❤💜❤ मंटो साहब के पास मानव-मन को पढ़ने और समझने की जो सकत थी, वह शायद ही किसी अन्य लेखक के पास हो। उनका हर अफसाना चौका देता है और क्लाइमेक्स में जी धमक-चमक होती है, उसका तो कोई सानी ही नहीं।सौ-सौ सलाम मंटो साहब। कमल कपूर
Manto sahab great aapne jo halaat Aazadi ke kahaniya likhe hai wakiye bhut umda hai Alhamdulila kaash aaj ke waqt mai b aise writter hote and sayma you are the best
I'm 28 single, i also collect empty glass bottles of every kind and empty cigarette packs. It's so strange that this story coincides with my condition. So strange, I'm speechless!
In life we see different types of people.. Some have habits of rearing pets some of habit of being aloof moral- be friendly with everyone... So that we don't remain aloof
Ma'am, aap ki narration inn afsanO ko bohot jajjti hain. poora pas e manzar saamne aa jata hain. kamaal hain mantO Sahab k afsaananay aur aap k ye andaaz e bayaan.
"Whiski ka maza uski zaban aur taloo par theek nahi beth raha tha.. tumhari tabeeyat whiski ko qubool nahi kar rahi"............. WOW awesome literature.. kya ilfaz hain.. zabardast!
Hat's off you Saadat Hassan Manto saheb.. Vibe alone until you're valued;lost in the echoes of silence because "Life is like a box of chocolates; you never know what you'll get"..
jo log akele hote hai woh log pet aur chizo (samaan) ko ek insaan samaj ke sath rakhte hai. akhir me jis aurat se shadi ki woh bhi khali (bejaan) aurat thi, tab pet aur chizo ko koi jaroorat nahi hoti kyunki wo aurat in jaise hai.
Mujhy khali berten jama krny ki adat hy ... bowlzzz ... Ajeeb lag raha manto ki baat sun kr ... 😔 Or bilay palay hoye m ny ... Boht saray ... Sach m in k sath tanhai ka ehsaass kam hota .... 😔😔😔😔
For those who only "listen to" literature as opposed to reading it, this is heavily re/para-phrased and the original Urdu words and phrases have been replaced by clumsy, badly written alternatives ("iss baat ko *ley ker*".. it's just too rough and ugly for Manto). Also, it's dub'bay, not dibbey.
sunShine Well, we don't have to conjecture. The original short story starts as, "یہ حیرت مجهے اب بهی ہے کہ..." (Yeh hairet mujhay ub bhee hai keh...). And generally among native Urdu speakers, one would say 'main iss baat per hairaan hoon' instead of 'iss baat ko le ker hairaan hoon'. The latter is perhaps a chiefly Hindi expression, not sure.
AMULYA MISHRA . I never said I was "offended" (too strong a word). I only pointed out something that such "listeners" may not know or realise. And if I can't understand, say, Flaubert, I should read the translated version (which clearly says 'translation' on it) instead of making a shoddy substandard version of, say, Flaubert in supposedly 'simplified' French claiming to be original.
میں بھی ایک 26 سال کا کنوارا نوجوان ہوں میں بھی ایک نیکر پہن کر رہتا ہوں ، کتوں سے بےانتہا پیار ہے ، عورتوں سے اکتایا ہوا ، اور لوگوں سے ملنا جلنا پسند نہیں مجھ سے جب بھی کوئی ملنے آئے میں کوئی نا کوئی بہانا کر دیتا ہوں ۔۔ خالی بوتلیں اور خالی ڈبے جمع کرنے کی عادت ہے۔۔ جب بھی گھر میں کسی چیز کی بوتل یا ڈبا خالی ہوتا ہے اسے میں اپنے دراز میں جمع کر لیتا ہوں ۔۔ یہ کہانی سننے کے بعد میں حیران ہوں کہ 100 سال بعد بھی یہ کہانی انسانوں کی نفسیات پر پورا اتر رہی ہے اس کہانی نے میری پوری زندگی بیان کر دی ۔۔
Your voice and video quality is great but why do you change some of the difficult Urdu words or complex sentences. I understand changing them will make them easier for people to understand but it compromises the exotic and pure urdu manto's used, decreasing the quality of his work. Read word to word afsaane please.
