Amazing Piano Climaxes and Codas (from Underrated Composers)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 6 фев 2025
  • PART 2: • Part 2: Amazing Piano ...
    Some of the best insane virtuoso piano climaxes and codas, featuring Alkan, Godowsky, and more. We all know our Liszt and Rachmaninov, but the works in this list are all masterpieces as well, so check them out. I already have some ideas for Part 2 - let me know your favorite big moments in the piano literature in the comments!
    Performances:
    No. 1: • Senekeremian Plays Alk...
    No. 2: • Medtner - Sonata Tragi...
    No. 3: • Godowsky: Passacaglia ...
    No. 4: • Medtner - Piano Concer...
    No. 5: • Felix Blumenfeld - Etu...
    No. 6: • Hamelin plays Alkan - ...
    No. 7: • Saint-Saens Piano Conc...
    No. 8: • Franck - Prelude Chora...
    No. 9: • Medtner - Sonata Tragi...
    Inspired by the videos from Music Playlist Central: • Video

Комментарии • 100

  • @tfpp1
    @tfpp1 4 года назад +104

    8:13 - It's actually the 3rd movement, not the 2nd.

    • @alesa351
      @alesa351  4 года назад +28

      You are right of course; this typo has been bugging me since the video's release

  • @Carlitamos
    @Carlitamos 2 года назад +34

    i showed this to my $100 walmart rockjam keyboard and I think it climaxed.

  • @flyingpenandpaper6119
    @flyingpenandpaper6119 4 года назад +92

    12:30 I find it both amusing and fascinating how Medtner simulates the drama of wrong notes by actually writing them in.

    • @zuhairbakdoud1360
      @zuhairbakdoud1360 3 года назад

      Is this a Hanson exercise ....

    • @WEEBLLOM
      @WEEBLLOM 3 года назад +11

      @@zuhairbakdoud1360 ???

    • @rosiefay7283
      @rosiefay7283 2 года назад +7

      Which ones sounded wrong to you? They all sounded fine to me.

    • @junwuwang5701
      @junwuwang5701 2 года назад +5

      They probably mean the F# and G clashes. But the G is actually held from previous bars (as a dominant pedal, though it goes from bass to treble) while bass note descend from F# to Db, the tritone sub. It is still amazing that Medtner decided to highlight that juicy clash though.

  • @Mezzotenor
    @Mezzotenor 4 года назад +36

    Saint-Saens' 2nd concerto underrated? News to me, I thought it's quite popular. And I believe it's the third movement you shared, not the second.

    • @sebastian-benedictflore
      @sebastian-benedictflore 3 года назад +4

      You aren't wrong. It's one of the staple piano concerti. Not many are more famous. Grieg, Rach 2, 3 and pag var, Chopin 1 and 2, maybe Liszt 1 and 2 and a few more maybe.

    • @KingstonCzajkowski
      @KingstonCzajkowski 4 месяца назад

      @@sebastian-benedictflore Beethoven emperor, Tchaikovsky 1, Bach Italian, Prok 2, maybe Brahms 1 and 2, Rhapsody in Blue

  • @uguslife
    @uguslife 6 месяцев назад +1

    I knew there will be Medtner just by the thumbnail! His concertos are so underrated! Piano concerto 3 has the greatest coda ever, but the 1st piano concerto has also many great reason to be on the list!

  • @Medtner26
    @Medtner26 4 года назад +19

    I've been dying to see some godowsky in compilations such as those. FINALLY!

  • @aidankoop2110
    @aidankoop2110 2 года назад +9

    Medtner's first piano concerto is the most amazing thing I have ever heard written for piano

  • @alcyonecrucis
    @alcyonecrucis 2 года назад +9

    Alkan has some sublime moments

  • @onemanmarchingband2995
    @onemanmarchingband2995 5 лет назад +35

    The Coda of the 4th movement of Alkan's Sonatine definitely deserves a spot in another part.

    • @rosiefay7283
      @rosiefay7283 2 года назад +3

      Oh, Alkan wrote so many epic codas. For example, "Quasi-Faust" from Grande Sonate and the finale of the Concerto.

    • @michelangelomarchetti9119
      @michelangelomarchetti9119 4 месяца назад

      @@rosiefay7283 The quasi-Faust is an absolute marvel, a truly stunning composition

  • @samuelholt846
    @samuelholt846 4 года назад +18

    Wow! I’ve never heard the Medtner piano concerto - beautiful! I want to listen to the whole thing now!

    • @sethjeppson5680
      @sethjeppson5680 3 года назад +1

      Have you listened to it? What did you think?

    • @SeigneurReefShark
      @SeigneurReefShark 3 года назад +5

      One of my favorite piano concerto ever! I hope you enjoyed it.

