The Fall of Star Wars: A Kathleen Kennedy Story

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 окт 2024

Комментарии • 1,4 тыс.

  • @istari0
    @istari0 Год назад +981

    I believe you nailed it. Lucas thought he could trust Kennedy and the folks at Disney but that was a massive mistake. Kennedy has never been a Star Wars fan and her driving purpose was to make herself famous so she would be remembered with the likes of Lucas, Spielberg, etc. That of course will never happen; it's a tragedy she all but wrecked Star Wars in the process.

    • @artsman412
      @artsman412 Год назад +64

      The problem is she missed what made Lucas and Spielberg famous in the first place; they gave us great stories! Maybe not entirely new in and of themselves, but they always put their unique spin on the stories they told. Nowadays, hollywood seems less interested in telling a good story and more interested in making a quick buck, which in tun make them less memorable, and less desirable stories to buy.

    • @ChernxbylCherrii
      @ChernxbylCherrii Год назад +67

      I mean in a way she did get her wish. She will be known but for destroying Star Wars. Not for being passed the torch and continuing the legacy

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +12

      I'm not so sure. He's spoken ill of the corporations before. I think he was rushing the deal because he knew to delay would mean to take a tax hit, it's all there in Bob Iger's book.

    • @thetraveler264
      @thetraveler264 Год назад +12

      Let us not forget that Kennedy has many successes under her belt. I mean my god she made ET!
      Sure there were mistakes made. And #Thor is right, Lucas sold Star Wars (for better or worse). He could have made it contractual that they followed his wishes, but he didn't.
      I am not saying that there weren't mistakes made and TLJ was a burning dumpster fire. But I am really enjoying Andor and the Mandalorian. Ahsoka wasn't terrible. Lol and I did actually like (for the most part) Kenobi (Watching Vader fight was bad ass).
      I won't lie, I can't believe Kennedy is still around. I would have guessed she would have been quietly terminated by now.
      Who knew lol

    • @bbtank3000
      @bbtank3000 Год назад +11

      Ironically, she’s infamous.

  • @lindamollman7878
    @lindamollman7878 Год назад +408

    When Kennedy publicly made the statement.."We don't owe Lucas anything for Star Wars" That sums up what is WRONG with Star Wars now under Disney. 😡

    • @antonioowensby8823
      @antonioowensby8823 Год назад +6

      😮😮😮😮😮

    • @tvbuu
      @tvbuu Год назад +6

      yikes

    • @Fostersauce
      @Fostersauce 11 месяцев назад +3

      I can't believe I never heard about her saying that. Absolute madness

    • @Odraude2105
      @Odraude2105 11 месяцев назад +3

      When did she even say that

    • @rvllctt871
      @rvllctt871 11 месяцев назад +3

      To be fair George got four billion dollars. He could have set up a shelf company to deal with it and have some direction but he sold out to the white slavers ... at least Empire Strikes back will stay the best movie of the franchise .... forever now.

  • @dereklopez9060
    @dereklopez9060 Год назад +610

    "The main thing is to protect these characters and make sure they still continued to live in a way that you created them and that the universe of Star Wars can continues to grow."
    Biggest lie she's ever told and an absolute backstab to George Lucas. They did the total opposite of "protecting these characters" and "continue to grow".

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +42

      Less than two years later, they nuked the EU and refuse to continue it as Legends, which fans have asked for going on ten years now. Such a bleeding shame. This is how our stories die. With thunderous applause.

    • @Milothemighty10
      @Milothemighty10 Год назад +22

      I just wanted to see the original trilogy cast together, one last time in the sequels but now it’s physically impossible. Peter Mayhew is gone. Kenny Baker is gone Carrie fisher is gone. Of course that’s not Disney/lucasfilms fault but still that doesn’t mean it doesn’t sting…

    • @FabuBrik
      @FabuBrik Год назад +23

      Imagine saying this right to his face and then having the ego to think you could do it better.

    • @thezman9522
      @thezman9522 Год назад +29

      George Lucas: "You agreed to 'protect the characters!'"
      Kathleen Kennedy: "I lied. As I had from the very beginning."

    • @dereklopez9060
      @dereklopez9060 Год назад +18

      @@Milothemighty10 Yeah, and Harrison Ford is very much done with Star Wars. It's truly mind-boggling that Disney bought Lucasfilm, and they made a trilogy where it had no plan from the start and waste their opportunity to reunite the old cast together. I know it's been 4 years since the sequel trilogy is over, but all that disappointed just sinks right back in.

  • @swagathan5
    @swagathan5 Год назад +258

    I think Kathy's statement when asked if she liked Star Wars was pretty revealing of her motives. She didn't take the helm because she was a fan wanting to do Star Wars right, she took it because she wanted the power and prestige of being the woman behind Star Wars and Lucasfilm. Some people want to create art and beauty -- Lucas certainly succeeded in that. Some only want to gain power. And that, I think, is the big difference between the two.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +8

      Disney wanted the power, and they'll keep it long after she's gone.

    • @lucky247365
      @lucky247365 Год назад +2

      Just because she didn't explicitly say she was a star wars fan, doesn't mean that she wasn't. She has a lengthy working relationship with Lucas and Speilberg dating all the way back to the 80s. She obviously would have had some passion for it if Georgie Boy felt he can trust her. It would be incredibly hard to fake it IMO unless Lucas is terribly gullible.

    • @Valen-mh9fh
      @Valen-mh9fh Год назад +8

      ​@@lucky247365saying she was a fan would only endear her to the fans. No reason not to admit it if it was true?
      Lots of people work on projects and do a professional job but aren't fans of the project per se.
      Lucas probably thought she understood the core themes, and she probably does, but she didn't tell George she was going to undo all that (maybe on the say so of Disney, which is why she's still there?).

    • @agent_exodus
      @agent_exodus Год назад +1

      Well said

    • @swagathan5
      @swagathan5 Год назад +2

      @@lucky247365 That is true, it doesn't mean that she isn't a Star Wars fan. But it struck me how it seemed like she was trying to avoid saying she was a Star Wars fan -- if anything, it seemed to me that she was more a fan of Lucas's cinematographic accomplishments and legacy. But that's just my take on it.
      As for your second point, it could be a mix of things. I agree that it would be hard for her to hide deceitful motives for all that time. It would make more sense for her to just be less creatively competent than George, with the power getting to her head. Honestly, I don't really know. I just know that I have seen the results of Kennedy's Star Wars, and I have been ultimately disappointed.
      Thanks for replying!

  • @muskatDR
    @muskatDR Год назад +120

    That clip of rian johnson wanting to make a divisive movie is kinda hilarious. He made a movie, got the exact reaction he wanted...and then got really mad about it

    • @SuperLuis225
      @SuperLuis225 11 месяцев назад +21

      Yeh he basically went "I want to anger the fans and make the fan base fight itself" then went "Hey why you all so mad?! It's just a movie! What do you mean it's my fault?"

    • @ling0s138
      @ling0s138 11 месяцев назад +12

      Best part is if that movie hadn’t had Star Wars in the title everyone would have hated that poor excuse for a story. Some people were just determined to like it based off the IP rather than quality of the film thereby accidentally making his goal a success

  • @thezman9522
    @thezman9522 Год назад +180

    George Lucas: "You agreed to 'protect the characters!'"
    Kathleen Kennedy: "I lied. As i had from the very beginning."

    • @ItsATrappProductions
      @ItsATrappProductions Год назад +12

      Props for that Force Unleashed quote. 👍

    • @abramsullivan7764
      @abramsullivan7764 Год назад +1

      Props man Star Wars The Force Unleashed

    • @n.l.4626
      @n.l.4626 Год назад +13

      George after TFA: "But you said..."
      Kathleen Kennedy: "I altered our agreement. Pray that I don't alter it furter"
      George: "But..."
      *Kathleen Kennedy snaps fingers, TLJ happens*

    • @fettbub92
      @fettbub92 Год назад +3

      She altered the deal, pray she doesn't alter it any further.

