How about that f16 long exposure timelapse to kick this one off? Also interested to know your take on the new system here. I'm happy with the glass and colour/image quality. Not so happy with the frames but I do really like the notch adjustment system. I'm torn, like Natalie Imbruglia.
Greg. I'm an ambassador for Benro over here in France. Like you I wasn't sure about the frames. However, did you know that Benro do another filter holder?
I sometimes wonder if these companies have an actual Photographer on their design team. I just don't understand why the filter and frame can't be one piece. Also why can't the polarizer be a segmented square that would change polarity as you raise and lower it, then there wouldn't be a need for removing to spin it. I love to bring order out of chaos so feel free to let Benro know I'd be happy to share my ideas. Begginer as they might be. BTW I'm also like Natalie Imbruglia, I wish I was there.
@@DavidSenteno it's not really my place to say too much. I personally prefer the other filter holder that Benro offer but have been told that other photographers like the one that Greg has. I do have it but it's not ideal for me. I have actually spoken to Benro about it and they are very receptive as a company to ideas unlike certain more well known filter companies out there. That is a good thing! With regards to companies employing photographers. That I have to wonder with companies. I spoke to a backpack company earlier this year whose speciality is photography backpacks. I explained to them that although the actual photography bag was near perfect for a travel photographer it was let down by the pocket that holds the laptop. That it was extremely thin and offered little to no protection. Which is completely daft! And they have a number of well known photographers as ambassadors which makes me wonder just how involved they are.
@@JulianElliottPhotography Hey Julian thanks for the response. I hope I didn't come across as angry. I was just expressing my thoughts. I'm glad to hear Benro is listening. Maybe someone will read these comments and we will see a change. Of course if someone made a perfect filter system then that would limit the number of filter system review videos that could be done. Wait!....It's a conspiracy!...lol. Peace.
David Senteno no, you definitely didn’t come across as angry! I think, personally, we have a right to express an opinion when we are putting our money and time into products. What you hope is that things get noticed and acted upon.
Hi, Benro UK here 😊 We have watched Greg's video and here are some comments from the UK brand manager. Firstly the bag, the bag we would like to have supplied was out of stock so we supplied a bag for a larger system, but there is a bag designed to hold the 100x150mm filters whilst in their frames. Then regarding the filter holder. We receive a mix of feedback - some love the frame and gearing system, others love the traditional style holder. No one is right or wrong, you use what you prefer. If you don’t like the system with frames and gearing, we offer a traditional filter holder where you manually adjust your filter level and it uses no frames. Greg’s comments about the framed filters not fitting in the filter wallets is something that has been noted and we will investigate making the wallets large enough to take a framed filter - the idea of the system is that you load the filters into the frames and you leave them there, so being able to protect them still in the frame is important. And what was the reason for the frames - the concept was to provide the photographer with the ability to have control over the height positioning of the grad filter in the mount which is driven by the gearing mechanism in the holder but to make that work you need the frame with the notched edge. The frame does also help protect the filter and it means when you handle it, you can hold the frame edge rather than the actual filter. Comments about the CPL being fiddly to load. This is something we’re already looking to fix and we have prototype units out being tested that make the process of loading and unloading the CPL much simpler and less fiddly. Finally, we are listening 👍 Feedback from all our customers is noted and shared with the Benro R&D team and if that feedback can be implemented to improve a product then Benro will consider it.
Benro UK in the house!! Nice to see such a detailed & honest response. I'm happy to know your R&D team are taking these points into consideration. Having a smaller bag with felt dividers would be a great fix for two of my current issues. I'll order that asap. I actually really like the idea of the frames, you're right they offer good protection to the glass and being able to adjust the height positioning in the mount with the gearing mechanism is an awesome development. The CPL is something I need more experience actually using in the field, but yes a new prototype would be nice to see in the future for sure. GREAT to see your presence here and the detailed comment. This is the sign of an positively engaged brand.
Just bought the system, so still learning about it. But not being able to slot the framed filters back into the lovely felt bags is v irritating. And, bad for you, it has discouraged me from buying additional frames, as I can't then store them easily in the pouches.
