You may think sliver overlord having 4 heads and 5 colors is bad flavor, however it’s noteworthy that sliver overlord has 4 heads and 1 butt, which obviously represents white.
Jodah was my first commander too. Somehow it just turned into a Thassa's Oracle + Demonic Consultation engine though. I think in my case it would be a 1/5.
Oh my sweet child. I can't imagine not casting big spells with Jodah. I rate my Jodah games based on how many Ultimatums I fire off. A poor game, maybe just 1 into defeat. A good game, maybe 2-3 and they set you up for success. A perfect game, all of my uniquely named ones and a couple copies with Mnemonic Deluge on the side, and your entire deck is on the table and +15/+15. Come on now. Everyone goes through fastest win con phases, if you're done with yours then rebuild ya boi.
Jodah was my first 5 color commander before I got the Ur dragon precon. Then it was Ur-dragon, legendary dragon tribal before I decided to combine it with Ramos God tribal and make Ramos the commander... then they printed Sisay weatherlight captain and jodah was cut from the deck completely to allow for max goodstuff bs (it's literally all the theros gods, Rhonas God eternal, Gisela, reki, jhoira, nykea, the spirit who returns legendary creatures back to hand when they die, kethis and arvad. For dragons it's all 5 color ones (and morophon), all the tri color pay 3 for x effect ones, all the on attack dragon lords, karthus, the dragon that makes dragon tokens, wasitoria (for the tokens UwU) and that's it. Non legendary wise it's only 3 cards. Chromatic lantern, mirari's wake, and Lurking predators (which is amazing when you only have 7 or 8 noncreature spells in the deck...) It should NOT win as often as it does, but it do. Something something God's don't die, something something, heroes podium, something something lethal, play my whole deck then mill everybody out for several times their deck. All it takes to stop me is a kill spell and since I'm so slow to start up, nobody even bothers
Finally a fellow train tribal connoisseur! So glad my fav deck type is getting some hype but wizards really needs a good train commander that partners with Toluz, Clever Conductor. There’s just not enough support to leave modern atm 😰
That moment when you read the title, click the video, go through the entire video….only to re-look at title to realize there were no tiers. Brilliant as always Colossal Dreadnoah 🎉
I just discovered you, and when I heard what yous aid about Flynn.....ohhhhh...well, let me tell you something! My inner soul laughed deeply, and I felt compeled to subscribe. Love this lol!
Oloro was my first commander also got him for $35, threw some upgrades into it like Shielded by Faith, Curator's Ward, Wall of Reverence, Sorin Markov, and a few others. I usually win games with 700+ health due to the Serra Avatar + Wall of Reverence combo.
Woow jodah was my first commander too. I built it as a dragon tribal for some reason and even though i was mostly reducing the cost of my dragons by 1 or 2 it was pretty fun. (Also it was budget af, so it wasnt working for the most part, but I had fun) its kinda sad to see where im now, playing on very very high power commander and I dont think my younger self would be proud..
@@Aubsty nah, im quite happy, where I am and I very much like high power (hoping to someday get into cEDH when there will be money for it), it is just that when I look back its kinda nostalgic.
It's okay. You can always rebuild ya boy. You can build a five color manabase of entirely tapped lands with a deck of cheap rares and you'll still dunk on them. I believe in the inner child that believes in you.
Only flaw... new blood exists and is very funny against krenko. On a side note, my brother won't play krenko against Edgar anymore... understandable since it happened every game between the 2 decks
Play yarok! Most creatures are shared and the wincons stay similar. Or slowly add more reanimate stuff until you enter meren territory, or even gitrog if you like combo!
I’m kinda new to mtg and the first commander I used was Klauth, Unrivaled Ancient in my red/green dragon deck. I’m able to get out some huge monsters and deal a lot of damage. I’ve really enjoyed playing it and hope to see how I can improve.