    • @humphrey_bear_MDC
      @humphrey_bear_MDC 11 месяцев назад +2

      KK - I lied to your face. Deal with it !

  • @ToonamiT0M
    @ToonamiT0M Год назад +201

    You don't need to be a fan of these legacy franchises. You just need to respect them and their fans. And for the life of me I have no idea why people who openly hate on these franchises and show contempt for the fan base are being put in charge.

    • @agrumpymonkey5800
      @agrumpymonkey5800 Год назад +28

      It’s because the executives doing the hiring want to appeal to a “broader” audience and attract people who aren’t interested in the IP, therefore they make the product as watered down as they can, while alienating the established audience. In the end the broader audience is bored with the terrible product and the established fan based hates it. Rinse and repeat with every IP out there until there is nothing left to remake

    • @ToonamiT0M
      @ToonamiT0M Год назад +7

      @@agrumpymonkey5800 Accurate. Star Trek is suffering the same issues as Star Wars. There's more content than ever, but only a tiny fraction is at all half decent.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +6

      @@agrumpymonkey5800 Exactly, Disney-owned Lucasfilm prefers drooling-dumb normies, not the most loyal fans willing to walk through rain and snow to buy this shit.

    • @lansfriszt7767
      @lansfriszt7767 Год назад +5

      I agree, top executives don't need to be fans and sometimes it might even be better if they have some distance with their product. But disrespecting the audience and blaming them for your failures is never going to work.

    • @TheGaboom
      @TheGaboom Год назад +5

      There are multiple reasons, one of which is seeking a broader audience as others mentioned
      But behind that, I think a lot of writers/creatives resent bigger IPs due to how they end up being 'forced' to work for them.
      Execs want to print money via popular IPs; No matter what.
      Working in that environment, only popular IPs are valued.
      Its an environment which pushes those within it to resent their work, while also giving liberties to try and 'fix' it.
      Like...Its similar to working at a restaurant for years and slowly coming to hate the food served there 🤔🤔

  • @Gaia1054
    @Gaia1054 Год назад +279

    It's absolutely heartbreaking to think of what they did to George. He sells his company off to someone he thought he could trust. Leaves behind story ideas and actively wanted to be a consultant on those films. Then his ideas are thrown out in favor of just repeating what he had done before, which is the thing that he hated the most about Hollywood. The endless and shameless cash grabs sequel reboot movies they pump out. George always tried to tell his story and try to do something brand new with each film he made. Such a shame that he had to watch from the outside as Star Wars became the very thing he swore to destroy

    • @BGS22202
      @BGS22202 Год назад

      Lucas is a hypocritical liberal who wants the rich to “pay their fair share” but rushed to cash out before a big Obama tax hike came into effect. And he wanted social justice cred for putting Kennedy in charge. He’s more culpable than Disney.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +9

      Not as heartbreaking as what's happened to us.

    • @evok993
      @evok993 Год назад +6

      @@saberiandream316 it can be really painful to see your best friend destroy hum Self, but it will always be worst for its parents ;)

    • @SymbioteMullet
      @SymbioteMullet Год назад +23

      She was the chosen one.
      She was supposed to protect the ip, not destroy it.
      Bring balance to the fandom, not leave it in darkness...

    • @davidjacobs8558
      @davidjacobs8558 Год назад +7

      apparently, George Lucas has severe trouble with judging the characters of women close to him.
      I'm pretty sure he is being manipulated by his current wife also.

  • @YegRon
    @YegRon Год назад +83

    This actually hurts. I know it’s small beans compared to so many of the problems in the world today, but she flat out lied to Lucas. And then her and her goons have the nerve to attack anyone who may have had issues with what they did to our beloved characters.

  • @JLP627
    @JLP627 Год назад +523

    Only true Star Wars fans will understand how heartbreaking this whole thing was.

    • @antonioowensby8823
      @antonioowensby8823 Год назад +11

      This is very heartbreaking

    • @masztaarc
      @masztaarc Год назад +11

      Indeed. The only ones who liked it are pretty much bots.

    • @TamNguyen-wd4op
      @TamNguyen-wd4op Год назад

      ​@@masztaarcIncluding Star Wars Explained, HelloGreedo, Palpamemes, the S.E.A., and other Disney shills

    • @andreslokillo
      @andreslokillo Год назад +10

      Agree... I see the interviews and feel anger...

    • @thetraveler264
      @thetraveler264 Год назад +6

      I guess I am not a "True Fan", as this doesn't affect my life to the extent of "heartbreaking". Heck, hardly even raises to disappointing. It's a group of shows, movies and other media.....nothing more. I know, that truth might not be popular. But it IS the truth none the less.
      Or maybe that makes me a bot...

  • @danielscott8180
    @danielscott8180 Год назад +272

    Kathleen Kennedy really betrayed George. What a duplicitious individual. Telling him everything would be safe and respected with her, and then meanwhile planning to totally undermine him and what he creatred. Seriously, it is pretty disgusting to watch.

    • @jimmyboydonald6578
      @jimmyboydonald6578 Год назад

      Would you have got rid of her if you were her parents?

    • @grawman67
      @grawman67 Год назад +11

      ​@@jimmyboydonald6578That's disgusting to even ask that. Attack the actions, not the person.

    • @infinitespace2520
      @infinitespace2520 Год назад +3

      @@jimmyboydonald6578 Not the right way to think about things bud, as grawman said attack the actions not the person. I would have gotten rid of her if I was her manager

    • @mar_speedman
      @mar_speedman Год назад +2

      @@jimmyboydonald6578 If I were here parent, I would blame myself for what she's become

    • @tvbuu
      @tvbuu Год назад

      sounds like a woman in a marriage

  • @philmontgomery95
    @philmontgomery95 Год назад +56

    George was afraid that a (trade) corporation would ruin his characters by diluting the quality for profit. He made the mistake of trusting his Star Wars universe to a wolf in sheep’s clothing who betrayed his good faith and seized control of the galaxy, using it to further her own political interests…. it’s basically the plot of Ep 1 and 2 and the splitting of the fan base is pretty much the Clone Wars.

    • @atrydes
      @atrydes Год назад +6

      Good analogy.

  • @offcourseoverland
    @offcourseoverland Год назад +103

    Handing the legacy to KK was like handing the keys to a child who has always hated you.

    • @Amp661
      @Amp661 11 месяцев назад +6

      No. It's handing the keys to someone who lies about having a driver's license and doesn't even know how to drive.

  • @Rickmagnus911
    @Rickmagnus911 Год назад +34

    Knowing KK studied film actually makes her story make a lot of sense to me. She likely always wanted to be a filmmaker but never got her chance, so she uses her position now to do what she always wanted, tell her own stories. Unfortunately she seems to have never grown past the cringe fanfiction phase of her abilities, so we get stuck with what we got. The things that don't have any connection to her, seem to be the most successful, The Madalorian (S1 since it gets progressively worse the more she is involved), Visions and Andor. I doubt that's a coincidence. I also think there is a little resentment towards George and Spielberg because she was basically a coffee girl for them.

  • @WonkoTheSane71
    @WonkoTheSane71 Год назад +57

    Kennedy’s only stipulation for the sequels was that they be centred around a young female jedi, which seemed fair enough, but I get the impression she didn’t really care much about the story or the other characters beyond Rey.
    Finn’s story had so much potential, but was continually squandered, perhaps because the filmmakers knew (consciously or unconsciously) that it might prove more interesting than Rey’s vague, sort of nothingy origin story. Boyega was definitely on to something when he complained about Disney/Lucasfilm giving all the focus to Rey.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +10

      Should've been Jaina Solo.

    • @robf228
      @robf228 Год назад +7

      They screwed Poe too.

    • @qui-gonrick7002
      @qui-gonrick7002 Год назад +1

      Unfortunately, you're giving JJ Abrams way too much credit in the sabotage of Finn's character. After that opening scene, Finn was turned into a joke almost immediately.

