What I Really Think of The Beatles New Song.
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 авг 2024
- 🎫 Tickets for LIVE! Justin Hawkins Rides Again...for the first time! UK Tour: tinyurl.com/kn...
🤝 VIP Meet & Greet Ticket Upgrades: tinyurl.com/yc...
The Beatles have released their last and final song "Now and Then" which features all four Beatles, Paul McCartney, Ringo Starr, John Lennon and George Harrison. It is a rather iconic moment.What do you think of it?
You can listen to the song in full here: • The Beatles - Now And ...
Dates:
18th March - Norwich LCR UEA
19th March - Bristol St George's
20th March - Sheffield Memorial Hall
21st March - Glasgow The Glee Club
22nd March - Gateshead The Glasshouse Sage 2
24th March - London Bloomsbury Theatre
25th March - Hayes The Beck Theatre
26th March - Cardiff The Glee Club
27th March - Birmingham The Glee Club
29th March - Salford The Lowry
30th March - Liverpool St George's Hall
31st March - Leeds City Varieties Music Hall
Join my special Mailing List here to get emails from me about stuff you might like: beacons.ai/jus...
Get a Justin Hawkins Rides Again T-Shirt & Hoodie here: thejawsofvicto...
I do monthly Zoom Call Nights over on my Patreon, they're A LOT of fun: / jushawk
Justin Hawkins Rides Again...The Podcast. You can listen on Apple Podcast, Spotify etc: open.spotify.c...
The Darkness are going on a World Tour this year to celebrate the 20th Anniversary of Permission to Land - get your tickets here: www.thedarknes...
#thebeatles #nowandthen #review
I cried the first time I heard it. My son passed away in 2020. He was 27. He loved the Beatles as I do. This song was like a conversation between us.
I’m so sorry 😢for your loss
That's so moving and beautiful. The power of music eh?
❤
❤️
Now THAT makes me want to cry.
I explained the story to my 84 yr old mum and then played it for her. She cried. To me the George solos are the most moving. Also John's voice of course.
The slide gitar solos are Paul's, playing in a way that emulates George.
@@jokermaan1 Correct. That's why it's missing a little magic.
Cringe.
@@FaxanaduJohn Call the judge and get the fudge.
This song is almost the definition of bittersweet. It's sad to witness the final chapter come to an end for the Beatles. It's also a privilege and a joy to be able to experience the end of their story and to feel the excitement of having a new Beatles track. I love those guys. Well played boys.x
Yes, bittersweet is the right word for it. It's wondrous to hear them together with the lovely time travel in the video. However it makes me feel wistful and so nostalgic but shining through is The Beatles presence. Lovely.
makes one contemplate killing themselves.....bad sog,,,ai macca bs garbage
Its incredible to think the Beatles formed, wrote and recorded all their music, and broke up before any of them turned 30 years old. Its insane to think of the creativity that poured out of those guys in such a short period of time. This song captures that. Now and Then. The old with the new. Its a great swan song.
I think it's beautiful. The lyrics to the song are close to the last words spoken to Paul by John. I'm not surprised that Paul felt that it was so important to see this song finished for his friend while he still could. The end of the video where it fades to black and white then the Beatles are gone really does seem to signify that this is the absolute end for the group. Very emotional ending.
Yeah, this whole thing is beautiful.
The fact that they get younger in the clips as the song goes on and they vanish at the end, and The Beatles in lights goes out, it's like they are saying "That's it folks, the circle is complete, thank you and good night X"
The strings and slide are subtle and sound beauitful agaist the harmonies, carnt sound to surprised i guess, they were and still are the Greatest band Ever ❤
A fitting end for the ultimate band.
As John said, "I'd like to say thank you on behalf of the group, and ourselves, I hope we passed the audition...".
The video is excruciating 🤣 when Paul and Ringo are singing I laughed out loud they should have just used old clips of all 4 of them but the egos of Paul and Ringo couldn't stop themselves from ushering themselves in 😅😅😅
A serious grower. On first listen I thought "Yeah, not too bad." I was wrong. After a few listens it's a masterpiece. The video is so powerful. The best band of all time.
They didn't care about making a great record, they just wanna sell boomer nostalgia.
i cried during the video. its so, yeah i dont know
Sentimental.@@joniiithan
@@paulknight9998 yeah I know. I usually don’t cry to stuff like this, but seeing John dancing there and young George besides old George just gave me the rest
Absolutely- sometimes the best songs take a couple of listens before they kick in.