  • @siavashsafari3795
    @siavashsafari3795 Год назад +5

    I am grateful that you chose underrated composers, most of climaxes are new for me

  • @randomcubing7106
    @randomcubing7106 2 года назад +13

    Tbh classical composers have way better chord progressions than us.

  • @bloba6969
    @bloba6969 10 месяцев назад +2

    I really need to dive deeper into Medtner's work

  • @geuros
    @geuros 4 года назад +11

    Surprised to see my favourite piece (Franck) here :-)

  • @williamhu4901
    @williamhu4901 5 лет назад +10

    Great list! Some of my favourites make an appearance here :)

  • @i.ehrenfest349
    @i.ehrenfest349 Год назад +1

    The last Medtner bit is my favourite

  • @utvpoop
    @utvpoop 5 лет назад +21

    You should listen to Balakirev's 1st Scherzo in B minor, IMHO is has epic climax and coda.
    I love these indications in Russian given by Medtner like: 1:51 "Here starts the (разливанная) cantilena" (I can't exaclty translate this word because people don't use it nowadays, but the closest is "broadly flowing"); 12:51 "Don't TAP the upper notes in thirds"

  • @teodorb.p.composer
    @teodorb.p.composer Год назад +3

    Yes, Alkan and Medtner are great, actually they are my most favourite composers ever!

    • @Lavirfra
      @Lavirfra 9 месяцев назад +1

      I have been seeing a lot of this "Medtner" lately. Heard many good things about the composer. Do you have some pieces you can suggest from him for me to listen? I would want to discover this composer.

    • @teodorb.p.composer
      @teodorb.p.composer 9 месяцев назад +2

      @@Lavirfra I suggest his mostly his piano concertos (2nd and 3rd are my favourite), Night wind sonata, Sonata romantica, War sonata in a minor, Opus 11, Violin sonatas (mostly 3rd one), opus 51, etc. He wrote so many great pieces, that it's hard to choose some.

  • @saravia1_
    @saravia1_ 3 года назад +8

    Saint Saëns piano concerto no 2 is standard piano repertoire.

  • @erwinschulhoff4464
    @erwinschulhoff4464 Год назад +3

    Next video:greatest piano edging

  • @zuhairbakdoud1360
    @zuhairbakdoud1360 3 года назад +1

    Thank you, sir. Have a good day.

  • @blahbousblah8886
    @blahbousblah8886 4 года назад +4

    SOUND QUALITY
    nice

  • @intellect376
    @intellect376 2 года назад

    Very enjoyable video!
    Thank you

  • @sergiopellitero4136
    @sergiopellitero4136 4 года назад +6

    Okey I stop playing piano

  • @4grammaton
    @4grammaton Год назад +2

    No Feinberg 3?

    • @KaikhosruShapurjiMedtner
      @KaikhosruShapurjiMedtner 7 месяцев назад

      These are great but I agree that the uploader should’ve added some Feinberg.

  • @Charlie_Miles
    @Charlie_Miles 4 года назад +8

    Saint-Saëns: what am I doing here?

  • @vaadwilsla858
    @vaadwilsla858 Год назад +1

    Really dislike Tozer's Tragica actually. It's played too fast and it becomes muddy and sloppy. Tozer is usually phenomenal (e.g. his rendition of the Minacciosa) but sometimes it's a clear miss.

  • @WD_GX
    @WD_GX Год назад +2

    no one can disagree, the best composer of all time, Alkan

    • @epicaunleashed8764
      @epicaunleashed8764 10 месяцев назад

      Are you on crack???!?! Bach clears all

    • @TFADcmoi
      @TFADcmoi 8 месяцев назад

      I'm sure many people disagree

    • @epicaunleashed8764
      @epicaunleashed8764 8 месяцев назад

      This statement is just preposterous. Nobody worth their salt things this.

    • @WD_GX
      @WD_GX 8 месяцев назад +1

      I'm not sure, but I guess that you didn't hear Alkan's pieces, or you did but only the hard montrous ones, or even that you're a beginner at music (please guys don't think of this is an offensive statement), I recommend you to hear his adagio from his sonate de concert for cello and piano, i guess that it's the best adagio that i've ever heard in my life, you can also search for Alkan's piano trio, the 3rd movement "lentement", or his esquise op 63 no 11 "les soupirs", the piece that inspired Debussy, there just so many underrated pieces by him, and it's a shame that some premiers are just done recently, I even talk about 3 years ago, while Alkan was about 200 years ago

    • @WD_GX
      @WD_GX 8 месяцев назад +1

      and i'm also pretty sure that the petroushka's theme was inspired by Alkan, you can search about Impromptu Opus 32 No. 1 No. 3 “Fantasietta alla Moresca”

  • @terpucom_
    @terpucom_ Год назад

    Is Saint-saens underrated...?????? sounds misleading...

