Premium Fixed Blade Broadhead Battle!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 фев 2025
- I put five of the best and most expensive broadheads on the market to the test. Check it out!
Please consider donating to my Channel so I can do more testing. The link is on my home page graphic. It is www.paypal.me/luskarcheryadventure
www.ironwillou...
Love your videos. I’m shooting a 175grain tooth of the arrow broadhead with a 584g arrow 24% FOC! Hits hard!
Thanks Brandon. That's a great choice. Glad it's working for you. I like a lot of FOC as well.
Thanks for testing these.
Thanks Brian...man, this was one of my first vid tests :)
Thanks for evaluation. Ordered my ATACS
That's great Chad. They are great heads. Make sure you get a pack of the extra blades, and you can use those for a long time.
Are you out of your mind? Cinder block? You broke my heart! That was painful to watch...
Haha, Right?!!! It was hard to let those arrows fly! But they are all reusable except for the Solid--geeze, that thing disintegrated! Thanks for watching Bartuna!
@@LuskArcheryAdventures Appreciate you doing it though!!! Which would you recommend out of the 5? I'm sorry if this has been answered.
I shoot 55 pounds with a 26 inch draw length and am going to be shooting either g5 Strikers or swhacker this year but if I stick with how hunting the iron will is definitely gonna be on the end of my arrow within the next 3 years
Very good. For those specs, I would recommend you not use a mechanical. Of course it can work with a good hit, but the odds are greater in your favor using a good fixed. Thanks for watching Logan, and good luck.
Nice Test! Those are some Durable heads with exception to the SOLIDS... Ive been shooting Ironwill and will continue. Good heads.
Thanks for watching and commenting Samuel. Yeah, these heads were all worth the sticker price--except the Solid. Wow. I knew it was thin and that SV30 steel is prone to chipping, but that was ridiculous. I really like those heads too, but now they got me worried if I hit a big bone. The Iron Will is a fantastic head! Good luck.
Nice work! Very enlightening.
Thanks Eric :) Hope all is well, my friend.
You are the master!!
Last night I killed my 1st hog with my new bow "halon 32"
Went for speed! gold tip 7.1 gr. Per in with a 85 gr. Stinger(double bevel with bleeder) 310 fps.
Hammered the front shoulder. Right threw it ! Into the hart! Did not penetrate the other shoulder.(200+ lbs)
Going for FOC never again,, even at 15 yards...
Thinking of 150 gr. With micro dia.
Wow! Congratulations Kim. That's awesome. Yeah, a 200# hog is TOUGH for any set up. Sounds like you got the job done very well. Stingers penetrate quite well. What's your draw length and poundage?
Holy Trinity slo-mo shot was uncalled for, the block was already cracked where you shot. New cinderblock per bh
Haha. If you want to buy the blocks for me, then I'll do that. I just thought it looked cool so I put it in slow motion.
Lusk Archery Adventures Lol, you buy me the broadheads and I’ll buy you the blocks! But seriously, less then $2 per block.
Just watched the normal priced head battle and the difference is nice to see. I guess you do get what you pay for with these.
Yeah, no doubt...most of the time.
I have not been able to shoot anything other than the solids to this point due to funds and I understand your testing, I do want to point out that bone breaks easier than cinder blocks, I had a solid legend 100 grain snap a deer femur bone in 2 then slice threw the other hind quarter nicely, I never found the arrow after searching several days and was really bummed. You are testing all solid broads except for the legend which is super vented compared to the other 4 so it makes sense for it to blow apart because of that right there especially with a cinder block. I will continue to use them due to fact I already own them and cant wait to get my hands on iron will for future
Thanks for watching and the comment, Kelly. Great points, indeed. They are definitely good heads. Yes, I am testing all non vented heads except for the Solids, but that is kind of the point; they're just not as durable as the others, due to the extreme venting design. I've used them very successfully on big hogs, and I'm sure they would do fine in most hunting situations. I especially like the large cutting diameter of the 125s. However, for larger animals, they would not be my first choice, due to their relative weakness. I have actually seen hog femurs damage broadheads more than steel flat bar and cinder blocks.