In the last two years some new or improved systems appeared on the market but none of them is perfect. If you take all these reviews you might be able to create a perfect filter system. But even this would not suit everybody because there are many different requirements (portability, use in rough environment, price...). I will stay with my Rollei system... Thanks for the wonderful b-roll material around the filters 😁👍🏼
I have a smaller filterbag from Benro, and it often ends up in my camerabag. The filterholder is ok, but placing the polariser is a bit slowly, and turning the filter make some noice - like turning a filter on a lens. Having the filters in the frames is to me part of the reason to get them. It makes them easy to hold and do protect the glass from fingerprints and dirt - and the filterframes can not drop out off the filterholder by accident. I have used the system for a year, and find that it works for me, but when not knowing other systems it is imposible to say if the filters are realy good or just ok compared to others.
Interesting, I like the adjustment knobs on the Benro filter holder. I currently use the Nisi V5 filter system and I've been happy with it. I also use the Mindshift gear filter hive, which I've also been pretty happy with, to carry the filters in my backpack. Thanks for your candid review. As I've mentioned to you before, overall I like and use other Benro products. Safe journeys!
In terms of size and weight check out the Kase filter system. The filter holder is small and lightweight. The filters themselves are nice and have little if any colour cast. I moved from Lee and don't regret the move away. Very pleased with Kase.
Cool and honest. Nice buddy, I like the idea of the adjustment knobs but the frames look like the need some work before they are there. And the new Lee systems has a very easy pop on/off polarizer filter which is pretty cool. Cheers che, see you around.
The frames are what make the system for me. You don't have to touch the filters with dirty fingers on the field, and they are (kind of) protected (a little bit more than naked filter). It seems that your main problem was the bag and the way they are stored ? would using a compartimented filter pouch be an option ? or find slightly larger individual felt pouches ? I always disliked the protruding polarizer on the lee system, especially on shots where you don't want to use ND filters (in which case light leaks like crazy). It also forces you to buy a much larger polarizer. But on the other hand, attaching/removing the polarizer with this system seems finnicky aswell ... maybe if it could be attached from the lens side, instead of under the square filters ? or maybe the easiest solution would be to have 2 holders, one with the polarizer and one without, wich is not a great solution either. Thanks for the honest review though, and for the great content you provide here and on BvS's and T.Heat's channels !
I have this system with an upgraded filter holder that is really annoying. It now has a spring loaded button next to the red dial that moves the filters up and down in the holder. In order to turn the dial, the spring loaded button has to be pushed in, a totally unnecessary addition that now requires using two hands instead of one. I resorted to cutting off the spring and gluing the button in. The system itself is fantastic and the filter holders are brilliant, reducing the need to touch the glass and you can make accurate adjustments very easily. I haven't noticed any colour casts at all when using the glass filters but I don't know about the resin ones as I don't own any. The polariser is excellent quality. The smaller filter bag is compact and excellent and I leave the filters in the frames and they fit in the small bag. I don't see the point of removing them from the frame.
I am using Formatt Hittech Firecrest holder and from what I see from your video, is is even slower to use compared to Benro one. I have no experience with filter system which has filter frames but I wanted to try something like that because I assume that it should have as good protection against light leaks as my current one but more convenient. Formatt has extra peaces of plastic inserts which I have to change depending on the type of the filters I would use every time I am out shooting which is a lot of hustle. I think the first system which had filter frames was Wine Country Camera, but it is very expensive and bulky. It is good that we have other variants of such approach on the market now.
Greg the main complaint of people with Lee Filters were centered around the flimsy plastic holder and the it's price. I solved that issue using a Zioti holder and rings (a fraction of the price of the Lee's). All filters in my are Lee, but I saved a ton of money on the foundation kit! My only issue has been when shooting @ 16mm since the polarizer ring (105mm) creates a vignetting effect. Other than that, I'm happy with the setup! Like you, I love some of the features of the Benro system. It looks very clever and handy. But I would probably be as frustrated as you with the extra space it will take in my bag. Excellent review and better pictures!
Some beautiful long exposure photos . You might be interested in the new Kase filter system. They have a good solution for the polarizer (magnetic connection) and filters slide in like the Lee system.
I watched the next video you linked to as well regarding the Benro filters. It looks like you can adjust the polarizing filter from nearest the lens easily... just not remove it quite as easily. The bag space may not be as much of an issue for those of us with non-nomadic lifestyles. Guess you could use your other filter pouch. Thanks for the info. Much appreciated.