What do you think about "Jhoira of the Githu"? Izzet colours but you use her to suspend big bad eldrazis, dinosaurs, and wordending events (like Jokulhaups, Worldfire)
Considering he likes big stompy stomp and dragons, I'm surprised he didn't give Miirym a 5/5, probably because of it being temur rather than gruul. But also all the commanders I'm building/play (except 4 color Omnath lol) got a s good rating so that's nice
my MTG Mentor has a Zaxara The Exemplary commander deck, with villainous Wealth in it, and the entire idea with his deck is to get his nyxbloom ancient on the battlefield, and then make a ton of copies of it, crank Wealth for 1000 mana, and then just runs you down with your own deck, either that or steals someone's deck and runs down everyone
what do you think about my favorite commander, Mogis God of Slaughter. He's very fair and balanced, and offers unique gameplay experiences to other players. :)
My 1st was Urza, Prince of Kroog with a bunch of artifact creatures, just to test and have confidence building a deck. It's not the most meta but big robots cool
You could probably find someone to give you the extra thick Precon Urza card to dabble with a bit of black. While writing this I realized that you can have Urza lead the Necrons, I just think that's hilarious.
My one and only commander deck is Izzet. Mizzix of the izmagnus. And not lot of people talk about this card, can u make a vídeo on it ? (I play magic for 2 years now).
My first precon was Draconic Dissent, with Firkraag, Cunning Instigator. Goad is cool, but not my kind of playstyle. Then yesterday I got Draconic Destruction, with Atarka, World Render. He's cool, I like big damage with double strike, but it's not quite what I want. Then my brother's girlfriend recommended Miirym, and I already love it. Just ordered him and 18 other cards that'll fit quite well. Now it's just looking which cards I want exactly. Also, I did put Atarka as a non-commander in the new deck for Miirym :)
Isshin should actually be rated as a 5/5, not because he has a good ability but because he has the high ground. Otherwise I agree that gishath is a cool dude. I love my Dino deck
Nekusar is absolutely amazing. Even if someone other than me plays him, Im like oh yes please make me draw. Nekusar is amazing anywhere on the table, I will gladly give my life to you to draw extra cards and see my other 2 opponents writhe in pain. 5/5 top 3 favorite commander cards of all time. But then its usually turns out to be a 3v1 when hes in play. Still 5/5
I have a dino deck, and my first comander was suns avatar by my cousin (an edgar player) would always hard target so i had to switch to atla to get less aggro
I'm a general Atla player and I get the flavor behind a dino hatching out of an egg or whatever, but I'd think Gishath is just generally more fun for dino tribal
As someone who has built a Jhoira Weatherlight Captain deck, you can hate it all you like. I WILL burn through my library at record speed and then either die or make everyone lose the game, not just at my table but also the next table over.
Voltron Jhoira is hilarious if you've never tried it. Mine is tuned for it since I'm not a fan of Aetherflux/Storm, but any other deck can literally just run a single copy of Nettlecyst and Greaves to threaten to dome a player out of nowhere. They'll never see it coming
You may think sliver overlord having 4 heads and 5 colors is bad flavor, however it’s noteworthy that sliver overlord has 4 heads and 1 butt, which obviously represents white.
This is a reference to the movie “Shid and Fard White is Bard”, directed by Quentin Tarinteno and Marten Scoresaze
The Liver Overlord
@@lysander3262 from the plane Liverpool
I love this comment so much 😂
I think you mean blue
Here we go
100 0:06 Sliver Overlord
99 0:14 Alesha, Who Smiles at Death
98 0:23 Torbran
