mariachi band ahead of me."
I love this game so much! Pretty much the summary of this game - "IS THAT THE GRIM REAP-"
Dude someone needs to animate that
gosh i can hear your comment loud and clear
I'm so glad I'm not the only one who thought of the Death whistle from Puss in Boots!
Idk, man, maybe we should be saying the *grill* reaper instead
Same here. One of the best games I have seen played out.
Thank you for this, there's not really much attention to this gem of a game, and no one to rattle on while you immerse yourself in the games ambience
Nobody "rattles on."
Your comment, is idiotic.
Because it doesn't officially release until June 1st... only people with early access can play it right now...agree about the immersion though so many people talk through all the important dialogue in these types of games and miss 90% of the clues lol 😂 I loved this too.
@@UnfazedPhoenix I don't mind commentary at times, but with this game, yeah they need to stop talking
@@UnfazedPhoenix I agree so I really enjoyed this video!
This is the best game I've seen, and would ever get the chance to play. It's story is magnificent, never seen anything better. There are also funny details in this game. I create killers in my story but they are all male, so far from what I know Dawn is the killer so for me, this broke that trend. Even more surprisingly, I share a name with one of the victims, Jason.
21:23 Peggy's victory pose in the background made me genuinely smile.
John Hedges is such a cool guy. He wakes up to a call at 2 in the morning, gets called in to do something he hasn't done for 10 years, and does it unquestionably.
Medic training never leaves you. I would know, my mom was a CNA.
Spoilers about every rescue:
Leslie tasered the whistling man to save Martinez inside their police car.
20:50
Sandra did some car wires moment and turned on the car without keys.
36:36
Maurice thought he trapped the whistling man but it was unexpectedly in vain (useless.)
58:50 is the trap
1:06:55 is whistling man escape
Virginia was saved by Plunker’s party, the whistling man ran away and this increased sanity, with a party at Virginia’s House.
1:29:23
Eugene escaped the maze, riding his bike home to escape the whistling man.
1:39:45
Murphy escaped such cruel dumpster, he was locked in it but fortunately Katherine saved his life.
1:49:10
Carrie was not a victim, the whistling man spared her for no reason and the other teens escaped in a vehicle, all the teens.
2:11:13
Chuck escaped his station, with other people inside it, thanks to Forrest mentioning his danger which the evidence was found by Clive’s hideout.
2:34:43
Ricky was alarmed by a break in, looks like Dawn was tricked because she was the whistling man who almost got shot by Ricky’s Rifle.
3:13:02
Jason was aided by Casey, healing him with remaining cloth and sources while John came to give medkits.
3:39:50
Last but not least, Teddy went unconscious and Peggy came in, Marie was gonna kill her but Forrest mentioned a birthday card, Marie was surprised but suddenly got ambushed.
4:13:42 Peggy is a witness
4:16:50 Saving Peggy
Ending: *Henry was arrested and Marie fell off the Gallows Creek point, unsure if she died.*
I loved the maize maze part so much and I can't stop replaying it help
Carrie herself wasn’t a target, given the current killing spree is motivated as vengeance for a prior prank that got someone killed.
Her friends were likely targeted due to engaging in that same kind of prank responsible that kicked off the game’s murder spree.
(Eugene was targeted for being the child of two deceased people affiliated with the prank. In general the planner was utterly vindictive and cruel, ignoring the pain caused to others and taking out their murderous desires on people whom didn’t even take part in the incident, as well being utterly cruel in their murders.)
the way you explained how they survived what happened reminded me of the quarry
@@teddybearpaladinMurphy had only been in gallows for 3 years. Why did they try to kill him?
@@Brettnoseque He challenged the killer to a fight, and Henry showed up because Marie raised him not to run away from a fight.
Fun fact that not a lot of people know: There are even more hints to save Roller Ricky than Dawn sounding suspicious.
First of all, and most obviously, there's no whistling in Dawn's phone call. The Whistling Man sure loves his whistling.
Second, and more obscurely, in Dawn's phone call, there is a train mid-call. Then there's a dog howl and then disco music playing. Maxy greets every train with a howl, and everyone knows Roller Ricky is the only one who plays disco. This means she was trying to get into the rink, not the apartment.