Yeah these are minimal issues really, it's only from experience of changing filters in crummy conditions and limited time that I could foresee more potential complications. Overall though I do really like the system and have been still using it. Just need to get the divider pouch.
Those are some amazing images! The Benro filters did a great job! Other than a UV filter, I actually don't own any filters right now, but I'm considering on getting some in the near future. The Lee filters sound like they might be great for newcomers with filters. Awesome footage! I'm looking forward to seeing you in Bali in a few days!
I have the opposite feeling than you and really like to keep the filters in the frame. My bag is smaller and easier to travel with. But as you I have not used the CPL in holder but connect to the lens before I put the ring on. Make it more easy to put on and off. A solution is to have 2 holders and just change them and slide the filters in.
Hi Arnfinn, that's a great idea regarding the CPL on the ring beforehand. Does the FH100M2 holder then fit over it...? I'll try it today and see :) Thanks for the great comment.
Mad props for your honesty, Greg. Looks like the filters did the job on the long exposures...nice! Also some great shots at the end of the vid. You might want to search on the online camera stores (B&H, Adorama, etc.) for "Lee filter wrap", and check out the one that holds 3 filters. I have one of those and it seems like there might be enough play to allow you to hold the filters in their frames. Could be a cheap alternative to what you're doing. If you're shooting with T.Heat anytime soon, I think that I noticed in a vid that he has his filters in one of these so you might be able to check out his to see if it would work for you. Cheers!
Benro does have an interesting system for sure, for me I have been using the Wine Country Camera systems which also uses frames so that one does not have to touch filter and the frames take pretty much any standard 100 X 100 or the Grad in 100 X 150. In addition they have the polarizer with a simple knob that set as the first filter in the system to the lens which can be easily removed. My favorite part is for the grad filter (2nd and 3rd slot) usage, they have a simple button that allows for easy adjustment and placement.Not sure but I think Benro and some other may have picked up some of the features that WCC started with. Regardless be very happy with Benro product and my heavy tripod is a Benro and it is a killer and great. All said though for filter system I love my Wine Country Camera systems thought to be honest they are on of the higher cost ones.
The lens used was it a 16-35mm f2.8 or f4, and why don't you use a lee filter pouch (the sand coloured one same as on your table), its smaller and more compact with soft separate pockets that would protect the filter when in the holders, also clips nicely to a tripod leg with the additional strap that comes with it.
Colin, the 16-35 is the 2.8. Yeah the LEE Tan Punch is a good option, but I think Benro also makes a smaller version bag with felt dividers as well. See their comment on this same video.
Like vlog and the honesty mate. Some great innovations but the frames seem super annoying. That polariser faf would also drive me nuts. I’ve switched to the new Lee holder and polariser setup and it is nice to use. For me, it would great to see Lee evolve their current system a bit further and incorporate some of the cool things that others are doing... dial to move filters up and down is a great idea... ramble over! Look forward to seeing Bali (I was THAT close to coming.... next time). Cheers Jase
What is confusing everyone is that there are two different holders a FH100M2 and a FH100M2B. The FH100M2B is the one that is compatible with the Benro MACPL95 Polarizer and the FH100M2 is compatible with the Benro MACPL82 Polarizer
Cannot wait until next year! Just waiting for you two to drop the next Mongolia trip!! Still trying to find a quality filter system! Was hoping that benro would be it but if they are finicky like that it would just aggravate me lol
Absolutely loved the idea of having a case that you can put around the filter just in case you drop it, don't like the idea that you can't put the filter and the case back in the felt pouches as you said. Also don't like the way the polarizer filter is I think it would put me off using it too. But the one thing I do love about this system that I didn't know about until watching this video is the mechanism to move the filters up and down that I do really like. I think there's a few little tweaks here and there this could be a fantastic filter system. Richard
@@gregorsnell there are a lot of good filter systems out there now by many companies. I've been looking at many filter system for a few months now but haven't settled on any as of yet, think i need to try a few out. But with yourself and other RUclipsrs that I follow making review videos like this makes my decision making so much easier. fingers crossed with in the next few weeks I'll have a new filter system myself.
