Thanks for your input. I am new to Islam and am deciding which path to take so I didn’t want to lose my time on a video by a bias person. So I will watch now. Thank you.
If quran by itself was clear; groups like wahhabism or ISIS wouldn’t exist. Have you heard of Thghalain hadith? Confirmed by all historians? My point is we can’t understand quran without the help of the prophet and according to the hadith I mentioned; Ahl ul bait or in other words imams.
@@LordXantos I completely agree. We are Brothers and should always support one another. Faith is something we may or may not practice in whatever way we like.
The prophet was intelligent enough to know that chaos would break out if he did not chose a successor. He did a 2-3 hour long speech in ghadeer after his last visit to mecca and in that speech about his duty to god he asked the 100k people three times if he (muhammed) is their moula. And then he said if i am your moula(master) then ali is your master. Later his corrupt companions claimed he forgot to choose a successor and that by moula he ment "friend".
At the time of Ghadeer people around Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) already knew that Ali (pbuh) was a close friend of Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) and after his announcement many came to Ali (pbuh) to congratulate him including the first caliph Abubakr (pbuh), so it wouldn’t make sense for the prophet to make an announcement gather everyone around him and tell everyone that Ali was his close friend and that’s it
It does make perfect sense if you had taken your time and read the context. What does not make sense is Allah's rasul(pbuh) instead of declaring Ali as his successor on top of mount Arafa, with almost all the Muslims gathered there, he chose to do it in Ghadir Khum, on the way back from Makkah when at least half of the Muslims had scattered? The sunni narrative makes perfect sense. People bothered the Prophet(pbuh) about Ali's actions in Yemen prior to Hajj. On the way back from hajj the blessed Prophet(pbuh) rested on Ghadir Khum and took the time to defend his cousin Ali(ra). Hence, why Ali(ra) was confused when people said you are our Mawla and Ali replied "How am I your Mawla when all of you are Arabs?" Meaning, he understood it as a term between master and slave and not as a successor to the prophet.
@@DrXoz the matter of yemen was actually resolved before the hajj, as it is mentioned that the prophet replied to those who opposed to the actions of Imam Ali as soon as they came to him!
there is no concept of sectarism that was political issue [6:159] Those who divide themselves into sects do not belong with you. Their judgment rests with GOD, then He will inform them of everything they had done. [30:31] You shall submit to Him, reverence Him, observe the Contact Prayers (Salat), and - whatever you do - do not ever fall into idol worship. [30:32] (Do not fall in idol worship,) like those who divide their religion into sects; each party rejoicing with what they have. [42:14] Ironically, they broke up into sects only after the knowledge had come to them, due to jealousy and resentment among themselves. If it were not for a predetermined decision from your Lord to respite them for a definite interim, they would have been judged immediately. Indeed, the later generations who inherited the scripture are full of doubts.
Hadith Tirmidhi! i think mentioned this. but you have to return to Sunnah of the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him and Kilafah Rashidun (all 5 ) and manhaj salaf!
@@zackgha5533 thats not pro shia, shiasm was made by ibn saba who said Ali is Allah, similar to how paul said Jesus is God. they try to change Quran do the shias. they want to divide the ummah! Sunnah and salafi manhaj corrects it!
Iran, the Republic of Azerbaijan, Iraq, Yemen, Lebanon and Bahrain are the six Shiite countries in the world, and there are Shiites in almost all Islamic and non-Islamic countries with a smaller percentage of Sunnis. We Shiites want unity and brotherhood with all Muslims, and the one qibla, one God and one book and one prophet is the hope of all the hearts of Muslims.
@@CD-123 why don't you start studying kuran.. And about islam then say about islam. I challenge you when you start studying kuran(holy book) then you will also convert into islam
No actually, you are just hearing the loudest voices and thinking it's most people. Islam is the Worlds fastest growing religion via converts 70-80% of converts are women between the ages of 25-40 years old. Let's see these hypocrites try and blame this on "spreading by the sword" BS. The more lies people try and spread the more people investigate and see the truth for themselves. This is why these hate mongers are desperate to keep trying to unsuccessfully spread fear and hate. As the evidence shows they will never win.
The “Spread by the Sword” thing is indeed true and it’s not just Islamic warlords and kings who have done it. It’s pretty much every religion and culture that has ever existed. If your neighbour is more powerful than you, conquers your lands and rules over your people, eventually your peoples culture and ideologies change. This is the reason why, for example, the America’s are predominantly Christian. Had the Indians colonised the American continent, Americans today would be predominantly Hindu. Had the Spanish reconquista not been so successful, the Iberian peninsula would still be predominantly Muslim. I’m just giving a couple of the hundreds of thousands of examples of how conquered lands eventually convert into the lands of the conquerer.
evaa, shiasm is actually a jewish sect made by ibn saba the jew similar who said Ali is god after fighting Muslims like how crypto jew paul said jesus is god after killing Muslims who follow JEsus. shiasm is a fake sect to fight Muslims
Ali ibn Abu-Taleb (Imam Ali) is the first person who accepted Islam, not the second. During the last time prophet Mohammad was on the way back from Mecca to Madine, on a place which called ghadire khom he stoped and told the Muslims who followed him that Ali is my successor, those who followed me, should follow him after me. This is why Shia muslims believes Imam Ali is the true successor after prophet Mohammad. I just don’t understand why Sunni Muslims don’t care about ghadire khom.
the response to your last query is because they believe the shias fabricated everything, infact, there was no such thing as shias or sunnis, but to create a divide in the muslim community much later on after the 4 rightly guided caliphs' times, did the transgressors finally emerge with their fabricated hadith and made-up religion and started to call it's followers as shias, these people weren't given any chunk in the power shared by the authorities before the abbasid caliphate and were severely persecuted by the remaining muslims so it comes as NO surprise that they decided to bring new ideas into an already formed religion disrupting the solidarity of muslims
Spot on. But you forgot to add one detail that’s important. After Mohammad dies his “close companions” are having this election and mohammad’s body is not even buried yet. Ali is the only one prepping the body and preparing for the funeral. This is a fact... in all books of hadiths (Sunni and shia) but you’re not trying to be bias in your videos so we get it. Thanks for your videos Khan Academy. I’ve been listening to your academic videos since I was in high school. You’ve made a great impact in my life and career. Thank you. May God bless you and grant you health and longer life.
What are you trying to imply? Of course Ali (ra) would prepare his body, since Ali(ra) is his immediate family. Paint the complete picture when it comes Saqifa.
Xoz eXoz but when the prophet was on his deathbed he said to Omar to bring him a pen and paper but omar refused and said your not well and ill and your hilucinating to the prophet and we don’t know what the prophet would’ve written
@@AmjedAce that is full of lies yes but also weakens the shia position, if it was anything of religious significance the prophet would say it during the three days he was still alive. SAW
As a Christian, an outsider, and obviously not knowing all the details, so far the impression that history and facts leave upon me is that Shia are correct.
