@@jojogo22 just think if it was the conservatives that lost a court ruling these would have exploded with accusations and bad mouthing Pierre for being such a heal, but no think nothing of the court ruling Trudeau will win appeal, this group is 100%pro liberal/ndp hopefuls
"Rouleau" was not picked because he was a "LEARNED JUDGE".... he was picked because he was a part of the Trudeau Foundation. He ruled exactly as he was directed to rule. Now a real judge has expressed what we all knew already.
Buy off for uncle Rouleau. He must go along with Trudeau, Freeland and Jagmeet. Free Tamara the hero. Give Trudeau jail with no bail. Treat him like Tamara ,Chris and others need to SUE the con artists.
The Judge upheld Canadian Law, as he saw it written in the Emergencies Act! The Canadian interests will be decided by the Supreme Court of Canada, and just so EVERYONE is clear! EVERYONE agrees that the Freedummies had to be removed, this is a legal argument over the rules and guidelines that they were removed under! The judge even said that the Freedummies rights were NOT infringed when removed, it was the freezing of bank accounts that he thought was an infringement!
As soon as you wrote Freedummies you ruined any chance of anyone taking you seriously. These were Canadian citizens engaged in a peaceful protest and whether you agree with them or not they have their rights and freedoms as outlined in the Canadian Constitution. If they are denied their rights we all risk being denied our rights in the future.
Tractors blockading capitals in Germany and Holland are examples that governments DO NOT invoke Emergency Acts, but actually listen to protester concerns.
@@DafinaMarkowa Judge is not wrong. Freezing people's bank accounts because they don't agree with you is literally fascist tactic. Trudeau and all trudeau supporters will be proven on the wrong side of history. it sets a dangerous precedent to freeze anyones bank accounts for anything. You are pro Palestine freeze their account. It might start in your advantage but soon enough all oppressive rules turn against everyone equally.
No it really has to be appealed to the Supreme Court so we have a precedent setting ruling. That way future governments have a baseline on the use of the Emergencies Act.
The problem is... in Canada 76% of the upper legal system Judges etc. are Liberals, or Liberal appointees so you only get real justice from the remaining 24% - "do you feel lucky" should be the moto when you go to court here in Commie Canada.
6:00 Robert Benzie of The Toronto Star made some truly idiotic remarks. Dragging the trucks into the Ottawa River? Tear gas? From a newspaper that saw nothing wrong with the ongoing Tamil protests a decade ago; that seemed to have no objections to the blockading of the Gardiner - on more than one occasion - by these same Tamil protestors; that has not spoken up about the recent blockading of the Avenue Road and 401 bridge, or the invasion of The Eaton Centre. The Star is very selective in the protests it supports, and those it will not tolerate. Oh, and Benzie qualifies his remarks with “I’m glad that didn’t happen.” No he’s not. That he could even imagine such actions . . . .
Robert Benzie: WAKE UP!! Trudeau’s finest moment is yet to come. It’s the moment he is walked out of the House of Commons as NOT the Prime Minister. This decision is a huge negative for him and his flunkies.
Well, let's remember that Harper fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors, EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million. I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power. The system works.
It's incredible the news in Canada doesn't think there's anything wrong of shutting down the truckers and Justin Trudeau not walk in out and try to talk to them. It's absolutely disgusting the news in Canada.
Well, let's remember that Harper fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors. EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million. I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power. The system works.
Its bigger than this . Trudeau , David Lametti , Menchinciohio , and Chrystia Freeland illegally and unconstitutionally took away the civil rights from sovereign Canadian Citizens . .
@@carlosgaspar8447: It's well past time that Canadians refuse to continue supporting this corrupt de facto system or to pay for their corporate debts.
Yes there will be taxpayer money involved if they win with a lawsuit. The politician's are immune from prosecution while in office, while preforming their duties.
None of this discussion is actually about “hey so maybe the govt was wrong to seize protestor bank accounts?” Instead this is just a discussion about public relations and whether the Liberals can stay “on message” (the message being that they will seize your bank account if you protest them too much).
@@robertolsen4140 No, she won't. She stands by her decision. Also Freeloader?! Where do you guys come up with these? Like it's kind of similar to Freeland, but.. like.. it's a stretch. Doesn't really roll off the tongue. Not like PP. PP just rolls off the tongue like molasses.
