Judge announces verdict in Andre McDonald trial
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 фев 2023
- Andre McDonald and his attorneys wait for the judge to read the jury's verdict. McDonald was found guilty on a lesser charge of manslaughter in connection with the death of his wife in 2019.
More on this story here: www.ksat.com/news/local/2023/...
How is he not guilty of murder? It’s one of the most gruesome cold blooded killings I’ve heard. Wow. Just wow.
She attacked him , he shouldn't be guilty of anything
Although he mutilated her body he is found not guilty in count 1, he even burn her body damn,that's anger
Justified anger. It warms my heart that he essentially got away with murder.
Karma to those who failed her.
And karma to those who encourage them.
KARMA TO HER FAMILY, THEY LIVED IN HIS HOUSE SO THEY MUST HAVE KNOWN THE WIFE WAS ABUSING THAT MAN, THEY SHOULD TRY SPEAKING TO HER TO STOP CHEATING ON THE GOOD HUSBAND SHE GOT, THEY PUSHED HIM TO WHAT HAPPENED, SHE WAS EVIL, I AM A WOMAN BUT SHE DID THAT MAN WRONG, I LISTEN THE EVIDENCE
@@annreed1084 stop saying this all the gold digger will come at you like white on rice I said the same thing many women will engage in a relationship knowingly that they are only their for the money they don't have any love towards that person who they're using and sadly this is the result and will continue to be because they don't care.
@@annreed1084 , maybe you one day will run into this same kind of demon! Good luck!
@@tatlinehoward4106 , I hope you find yourself this same kind of good man! Good luck!
The Lord is going to hold him and the full court system accountable
Naah. If he repents, he & the Lord will be tight🤞
@@jamiedavid8023 IF
If I could hold you and hug you. You are so right. All of them going to feel the wrath of God. Wait
@@mamanicks937 hugs right back at you☺️
What Lord 😂😂
Manslaughter is killing a person without malice or intent. However he can be given the maximum penalty of life imprisonment or he can serve some years. After such a graphic description of what he did I wonder why they came up with manslaughter. Smh
This is spooky🤔🤔😡😡
She didn't love him, she only used him for a green card to get to America.because she was in love with another man. I think he loved her very much you could see it in their pictures.
Exactly. The intention was more than clear. He murdered her and tried to conceal his crime by mutilating her body. He had no problem remembering all his steps. So how much do we remember something when done in the spare of a moment. He must have planned it all. With all his military training, her carrying him on her back meant nothing, they were just playing. He's a coward.
He is in the military....
Money, sift on crime policy we can thank George soris Barack Obama on his Marxist ideology
For someone to listen to how he smashed her head in, then turn to her face and smash her face and how he planned to dispose of her body and said this guy doesn't deserve the death penalty is simply the reason the murder rate is skyrocketing, Criminals aren't being punished for their crimes, Lawyers uses loopholes while the prosecutions sit like a dear in a headlight
Wow you are dark. Step into the sunlight once in a while. See what emotions made this guy do!?
It may sound hypothetical to say,he should have killed his wife but we cannot judge this man. Not one of us lived in their environment and when people are under severe strain and manipulation, keeping all the pressures that family life and the world brings, anyone can snap.
I just feel very sad about the whole situation and especially for their young child and the entire families.
Such a sad case!
Peace ✌️, Love, Blessings and Nuff respect to all connected in this situation.
Jah, Jah!
@@paulineboothe9982 His problem is happening all over the world daily, If everyone reacts the way he did we are in serious trouble, what we heard is a well-planned story by his defense, imagine for a minute you witnessing the murder step by step according to him, we now know where those anger came from , Father a double murder and the son follow
@@jamiedavid8023 imagine if women start k!lling men becos we are emotional, guess how many men will be gone
@@maameabena1458 yall do
This is San Antonio. They love their military and they love to look down on wives who aren’t submissive. The lawyers did a good job knowing who they were playing to and having him describe how upset he was because of the cheating. This says more about the jury and San Antonio.
Submissive my azz. That outdated mentality needs to be up out of here. You don't submit to an adult when you are an adult. It's stupid.
Good.
Unbelievable! Our justice system is horrible.
Remember this when voting.
Atrocious
How? It was a jury trial. The jury decided it. Not the judge
The JURY has spoken*
@@fartgangtv9143 🤭🎯
losing faith in the justice system.
😳Just now❓️🥴
@@deonnatrice5931 lol
It is so bizarre that his father (Beachy Stout) is on trial in Jamaica 🇯🇲 for ordering the murder of his two wives several years apart.