97 0:31 Tuvasa the Sunlit
96 0:36 Admiral Beckett Brass
95 0:43 Codie, Vociferous Codex
94 0:51 Omnath, Locus of Rage
93 0:54 Tatsunari
92 1:01 Milicent
91 1:05 Fynn
90 1:10 Raffine
89 1:15 Awaken The Blood Avatar
88 1:24 Tasigur
87 1:27 Tiamat
86 1:34 Varina
85 1:44 Aminatou
84 1:53 Jhoira, Weatherlight Captain
83 2:04 Kozilek, The Great Distortion
82 2:10 Myrkul
81 2:14 Light-Paws
80 2:20 Anhelo
79 2:25 Ramos
78 2:34 Kinnan
77 2:40 Jetmir
76 2:46 Winota
75 2:55 The First Sliver
74 2:59 Obeka
73 3:06 Captain N'ghathrod
72 3:15 Adrix and Nev
71 3:22 Henzie
70 3:29 Galea
69 3:33 Chulane
68 3:39 Kalamax
67 3:42 Syr Gwyn
66 3:50 Volo, Guide to Monsters
65 3:57 Marchesa
64 3:59 Jerma (Marrow-Gnawer)
63 4:13 Dina
62 4:18 Tergrid
61 4:23 Jodah
60 4:30 Lord Windgrace
59 4:37 Magda
58 4:43 Giada
57 4:52 Morophon
56 5:02 Brago
55 5:07 Hinata
54 5:11 The Scarab God
53 5:17 Kess
52 5:25 Urza, Lord High Artificer
51 5:33 Sefris
50 5:37 Najeela
49 5:46 Zur the Enchanter
48 5:52 Satoru
47 6:02 Rin and Seri
46 6:10 Feather
45 6:26 Anowon
44 6:35 Kykar
43 6:38 Aesi
41 6:45 Zaxara
40 6:52 Teysa Karlov
39 6:56 Jodah, the Unifier
38 7:03 Orvar
37 7:08 K'rrik
36 7:14 Oloro
35 7:19 Liesa
34 7:21 Atla Palani
33 7:27 Yarok
32 7:32 Veyran
31 7:34 Nekusar
30 7:41 Niv-Mizzet, Parun
29 7:49 Osgir
28 7:55 Queen Marchesa
27 8:03 Tovolar
26 8:06 Gishath
25 8:19 Sisay, Weatherlight Captain
24 8:29 Alela
23 8:32 Animar
22 8:35 Sythis
21 8:43 Meren
20 8:49 Breya
19 8:53 Arcades
18 9:00 Shorikai
17 9:06 Chatterfang
16 9:08 The Prismatic Bridge
15 9:12 Go-Shintai of Life's Origin
14 9:15 Kaalia
13 9:22 Krenko, Mob Boss
12 9:26 Miirym
11 9:34 Muldrotha
10 9:37 Omnath, Locus of Creation
9 9:39 Korvold
8 9:45 Isshin
7 9:53 Prosper
6 9:58 Edgar Markov
5 10:03 Kenrith
4 10:11 Wilhelt
3 10:13 The Ur-Dragon
2 10:19 Yuriko
1 10:22 Lathril
0 10:25 Atraxa
Why did I do this, hope I didnt mess anything up
strange you took all that time but didn't just include the rating.
@@Fausto_4841 that would have been a great spoiler
Thank you, this helped a lot!
Thank you
Damn, I guess Prossh isn't popular anymore
I'd argue that Rin and Seri is 10/5 because there are two characters in the art that deserve 5 each
best comment
5/5 + 5/5 = 10/10
@@Dasky14 that’s not how math works.
5/5 + 5/5 = 2 so it’s 200% obviously.
Surprised that he gave Kozilek 5/5 it turns all yoir cards into free counter spells, that's like the most blue thing to do outside of blue.
that's pretty much how to kill fun: being an Eldrazi
I was thinking the same thing
I mean, he rated Kinnan & Tergrid favorably so I guess some BS gets a pass.
When you actually rated Nekusar and Urza not a 1 instantly for being blue or not a straight damage dealer I was pleasantly surprised
That's because the only bad color is white
obeka is fuckin hilarious, "oh i'm gonna lose the game or sack these tokens at my end step? no i'm not"
Jesus loves you
John 3:16-17
Romans 8:35-39
YOU CAN'T JUST DO THE WHOLE RATS SONG AND NOT GIVE MARROW-GNAWER A 5/5
"I would pay 39 life to draw one card"
JLK is so proud of you
The greatest game was the Theros episode where he dug too deep and too greedily, and it lead to his ruin.
@@dyciefisk2535 strixhaven has entered the chat
Jodah was my first commander too. Somehow it just turned into a Thassa's Oracle + Demonic Consultation engine though. I think in my case it would be a 1/5.
Oh my sweet child. I can't imagine not casting big spells with Jodah. I rate my Jodah games based on how many Ultimatums I fire off. A poor game, maybe just 1 into defeat. A good game, maybe 2-3 and they set you up for success. A perfect game, all of my uniquely named ones and a couple copies with Mnemonic Deluge on the side, and your entire deck is on the table and +15/+15. Come on now. Everyone goes through fastest win con phases, if you're done with yours then rebuild ya boi.