It was the right decision, but it should have been done properly via legislation changing the reporting rules for FINTRAC. Foreign organizations should not be able to raise $$ for protest groups without registering with the lobbying commisioner. Cough, cough Tides Canada
He must realize that we no longer have a constitution in Canada. It's not worth the paper and sprinted on and completely and totally ignored, along with the Canadian bill of rights and freedoms. They mice as well be in file 13.
I don't see how having guns, thousands of rounds of ammunition, pipe bombs, and blasting truck horns 24/7 causing noise damage and sleep deprivation to residents is "peaceful". And that's just some of the things they did! But, hey, you keep getting your information from conspiracy theory sites! Seems to be working out well for you. You're not in the mental hospital yet!
Justice Mosley gave a well reasoned judgement today. “I have concluded that the decision to issue the Proclamation (of the Emergencies Act) does not bear the hallmarks of reasonableness - justification, transparency and intelligibility - and was not justified." No, it wasn’t OK for the federal government to commandeer banks and perform account seizures.
Are you kidding me? “No other country would tolerate the trucks blocking…”. Do you have no idea what’s going on in Germany and in the Netherlands just to name two countries, where there’s blockades right now?
They couldn't do their jobs without vaccines. They couldn't cross the borders all of a sudden. They were protesting their rights. See your house? A truck brought the supplies to build it. See your fridge? a truck brought it. See your food in your fridge? A truck brought it. The table you eat at the car you drive trucks brought that.
Well, let's remember that Harper fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors, EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million. I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power. The system works.
If this was a trial at which someone had been found guilty of a crime by the Court, that lack of remorse would not help them at sentencing. The government should be ashamed of itself.
Doug Ford, the OPP and OPS should be ashamed of themselves. This was a colossal failure of several levels of government and should never had made it to Trudeau's desk. It should've been stopped but Dougie went snowmobiling instead.
Well, let's remember that Harper fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors, EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million. I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power. The system works.
Honestly, I expected the supreme court to side with Trudeau. I had lost hope, but this ruling makes me hopeful for our country. Now we just need to show the liberals the door next election.
Well, let's remember that Harper fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors, EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million. I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power. The system works.
Mulcair is the only one on the panel for whom I had respect. Note: *Had* He backed Jagmeet Singh voting for the Emergency Measures Act. He's as bad as any of them and my disappointment is profound.
Also, to say that the protesters claimed they wouldn’t leave until they changed the govt, and to say that the govt couldn’t do anything with existing legislation is ridiculous. The convoy organizers’ primary goal was to end the mandates, not change the govt. And the govt’s ONLY reaction appears to have been the invocation of the EA. But I’m used to seeing Mulcair blather on like that.
@@darrellskinner5263: their Memorandum Of Understanding said otherwise. Unfortunately the govt gave them the opportunity to retract it instead of using it to charge them with insurrection.
Of course the Toronto star guys take is the dumbest. The public hearing was done to determine if the government satisfied the conditions that needed to be met to reach their decision to envoke the act. It was not done to determine if the government actions were legal. The ruling today from a federal court found that the governments actions violated the constitution, unreasonable and illegal. This isn't a situation where one judge ruled one way and the other ruled the other way because one judges ruling is legal decision based on facts the of the case, the other was an opinion on how the government handled the situation. But this is what happens when so called "journalists" receive government subsidies, refuse to ignore their bias when covering news, and who's egos make it physically impossible to accept they were wrong about something.
Just like his ski and cottage buddy who sat on Trudeau foundation until he, David Johnson was picked to investigate his old friend Trudeau. See what happens when it’s not a hand picked friend of Trudeau’s, we actually get the correct rulings.
He didn't commit any crime. What about when premiers invoke the not wis standing clause do they commit a crime. No because the law exists and when they use it they breach peoples rights and they have 5 years to correct the problem.
Well, let's remember that Harper fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors, EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million. I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power. The system works.
Tom, interesting choice of words? "Over throw the government ". Some who live in the real world, might say that it has been the government that is trying to " over throw " Canadian citizens. I would add, that I don't mean the truckers. The government seems to be " minding My business" way more than it should, to somewhat quote the future prime Minister.