Ali did not have a problem with Abu Bakr being the leader after the death. Abu Bakr was the prophet's dearest friend and eventual father-in-law. Ali respected him and did not oppose him. This divide isn't really necessary this early.
@@shifan2482 I am a shia imam Ali never gave alegencie to Abu Bakr Omar or Uthhman but he took prophet Mohammed advice to have patience and he did he was Khalifa for few years but he never really cared about that. He could be Khalifa from the start but he wanted to preserve Islam and the ummah from early destruction with Roman and Persians around. I feel sad to see sunni brothers putting lies saying a jew created shia Islam or other lies which only create division. I choose to live by my Imam Ali way and have patience and love for Islam and Allah and his messenger.
shiasm is teh divide, its made by ibn saba jew who said Ali is god to pretend to be Muslim and push paganism and violence, similar to how paul said Jesus is god and pushed violence too, shiasm mean to pretend to be Muslim & fight them!
@@zackgha5533 I wrote something aginst him as well but really brother sometimes I wonder even these people are Muslims. I think they are trained to create discord and they may be atheist agent of the west.
@@bahramzareie2447Salam Brother. We shia/sunni= Muslims and brothers but some people talks about the past pointing at each other mabe its the WAHABI's bro i dont know but for sure with negative attitude is just like a (Donkey)
As salaamu Alikum Brother and sister We are Muslim And we should follow the Quran and sunnah... Not the leaders... Let us be united and follow our deen... This is the only solution to this problem.. May Allah swt guide us all.. Ameen
Something not mentioned here that seems important is the fact that Abu Bakr and the others that became caliphs pledged allegiance to Ali after Muhammed's speech.
I think Ali pledged to Abu Bakr who lead the salat during Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him's lifetime. shias made Ali into a "God" similar to how paul made Jesus into a God!
false sects like shia are judeo made Mate you know nothing, imam ali never accepted abu bakr as a caliph , while they were praying when abu bakr became "caliph" imam ali was doing janaza to the prophet ( pbuh) .
Both groups are primarily Muslims . Just because there is a little difference in ideology doesn't mean we have cast out different sets. Instead look at the similar believes , Worship 1 God follow his messengers
But his not that accurate... As a Muslim, its better if one to goes for a self investigation of their own history & tradition...without the influence of other interpretation or views, but strictly on the Quran & Authentic Hadith's.... ;)
I really liked your video that you done about Islam but I'm going to say this. if his companion were close to the prophet Muhammad wouldn't they help with his family setting up the funeral rather than talk about who should be the next leader?
Nour elcheikh. Your question is insignificant. If Mohamed had been the most important person in their lives what makes you think they would fail to bury him ? Of course they buried him. What you don't understand is that the muslim nation was facing a rebellion the moment mohamed died. Without a leader it also faced a power vacuum with no one able to combat the rebellion and no one to fight off evil contenders for mohamed's position. If mohamed's followers did not install a leader immediately the enemies would have attempted to install their own leader. That would have been pretty bad for the muslims. We find that eventually this did happen after the four khalifa's had served their time as leaders. Their demise ushered in the sick demented amayyad tribe later to be followed by the just so sick and demented abbasid mob or the muawiyah's as they were known. Islam would spread under these two dynasties but we have to ask were they spreading islam or were they just expanding arabia. We have to ask this because they were evil. They pretended to be muslim and they expanded their borders by using islam to rally their troops. We see the same thing happening today when we look at terrorist mobs like ISIS who fight for money while pretending to fight for God.
We need to remember why Umar rushed to mosque to take decision of succession. Firstly, there were people who claimed prophecy and people were asking for someone to lead the state. By that time, only way Umar found was to call Abu Bakr and then we know he became Khalifat un Nabi.
@@hashirjaffry3165 you seem to be lying, Ali said Abu Bakr and Umar RAdiyallahu anhum are better then him. Thats why Ali married his daughter to umar and Prophet peace and blessings on him told Abu Bakr Radiyallahu anhu to lead salat. shiasm was made by ibn saba who said Ali is Allah similar to paul who said Jesus is Allah, and tried to change scripture to divide the ummah!
false sects like shia are judeo made that’s more precise it all started with Abdullah Bin Saba , although he was burnt alive by Hazrat Ali (RA) along with his 40 other followers but what he gave to Islam is something which will remain as a big deep scar .. may Allah guide us all to the right path
or we can teach the shias to be Sunnis as shiasm was made by a jew ibn saba and shia leaders like khomeini have said the Quran in incomplete whe the Quran itself says its perfect. this shows shias don't follow Islam's pillar!
One has to go through deep history its not so superficial...... And ghadeer e khum is not just one sentence ....its an event and 5 hours long sermon of prophet muhammad saww....which is often not revealed ..... So understanding shia narrative requires long hard work
Beautifully explained. I just wanted to make it clear that Shias did not decide on their own, it was all by Allah swa that the Prophet of Islam be raised by His chosen one, Abu Talib father of Ali a.s and later Ali a.s was raised by Prophet Muhammad saww therefore becomes the first male Muslim! The Ayat in Quran does not mention compainions, but the Familyof Prophet Muhammad saww and that's what us Shi'as honor. " Verily Allah swa desire is to remove blemish from you, O People of Household (Ahlul-Bayt) and purify you with a perfect purification" (33:33)
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 No cursed bustred you who like scare rat do not put your name here - as this noble Sunni Shaykh says it in this lecture: ruclips.net/video/9FU30nfjB5o/видео.html In minute 8:22 he narrates Ibn Abbas (ra) who said by whom that my life is in his hand this is " the will " of messenger of Allah sawa and the shaykh continues that Messenger of Allah while being on a she camel gave this lecture and among things he said was this " this my will for you after me that if you follow it and cling to it you would not be misguided and that is the book of Allah and my Family (not the book of Allah and Sunnati that it is not mentioned in Bukhari and Muslim) that you the naasibi dogs used and it source is the servant of Ka'ab bin Ahbar who was the enemy of Imam Ali (as) Then shaykh continues in minute 11:33 that messenger of Allah again gathered the Muslims in a place called Ghadeer khum and stood between five trees and again in minute 12:07 after the messenger of Allah says that I leave with you two weighty things the book of Allah and my Family...then he (sawa) continued to say: see how you treat them after me (recallectoin: you Nasibi dog and your ancestors cursed the Imam Ali (as) who prophet said that me and I am from Ali and Ali is from me, and me and Ali are from the same tree and other people from the other trees.