Sadat Hasan Manto ke afsane phir uspe rj sayma ki awaz zabardast Mene 2-3 din Mai hi kitne hi Afsane sun liyee
Meny bhiii....awsome
Main ne bhi
❤💜❤ मंटो साहब के पास मानव-मन को पढ़ने और समझने की जो सकत थी, वह शायद ही किसी अन्य लेखक के पास हो। उनका हर अफसाना चौका देता है और क्लाइमेक्स में जी धमक-चमक होती है, उसका तो कोई सानी ही नहीं।सौ-सौ सलाम मंटो साहब।
कमल कपूर
Readers k liye ye ek khazane se kam nahi.. thank you Radio Mirchi....
Priya Kar gigj
Yes
Manto sahab great aapne jo halaat
Aazadi ke kahaniya likhe hai wakiye bhut umda hai Alhamdulila kaash aaj ke waqt mai b aise writter hote and sayma you are the best
The female voice is just amazing.every word and the pronunciation is just apt and making the story more interesting
RJ Shayema
Manto Saab was way ahead of his time 🙏🙏
❤💜❤ साइमा साहिबा का जादूई स्वर, दिलकश अंदाज-ए-बयां•••जैसे मंटो साहब की सोने सी कहानियों-में सुंदर सुगंध भर देता है।
कमल कपूर
Amaxing Man and he wrote nice stories....lovely
The suspense romance in manto sahab' story is jst aafreen🔥
I'm 28 single, i also collect empty glass bottles of every kind and empty cigarette packs. It's so strange that this story coincides with my condition. So strange, I'm speechless!
even my uncle do this..this practice has been going on for 100's of years i guess🤷♀️
Mujhe bilkul smjh nhi Aaya kiu
Kya mujhe smjha skte ho?
Kyun rkhty hain ap ye cheezain?
Koi wajah
@@muhammadehtesham6245 bs ek adat hai koe wja nhi.
@@faisaljaveedtv iski story ka khulasa kia hai yr..
Ye kaisi adat hai..
Smjh sy bahir jai
manto sb great narratior.......
waqi insan jca khud hota he wsa hi pasnd krta he 2 ne apny khali pan ka elaj ik dosry ma talash kr liya
Aapki aawaj me jaadu hai devi g. Aapko naman hai for such a lovely voice. 🙏
Itne achi kahani Maine aajtak nahi suni
In life we see different types of people.. Some have habits of rearing pets some of habit of being aloof moral- be friendly with everyone... So that we don't remain aloof
Manto ki kahania itne alag hai ki sunke maza a jata hai
Ma'am, aap ki narration inn afsanO ko bohot jajjti hain. poora pas e manzar saamne aa jata hain. kamaal hain mantO Sahab k afsaananay aur aap k ye andaaz e bayaan.
Bht khoob bhaee, iss female narrator ki aawaaz ma tou jadoo ha koe....
Very nice speechless hai kya kahu..... 🤐
Mam aapki awaaz bhut acchi hai,
Bhut zabardast!
Pleaz aik week me 2-3 afsany document kar día karen!
Great job
Ahmad Sohalil
Excellent....
Zabardassttt
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Khali pn ny dosray khali pnn ko bhar dia ho ....
Pr ab dar lag rha ...
Nai
Plzz
Allaah miyan g ..
Nhi .... 😔
Very good work, i just love it, great voice, excellent script
बेहतरीन अफसानों में से एक,,,, वाह वाह वाह वाह वाह वाह वाह वाह वाह ❤️❣️🌹
Thanks for uploading these...with such a beautiful voice and background music is awesome....every thing is great ...
It's really like a story forum, as we hear story from other person.