@@keithhannah8695 My favourite flavour is urine. As in.. urine a pretty warped place mentally and I think you should reevaluate the direction you're headed before it's too late.
Invoking the emergency act, suspending charter rights should always be something that should haunt any government. They should prove again and again that the decision was justified snd not something that was done spur of the moment. I am very glad that the court decision went the way it did. I am glad that we will be talking about the convoy for the foreseeable future.
I think there is enough information that shows Canadians have lost confidence in this government. The Liberal Party and more importantly the NDP should call an election to let Canadians decide on a new mandate.
Well, let's remember that Harper fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors, EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million. I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power. The system works.
The difference is this decision was made by someone not paid by or a friend of Trudeau or a member of the Trudeau Foundation... A truthful decision for a change !!👍🍁
Just to be clear, today’s federal ruling overrides the public inquiry ruling. You can stop bringing it up to try show a contrast, it’s meaningless unless they win in federal appeals court which they won’t since this wasn’t a national emergency. You guys did give me a chuckle with your biased spin though, nice work!
When Trudeau try's to paint Pierre as a convoy sympathizer as a slanderous allegation, which side of history do you want to be on now! This will be a Pierre campaign ad for sure!
Well, let's remember that Harper (with Pierre) fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors, EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million. I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power. The system works.
Trudeau will not resign his ego is too big. He gets another raise on April 1st. The vacation to Jamaica was not pre- approved by the ethics commissioner.
It's nice your network is finally seeing the light with regards to our government. However I remember your coverage of the convoy and your fervor to go after protestors. We all remember
So when does the non-confidence vote happen so that Canadians can move on from this veil of “we are doing all these things for Canadian’s” while applying taxes to the point where I am ready to leave?😢
Yes you sure can. That’s why they want to appeal this courts ruling too, to skirt liability and from having to pay out millions of dollars and the banks can be sued too. There is nothing in the Emergencies act that gives them the right to freeze bank accounts. They needed probable cause and then a warrant to get private citizens banking information. A total breach of public trust and a breach of many privacy laws.
a proccess is already in the works to give money to those whose bank accounts were seized by the govt dring the slam down by trudeau on the convoy..look for it@@tammyrobinson5249
![LAVROV's interview with Tucker CARLSON 😁 [Parody]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mbMemqc-QEk/mqdefault.jpg)
![Chris Langan - The Interview THEY Didn't Want You To See - CTMU [Full Version; Timestamps]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9miVG2xT5jY/mqdefault.jpg)
Unimaginable trampling of Canadians rights. Hearing that they will appeal is disturbing.
I always imagined it would end up this way. Justin was always going to end in disaster.
Trudeau would spend 30 billion to try to prove he was right. Our money means nothing to him.
@@grandmufftwerkin9037 GET YOUR POPCORN :D
@@Temp-md7pn not sure if you're making fun or stating that you vote for a criminal racist.
The Supreme Court may or may not even accept an appeal.
Why am I hearing from these totally out of touch champagne socialites on these matters?
My thoughts exactly.
@@jojogo22 just think if it was the conservatives that lost a court ruling these would have exploded with accusations and bad mouthing Pierre for being such a heal, but no think nothing of the court ruling Trudeau will win appeal, this group is 100%pro liberal/ndp hopefuls
most up there are liberal meat riders lol.
It’s entertaining, how out to lunch they are
"Peoples rights were unreasonably restricted" ya think. I'm positive the Canadians trampled by horse and assaulted by riot police would agree.
"Rouleau" was not picked because he was a "LEARNED JUDGE"....
he was picked because he was a part of the Trudeau Foundation.
He ruled exactly as he was directed to rule.
Now a real judge has expressed what we all knew already.
Buy off for uncle Rouleau. He must go along with Trudeau, Freeland and Jagmeet. Free Tamara the hero. Give Trudeau jail with no bail. Treat him like Tamara ,Chris and others need to SUE the con artists.
FINALLY a judge upholds Canadian interests
Yes it’s about time
The Judge upheld Canadian Law, as he saw it written in the Emergencies Act! The Canadian interests will be decided by the Supreme Court of Canada, and just so EVERYONE is clear! EVERYONE agrees that the Freedummies had to be removed, this is a legal argument over the rules and guidelines that they were removed under!