You may be thinking "Well what if the apartment is right next to the rink?". Look at the map in the radio office. Wood Side Apartment is nowhere near a train line. If she actually was trying to "get into her apartment", the train that blared would've been silent, if not, much quieter than it was.
Another even more OBVIOUS hint that Dawns story didn't check out is that, on the order form for the Starling 4000, it wasn't even INSTALLED at Wood Side yet. Forrest mentions this once you pick up the form.
@@memehunter2476 If only she had gotten her son Henry to whistle in the background (he has an identical whistle), then her story would've been at least somewhat believable. Thank goodness she didn't and Roller Ricky was the easiest to save. He's too good to die.
i had a thought dawn was infact the killer she was too sus but my suspicions were dispelled about certain things
i thought she just knew more than things so the killer was after her, at this point i lost a few context with the entire story so my only thought was to keep her alive until i just face palmed cause at this point i ralized there could be 2
its a weird way to know there where 2 whistling men after failing to save cool roller ricky
@@stefgen6394rip roller Ricky if you failed :( did max get killed?
@@Dontreadthis_ Yep. Max dies first, then Ricky if you fail.
My biggest complaint about this game is not having a segment where you have to save Ponty, and at the end she’s like “he was annoying me that’s why”
Haha,but i feel she would say more something Like"he was promoting on georges death" or like that
Yeah he was just forgotten about after Forrest finally wished the Whistling Man would get rid of him, would have been nice if Marie mentioned that as a possible reason why she thought Forrest would help her.
@@Bluestone775YES THAT IS LIQUID SMOOTH STORY LINE
@@Bluestone775 Given that he nor his family was not directly involved in the incident, Henry would be the more likely suspect, Marie might have her reservations since Ponty wouldn't be aware of the whole situation
I love the little moments of self expession hidden in here, playing the Teddy Gallows Jr. ad right after he was a self-centred jerk, a couple sassy replies to the non-emergency callers, very funny.
I was looking for someone to comment this 🤣 I started cracking up when after all that with Teddy, the ad picked was HIS. Just… *chefs kiss* beautiful irony lmfaooo
"Please don't tell me this hick town only has two cops."
"Don't be ridiculous. We have three!"
Well, that's even worse.
I hope someone animates some of these callers descriptions of the events, would love to see someone jazz run away from a killer
Yeah, but don't forget that Jimmy had his *fucking face cut off*
Finally a full game and I like the player really focus on the story.
@zico Absolutely. This gameplay inspired me to the level that I'm gonna play and upload it on my channel too😅 ❤
@@gamingbud134 good luck on your gameplay then, subscribe to you for good luck
I honestly think that clive is the dude in the tutorial as he enters a storage room that looks alot like a janitors closet
Thank you, I was trying to figure out who the dude was.
Kinda explains how he was missing throughout the game ngl
@@Gl1tt3ry_C0m3t and explains how the killer knew so much about the full picture
They went in and listened to his tapes then left as we went outside
@@greasymonk3y Except they were already killing in other towns before finding Clive?
I'm also thinking he could be the guy in the credits listening in on the police chase
That Teddy Gallows Jr. ad is just perfect right after that phone call💀
IKR, it's good comedy
I have a feeling it was intentional... By the person who is playing this game I mean.
@@Kensuke22 Maybe. The player does seem to know where things are... 😅
Gab Smolders accidentally did the same thing during her playthrough, then immediately took the tape out and yeeted it across the room. 😂
that timing was FOUL lmao /pos
As heartless as it is to say, jimmy (i think) had it coming. He made fun of a day relating to a serial killer like peoples deaths are a joke and was scaring people on a night when a killer was on the loose like he was invincible.
I dont think someone being an asshole as a teenager means they deserve to die. Very little people deserve to die and I wouldn't say someone like that is one of them
@@homoerectos1110 considering the killer at the time was Marie ( the person who spared Carrie), she got so offended at Jimmy's prank since that's how George got killed. "It's just a prank bro" gone wrong.
Nah, he deserved it @@homoerectos1110
@@jocelantonettetenoc5996 yeah but that doesnt mean killing jimmy was right
She killed Jimmy cuz she got reminded of Teddy doing a "prank" that got her boyfriend killed
Jimmy is at fault for being stupid and got himself killed for the "prank"
Spoiler alert: I think one of the reasons why the killer spared Carrie regardless of ending is because she remembered George being pranked in the same way years ago? Anyway Carrie is best girl.