"Whiski ka maza uski zaban aur taloo par theek nahi beth raha tha.. tumhari tabeeyat whiski ko qubool nahi kar rahi"............. WOW awesome literature.. kya ilfaz hain.. zabardast!
Momina Khan asha ji?
Momina Khan hi
Urdu hain hi aisi zuban ke jisme lutf aiyen
Very good
LOVELY VOICE SAIMA so sweet
Manto jesa koi nahi
लाजवाब
thnxxxx MIRCHI
Plz roz uplod kr do zada nh sirf ak story rj saima ki. awaz ma plzzzzz irequest you
Loha lohe ko kat ta he thik wasehi ak khali pan ne dusre khalipan ko bhardia..nice story
Saima love your voice
Ham....or mujhe bahot psnd hai
Fabulous...
Hat's off you Saadat Hassan Manto saheb..
Vibe alone until you're valued;lost in the echoes of silence because "Life is like a box of chocolates; you never know what you'll get"..
Dis voice is amazing
Kon kon 2020 Manto ke afsaney sun raha hai
Main2😘😘😘
Aapki aawaz bahut bahot khoobsurat hai mashaallah ❤👌
Wah wah
ultimate work...
The voice is so amazing😘😘😘😘
That hint of degining probably the gay man of his time is subtle. The shift from rum to whisky explains it really well.
Best of all manto's creations .. 👏👏
bahut badiya...nyc voice..
Very nice story.....
Bht achy
Wow...
madam mjhe to laga tha ki sirf ladkian ko ye boltolen or dibe pasand he or ye ladke lo kabse pasand ane lage ☺️☺️☺️☺️☺️
Very Amazing story
Khallii dibaayyy .. 😔😔😔😔
Wonderful
Wooow!
Nice 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Rj Sayema💝🎧
Wah🌻
Khoobsurat
Nice story
Very nice
Zabardast
nice voice👌👌👌
Lol I do this too with glass jars, bottles, plastic containers and metal boxes etc.
So u r married or not???
It means that you are single
Super
Or video post kiya kijiye plzz
The main story was start at 8:28
🙄
Nope, it starts from the start
Is bnday ny arts ki jaga science rkhi hti to nobal prize zror milta...
Kmallikhty thy...
Tab aap or main ye khubsurat kahaniya nhi sun rhe hote...
Wahhh
Saba Mubashar hi
Nice voice r j shayma
Kitne baje aata h fm pr mantu ki kahani?
Awarapan, banzarapan...
Ek halaa hai seene mein...
Maine dil se kaha dhund Lana Khushi
Please explain the logic behind the story!what saadat hassan manto sahab want us to convey ?what result should i infer from ending.
Usman Ur Rehman ek insaan ka khaali pnn ek insaan he purra kr skta h
jo log akele hote hai woh log pet aur chizo (samaan) ko ek insaan samaj ke sath rakhte hai. akhir me jis aurat se shadi ki woh bhi khali (bejaan) aurat thi, tab pet aur chizo ko koi jaroorat nahi hoti kyunki wo aurat in jaise hai.
Moral of the story is depend on ur thinking...
Insaan ko hamesha insaan ki zarorat hoti hai jab woh nahi milta ya phir milti tou woh uss ka badal talash kartey phirtey hai...i think so
आप लोगो को सफ़सना कुछ समझ मे नही आया बिला वजह ही बोले ज रहें हो
खाली क मतलब क्या है कोई बताएगा
awsm
Nice
Kya BT ha
Veri.nece
Awaaz bahut mast ha ....
Ramswaroop = khali botley
Ram sawaroop
Apne azeez ke baare me ye kaise maloom ke wo saare kapde utaar ke tauliya bandhte Hain...tab nahane jate hain
Mujhy khali berten jama krny ki adat hy ... bowlzzz ...
Ajeeb lag raha manto ki baat sun kr ... 😔
Or bilay palay hoye m ny ...
Boht saray ...
