지금껏 너무나도 많이 접했던 영문법 내용 과거진행, 단순과거의 설명이었습니다. 그러나 샘의 알림은 달랐습니다. 아니 명쾌했습니다. 단순히 과거진행의 단문 하나만 말한 것은 특별한(과거특정시점을 서로 알 때) 경우을 제외하고 틀린 사용법이다. When 과 While의 명확한 비교! 게다가 시제를 사용해서 Social distance 뉘앙스를 표현한다는 알림! 너무 너무 감사합니다. 그리고 역시나 이번에도 질문 하나가 있습니다. 선생님의 과거진행의 구성과 뉘앙스를 받아들여 생각을 넓혔습니다. 그랬는데, 의문이 들었습니다. 동시에 확신이 들었구요!! 제 각이 맞는지 궁금합니다. 소위, 학교문법에서 "시간이나 조건의 부사절에는 현재시제가 미래시제를 대신한다." 라는 말이 있습니다. 그 동안, 그 이유를 다소 모호하게 이해하고 있었습니다. 그런데, 샘의 이 영상을 듣는 순간 떠올랐습니다. 과거에 경험한 특정시점은 화자가 알 수 있으니 특정시점(과거진행과 교차하는)을 표현해야 합니다. 하지만, 미래는 화자가 미래의 특정시점을 정할 수 없습니다. 해서 단순미래 또는 미래진행의 시점을 특정할 수가 없습니다. 그러니 현재시제로 쓸 수 밖에 없다는 결론입니다. 물론, 말하고 있는 지금의 현재와는 when, while을 쓰는 순간 구분할 수 있으니 말입니다. 저의 추론이 타당한가요? 아니면 다른 이유가 있나요? 오늘도 너무 기쁘네요, 샘 영상 보고...감사합니다.
WOW This is a type of questions that linguists would ask. There could be many ways to explain why a present tense is used to express a future meaning in adverb clauses. Due to lack of space and time, let’s just see one example below. A-1 I will call you when I get home. A-2 I don’t know when I will get home. In A-1 the “when I get home” is a adverb clause expressing the moment of time and not action. Tense can only be given to actions by definition. Tense refers to the time of an event/action. On the other hand, in A-2, “when I will get home” is a noun clause expressing the action which needs a tense: future in this case. In short, I think you understand how to use adverb clauses correctly. It’s easy to just understand how Korea works. “집에 도착하면” this has no tense so in English when I get home “언제 집에 갈지” this has future(~할) tense so in English when I will get home Thank you for the great questions. Sorry I couldn’t elaborate further. Yet, I’m not worried because I think you got this. Thank you and have a great weekend.
I was studying English when you called last night. I was exercising after work when you worked overtime. He was eating dinner alone while she was taking a nap on the couch. What was he doing while you were cooking lunch? I was wondering if you could make some time for me this Friday. I was hoping you could give me some advices about my son. What was she doing while her baby was crying badly? She was cleaning up my house all day thankfully while I was being away. You were hanging out with your friends when I visited your house. He was reading a book at the station when I got there. What were your kids doing while you were trimming plants in the garden? I was baking animal-shaped cookies for grandson while he was vacuuming.
Thank you for your question Yes you can use "talk with" Talk to and talk with are used interchangeably with no big difference in meaning. Thank you and have a great day
올려주신 동영상을 한번 더 꼼꼼히 보면서
when 과 while 로써 편안하게 과거 진행형을 이어나가는 늬앙스도 확실히 익히고, 혼자 빙긋이 미소지으며 마지막 문제를 풀었습니다.
내일은 어떤 선물이 날아올지 기대하며 오늘 하루를 마무리 합니다.
선생님 감사합니다.
열심히 해 주셔서 제가 감사합니다.
매일 정성 어린 댓글 제게 큰 힘이 됩니다.
Thank you for all your support.
믿고 보는 선샤인영어~
오늘 강의도 너무 감사드리며
잘 듣고 갑니다^^
Thank you for catching up with the old lessons
If you have any questions please let me know
Thank you and have a great weekend
감 사 해 요 ~~♡
Thank you for being studious like you said.