I think you should probably not just put the spoiler alert and the spoilers in the same line....
But yeah, Carrie was probably spared because she was a victim of the type of prank that caused the killings at the same time
Peggy better girl
Oh for sure, they actually go out of their way to save her since if she gets trapped under the car if you assign the wrong driver and it crashes, the killer will free her leg and then walk away. They were serious about sparing her.
Gotta say that was a hell of a game. I remember seeing this the first time and man what a change it went though. Props to the makers.
And nice job saving everyone, I don't think I could do that
I do wish, that they'd kept Forrest's voice/tone the same, though. It, this game, explains why he seemed so sullen.
@@Jaybird196 Hearing the old voice previously, I think I prefer this one
@@22kingdomheartsfan Oh? What makes you say that? 'Just curious.
@@Jaybird196 No real reason, this voice just sounds better to me. Different taste I guess
@@22kingdomheartsfan Fair enough, I suppose.
This game is very neat. I like how its a horror game but you can save others from the Killer.
Well Except Jimmy... Poor kid didn't deserve that.. :(
@@ashlight6107 nah he did
@@eliseo5416 I mean, he was a dumb kid. While he was a jerk, he was just a kid. He definitely didn’t deserve THAT.
@@CrowlessSunbathe Agreed.
@@eliseo5416he deserved a slap to the face, not a knife to carve it off.
I found out about this game because of a friend and god do I love it. I love the storyline and all the unique characters. This is a textbook example of how not everything needs to be shown in order to be horror.
Ponty was hilarious. And it didn't take me too long to figure out Teddy was involved and was covering it up. And that epilouge, so history repeats itself. I have a feeling that we will see him again. The one thing I don't get is why Murphy was attacked. Wait, the garbage plant was owned by Teddy, ohhh he was just in the wrong place at the wrong time
I think it’s more so he got cocky and the fact Marie taught Henry to ‘never run away from a fight.’ But hey maybe it contributed who knows
He told Henry to come and fight him and told him where he will be at so he can kick his butt with some moves from Master Robbie (or at least try to). Dude had me crying😂
He and Ponty are my faveriote dudes in this game
@@BallinCollin1 i think his parents did something in the prank but they died so she went after their son Eugene
@@BallinCollin1 This is mentioned in the game when Peggy burst in and Marie was about to kill her. Eugene's parents were at the party and she was gonna kill them. Since his parents died in the bus accident, she went with the next best thing which was him.
Thanks so much for the video!! I love a good suspenseful mystery and watched it all in one sitting this evening! It was wonderful experiencing it with no one talking over it and no mistakes, meaning the plot kept moving instead of someone going back to correct their errors. The story kept me on edge wondering what was coming next! I love the inspiration for when I one day write my own story! And it’s really nice getting something like this without it depending on showing gore or gross things, but keeping things intense and with a creepy atmosphere, even having you go outside at one point! The twists too! This was amazing to watch and I would love to see more games like it! Now I’ll probably watch some typical let’s plays and see how things go. Thanks again!
Lmao i loved when Forrest fell for Ponty's tricks, getting so mad then being tired of it 😭💀
(Edit)
Loving yalls replies :)!!
PONTY'S PIZZA 🔛🔝🗣🔥🔥🍕🍕
best part of the game
Reminds me of Archie
it’s PONTY’S PIZZA-
@@CocoaChris917forrest nash gonna say: “PONTY KILL YOURSELF!”
It's like the prank calls except It's the pizzeria this time hahaha haha
this game is a hidden game!!! definitely interesting, worth playing and can be made into a Hollywood movie!!!
"game is a hidden game!"
im pretty sure its right here
@@SpathiCaptainFwiffo i think he/she meant hidden gem
I'm pretty sure this game came out only a couple of days ago. Y'all need to be more patient.
@Akane Kitaouji Absolutely true. After watching this I'm gonna play and upload it on my channel too ❤
The game is playing hide and seek💀
Anyone think that the opening tutorial was depicting Clive’s murder?
I was thinking so!