The 175 grain solid would dominate. Again this is just a test and anyone swearing off a Broadhead because of this test is a little premature. Had a buddy in Texas go through three different types of broadheads because he said they were crap because everytime he shot a deer, it still didn't die or never found it. Shot placement is a lot of it as well as not trying to shoot through the shoulder of an elk. I like the cutting surface of the Legend.
Had a bow sight failure and shot my last elk with solid in the spine and dropped it. Zero tracking
You shot a deer in its butt?! What type of shot were you taking?
Wish I had seen this 3 months ago just bought the solid broadheads they shoot really good but at there cost did not try testing anything like steel or concrete . So looks like I am going to switch to the iron will heads.
Haha. I know the feeling. But actually the Solids are pretty good heads. I've taken some hogs with them and they held up quite well...but I didn't hit any big bones. I'd use them for deer and hogs, but not for elk sized animals. Thanks for watching and commenting Glenn; hope you can check out my other bowhunting vids as well :)
I bought the scientific method broadheads years back thinking I was done searching for broadheads, I was wrong I had terrible results with them. Am doing some testing of my own, I got six different broadheads to test, am looking more for accuracy the toughness.
That's interesting. What did you not like about them? What were the terrible results?
Just getting into archery and getting setup for hunting later in season. Will be shooting 70lb draw and 25" length. Thinking of going heavy on arrow around 500 grain or little more. Not sure if my setup would support mechanicals. Haven't decided on which fixed blade to go with. Nice channel. Will be subscribing.
Thanks for watching, commenting and subbing! I really appreciate it. You can certainly shoot mechs with that set up, even with the shorter draw length. I'm assuming your primarily hunting whitetails, is that right? And in my opinion, if you are using a mech, I'd go with one that is known for its penetration. You can check out my vids on different mech tests. The Afflictor or Deadmeat are two of the best that could work well for you. If you were going with a fixed, I'd consider the Exodus or a Magnus. Good luck!
Great testing John. I would appreciate to see German Kinetics been tested the same way.
Thank you. Yeah, I would appreciate that as well...but I ran out of money with this test :)
They would blow up on the cinderblocks too.
A-TACS shoot extremely good. I killed a few deer and big cow elk with em, I struggle getting them sharp.
Yeah, it is not super easy to get the leading blade sharp and it's not replaceable. However, I've had the most success with a thin stone; just trying to match the bevel that's already there. Thanks for watching and commenting.
Great video from the guy who has the best broad head testing on RUclips! I'm curious have you ever tested these same fixed broadheads especially the Iron Will's with a high speed (400 +FPS) crossbow? Would make a great test and video!
Thanks Ron. I'd sure like to do that, but I don't have a crossbow yet.
Great videos! What’s your current go to broadhead? Top 3? Also what archery targets do you prefer? Thanks!!
Thank you. This was one of my first vids; I think they've improved a lot from those earlier days. Top 3? It largely depends on what I'm hunting. For whitetail, for Fixed heads, I'd say Exodus, Tooth of the Arrow XL, and Kayuga Gen 2 Pilot Cut (and Iron Will Wide if you can afford it). For mechs it's Sevr and Afflictor.
Dang alright!! Bishop should rename the Holy Trinity to the Holy Crap!!
Haha. Those things are amazing.
Just ordered iron will 100 wide 🦌😁😁love the holy trinity 3 blade 100 though what are your thoughts on these 2💪🦌🦌🦌🦌🦌🦌love your videos
Just replied to that question on another vid you asked it :)
Good test... The cutting edge ranking makes sense for the solid since it is wider than the others but man the way that thing exploded?!? I am using solid legend 175gr this season and they seem far more robust than the 125, the venting on the 125 makes it look so weak vs the 175 which has very little venting. Do you think the more stout 175gr solid head would have fared better? Do you have the other two from the pack and have you seen similar results from those as well?