Are you sure its his dad..his surname is "Mcdonald",, and as you stated the father's surname is "Stout"
@@Oldlegends618 His father’s real name is Everton McDonald. Beachy Stout is just a nickname.
@@Oldlegends618 Beachy Stout is his pseudo
@@Oldlegends618 like father like son
Like father like son who fi tel if she's the first he murder
The ppl on his jury should be publicly shamed. I’m disgusted that the judge thanked them . They’ve done the world a disservice
He showed zero remorse & it was intentional. Guilty murder! F’n jury is heinous.
I am puzzled what the hell? How did he get the lesser charge? Those are mighty good lawyers because that’s very very very rare. Just sickening
Yes because it was because he was extremely honest.. and he felt as though everybody would agree with his wife's behavior that anybody could just kill someone for getting a tattoo of another man's birth date
Because it was a crime of passion he didn’t pre plan it
Whenever you put 12 randos on a jury you’re gonna sometimes have a bunch of persuasive idiots on the jury. That’s just the reality of a jury system.
Hes innocent
What's wrong with the judicial system in our country???
He will rot in prison he not getting over
Special Intetest GrOUPS, soft on crime policy. Barack Obama, George Soros. MARXIST IDEALOGY. CITIZENS NEED TO TAKE BACK THEIR COURTS.
Truly disgusting! He literally got away with MURDER. May the remainder of his life still be CURSED!
You lot needs to listen the case good
She done too much to this giy this girls need to stop playing with them man and still having gun man dictating their lives
All he has to do ask God for forgiveness,he is the real judge of man n he forgives.
This boy deserves death penalty!!! He’s a murderer no matter what jury says !!!
@@islanfoodz4132 You know it either they don't know story or they don't care.Not one member of her family had anything bad to say about this man.He intended on murdering his wife he out would not have done it that way.I can tell you that.I know he curses the day he met that demon .
His own testimony did him in. He has no remorse
I disagree. Otherwise he would have been found guilty of murder not manslaughter. What a disgrace the justice system is.
@@dawnatkinson7704 the jury decided it
@@dawnatkinson7704e went to that park to make sure she was sleepy or caught off guard. He pre-meditated this heinous crime. Painted her to be so strong and she could lift 280lbs. But could not prevent him smaller frame from what he did. She was like a MMA fighter and he was much smaller than her. BW are being murdered every 4.5 hrs by BM. Black femicide is on the rise. His punishment does not fit the crime.
This is disgusting. You can put a hammer through someone's head and you'll be not guilty of murder? This is SICK
Imagine the police did all those investigations, went through weeks of searching, the skillet admitting the inhumane things he did to wife after an elaborate description of how he killed her only for this JURY to this! My goodness! What is wrong with these people?????
What an arrogant man!
I thought he showed no remorse or was arrogant in the way he testified about the fight, her death and his actions of not being guilty. However, I also thing that's what his lawyers prepared him to do. It also sounded rehearsed.
His father is on murder trial in Jamaica for ordering hits on his two wives, years apart. It runs in the family.
The fact that he confessed to going back to her dead, buried body to attack her some more and the jury still found him not guilty of murder is sickening
Justice NOT served. I cannot stand his smug face.
Justice was served bc the jury decided it
@@JB-mb6lm Thank you for expressing YOUR opinion. Mine differs. A jury doesn’t always get the verdict correct.
@Hot Mess that's true. But it's your opinion that the jury didn't get it correct. He does need to be in jail but I can see someone being pushed to do it.
@@JB-mb6lm Of course it is MY opinion. That is why I said ‘mine differs”. I would concede that someone could be “pushed” but not what he did with the body afterwards. Desecrating a human corpse is not something one is ‘pushed’ to doing.
@@hotmess1971 I agree with you on that
Like seriously manslaughter this man sitting down like nothing happened is father here in Jamaica for death of his two wives this man shouldn’t see the light of day again
2 wifes?
@@tommas2674, yes two wives! Then it is ALLEGED that there are more people.
and one piece of moldy bread quickly spoils all.
@@beescraftycorner4491 he is a serial killer. bet they didn't allow that in this hearing But it should be. demonstrates serial killer...
Like father like son.resident evil 👿
Well played, he didn’t getaway with it but he definitely influenced the jury. The crazy thing was is that he planned everything down to beating her with the hammer to disguise how heinous her initial attack was. Crazy case.
How did he influence the jury ? 🤔
I’m shocked 😮. He’s showed absolutely no remorse!
Lmfao why would he? A witch dying is always a joyful day.
Looks like he fooled the jury just like he must have fooled his wife into getting with him. May she rest in peace and lord let the public see right through him.