I was wondering who we were playing as in the prologue. That certainly makes sense due to Clive being implied to have died. Although now I’m wondering who we’re playing as in the epilogue?
@@Lizuma it makes sense, since the last thing we see is the Whistling Man, and Clive expects to be dead in his tape, since he looked to be the Gallows family fixer.
@@eyeofsauron1502 I had a stupid hunch that it either could be the police lady we talked to on the phone earlier or it could be either Henry or Marie (which is highly illogical tbh). Honestly, out of the two, which do you think was the one that got caught and which one jumped?
Yeah it's Clive
If you pay really close attention you'll notice the mattress and gate where you find the record Dawn wants you to play and since Clive is the janitor who works at KFAM it'd make sense for him to be the one you're playing as in the prolouge (along with hin throwing away the bottle you have to throw away which makes sense for his job but is a big stretchL)
You also see the whistling man outside the gate when you have to grab Dawn's record so i think Clive's murder is just a little bit before you grab that record
the story line of this game is just...SO AMAZING I hope they make a part two on this game everything is like "what" "wow" and "how" this game is just amazing!!
I think its hilarious how Marie's grand plan for revenge ended up with only two (maybe 3) dead (one not even linked to George), a blown up gas station and waste plant, and her kid getting arrested, all because of some disc jockey
It just came out so I don’t expect tons of people to be posting it,I’m glad I got into it early tho it’s such a cool game bro. Especially the design and graphics to it (I really love Forrest voice too) I was so shocked there was already a full gameplay too! Just came out 🎉
DAAAAAAAAAAAAmn, I just thought, Ricky says that Maxy loves the trains as they go by his apartment, and then when dawn calls, a train flashes past. That's super cool to me. How they let you know (Don't trust, this, person.)
Small attention to details :D
This is not just a game. It's an awesome ASMR novel.
*Whiiiiii-ssstlllle-lllleee*
And this came out from creators of Worms shooters and the Escapists. Team 17 are really well-versed in different genres. Albelt Dawn as killer got spoiled a bit stupidly from her side, as she said about how Peggy threw the record out of window. She couldn't have heard it since Peggy said it post-fact, after she hang up. So it either she was eavesdropping in the alley, or Henry was, and he told her afterwards
Actually, if you pay attention during that segment where Peggy talks about throwing the record out the window, they're still showing as ON AIR. So if Dawn was still listening to the radio station then she would've heard Peggy mention throwing it out the window after hanging up.
@@shaelynmartin1996 Hmm. Ok then, I just assumed they were not broadcasting them speaking at that moment
@@shaelynmartin1996 That actually clears so much up. I always wondered the first time I noticed this, "How the HELL do you know that? You weren't even in the area to hear that!"
I love the tone that plays when you save someone. It's much more subtle than the whistle of a doomed caller, but it seems like something that would play at the end of one of those campy B-movies when the killer is defeated. Which...fits this game, honestly.
This is amazing especially timing the ads super funny!
Also JOHN IS A GODDAMN HERO reminded me of a few people Ive had the honor of knowing and i was fist pumping when he went into "work mode"
you know many simpathy Marie but objectively speaking she is even worse then Teddie.
After her lover died, she:
1 Ruined the life of her child raising him into antisocial bloodlusted maniac
2 With his help kills 2 to 24 (Clive, Matthews and all people whos photos are at the end titles) people at minimum
3 Her grudge is so huge her kills are almost as good as random (Eugene case, prankster teens might have been more)
also to add that she probably was planning it for around 20 years even waiting for a whistling night, just to spread more terror
Yeap, as petty as they come, and she was still justifying her ways even on the thinnest strands.
Poor Eugene, Peggy, Murphy, and those kids, they had literally nothing to do with what happened but Marie was obsessed with her own catharsis so she'd kill anyone that wronged her, even their children just to feel like she was avenged or they picked a fight with her and her kid.
And poor Henry, of course, they could've had a happy childhood but Marie cared about nothing but vengeance, not happiness or closure.
This was great to watch through. Thank you, but can I just say, I really appreciate that you kept the studio so clean XD I would also put away all the paper and tapes.