Jodah was my first 5 color commander before I got the Ur dragon precon. Then it was Ur-dragon, legendary dragon tribal before I decided to combine it with Ramos God tribal and make Ramos the commander... then they printed Sisay weatherlight captain and jodah was cut from the deck completely to allow for max goodstuff bs (it's literally all the theros gods, Rhonas God eternal, Gisela, reki, jhoira, nykea, the spirit who returns legendary creatures back to hand when they die, kethis and arvad. For dragons it's all 5 color ones (and morophon), all the tri color pay 3 for x effect ones, all the on attack dragon lords, karthus, the dragon that makes dragon tokens, wasitoria (for the tokens UwU) and that's it. Non legendary wise it's only 3 cards. Chromatic lantern, mirari's wake, and Lurking predators (which is amazing when you only have 7 or 8 noncreature spells in the deck...)
It should NOT win as often as it does, but it do. Something something God's don't die, something something, heroes podium, something something lethal, play my whole deck then mill everybody out for several times their deck. All it takes to stop me is a kill spell and since I'm so slow to start up, nobody even bothers
Jodah has always been 1/5 because it's Jodah
Finally a fellow train tribal connoisseur!
So glad my fav deck type is getting some hype but wizards really needs a good train commander that partners with Toluz, Clever Conductor. There’s just not enough support to leave modern atm 😰
That moment when you read the title, click the video, go through the entire video….only to re-look at title to realize there were no tiers. Brilliant as always Colossal Dreadnoah 🎉
I just discovered you, and when I heard what yous aid about Flynn.....ohhhhh...well, let me tell you something! My inner soul laughed deeply, and I felt compeled to subscribe. Love this lol!
First commander was Oloro, got sold the deck for like 30 bucks. Very fun deck because I get to watch everyone else play then win at the very end.
Dork alert 🤡 🚨
Oloro was my first commander also got him for $35, threw some upgrades into it like Shielded by Faith, Curator's Ward, Wall of Reverence, Sorin Markov, and a few others. I usually win games with 700+ health due to the Serra Avatar + Wall of Reverence combo.
Ok Noah you have convinced me to subscribe. Great videos keep up they great job. New viewer from Tampa Fl
He skipped over omnath and I felt that in my soul and connected on a spiritual level
AHAH I LOVED your argument to the Sliver Overlord (my preferred historically preferred tribe [it's still among the most beloved ones]
Just happy to see my rogue tribal Anowon. Favorite deck I’ve made that’s actually effective
Woow jodah was my first commander too. I built it as a dragon tribal for some reason and even though i was mostly reducing the cost of my dragons by 1 or 2 it was pretty fun. (Also it was budget af, so it wasnt working for the most part, but I had fun) its kinda sad to see where im now, playing on very very high power commander and I dont think my younger self would be proud..
Find a playgroup that likes to play lower power stuff !
@@Aubsty nah, im quite happy, where I am and I very much like high power (hoping to someday get into cEDH when there will be money for it), it is just that when I look back its kinda nostalgic.
It's okay. You can always rebuild ya boy. You can build a five color manabase of entirely tapped lands with a deck of cheap rares and you'll still dunk on them. I believe in the inner child that believes in you.
@@lysander3262 True, only think you have to do is believe!
Lol me too jodah the unifier with legendary dragon tribal honestly is really fun
as someone who built Krenko as his first deck i approve of this rating. he's good commander with no flaws
Yes yes is good very no shenanigans
Gobbo is fren
Only flaw... new blood exists and is very funny against krenko. On a side note, my brother won't play krenko against Edgar anymore... understandable since it happened every game between the 2 decks
i did tinstreet kingpin as my first, mob boss my second. I love gobbos
@maxkordon yeah clean deck no shenanigans. * hides kiki jiki, conspicuous snoop and goblin recruiter* just some fun magic here.
Millicent restless revenant was my first commander and I Appreciate the love!
Glad to finally hear some relevant opinions on 4 color omnath
muldrotha is my first commander and feels so unique and fun to me that im scared to make another deck lol
Play yarok! Most creatures are shared and the wincons stay similar. Or slowly add more reanimate stuff until you enter meren territory, or even gitrog if you like combo!