Hey Ben. Thank you for watching and commenting. I really do appreciate it. I have several thoughts on it. First of all, shooting into concrete is obviously quite a bit different from shooting into an animal. I know that the Solids have a warranty if they fail under hunting conditions. That being said, I've shot into heavy femurs that cause as much damage to broadheads as shooting into steel flat bar; that's why i prefer a head that is relatively indestructible. Second, SV30 steel is much better than typical stainless, but it is really not the best choice for broadheads. If you research it a bit, you will see that it is even critiqued quite a bit as a knife blade material since it is prone to edge chatter and chipping. It does hold an edge well, under normal conditions, but it does not do well with much of an impact. Well, a broadhead is all about impact, so that's a bit of a problem. Third, there is no doubt in my mind that the 175 gr would be much more durable than the 125. The 125 is so vented that is is no where near as strong as the 175. Since I already use a 75 gr brass insert, I didn't want to add another 175 grains to the tip. But I would be much more confident if I were using the 175 gr model. Fourth, I have taken hogs with the 125 model, cause I love that big cut, and it has performed well and held up well...so far. Fifth, I do believe the other heads in the pack would have performed exactly the same as the one I tested; it's due to the steel and the design. Sixth, if you look at used Solids for sale, the edges are usually really nicked up; it's just what they do. Overall, I still think it's a decent selection for a head...but I will not be buying any more of them. And I would not use the 125 on an elk, when I'm really wanting to capitalize on that one opportunity I may get to nail a big bull. But I would be much more confident in the 175 gr model. But I will say, if you're going to spend that much on a broadhead, then you're better off using an Iron Will. Hope that helps!
Wow thanks for the detailed response! I actually won the broadheads :) so the idea is to use them as long as I can. Realistically though, I love trying broadheads out so much I'll probably get others to try out as well - maybe even this season hahaha... If I was to spend a ton on some broadheads, I think I would go straight to the top and get S7 bishop single bevels. The Iron wills do look awesome to me and I love A2 steel (My woodworking chisels are A2 and I get them RAZOR sharp and they can take a beating though hard, hard wood while retaining a great edge). I wish someone would make a curved head like the solid, probably with a single bevel, but out of more impact resistant steel. How would you rank 440C steel with the others tested in this video?
Anyway, thanks for the reply
Thanks Ben. 440C is a great steel for knives, but is not really optimal for broadheads because it can be a bit brittle. Most heads that use stainless go with 420 cause it tends to bend before it breaks.
I would be interested to see some penetration tests with different shaft widths, I think the skinnies are really the rage right now.
Thanks Zac. That's a good suggestion. I used to shoot Injexions, and liked them, but I prefer the Hexx shaft now. From what I've read, there is no appreciable difference in penetration in most animal situations between the different diameters, as long as the broadhead has a wider cut than the arrow. But in mediums such as I used in this test, I would think the thinner shafts would penetrate slightly deeper.
Thanks for the test, I'm currently using the QAD exodus but I'm considering switching to a more premium broadhead, do you have any experience with grizzly stik broadheads? I like the look of their forged broadheads.
Thank you Ross. I do have a bit of experience with them. Check out the Broadhead Battle Vids I have; there are three different rounds; I believe the Grizzly Stik is in the Heavyweight, but it might be Light Heavyweight round. They are good heads, but honestly, there are better. The Bishops are the best in that arena, but the Cutthroat are also really good for the price.
@@LuskArcheryAdventures I went and watched those videos, the bishops are very impressive!
Ross Feiler yes I do I use the 125 maasai and 300 nannok on many cape buffaloes in Africa.
Is there really a benefit to spending 400 on broadheads? That is a good portion of a paycheck for me.
Well, on a "normal" budget, I wouldn't think it's a wise investment...though they will last a few lifetimes :) But for people with huge budgets who are looking for the very best, then it's a great choice.
@@LuskArcheryAdventures right on thank you
One more question... What type of fletching setup do you run? I love fixed blade heads due to the durability and I'm looking for basically the most durable, but smallest profile fixed head that will minimize planing in the "regularish" process category. What would you recommend?