    • @Valen-mh9fh
      @Valen-mh9fh Год назад +5

      Unfortunately, Finn, with Boyega cast in the role, couldn't be anything other than comic relief since certain global audiences wouldn't go for it if he was a main character.
      Boyega just became a tick box target for the studio. A shame as I like him as an actor and the character had potential.

  • @seancrowley3142
    @seancrowley3142 Год назад +84

    For the life of me, I do not understand how a multi million dollar company makes a movie trilogy with absolutely no road map, no planning whatsoever.

    • @akumaking1
      @akumaking1 Год назад +1

      Because the cult of woke has no planning; just primal screaming and lashing out.

    • @stevequincy388
      @stevequincy388 Год назад +11

      Hubris, they were too busy sniffing their own farts to properly plan out a successful Star Wars trilogy. They thought they could crap out whatever they wanted and the fans would lap it up. And fans kind of did (at first with TFA), but oh boy did it change with TLJ. Their egos just wouldn't let them admit they made a huge mistake.

    • @roberterwine7650
      @roberterwine7650 11 месяцев назад

      all it is was 'legends' re-written .

    • @Amp661
      @Amp661 11 месяцев назад

      Because it doesn't take huge amounts of money to create art. It's not hard to understand.

    • @AmazePaulz
      @AmazePaulz 7 месяцев назад +1

      You see, your failure is to assume having lots of money automatically means being sensible.
      The hookwink of the last 20 years has been convincing the internet generation that power and wealth must be because of diligence and intellectual rigour.
      The cracks in the system were showing in the 90s, so the social commerce pivot (entertainment) was to marry financial success to intelligence. Its why nerds stopped being the butt of jokes and a new style of nerds being autistic legends was created.
      Now they have pivoted again to convince people that power and wealth are inevitably entwined in order to delete the vestiges of political power being held at the ballot.
      All part of the end stages of capitalism.
      This last stage will then give way, in the 30s and 40s, to the notion that money is less important than the power it derives

  • @coda7994
    @coda7994 Год назад +74

    I wonder what George honestly thinks about all of this. It hurts to see him in these clips, and how much he was betrayed.

    • @crazyralph6386
      @crazyralph6386 11 месяцев назад +3

      Don’t know about George, but I’ll tell you exactly how Spielberg feels? Watch how he intentionally goons her during that Indy 5 premiere in which he honours Lucas, Ford and Williams, which left her fuming 😂

    • @coda7994
      @coda7994 11 месяцев назад +3

      @crazyralph6386 yeah Spielberg tells it like it is. He said her main contributions were talking over other people and tossing out absurd ideas

    • @crazyralph6386
      @crazyralph6386 11 месяцев назад +2

      @@coda7994 Like interrupting a writers meeting and insisting Indy should get the dog at the end of the film instead of the girl! 😂

    • @Pahoe77
      @Pahoe77 10 месяцев назад

      GL compared selling the rights to the films to selling his kids to white slavers, in a interview after selling them and being snubbed by them. "They weren't keen on having me involved ".

  • @mikenayers5981
    @mikenayers5981 Год назад +19

    Kathleen Kennedy’s answer on Star Wars is pretty much what Hansel says about Sting in Zoolander.
    “Sting. Sting would be another person who's a hero. The music he's created over the years, I don't really listen to it, but the fact that he's making it, I respect that.”

  • @TheSt1092
    @TheSt1092 Год назад +100

    At least when George was in charge he tried to enrich the universe with new things even if his execution was poor . The fist six films had imagination and vision at least.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +18

      And he let EU authors tell stories he wouldn't and couldn't. Disney does NOT do the same thing.

    • @JP-eu2dc
      @JP-eu2dc Год назад +1

      Amen

    • @jamesarnold7253
      @jamesarnold7253 Год назад

      Episode 8 isn't my favourite by far but it's the best example of doing something new in star wars along with R1 and Andor. I'm not sure where you think Lucas did after the first 2 movies? Even episode 6 is basically a mix of 4 and 5

    • @TheSt1092
      @TheSt1092 Год назад +7

      @@jamesarnold7253 TLJ is the greatest indult to Luke Skywalker.

    • @jamesarnold7253
      @jamesarnold7253 Год назад

      @@TheSt1092 nah, he dies using the force for defence, never attack. That's literally what his masters told him to do and what made him better than his father or Kylo. Like in the OT Yoda and Kenobi never actually kill anyone. It's the prequels that made the Jedi into superhero army generals.
      If episode 4 and 5 came out after episode 3 the same people crying about Luke would be crying that hardcore warriors Kenobi and Yoda just pass their knowledge to the next generation and die

  • @robertluna5737
    @robertluna5737 Год назад +23

    I wish I had the talent to make a documentary about this disaster. I hope someone does in the future. This story needs to be preserved as a warning and roadmap for any would-be franchise.

    • @Gilmore74
      @Gilmore74 11 месяцев назад

      Exactly right. Should be used as a case study in every film school across the world

  • @jetblast190
    @jetblast190 Год назад +128

    I don’t think the scariest part is that she set out to destroy SW, but that she is completely clueless that she did or is.

  • @jamiegodfather
    @jamiegodfather Год назад +60

    I think KK definitely thought and assumed Rey, Finn and Poe was gonna be this generations Luke, Leia and Han so she waisted the Greatest Opportunity of all time to reunite the original three in a whole new story but sadly she killed them all off with the assumptions everyone was gonna love Rey which no one does

    • @jamiegodfather
      @jamiegodfather Год назад +3

      @@Alec-d1g I liked Ahsoka well enough but I think the should’ve cast Ashley Eckstein for the role she will always be my favorite Ahsoka

    • @mycelia_ow
      @mycelia_ow Год назад

      @@jamiegodfather Her performance wouldn't have been as good, and this Ahsoka is almost 50 years old so idk. She is the voice of her no doubt.

    • @mycelia_ow
      @mycelia_ow Год назад +1

      @@Alec-d1g "Disney's" Thrawn isn't much worse than book Thrawn.

    • @rybald1973
      @rybald1973 Год назад +1

      @@Alec-d1g and who is talking about that show? it's already gone down the memory hole of the so called fans. Poor ratings, low views that drop each episode, stocks in down fall, merchandise not selling , theme park not breaking even all shows the fans they wanted don't care about star wars they care about virtue signals.

    • @johnhoney5089
      @johnhoney5089 Год назад +1

      ​@@jamiegodfatherTo be fair, that voice would sound jarring coming out of 60 year old Ahsoka's body.
      It'd be like if Luke took off Vader's helmet on the Death Star and you heard Hayden's voice come out of him.

  • @leelynn14
    @leelynn14 11 месяцев назад +7

    I had tears in my eyes by the end of this....They took something I had so deeply cherished for nearly two decades and altered (destroyed) it beyond recognition. I never would have imagined myself falling out of love with Star Wars. Interests would come and go, but Star Wars was the only thing that would stay, and the only thing next to music I'd feel genuine passion for in my shitty life. Yet here I am today...with nothing but grief and not an ounce of the love and excitement I used to feel for this franchise. RIP Star Wars....

  • @heartshinemusic
    @heartshinemusic Год назад +12

    It's totally irrelevant if KK has seen that old Rian Johnson clip about dividing audiences, because it was all there for her to read in TLJ's script. It was not some secret mission of Johnson, it was right there on the pages!

  • @dwaynecuster
    @dwaynecuster Год назад +14

    We shouldn't forget that some of this blame needs to go to Bob Igor and the Disney board of directors trying to make Star Wars a production line of movies and shows just like Marvel. Now we see that both franchises are suffering and/or gasping their last breaths.

    • @donn.4766
      @donn.4766 11 месяцев назад +1

      This is true. Marvel and Star wars was cool, until disney took over them and made them woke production line movies. There was no more uniqueness about them, just the next thing to see.