  • @danielhughes441
    @danielhughes441 4 года назад +8

    Saint-Saëns is NOT an underrated composer, and the concerto featured here is one of the standards in the repertoire!

  • @robert-skibelo
    @robert-skibelo 2 года назад +1

    I'm not a great fan of collections of hard loud bits divorced from their musical context. It's a bit too much like vulgar sensationalism. And I doubt the composers would like the thought of being turned into a kind of musical circus.

  • @LalzJeNeSuis
    @LalzJeNeSuis 2 года назад +1

    The only good one is Number 6 imo, Alkan is a beast and he's underestimated.

  • @vincent-ataramaniko
    @vincent-ataramaniko 3 года назад +5

    I can only disagree. The first one is for example a pale imitation of Chopin Scherzo quoda. César Franck is a genius and way above all the others in this video.

    • @Lucmercurius
      @Lucmercurius 3 года назад +1

      Agreed. The first one.. it's terrible. It's the type of piece that seems to have been composed by an AI. People think CODAs must be extemeley fast and full of thousands of notes to be good. When we compare the harmony constructed by Chopin with some of this list.. it is tragic.

    • @vincent-ataramaniko
      @vincent-ataramaniko 3 года назад

      @@Lucmercurius I wouldn't have said it better

    • @rosiefay7283
      @rosiefay7283 2 года назад +3

      @Rexy I agree. The second movement of the Grande Sonate, "Quasi-Faust", is better than the first movement.

    • @lucaslorentz
      @lucaslorentz Год назад +3

      Sure thing, but the medtner pieces in here for instance simply pure gold and saying franck is much abive him is kinda nonsense since they are not comparable and masters at their own craft

    • @stoppelhopser1848
      @stoppelhopser1848 Год назад

      no piece in this list is as good as the passacaglia by godowsky.

  • @danielhughes441
    @danielhughes441 4 года назад +5

    César Franck is NOT an underrated composer, and the work featured here is also a standard in repertoire! GEEZ!

    • @ShuckleDoesGaming
      @ShuckleDoesGaming 4 года назад +17

      You genuinely dont know what underrated means, do you?

  • @Pianova1
    @Pianova1 7 месяцев назад

    Franck is not underrated

  • @zuhairbakdoud1360
    @zuhairbakdoud1360 3 года назад +2

    This is music, not technical exercise....

    • @dzordzszs
      @dzordzszs 3 года назад +4

      Yes

    • @kofiLjunggren
      @kofiLjunggren 3 года назад +7

      Who said that these were just technical excercises?

  • @martinhnilo7961
    @martinhnilo7961 3 года назад +2

    Why underrated composers? There is a difference between technical virtuosity and composers genius. Maybe this codas make effect, but they are just noisy, using too much of ligtning und thunder, but that´s all.

    • @orb3796
      @orb3796 3 года назад +14

      Disagree, these are deeply musical codas

    • @7Volkan6
      @7Volkan6 3 года назад +23

      I know it's hard to accept that these are musical, because that would by default mean that it's you who lack in understanding. But no one understands all music. Even if you are a genius when it comes to one form, like electro, you might be average in another, say bebop. If you're a genius when it comes to Chopin, you might be ignorant when it comes to Cesar Franck. Which is completely okay. Through confrontation one builds an understanding for it, like with wine. But to accuse the debated object of being faulty, that just highlights bias and unwillingness to find fault in self.

  • @maratgubaidullin7788
    @maratgubaidullin7788 3 года назад +1

    Thanks God we hear this moments of piano rubbish so rear. Only Saint-sans has an appropriate coda in that examples.

  • @zuhairbakdoud1360
    @zuhairbakdoud1360 4 года назад +2

    This is not music - it is mere technical exercises...
    We have “pianists” today who play this noise and call themselves musicians...
    I give them one thing, though, they are fit to join the Olympic Games.

    • @pineapple7024
      @pineapple7024 3 года назад +34

      Hey champ, that’s really interesting! Next time, keep it to yourself.

    • @7Volkan6
      @7Volkan6 3 года назад +7

      I genuinely am convinced that you're just a troll and you're knowingly saying things that are stupid.

    • @zuhairbakdoud1360
      @zuhairbakdoud1360 3 года назад

      Pineapple, in the USA we have free speech. Guten Tag. And thank for your message.

    • @pineapple7024
      @pineapple7024 3 года назад +12

      @@zuhairbakdoud1360
      Didn’t know that people in the US didn’t practice common sense, because you left like 3 different comments on something you don’t even enjoy... Gluten day to you too

    • @zuhairbakdoud1360
      @zuhairbakdoud1360 3 года назад

      It must be nice to be smart.

  • @DeeCeeHaich
    @DeeCeeHaich Год назад +1

    they're overrated, should be left to rot in history.

  • @gizmo4453
    @gizmo4453 2 года назад +1

    boring