Thanks for watching and for the question, Kevin. Much appreciated. I've tested a lot of different vanes and configurations, but my favorite by far is 3 Blazers, put on with a helical twist from an Arizona EZ Fletch Mini. That really improves accuracy on long range shots. And increasing my FOC helped as well. My absolute favorite fixed head in the normal price range is the Exodus. It has the best balance of accuracy, penetration, cut size, ferrule strength and edge retention of any fixed blade head in its price range. Another decent option is the Magnus Black Hornet...but I prefer the Exodus, personally. I've taken over 50 animals with it so far, including bull elk, big bears, huge hogs, and African Plains Game. Hope that helps!
@@LuskArcheryAdventures p
@@LuskArcheryAdventures how come you have your arrows fletched so far down the shaft and not in the rear like it would normally be done?
great videos!
Thank you Crusty. I really appreciate the encouragement!
@@LuskArcheryAdventures You got It! I have looked high and low for extensive broadhead tests. None have come close to these.
What a GREAT improvement on your audio quality! Nice! (Okay, so not on the cinder block piece, but overall it was much easier to listen.)
Oh, and now I have a very nice mic--way way way better than this. I just got it at the end of 2019.
Found you looking for reviews on Iron Will, knowing I would never buy them. I've always thought broadheads were $40/3 and basically disposable. Never knew there were so many nice heads. That said, if you were filling a quiver for elk and deer, which Iron Will would you pick?
I'd use the Wide for shots under 50 yds and the Solid 125 gr Original for shots beyond that.
I’ll stick with my solids. Had great luck with them so far and they flight true out to 80yds
Yes indeed. They are still great heads. They do get pretty nicked up and their super vented design is not the most durable--but they can still get the job done. I love the bigger cut they have.
I like the iron will broadhead myself. Have you ever tried steelforce phat heads?
I've shot other Steeforce heads, but not the new .080" thick Phathead. It's intriguing, but I'm sure it is nowhere close to the Iron Will or the Bishop, just due to the steel they use. It still may be a great head, though.
I agree. They may be towards the top end of the regular priced broadheads though given the thickness and the steel used. I'm going to give them a shot soon and see how they do.
Yep, I bet they would perform well.
I would be interested in a video comparing different single bevel broadheads such as the Scientific Method, Grizzlystik, Bone, Strickland Helix, etc.
Thanks for the comment. Please check out my channel, I have four different videos with single bevels. Three of them are head to head comparisons.
Have you tested the Solid Broadheads? They look very similar to the iron will and same price as well.
The Solid Legend is in this test; did you watch it? It exploded on impact. I have taken a few hogs with them and like them--but they're just not very durable.
Lusk Archery Adventures I honestly don’t know how I missed that, graveyard shift brain I guess. Thanks for the video very insightful, sounds like the iron will would be a great buy.
What is the overall best fixed blade broadhead you have shot? I am considering the Atac or Day Six Evo for 2021 give me your thoughts on these two plus what you think is the best?
It depends on what my goal is--if it is long range flight, I may pick one head, or if it is penetration another, or if it is cut size, yet another. Bishop and Iron Will are top of the food chain. Exodus is one of the very best in the normal price range.
Please make a test for the Delma MA3125 Broadheads ....theses are Legendary !
What is is you like about them?
I love your videos! I am new to archery and looking to get some premium broadheads. I have settled on Bishop. Would you start with the holytrinity or scientific method?
Man those heads are amazing! I've shot both extensively. As for which I use, it all depends on what I am hunting and what my set up is. For N American game, I generally prefer the Holy Trinity cause it cuts more tissue and still penetrates very well. But if I were going after a moose or a Bison, I may use a Scientific Method. For my Cape Buffalo hunt in a few weeks, I'm using the 250 gr Scientific Method. Check out my new vid of that Arrow Build; it's pretty cool what that broadhead can do.
@@LuskArcheryAdventures Thanks so much for the info! I am going to get some holy trinity ordered..... The cape buffalo arrow build is awesome! Can't wait to see how it performs on black death!