The judge even said that the Freedummies rights were NOT infringed when removed, it was the freezing of bank accounts that he thought was an infringement!
You are seriously unhinged. I guess you live in Ottawa @@chrishogan8125
@chrishogan8125 Thanks for the insite Trudeaudummy. We were fighting for the rights of all Canadians.
As soon as you wrote Freedummies you ruined any chance of anyone taking you seriously. These were Canadian citizens engaged in a peaceful protest and whether you agree with them or not they have their rights and freedoms as outlined in the Canadian Constitution. If they are denied their rights we all risk being denied our rights in the future.
Tractors blockading capitals in Germany and Holland are examples that governments DO NOT invoke Emergency Acts, but actually listen to protester concerns.
Not sure what you saw that but it never happened!
@@WildMan576
Do you rectally insert your Trudeau bobblehead each morning? 🙃
@@antoniof72It happened last week.
But the protests in Germany are against far right extremism, whereas the Convoy was in favour of it. So. There's a difference.
@@thimblemunch24 It's actually ongoing.
The fact they are appealing is actually disturbing.
There is nothing to appeal . There never was a Threat to Canada 's National Security .
Can never take responsibility the Liberal's logo..
On the contrary. The judge is wrong.
@@DafinaMarkowa Judge is not wrong. Freezing people's bank accounts because they don't agree with you is literally fascist tactic. Trudeau and all trudeau supporters will be proven on the wrong side of history. it sets a dangerous precedent to freeze anyones bank accounts for anything. You are pro Palestine freeze their account. It might start in your advantage but soon enough all oppressive rules turn against everyone equally.
Disgusting they are going to waste our tax dollars to try and clean up the mess they made.
Freezing bank accounts is criminal. Other protests that blocks supply chains doesn't get the same treatment. That's the main difference
yes and the government has the gall to appeal an unlawful act. This woman is crazy saying they should appeal.
Supply chains Blockers and Protesters never BLOCK FOR 3 WEEKS TO A MONTH ; that's the BBIG DIFFERENCE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
No it really has to be appealed to the Supreme Court so we have a precedent setting ruling. That way future governments have a baseline on the use of the Emergencies Act.
@@TimDyck They had a base line its called an emergency only Stevie Wonder couldnt see that.
About time we had a judge with some common sense !
Or knew how to apply the law we have in Canada.
@@jacobsladder827 same thing
Trudeau is banking on all his Liberal Judges to bail him out.
The problem is... in Canada 76% of the upper legal system Judges etc. are Liberals, or Liberal appointees so you only get real justice from the remaining 24% - "do you feel lucky" should be the moto when you go to court here in Commie Canada.
6:00 Robert Benzie of The Toronto Star made some truly idiotic remarks. Dragging the trucks into the Ottawa River? Tear gas? From a newspaper that saw nothing wrong with the ongoing Tamil protests a decade ago; that seemed to have no objections to the blockading of the Gardiner - on more than one occasion - by these same Tamil protestors; that has not spoken up about the recent blockading of the Avenue Road and 401 bridge, or the invasion of The Eaton Centre. The Star is very selective in the protests it supports, and those it will not tolerate. Oh, and Benzie qualifies his remarks with “I’m glad that didn’t happen.” No he’s not. That he could even imagine such actions . . . .
Trudou could have just went out and talked to the truckers, but he was too much of a coward to do that
His COVID infection was impeccably timed.
Don't forget arrogant
He was more of a narcissistic, arrogant, smartarse than a coward......on this occasion anyway. I do agree he does have a great big yellow streak also.
learn how to spell trudeau please
@@mattmcneill3669 you are right there. It's actually spelt Dildeau
Robert Benzie: WAKE UP!! Trudeau’s finest moment is yet to come. It’s the moment he is walked out of the House of Commons as NOT the Prime Minister. This decision is a huge negative for him and his flunkies.
Can the Toronto Star guy be more pro Trudeau!
It's Toronto Star, of course he is pro Trudeau
Should be called the Toronto Liberal Star.
How low can he get!
What he says about the ruling…IS BAD for the government…so to pop your balloon MrToronto Star
Well, let's remember that Harper fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors, EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million.
I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power.
The system works.
It's incredible the news in Canada doesn't think there's anything wrong of shutting down the truckers and Justin Trudeau not walk in out and try to talk to them. It's absolutely disgusting the news in Canada.