The issue was that shia don't think logically. They don't think anyone else could be leader other than descendants of Nabi (A.S). So this problem gets its strong view against Caliphate although Ali was Supreme Judge and most important advisor to first two Caliphs. So the real source of divide between Muslims came after death of Uthman. Ali got stuck between demand to execute Uthman's killers and his desire to maintain peace in Islamic empire. His viewpoint got challenged by Uthman's relatives. There is good detail to these particular set events. But I think that's enough for a comment
@@twinklingstar2082 how exactly "The issue was that shia don't think logically", 1. Ghadir khum was not the only ceremony were he gave hints, before ghadir khom Prophet Mohammad gathered his companions, in his last pilgrimage to Mecca, in what is known as the Goodbye speech, were he said: " I am leaving you with 2 things, if you follow them you will never lose your path again.", after his companions asked him what are those 2 things, he said: ""the word/book of God(The Quran), and my household", what happened to said household, they were all assassinated at the hands of so called caliphs that came from the Ummayad day till the Abbasid. 2. and after the goodbye ceremony wene they were moving back towards Medina, Ghadir khum happened. 3. All Prophets left a successor, which prophet did not leave a successor before, in a ceremony. 4. Ali and his sons had Islamic knowledge unparalleled by anyone else except for Prophet Mohammad, because they were hand taught Islam by Prophet Mohammad himself, Ali was the first Muslim male to accept Islam, Ali have been by the side of Prophet Mohammad from the beginning, he risked his own life to protect prophet Mohammad, and after he got Hassan and Hussein, while other children were playing outside, they were both being taught Islam by Ali and Prophet Mohammad himself. 4. As the person in the video said, while Prophet Mohammad family were busy burying him, some of his companions were already discussing who would be a successor. 5. you claim that Shi'ia Muslims don't think anyone else could be leader than descendants/household of Nabi, yet a lot of Sunni Muslims claim that Abu bakr is the caliph because Aisha married Prophet Mohammad, really contradicting themselves, not wishing to start a fight or anything, but stop with those baseless accusations, and its not that they are the descendants of Prophet Mohammad, its just they are the only ones that had knowledge of Islam and people that you could ask them everything about Islam. 6. Shi'ia Muslims did not pick Ali because he is just the descendant or even picked household of Prophet Mohammad through Ali just because they were descendants, they Picked Ali and his family because at that time, it was only Ali and the household of Ali that were trained in the pure knowledge of Islam, after all look at the history which is usually overlooked of what happened to Prophet Mohammad household through Ali, they became scientists, Judges, Islamic Jurists, they even trained some Imams. 7. What this small narration of events also overlooked is the fact that all 11 descendants of Prophet Mohammad that had the pure knowledge of Islam were killed at the hands of the caliphs that came from the Ummayad era till the Abbasid era, all of them got poisoned, except for Hussein which was decapitated and his head taken to Yazid I for some Golden coins, the killers of Hussein were hunted down and killed. 8. Do you know the reason for the downfall of the Ummayad Empire? wene people found out what Yazid and his ancestors have done to Prophet Mohammad household, a violent rebellion started and every suspected Ummayad was killed.
@@mohammadjaafar1496 " Its just they are the only ones that had knowledge of Islam and people that you could ask them everything about Islam." When you say those were the only ones with knowledge, does it mean that other companions of prophet were not qualified at all? Brother, when you talk of knowledge then Ibn e Masaud was also knowledgeful like Ali (A.S). Indeed Ali (A.S) was "key to city of knowledge" according to Hadith of prophet But His political decision of taking pledge for Caliphate before bringing Killers of Uthman caused trouble for him even when his son Hasan(A.S) advised against his decision to take pledge. The first five rightly guided Caliphs were capable to rule Islamic State and they ruled it in best interest of Ummah. Shia Muslims still think that only descendants of Nabi are capable to rule Islam although Nabi (Peace Be Upon Him) told that merit of superiority lies in piety and good action. Indeed household of Prophet were pious. I don't think we are disagreeing.
kinda similar to how the brand of christianity that the 12 disciples of jesus spread didn't spread wide but the romanized christianity that paul spread 50-100 years later was more popular in the roman world. less of a direct conflict but rather similar in popular alternative view.
Then why abu bakr made injustice on the daughter of muhammad?? Why he burned the door of fatima?? Why he take the fidakk of fatima?? Why umar did not let the muhammad to write something, at last moment of him, in order to protect from fittnah??
بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم «« وَوَهَبْنَا لَهُم مِّن رَّحْمَتِنَا وَجَعَلْنَا لَهُمْ لِسَانَ صِدْقٍ عَلِيًّا »» سورة مریم ، آیة 50 / sura maryam , Aya 50 And We bestowed Our mercy on them and made Ali "the tongue of truth" (confirming the Prophet Ibrahim). أشهد أن مولانا أمیرالمؤمنین علیاً ولي الله
This is not an unbiased video.It's the sunni version of events. They didn't invite Ali to their meeting to elect a new caliph because Omar wanted to make Abubakr caliph. Abubakr confiscated land that belonged to Fatima daughter of prophet who was a vocal opponent of Abubakr becoming caliph and Abubakr men in their attack on Ali's home slammed the door in flank of Fatimah which led to her death. Abubakr never punished those men. They physically assaulted Ali and only because a war with heretic tribes was going on and Ali didn't want a civil war on top of it he accepted Abubakr to become caliph. Abubakr also exiled Abazar another friend of prophet for supporting Ali. He died in exile.
For your kind information, Sunni and Shias are brothers, yes there is a question on Khilafat and Immamat. Shias followers of immamat and Sunnis Khilafat. Now where is bloodshed come from. There is no difference among Muslims. Our prophet is one, Book of Allah is One, Our Kibla (The house of God is) is one.