I keep laughing both in hilarity & annoyance at Ponty trying to advertise for free XD
(Ponty timestamps are 39:46 1:30:51 3:03:31 3:04:41)
Thanks
“Oh my, goddamn it!” Was awesome 😂
"Stop calling us!!!"
@@izzfitri6888 I’m so glad this game wasn’t just scary or one sided, they had plenty of funny parts!
The Music and Voice acting in this game is really top notch
I HAD to watch someone get these calls right! I stopped watching two other playthroughs cause they frustrated me when they missed obvious choices 😭 thanks!!
Kubz Scout especially 😢
Insym did good
@@-CarPBon- He didn't save Murphy, Virginia, and Tammy(one of the teens) though.
@@EvelynL.1112 I didn't say it was perfect
LITERALLY
i love Forrest’s impersonation of Maurice i CAN’T get over it!😂😂😂
It combined Scooby Doo series and 90's killer movies.
Epic and never try at home.
The Ponti's Pizza really got me laughing hard, so desperate for him to spread the word despite a killer on the loose XDXD
I bought this randomly in a sale because it sounded interesting and absolutely loved it. Real hidden gem of a game imo
I remember the beta for this and it's *completely* changed now!
I just finished watching it all and I just say, what a riveting story! They definitely improved 20x over with the story.
Truly a class of its own in suspenseful thriller story.
I must say however it was pretty easy to see that Dawn was trying to break into the roller rink because while the S4000 could be anywhere, the "neighbor" is a male, has a dog, and is blasting music. All things Ricky mentions in his call to the station. Even without the chapters, it was pretty obvious. Other than that, and putting the pieces together myself before the game did, kept me entertained.
Edit: speling
also a train was heard during her call just like in Ricky's call
I think it's supposed to be a bit obvious. That way it's a lot easier to put together the pieces.
and there was no whistling
This would make a good interactive TV series
Agree. Also there are a lot of games if you make them in a Movie they are gonna come out as a best selling horror movies.
Anyways as I'm a gamer and also have a gaming channel, I truly love this game and soon could play and record too.
I think we could definitely see a sequel with Marie’s son coming for Forrest after ruining his mothers plans
I can see that working. I don't think we get a clear idea of who got captured & who escaped, so it could be Henry? Though I do have a feeling it was Marie who got away unless I missed something.
@@WanderingSorceressI saw someone say Marie was the one who fell off the cliff and her son was the one who was captured, but I don’t know how they knew this.
Maybe because at the end the cop says Marie got away but the cops are closely pursuing her.
@@BananaWasTaken Maybe that was a different ending?
@@BananaWasTakenif you pay attention you can hear the cops arresting Henry right outside the station, while the cops on the phone tell that Marie ran away and is currently being chased, since whistling point is near the school she was likely the one who jumped.
That's what I was thinking! My idea, instead of Forrest trying to save everyone threw the radio, it's him who is trapped and needs to be saved by the radio (Like Peggy could be guiding him threw traps and such with the help of the towns folk while the cops try to locate where he his being kept.)
This is such a wonderful and unique horror game, saving people though the radio station when you can't see the situation but need to imagine it in your head since you can only hear it, it adds to the scary factor. And what a wonderful story, the vibes are absolutely amazing! I loved it, thanks for the walkthrough!
This game has easily become one of my comfort games, the art style, the amazing audio and voice work is astonishing. I love especially the characters, we don’t know anything about these characters when we dive in besides from Peggy asking the occasional question. just from the voice acting we can tell that Forrest obvious disdain for Gallows Creek, he isn’t the biggest fan of Peggy either but we feel them warm up to each other as the night goes on and we try to save more and more lives, we even eventually find comfort in the banter with her. All in all a beautifully done game
Damn that was not what I thought it would be VERY big plot twist love it!
Thanks for this, because Jay, did not want to save that grinch guy, I think the one where he said he had a wall or something, Jay did not care about the man lol😢 44:46
He also doesn't pay attention to the clues, talks through the dialogue, and spastically moves his mouse around so much it makes me motion sick. 😂 he did go back and save the people he lost in his new upload. But again, by brute forcing it, not actually paying attention lol.