Have a productive day
개념정리의 끝판왕이십니다. 👍
Thank you
Glad that it was helpful
Thank you and have a beautiful day
설명 잘 듣고 갑니다.
연습문장 만들어 보는게 저에게 너무 좋았습니다.
감사합니다.
지금껏 너무나도 많이 접했던 영문법 내용 과거진행, 단순과거의 설명이었습니다.
그러나 샘의 알림은 달랐습니다. 아니 명쾌했습니다.
단순히 과거진행의 단문 하나만 말한 것은 특별한(과거특정시점을 서로 알 때) 경우을 제외하고 틀린 사용법이다.
When 과 While의 명확한 비교! 게다가 시제를 사용해서 Social distance 뉘앙스를 표현한다는 알림!
너무 너무 감사합니다.
그리고 역시나 이번에도 질문 하나가 있습니다.
선생님의 과거진행의 구성과 뉘앙스를 받아들여 생각을 넓혔습니다.
그랬는데, 의문이 들었습니다. 동시에 확신이 들었구요!! 제 각이 맞는지 궁금합니다.
소위, 학교문법에서 "시간이나 조건의 부사절에는 현재시제가 미래시제를 대신한다." 라는 말이 있습니다.
그 동안, 그 이유를 다소 모호하게 이해하고 있었습니다. 그런데, 샘의 이 영상을 듣는 순간 떠올랐습니다.
과거에 경험한 특정시점은 화자가 알 수 있으니 특정시점(과거진행과 교차하는)을 표현해야 합니다.
하지만, 미래는 화자가 미래의 특정시점을 정할 수 없습니다. 해서 단순미래 또는 미래진행의 시점을 특정할 수가 없습니다.
그러니 현재시제로 쓸 수 밖에 없다는 결론입니다. 물론, 말하고 있는 지금의 현재와는 when, while을 쓰는 순간 구분할 수 있으니 말입니다.
저의 추론이 타당한가요? 아니면 다른 이유가 있나요?
오늘도 너무 기쁘네요, 샘 영상 보고...감사합니다.
WOW
This is a type of questions that linguists would ask.
There could be many ways to explain why a present tense is used to express a future meaning in adverb clauses. Due to lack of space and time, let’s just see one example below.
A-1
I will call you when I get home.
A-2
I don’t know when I will get home.
In A-1 the “when I get home” is a adverb clause expressing the moment of time and not action. Tense can only be given to actions by definition. Tense refers to the time of an event/action.
On the other hand, in A-2, “when I will get home” is a noun clause expressing the action which needs a tense: future in this case.
In short, I think you understand how to use adverb clauses correctly.
It’s easy to just understand how Korea works.
“집에 도착하면” this has no tense so in English when I get home
“언제 집에 갈지” this has future(~할) tense so in English when I will get home
Thank you for the great questions.
Sorry I couldn’t elaborate further.
Yet, I’m not worried because I think you got this.
Thank you and have a great weekend.
명쾌한 설명입니다. 머릿속에 쏙쏙 들어왔어요.
Glad that the lesson was helpful
Hope you had fun
Thank you and have a productive day
good ^^
Thank you
Have a great day
I was studying English when you called last night.
I was exercising after work when you worked overtime.
He was eating dinner alone while she was taking a nap on the couch.
What was he doing while you were cooking lunch?
I was wondering if you could make some time for me this Friday.
I was hoping you could give me some advices about my son.
What was she doing while her baby was crying badly?
She was cleaning up my house all day thankfully while I was being away.
You were hanging out with your friends when I visited your house.
He was reading a book at the station when I got there.
What were your kids doing while you were trimming plants in the garden?
I was baking animal-shaped cookies for grandson while he was vacuuming.
I think you got the nuance
Great job
Thank you and have a nice day
I was talking to my teacher when the bell went off
I was talking with my teacher when the bell went off
With로 바꿔써도 되나요?
Thank you for your question
Yes you can use "talk with"
Talk to and talk with are used interchangeably with no big difference in meaning.
Thank you and have a great day