To all of you who are Gold digger , you will all ena up like her
@@i-risesi2040 you're about the stupidest...lol
Don't speak of what you don't know
@@i-risesi2040 Amen to that they all better wake up people are wising up and if you play games you will win deadly game
The jury just wasn't blinded by emotions like you.
I am an AirForce Veteran and this is embarrassing, cruel and shows alot about the court system there. Crazy Virginia would have ensured he got murder period! This is heartbreaking to hear. I bet he is smiling & happy as a narcissist would. There is no excuse for this.
The jury he will have to answer to is our mighty God
The jury did what they were assigned to do. The murderer is the one who will “ have to answer to our mighty God. Remember…… God’s words …. thou shall NOT kill !
Also the one that provoke it
@@tatlinehoward4106 well , if you can base your opinion based on the words of a murderer. Says a lot.
@@carolreid7875 And you continue to encourage gold digger that says a lot many more will end up just like her and I hope if you have any father son, brother are any other men with your DNA you say the same thing.
@@tatlinehoward4106 Well , you should stop your misinterpretation of what I said.
What did I say that is encouraging gold digger ? Hope you don’t have a mother, sister, aunt , niece,cousin who gets involved with someone like that killer . Would be interesting if you still hold your opinion.
He killed his wife the mother of his child what man do that he is a murder
His father did the same thing in Jamaica for years ago he killed is to wife is also in jail waiting trial the justice system has failed us once more if you have a conscience God help him he is going to rot in hell for what he did to this woman and his child
And to see his father here under trial for similar offence is heart rending.
Father like son!
In the bloodline
Wow! That’s insane
His dad was something else. He killed 2 wives. I wonder if his father's first wife was Andre's mother.
@@woodswal rawse, is that Beach Stout's son?
He just wasted his life for nothing
I know right. He was hurt; but he could have just divorced her. There is no excuse for killing someone. He is going to lose everything. 🤷🏾
I think there is a need for countries that use the Jury Judicial System to educate the general masses on the ingredients or what constitutes an act as a crime especially the element of Mens Rea(Mental state of the suspect at the time of committing the act. What was his or intention and the various ways through which this intention can be construed/ determined for example,weapon used,was it a lethal or non lethal weapon, was the force of the weapon commensurate to the amount of force being used by the victim (one can't use a gun to defend themselves against fist punch). Which Part of the body was attacked can also be another way of knowing what the intentions were, an attack on any part waist up is intended to cause serious bodily injury that can easily lead to death as opposed to attacking the legs which usually means rendering the attacker weaker by reducing his mobility.
Local ordinary people don't understand thes principles and so they may not be able to construe them. They may be looking for a direct recording of the accused saying,I am killing you today which in most cases is not there and so they end up translating the lack off as lack of intention to cause death. This guy admitted cause serious bodily injuries to his wife,smashing her face like a wild animal yet here we are, Not guild of Murder. Guilty of Manslaughter means he did not have the intentions of killing his wife when he did all of those inhumane, disgusting and beastly things. In other words ,he was just scaring her and she got so scared and died!!
You would think Casey Anthony was the last time we would see this kind of injustices but Nope!! Still a long way to go!!
May his wife rest in peace and may the death penalty be served upon him in another way!!
What is this verdict! Not guilty of murder but of manlaughter???? So isn't she dead by this man hands still, this is MURDER with premeditation! Justice needs to serve well like a good plate of belly full meal without parole or electric chair, wickedness leaving the poor kids motherless, my god!!
He got off lightly, Hope his father gets the full blunt. They have a bad blood running through their veins which makes them no respecter of women.(smh)
Foolishness your talking the woman plot to kill the guy and she done too much trust me you guhs need to stop promoting woman to do wrong
You're right. He will do it again. Mark my words, smh.
Manslaughter??? SMH
He should doing life in prison. The fact that he isn’t shows how time and time again the “justice system “ fails
Can only hope for prison justice. This jury failed us.
You really don't know how the law works! what else was there to charge him with?
He didn't leave court to go HOME when it was over. WTF 😕
@@hooligan7006 🎯
As a Jamaican am sad for both of them
"WALW AWAY"
This guy deserved more. He’s horrible. May his wife rest in peace.
Lmfao y’all funny as hell
Karma will come for him. Anybody remember OJ?
OJ is living a great life! More so he was found NOT guilty by a Jury of his peers.
OJ. I never seen a man so free 🥂
Incredible.
Wow!
You should have never withdrew the Divorce the first time. If you hadn't, you could have taken half and rebuild your life. Met her, married took her from Jamaica, filed for her, so she could get a better life and she played you. You snapped, killed her, now your daughter has no parents for atleast the next 20 yrs. There is a lesson here, you should have married a woman here and not sacrifice for such an ungrateful woman. You killed her and now your life is ruined forever.
