This or that Melanie Martinez!

[@Doctor-edits]

And there you are round 2 is up sorry if your fav got eliminated!❤

[@BlueberriesInMyGarden]

???

[@Doctor-edits]

@@BlueberriesInMyGarden I made another one with the comments say there favourite is

[@heyitsmelon7]

Don’t get it?

[@user-rn1mm3gg7f]

round 1: mad hatter won
round 2: nymphology won
round 3: pity party won
round 4: detention won
round 5: strawberry short cake won

[@StarryMushrooms]

?

[@1melaniesgarden]

Nymphology and high-school sweethearts was where I was STRUGGLING 😭

[@giana_x0x0]

FRR

[@noelsdrawings1547]

I think I prefer High School Sweethearts but Nymphology is still good too

[@xXBaileyWithTheHaileyXx]

THEY ARE MY TWO FAV SONGS 😭

[@BUNBON-yf6le]

SAME

[@Just_a_fairy_with_a_kni4e]

Fr fr

[@00..63]

Doll house, nymphology, pity party, detention, strawberry shortcake! i love melanie smmm

[@goldenfroglegs8924]

Nymphology is like one of my fave Mel songs so def had to pick that

[@YenzL]

My choices were, Mad Hatter, Nymphology, Pity Party, Tag Your It, and Teachers Pet❤️

[@lqvesvy]

SAME

[@Melanie-s9l]

samee

[@daniela4585]

Same

[@Mushgloom]

Mad hatter
Nymphology
Pity party
Detention
Strawberry shortcake
:>

[@partyhearts]

same👌

[@bivnca.]

Dollhouse, High school Sweethearts, Pity Party, Tag you’re it and Teachers pet. it was very hard to choose from-

[@janie_steele333]

Mad hatter, high school sweethearts, pacify her, tag your it, teachers pet❤🖤

[@A01AKAN3]

Mad hatter, NYMPHOLOGY, Pity party, Detention, Teachers pet
this was hard all of the songs are so good 😭

[@melsplaydate]

mad hatter, nymphology, pity party, detention, strawberry shortcake
picking between dollhouse and mad hatter was so hard 😭

[@bauhausliker0]

same

[@queen_kat3578]

Omg you picked the exact same as me! 😂

[@AmikoPoole11]

@@queen_kat3578same!

[@manjii-_-]

Same

[@Kj2cool]

Same

[@mushroomsmashups]

Mad hatter, Nymphology, Pacify Her, Tag you're it and Teacher's Pet❤

[@SaturnEditz123]

we had the same-

[@mushroomsmashups]

@@SaturnEditz123 your musical tastes: 📈

[@urxfavbrunette]

OMG I WOULD SAY TWINS, BUT TRIPLETS 💖

[@hadleystrongleaf]

Same 😂😂❤

[@alinadicaprio7268]

Same

[@partyhearts]

mad hatter, nymphology, pity party, detention, and strawberry shortcake 10000% ❤️👌

[@Unknown.person54]

It’s hard bc I hear all of her songs 😭

[@KoiRblx]

I cant choose because all her albums are 10/10 💅💅💅

[@Love4melanie]

Not even bro 100000000000000000000000000000000000/10

[@andysgacha-3-]

dollhouse, high school sweethearts, pity party, strawberry shortcake and i dont remember the other choices lol

[@WEirdz0sHandle]

We had a lot of the same answers 😂

[@bigbodylittleheart_.]

NO NYMPHOLOGY?

[@Vanilla_boos]

TAG YOUR IT OR DETENTION

[@andysgacha-3-]

​@@bigbodylittleheart_.i dont rlly like NYMPHOLOGY 😭 (compared to her other songs at least)

[@andysgacha-3-]

​@@Vanilla_boostag ur it is good, but detention is just such a vibe

[@N3PTUN3Z_M00N]

Mad hatter, Nymphology, pity party, detention and STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE! Some of my fav songs from Melanie :)

[@Civilian444]

1.dollhouse
2.nymphology
3.pacify her
4.detention
5.teachers pet

[@Silver_Is_Sillay]

Mad hatter, highschool sweethearts, pitty party, tag your it and strawberry shortcake

[@stxrsnglitter]

same answers!!

[@macyyy1]

mad hatter, high school sweethearts 🫶🏼🫶🏼, pacify her, detention, strawberry shortcake

[@heavydirtyloan]

LIKE HIGHSCHOOL SWEATHEARTS >>>>

[@macyyy1]

@@heavydirtyloan MY FAVE 😻😻

[@yurilalla]

I GOT THIS TOOO SLAY

[@poketboy3588]

Same 😍😍

[@candyphonecosplay]

💖 Dollhouse, high school sweethearts, pity party, tag you’re it, teacher’s pet 💖
Great video by the way

[@TheDrawingWolf-mc7vi]

That guitar goes hard in teachers pet

[@LillyXrenz._]

Samee

[@heyitsmelon7]

Dollhouse, nymphology, pity party, detention, strawberry shortcake 🍰!
I ❤️ Melanie

[@writteninink-]

mad hatter, nymphology, pacify her, detention, teachers pet

[@Lqvenderbee0]

