Anti-Hadith Hadith of Sahih al Bukhari - Quran Talk
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 окт 2022
- Quran Study App: apple.co/2C1YGXj
Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2022/10/13/...
Discord: / discord
Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw
Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE
Twitter: / talkquran
Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid
Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/
QuranTalk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/
Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.gitbook.io/quran-in...
As long as hadits are read, with a grain of salt, as religious literature to get some historical context and information, there's no problem with them and it's easy to tell when they are in harmony with the words and/or spirit of the Qur'an and when they are in contradiction with it.
But if we take them as a source of authority and law on a par or even above the Qur'an, then we are in deep problems.
Great video as usual.
You will get accurate information regarding a topic in QURAN 'the QURAN does not need support 'as soon as you try to get further content from HADITH even if it lines up with QURAN 'you have associated other judgement with ALLAH judgment,
QURAN says in 5-44 if you do not judge what ALLAH revealed than you are the disbeliever.
@@MuslimforAllah. i didn't say you need support from them or you take them as a source of law, don't put words in my mouth. I only said that they are religious litterature that you can get benefit from, when they are in harmony with Qur'an, as you can get benefits from reading many other sources, both Islamic and non islamic. We shouldn't be reading any book or learning from any source beside Qur'an, according to you?
You could not be more incorrect.
They are extremely blasphemous and dangerous and clearly satanic.
@@benfoster5387 i don't deal with extremism. Of any kind.
@@musamusashi I will pray for you.
Praise God. Excellent episode!
MashaAllah. God Alone. Quran Alone
I am always waiting for new videos from this channel. These podcasts are based on facts and intellectuals than emotion and assumptions.
They are based off of ignorance and misguidance based off of that ignorance such as translating محدث as "hadith narrator" rather than "murderer" in the context of that hadith
Great job my man
Alhumdulillah...thanks Brother ...PEACE
MashAllah. God bless you
All hadiths should be doubted
use your own mind is gods advice. that's enough for me.
Just checked it. Wow
Peace be upon you.
If we reject all of the hadiths i think for the sake of consistency, we should not use them at all, even to support our own view as we reject them for not being trusworthy enough. Don't you think ?
So if you mentioned these that means that these are acceptable from Bukhari.
6:42
Reading hadith like reading history is a different matter. Taking hadith as authoritative to the same level (or even any) as the quran is borderline blasphemous.
Fulamuso, if you insist on defending hadith:
Yahoo gnaamaaa (fulani lol) 7 dates and then consume deadly poison afterwards to see if it holds any truth.
Come back when you've done it :)
Salam
Please please please make the app for Android
if he ommited some verses of the Protected Noble Quran like Rashad Kalifa, then this app loses credibility for me.
On a different note, keep on striving with the Quran alone as law
Salam :)
Bukhari had nothing over Imam Malik regarding Hadeeth
hadith worshippers are obviously wrong but Quran only isn't really better. you're basically exchanging bad explanations for no explanations, same problem. not sure why people even argue when the Quran tells us what to do (21:7).
Brother stop this nonsense. Quran is enough and Allah states he alone guides as he pleases. Its not upon the Messenger to Guide.
You misinterpreted the verse to suit your beliefs.
21:7
And We sent not before you, [O Muḥammad], except men to whom We revealed [the message], so ask the people of the message [i.e., former scriptures] if you do not know.
He was not the first. Many great hadeeth scholars before him.
Sahih means correct or accurate.
Authentic is Muathaq.
Written in this paper... is a clear forgery... paper wasn't available to ali at that time
Peace the Arabic is الصَّحِيفَةِ which means pages. It does not mean literally paper. This term is also used in Quran towards the teachings of Abraham as well as Moses that came before the Quran.
[87:18] This is recorded in the earlier al-suhuf.
(١٨) إِنَّ هَـٰذَا لَفِى ٱلصُّحُفِ ٱلْأُولَىٰ
[87:19] The suhuf of Abraham and Moses.
(١٩) صُحُفِ إِبْرَٰهِيمَ وَمُوسَىٰ
How i perform salat using only Quran. Please clarify me
Salam,
I got you bro :)
Read when you have time!
(Ps: bear in mind the prayers were performed even before Prophet Muhammad by Muslims all around the world. Prophet Abraham is the first of the Muslims after all :)
{Quran 20:130}
Before rising fajr
|~
Before setting of sun (Asr)
|~
From the hours of the night (any) {Isha’a)
|~
Ends of the day(sunrise-sunset) {fajr-maghrib}
|~
{Quran 50:39}
Before rising and before setting (fajr & Asr)
Quran 50:40
Of the night (Isha)
{Quran 30:17}
When evening is reached {Maghrib)
morning is reached (fajr)
|~~
{Quran 30:18}
At night {Isha}
At noon {Dhuhr }
Quran 11:114
Ends of day { fajr&maghrib}
Approach of night {Asr}
Quran 2:238
Many& the middle ?