It's crazy to me how much this song is growing on me. I like it twice as much as I did yesterday, and can't take it off loop. I hope everyone who worked on it are/were proud of what they achieved with this.
Same. I get that melody in my head and it stays there for days on end.
I’m glad you said this because I thought it was just me. 😆
@@thewyldness same ?
They changed the world in the 60’s and again in 2023 as only the 4 lads could. From a 5 year old sitting in front of our black and white TV watching them on the Ed Sullivan show, to a 64 year old lifelong fan, this is magical. Thank you John, Paul, George and Ringo. Beatles forever ❤❤
Bit hysterical this
I'm the same age as you and I mirror your sentiments. The Beatles have been a part of our whole lives!
This song is so fitting. It’s almost feels like it’s a final goodbye to the fans. I’ve cried a lot as you can imagine. Feels like we were robbed of what could have been, had John not been murdered in 1980. All in all, The Beatles and Peter Jackson did an excellent job taking John’s demo and breathing extra life into it.
I look at it as a message to the fellow Beatles.
Or, one could look at it as a message to loved ones.
Great song either way.
I think that’s what makes it so moving/emotional.
Realy you cried
I agree, it did feel like a final goodbye to fans :(
Agreed.
We've been blessed with the closest thing we can expect to a fitting end to an epic story and for that I thank Paul for his stubborn insistence in seeing through to completion the hint of the potential he heard in this song since 1995.
An incredible gift that hit me in all the right places emotionally.
We have no idea if or how The Beatles story would have continued beyond 1980 if John and George were still with us today.
What we do have, at least, is the best attempt and intent by Paul, Ringo, and the estates of George and John to give us closure. And the results are more than I could have ever expected.
For that I'm thankful.
I was surprised at how emotional I was after listening to this song for the first time last evening. Never thought I'd get to hear a new Beatles song in my lifetime, but I'm so glad to see the technology exists to have made that possible. It's a beautiful thing.
I'm not a Beatles fan per se, but I certainly can sing along to many of their songs. I really found this moving, and like I'm witnessing a special part of music history that will never be again. I love the song.
So lovely to hear John singing again, it was a privilege to hear as a life long fan from the beginning, lovely song😊
It's a time travel/"what if" universe - what if Beatles were alive and made a "modern" record. Kind of - at least this is the closest thing to that. Plus it's an obvious homage to John and George, from their older friends, in modern times, who miss their old friends.
I love it. It's really touching.
Four Guys. Love that song.
It's much of that, but mostly it is a collective goodbye and thanks from the boys to all their fans.
There goes the Beatles once again as the pioneers of new technology, mind blown 🤯. I first heard the audio only and thought it was alright. But when I listened again while watching the video I was a slobbering mess. I’ve known for the longest time that we’d never hear from them again, then we are given this beautiful gift. ❤😢
Me too. Fine with just the audio. Absolutely in bits whilst watching the video. It's incredibly well done. I wouldn't even consider myself a Beatles fan but this is special
Same for me! And now I love it ❤
Yeah a wonderful gift for sure. I would love to see it go #1 everywhere. This deserves evetything💪😎💪❤
the pioneers of modern technology? Have they EVER been that? and they had nothing to do with the technology in this, apart from it being suggested to them
@@ThePedroDB I'm a lifelong Beatles fan so yeah-it had me quite choked up...very powerful and moving video for sure.
Beautiful song. Beautiful video. Very nostalgic in that it shows all the Beatles throughout their career together, and goes back and forth through their years. As a Beatles fan all my life, I think this is a wonderful tribute to the greatest band ever.
Wonderfully put-I couldn't agree more!
Brilliant song, arrangement, and video. Made me cry to realize this truly is the end, and almost grieving for the talent we lost.
The song moved me to tears. That’s all that needs to be said.
It's an absolutely beautiful song, and a beautiful music video as well. Joyful and sad all at the same time. Thank you to the Beatles for giving us so much joy!
🎯
Over 10 million views in less than 24 hours. Proof that music is not dead. No band better to illustrate that, than the greatest of all time.
Wow really?! That warms my heart immeasurably. No music is not dead, if more people spent their time listening than arguing on social media it could be a better world. Long Live The Beatles-forever in our hearts!