Mad hatter, nymphology, pacify her, detention, teachers pet

[@vyanillar]

"This This That That This"👀

[@StarAndTheBiziBand]

We had the exact same 🤭🤭

[@morecheese806]

Mad Hatter ,Nymphology,Pacify her ,Detention , Teachers Pet

[@AlixDaAxo]

Mad hatter, nymphology, pity party, tag your it, teachers pet

[@NotCryptic234]

Mad hatter, nymphology, pacify her, tag your it, and teachers pet

[@auwiahkaisgs]

Mad hatter, high school sweethearts, pity party, detention, strawberry shortcake

[@AM34prods]

Omg I was going with the top one before it said nyphology, that is literally my fav Melanie Martinez song

[@el3anors.avenue]

Dollhouse, nymphology, pity party, tag your it, strawberry shortcake.

[@sour_skittlez_jester]

Mad hatter, nymphology, pity party, Tag you’re it, and Strawberry shortcake-
The pick between dollhouse and max hatter was fr a struggle cause they both be great songs 😭

[@steveparker3148]

Mad hatter, the 2nd one I couldn't choose cause I love both so muchhh😭😭😭😭, pity party, detention, strawberry shortcake

[@m3lan1e__]

Mad hatter, high school sweethearts, pacify her, detention and teachers pet 😭🫵💗

[@callmemelody.]

mad hatter, high school sweethearts, pity party, detention, strawberry shortcake

[@MEEE2..-..-..-2]

Mad hatter, nymphology, pity party, detention, teachers pet~ pity, party, and pacify her + strawberry shortcake and teachers pet had me sweating😅

[@deffnothappyrn..]

1: This
2: That
3: That
4: This
5: That ( ALL DAY EVERY DAY ) ❤

[@bfdimouth629]

Doolhouse, nymphology, pity party, detention, teacher's pet. They're all pretty good

[@kate_luvs_y0uuu]

No.1 dollhouse
No.2 nymphology
No.3 pacify her
No.4 tag your it
No.5 strawberry shortcake

[@eelverse]

Strawberry Shortcake is my favourite!

[@windchaser4979]

Dollhouse{my fave},nimphology ,pity party,strawberry shortcake

[@xXAesiraXx]

Mad hatter, Nymphology, Pity party, Tag You’re it, Teachers pet.
Picking between all of these were so hard because I love them all! 😭❤

[@_hxla_]

Mad hatter, Nymphology, Pity party, Detention, Strawberry Short Cake,

[@Sarah_The_Rat]

Mad hatter, nymphology, pacify her, tag your it, Teachers pet.
Tag your it and Detention was so hard to choose, Heck ALL OF THEM ARE SO GOOD

[@lxniii3]

it’s all that except the last one🤩🤩

[@Chuuyasvillainarc]

mad hatter, nymphology, pity party, dentention, strawberry shortcake. yes

[@AsheRoblox_Offcial19]

dollhatter, highphology, pacifyparty, tagtenion, strawberrypet

[@Dinonugget62]

The hardest one for me was pity party or pacify her caus they are like my fav songs

[@Caramelcarolyn2099]

I blanked out on last two they’re my favvvv ❤ love the vid btw

[@Lily.k]

Mad hatter, Nymphology,pitty party,detention,teachers pet, 😂❤😊

[@vintag3_l0ver]

mad hatter, nymphology, pacify her, tag youre it, and im physically unable to choose between the last two 😭❤️

[@szlifierka_katowa]

mad hatter, nymphology, pity party, tag you're it, teacher's pet

[@jordypop]

Dollhouse, high school sweet hearts, pacify her, tag your it, strawberry shortcake. :D

[@miserysandwich]

how dare you make me choose between nymphology and high school sweethearts😭

[@gretchencoombes4547]

mad hatter, high school sweethearts, pacify her, detention,strawberry shortcake.
picking between nymphology and high school sweethearts was so hard ahhh

[@SlayPea]

Mad hatter, nymphology, pity party, detention, teachers pet

[@rubywilliams5767]

I can’t choose for any of them, I love her so much

[@fictionfae]

mad hatter, nymphology, pacify her, detention, strawberry shortcake

[@t0xc.w4st3alt2]

Mad hatter, nymphology, pity party, detention, strawberry shortcake

[@esiuolcunt]

Mad hatter (my fav)
High school sweethearts
Pity party
Tag you’re it
Teachers pet
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@leonardo_dicaprio_editzzz]

mad hatter, nymphology, pacify her, detention, strawberrry shortcake

[@ilianazifos609]

1:mad hatter
2:high school hearts
3:pity party
4:tag you're it
5:teachers pet

[@_...Lulu..._]

Mad hatter, High school sweet hearts, pacify her, detention, teachers pet.
Teachers pet is my fav

[@unahumana6232]

mad hatter, nymphology, pity party, detention, strawberry shortcake

[@Alisaplayz]

1 mad hatter
2 nymphology
3 pity party
4 detention
5 teachers pet

[@SpencerBurrows595]

Nah ya’ll made this so hardddd! I CANT JUST PICK ALL HER SONGS ARE AMAZINGGGGG

[@littlecute-hf5dk]

Mad Hatter, nymphology, pity party, detention, teacher's pet.