He thinks he is above them, that's why he wouldn't talk to them.
Well, let's remember that Harper fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors. EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million.
I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power.
The system works.
Canada is a disgusting country, wake up. Try not to trip on a homeless Canadian on your way to work.
Its bigger than this . Trudeau , David Lametti , Menchinciohio , and Chrystia Freeland illegally and unconstitutionally took away the civil rights from sovereign Canadian Citizens .
.
Bought and paid for opinions with your tax dollars.
Freeland has about as much credibility as Trudeau himself.
Which is zilch....both of them are repulsive and draconian.
she's much worst. She's a russian studies major. no economic background.
Even less she is managing the country is so Dumb and she is very nine 🧙🧙🧙🧙🧙🧙.We have to get rid of both of them.Oh we can forget all the ministers
Zero times zero is still zero
NO credibility for the so called liables
There should be no appeal with taxpayer money!
more like unlimited public funds.
@@carlosgaspar8447: It's well past time that Canadians refuse to continue supporting this corrupt de facto system or to pay for their corporate debts.
Yes there will be taxpayer money involved if they win with a lawsuit. The politician's are immune from prosecution while in office, while preforming their duties.
Look up the word insular, then look in the mirror. @@Temp-md7pn
what are you talking about?@@Temp-md7pn
None of this discussion is actually about “hey so maybe the govt was wrong to seize protestor bank accounts?” Instead this is just a discussion about public relations and whether the Liberals can stay “on message” (the message being that they will seize your bank account if you protest them too much).
That bank account seizing was Freeloader's idea. She was so proud of herself. Now she will be whistling a different tune !
@@robertolsen4140 No, she won't. She stands by her decision. Also Freeloader?! Where do you guys come up with these? Like it's kind of similar to Freeland, but.. like.. it's a stretch. Doesn't really roll off the tongue. Not like PP. PP just rolls off the tongue like molasses.
@@stratford374 i can tell you're enjoying trudeau's commie dystopia
Exactly! They only care about the politics not the country. It’s so sad.
It was the right decision, but it should have been done properly via legislation changing the reporting rules for FINTRAC. Foreign organizations should not be able to raise $$ for protest groups without registering with the lobbying commisioner. Cough, cough Tides Canada
And instead Poilievre goes and listens to their concerns. Canadians are allowed to protest!
Absolutely, but they're NOT allowed to have an "occupation", and shut down a city!
@@chrishogan8125 apparently the law does not agree with you
@@chrishogan8125
Oh please, the city was not shut down.
@@OceanFrontVilla3 Sure bud, you tell yourself whatever you have to, to satisfy your point of view.
Lol the bot or 50cent army deleted their post...
you forgot it was also deemed "Unconstitutional"
And illegal
He must realize that we no longer have a constitution in Canada. It's not worth the paper and sprinted on and completely and totally ignored, along with the Canadian bill of rights and freedoms. They mice as well be in file 13.
Mr Trudeau... 'Canadian values' are something you sorely lack. You also lack shame.
We will never forget what you did to peaceful protestors.
Or with the planidemic response.
@@Temp-md7pn Talking to yourself again?
I don't see how having guns, thousands of rounds of ammunition, pipe bombs, and blasting truck horns 24/7 causing noise damage and sleep deprivation to residents is "peaceful". And that's just some of the things they did! But, hey, you keep getting your information from conspiracy theory sites! Seems to be working out well for you. You're not in the mental hospital yet!
Is that you, Chrystia?
@@Temp-md7pn
Trudeau thinks MARXIST and dictatorial are Canadian values because he learned at Daddy's knee!
It's about time the Feds are accountable for their actions...
Justice Mosley gave a well reasoned judgement today. “I have concluded that the decision to issue the Proclamation (of the Emergencies Act) does not bear the hallmarks of reasonableness - justification, transparency and intelligibility - and was not justified." No, it wasn’t OK for the federal government to commandeer banks and perform account seizures.
used covid to avoid a vote through the legislature,
Commandeer banks? Account seizures? You mean how they froze a couple bank accounts?
@@stratford374you new?
@@stratford374 bank accounts of major donors were also frozen, and you could not support the movement using patreon or give send go.