The question that arises is how the Prophet Muhammad may God’s prayers and peace be upon him and his family, who is the most knowledgeable of the people ,how he did not appoint a successor for the Muslims after him? Knowing that people have asked him even about how to enter the bathroom, and how to perform ablution many many times , so how can they not ask him about the fate of Muslims after his death? the answer is that they asked him and of course it is impossible that the prophet would leave such an important decision which is who will be the successor of the Muslims after him to the people, but rather appointed Imam Ali who is his cousin, and his daughter’s husband the Lady of the Women of Paradise (Lady Fatima al-Zahra). The evidence is what happened in Ghadeer Khum when the Prophet raised the hand of Imam Ali and said:any one whom iam his leader then Ali is his leader, ((((Allah is my leader (mawla) and I am the leader (mawla) of the faithful and I have superior right on and control over their lives, and Ali is the mawla of those of whom I am mawla, he said it three times ,The Holy Prophet then continued to say: “O’ God, love those who love him, and be hostile to those who are hostile to him”. Once the Holy Prophet (peace be upon him and his household) completed his speech this verse of the Holy Quran was revealed to him,{Today I have perfected your religion and completed my favor upon you, and I am satisfied that Islam be your religion})))). ■Now as for the Sunnis, they follow people who did not follow the commandment of the Prophet Muhammad may God’s prayers and peace be upon him and his family, and they distinguished between Muslims. Some of the Muslim didnot accept this matter and followed Imam Ali and his family(Shia), and some of them followed Omar and Abu Bakr (Sunni)who didn't follow the Prophet’s commandment. ***Evil Is With Those Who Will Extinguish The Light Of Truth ***
@MIke Zandi they are bibi khadija's sister daughters after sister died bibi khadija adopted him after prophet Mohammed s.a.w marriege they called prophet Mohammed s.a.w dauggters understand hazret mohammed habe only one blood daughter called bibi fatima a.s she is a real sister of hazret mohammed s.aw and bibi khadija a.s and other 3 are bibi fatima a.s cousine sisters not a real sister
As I understood from what I read, although the Sunni - Shia difference was visible immediately after Muhammed's death, the distinct Sunni and Shia dividing identities were formed much later.
@Islamist Reactionary إرتجاج الإسلامي who are you, why are you trying to spread this falsehood upon the people. While the truth stands clear with the people. May Allah(saw) silence your lying breath. Luqman a. Alim
@@cliftonpowell6418 what falsehood, shia books even say ibn saba formed shiasm, go see anit majus productions. ibn saba said Ali is a "God" similar to how crypto judeo paul lied and made Jesus one! they try to divde ppl.
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 Imam Ali "As" imprisoned then killed and burned Abdullah ibn Saba for calling Imam Ali a God. We is cursed in Shia Islam. Your hatred and falsehood will not change anything. We are followers of Ali on this day and until last day of this Universe. May Allah curse fall on your forehead you shitiyan.
We may differ in a few matters, but our differences are only limited to discussion or debate which can be resolved, not a conflict or hatred, and our differences were merely a political dispute and should not be a theological dispute. Despite this, our ancestors remained united under one umbrella [i.e. Islam] and they shared the same Aqidah because of the Qur'an and the teachings of our Beloved Prophet (ﷺ). We too can unite. ❤️
Ok I know next to nothing about Islam, please stop me if I got it wrong - Ali is Mohamed's first cousin, right? Fatimah is Mohamed's daughter, right? So to Ali, Fatimah is his first cousin once-removed (or niece), right? The video is amazing but explains very little on how the Muslim world views and treats incest and what the Muslim society is doing to prevent that.
It is not about Muhammad's family. It is because Muhammad nominated Ali as his wazeer, with the status of Aaron to Moses without being a prophet. May God bless them all. Additionally the prophet says that he is the most knowledgeable and noble and is the waly/mawla and khalifah of the Muslims in a way that the prophet was. Additionally, Ali's two children are are called two leaders in paradise. Sunni hadeeth also say that the blood family of the prophet would never separate from the Quran and that the prophet let behind these two to guide the Muslims.
First you should mention that Khadijah in not a widow in Shia tradition Also in Sunni sources Imam Ali was the real First khalifa (successor) chosen by the prophet long before Ghader khom event. that event was one and not the only evidence. but many hypocrites didn't allow this to happen therefore Muslims got divided. قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم لعلي عليه السلام: انت مني بمنزلة هارون من موسى الا انك لست نبيا وانت خليفتي في كل مؤمن بعدي السنة لابن ابي عاصم ص799/800 حديث 1222
@@blakz28 You should be ashamed of your self. You left out our most authentic sources and ran straight to some fabricated hadith. Sahih Muslim 2404 Sa'd b. Abi Waqqas reported that Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) left 'Ali b. Abi Talib behind him (as he proceeded) to the expedition of Tabuk, whereupon he ('Ali) said: Allah's Messenger, are you leaving me behind amongst women and children? Thereupon he (the Holy Prophet) said: Aren't you satisfied with being unto me what Aaron was unto Moses but with this exception that there would be no prophet after me? We can clearly see that the Prophet left Ali in charge of the people, just like how Musa left Harun to look after the people after he went to Allah SWT for forty days. And it cannot mean khilafat because Harun died before Musa.
@@DrXoz You should be ashamed of yourself for being ignorant even in your own Hadiths and books the one i mentioned your scholars said its correct (Sahih) to say its fabricated you're being stupidly blinded. just because it's not from bukhari or Muslim does not mean its not Sahih or authentic you can twist the story as much you like but the truth is the word "Khalifa after me" is clear for anyone who understand Arabic whether Harun died or lives the point is the Prophet chosed Imam Ali as his Khalifa after him whether you like it or not.
@@blakz28 Your dishonesty is of the chart. The reason I quoted Sahih Muslim was to show you that the last part of the hadith you mentioned (Khalifah) is not original. You are brushing off the most authentic, and running straight to variants which you think supports you Shirki religion. It is well established that the successor to the prophet Moses was Yusha bin Noon, so it would make more sense for the prophet to say "You will be to me, as Yusha was to Moses" had he intended to name Ali as his successor. Dishonesty is a trait among you and your forefathers.
@SAA drinking alcohol doesn't take one out of Islam but it does make them a sinner If they believe/ deem it to be halal, then and only then, will they leave Islam
I am from Bangladesh. Mostly we are all Sunni Muslims. But I don’t like this difference. So little difference is turning us against each other. Is it worth it? NO. I am a Practicing Muslim who follows our Rasul (SM)‘s Sunnahs. That’s it.
Then why abu bakr made injustice on the daughter of muhammad?? Why he burned the door of fatima?? Why he take the fidakk of fatima?? Why umar did not let the muhammad to write something, at last moment of Muhammad , in order to protect from fittnah?? Why fatima did not talk to the three caliph till death???
Sunni or Shia were all Muslims we should read our prayers and the Qur'an and be stead fast... focus on our deen our eternal life in jannah Rather then who should be next in line thy all had the same beliefs we should concentrate on that more the beliefs...
i am not a muslim i love jesus but i love all people and GOD loves me and you my brother AND I LOVE YOU MY BROTHER AND WITCH EVER GOD WE LOVE HE WILL LOVE YOU AND ME SO BE OF GOOD HEART AND SOUL AND WE SHOULD ALL SHOW LOVE MY BROTHER TO ALL PEOPLES ON EARTH
But you have to follow one of the two sides of Islam Sunni/Shia or any other group for example when Aisha and Ali fought in the battle of the camel you couldn’t have been on both sides because one of them had to be wrong. And there is different rules in different Muslim groups for example Sunnis pray with their arms to their stomach while Shi’a pray with their arm to their legs so you have to choose on of the ways
If first 3 caliphs was on right path, Then why abu bakr made injustice on the daughter of muhammad?? Why he burned the door of fatima?? Why he take the fidakk of fatima?? Why umar did not let the muhammad to write something, at last moment of Muhammad , in order to protect from fittnah?? Why fatima did not talk to the three caliph till death???