  • @MedalionDS9
    @MedalionDS9 Год назад +99

    I don't think KK seriously set out to destroy Star Wars on purpose, but having said that... she also doesn't care if it gets "ruined" for the old fans of SW... her whole goal seems to be distancing from the past and courting newer generations... the old legacy stuff is for baiting but never truly honoring them.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +21

      And the Disney apologists use people's reception to the prequels to try and defend her. The prequels were bad movies with great ideas that needed more time to cook. It's completely different.

    • @TheSt1092
      @TheSt1092 Год назад +8

      @@saberiandream316 Episode's 1 and 2 were bad . Episode 3 was a mixed bag with some great moments.

    • @MobbJacket88
      @MobbJacket88 Год назад +2

      That's pretty much hitting the nail on the head. All other comments go home.

    • @lookingforwookiecopilot
      @lookingforwookiecopilot Год назад

      Not caring if Star Wars is ruined for old fans, is George's philosophy when he made the prequels.
      KK didn't ruin Star Wars, she saved it!

    • @TheSt1092
      @TheSt1092 Год назад +1

      The problem with the prequels is that Georgr hired peopole he knew wouldn't say no to his ideas.@@saberiandream316

  • @WhiskyCardinalWes
    @WhiskyCardinalWes Год назад +22

    At some point in time, George said, or did something to offend Kenady so much so she held a secret grudge against him. Now that she has the position to punish him, she wrecked an IP that not only has hurt Lucas, but millions of others.

    • @BingLing-vz3og
      @BingLing-vz3og Год назад +3

      It doesn't feel like spite, more like ego.

  • @jaxsonburch-eo1vz
    @jaxsonburch-eo1vz Год назад +16

    If you guys want to know what George had wanted to do in his sequel trilogy, go watch Star Wars theory’s breakdown of it. Even if you don’t like him, it’s very informative. There were a lot of cool ideas.

  • @anthonyyoutubefan7567
    @anthonyyoutubefan7567 Год назад +12

    Funny...sounds like, from George Lucas' standpoint, there was a good deal of source material and even some ORIGINAL ideas and concepts for future Star Wars content. Let's also keep in mind, Bob Iger is THE ONE who decreed that the "new plan" for Episodes VII thru IX should be to just remake The Original Trilogy. So, between Iger, Kennedy, Kiri Hart (her choice to run The Lucasfilm Story Group), and Pablo Hidalgo, this was already starting everything off on the wrong foot.

  • @michaelmccormick6571
    @michaelmccormick6571 Год назад +67

    There is no defense for Rian Johnson , something different doesn’t mean something good. I have not seen anything good from Rian Johnson

    • @zacharymccants77
      @zacharymccants77 Год назад

      He done good work with Breaking Bad. But that’s it.

    • @lordcarnorjax8599
      @lordcarnorjax8599 Год назад +9

      @@zacharymccants77 But he didn't write the Breaking Bad episodes. That's the big problem with Johnson, his writing sucks. He's a very talented director who has a good eye for visuals.

    • @pure-blood17
      @pure-blood17 Год назад

      ​@zacharymccants7922 .....so brian understands the fine nuances of making and distributing meth, and admittedly he did do a good job on that series. A lot of red flags are raised when you sit back and ponder this reality.....to be honest, the star wars movies he made are exactly what a meth head would make. Nothing was coherent, nothing matched what was already in place, and the weak minded crybaby crap he pulled when everyone on earth hated his dumpster fire is exactly how a dirt bag druggie would act.

    • @zacharymccants77
      @zacharymccants77 Год назад

      @@lordcarnorjax8599fair point.

    • @mycelia_ow
      @mycelia_ow Год назад +2

      @@zacharymccants77 Rian's talent only made episode 8 worse off, he's just not compatible with Lucas's work. He's a good director otherwise.

  • @lordmclovin3694
    @lordmclovin3694 Год назад +19

    Richard Donner on making Superman in 1978 said the following
    “you take material seriously but don’t take yourself seriously”
    Had only the makers of the last trilogy followed that mantra who knows what they could have done.

    • @АлексейМомот-щ7о
      @АлексейМомот-щ7о Год назад +7

      That basically means leaving the ego at the door. That's impossible today.

    • @emberfist8347
      @emberfist8347 Год назад +1

      @@АлексейМомот-щ7о It actually isn't. For example, Gareth Edwards the director of Godzilla 2014 was respectful of the source material. He claimed the Legendary Godzilla was designed by the crew under the assumption the 1954 Godzilla movie was based on real events and what witnesses remembered of Godzilla's appearance.

    • @АлексейМомот-щ7о
      @АлексейМомот-щ7о Год назад

      ​@@emberfist8347you're citing a guy whose career they killed?

    • @emberfist8347
      @emberfist8347 Год назад

      @@АлексейМомот-щ7о What are you talking about he just had a movie out?

    • @АлексейМомот-щ7о
      @АлексейМомот-щ7о Год назад +1

      @@emberfist8347 For years he was banished from Hollywood by Kennedy for Rogue One

  • @Flopdoodle
    @Flopdoodle Год назад +15

    I can tell you how Star Wars would not have been if George was in charge. It would not have been the smoking remains of a dumpster fire. The prequels told a very straightforward story with gorgeous action choreography to carry it (because the dialogue certainly didn't).

  • @poelmeister
    @poelmeister Год назад +17

    What I’ve been wanting to say for the last decade:
    KK, you’re FIRED.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад

      You could easily be _pining_ for her with the next leader. Don't think it can never happen. It very easily could.

  • @TheMokeleMbembe
    @TheMokeleMbembe Год назад +15

    To my mind, Iger is the root of the problems at LFL. He was the one who wanted the rushed production schedule, and he was the one who wanted George's stories jettisoned (I mean, he was part of that group and was the one with the most power - Kennedy was there too but he was her boss, essentially, right?). In the back of my mind I remember how he's the same guy who, in a different lifetime, forced TWIN PEAKS to reveal the killer early, resulting in a season of bad stories and the eventual cancellation of the show. He may be a good businessman, but that does not necessarily have anything to do with good storytelling.

    • @vincentdegheyndt3609
      @vincentdegheyndt3609 Год назад +4

      Never knew he was the reason for this. That explains a lot

    • @zerubbabelsbridge
      @zerubbabelsbridge 10 месяцев назад

      Is that what happened to that show? Gosh it sucked

  • @timothyfitzgerald3168
    @timothyfitzgerald3168 Год назад +15

    How could it be worse? Guaranteed Lucas didnt (in his concepts for the Sequels) cuck his own best characters (Luke and Han), and that alone would have preserved a huge portion of the fanbase.

  • @Anime300
    @Anime300 Год назад +10

    It's an incredibly depressing and infuriating story. Every time I see it come up, I am just furious for him.

  • @johnpoulton9446
    @johnpoulton9446 Год назад +9

    There are 2 examples that aren’t talked about as often but at a time of excitement I felt may not have been good omens. One is when KK canceledThe Clone Wars mid story arc. I get that Cartoon Network had them and Disney needed to make that change but KK didn’t realize the impact and love the fans had for that. Hence years later we finally got the Seige of Mandalore story arc completed. And the other was a quote before TFA opened and she was surprised by the huge reaction the “Chewie we’re home” clip got. She said she knew it would be a nice surprise but was shocked at how big a response it got. Just SO out of touch with the product she was in charge of. So I of course would still be disappointed on the ST but it also adds anger because it’s not as much THAT she failed but HOW and WHY she failed since it was because of ego and lack of respect for Star Wars and the fans.