[@sillysakura_.]

mad hatter, nymphology, pity party, tag you're it, strawberry shortcake

[@FN4F_NERD]

#1: dollhouse
#2:nymphology
#3:pity party
#4: detention
#5: teachers pet

[@alinadicaprio7268]

Mad hatter, nimphology, pity party, tag you're it, teacher's pet. ❤

[@Class_f1ght]

Mad Hatter, nymphology, pity party, detention, strawberry shortcake

[@Sillyaliens]

Mad hatter, nymphology, pity party, tag your it, and teachers pet
IT WAS SO HARD CHOOSING BETWEEN HSSH AND NYMPHOLOGY

[@laundrybasket4911]

mad hatter,highschool sweethearts,pity party, detention,teachers pet.

[@ThatBunnyNJ]

1. Dollhouse
2. High school sweathearts
3. Pacify her
4. Tag, you’re it
5. Teachers pet

[@Iymmwybmwycmtte]

You made almost all of these so hard but I think i would choose dollhouse and teachers pet for the easy ones

[@sh4arkck]

mad hatter, nymphology, pity party, tag youre it, strawberry shortcake!
it was rlly hard on the last one but strawberry shortcake is so underrated! ❤

[@St4rs_4_lexi]

Ok the 2nd one was hard BUT NYMPHOLOGY IS AN ABSOLUTE BOP

[@Stvrlightt_083]

Teachers and strawberry short cake are both my fave so I can't choose 🥲

[@agatkaw.1455]

Strawberry shortcake and teachers pet was FRACKING IMPOSSIBLE

[@moonzsqx]

I COULD NOT CHOSE BETWEEN HIGHSCHOOL SWEETHEARTS AND NYMPHOLOGY- THOSE ARE LIKE MY 2 FAV SONGS- 😭🫶

[@stvr.liightt]

mad dollhouse, nymphology sweet hearts, pacify party, tag detention, strawberry pet 😭💗🤚

[@LovelyPinkBunni]

As a HUGE Mel fan who listens to every one of her songs, this is going to be so hard 😭 Here are my answers.. They were hard to pick!
Mad Hatter VS. Dollhouse: Mad Hatter
Highschool Sweethearts VS. Nymphology: Nymphologyyy!
Pacify Her VS. Pity Party: I’ll go with Pity Party because that’s the first song I ever heard of hers 😭
Tag You’re It VS. Detention: Tag, You’re It!
Strawberry Shortcake VS. Teacher’s Pet: I LOVE TP BUT STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE 100%
That was fun! Thank you for that ^^

[@OliviaRodrigoFan2021]

SAMEE ❤

[@I_like_pink4444]

I picked dollhouse, NYMPHOLOGYYYYY,
Pity party,
Detention,
Strawberry shortcake

[@Hyunjinmyman]

mad hatter, high school sweethearts, pity party, detention, teachers pet!❤

[@_M3L_]

" nymphology or high-school sweethears ?" me : ..all .

[@faerie_editz]

mad hatter, highschool sweethearts, pity party, detention, strawberry shortcake
HOW DARE YOU MAKE ME CHOOSE BETWEEN HIGH SCHOOL SWEETHEARTS AND NYMPHOLOGY 😭

[@n4dia_24]

Mad hatter, nymphology, pity party, tag you're it, strawberry shortcake

[@raqluvvs_icespice]

dollhouse, nymphology, pity party, tag you're it, teacher's pet

[@audreyj4895]

mad hatter, nymphology, pity party, detention, and teachers pet 🏩

[@MadiBeCrazy08]

Dollhouse, nyphology,pity party, detention and strawberry shortcake

[@sugaryxsweet.]

THAT! all times!

[@mewingstar]

Mad hatter and dollhouse are both iconic songs it was so hard no fair ):

[@Love4melanie]

THIS WAS SO FREAKING HARD BRO AGHGGHGGGHGGH I LOVE MEL BRO I COULD BARELY CHOSE

[@ixpaique]

Dollhouse,nymphology,pacify her,tag you're it,teacher's pet

[@theofficalsilentraven]

Mad Hatter, Nymphology, Pity Party, Tag Your It, Teacher's Pet.

[@FluffyPinkNarwhals]

Mad hatter, Highschool sweethearts, pity party, detention, teachers pet :D

[@f1uffyc4t85]

Dollhouse, nymphology, pity party, tag you’re it and strawberry shortcake

[@TheFluffins]

That for all of them😭💖
Actually nvm, this AND that for all of them😍

[@duckysguidetoshipping8930]

Mad hatter, high school sweethearts, pity party , detention and strawberry shortcake 😭 this is hard

[@rebeccarose7847]

Mad hatter, nymphology, pity party,dentention, teachers pet :)

[@CloudyLovesCreatingStuff]

Mad hatter, highschool sweethearts, pity party, detention and teacher's pet
I ALSO ADORE DOLLHOUSE AND NYMPHOLOGY I CANT CHOOSE😭

[@I_love_men_him-hehe]

I love high school sweetheart and nymphology so much