@@gmc1413 fake? Are you sure? Because these stories are actually in sahih Muslim and sahih bukhari! So unless you're saying that sahih Muslim and bukhari are fake, you have to accept those "fake stories"!
Thank you very much for the information. As we all learn about Islamic History, I believe its safe to say that Muslims today would not follow the Bani Umayyad or Abbasids like Muslims back then did. This is evident as the Axis of Resistance grows and non-Muslims flock to Islam by day. MashAllah!
Dear muslims, please do research on the differences between m'utazila Islam and A'shari Islam and the history thereof. Then do yourself a favour and study Islamic history to see what happened to the family of the Prophet (SAW) after his death. Also, try and find out how his companions behaved on his deathbed and how his body was treated after his death. Who washed it and how long was it left to lie unburied. If you can please come and leave a comment here after you've done your research. To make this easy good Google: Incident of Qirtas, Event of Ghadeer Khum, Hadith ul Manzilah, Dawatul Ashira, Mubahila and Hadith al Kisa.
@@RocketAfriqueZA that's great. I am a shia too. I was wondering if i could recommend you great hadith PDF which has knowledgeable and informative hadith by the Holy Ahlulbayt (pbut) regarding tawheed, morals and ethics so on and so forth.
@@RocketAfriqueZA fot instance, *Imam Ali Al Riza's (a) (8th Imam) Sermon On The Unity/Oneness Of God* Al-Ma’mun (May God Curse him) sent someone after him and he came. The Hashemites told him, “O Abul Hasan (Imam Riza)! Climb up the pulpit and display for us a sign whereby we may worship God.” So he (a) climbed up the pulpit and sat there for a long time with his head bowed down in silence. Then he trembled - a great trembling - and stood up straight, praised the Sublime God, and recited God’s praises and asked for His blessing for His Prophet and the Members of the Holy Household. Then he (a) said, “The first element in the worship of the Sublime God is His recognition. The root of recognition of God is to profess to His Unity. The order for professing the Unity of God is to deny He has any attributes, since the powers of reasoning testify that every attribute and everything which possesses an attribute are created. Everything that is created testifies that it has a Creator which is neither an attribute nor does it possess any attributes. Every attribute and everything possessing an attribute testify to the association between the attribute and that to which it is attributed. Any association testifies to temporality. And temporality testifies that it accepts not the Beginningless which accepts not the temporal. So it is not God whose Essence is recognized through striking similitude. It is not His Unity that is professed by someone who attempts to fathom Him. It is not His reality (haqiqa) that is attained by someone who strikes a similitude for Him. It is not He who is confirmed (tasdiq) by him who professes an end for Him. If one points to Him, it is not God that is pointed to. It is not He who is meant by him who compares Him (to something). It one ascribes parts to God, he has not indeed humbled himself in the presence of God. And it is not God who is desired by one who conceives of God in his imagination. Everything that can be known in itself is fashioned. All that stands apart from Him is an effect. God is inferred from what He fashions, the recognition of Him is expedited by the powers of reasoning, and the argument for Him is established by (man's) primordial nature. God's creating of the creatures is a veil between Him and them. His separation (mubayana) from them is due to the fact that He is disengaged from their localization. That He is their origin is proof for them that He has no origin, for none that has an origin can originate others. That He has created them possessing means (of accomplishing things) is proof that He has no means (adapt) for means are witness to the poverty of those who use them. So His names are an expression, His acts are (a way) to make (Him) understood, and His Essence is Reality. His innermost center separates Him from Creation, and His otherness limits what is other than Him. Therefore ignorant of God is he who asks for Him to be described!Transgressing against Him is he who seeks to encompass Him!Mistaken is he who imagines to have fathomed Him! Whoever asks 'how?' has compared Him (to something). Whoever says 'why?' has professed for Him a cause. Whoever says 'when?' has determined Him in time. Whoever says 'in what?' has enclosed Him. Whoever says 'to what?' has professed for Him a limit. Whoever says 'until what?' has given Him an end. Whoever gives Him an end has associated an end with Him. Whoever associates an end with Him has divided Him. Whoever divides Him has described Him. Whoever describes Him has deviated from the straight path concerning Him. God does not change with the changes undergone by Creation, just as He does not become limited by delimiting that which is limited. He is One, not according to the explanation offered by number; Outward, not according to the explanation of being immediate (to the senses); Manifest, not through the appearance of a vision (of Him); Inward, not through separation; Apart, not through distance; Near, not through approach; Subtle, not through corporealness; Existent, not after nonexistence; Active, not through coercion; Determining, not through the activity of thought; Directing, not through movement; Desiring, not through resolution; Willing, not through directing attention; Grasping, not through touch; Hearing, not through means; and Seeing, not through organs.Times accompany Him not, places enclose Him not, slumber seizes Him not, attributes delimit Him not, and instruments are of no use to Him. His Being precedes time, His Existence precedes non-existence and His Beginninglessness precedes beginning. By His giving sense to the sense organs it is known that He has no sense organs. By His giving substance to substances it is known that He has no substance. By His causing opposition among things it is known that He has no opposite. By His causing affiliation among affairs it is known that He has no affiliate. He made darkness opposite to light, obscurity to clarity, moisture to dryness, and heat to cold. He joins together those things which are in total contradiction with one another and separates those which are near. They prove (the existence of) their Separator by their separation and their Joiner by their junction. That is (the meaning of) the Sublime (God’s) words, ‘And of every thing We have created pairs: That ye may receive instruction.’ So through them He separated 'before' and 'after' that it might be known that He has no before and after. They testify with their temperaments that He who gave them temperaments has no temperament. They prove by their disparity that He who made them disparate has no disparity. They announce by their subjection to time that He who subjected them to time is not subject to it Himself. He veiled some of them from others, so that it might be known that there is no veil between Him and them other than them. His is the true meaning of lordship when there was none over whom He was Lord; the reality of Godhood when there was nothing for whom He was God; the true meaning of All-Knower when there was nothing to be known; the true meaning of m Creator when there was nothing created and the interpreter of hearing when there was nothing to be heard. It is not because He created that which makes Him deserve the true meaning (of the term) 'Creator' and not because He brought the creatures into being that the true meaning of 'making' is derived. How (could it not be so)? For using such words as ‘ago’ conceals Him not, 'already' brings Him not near, ‘perhaps’ veils Him not, 'when' limits Him not in time, 'at the time of' contains Him not, and 'with' associates Him not. Instruments limit only themselves and means are only effective upon other similar means. Their activities are found only in things. The word ‘ago’ keeps things from being eternal; the word 'already' shields them from beginninglessness; and the words 'if only' wards off perfection. Things become separate and thus they prove (the existence of) their Separator. They become distinguished and thus they prove their Distinguisher Through them their Maker manifests Himself to the powers of reasoning, and He becomes veiled to the sight through these powers. To these powers of reasoning imaginations appeal for a decision. And in them is substantiated (only) other than Him. From them is suspended the proof and through them He has revealed to them the acknowledgement of His Unity. Confirmation of God is made fast by the powers of reasoning, and faith in Him attains perfection through acknowledgment. There is no religiousness except after recognition, no knowledge except through sincerity and no sincerity along with striking similitude. If one ascribes attributes for God, then he has indeed drawn a similitude. So nothing in Creation is found in its Creator. All