I tear up every time I hear this song. It’s definitely not my favorite of theirs, but it’s still a beautiful gift to us fans.
This one made me really emotional. My dad was a big Beatles fan and we used to sit together every once in a while and listen to a few Beatles records together, sometimes i even took my bass and played along to them. It made the two of us really happy that we could bond over their music even though it was made way before my time, talk about what made the records great, what our favorite parts were and so on.
Sadly my father died last year after a motorcycle accident.
I would have loved to listen to this with him and share our impressions.
The ending of the video brings a tear to one's eye. The song really does grow on you the more you hear it. The chorus is quite good.
Especially the simultaneous fadeout of the music and the images of the Beatles.
Almost all of the beatles songs are like that. They grow on you... sometimes you are just not aware and the song is in your head for weeks
Every time I see a video of the Beatles creating or writing it’s so incredible how ahead of their time they were. The chord progressions, the melodies, the harmonies are light years ahead of most music today.
Ahead of their time yet I don't see anything matching the beatles these days
They even make a 12 bar sound so good with the chord progression
I cried like a baby. It’s so bittersweet and beautiful. It makes me sad because my Dad never got to hear this.
I feel privileged to be alive to hear this. It's beautiful and the perfect final song ❤
A hundred years from now, there will be kids saying they were born in the wrong period whilst fangirling the Beatles. The Beatles are so culturally important to the UK that their legacy will live on forever.
PPS they've taken samples of harmonies from original Beatles songs!!
I agree, 100 years from now people will still be listening to and discussing The Beatles, long after, Taylor Swift, Post Malone, Beyonce, et al are long forgotten.
Not just culturally important to the UK, but globally, I'd say. 👍
I think it's the best music McCartney has been involved in for a long time. John always brought out the sublime in him. It's very well done indeed. A beautiful, last... goodbye.
Deeply moving. I’m so glad that Paul and Ringo followed through with this ❤🙏
Thank you for the cassette, Yoko.
A trip in a poignant and heart aching time machine.
Your thoughts and musical analysis are always appreciated, Justin.
❤❤❤
Did she get /is she going to get a cut of the royalties?
I agree, Yoko played a big part.
We shall see how truly generous she was.
And how generous Paul and Ringo are.
I hate seeing it that way as I love this song.
You didn't mention the song is a hit, did you? A total banger. I heard it once, and voilà, the melody has stayed in my head ever since. Impeccable arrangements, too. And the video… I cried.
Sweet, lovely song. And to hear John and George again. Heartbreaking to hear young John singing with old Paul. Most of all, I love it for Paul and Ringo. I’m grateful they shared it with us all. Poignant, that’s the word I’m looking for.
Great song honestly. Beatles music literally can change my mood from grim to happy so quick. Their music is just so melodic and happy.
I've listened to it perhaps 40 times. It's just playing in my head all day. There couldn't be a more fitting final song
I just fucking love you so much, Justin. Your appreciation for, knowledge of, and respect of music as a whole is just heartwarming, wholesome, and encouraging. Please don't ever stop making this content.
I second that ❤
A beautiful and touching end to The Beatles' career. They have just de-throned Taylor Swift on the Spotify chart which is music to my ears. Great video Justin!
I am such a Beatles freak - there are so many of us out there! This was wonderful to watch! Thank you! Love this so much!
This was a long awaited end to the beginning moment of Ed Sullivan's introduction to a band that walked me thru my life. I cried emotionally and fell in love once again with all of them. I am so thankful to have been around to meet the Beatle! A band that will never be replaced! Amazing and talented ! I love the song
As you said, it's incredibly nuanced. The strings arrangement is subtle but really puts growing power behind the song. Compared to the '95 songs (which I like a lot as well), this feel more like a song and not a stitch up job. It was hard to feel John's real presence in those songs, but with this one he really jumps out of the speakers. It made me cry from sure. The modulation to the relative major in the chorus started the water works.
I was wondering if they should try remastering Real Love and Free as a Bird. Get some more clarity on the vocals.
i think that was down to Jeff Lynn who made real love and free as a bird sound like ELO tracks
@@DesireeStamatI’d be very surprised if they don’t
Kidding, right? It’s elevator musak at its best. Are you tone deaf or a diehard fan of The Monkees or The Bay City Rollers pablum?