Harry!! I miss you too buddy. Sorry for my smelly boots in Patagonia 🤣 You'll be happy to know the new Trail Runners don't smell at all though. & I've been tearing them to shreds as you do. The real test will be in Nepal. Let's see if they can handle the Anapurna.
@@gregorsnell haha, good to know you have a new runners after Patagonia and I look forward to see your up coming video in Napal. I am sorry to let you know that I have not done any photography after Patagonia, been very busy with work and family. Fortunately , I still can watch the video from you guys to keep me motivated.
I am building my Filter System around the Benro FH100M2 Filter Holder. I love the construction and ease of adjusting grad filters and rotating the ND Filter, may I recommend buying more frames and you will find the easy way to fit the filters. The big advantage will be paid off the day you drop a framed filter on a solid ground and it is not broken. Can you please let me know what Benro (Carbon Fiber) tripod you are using. Thanks.
Great video Greg, I already have an SW150 system from Nisi for my Sigma Art 12-24 but I recently bought a canon 16-35 to downsize on longer trips out of the country. @Benro EU just wondering where can I can buy the Filter Kit online as It does not seem to be on your website as I'm curious about the price. Also, the smaller bag to hold the filters in the frames, will that come with the kit or does it cost extra as I would have no interest in such a big bag for everything.
Tengo el sistema anterior a este de aluminio, también. Por lo que veo Benro continua con el mismo sistema de colocación del polarizador. Eso se mantiene igual en ambas versiones. A mí me resulta incomodo porque el polarizador es muy delgado y es muy fácil de que se pueda caer al intentar colocarlo. Creo que el sistema de Lee al tenerlo adelante es mucho más comodo. Más allá de ese detalle, el polarizador Benro es excelente, es un cristal con mucha tecnología, muy fácil de limpiar y se pueden combinar con los demás filtros Benro y las imágenes no pierden calidad.
Thank you for this, I did pick purchase the Benro FH100M2 because of the movement grad filters, unlike you I'm a medium film shooter and speed is not a factor. On that note if I were to be running around different locations Benro would not be on my top 5 list when using digital. Good review love the location.
Liked the look of the Benro holder and its functionality but the filter holders looked a pain in the backside. Currently using Lee system and occasionally using Formatt-Hitech filter holder for long exposure as you can encase the ND filter in the holder to reduce light leakage paths via the holder. Saying that the colours in your images looked 👍🏼
I like the idea of those filters as a whole. With a little tweaking like downsizing and allowing rotation of the polarizer, they would have a winner. Great video 👍📸
I noticed your bag is different to what benro supplied me. In my bag are separator slots where each frame can be stored plus the bag is smaller than yours.... not sure why they supplied you with that bag?
Benro makes a zipper pouch just for this filter set up that will hold each individual filter. You have the wrong one. This is the one you want. Benro Master Holder and Filter Bag for FH100M2 benrofilters.com/us/product/benro-master-holder-and-filter-bag-for-fh100m2/
Great vlog Greg. Love your honesty. Seems pretty simple to me (Benro, are you listening?). Just have the pouches bigger to fit the frames in while they are holding the glass. Simple, no fuss, less time consuming and...the frames still do what they are designed to.
How about that f16 long exposure timelapse to kick this one off? Also interested to know your take on the new system here. I'm happy with the glass and colour/image quality. Not so happy with the frames but I do really like the notch adjustment system. I'm torn, like Natalie Imbruglia.
Greg. I'm an ambassador for Benro over here in France. Like you I wasn't sure about the frames. However, did you know that Benro do another filter holder?
I sometimes wonder if these companies have an actual Photographer on their design team. I just don't understand why the filter and frame can't be one piece. Also why can't the polarizer be a segmented square that would change polarity as you raise and lower it, then there wouldn't be a need for removing to spin it. I love to bring order out of chaos so feel free to let Benro know I'd be happy to share my ideas. Begginer as they might be.
BTW I'm also like Natalie Imbruglia, I wish I was there.
@@DavidSenteno it's not really my place to say too much. I personally prefer the other filter holder that Benro offer but have been told that other photographers like the one that Greg has. I do have it but it's not ideal for me.
I have actually spoken to Benro about it and they are very receptive as a company to ideas unlike certain more well known filter companies out there. That is a good thing!