that is possible in it is impossible in its Maker. Movement and stillness do not affect Him. How should that which He affects (in others) have any effect upon Him, or that which He has originated recur for Him?Then His Essence would be disparate, His innermost center would be divided and His being Eternal would become an impossibility. How would then the Creator have a meaning different from the created? If something from behind limited Him, then something in front would limit Him. If perfection were seeking Him, imperfection would be upon Him. How should that which does not transcend temporality be worthy of (the Name) 'Beginningless'? How should that which does not transcend being produced, produce the things (of the world)?There they would have arisen in Him a sign of having been made and He would become a proof after having been the proven. There is no argument in absurd opinions; there is no answer when it (absurdity) is asked about; and there is no glorification of Him in its meaning. Nor is there any absurdity in distinguishing Him from Creation, unless it be that the Independent accepts not to be made into two, nor does the Beginningless accepts to have a beginning. There is no god but God, the All-High, and the Tremendous. They have cried lies that ascribe equals to God! They have gone astray into farreaching error and suffered a manifest loss!May God’s Blessings be upon Muhammad and his Pure Household. Uyoon Akhbaar Imam Al Riza (a) vol.1 p.142
@@RocketAfriqueZA for instance, *The Commander Of The Believers Imam Ali ibn Abi Taalib (pbuh) Describes The Qualities Of A Believer* Once a man called Hammam, a devout worshipper practicing religious rules and a hardworking man came to The Commander Of The believers Imam Ali ibn Abi Taalib (pbuh) during his speech and said, ‘ O Commander of the believers, describe for us the qualities of the believer as if we see him before our eyes’. 'The commander of the believers Imam Ali (pbuh) said: ‘O Hammam, a believer is a smart, intelligent one whose delight is on his face and whose sadness is in his heart, his chest is vastly open, his soul is most humble, he criticizes one’s leaning to every mortal, exhorts to everything good. He is not hateful, quarrelsome, scandalous, faultfinding or backbiting. He dislikes high positions (leadership) and is an enemy of fame and publicity. His sadness remains for a long time, his ambition is far reaching. He very often remains silent, dignified, ever remembering (the Lord), exercising patience, grateful, sad due to his thoughts, happy with his poverty, easy in his nature, kindhearted, of strong loyalty, of very little trouble, not a liar or insulting, ‘When laughing, he does not burst. When angry he does not rush. His laughing is smiles, his question is to learn, his review is to understand, his knowledge is plentiful, his forbearance is great and his blessing is a great deal. He is not stingy, he does not hasten, irritate or acts as an extremist, is not unjust in his judgement, or unfair due to his knowledge. His soul is more solid than a rock, his labour is sweeter than honey. He is not greedy, intolerant, violent, conceited, pretending or exaggerating. He is graceful in disputed matters, of honourable visitation, a man of justice when angry, and a friend when asked. He is not adventurous, or insulting and intimidating. His love is pure, he is of solid promise, of fulfilling commitment, affectionate, a keeper of good relations, and forbearing, calm, of very little that is extraneous, happy with Allah and opposes his own desires. He is not rough toward his inferiors and does not indulge in what is not his business. He is a supporter of religion, a defender of believers; a stronghold for Muslims, and admiration does not affect him negatively, greed does not hurt his heart, playfulness does not change his judgement and ignorant ones cannot find the limits of his knowledge. ‘His words are many and he is a determined scholar. He is not abusive or furious. He reaches out without harshness, is generous not a spendthrift, is not deceitful or treacherous, is not a faultfinder or unjust to a human being. He is a friend of the creatures, effortful on Earth, assistant of the weak and a helper of the helpless. He does not violate what is hidden or uncover secrets; his trials are a great deal but his complaints are very little. He remembers the good that he had seen, covers up the evil that he may observe, hides the defects, safeguards the unseen, corrects slips and forgives mistakes. He does not walk away from an advice that he can give, and he does not give up reforming an unjust instance. He is trustworthy, steadfast, pious, clean, purified and consenting. He accepts excuses, speaks of someone with grace and he is good and expects good from people. He accuses his soul of defects, loves for the sake of Allah;with understanding and knowledge, cuts-off relations for the sake of Allah with firmness and determination. Happiness does not trespass upon him and intense happiness does not make him excited. He is a reminder for the scholar and a teacher for the ignorant. He is not expected to cause a calamity. He is not feared for causing a tragedy, every effort to him is more sincere than his own and every soul is more correct than his own. He knows his defects. He is busy with his own sadness. He does not rely on anyone except his Lord. He feels a stranger, lonely, dispossessed and sad. He loves for the sake of Allah, strives for the sake of Allah to follow His Happiness. He does not revenge by himself for his ownself. He does not make friends to make his Lord angry. He sits with the poor, is a friend of the truthful ones, a supporter of the people of truth and an assistant for those near to him. He is like a father for the orphans, like a guardian for the widows, the first hope for the destitute, expected to remove every resentful matter and to relieve every difficulty. He is light and happy, is not frowning or sly, and is strong, controlling of anger, smiling, sharp-sighted and greatly cautious. He does not ignore, and if ignored, he is forbearing. He is not stingy and if stinginess, is used against him he exercises patience. He understands, thus he is conscious, is content, independent and is self-sufficient. His abstinent is higher than his lust, his love is higher than his jealousy and his forgiveness is higher than his hate. He does not speak without correctness and does not dress unless it is economical. He walks humbly, is submissive before his Lord in obedience and is happy with Him in all conditions. His intention is pure and sincere. His deeds are free of fraud and deceit. His observations are good lessons, his silence is thoughtful and his words are wisdom. He is advising, charitable and brotherly. He gives good advice in public and in private. He neither abandons his brother nor backbites and nor plots against him. He does not regret what he has missed, and does not become sad for whatever befalls him. He does not hope for what is not lawful. He does not fail in hardships and does not perpetrate in comfort. He mixes forbearance with knowledge and reason with patience. He is not lazy but is always active, of very short longing and of very few slips. (Good) is expected through him, his heart is fearful, he always speaks of his Lord, his soul is content, his ignorance is negative, his affairs are easy, he is sad for his sins, his lust is dead, his anger is controlled and his moral behaviors are lucent. His neighbours live safely with him, he has suppressed his pride, he is content with whatever is determined for him, his patience is strong, his affair is well established and his remembering (the Lord) is a great deal. He meets with people to learn and remains silent for safety, he asks questions to understand, and he trades to earn. He does not remain silent for good to be subjected to injustice, and does not speak to be used in doing injustice to others. His soul is tired of him and people are comfortable with him. He has tired his soul for the gains of the next life and has provided comfort to others by means of his soul. If rebellion is committed against him he exercises patience until Allah finds support for him. His distancing when distancing is needed comes in overlooking and in graceful disregard, and his closeness when closeness is needed comes as kindness and blessings. His distancing is not out of boastfulness or greatness and his closeness is not a plot or deceit. It is because he follows the footsteps of those before him, the people of goodness. Thus, he is the leader for those after him.’ ‘The narrator has said that Hammam breathed very deeply and fell down unconscious. Imam Ali (pbuh) said: ‘By Allah I was afraid of its effect for him. This is how effective advice works on people deserving such advice. Someone said: ‘Why does it not apply to you, O Commander of the believers?’ The Imam (pbuh)said: ‘For everything there is an appointed time that is not surpassed and a cause that does not fail. Wait, and do not transgress. It was a blow that Satan made to flow through your tongue’.