I much preferred Free as a Bird
I was so unexpectedly moved by this song. My cynicism pre-release quickly dissipated when John started singing. A beautiful farewell.
The Beatles are simply timeless. Loved the song, very touching and moving. ❤
❤It's a HIT !
How could it not be? The musical layers, the lyrical message, the fact that it took nearly 50 years to see fruition, and now, John and George's spirits returning to complete the Fab Four one more time, is beyond comprehension other than it was by grand design that we have this finale.
All I can say is BRAVO, BRAVO, BRAVO ! The Beatles aren't The Beatles for nothing - eternally so.
Peace through music.
Yep it’s a winner for me. The production, lyrics, melody, class of it, simply beautiful.
It’s beautiful and a perfect last song for The Beatles. And the journey of this song is remarkable. I have no doubt John and George would have loved it as The Beatles were always embracing and inventing new technologies. I’m so glad Paul and Ringo were able to see this through for their friends.
I believe it was Paul doing the slide part in tribute to George. I heard they never got that far in 1995 to add a solo. So moving.
Yes. The little slide accents, were George from ‘95, but the solo was Paul as a tribute to George.
It's rubbish
The Beatles are forever GOD'S gift to the pop music world. Doesn't matter if this song is catchy or enjoyable.... its the Beatles and a another gift to the world.
Julian is really talented. Listen to Valotte from 1984 his voice is nearly identical to John’s.
Love the commentary. Beatles giving us one more in 2023 is epic! That one band had this much of an impact on the world is phenomenal!
I was 12 when John was Assassinated outside The Dakota, but had been a Beatles fan since I was younger thanks to my parents, and thought, well there it goes, there will never be a reunion now, and 43-years later, at age 55, I am blessed with this masterpiece, RIP John and George, thank you Paul, Ringo, and everyone associated with this work.
So nice of them to leave us one final piece of Beatles Magic.
brought me to tears to hear Lennon's voice so beautifully vulnerable and - just like Double Fantasy seemed to hv a knowing narrative of his limited time on this earth - this too so poetically brings their incredible legacy to a close...looks like its heading to #1 in the UK and as it is a AA side release with Love Me Do means there first single and chart topper will also be their last.
Emotional and intimately epic.
My housemate and I had had this song stuck in our heads every since it came out. We think because it's more haunting, considering the circumstances surrounding it. Quite beautiful in it's own way.
I think this came out better than I was expecting. The technology that Peter Jackson came up with to isolate John's vocals is pretty amazing. I know I've listened to it only a few times, but at least so far I think it's a better result than what they got for _"Free as a Bird"_ back in the 1990's. I'm glad they put the effort into doing this.
The ‘90s singles were amazing for their time, but the demo’s rough sound was obvious. I always hoped there’d be a way to overcome that. They did it!
As someone who started their musical journey because of the Beatles, I was in tears, made me proud. Seemed to be a goodbye and thankyou sort of song. Brilliant
The video was phenomenal. The song made me cry. Made me miss my father a lot, he grew up in the Beatles era and they were his favorite band. He would have loved this so much.
I love the song. Even though I was born in the early 80's, I grew up listening to the music from the 60's. And this song transports me back through the decades.
Same! 🍻
Really really moving. Me and my mate listened together and were in bits
Thanks for your thoughtful analysis. The production was not a "cash grab". It is a touching farewell. Didn't expect to cry. Saw them (didn't hear them but it didn't matter) at Shea in 1965. They and their music changed the world--music, fashion, politics, the voice of youth calling for peace and self-expression. As they grew, they embraced new technology, as they did to finish this recording. Long live Paul and Ringo, the music will live forever.
It has really grown on me. I wasn’t sure at first but in the last couple of weeks find it is stuck in my head frequently.
My first listen I thought it was a nice B side. I played it again immediately, many times, and fell in love with it. I bawled when I watched the video. No need to be hyper critical like some people. If you don’t like it fine. The rest of us can love it, right?
Exactly what I think. For me the strings are too much, plus some Paul piano that sounds strange. I feel like it should just have been remastered as a Lennon song. But it's an emotional legacy thing for Ringo and Paul.