@@stratford374couple of bank accounts? Ok commie…
Are you kidding me? “No other country would tolerate the trucks blocking…”. Do you have no idea what’s going on in Germany and in the Netherlands just to name two countries, where there’s blockades right now?
They are "stuck on stupid" - Trudeau fans!
They couldn't do their jobs without vaccines. They couldn't cross the borders all of a sudden. They were protesting their rights. See your house? A truck brought the supplies to build it. See your fridge? a truck brought it. See your food in your fridge? A truck brought it. The table you eat at the car you drive trucks brought that.
The Toronto Star kisses Trudeau ass 24/7.
They say anything to make their point hoping Canadians are dumb enough to go along.
The funny part is they just reported on the German protest a couple days ago.
Trudeaus finest moment, are you insane?
saying that that was trudeaus finest moment says so much about u
It sure does! I agree 100%
I cringed when I heard him say that. What a clown hey?
That's rite !.Trudeau is a liar and a coward ..
He has never had a finest moment.. ever
trudeau;s finest moment will be the day he leaves
for prison@@PeterthePiper777
Trudeau and Freeland should be charged. Our Rights and our laws have to be obeyed by all.
The judge also said in the ruling that had he been in the room he would of voted for the EA.
Anyone who was paying attention and not paid by PM knew that EA was overstepping!
@@Temp-md7pn We know you have daddy issues. Just go and get the help you need, little one.
Especially when he was roasted in the EU parliament for it LMAO
Well, let's remember that Harper fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors, EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million.
I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power.
The system works.
If this was a trial at which someone had been found guilty of a crime by the Court, that lack of remorse would not help them at sentencing. The government should be ashamed of itself.
Doug Ford, the OPP and OPS should be ashamed of themselves. This was a colossal failure of several levels of government and should never had made it to Trudeau's desk. It should've been stopped but Dougie went snowmobiling instead.
Well, let's remember that Harper fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors, EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million.
I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power.
The system works.
Trudeau and Freeland should be charged. Our Rights and our laws have to be obeyed by all. trudeau is not above the law
Court and most of Canada: what you did was unconstitutional.
Freeland: I feel we did the right thing.
Her grandfather made his fortune on confiscated Jewish property.
Read books!
c'mon Mulcair, Rouleau gave a soft decision, Mosley was solid in his decision
Honestly, I expected the supreme court to side with Trudeau. I had lost hope, but this ruling makes me hopeful for our country. Now we just need to show the liberals the door next election.
I’m confused 😳! Is Trudo still our prime minister? The court got something right , right in front of him I guess he forgot to tell them how to rule
He was on holiday and forgot about it!
@Temp-md7pn I never voted for him ever and I would NEVER VOTE FOR THAT CORRUPT CLOWN!..im a firmer liberal by the way!
@Temp-md7pn: OK BOOTLICKER.💩🤡
The judge was not a uncle brother in law or ski buddy
Well, let's remember that Harper fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors, EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million.
I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power.
The system works.
They have been protesting in Germany for weeks, as they did in Holland, no emergency act then
Time to jail these crooks
Trudeau needs to now face criminal prosecution.
Such an act of authoritarianism should never go unpunished in a free and democratic country.
Mulcair is the only one on the panel for whom I had respect.
Note: *Had*
He backed Jagmeet Singh voting for the Emergency Measures Act.
He's as bad as any of them and my disappointment is profound.
Also, to say that the protesters claimed they wouldn’t leave until they changed the govt, and to say that the govt couldn’t do anything with existing legislation is ridiculous. The convoy organizers’ primary goal was to end the mandates, not change the govt. And the govt’s ONLY reaction appears to have been the invocation of the EA. But I’m used to seeing Mulcair blather on like that.
@@darrellskinner5263: their Memorandum Of Understanding said otherwise. Unfortunately the govt gave them the opportunity to retract it instead of using it to charge them with insurrection.
They asked for tanks and the military refused. It could have been much uglier. They also never spoke to them.
Of course the Toronto star guys take is the dumbest.
The public hearing was done to determine if the government satisfied the conditions that needed to be met to reach their decision to envoke the act.
It was not done to determine if the government actions were legal.
The ruling today from a federal court found that the governments actions violated the constitution, unreasonable and illegal.