It's one of my favorites, it can be nice and fun to play against or it can be a absolute powerhouse. That makes it an amazing commander.
Possibly my favorite deck to play is Chatterfang. I can confirm that “squirrel” sums him up pretty well.
Surprised I didn't see my first and favorite commander Riku on the top 100. Super good colors and lots of ways to build him
I’m kinda new to mtg and the first commander I used was Klauth, Unrivaled Ancient in my red/green dragon deck. I’m able to get out some huge monsters and deal a lot of damage. I’ve really enjoyed playing it and hope to see how I can improve.
SUBSCRIBED BECAUSE OF THIS VIDEO MAKE MORE PLEASE WE NEED YOU
Was kinda hoping Marwyn the Nurturer would be in this video somewhere since that's my commander, but hey, funny vid very cool 5/5
i made this into a drinking game with my friends - for every time you said "alright" they take a shot. hahaha good job on the vid. nice
Lol I subbed just for this video. You funny keep it up
Wait I changed my mind you called the good jodah bad
Still subbed tho
The fact that you mentioned Omnath but just skipped him made the whole video.
Thanks for the laugh
2:20 "Do the cha-cha slide" gave me a good lol.
How this guy describes these cards, just perfection LOL
I audibly cackled at the Prosper, Tome Bound section haha
What do you think about "Jhoira of the Githu"? Izzet colours but you use her to suspend big bad eldrazis, dinosaurs, and wordending events (like Jokulhaups, Worldfire)
Probably 3/5
Your really blowing my mind rn
I want a counter for the amount of times you said "alright" XD
Considering he likes big stompy stomp and dragons, I'm surprised he didn't give Miirym a 5/5, probably because of it being temur rather than gruul. But also all the commanders I'm building/play (except 4 color Omnath lol) got a s good rating so that's nice
"Omnath."
*refuses to elaborate*
*leaves*
my MTG Mentor has a Zaxara The Exemplary commander deck, with villainous Wealth in it, and the entire idea with his deck is to get his nyxbloom ancient on the battlefield, and then make a ton of copies of it, crank Wealth for 1000 mana, and then just runs you down with your own deck, either that or steals someone's deck and runs down everyone
Not the tier list we deserved, but the tier list we needed
Hey Noah, what's your thoughts on Vela, The Night Clad?
Your opinion about Phenax mill theme
And Elesh Norn flicker theme?
I have an first sliver deck with all creature types in it. Gets that more than 1/5?
I had to rewind cuz I thought I missed the rating on 4color omnath. Well played.
You should do a video on your favorite decks from the new set.
I would love to see a Maldhound vs Magic the Noah rap battle
I like how Noah knows that five-headed dragon from Yu-Gi-Oh is an absolute stinker.
Take a shot everytime he says "alright"
How do you feel about Narset (Enlightened Master) or Ghalta?
what do you think about my favorite commander, Mogis God of Slaughter.
He's very fair and balanced, and offers unique gameplay experiences to other players.
:)
My 1st was Urza, Prince of Kroog with a bunch of artifact creatures, just to test and have confidence building a deck. It's not the most meta but big robots cool
You could probably find someone to give you the extra thick Precon Urza card to dabble with a bit of black.
While writing this I realized that you can have Urza lead the Necrons, I just think that's hilarious.
@@dyciefisk2535 sounds cool!
@@dyciefisk2535already done. Biotransference Is Life.
Alela is Voltron that gets tokens for blockers. Mine has 0 creatures and is mostly equipment and auras that go on the fairy queen
he doesnt like her colors i guess
Take a shot every time he says "Alright"
9:51 I like that Soldier token, it looks very good
Man I can't wait to see what Noah thinks of my favorite commander scarab go- oh
Just have at least 6 zombies out on the field at the beginning of your next upkeep and scarab god would've exceeded his expectations
My one and only commander deck is Izzet. Mizzix of the izmagnus. And not lot of people talk about this card, can u make a vídeo on it ? (I play magic for 2 years now).
pls do next 100 commanders
My first precon was Draconic Dissent, with Firkraag, Cunning Instigator. Goad is cool, but not my kind of playstyle. Then yesterday I got Draconic Destruction, with Atarka, World Render. He's cool, I like big damage with double strike, but it's not quite what I want. Then my brother's girlfriend recommended Miirym, and I already love it. Just ordered him and 18 other cards that'll fit quite well. Now it's just looking which cards I want exactly. Also, I did put Atarka as a non-commander in the new deck for Miirym :)
My friend built Jodah Eldrazi that was seriously an interesting game lmao also building Ur-Dragon most of it is actually foiled that i bought.
the most unhinged tier list ever, thank you
Man likes Voltron decks. So do I. I currently play Charix in a Toughness style deck.