There's an analysis video that says some parts were taken out, the bridge for the guitar solo was added, and some Beatles background vocals were recycled, for example from "Because" on Abbey Road.
ruclips.net/video/Xk88M4ABo_4/видео.html
@@peztopher7297 The strings are a little too much, I agree
It's Paul playing slide, emulating George. He also redid John's piano.
It's touching right from the beginning. So beautiful ❤ happy that this was possible to create
the timing of "Are you ready guys I might cry" AAGGAAIINNNN
I can't help but tear up listening to this song. I'm in my 60s, and it really hits me hard for so many reasons.
Truly magical... At 69, the Beatles have been the constant soundtrack to my life and to hear this now, unexpectedly, is a beautiful, elemental experience.
Isn't it incredible that the Beatles release a new song, and it's instantly far superior to most things released now a days.
They truly are timeless.
Not all hope is lost. There are some real gems out there at the moment. And then I hear _this_ track and it puts all other music into context.
@@carlmanvers5009 I hope so.
That's not incredible - it's bollocks. It just shows complete ignorance to dismiss literally every kind of music in the whole entire world.
Its a beautiful mesmerizing song, with a modern twist - but so recognisable as the Beatles.
Christmas No1 written all over it. ❤
Such a gift…so happy to live in a period where you can hear a ( very good) new song from the Beatles ❤ sweet sounds from heaven 😊
The crazy thing is that despite the enormous catalogue of awesome songs they have released, there was also stuff like this just sitting around unfinished, and despite all the decades that have passed it is still an original composition that no one else incidentally made during the passing years, and it sounds like nothing but other Beatles tracks.
In fairness, this might well have ended up on a Lennon album in the 80s or 90s, had he not died. I’m not sure there are vaults worth of unfinished material from the rest of them. McCartney, for example, has had plenty of time to go through everything, and is fairly prolific. Harrison wasn’t really that prolific at all - as I understand it most everything he wrote was released in some form before he died.
@@GregorBarclayPaul has written over 1000 songs iIrc, and there are still a few unreleased ones, that fans have only known from bootlegs, for example "Central Park".
@@JarrettMehldau Speaking as a talented, though extremely "not known" musician, i can safely say that ideas accumulated over the course of a musical life counts in the thousands. And maybe 10% of those get put on to tape (if you're lucky). Factor that notion into the combined creative force of Lennon and McCartney and you've got yourself a hell of a unreleased vault :)
@@scumboi78 Yeah, if we include snippets and fragments the amount of potential songs probably increases by a lot, particularly in Paul's case, since he has been living for a long time in the era of hand held recording devices.
I agree that despite all the decades that have passed it is still an original composition that no one else incidentally made during the passing years, like you said. However the song Endlessly by Muse, released in 2003 has similar chords and some phrases in this song sound almost alike, which is quiet surprising. So it makes me wonder if Matthew Bellamy (singer from Muse) did hear the original demo, or the 95 session, or if he simply just incidentally landed on the same musical ideas, or grabbed it from the same place out of the ether, while writing his song.
The full video on how the song finally came together after so many years is truly amazing!! Also, I wish my mother was still here to see this, she passed 10 years ago … Ringo is her 2nd cousin (my grandfather and Ringo are first cousins) and I imagine this would have been something she never imagined would happen. I’m happy I was here to see it though 🙌
Ringo's mother and my mother were cousins😊
@@KayEl58 hey Fam!! My connection is from his fathers side, my grandad is a Starkey. 🙂
@kiwigirljacks Ah, my mother was a Gleave. She told me they were good friends until my mother moved to 'the wilds of Speke' and the bus journey back to Dingle 'took hours'. I think that might have been a bit of an exaggeration 😂
@@KayEl58 😅 ahh yes, they love to exaggerate… just as mother use to tell me about the hours of walking to school in the snow lol.
My grandfather moved the family to New Zealand in the 60’s but the family got to catch up with Ringo when the Beatles toured here in the late 60’s. I have a fabulous photo from that tour of my mum and aunts with him - the only picture that survived after a fire.
Funnily enough there are other relatives here in NZ also that I never knew about until a few years ago.