  • @glucky9970
    @glucky9970 Год назад +7

    Well put,
    My heart breaks everytime I have a thought about how great things could have been

  • @nichlaschristensson1055
    @nichlaschristensson1055 Год назад +7

    I think you did a good summary of what happened. I still feel the same when I watch that interview, where she says that she will honor his work and characters, that she's not truthful. The way she looks at him feels like she is saying what he wants to hear. It also feels like she doesn't know what she is talking about. This was the first time I ever saw her in an interview, and my reaction was Why did he pick her, there must be someone that is more truthful and capable then her.
    And I was sadly right, I thought George new her so it will be okey, but no.
    Then it somehow started not that bad, I was okey with TFA. George wasn't involved anymore, I might be able to still enjoy this. Rouge One I still think is very good. But when TLJ came and we also heard that Rian got promised a trilogy, before the movie came out, I also had watched the clip you showed. I got suspicious and it didn't take many minutes of that movie to understand why. Rian didn't want to honor George's characters that's why he got a trilogy. We also know how she didn't really like Favreau putting Luke in Mando, making Luke great again.
    I actually think she is the wrong person for the job, she was bad as a secretary for Spielberg and I don't understand that George didn't know her lack of competence better.
    We should also have in mind that George can have put in her contract that she couldn't be fired. That might be the reason why she is still there. Or is it that she follows Igers plan so well

  • @ian-flanagan
    @ian-flanagan Год назад +17

    When your trilogy is punching itself in the face, not being a SW fan is luxury problem to have.

  • @jbardige
    @jbardige Год назад +5

    I hadn't seen that quote from Rian Johnson before today. What a strange motivation: to make a movie that some people hate. Mission accomplished, I suppose.

  • @Finngrinder
    @Finngrinder Год назад +7

    Only question relevant is, how much was Lucas aware of Blackrock, Vanguard and all of those taking over media, food, medicine, agriculture, politics and most other existing ressorts completely. If he knew, it's all his fault too if Kathy was associated with them back then

  • @TheAETHER22
    @TheAETHER22 Год назад +11

    Imagine how much of a double headed snake you have to be to earn someone's trust. She probably spend 20-30 years pretending someone she isn't around him. A yes woman. Only to eventually betray everything. Like a blood sucking vampire plotting to earn someone else's fortune. She deserves ALL the hate she gets, may she never live a peaceful life.

  • @artsman412
    @artsman412 Год назад +17

    Being a fan of Star Wars doesn't necessarily mean you can make Star Wars. Filoni is clearly a fan, and while I like a lot of projects he's had a hand in, I wouldn't say he's batting 1000. The problem with Kennedy, that I think you can pick up on from that interview clip, is that she admired Star Wars as a film project not as a story. She admired Star Wars because it was a successful film that changed the industry; and fair enough. But the main reason it changed the industry is because it had a good story at the heart of it. Avatar had ground breaking technology behind it; how many people do you hear talk about it for it's story, or say it's their favorite movie? Lucas changed the film industry because he pushed the industry in order to better tell his story; he made ILM specifically to help him make the story he wanted to tell. That's what Kennedy is missing. She's always seen Star Wars as a franchise to market rather than a story to tell; the problem is a bad story is hard to sell to people.

  • @sebastianprimomija8375
    @sebastianprimomija8375 Год назад +38

    Honestly I just want to get over Star Wars but I don't want to abandon channels like yours. Star Wars to me is like a wound that I'm not letting heal because I'm metaphorically moving about and with each movement I keep on opening it.
    I just want to move on.

    • @DS9TREK
      @DS9TREK Год назад +9

      I get how you feel. I moved on from Star Trek and Doctor Who, but I don't wanna do the same with Star Wars even though I know I should

    • @sebastianprimomija8375
      @sebastianprimomija8375 Год назад +7

      ​@@DS9TREKI grew up on Star Wars the first movie I ever saw in theaters was SW:PM with my dad and watching it being torn apart and its skin being used as a suit by Disney just hurts man.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +10

      Do as I do. Stick to the old EU and nothing else, literally don't PAY for anything else. Make a statement with your money.

    • @Teverell
      @Teverell Год назад +3

      @@saberiandream316 Same. I just dug out Heir the Empire to reread for thousandth time... Those characters are REAL in a way that Rey and the rest of the sequel trilogy characters won't ever be.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +2

      @@Teverell Read Jedi Apprentice and Young Jedi Knights too. They are literally stories Disney would never give you because they don't reprint them!

  • @WrectumTerror
    @WrectumTerror Год назад +60

    People laughed at me when I said Ashoka would bomb and be a the final nail in coffin. Well, here we are.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +25

      Hopefully people stop making excuses for Filoni. Filoni was the sole writer for that show.

    • @janoslambert-cannon7146
      @janoslambert-cannon7146 Год назад +16

      i was unfortunately one of those on serious copium, i have now seen the light, or the darkest pit of hell star wars has become under disney.

    • @achaudhari101
      @achaudhari101 Год назад +5

      @WrectumTerror No doubt you were drunk since the show didn’t kill the franchise.

    • @gaw6352
      @gaw6352 Год назад +9

      It didn't though. People will still watch andor, bad batch season 3 and play the new video games. People have been saying star wars is dead since 1999. It's not.

    • @cacuevas
      @cacuevas Год назад +4

      @@achaudhari101true, the franchise has been dead for almost a decade now

  • @nobusugiyama2804
    @nobusugiyama2804 Год назад +9

    I think kk is a woman who just can’t stand men enjoying something they love so she has to take it and make it hers and by doing so the impossible of turning a billion dollar franchise into a money losing disgrace.
    I wonder what did Luke and Indi ever did to her to not only destroy their life long legacy but to humiliate them like that? Disgusting.
    I think whatever she does and did will be forgotten but Luke,Han and Leia will always be icons

  • @madhattersc4051
    @madhattersc4051 Год назад +3

    I think you nailed the whole situation. In some sense I feel for Kathleen as she has been at the nexus point of some of the most impactful films of all time and she’s been just out of sight, “behind the boys” and likely in those days not given much credit or thought. So she decides I can do this, I’ve watched the likes of George and Steven do it for decades, I have learned the secrets. But those two are special directors and creators who no one is going to simply reproduce their results via osmosis. It does feel like a tale of hubris and regret. Her moment for “salvation” (for lack of a better term) can be in her recognition of her limitation and finally handing things over to Dave and Jon and stepping out of the way. It seems that would be out of character for her, but it might be her best path to redeeming her time as head.

  • @knubson
    @knubson Год назад +7

    You nailed it sir. Lucas thought he could trust Kennedy and the folks at Disney but that was a massive mistake. Kennedy has never been a Star Wars fan and her driving purpose was to make herself famous so she would be remembered with the likes of Lucas, Spielberg, etc. That of course will never happen; it's a tragedy she all but wrecked Star Wars in the process.

    • @anonygent
      @anonygent Год назад +2

      She made herself famous, all right. She will probably be studied in business schools for decades on what not to do. The whole series of female caused catastrophes, like Bud Light, et. al., could be a whole course in itself.

  • @rogerpalsgrove9678
    @rogerpalsgrove9678 Год назад +8

    I think Star Wars will always be a cultural juggernaut. It just needs to be in the hands of people who understand it and will nurture it back to the well-loved property it once was. That last picture with Igor and Lucas before the Kennedy one. I don't know if it's just me, but I think I saw some doubt in his eyes. Maybe that's why you picked it.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +4

      I get more anxious about the old EU. There hasn't been a new story for Legends in almost five goddamned years, and it just feels like that as time passes, more people forget it. They'd rather ask Disney to cherry-pick ideas from Legends to make "canon" again, without understanding that changing the context doesn't make our stories "canon" again, because they're not the same anymore. Look at Thrawn to see what I mean. All that people are going to associate him with is Filoni's bullshit. They are rewriting Star Wars and they will succeed in burying the EU forever.

    • @rogerpalsgrove9678
      @rogerpalsgrove9678 Год назад

      @@saberiandream316 When they announced Thrawn was going to be in Rebels, in my opinion I thought it was the wrong kind of fan service. I've never read any of the Thrawn books, but I could see what they were doing. I knew then why the de-canonized the EU. I had pretty much checked out of Rebels after the first season as well.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +1

      @@rogerpalsgrove9678 We older fans aren't the primary customer base anymore, it's the drooling idiot demographic who will buy anything, while all the older fans are drifting off into other interests, like Babylon 5, Stargate, Dune, Warhammer 40,000...