This isn't a situation where one judge ruled one way and the other ruled the other way because one judges ruling is legal decision based on facts the of the case, the other was an opinion on how the government handled the situation.
But this is what happens when so called "journalists" receive government subsidies, refuse to ignore their bias when covering news, and who's egos make it physically impossible to accept they were wrong about something.
Benzies ....what joke ..the ( other) judge was a family friend appointed by the guilty one
Just like his ski and cottage buddy who sat on Trudeau foundation until he, David Johnson was picked to investigate his old friend Trudeau. See what happens when it’s not a hand picked friend of Trudeau’s, we actually get the correct rulings.
You guys wanted to declare the emergency before the truckers even got to Ottawa. What about the tanks/ tank you wanted to use on the protestors.
Exactly right.
Maybe Freeland should have talked to a lawyer not just colleagues “and many others” before they implemented the War measures act.
She wanted this so bad she was twitching at the thought. Not surprising when you read about her background.
They will never admit they were wrong!
The guy from Toronto star is trapped in a toxic Trudeau bubble .
Tiananmen Trudeau must be held accountable.
Nice. 😎
@@Temp-md7pn No he won't? Or, "Nope. He's innocent." The former rather than the latter.
@@Temp-md7pn
Dope?
@@Temp-md7pn Trudumb! Is that you??
What about Grandma's bank account?
Jackboot Justin trampled all over the nation.
Lol those that " feel" their rights were violated . The fact these clowns cant read the room is astonishing
This Mr. Benzie is delusional
Trudeau needs to be sentenced for his crimes
He didn't commit any crime. What about when premiers invoke the not wis standing clause do they commit a crime. No because the law exists and when they use it they breach peoples rights and they have 5 years to correct the problem.
@@Temp-md7pnyou smoke meth?
You need to be sentenced
Well, let's remember that Harper fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors, EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million.
I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power.
The system works.
@@Temp-md7pnwhat are you ... 10-years-old?
How do you set up a class action suit, against the government? Asking for a friend:)
bring lots of money...
3 person can do it with a lawyer on contingent commission (no pay till win) as I understand ......
Yes I have a friend asking the same question
Tom, interesting choice of words? "Over throw the government ". Some who live in the real world, might say that it has been the government that is trying to " over throw " Canadian citizens. I would add, that I don't mean the truckers. The government seems to be " minding My business" way more than it should, to somewhat quote the future prime Minister.
💯
That is one of the most idiotic statements and we are all stupider for having read it.
I like Kool aid
Too
What's your favourite flavor?
He wants to.
CRUSH YOU
@@keithhannah8695 My favourite flavour is urine. As in.. urine a pretty warped place mentally and I think you should reevaluate the direction you're headed before it's too late.
Invoking the emergency act, suspending charter rights should always be something that should haunt any government. They should prove again and again that the decision was justified snd not something that was done spur of the moment. I am very glad that the court decision went the way it did. I am glad that we will be talking about the convoy for the foreseeable future.
I think there is enough information that shows Canadians have lost confidence in this government. The Liberal Party and more importantly the NDP should call an election to let Canadians decide on a new mandate.
He'll walk away scottfree just like with every other scandal. But no one escapes eternal judgment.
That's the problem. Nothing EVER happens to discipline he's incompetentcy
Well, let's remember that Harper fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors, EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million.
I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power.
The system works.
It's 'Scot-free', mon ami.
Remember Justice Rouleau was a commissioner appointed by Trudeau! Not playing the role of a Justice!
The difference is this decision was made by someone not paid by or a friend of Trudeau or a member of the Trudeau Foundation... A truthful decision for a change !!👍🍁
Just to be clear, today’s federal ruling overrides the public inquiry ruling. You can stop bringing it up to try show a contrast, it’s meaningless unless they win in federal appeals court which they won’t since this wasn’t a national emergency. You guys did give me a chuckle with your biased spin though, nice work!
I talked to colleagues and party members and decided it was time to invoke the emergencies act - Freeland
The Convoy never said they wouldn't leave until there was a change of gov't.
Precisely!
Walk them out and charge them !
Perp walk!!!
Freehand is delusional and also needs to be in jail for every liberal member that voted against All Canadians needs to be in Jail!!!