@@UnfazedPhoenix Yea I noticed that Jay doesn’t really pay much attention to detail, especially after his sally face play through. But I still enjoy his content its entertaining imo but he can be difficult to watch when it comes to puzzle solving type games lol
His horror game vids r amazingly hilarious lmao
Maybe jay has adhd or just attention difficulties because i have that it's also in a way stressful but i do agree that he does talk alot....
Thx man! I’ve been wanting to see the old grumpy guy live.
100% love it. It has a ghostface based plot since there was 2 killers
The radio station is literally called The Scream.
@@zerotodona1495 makes sense
Putting back the Friend's Quiz got ya a Sub, utterly didn't need todo that but ya did.
Fun fact, at the end, if you annoy dawn enough, forest will get killed
Wym annoy?
@@franc_idk Like if you refuse to play her game or answer her questions
@@metagamer3534 btw how'd u found that out
@@franc_idk I got curious when I got the game and experimented with that senerio
@@metagamer3534 does she comment on it or?
Finally, I was trying to hunt a video like this down
And you sectioned off all of the people being saved?? this is great
This is the best horror story I've seen since the first Scream.
Good voice acting too
Some people shit on the voice acting, but I like how it makes it sound more like an old horror movie, and it's pretty good by itself too.
@@DARKANDGRIDDY1984 true,btw you look similar,did you comment on a post i made a few hours ago?
@@DARKANDGRIDDY1984 They don't make horror movies like they did back then, well they do, sorta. But recreating 80s horror cheese isn't easy let alone make it tolerable for the modern age
I loved ponty's va's work
Dude I love this game. Seeing it remastered is amazing!
Wow this game is so well written. Taking such an awesome premise and absolutely running with it for so many different scenarios and gradually building the tension with more and more pressure and twists all leads to that awesomely earned ending where your only chance is to stall while all control is stripped away from you.
Yo, Henry is kinda...👀.
Especially when he LEANS ON THE GLASS!
1:54:38
"He played a lot of sports back in the day, and never lets anyone forget it."
*PLAYED COLLEGE BALL, YOU KNOW!*
COLD'VE GONE PRO IF I HADN'T JOINED THE NAVY
That ending song is fucking sick, hopefully it goes out as a track soon
Very solid voice acting, really selld the whole story.
4:19:07 It’s so weird seeing everyone that you saved and what you look like here
Thank you so much for this! You're a total lifesaver!
Phenomenal game. Very climatic, great music, interesting story. More things like this, please! I want more!
3:03:33 Ponty tricking Forrest was hilarious
Why do I want to see a bunch of comics showing how the all the characters go about their lives after the this story?
We do have rough ideas of what they look like and they all have distinct personalities. We could see Forrest skating with Ricky while Peggy plays with Maxy. There would be funerals for Sheriff Mathews, Jimmy, and Clive. Murphy would take proper lessons in self defense so he can protect himself and his kid in the future. Virginia and Plunker would go out for casual drinks at a bar. Sandra and Forrest might even get together and have a relationship thanks to the slight flirting that was tossed between the two. Sandra would also do her best to get Forrest into jazz. I don't know. But these characters interacting with each other in a non horror setting sounds wholesome and is cool to think about the possibilities of each character surviving the experience.
Bro if I was a legendary killer getting stumped by a radio show host on the night of my death and return I would be livid
Thank you for uploading the game. Such a great story to experience.
This game reminds me of the movie Scream. There's two killers. They kill people in the town because of something in the past. All I need to figure out is who killed who, Henry or Dawn/Marie.
The name of the Radio Program is "The Scream", so the references are presumably intentional.
Henry was likely the one attacking Jason if you want to start mapping their movements. He didn’t have his knife when he was sitting in the studio. And attacked Murphy since he was taught to never walk from a fight.
@@zoeynightshade5550 I think Marie attacked Jason because the Whistling Man asked him something along the lines of "How does it feel to be stabbed for real?" and Marie saw Jason get faked stabbed during the prank
Team 17.
I saw an ad for game before this video started. Nice.
I just love Murphy. I'm glad that he lived in this playthrough
This was an interesting game and the way the killers got away who knows they might make a second game
What a hidden gem this is! I found this game on PlayStation Access live stream recently and I wanted more. Thank you for this, such amazing game, this would definitely be one of my top games this year.