Quran 24:58
Dawn prayer fajr
Noon prayer Dhuhr
Night prayer Isha’a
Quran 3:41
In the evening ?
Morning ?
Quran 17:78
Decline of the sun (asr)
Till darkness of night(maghrib&isha?)
Quran 13:15
Mornings (fajr?
Afternoons (asr)
In conclusion, there appears to be
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||| 5 Prayers ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||daily, to the best of my knowledge. May Allah guide his humble servant to the truth, Ameenn
Great question, Brother. Ive asked the same question and then decided to do my due diligence and see for my self. I have gone thru the entire 'Book of Prayers' in sahi Bukhari and sahi Muslim. I concluded that its impossible to reconstruct prayer thru these hadith, and also if you read these hadith, you will realize the Prophet(PBUH) never taught them prayer until they annoyed him immensely.
If you can locate full prayer from either bukhari or muslim, please advise us and send link. I can provide my email if more convenient, i just want to get to the bottom of this.
Lastly, bukhari was quoted saying he performed 2 rakat prayers prior to recording each narration, how did he know how to pray?
@jimmybeam1550 the salah was part of a living tradition that was known before the Quran was revealed. This is why no details are mentioned in the Quran. The hadiths don't contain any details either about salah.
@@hassanabdur-rahman1559 thats exactly the point im trying to make. They try justifying the importance of hadith as if prayer wouldn't have existed without it. Prayer existed prior to any hadith and would exist with or without hadith. Hadith doesn't even full detail prayer. If you were to read entire Book of Prayers in Sahi Bukhari or sahi Muslim youd realize the narrators are only guessing and weren't even fully aware of prayer themselves.
@@peace_seeker5545 thank you brother. Even though I was aware of all these verses, Its still nice to see posts such as this, some of us actually recite the Quran and are mindful of the words of our Lord.
Unfortunately many miss the meaning of these simple verses. Most of the muslim ummah are led astray with the advent of tafsir, a form of brainwash by manipulating the meanings and moulding the minds from truly grasping the content.
Eid Mubarak and stay blessed, Peace!
You cannot even pronounce the word Sahih صحيح you really have to understand before you speak just study Many of your points are well taken but you're overall conclusion is wrong because you have not studied enough.
For all those whom you mislead will be on your shoulder
I hope you've conclusively figured out how or why the injeel and Torah became corrupted. Going by your statement I'm almost for certain you have came to a conclusion about the previous scriptures being corrupted because it's stated in the Quran. Meanwhile without ever investing real time or effort to find out why or how they were corrupted. Alhamdullah for the Quran.
Are you defending the unverifiable hadiths against the Protected Quran?
God brings Torah.
People corrupt it and add their own stuff.
God brings Injil.
People corrupt it and add their own stuff.
God brings a protected Quran.
People can't corrupt it and add their own stuff.
People think of a way to add to it to corrupt it.
They make a separate book, call it Hadith and make it mandatory for Islam.
People are tricked by Satan and believe in it.
"Except a few" - Quran in many places.
The jews, athiests, christians are very happy with this videos.
Good then they will become muslims
None non muslim give a damn about hadith honestly
This is blatant dishonesty.
The word mentioned in 12:22 is not "hadith" (حديث) but rather is "hadath" (حدث), which means many different things but in this contexts means a murderer, not a hadith narrator.
The problem with many hadith rejectors is unfortunately a lot of you guys just really don't know the Arabic language well at all, which is a shame because knowing Arabic well with all you to understand and appreciate the Quran tat you claim to only follow better.
Hassan Farhan doesn't know Arabic also then? Do you speak the same as the prophet?
I don't know whom or what specifically you are referring to but yes I am Arabic and alhamdulillah speak Arabic fluently and yes even Fusha and prefer using it over my dialect.
If you are referring to Hasan bin Farhan al-Maliki then he believes in hadiths and quotes them and refers to them all of the time. He just doesn't believe in blindly accepting all of Bukhari, etc. I've watched many many hours of his content and he is an interesting and knowledgeable man (even if I disagree on some things) and isn't a hadith rejecter like you guys.
أنا لا أعرف من أو ماذا تقصد ولكني عربي ونعم ولله الحمد أتقن اللغة العربية وبالذات الفصحى وأفضّلها على لهجتي.
وإن كنت تقصد حسن بن فرحان المالكي فالرجل لا ينكر الاحتجاج بالأحاديث بل هو يأخذ بها بشروطه وإنما لا يقبل كل ما في صحيح البخاري وغيره.
أنا استمعت إلى ساعات من منشوراته وأراه رجلًا عالمًا ومفكرًا ممتعًا وإن كنت اختلفت معه في بعض الأشياء
@@rarebreed748
@@user-ls8ks7kv8c how many times did he say to pray? Yes may Allah reward him
I don't recall him ever saying anything about it not being 5 times a day?
Unless you have proof of him saying otherwise? @@rarebreed748
Brothers and sisters do not follow this channel