    • @sebastianprimomija8375
      @sebastianprimomija8375 Год назад

      ​@@saberiandream316I'm not an older fan I was a toddler when Phantom Menace came out but I've drifted off to Firefly and Stargate.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад

      @@sebastianprimomija8375 Living proof of what I'm saying.

  • @LumVaughan
    @LumVaughan Год назад +4

    Exactly right, Thor, the disaster of Disney SW can also be seen to be due to Lucas, Kennedy, Iger and the rest of the corporate suits or filmmakers not realizing how well loved the SW universe is and how these fans expect QUALITY to the tales told in this universe. Kennedy thought she could be PC and at the same time make fans happy by throwing in cool ships, great special effects, lightsabers, stormtroopers, a few aliens and a droid or two. She thought that the spectacle was all fans care about, the story (she thought) was of secondary importance. It was all about making money and being seen as someone who brought SW forth from the Lucas era into the modern era. Those two things were all Kennedy cared about and she was arrogant enough to think that anything she did would work because she knew the magic formula to make it all work.

  • @bub5842
    @bub5842 11 месяцев назад +1

    I see a lot of rage bait videos. People calling this or that person stupid for ruining star wars, but never this level the approach to the conversation/ insight into the actual good intention, ego, and ultimate failure. This was a fantastic video. I think you absolutely nailed it. Well done you earned a fan.

  • @Leondrius
    @Leondrius Год назад +3

    These guys FUCKED UP! The only thing that comes close to this in my mind was when they killed Newt and Hicks offscreen.

  • @Cletus_the_Elder
    @Cletus_the_Elder Год назад +33

    What Kathleen Kennedy has done cannot be undone. Because we have a canon, her disastrous decisions have ruined the lore for those who began the journey in the Star Wars universe as children. It is a loss of what was magical. What we can do, and what Gina Carano alluded to, is heal and move on from the work of her hands. That is, if the reins are taken from her.

    • @abramsullivan7764
      @abramsullivan7764 Год назад +1

      Yeah I pretty much move on to other things to enjoy.

    • @virajs.8864
      @virajs.8864 Год назад +2

      We’re quoting a nazi sympathizer now?

    • @smartalec2001
      @smartalec2001 Год назад +3

      @@virajs.8864 This is such an out-there thing to say that I genuinely have no idea who you're talking about.

    • @satori2890
      @satori2890 Год назад +1

      We can have the Lucas Trilogy as Animated

    • @IndyDefense
      @IndyDefense Год назад +1

      Canon is and always was what George Lucas decreed. So I dont know why youre saying what she did cant be undone. It would be like saying that Rings of Power ruins the work of JRR Tolkien.

  • @nathanbailey6231
    @nathanbailey6231 11 месяцев назад +3

    I really feel most saddened by the fact that the opportunity to have Han, Luke, and Leia on the screen again was utterly wasted, and we won’t ever get that chance again.

  • @Shane-fd5es
    @Shane-fd5es Год назад +4

    They can call us toxic fan boys all they want. I absolutely will not spend my hard earned money on something that does not have my interest. I'm done arguing with people. If they actually believe the direction they have been heading in is profitable then all i can say is good luck

  • @D-M0N
    @D-M0N Год назад +3

    People need to understand the damage that tfa created
    It was the snowball. It introduced worthless mysteries and broken characters
    Tlj did what it could with the garbage that tfa was. Tfa was the middleman of a telephone game

  • @StoryTeller796
    @StoryTeller796 11 месяцев назад +1

    From what I've learned from nearly every person who's ever worked on a creative project, it is never, *ever* a question of "Can you" because no duh. If you can think of it, you can do it with the right creativity and knowledge on how to do it. It should instead be a question of "Should I?" and for a lot of original projects I would say "yeah, give it a fair swing and see how far you can go. Even if you have to release it and you've realised that you aren't proud of it, no biggie. Just pick up the money and start over on either something else that you prefer or reboot your original property or if some group of people liked it sell it off to them and let them like it if it doesn't hurt anyone."
    However, should you be put in charge of someone else's creative work, treat it with the utmost respect. You shouldn't spoil it rotten if the original concept is arguably kind of bad or offensive and needs a good cleaning and polish in some areas, and you should absolutely *N O T* drag anyone or anything down. Using negativity or destruction on someone else's work is malicious not just to the original work in every sense of the word, but to the creator in their time and energy in creating something that people are passionate about and a waste of time and money to the fans and people who paid to watch a work they trusted you to do a good job on.

  • @douglasmyers5239
    @douglasmyers5239 Год назад +3

    All I can say..all I feel..and I say this with my true love for star wars...is that this is truly sad.😢

  • @Spinozin
    @Spinozin 11 месяцев назад

    Your thumbnail captures it all. George looking at us in that final moment before the fall

  • @Gundam4
    @Gundam4 Год назад +22

    A tiny part of me wants to think that Kennedy had the best of intentions. But she was just overcome by her own hubris. At the same time, there's too much evidence pointing that everything she had done was completely intentional. To serve her own feminist agenda. She had several chances to course correct, but she chose to keep going down the path she believed, and now our once beloved franchises in ruins

  • @mrcat3493
    @mrcat3493 Год назад +8

    I'd really like to know Lucas' inner thoughts on selling to Disney.

    • @donn.4766
      @donn.4766 11 месяцев назад

      Its because of the fans that shitted on his prequels. People don’t know that the prequels were all George Lucas. He poured his heart into those, and “fans” made fun of it and hated it.

    • @mrcat3493
      @mrcat3493 11 месяцев назад

      @@donn.4766 the prequels are not good films though, so there’s that.

    • @donn.4766
      @donn.4766 11 месяцев назад

      @@mrcat3493 i disagree, i thought the prequels were good movies that dove into a lot of the lore of the star wars universe. I guess you only like the original trilogy, because ur saying the prequels suck and the sequels sucked.
      A part of why the original trilogy gets a pass is because it was in a generation with the internet, so criticisms of it wouldn’t be wide spread. And honestly, a lot of the dialogue in the OT are cringey as hell too. Either way, the prequels shit on the sequels.

    • @mrcat3493
      @mrcat3493 11 месяцев назад

      @@donn.4766 the OT was new and fresh at that time period. Yes some of the dialogue is cheesy, but overall the OT is very focused on the story and characters; something that the prequels and sequels don’t do. I’d argue Return of the Jedi is the lesser of the OT with the emphasis on the Ewoks. The current films are much more about the spectacle. And calling the sequels trash in light of the prequels is damning with faint praise.

    • @donn.4766
      @donn.4766 11 месяцев назад

      @@mrcat3493 the prequels are way better than the sequels. They are still george lucas’ star wars. Im not one to watch star wars and expect great acting and drama. Imo, star was is about the deep lore of the universe, the action and the characters. The prequels made jedi’s elite and cool.

  • @joeclaridy
    @joeclaridy Год назад +5

    No Thor, she really wanted to destroy Star Wars and remake it in her own feminists image. She is the worst type, a betrayer.

  • @cadis4257
    @cadis4257 Год назад +6

    When you rake into account the destruction of Indy and Willow alongside stories by once again destroying what came before.
    I believe she really sis intend to destroy SW.
    ANYWAY, SW is a dead franchise at this point. Its too broken to fix and aparhy has pretty much replaced the feeling many once had for this series.

  • @Ten-gd1qh
    @Ten-gd1qh Год назад +5

    I've wondered if George could keep stake in the company and have a creative control clause in the contract
    to use he's ideas first

    • @mycelia_ow
      @mycelia_ow Год назад

      Too late for that, but he should have.

  • @johnpoulton9446
    @johnpoulton9446 Год назад +2

    From those previous statements made by Steven Spielberg about interrupting meetings, not taking notes as asked, trying to put in her opinions etc, it appears she’s had her agenda for years and when she got made head of LF she was using SW as a vehicle for that instead of any interest in the universe George created.