With regards to companies employing photographers. That I have to wonder with companies. I spoke to a backpack company earlier this year whose speciality is photography backpacks. I explained to them that although the actual photography bag was near perfect for a travel photographer it was let down by the pocket that holds the laptop. That it was extremely thin and offered little to no protection. Which is completely daft! And they have a number of well known photographers as ambassadors which makes me wonder just how involved they are.
@@JulianElliottPhotography Hey Julian thanks for the response. I hope I didn't come across as angry. I was just expressing my thoughts. I'm glad to hear Benro is listening. Maybe someone will read these comments and we will see a change. Of course if someone made a perfect filter system then that would limit the number of filter system review videos that could be done. Wait!....It's a conspiracy!...lol.
Peace.
David Senteno no, you definitely didn’t come across as angry! I think, personally, we have a right to express an opinion when we are putting our money and time into products.
What you hope is that things get noticed and acted upon.
Hi, Benro UK here 😊 We have watched Greg's video and here are some comments from the UK brand manager.
Firstly the bag, the bag we would like to have supplied was out of stock so we supplied a bag for a larger system, but there is a bag designed to hold the 100x150mm filters whilst in their frames.
Then regarding the filter holder. We receive a mix of feedback - some love the frame and gearing system, others love the traditional style holder. No one is right or wrong, you use what you prefer. If you don’t like the system with frames and gearing, we offer a traditional filter holder where you manually adjust your filter level and it uses no frames.
Greg’s comments about the framed filters not fitting in the filter wallets is something that has been noted and we will investigate making the wallets large enough to take a framed filter - the idea of the system is that you load the filters into the frames and you leave them there, so being able to protect them still in the frame is important.
And what was the reason for the frames - the concept was to provide the photographer with the ability to have control over the height positioning of the grad filter in the mount which is driven by the gearing mechanism in the holder but to make that work you need the frame with the notched edge. The frame does also help protect the filter and it means when you handle it, you can hold the frame edge rather than the actual filter.
Comments about the CPL being fiddly to load. This is something we’re already looking to fix and we have prototype units out being tested that make the process of loading and unloading the CPL much simpler and less fiddly.
Finally, we are listening 👍 Feedback from all our customers is noted and shared with the Benro R&D team and if that feedback can be implemented to improve a product then Benro will consider it.
Benro UK in the house!! Nice to see such a detailed & honest response. I'm happy to know your R&D team are taking these points into consideration. Having a smaller bag with felt dividers would be a great fix for two of my current issues. I'll order that asap.
I actually really like the idea of the frames, you're right they offer good protection to the glass and being able to adjust the height positioning in the mount with the gearing mechanism is an awesome development.
The CPL is something I need more experience actually using in the field, but yes a new prototype would be nice to see in the future for sure. GREAT to see your presence here and the detailed comment. This is the sign of an positively engaged brand.
Just bought the system, so still learning about it. But not being able to slot the framed filters back into the lovely felt bags is v irritating. And, bad for you, it has discouraged me from buying additional frames, as I can't then store them easily in the pouches.
In the last two years some new or improved systems appeared on the market but none of them is perfect. If you take all these reviews you might be able to create a perfect filter system. But even this would not suit everybody because there are many different requirements (portability, use in rough environment, price...). I will stay with my Rollei system... Thanks for the wonderful b-roll material around the filters 😁👍🏼
The closing time lapse and images....YOU MAKE ME PEANUT BUTTER AND JEALOUSY
I was looking for a review of the Benro system and you just nailed it. Thanks for that. Photos were awesome keep up the good work
Beautiful as always!
I have a smaller filterbag from Benro, and it often ends up in my camerabag. The filterholder is ok, but placing the polariser is a bit slowly, and turning the filter make some noice - like turning a filter on a lens. Having the filters in the frames is to me part of the reason to get them. It makes them easy to hold and do protect the glass from fingerprints and dirt - and the filterframes can not drop out off the filterholder by accident. I have used the system for a year, and find that it works for me, but when not knowing other systems it is imposible to say if the filters are realy good or just ok compared to others.
Interesting, I like the adjustment knobs on the Benro filter holder. I currently use the Nisi V5 filter system and I've been happy with it. I also use the Mindshift gear filter hive, which I've also been pretty happy with, to carry the filters in my backpack. Thanks for your candid review. As I've mentioned to you before, overall I like and use other Benro products. Safe journeys!