Sach m in k sath tanhai ka ehsaass kam hota .... 😔😔😔😔
film ke r hiroine zinat aman lag rhi he
For those who only "listen to" literature as opposed to reading it, this is heavily re/para-phrased and the original Urdu words and phrases have been replaced by clumsy, badly written alternatives ("iss baat ko *ley ker*".. it's just too rough and ugly for Manto).
Also, it's dub'bay, not dibbey.
Abubakar Mehmood what would Manto have written instead of "is bat ko *le kar*"
sunShine Well, we don't have to conjecture. The original short story starts as,
"یہ حیرت مجهے اب بهی ہے کہ..."
(Yeh hairet mujhay ub bhee hai keh...).
And generally among native Urdu speakers, one would say 'main iss baat per hairaan hoon' instead of 'iss baat ko le ker hairaan hoon'. The latter is perhaps a chiefly Hindi expression, not sure.
Abubakar Mehmood oh right. Thanks a lot for the information. This would be another reason to start reading urdu literature.
Not all listeners would be able to understand Urdu expressions that's why to make it easier, she has simplified it
Nothing to get offended
AMULYA MISHRA . I never said I was "offended" (too strong a word). I only pointed out something that such "listeners" may not know or realise.
And if I can't understand, say, Flaubert, I should read the translated version (which clearly says 'translation' on it) instead of making a shoddy substandard version of, say, Flaubert in supposedly 'simplified' French claiming to be original.
😏😏😏😏😏😏😏
leemin Sultana
Chunachu kya hai
ashish kumar Singh chunancha means thats why
Therefore
isiliye
Is story ka maqsad kia tha?
میں بھی ایک 26 سال کا کنوارا نوجوان ہوں میں بھی ایک نیکر پہن کر رہتا ہوں ، کتوں سے بےانتہا پیار ہے ، عورتوں سے اکتایا ہوا ، اور لوگوں سے ملنا جلنا پسند نہیں مجھ سے جب بھی کوئی ملنے آئے میں کوئی نا کوئی بہانا کر دیتا ہوں ۔۔ خالی بوتلیں اور خالی ڈبے جمع کرنے کی عادت ہے۔۔ جب بھی گھر میں کسی چیز کی بوتل یا ڈبا خالی ہوتا ہے اسے میں اپنے دراز میں جمع کر لیتا ہوں ۔۔ یہ کہانی سننے کے بعد میں حیران ہوں کہ 100 سال بعد بھی یہ کہانی انسانوں کی نفسیات پر پورا اتر رہی ہے اس کہانی نے میری پوری زندگی بیان کر دی ۔۔
Your voice and video quality is great but why do you change some of the difficult Urdu words or complex sentences. I understand changing them will make them easier for people to understand but it compromises the exotic and pure urdu manto's used, decreasing the quality of his work. Read word to word afsaane please.
Yah kahani mujy mara sa link ha. Mara koibbe relation nai. Or na he koi rista hota ha. Nasab ki baat ha. I am curse with loneliest
G.
G ???
Iski recording ke waqt shayad apko sardi thi...
Kya baat hai😊
Yai katay
Khilafat NH
Mukhalifat
Mukhalifat means opposition
Khilafat means caliphate
Bottle and dibe wale room main Apni wife ko band kar dega🤣🤣🤣🤣ya nikkar pehn kar apni bibi ke sath khelega🤣🤣🤣kya soch hai
Mujy k6 smj nhi iii
Rj sayema ko zukham ho gya hai aaj shayad ..
😁😁
ye sary hazrat GAY thy hahahaha
Haha. I was expecting such type of commit from anyone.
@@cssquiz343 do u disagree with his comment?
Samajh nahi aaya
😯😯😯😯😯
Aaj se lag bhag das saal bad dobara sunye ga. Shaid zindagi k talkh tajruby ap ko yeh smjha saken
Oooor ooo sanki mard may hu
Bakvas Koi sens Ni tha kehna or karna kya chahate ho
komal chouriya kyu k ab tumne yahn apni jahiliyet ka saboot dediya hai to ab kahin or ja kar maro idr kyu aye ho