1. He did his daughter a favor. 2. He will be in prison for less than 10 years. LOL @ “20 years.”
So father going to charge for the same thing too????
like father like son , the father killed 2
@@maninthevan53 and this one will kill again
Father already convicted & in prison
@@carolreid7875 he did kill 2 maybe he wants to kill 1 more to be like his dad
@@jacquelinegrayden4706 It is in his DNA
He is smirking
Me too 😏
Wtf!!!
Wait, What.. Really?
Exactly what I said 🤦♀️
Best argument for Andreen I’ve seen.
Just like in Jamaica his father killed his ex-wives and got away with it. Because they have money. Like father like son.
His 2 wives, they weren't exes. He killed the first, then married the second.
In what state did this trial take place?
Texas
This is why I keep to myself as much as possible. They will set a murderer free, but give a j- walker a life sentence (figure of speech)🤕🤦🏽
I'm sure if it was Tax evasion they'd would have thrown the book at him 😢
Judge Franco are you proud of what you did it looks so you are smiling but our God is mighty 🙏
Woww this is shameless that is why killers of today don't give a damn, prosecutors in this country is a total sell out, the way this man describe how he murdered his wife is something out a movie, and all he get is twenty years where he can still enjoy free meals, exercise have family members visit him, but the victim the only thing her family can do is visit her grave, is this really fair this is one case that deserves the death penalty..
How can you stand with your hands in your pocket in front of a judge in court is that honorable
Not guilty? I’m going to watch his testimony in it’s entirety now
Yes they got it wrong! At least he’ll be looking at 15-20 years I believe!
Some justice for Andreen and her daughter 💕💕
Killing her was no right but what she was planning on doing to this man and got a known criminal in another country helping to come here to reck more destruction. I stand with the verdict. Hopefully dude gets 5 yrs max. That girl was too evil.
I told you Sheri!! Andre is a good man i went to school with him
@@albertgonzalez9179 lol Albert this means nothing of him being a good man…period!
Nobody knows she was trying to have him killed, GTHOH with crap that he said. Her sister or anyone. Still never happened, he’s still guilty and he’ll forever be a heinous evil
Murderer
He better hide when ge gets out the guy with the tattoos is coming after him
Absolute joke another failure by our lovely justice system. This guy should never walk free again.
Am so sorry for the young man
I’m not “Am”
Manslaughter seems pretty light for all he did.
I watched this trial and was stunned in the verdict. The defendant took the stand and was very arrogant but there were comments complimenting him. He describes what he did to her coldly. Did not just react in anger and hit her a few times and that led to her death. No, it took awhile and he was very violent and tells what he did with no feeling. He had to incapacitate her first then decide to murder. He thinks did nothing wrong!! The victim may have been hiding money from him and it seemed as many thought he had a right to kill her!! Shocking. So if find victim had flaws, or don’t like personality, it is justification for murder? Wonder if would feel same if it was their daughter. Killed her in the house with their child there!! Then left that child alone while he moved her mothers dead body, mutilated the body. He talks about how he striped her because it was a very stressful situation. WTF? Poor Andre so stressful murder is so stress leads to exposing the mother of his child to demean her. Says hit her with hammer because hitting the person who caused it. It WAS her fault. He says it on stand with fervor. It’s crazy. His lawyer stated Andreen spit in his face and have right to meet with equal force. Beating and murdering is equal to spitting? I also have memory of Andreen mother not seeming as if loved, or even liked her daughter. It was mind blowing. May be just the way she expresses, or lack of, herself. It was obviously first degree murder IMO. He had time to decide to stop while beating her, then time to decide not to do more and kill her. He was still angry and when dumped her body he kicked, and I think hit her with hammer (that info came from the defendant himself). So this man gets up tells how he brutally murdered his wife with child in the home and states she was to blame. But some how this jury found him not guilty of murder!! I don’t like criticizing a jury. Feel mostly try their best and want to do the right and just thing. I can not comprehend this verdict. This arrogant, violent, remorseless man is basically told they agree. Poor Andre, appears she was hiding money so that betrayal justifies your actions. It wasn’t even as if he got on stand and through tears of regret states just lost his mind for a moment. I have to stop typing as I can not wrap my mind around it, can not articulate how awful this man was and will never comprehend how jury came to their verdict. He will be out of jail in short time and will just have to hope he only kills some one these twelve think deserved it.
What the hell. Sometimes I wonder how the justice system works.