The word "fight" maybe much offensive word for some folks. It is due to translation of Arabic to English..The best word which can be used is " Combat".. If They combat you combat...If they cease you cease...For sure God is merciful.... There are many verses in Bible that people may seem offensive...But it is all due to translation.... In the story of Noah (p.b.u.h) where God finished a whole nation... And it really doesn't matter which religion you follow unless you pray to one God almighty and at the end of the day we all going to same God...For God doesn't see you face ,color or race but faith in him alone.United we stand.Divided we fall....
Nothing but truth, man. You're spot on. Muslims are one group of descendants of the tribes of God that God allowed to repopulate the Earth after the flood. Every group of people around the world that survived the flood all worshipped the Sun God, as the Sun is the closest physical incarnation of divine power to us. No matter what religion or spiritual belief anyone follows, we must all recognize with utmost respect and honor that there is *one* true divine, incomprehensible force that drives the universe. Materialistic/Atheistic scientists could not disprove 'God' in the past and they cannot disprove 'God' now. The way I view 'God' is non-religious, but rather personal and unique. I view God as simply the supreme being that all of reality derives from and is a part of. I view God as everything, an eternal intelligence, an infinite force of endless possibility. Not 'he' or 'she', but rather 'God' singularly on it's own.
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
I am Muslim my self and u are the first person who doesn't use bias during their informational videos so i have to say Thank you
me to bro Any Muslims who Listen to the Prophets last speech in Ghadir Khumm ?
@@cresxent9485 so that's why he is so biased
thanks for the info
it was very weird listening to this video but now I understand
Thanks for your input. I am new to Islam and am deciding which path to take so I didn’t want to lose my time on a video by a bias person. So I will watch now. Thank you.
Zack Gha yes he is narrated to have have said I leave you two things. Quran and Ahlulbayt. This is narrated in both Sunni Shia literature
Loop Doc please follow ahlulbayt. The family of the prophet Muhammad.
Great video. I'm just a Muslim. I refuse to label myself Sunni or Shia. The Quran is clear, do not break the religion into sects....
If quran by itself was clear; groups like wahhabism or ISIS wouldn’t exist. Have you heard of Thghalain hadith? Confirmed by all historians?
My point is we can’t understand quran without the help of the prophet and according to the hadith I mentioned; Ahl ul bait or in other words imams.
sunni are just following the sunna of the prophet
shia founded a sect with completely new doctrines like imamah
@@AmirAli-bl4fp isis was made with western policy. no such thing as Wahabism, its a revival!
@9-11 is a Judeo PNAC inside job there are extremists of every denomination....
Eric Husayn Nice statement Thats how it should be
This was probably your most important and sensitive lecture and could only have been done by you as founder of khan academy
Its funny though. Never thought that my favourite biochemistry channel knew more about this than me who's a Muslim.
I believe he may be Muslim as well
he's a muslim though
He’s Muslim
He himself is Muslim with Bangladeshi father and Indian muslim mother
jokes on you huh
How does this guy know everything?
He's a gentleman and a scholar
history doesn't perish away.
God's peace be upon Ahla-beit.
Probably just read Destiny Disrupted. Great history of Islam
@User1234 of course Allah knows Everything he just said like a joke Because Khan Academy teaches advanced math and now Islam history
Because he's a teacher bro😄
No Shia no Sunni. We are all muslims. No division.
Your correct
How about we are all human beings... Better don't you think?
@@LordXantos I completely agree. We are Brothers and should always support one another. Faith is something we may or may not practice in whatever way we like.
@Forgotten Soul why?
@Forgotten Soul This is true... But we must still trying or the mankind is doomed to conflict forever
as a Muslim(who loves your channel) I love how deep you go into the history of Islam, and i have to say well done!:)
Ahman Shah 👍
Any Muslims who Listen to the Prophets last speech in Ghadir Khumm ?
The prophet was intelligent enough to know that chaos would break out if he did not chose a successor. He did a 2-3 hour long speech in ghadeer after his last visit to mecca and in that speech about his duty to god he asked the 100k people three times if he (muhammed) is their moula. And then he said if i am your moula(master) then ali is your master. Later his corrupt companions claimed he forgot to choose a successor and that by moula he ment "friend".
What does this guy not teach?
The McDougal Bugle pe
The truth behind McDonald's ice cream machine
I wish to know that
I am not Suni
I am not Shia
I am just a Muslim
سلام علیکم
At the time of Ghadeer people around Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) already knew that Ali (pbuh) was a close friend of Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) and after his announcement many came to Ali (pbuh) to congratulate him including the first caliph Abubakr (pbuh), so it wouldn’t make sense for the prophet to make an announcement gather everyone around him and tell everyone that Ali was his close friend and that’s it
It does make perfect sense if you had taken your time and read the context. What does not make sense is Allah's rasul(pbuh) instead of declaring Ali as his successor on top of mount Arafa, with almost all the Muslims gathered there, he chose to do it in Ghadir Khum, on the way back from Makkah when at least half of the Muslims had scattered? The sunni narrative makes perfect sense. People bothered the Prophet(pbuh) about Ali's actions in Yemen prior to Hajj. On the way back from hajj the blessed Prophet(pbuh) rested on Ghadir Khum and took the time to defend his cousin Ali(ra). Hence, why Ali(ra) was confused when people said you are our Mawla and Ali replied "How am I your Mawla when all of you are Arabs?" Meaning, he understood it as a term between master and slave and not as a successor to the prophet.