‘Seven degrees of separation’ hey! I imagine there are many of us all scattered around this globe 😁
@@kiwigirljacks Yes, I'm sure there are distant relatives all over the place. It's a small world. Nice talking to you 💖
They are indeed the best band who ever walked the earth 🎉
I’ve been in floods of tears since watching the ‘Now And Then’ short film! Mourning, anew, the loss of John, of George and the music that might have been. Hearing this new Beatles song is poignant and sweet and joyful and sad, all at once. I’ve listened to it over 50 times since it’s release, like a plant drinking sunshine 🌞
Here we are all together, again, listening to The Beatles ☮️🌍 I love you
I couldn't help but shed a tear. I've always thought that I was born too late to witness rock history moments like this. This is definitely one of them, just being able to listen to the last song with the fab four together is a real gift. This also brings some sort of closure before the inevitable. The last scene of the empty stage is there to remind us.
As a Beatle disciple since 1963, I am delighted to be alive to witness this heavenly coda to the seminal influence on my lifetime of love for all music genres.
It’s a beautiful and moving song . The video matches it perfectly and is a real tear jerker!
The Beatles are so underrated.
They are the most celebrated band ever.
🤣 we see what you did there…
😂
Cheers for this! I'm on the fence for now, but I have to admit to being happy to hear a "lost" track brought to life from the World's Greatest Band.
I'm also happy to hear that you'll be touring once again! Walk the line, brother. I'm proud of you.
"It is I". Still can t get over that, awesome, what an intro today! joyfull
Paul did the slide guitar as a tribute to George in George's style.
My initial impression is that it's a nice Beatles song, and the second best of the three post-John recordings. "Real Love" is still my favorite of the three. I'd love it if they re-released "Free as a Bird" and then "Real Love" as AI-enhanced singles.
Third for me after real love and free as a bird
The editing of the music video is absolutely sumptuous work. It's great hearing Sean Lennon being involved as well.
It was. Although he does have some early memories i've always felt for Sean as his dad's always been 'public property' and most of what he knows has come through Yoko, the endless hours of footage and chats with the other 3 Beatles and his brother Julian. It would've been nice if Julian had been involved in some way
@@timedwards5734 I'm not sure how he learnt stuff but it's a different world. I guess others are more private. They choose their own paths.
A stunning piece and fitting end to the recording legacy of the greatest band of all time. Incredibly emotional and another testament to their musical timelessness. A true technological feat, not to mention a beautiful artistic statement. Can you believe it’s 2023 and we’re all talking about “the new Beatles single?”Very thankful to have one last song to relish from John/Paul/George/Ringo. 🖤🔥
It made me cry. I’m 68¾ and not ashamed of that at all! Annie💋
The "now and then I miss you" line gave me the feeling that John was actually thinking of Paul when he wrote it. It is really a fitting closure (if it really IS closure, that is; I wouldn't be surprised if they came up with a new "last Beatles song" in a couple of years).
Totally possible. I watched A LOT of clips and videos since Get Back and I saw a clip of John being interviewed on a beach and he said that he was totally ready to go back to the studio and record again with the others after they settled their dispute over Allen Klein. I think John even admitted that John was right, not an easy thing to do for some egos. May Pang also said that John really missed Paul. They were best friends since they were 14,15 years old. Both of them had lost their mothers too early, their thing for music etc. Those are our best friends with friendships lasting the whole life. John and Paul had a special bond.
On the topic of another last Beatles song, I’d be surprised if there weren’t other Lennon tunes on tape that were just wildly unsuitable for release in ‘95, too noisy and compromised, and subsequently not even considered. I’d be interested to see if any of those are now dusted off by someone, just out of curiosity, to see what they can do with them with the new tech. However as far as it being a new Beatles song, it would need to have contributions from all four of them so unless someone unearths a demo with Lennon and Harrison both playing on it, it ain’t gonna happen.
@@GregorBarclay I'm aware of how the story went, what they did for the Anthology project, and apparently that was all there was. But Jackson himself said there's quite a bit of unused and as yet unseen stuff from the Let It Be sessions. And not lo ng ago I saw a compilation of unpublished songs some of which were actually new to me and pretty good...
I get the impression that, to the remaining Beatles, the appeal of Now and Then, FAAB and Real Gone was that they were tracks that they hadn't previously heard - thus the enthusiasm to build something out of them. Whereas any unreleased stuff Jackson is hearing on the Let It Be tapes will be stuff all four Beatles heard and discarded 50 years ago. I don't know quite what Jackson is suggesting tbh, it's not like there's going to be songs hiding in there that can be unearthed in the way he unearthed the dialogue in Get Back - the only reason the dialogue was hidden was because it was unmiked - the music has been clear the whole time, and as I understand it all the songs from those sessions have been available as bootlegs for decades, so there aren't really any surprises in there.@@nachovillaro7750
The Beatles catalog 1963 to 2023. It's just unbelievable! It's a tribute to them, by them, for us. Just beautiful.