Wow. Sheriff gave cuffs to her father😏
The defense got the naive gullable jury of their dreams.
OMG can’t watch this or him anymore. 😢
Humans will do what they think is their best, but God Almighty is the greatest judge. At the appropriate time, he will make bare his judgement.
The LORD knows best.
This is what evil looks like.
Why did he get charged with abuse of a corpse?
This man is going to be tormented for the rest of his life
Unbelievable but I’m not surprised.
How did the prosecution lose this case??????
Jurors watch too many crime shows and expect too much physical evidence. And are easily confused by attorneys.
@@SS11660 I understand what you are saying
I think the testimonies given by Andreen’s mother and sister may have played a role to the lesser charge.
@@SS11660 her family's testimonies did not make it better for her to get justice. If anything, it helped him
@@Shalom491 What were the testimonies by Andreen's mother and sister?
SMH!
Pumping my fist in victory
His wife was a nightmare it sounded like- but murder is not acceptable! Divorce and move on. He killed her in an angry rage 😡 thinking only of himself and not his precious daughter. MOVE ON, regardless of what one does. “Pray for your enemies, do good to those who abuse you. “ That is God’s command! And it serves us best to obey him!!
I knew it
It's sick to the stomach watching this. For a crime as gruesome as this, ho w do u not get a life sentence or death. Wow the justice is really not for the innocent but it is for the guilty.
I literally cheered as I heard the “ it guilty” verdict.
please somebody tell me where andre mc Donald from
He is from Jamaica, but has been living in. The states for a.good while.
@@normacolon9618 thanks miss Norma colon andre colon his a pure evil may almighty God reserve his place because the lady was a bright future for the family 👪 God bless the family 👪 I from haiti I have 6 daughter I give birth in miami I don't want no mother bury their children like that it's so sad
He sits with not a care in the world,my God!
He did have a horrible wife
Wow! Them without capital get capital punishment some DR inmate said that and here it is....
Go bless baby girl
Beating her with a 🔨 in front of y'all kid smh
That was after he dumped her body. The kid was at home.
I felt sorry for you buddy but always think 🤔 before you act, don't have your cake 🍰 and eat it, you have done the crime 😉 it's so face 😈 the time
Why feel sorry for him, when he killed someone ?
He defended him self against
Amazon woman 5' 11"
Working out and displaying how strong she was against
Medium size man...5' 9"
Empire built - stolen by Greedy wife.
Adulterous ho...didn't want divorce to split Empire..
@@irie256 The jury has spoken ! Dead man ( in this case, woman) tell no tales !
Of course, he will portray her as the violent one & he has always been the victim. But , an Army Major is not going to,be victimized. So he said she was stealing from him. Pay back for him is killing her. Maybe she was trying to get something in her name, so she can get away from him & not be dependent on him. Justice will be ,life without possibility of parole.
His father killed two wives and this murderer has a lot of enablers that don't think what he did was wrong. I hope he gets what he deserves.
@Carol Reid she was making much more than him. Lets not get carried away because of his job description. I know all well about these kind of sociopath and narcissist. One claim to give me half million. When he was homeless, people ignorant and stupid think these people make money. LOL. They have benefits. She's the one that was making the money.
He only got 7 1/2 years.
Like father like son
The auntie is a very good witness!.
Those jurors were wrong this is sickening.
Hardly. I feel exactly the opposite way.
While on bail, he had the opportunity to dip back to Jamaica and hide in the mountains with the Maroons, but he was thinking that a prison cell was much better than his homeland... SMH
Sad commentary in our times. How is this possible?
NO REMORSE at all,,, he was so dam jealous of her,,,,,
Her poor father
@0:53 ~ Don’t ask me why, but I thought the defendant was the white guy that’s third from the left when I looked at the thumbnail. The thumbnail is basically the view at this timestamp I listed.
But obviously my brain kind of had a glitch because i’m pretty sure the name “Andre“ is much more likely to be a black guy’s name in white guy’s name. Especially an old white guys name. It’s funny how sometimes your mind jumps to a conclusion that isn’t necessarily logical.
this man is evil after killing her he went back and beat her with a hammer and tried to burn her. this jury SMH!
Waiting for the movie.
He didnt bother to wear a tie as he knows he is going straight to prison. Like father like son. My gosh just walk away.
How many years wil he get, 10 to 20
Not life in prison?
Andre the GOAT!!!! 🐐🐐🐐
Like father like son..... MURDERERS
He will not last long tell the family to keep praying for him and the lawyer s the judge your God will deal with it he will have acouncusion
All who failed her have karma coming there way ,pray for her and her daughter, let him rot before burning in hell
Wtf is Going On In The World 😡