  • @Ten-gd1qh
    @Ten-gd1qh Год назад +5

    Ruin Johnson talks out his back side
    if franchises are toxic don't sign up for a movie that's in a trilogy

    • @alexmartin3143
      @alexmartin3143 11 месяцев назад +1

      I love how he points out the flaw in his own logic making a finale type movie in the MIDDLE movie…

  • @QuestionMan
    @QuestionMan Год назад +2

    Gratefully, the Star Wars that was still exists. I don't need Disney SW to enjoy what was there before it and I can pick and choose what I keep and what I ignore just fine.

  • @mga149
    @mga149 Год назад +5

    I don't think Kennedy intended to destroy Star Wars.
    Any more that Anakin intended to drive the entire galaxy into darkness.

  • @DannsProductions
    @DannsProductions Год назад +15

    Again, you can create female characters and have them be leads but when you don’t do it correctly that’s when I have an issue. You have some great female characters in legends but never wanted to bring them on the big screen.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад

      I really Filoni doesn't make Mara Jade "canon" again, it's not going to be the same, look what he's done to Thrawn, it'll just be a redhead, perhaps even a race-swapped woman, sharing a similar name in a parallel universe.

    • @michaellane5381
      @michaellane5381 Год назад +1

      I still think the worst sins of the sequel movies is they destroyed most of the best female characters to create Rey... Imagine if Audiences got to see real quality female characters in theaters like Mara Jade, Winter, Jaina, or Tahiri... Not a single one of them is now possible in Disney Canon, Jaina because the twins and Anakin being replaced by that toddler Ben who then kills his father, Winter because she lost the twins she babysat and the Alderanian special forces were made to look like morons in Kenobi, Mara Jade for similar reasons in the video, and Tahiri was basically replaced by Disney Canon Boba Fett while also losing her tie to Anakin Solo(as he doesn't exist)... And again, all of these were invalidated by simply the characters and plot in TFA, no other sequel required to screw their canon status.

    • @mycelia_ow
      @mycelia_ow Год назад

      @@saberiandream316 What's the issue with Thrawn? I though his new portrayal was alright tbh.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +1

      @@mycelia_ow As I said, it won't be the same character, just a redhead (or a race-swapped woman since Hollywood hates redheads) sharing the same name. Her story won't be the same, and Filoni contributes to the Marvelization of Star Wars. He says of the EU, "if I'm gonna use it, I don't want to change it, that'd be rude," but that's literally what he's done the whole time. He's not "adapting" the EU at all, and he proudly admits he was doing the "canon bomb" the whole time.

  • @TheBobaJames
    @TheBobaJames Год назад +5

    Every time I see this my heart breaks even more. 0:15

    • @DS9TREK
      @DS9TREK Год назад

      💔💔💔 😭😭😭

  • @StarWarsDecrypted
    @StarWarsDecrypted 11 месяцев назад +1

    You said at the end we can’t say what Star Wars would have been like if Disney didn’t buy it, we can though, just look at the dozens of new novels that got cancelled, like the Jaina books or the Nomi Trilogy, conclusion of Legacy era, Mille video games comics everything, all cancelled, we would have at least had a timeline that we care about carried on and concluded, it’s just sad tbh makes me genuinely sad

  • @SpliffMcInerny-rv5my
    @SpliffMcInerny-rv5my Год назад +6

    It’s time that Lucas be held accountable, too, for being such an easy mark for con artists.

  • @atomiswave1971
    @atomiswave1971 11 месяцев назад +1

    Currently selling all my Disney star wars movies except Rogue. I don't even know why I bought them I was disappointed in them. The fact that Disney + exists and just keeps pushing out mediocre quality has worn me out on Star Wars. It would take a miracle to get me back on board.

  • @teddy_westside81
    @teddy_westside81 Год назад +3

    They don’t hire anyone that knows what makes Star Wars special. All these writers miss the mark. The Original Star Wars movies was the hero’s journey. A perfect story of a hero with flaws, training and overcoming evil. These new shows and movies have no soul in them. Nothing but spectacle. Star Wars is more then light saber fights.

  • @Peepeestorm
    @Peepeestorm Год назад +2

    When it was announced Disney bought Star Wars, I knew it was the beginning of the end. I was called crazy and sure, when the Force Awakens came out, the hype was real but man, I hate how damn right I was. It’s sad.

  • @hawkingjim
    @hawkingjim Год назад +3

    I hate that screen shot of George's face. It always reminds me of that meme "If only you knew how bad it is "

  • @lunalouhoo
    @lunalouhoo Год назад +1

    To think they missed the one chance to have at least ONE FEAKIN' SCENE with all Luke, Leia, Han, and even Chewie...and they didn't even try...they blew that all away... not to mention didn't plan the story...

  • @NisGaarde
    @NisGaarde Год назад +6

    Star Wars is 6 movies made by George Lucas. The end.

  • @Hanoua2
    @Hanoua2 Год назад +1

    "The main thing is to protect these characters and make sure they continue to live in the way that you created them, and that the universe of star wars continues to grow"
    The first movie they release, Luke's jedi academy and all of his student are dead, the new republic and its entire fleet is destroyed, Han Solo is murded... Great

  • @TheTaylor1982
    @TheTaylor1982 Год назад +4

    Disney definitely dropped the ball, no doubt about it.
    Hopefully Rebel Moon will deliver a fresh and exciting space opera story.

    • @mushroomlord2347
      @mushroomlord2347 Год назад +1

      Rebel Moon > SW Sequel Trilogy

    • @daveyalbert4839
      @daveyalbert4839 Год назад

      They're going to combine Barbie the Movie and...
      The Cast of Ghostbusters

    • @officialthomasjames
      @officialthomasjames Год назад +1

      What is Rebel Moon

    • @Ale-dd3ek
      @Ale-dd3ek Год назад

      ​@@officialthomasjamessomething made by Zack Snyder
      Honestly I'm not very optimistic: when he's not adaptating something Zack isn't exceptional
      I only Hope he doesn't spam slow motion and women choirs Every 3 seconds again

  • @michaellane5381
    @michaellane5381 Год назад +2

    He'd have destroyed Rogue 1 "What if we subvert expectations and the rebels DON'T get the plans for the death star? Darth vader just destroys it himself after getting a parking violation."

  • @TexasSlim13
    @TexasSlim13 Год назад +5

    I want to see an alternate timeline where the sequel trilogy had a roadmap and was made by one or two directors for all three instead of each director getting their own movie. I'd also like to see what a Rian Johnson standalone movie would have been like. If he was given something like Rogue One with few or no legacy characters, would the fanbase feel differently about him. Alas, we'll never know, but it's interesting to think about.

    • @achaudhari101
      @achaudhari101 Год назад +1

      We’d be proud fans of the Disney Empire.

  • @Ten-gd1qh
    @Ten-gd1qh Год назад +2

    I bet KK didn't tell George she thought the force was female when they were talking about future plans

  • @crossfire34
    @crossfire34 Год назад +7

    Kennedy's legacy will be one of complete failure. She won't be remember has a great film maker, just the person who truly ruined Star Wars and Indiana Jones.

    • @achaudhari101
      @achaudhari101 Год назад

      Indiana Jones is debatable at best.

    • @crossfire34
      @crossfire34 Год назад +1

      @@achaudhari101 Sure pal. Whatever you say.

    • @achaudhari101
      @achaudhari101 Год назад

      Overhated for dumb reasons.

  • @TheBmb2jn
    @TheBmb2jn Год назад

    The ironic thing of Kathleen Kennedy saying they have no source material to work on is that they indirectly used the source material.
    The Sequel Trilogy was a hybrid between Legacy of the Force and Dark Empire. The story of Kylo Ren was similar to Darth Caedus. Han and Leia's son turn to the Dark Side. And then Dark Empire and Rise of Skywalker was about Palpatine's Ressurection.
    And now, Dave Filoni's Mandoverse is the Thrawn Trilogy. He's making a Heir to the Empire movie.
    And theres rumors about Abeloth being in the Rey New Jedi Order movie.