You're right Justin. It's a beautiful moment...we don't need to unpack it all. It's all very moving.
Personally I think of the 3 songs John left behind 'Real Love' is probably the best of the bunch.
There was a fourth demo Grow Old With Me which the three decided not to use. IMO I think they should have used that song instead it was a beautiful song and more complete
@@monkee5th I'll have to find it and give it a listen!
even after all these years , still the best band that ever was , genius
Yes. The Beatles are in an own division, when you talk about bands in the pop-history! Outstanding is another word!😊
WOW! Just incredible, seeing all the footage of them then and now, and blending , the song is very moving too, has the essence of the Beatles, so glad thet Sir Paul and Ringo made this, such a wonderful tribute to John and George, really made me cry both the song and the video So beautiful 💖💖💖💖
Already tearing up here.. never thought I'd get to see a new Beatles song released ❤
Thank you so much for this review, Justin. It is amazing that technology can give it a clean, contemporary sound and yet they keep what many of us regard as the essential Beatles components and the nostalgic vibe. When I heard it premiered, I felt unexpectedly emotional. Saying you like something is a valid critique. Big respect for you being your own person on this.
I've been listening to it several times a day since Thursday. It really is beautiful and I'm thrilled they were able to put it together.
It’s an incredible finale. Reduces me to tears every bloody time...
When I heard the song when it was first release, it was a heart tugger for me. My late dad got me into the Beatles when I was gery young, early 70s. When the vodeo dropped after the song, whenever I see it, I tear up, bringing back the memories of me and dad, and knowing this is the last Beatles song by the Beatles ever.
Well done, lads. Thank you so much for the music and the memories.
They were the most important band in the history of all music! This is extremely emotional hearing this❤❤
Its a glimpse and a reminder of who and what the Beatles were and still are. Simply the greatest band to ever exist.
I bawled my eyes out when I first saw the trailer and heard this beautiful song....aren't we so lucky to have been on the planet at the same time as The Beatles? 💖💖💖
This song has really grown on me since it was released a week ago and when I watch the video I'm totally spellbound. I love the moment at 1m30s when they show the footage of John and George at Shea Stadium with the lyric "I miss you", really beautiful. Also it's really sweet how most of the footage of John is of him goofing around. I watch it with my kids and the ending as it shows them younger and younger until they are not much older than my kids are now is wonderful.
The guitar solo was laid down by George in mid 90s but the slide part was recorded in 2022. Much in style of him of course. If you didn’t know, you wouldn’t know:) beautiful song, it Free as a bird still has the upper hand imo. Thanks for the analysis Justin, always nice to hear your thoughts!
You may be right but I heard Harrison doesn't play any lead guitar on this McCartney did it as a tribute to George
Paul is doing the solo in the style of George
George didn't do a solo for this song since they didn't actually work on it very long, however he did play a rhythm track I believe, so they used those tracks for this and Paul himself said that he played the slide solo as a tribute to him.
I think that slide is Paul. I'm sure he says he wanted to do a bit of an homage to George so he did the solo in a style what he thought was the way George might have played it.
My understanding is that the rhythm guitar includes George, but Paul did the slide as you said.
I was one of those screaming girls at Shea Stadium in 1965, Justin. With all the amazing & wonderful events and people I’ve had in my life, if someone asked which moment in my life I would repeat if I could, it would be at that concert screaming “Don’t leave Paul, don’t leave!” Little could I have imagined that 60 years later, I would have seen Paul & Ringo many times onstage,selling out stadiums still ! You can imagine the emotions I feel hearing & seeing this new Beatles record. Yep, I ‘d go back to that 14 year old who was living one of the most incredible, breathtaking, joyous events of her life!
I think is so beautiful. Beautiful final Beatles song. And I’m glad I’m still around to hear it. Btw, that slide guitar is not George. He never recorded a solo in 95. Paul played it, in George’s style as a tribute.
Beautiful song that was beautifully done. Bravo and Vive Le Beatles!