When Trudeau try's to paint Pierre as a convoy sympathizer as a slanderous allegation, which side of history do you want to be on now! This will be a Pierre campaign ad for sure!
Well, let's remember that Harper (with Pierre) fought the Toronto G20 Summit case (the most arrests of protestors, EVER) against his government for abusing its power and eventually lost to the tune of 16 million.
I'm glad the court rejected the Liberals abuse of power as well because I know once one Party gets away with it, both parties will abuse it again once they get back in power.
The system works.
If Freeland was so certain, what does that say about her judgement. They should all resign.
Once again a pathetic attempt to cover for our embarrassment of a government
Just another day in the basic Trutatorship.
🤣🤣🤣💯
News Flash! This is detrimental to the Government!
😂😂😂
The support for what Trudeau did is pathetic, All he had to do is meet them and not insult them, which poured fuel on a bonfire.
hopefully no Handpicked judges this time
Trudeau will not resign his ego is too big. He gets another raise on April 1st. The vacation to Jamaica was not pre- approved by the ethics commissioner.
It's nice your network is finally seeing the light with regards to our government.
However I remember your coverage of the convoy and your fervor to go after protestors.
We all remember
Trudeau. Always rolling up his sleeves. Just so he can reach even deeper into our pockets.
😂 He's cut the sleeves off at this point.
Doesn't Brian Pickford already have a case in play regarding the inappropriate invocation of the emergency measures act?
His case was dismissed because the imminent "threat "was gone, the EAct was withdrawn.
You can tell Brian Gallant and Benzie are working on their12th boosters.
Lay off the horse paste, it's rotting your brain.
LOL 😅
@@stratford374Tell that to Africa, they've been using it for years now.
Robert benzie has no clue about human rights, and job loss.
Liberal s better go back to school and learn the law system
...but Champagne is a lawyer and love to advise mp.
History will not be kind on this administration… and even though it’s my tax money I hope whatever lawsuits can be filed will be.
Ditto
What’s Robert Benzie been smoking?
Hopefully that judge doesn't get threatened.
So when does the non-confidence vote happen so that Canadians can move on from this veil of “we are doing all these things for Canadian’s” while applying taxes to the point where I am ready to leave?😢
Yet another reason Canadians should be outraged! Are they capable of doing anything ethically?
This country had a reputation for being "nice." In reality, behind the smiles and the "sorries" this is a country of abusers and abuser sympathizers.
It’s not a bombshell ruling. It’s what we all knew from the beginning. Not time for some arrests.
Toronto Sun reporter is so out of touch with reality
Now with this ruling by the courts. Can anyone slap a lawsuit against the Canadian government that was affected by the emergency act?
Yes you sure can. That’s why they want to appeal this courts ruling too, to skirt liability and from having to pay out millions of dollars and the banks can be sued too. There is nothing in the Emergencies act that gives them the right to freeze bank accounts. They needed probable cause and then a warrant to get private citizens banking information. A total breach of public trust and a breach of many privacy laws.
a proccess is already in the works to give money to those whose bank accounts were seized by the govt dring the slam down by trudeau on the convoy..look for it@@tammyrobinson5249
If this doesn’t lead to a NON CONFIDENCE VOTE then Canada is screwed worse than anyone can imagine.
It won't, Jagmeet and Trudeau are a part of the World Economic Forum Young Leadership program. They're butt buddies.
Charge everyone that voted for the emergency act now.
German farmers parked tractors in Berlin in protest to the fertilizer laws. Not one bank account has been frozen.
They're squirming.
Someone needs too be held accountable for the emergency act.
This is ridiculous,its no wonder I gave up on your corporate news years ago.
Freeland being certain about something is like a flat earther being certain about the earth being flat
An election is needed now. This current government is incompitant on all levels. NDP needs to stand on their own.
Every single Canadian needs to come together and vote conservative this year and remove the liberal criminals after that then vote whoever you want .
Unconstitutional. Not just unreasonable.
Who was that guy talking about Trudeau as his finest moment omg.
As usual, no one in Canada is paying attention to this court ruling as everyone is busy watching the USA primaries.
Oh you are so wrong
What's the consequence for these corrupt politicians?
Chrystia Freeland's certainty has shown repeatedlly nothing but calamity.
What a win 🏆 thank you courts
Thank you truckers.