  • @cuyospartan02
    @cuyospartan02 Год назад +6

    To be fair, Lucas’ decision to sell Lucasfilms to Disney was a really braindead one since the very beginning, there was tons of red flags but he chose to ignore them completely

  • @leonrobinson2053
    @leonrobinson2053 Год назад +1

    She was never a fan because in the clip, she mentions how big it was and that she wanted to be associated but she never said "Yes, I'm a Star Wars fan", which any fan, regardless of subject would say.

  • @chasehedges6775
    @chasehedges6775 Год назад +11

    From the creative masterpiece of George Lucas the to the disaster messterpiece of KK, Jar Jar Abrams, Ruin Johnson and Dave Baloney.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +2

      Funny to finally see people bashing Filoni, I've dreamed of it for years while the fake cowboy got so much undeserved praise.

    • @АлексейМомот-щ7о
      @АлексейМомот-щ7о Год назад +2

      Dave is not even close to being as bad as Rian and JJ. 😂

    • @crossfire34
      @crossfire34 Год назад

      Heh, Dave Baloney. It's dumb, but really funny.

    • @achaudhari101
      @achaudhari101 Год назад +1

      It is dumb because it makes no sense to condemn him like that.

    • @chasehedges6775
      @chasehedges6775 Год назад

      @@achaudhari101 It makes perfect sense

  • @PaulVandersypen
    @PaulVandersypen Год назад +1

    Before KK became the president of Lucasfilm, she and her husband Frank Marshall were arguably the most successful producers in Hollywood history. Now that she is on her own, I suspect that it was Frank who knew how to make movies and Kathy who knew how to get coffee. She can't take the credit for Star Wars' successes (The Force Awakens was always going to make money, and she had little input on Rogue One, Clone Wars, or Mandalorian seasons one and two). All the failures have her fingerprints everywhere (Solo being unwanted by fans, not vetting directors and writers, starting production on various projects only to have them cancelled or drastically changed after lots of time and money, forcing underdeveloped characters into everything). Kathleen Kennedy makes Roger Corman look like a genius.

  • @keithunlimited
    @keithunlimited Год назад +4

    Anyone notice how Ahsoka's story matches up with exactly the story we should be seeing with Luke Skywalker.. from training a new padawan, to chasing down Thrawn.......... to worrying about the legacy of Anakin Skywalker.

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +1

      Then read the EU. I am, I don't know bullshit from Disney or Filoni.

  • @BloodyInitiate
    @BloodyInitiate Год назад

    Dodging the questions is indeed BSing.
    BSing isn’t just being dishonest, it’s misdirection, creating distractions and muddying the waters as well. Delay, distract, obstruct, all while appearing to do your best.
    It’s weird how few people get this. I guess everyone else was a better student than me who got their assignments in on time.

  • @saberiandream316
    @saberiandream316 Год назад +16

    Thor, I get holding Kathleen Kennedy accountable due to chain of command logic, but at the same time, I don't like treating her as a magic fix button, that by removing her, things get better, the way the majority of this community does. Are we being too hard on Kennedy? Because these are DISNEY issues, they are going to outlast her, and fans who think otherwise are in for huge disappointment.

    • @jhallam2011
      @jhallam2011 Год назад +1

      Truth

    • @achaudhari101
      @achaudhari101 Год назад

      @saberiandream316 Well an EU zealot like you is also part of the problem.

    • @michaelmccormick6571
      @michaelmccormick6571 Год назад +9

      She needs to go, it’s an important first step

    • @MetalMilitia83
      @MetalMilitia83 Год назад +6

      Removing her is just the first part, Star Wars can’t change with her having all of the creative power. She is the ruler of the Star Wars properties and she approves everything. She is the main person and we should start with her before moving onto everything else. Writers won’t change if she’s still in charge

    • @saberiandream316
      @saberiandream316 Год назад +1

      @@michaelmccormick6571 What I want most is more EU as Legends stories. I think Disney's the reason that we're not getting it, and without her, nothing substantially changes for me. So I have no vested interest in removing her. But you can sure as hell bet she's choosing her successor.

  • @thechairman74
    @thechairman74 Год назад +1

    Since Johnson was on record from the beginning that he valued being a provocative filmmaker as his most important goal, which is fine for him to aspire to be, for Kennedy to then still hire him shows either complete negligence on her part for not being aware of that desire, or complete contempt for Star Wars thinking that was what the franchise needed. Regardless, she should have lost her job a long time ago.

  • @The-Duggernaut
    @The-Duggernaut Год назад +3

    She definitely didn't do all of this 'on purpose', but it speaks on how horrible of a choice Lucas made to pass his prized and coveted torch to someone that would let it collect dust if it meant she got credit for owning the torch in the first place, and thinking she did something good with it

    • @lupaswolfshead9971
      @lupaswolfshead9971 Год назад +2

      yeah right "the force is female" says that statement is bs

    • @azjim2946
      @azjim2946 Год назад

      I would disagree. She did do it on purpose, except her "purpose" exploded in her face. If the fan base loved what she did, she would be claiming all the credit in the world. Of course, she won't take responsibility for the disaster she caused the franchise.

    • @CaptainGrat75
      @CaptainGrat75 Год назад

      @lupaswolfshead9971
      That was a joke lol, KK is a corporate ghoul who doesnt care about women

    • @mycelia_ow
      @mycelia_ow Год назад

      Her main philosophy is to make money, keep profits flowing which is a perfect choice in Di$ney's eyes. Kennedy was good at that before. Makes one wonder if Lucas really had a choice. We may be getting a new CEO soon anyway.

  • @ioncewasmikey
    @ioncewasmikey Год назад +2

    The Prequel backlash argument has always felt weak to me- it's common knowledge that Lucas was heavily involved with The Clone Wars animated series & was also developing a live action Star Wars tv series. I don't know how so many people seem to forget that when arguing about his reasons for selling.

    • @admiralseabass8993
      @admiralseabass8993 Год назад +1

      it's a weak argument but there is no doubt KK and Disney wante to "fix" the alleged problems of the "prequels"

    • @ioncewasmikey
      @ioncewasmikey Год назад

      @@admiralseabass8993 Oh yeah, that's another matter entirely.

  • @RainSpitter
    @RainSpitter Год назад +1

    I became I Star Wars fan during the prequel era and while I did like the original trilogy and recognized its achievements over the prequels, to me the prequels are those movies that I identify with growing up. Having said that if all the people Lucas could have trust with SW I was baffle about him selling to disney. I didn’t grow up with disney and I always felt like they were to childish and I thought that they were the kind of company that would ignore IP and let it waste away without using it. Never in my wildest dream would I have thought about what they have done to SW. I really think Lucas did it out of spite, specially considering the messaging of the prequels and the original trilogy. Lucas sold to the empire so that we would see what a souldless corporation would do to all entertainment. I think Lucas knew that a lot of the criticism for the prequels was rooted in bough media outlets criticizing him for his success and the fans ate it up, so he showed us by sacrificing SW so we could open our eyes to all the propaganda.

  • @gammonju8615
    @gammonju8615 Год назад +1

    The best way to protect the characters was to leave it alone. I would have liked for them to dive into Old Republic content or a story from the past. It’s unfortunate Kathy and her team went the wrong direction.

  • @CloneScavengerVulpin8389
    @CloneScavengerVulpin8389 Год назад +2

    Just asking but what would have happened if george sold it to cartoon network? Given the fact that the clone wars was originally produced on it's channel.

  • @jamiejones7325
    @jamiejones7325 9 месяцев назад +1

    Lucas NEVER cared. Very first last scene III Obi-wan and R2D2.
    Very 1st scene IV.
    Obi-wan doesn’t recall EVER owning a droid let alone same R2D2.
    Would your English teacher let you get away with that in writing?
    I know, but it’s not just ‘editing’ and ‘continuity’ it’s the very storyline.