This man is unhinged
Glad you didn't forget Ren and Stimpy :)
"This guy can get trains, and trains are really cool." Thomas liked that!
One of my favorite commanders that I use is Kodama of the East Tree
good stuff to fall asleep, thx bro
Hard level challenge, take a shot every time he says alright and not die
The First Sliver made my day.
as someone whos first commander deck was a locus of creation deck, i could not agree more with skipping it entirely
I love Pirates of the carribean and mtg davy jones is also cool
He likes my favorite commanders: Atla Palani, Volo, Rin and Seri, Adrix and Nev. Now I'm certain I have good taste
What’s y’all’s opinion on sidisi, brood tyrant? Be honest she was my first commander and still my favorite.
Skipping Marchesa right into a rats song made me cackle
What about some of the unfinity cards? Lol I know they are not good but I find it fun to play them. Confuse your opponent even more with new mechanics
Drinking game:
-take a drink every time this dude says “alright”
Isshin should actually be rated as a 5/5, not because he has a good ability but because he has the high ground. Otherwise I agree that gishath is a cool dude. I love my Dino deck
I thought I filed a restraining order.
I am a lord wind grace main lol, my landfall deck goes crazy
As an Omnath player I take the 0.1 seconds he was on the screen
Every video sounds like he drank an entire bottle of beer 5 seconds before he started the recording
Nekusar is absolutely amazing. Even if someone other than me plays him, Im like oh yes please make me draw. Nekusar is amazing anywhere on the table, I will gladly give my life to you to draw extra cards and see my other 2 opponents writhe in pain. 5/5 top 3 favorite commander cards of all time. But then its usually turns out to be a 3v1 when hes in play. Still 5/5
Noah is a legend for the Rats Movie reference
Came here to see what you thought of Jodah, seems like it was both our forst commander 🤣
Was wilhelt the rotcleaver in here? I was listening for him but didn't hear it
But how would you rank a commander deck containing these 100 commanders?
How would you rate Ivy, Gleeful Spellthief
First commander was aesi and I played primal surge with no other non-permanents to flip my deck and win through lab man/jace/thassa’s oracle
meren was my first commander so I was happy with 4/5 rating for her haha
I have a dino deck, and my first comander was suns avatar by my cousin (an edgar player) would always hard target so i had to switch to atla to get less aggro
I'm a general Atla player and I get the flavor behind a dino hatching out of an egg or whatever, but I'd think Gishath is just generally more fun for dino tribal
@@brosam_ i like them both, and he's still in the 99, but my board exists faster with atla, especially the stomp bois
Cool vid but the white background is harsh. Do you not watch them before you post them?
Just happy he put my first commander who I still love ❤ 10:23
Workshopping a Teysa vampire token deck on Arena rn, and I can't deny that it's just salt & vinegar Yarok
Jodah was my first as well, for a angle tribal
#1 FAN OF THE DOOR! WHERE IS IT?
1st comment! Ha!
0:42 usually when I tap Codie I cast a 1 mana spell, cascade into infernal tutor, and search ad nauseam. 1/5, same combo every game.
Best tier list I’ve ever seen
why skip Marchesa :(
Woah! What rating is Uril the Mist stalker?
As someone who has built a Jhoira Weatherlight Captain deck, you can hate it all you like. I WILL burn through my library at record speed and then either die or make everyone lose the game, not just at my table but also the next table over.
Voltron Jhoira is hilarious if you've never tried it. Mine is tuned for it since I'm not a fan of Aetherflux/Storm, but any other deck can literally just run a single copy of Nettlecyst and Greaves to threaten to dome a player out of nowhere. They'll never see it coming
When he said 'alright' I felt that