How about a test of some less expensive two blades. Bone, Ozcut, Vandieman
Thanks for the idea. I've tested nearly a hundred different heads so far, in all different price ranges. There is one vid called Broadhead Battle Light Heavyweight Round (maybe you've watched it) where I tested a bunch of different single bevel two blades, in all different price ranges. I would like to test the three you suggest at some point. Thanks for the suggestion!
Right before the holy trinity. Broadhead hit the block it looks like the block is shot with a 22 rifle
yeah, it was getting pretty beat up!
Excalibur 405 mega matrix. Any suggestions on broadhead for elk? Preferably fixed. Mechanical not legal in Idaho.
Yeah, I'd suggest an Iron Will Original. If you can't afford that, cause they are pricey, I'd suggest an Exodus or Tooth of the Arrow.
I noticed that I haven't seen much about vpa broadheads..3 blade or 2 blade.. they seem like a well made solid durable broadhead. Do they not fly well, or hold up well? I just see them as a much cheaper alternative to the bishop heads. What's your opinion on them?
Thanks for watching and commenting Kevin. I really like VPAs. They use a high carbon steel that is good. They do hold up fairly well--not like a bishop or an Iron Will, but they are at a much lower price point. I think they're a great option. I wish they made their three blades a bit shorter, like the Bishop is; the same designer worked on both and made some good improvements in flight and structural integrity with the Bishop, even apart from the pricey steel. But I would have no hesitation using a VPA.
Wow I wish I had that kind of money
It was kind of hard to shoot these heads into the concrete. I get about half of the heads I test given to me and I purchase the other half. The views on my channel from people like you pay for those heads :) Thank you!!!
what is your AT handle would like to be able to message you with further question
Thank you. It is Bowhuntr64.
Which one flies better between the Iron Will and the A-Tac?
That's a really good question. I put them both in the "excellent" flight category, of which I would only put a few fixed blade heads. The best three I've tested at very long range are the A-TAC, the Iron Will, and the Bishop Scientific Method. Of the four blade heads, I would give a very slight edge to the A-TAC. Thanks for watching Ryan. I really do appreciate it. You can see some of the long range testing vids I've done here on my channel.
You should picture the broadhead as you talk of them not everyone is super familiar with the name and look of each head and when you went through the data I was lost as to which head was which.
That's good input. Thank you. Sorry it was confusing. But thanks for watching and commenting.
Do you find an difference between the Bishop holy trinity and the annihilator broad head?
Yeah, really different designs. The Bishop has a wider cut and is a stronger steel.
In the video of the hog hunt you went on about a week ago, you used the solid legend to harvest a hog. I was wondering why you decided to use it when in this test it proved to be so-so on performance.
I used it cause they were really pricey and I wanted to get some use out of it. It worked well on the hog.
How about testing the Annihilator broadheads?
I ordered some a while back and just now got a note that they have been shipped. They were on backorder.
@@LuskArcheryAdventures awesome! I review would be much appreciated!
And when you lose an arrow that will be expensive.
Good test. I would say shooting animal parts with bone would be a little more realistic instead of a cinder block
This was a really old test of mine. My testing has evolved quite a bit since then. But I don't use bone (at least is my official process), because my testing is all based on consistency...in order to provide comparative data from one broadhead to another. Bone densities and geometries vary too much to provide accurate comparative value.
That being said, I do sometimes shoot into elk scapula, and I use as many different heads as I can in my own hunting, to test on real animals.
Gave this a thumbs down..my reasoning.
1) didn't show what the broadhead looked like After the cinder block
2) where was the grouping test
3) cost difference
4) sharpness test...how well do they stay sharp
Sorry it didn't meet your expectations.
Let me waste a couple of hundred bucks in the name of cinderblock hunting science...
Ouch!
Haha. Yeah, that's what I do :) Thanks for watching and commenting.