Great walkthough i needed to see how they survive And why do the callers talk so damn loud When the killers are nearby
Panic probably
They aren't using concealment as cover from the killer, soo i guess it's fine to be loud
The killer was probably like “this fuckin guy”
And he was supported by "that biotch".
Honestly Eugene should've just ran through the maze walls because thats exactly what I would've done (ik its an option but it doesn’t work)
ty i was looking for this
The music in this game is such a good jam! Props to the people who worked on the music for this game, they are all bangers!
im pretty sure we all had a good feeling at the end
Thank you for this, the pizza box was stuck behind the bin in my game and I had no way to progress
just finished the game and got the bad ending... the game was pretty fun tho took me some hours to beat it and i love the concept of it its just one of the MOST underrated horror games of all time
Dang goodness, this was a satisfying (no commentary) walkthrough to watch
I like how Forrest save everyone from the killer and get the best ending.
marie dying the same way george did... the poetry
That was a fun thrill, thanks for this run.
Omfg, the Spanish restaurant being named “Chalupa-Cabra’s” almost killed me.
I noticed a few things, Sherrif Mathews, Leslie, Carrie and Jimmy aren't on the killers list of targets shown at the end of the game, what it could mean is that Carrie, Leslie, and Jimmy weren't the killers targets, Marie or henry killed him because he was orchestrating a prank similar to the one that George died in, and they reminded her of the people who got George killed, so they killed jimmy, but then why was Forrest on the list, he had nothing to do with the incident, I feel like Marie/Henry wanted to kill him last as a punishment for trying to save the victims. The second that I noticed is that we don't know who we play as in the epilogue, but I have a theory, since one was arrested and the other jumped into the river. it can't be the killers, it COULD Be, however, an investigator, Peggy, or Leslie investigating the killers hut.
I believe that Marie/ henry made the list after killing the Sherrif and Clive, which would explain why Clive and Sherrif Mathews wasn't listed.
In Clive’s basement, you can actually find a fake report by sheriff Matthews meaning he was in on it and had a reason to be killed
I think someone else made it,but forgot Matthew,Leslie, Clive and Jimmy
They're not listed for gameplay reasons, not plot ones- the people on the list are the ones whose fates you control. The Sheriff and Jimmy will always die, and Leslie and Carrie will always survive.
@@shadow81818 I know that...but still. it is something to think about, I guess
Ngl it wouldve been a great plot twist if Leslie was the second killer instead of Marie's son
This feels like an interactive radio drama, and it's expertly written.
you just made me love this game
I wonder if Peggy hates the song Marie kept asking for because it reminds her of her sister
You could take the audio from this game and with minimal editing turn it into a GREAT audio drama. The question really would be, you can't have a slasher situation without SOME deaths, so who among the potential victims would be best to die for the story? Due to probably them not wanting to record endless amounts of situational conversations, a lot of the deaths aren't acknowledged throughout the game.
Martinez: It was Matthews who covered up George's death, hence why I think she was knocked out when he was murdered instead of killed, so her being killed after wouldn't make much sense. It seemed like the killer was more so making sure no police would be around to help rather then a vendetta against Martinez.
Sandra: While she is 'involved' in George's death, most of what she adds is just that she saw the body in a different place, which is kind of implicated in the reports and Clive's notes Forest Finds so I don't think her surviving adds anything to the story. I think she could be a potential unfortunate victim.
Virginia: I think would need to survive as she's pretty crucial to solving the mystery behind George's death.
Maurice: Since there isn't a lot of evidence of the paper covering up George's death (only really Marie mentioning it to my knowledge) and Maurice doesn't really bring it up, I think Maurice could die without losing anything to the story, although his going back with his friends to find the killer gone helps set up that there's two killers.
Murphy: isn't really involved in the plot with George, probably also why he was knocked out and was more so a unfortunate victim of them destroying the Gallows Disposal Facility and him living does add evidence to that there's two killers so I think he should live.
Ernest is kind of hit or miss, him being targeted in general is explained with Marie targeting kids of those who were involved so it seems his survival isn't necessary to the story.
Murder House Kids:....it's kind of uncertain if they are being targeted because they are pulling a Whistling Man prank or if the kids involved are kids of those Marie wants to target. Eh, It's kind of a toss up on if they need to live. It does seem unnecessary as Marie's primary focus is those involved directly or indirectly with George's death though.