I have been looking to get a filter system. thanks for the vlog, this was helpful. Even if I still don't know which to buy.
In terms of size and weight check out the Kase filter system. The filter holder is small and lightweight. The filters themselves are nice and have little if any colour cast. I moved from Lee and don't regret the move away. Very pleased with Kase.
Have the benro system love it, the frames are great
Cool and honest. Nice buddy, I like the idea of the adjustment knobs but the frames look like the need some work before they are there. And the new Lee systems has a very easy pop on/off polarizer filter which is pretty cool. Cheers che, see you around.
Great in-depth review G
That LE was superb
Weill done Bro
The frames are what make the system for me. You don't have to touch the filters with dirty fingers on the field, and they are (kind of) protected (a little bit more than naked filter).
It seems that your main problem was the bag and the way they are stored ? would using a compartimented filter pouch be an option ? or find slightly larger individual felt pouches ?
I always disliked the protruding polarizer on the lee system, especially on shots where you don't want to use ND filters (in which case light leaks like crazy). It also forces you to buy a much larger polarizer.
But on the other hand, attaching/removing the polarizer with this system seems finnicky aswell ... maybe if it could be attached from the lens side, instead of under the square filters ? or maybe the easiest solution would be to have 2 holders, one with the polarizer and one without, wich is not a great solution either.
Thanks for the honest review though, and for the great content you provide here and on BvS's and T.Heat's channels !
I have this system with an upgraded filter holder that is really annoying. It now has a spring loaded button next to the red dial that moves the filters up and down in the holder. In order to turn the dial, the spring loaded button has to be pushed in, a totally unnecessary addition that now requires using two hands instead of one. I resorted to cutting off the spring and gluing the button in. The system itself is fantastic and the filter holders are brilliant, reducing the need to touch the glass and you can make accurate adjustments very easily. I haven't noticed any colour casts at all when using the glass filters but I don't know about the resin ones as I don't own any. The polariser is excellent quality. The smaller filter bag is compact and excellent and I leave the filters in the frames and they fit in the small bag. I don't see the point of removing them from the frame.
Hi Greg, I like your review, especially you can compare the difference between other brand name. Good job !
The mechanism looks pretty cool on the filter kit.
Agreed. & it's colour coordinated to my lenses. Boom.
I am using Formatt Hittech Firecrest holder and from what I see from your video, is is even slower to use compared to Benro one. I have no experience with filter system which has filter frames but I wanted to try something like that because I assume that it should have as good protection against light leaks as my current one but more convenient. Formatt has extra peaces of plastic inserts which I have to change depending on the type of the filters I would use every time I am out shooting which is a lot of hustle. I think the first system which had filter frames was Wine Country Camera, but it is very expensive and bulky. It is good that we have other variants of such approach on the market now.
Greg the main complaint of people with Lee Filters were centered around the flimsy plastic holder and the it's price. I solved that issue using a Zioti holder and rings (a fraction of the price of the Lee's). All filters in my are Lee, but I saved a ton of money on the foundation kit! My only issue has been when shooting @ 16mm since the polarizer ring (105mm) creates a vignetting effect. Other than that, I'm happy with the setup!
Like you, I love some of the features of the Benro system. It looks very clever and handy. But I would probably be as frustrated as you with the extra space it will take in my bag. Excellent review and better pictures!
Greg check out the Nisi V6 filter kit. After looking at everything I could find I switched to it and so far so good.
Some beautiful long exposure photos . You might be interested in the new Kase filter system. They have a good solution for the polarizer (magnetic connection) and filters slide in like the Lee system.
Cheers mate. I'll look into it.
I watched the next video you linked to as well regarding the Benro filters. It looks like you can adjust the polarizing filter from nearest the lens easily... just not remove it quite as easily. The bag space may not be as much of an issue for those of us with non-nomadic lifestyles. Guess you could use your other filter pouch. Thanks for the info. Much appreciated.
Yeah these are minimal issues really, it's only from experience of changing filters in crummy conditions and limited time that I could foresee more potential complications. Overall though I do really like the system and have been still using it. Just need to get the divider pouch.