Those solids are complete junk.. In my opinion the Iron will is the best broadhead ever made.. I dont see myself ever shooting a different head
Thanks Hook and Arrow. Yep, the IW is top top tier that's for sure.
sorry this is the first time watching and i can not watch no more... best of luck bud!
Thanks Christopher...do you mind me asking why you can't watch any more?
What would your recommendation be for a single bevel broadhead?
Pls check out the vids I have on Single Bevels. I have three of them. I think they're called, BIG BROADHEAD BATTLE, and there are three rounds: Light Heavyweight, Heavyweight and Super Heavyweight.
I have never heard of any of these broadheads.
Really? I am kind of a broadhead junkie so I research about every head on the market. These are some of the finest, most expensive ones made. I really do appreciate you watching and commenting. Perhaps you will enjoy some of my other vids here on my channel. I have nearly 80 and just uploaded a mountain lion bowhunt from last week.
You need a new microphone, and talk a little bit less, I like watching you. And you do a good job.
Thanks for the feedback Noah. I did this vid a long time ago and have done about a hundred more since. I now have a much better camera and mic....but I'm a preacher and do tend to talk too much :)
This bloke sounds like a young Steve o :P
Haha. That's funny. Thanks for watching and commenting.
@@LuskArcheryAdventures and honestly, no offence! Haha thanks for the video!
If you added another 100 grains to your arrow you’d be telling a different story again.
Well, that's an interesting claim. Please explain...But the test was done with the same arrows for each head, and thus, the comparative results are valid. Thanks for watching.
You should try out tooth of the arrow broadheads
I have researched them quite a bit. There is a lot that I like about them.
Lusk Archery Adventures Get should of me on Facebook. I will send you a pack of 175s for testing!
I do not understand your reasoning about using manmade materials like plywood ,rubber and carpet as opposed to the thing we would actually be shooting at doesnt make any sense at all. and as far as a premium head based on price I think you're losing it buddy
Well, thank you for watching and commenting, Mike. I've tested over a hundred different heads and I am an engineer and have shot way over a hundred animals with my bow, so honestly, I'm not "losing it" :) I've used animal parts quite a bit in my testing, and whole animals and live animals in my hunts. But for comparative testing I never want to use mediums that are inconsistent. I've done and seen tons of tests like that and they make no sense. Animal bone densities vary and their geometries vary, and the angle at which they hit vary, so you cannot conclude anything about the head from those tests. At the same time, I understand that the tests I do are certainly far from "fool proof." They are simply providing a few more data points to consider in your broadhead selection.
No broad head should cost $100
Well, as long as there are people who will pay for it, why not? Everyone's budget is so relative. I once heard that if Bill Gates were to drop a $100 bill, it would literally be a waste of his time to bend down to pick it up :)
Should have tested Silver Flames.
Yes indeed! I wanted to, but my budget ran out. I do know that the steel they use is not the most durable. But they are certainly top tier heads. Thanks again for watching Bob. Much appreciated.
holy trinity lol
Yeah, kind of a funny name to call it. But man it was one tough head!
Could you please do an in depth review of the thorn Archery broadheads? I'm very interested in these, but cannot find much about them yet. I shoot a crossbow in the 390-395 fps range using a 22 inch black eagle executioner arrow. I've provided a link for you below. Thank you and God bless you sir!
-Don
thornarchery.com/
Thanks Donald. I will do them at some point. There are some things I like about them, like the very low profile in flight. But there are other things that do not really interest me. I am concerned about their durability. But I should test them. Next on my list is the Afflictor and the Dead Ringer. Thanks for watching and for the suggestion!
@@LuskArcheryAdventures sounds good sir! Can't wait for you to post them! Thank you for your response, God bless you sir!
......"deng"
Thanks for watching
Useless test for the every day, blue collar hunter. $100 bucks for 3 broadheads is ridiculous.
Well, we all have different budgets. Look at the price difference in bows, trucks, cars, houses, etc. They're certainly not going after the blue collar hunter on a tight budget.
Can't even see the one that shattered some stupid video is covering it up.
Sorry. I need to change that.
@@LuskArcheryAdventures Thanks