Roller Ricky: while he's a nice guy, him being killed would be a nice set up for Dawn being painted as the sole killer at the moment in the story as well as her being remorseless and a manipulator. It also shows that while she sees herself as 'justified' her plot is involving killing people who weren't really responsible. Eh, I think it would be ok for Ricky to live if then Chuck Brody gets killed.
Chuck Brody: he doesn't add a lot of evidence so I think if you needed another 'body' he would be ideal. He was also the 2nd Whistling man when George was killed so it would seem like Marie would want to make SURE he's dead.
Jason: Jason provides a lot of evidence regarding the first Whistling night and his situation is pretty harrowing so I think him living would be ideal.
Teddy Gallows JR: While the guys is a jerk I think Forest figuring out where Marie is with him is a nice cap on the story so if he survives as a result, ah well what can you do.
Peggy: Peggy only being targeted due to Marie's beef with her parents is kind of a relatively weak motive, only really compounding Marie's deteriorating mental state, so I think her dying doesn't add anything.
legit talk, if i played the game before i watched this.. i have no doubt i would have gotten ricky and max killed... took me by surprise
Started watching this after Jay's last episode of this game. Neve get sick of this game ❤
Yess!
This game deserves a sequel. Idk how, but it really deserves one!
I really want to write a play based off of this game and make it like a sequel!
@@eliza_rad Hold on. At the end, it sounded like an officer knew the whistling man duo. Think that might be material for a sequel?
Or maybe they'd bring back the original whistling man, following the local legend of Gallows Creek?
@@Vitreous78 OOO WAIT I LOVE THIS IDEA! I’ll definitely have to plan it out!
@@eliza_rad Glad you like it. Though I wonder... What drove the original whistling man to go psycho? He must have had some reason to become a serial killer, whether it was revenge, not-so-temporary insanity, etc.
@@Vitreous78 Maybe there is no motive. Like Billy Loomis claimed in "Scream" it's much scarier if there is no motivation.
Marrie's reason to killing everybody even though justifiable, is extremely PATHETIC, sure there’s probably no innocents but I don’t think killing people who was blackmailed into covering up doesn’t mean they deserve to die. But the only victim through out all of this…is her son she made him into a killer.
Hey let's not forget about Eugene and those kids like Jimmy. Eugene had the almost COSMIC misfortune of his parents being involved. And Jimmy, well Jimmy's case is more of a matter of natural selection than anything karma related. But, Marie was also out to kill HER OWN SISTER simply because HER OWN parents weren't around anymore.
Remember that Marie did not know the full picture, and could only see the cover-up and the subsequent betrayal of everyone turning their back on her when she had a child out of wedlock.
It’s not pathetic in the slightest - tragic, sure, but nobody gave Marie ANY reason to believe in them. NOBODY spoke up.
They were guilty, just not as guilty as Marie thought they were.
I still hope Teddy got the punishment he must be given though, still not sure if she managed to kill him before cops came in...
@@onebear6504 he’s definitely alive Forrest stalled Marie long enough
@@michaelrhodes3285 argh, I had a feeling that was the case, f that guy. Also wow, didn't expect a reply from a months old comment so fast, thanks for the info~
Good game but of course the final questions left over is which of the suspects was apprhended and which one jumped and if the jumper died when they did? Probebly answers that will be fulfilled if this game gets a sequel.
Marie was most likely to be the one that jumped and killed herself since Whistling Point is close to the school and Henry was the one who got caught since the police most likely surrounded the building. Plus if you think about it, Marie would want to be with George. Also it really didn't imply that the jumper died. The last thing said was that the suspect could not be found.
@@SkeeBall_Gaming I know but that is why I brought up the mystery would be solved if the creator of this game does a sequel
@@blackdemonknight I really hope they do make a sequel tho
DLC at best
@@titanking8403 that too
I really loved watching people play this and I just loved the story and how Forrest pieced it together. I really hope another game like this is made! Honestly, I kind of hope that Henry and Dawn aka Marie survive..
2 TWISTS IN ONE ENDING
I like how accurate the first aid they tell you to do is, its almost 1 to 1 for most basic first aid handbooks