Those are some amazing images! The Benro filters did a great job! Other than a UV filter, I actually don't own any filters right now, but I'm considering on getting some in the near future. The Lee filters sound like they might be great for newcomers with filters. Awesome footage! I'm looking forward to seeing you in Bali in a few days!
I have the opposite feeling than you and really like to keep the filters in the frame. My bag is smaller and easier to travel with. But as you I have not used the CPL in holder but connect to the lens before I put the ring on. Make it more easy to put on and off. A solution is to have 2 holders and just change them and slide the filters in.
Hi Arnfinn, that's a great idea regarding the CPL on the ring beforehand. Does the FH100M2 holder then fit over it...? I'll try it today and see :) Thanks for the great comment.
Mad props for your honesty, Greg. Looks like the filters did the job on the long exposures...nice! Also some great shots at the end of the vid.
You might want to search on the online camera stores (B&H, Adorama, etc.) for "Lee filter wrap", and check out the one that holds 3 filters. I have one of those and it seems like there might be enough play to allow you to hold the filters in their frames. Could be a cheap alternative to what you're doing. If you're shooting with T.Heat anytime soon, I think that I noticed in a vid that he has his filters in one of these so you might be able to check out his to see if it would work for you.
Cheers!
Benro does have an interesting system for sure, for me I have been using the Wine Country Camera systems which also uses frames so that one does not have to touch filter and the frames take pretty much any standard 100 X 100 or the Grad in 100 X 150. In addition they have the polarizer with a simple knob that set as the first filter in the system to the lens which can be easily removed. My favorite part is for the grad filter (2nd and 3rd slot) usage, they have a simple button that allows for easy adjustment and placement.Not sure but I think Benro and some other may have picked up some of the features that WCC started with. Regardless be very happy with Benro product and my heavy tripod is a Benro and it is a killer and great. All said though for filter system I love my Wine Country Camera systems thought to be honest they are on of the higher cost ones.
The lens used was it a 16-35mm f2.8 or f4, and why don't you use a lee filter pouch (the sand coloured one same as on your table), its smaller and more compact with soft separate pockets that would protect the filter when in the holders, also clips nicely to a tripod leg with the additional strap that comes with it.
Colin, the 16-35 is the 2.8. Yeah the LEE Tan Punch is a good option, but I think Benro also makes a smaller version bag with felt dividers as well. See their comment on this same video.
Like vlog and the honesty mate. Some great innovations but the frames seem super annoying. That polariser faf would also drive me nuts. I’ve switched to the new Lee holder and polariser setup and it is nice to use. For me, it would great to see Lee evolve their current system a bit further and incorporate some of the cool things that others are doing... dial to move filters up and down is a great idea... ramble over! Look forward to seeing Bali (I was THAT close to coming.... next time). Cheers Jase
What is confusing everyone is that there are two different holders a FH100M2 and a FH100M2B. The FH100M2B is the one that is compatible with the Benro MACPL95 Polarizer and the FH100M2 is compatible with the Benro MACPL82 Polarizer
Cannot wait until next year! Just waiting for you two to drop the next Mongolia trip!! Still trying to find a quality filter system! Was hoping that benro would be it but if they are finicky like that it would just aggravate me lol
Nice!! That's awesome news dude. You & a few others are keen to secure a spot on Mongolia 2020. Announcement coming soon. I'll keep you in the loop.
Absolutely loved the idea of having a case that you can put around the filter just in case you drop it, don't like the idea that you can't put the filter and the case back in the felt pouches as you said. Also don't like the way the polarizer filter is I think it would put me off using it too.
But the one thing I do love about this system that I didn't know about until watching this video is the mechanism to move the filters up and down that I do really like. I think there's a few little tweaks here and there this could be a fantastic filter system.
Richard
Agreed 💯%
@@gregorsnell there are a lot of good filter systems out there now by many companies. I've been looking at many filter system for a few months now but haven't settled on any as of yet, think i need to try a few out. But with yourself and other RUclipsrs that I follow making review videos like this makes my decision making so much easier. fingers crossed with in the next few weeks I'll have a new filter system myself.
Can you say more about filrers how they compare in terms of sharpness and colors to other brands like NiSi?
Hi Greg, Harry here, I miss you, have fun in Mongolia!
Harry!! I miss you too buddy. Sorry for my smelly boots in Patagonia 🤣 You'll be happy to know the new Trail Runners don't smell at all though. & I've been tearing them to shreds as you do. The real test will be in Nepal. Let's see if they can handle the Anapurna.
@@gregorsnell haha, good to know you have a new runners after Patagonia and I look forward to see your up coming video in Napal. I am sorry to let you know that I have not done any photography after Patagonia, been very busy with work and family. Fortunately , I still can watch the video from you guys to keep me motivated.
I am building my Filter System around the Benro FH100M2 Filter Holder. I love the construction and ease of adjusting grad filters and rotating the ND Filter, may I recommend buying more frames and you will find the easy way to fit the filters. The big advantage will be paid off the day you drop a framed filter on a solid ground and it is not broken. Can you please let me know what Benro (Carbon Fiber) tripod you are using. Thanks.
Great video Greg, I already have an SW150 system from Nisi for my Sigma Art 12-24 but I recently bought a canon 16-35 to downsize on longer trips out of the country. @Benro EU just wondering where can I can buy the Filter Kit online as It does not seem to be on your website as I'm curious about the price. Also, the smaller bag to hold the filters in the frames, will that come with the kit or does it cost extra as I would have no interest in such a big bag for everything.
Tengo el sistema anterior a este de aluminio, también. Por lo que veo Benro continua con el mismo sistema de colocación del polarizador. Eso se mantiene igual en ambas versiones. A mí me resulta incomodo porque el polarizador es muy delgado y es muy fácil de que se pueda caer al intentar colocarlo. Creo que el sistema de Lee al tenerlo adelante es mucho más comodo. Más allá de ese detalle, el polarizador Benro es excelente, es un cristal con mucha tecnología, muy fácil de limpiar y se pueden combinar con los demás filtros Benro y las imágenes no pierden calidad.
Thank you for this, I did pick purchase the Benro FH100M2 because of the movement grad filters, unlike you I'm a medium film shooter and speed is not a factor. On that note if I were to be running around different locations Benro would not be on my top 5 list when using digital. Good review love the location.
Liked the look of the Benro holder and its functionality but the filter holders looked a pain in the backside. Currently using Lee system and occasionally using Formatt-Hitech filter holder for long exposure as you can encase the ND filter in the holder to reduce light leakage paths via the holder. Saying that the colours in your images looked 👍🏼
scotty4418 have the benro love the frames not a pain at all
I like the idea of those filters as a whole. With a little tweaking like downsizing and allowing rotation of the polarizer, they would have a winner. Great video 👍📸
Are you still using this filter system?
Were those the glass or resin filters?
Glass.
@@gregorsnell Nice, you got a freebie amounting to what I paid for my DSLR :)
@@gregorsnell Of course when I say 'freebie' you've put in the effort to get to this point. :)
Just chuck that tea like a gangsta'...
Beastmode.
I noticed your bag is different to what benro supplied me.
In my bag are separator slots where each frame can be stored plus the bag is smaller than yours.... not sure why they supplied you with that bag?
I have the same kit and the smaller and better bag.
Yeah same here!
Yeah, one of the photographers on the Mongolia Adventure had the same bag. I'm going to order it this month. WAY better.
I have the smaller bag also but all the slots are nylon instead of a soft felt.
wondering if your still using the benro system..?
Yup. Still holding up good too.
That system looks like a complete pain in the a$$. Keeps me content with my Lee setup with the new holder. Thanks for the review!
Use the fg100 filter holder instead
Benro makes a zipper pouch just for this filter set up that will hold each individual filter. You have the wrong one. This is the one you want.
Benro Master Holder and Filter Bag for FH100M2 benrofilters.com/us/product/benro-master-holder-and-filter-bag-for-fh100m2/
You can't even tell those are my legs in your Gert....or is it Yert?
It's a gyert.
Look at me. I'm watching a youtube video 😁
Yes!!! Look at the Benro comment in this feed. It's detailed and good. We should follow up with them before you buy.
Great vlog Greg. Love your honesty. Seems pretty simple to me (Benro, are you listening?). Just have the pouches bigger to fit the frames in while they are holding the glass. Simple, no fuss, less time consuming and...the frames still do what they are designed to.