@@DrXoz the matter of yemen was actually resolved before the hajj, as it is mentioned that the prophet replied to those who opposed to the actions of Imam Ali as soon as they came to him!
Thanks mate for explaining in a decent manners, it gave a lot of knowledge over history.
there is no concept of sectarism that was political issue
[6:159] Those who divide themselves into sects do not belong with you. Their judgment rests with GOD, then He will inform them of everything they had done.
[30:31] You shall submit to Him, reverence Him, observe the Contact Prayers (Salat), and - whatever you do - do not ever fall into idol worship.
[30:32] (Do not fall in idol worship,) like those who divide their religion into sects; each party rejoicing with what they have.
[42:14] Ironically, they broke up into sects only after the knowledge had come to them, due to jealousy and resentment among themselves. If it were not for a predetermined decision from your Lord to respite them for a definite interim, they would have been judged immediately. Indeed, the later generations who inherited the scripture are full of doubts.
Hadith Tirmidhi! i think mentioned this. but you have to return to Sunnah of the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him and Kilafah Rashidun (all 5 ) and manhaj salaf!
Asalam Alaikum Exactly it’s sad to see the ummah so divided because of politics and culture 😢
you mean to say,theres not existance of muslim in the word as all of then divided in different sects???
Any Muslims who Listen to the Prophets last speech in Ghadir Khumm ?
@@zackgha5533 thats not pro shia, shiasm was made by ibn saba who said Ali is Allah, similar to how paul said Jesus is God. they try to change Quran do the shias. they want to divide the ummah! Sunnah and salafi manhaj corrects it!
Iran, the Republic of Azerbaijan, Iraq, Yemen, Lebanon and Bahrain are the six Shiite countries in the world, and there are Shiites in almost all Islamic and non-Islamic countries with a smaller percentage of Sunnis. We Shiites want unity and brotherhood with all Muslims, and the one qibla, one God and one book and one prophet is the hope of all the hearts of Muslims.
Love from sunni from Bangladesh
Love shia
@@na-zt4hj thanks brother 💓
No sunni no shia only Muslim
very appreciate this effort to make history explanation... may God bless you
To be very frank I have started liking Islam even more after your videos. Thank you very much.
Because you are stupid may be
@@CD-123 why don't you start studying kuran.. And about islam then say about islam. I challenge you when you start studying kuran(holy book) then you will also convert into islam
@@amjadalam6249 your are stupid dude.... don't you see his profile pic
@@readersclub1999 is he Jewish or pakistanahmedy?
@@goldenmemes51 to me it looks satanic
It's 2017, most people look down on muslims. This should be a perfect opportunity for Sunni and Shia to become closer, not fight with each other
No actually, you are just hearing the loudest voices and thinking it's most people. Islam is the Worlds fastest growing religion via converts 70-80% of converts are women between the ages of 25-40 years old. Let's see these hypocrites try and blame this on "spreading by the sword" BS. The more lies people try and spread the more people investigate and see the truth for themselves. This is why these hate mongers are desperate to keep trying to unsuccessfully spread fear and hate. As the evidence shows they will never win.
Evaaa A1 Exactly!
Evaaa A1 Sects are OFFICIALLY man made.
The “Spread by the Sword” thing is indeed true and it’s not just Islamic warlords and kings who have done it. It’s pretty much every religion and culture that has ever existed. If your neighbour is more powerful than you, conquers your lands and rules over your people, eventually your peoples culture and ideologies change. This is the reason why, for example, the America’s are predominantly Christian. Had the Indians colonised the American continent, Americans today would be predominantly Hindu. Had the Spanish reconquista not been so successful, the Iberian peninsula would still be predominantly Muslim. I’m just giving a couple of the hundreds of thousands of examples of how conquered lands eventually convert into the lands of the conquerer.
evaa, shiasm is actually a jewish sect made by ibn saba the jew similar who said Ali is god after fighting Muslims like how crypto jew paul said jesus is god after killing Muslims who follow JEsus. shiasm is a fake sect to fight Muslims
Ali ibn Abu-Taleb (Imam Ali) is the first person who accepted Islam, not the second.
During the last time prophet Mohammad was on the way back from Mecca to Madine, on a place which called ghadire khom he stoped and told the Muslims who followed him that Ali is my successor, those who followed me, should follow him after me.
This is why Shia muslims believes Imam Ali is the true successor after prophet Mohammad.
I just don’t understand why Sunni Muslims don’t care about ghadire khom.
the response to your last query is because they believe the shias fabricated everything, infact, there was no such thing as shias or sunnis, but to create a divide in the muslim community much later on after the 4 rightly guided caliphs' times, did the transgressors finally emerge with their fabricated hadith and made-up religion and started to call it's followers as shias, these people weren't given any chunk in the power shared by the authorities before the abbasid caliphate and were severely persecuted by the remaining muslims so it comes as NO surprise that they decided to bring new ideas into an already formed religion disrupting the solidarity of muslims
Final sermon in arafat does not mention
Spot on. But you forgot to add one detail that’s important. After Mohammad dies his “close companions” are having this election and mohammad’s body is not even buried yet. Ali is the only one prepping the body and preparing for the funeral. This is a fact... in all books of hadiths (Sunni and shia) but you’re not trying to be bias in your videos so we get it. Thanks for your videos Khan Academy. I’ve been listening to your academic videos since I was in high school. You’ve made a great impact in my life and career. Thank you. May God bless you and grant you health and longer life.
What are you trying to imply? Of course Ali (ra) would prepare his body, since Ali(ra) is his immediate family. Paint the complete picture when it comes Saqifa.
@Adil sidd the Shi'i alleged place where AbuBakr and Umar usurped the rights of Ali.
Xoz eXoz but when the prophet was on his deathbed he said to Omar to bring him a pen and paper but omar refused and said your not well and ill and your hilucinating to the prophet and we don’t know what the prophet would’ve written
@@raven6955 lies
@@AmjedAce that is full of lies yes but also weakens the shia position, if it was anything of religious significance the prophet would say it during the three days he was still alive. SAW
As a Christian, an outsider, and obviously not knowing all the details, so far the impression that history and facts leave upon me is that Shia are correct.
redlander55 I like how you are a Christian and looking at Islam, however I disagree, but we all have opinions
Son of Mountain - you are what is wrong with Sunni Muslims.
Ali did not have a problem with Abu Bakr being the leader after the death. Abu Bakr was the prophet's dearest friend and eventual father-in-law. Ali respected him and did not oppose him. This divide isn't really necessary this early.
Correct
@@shifan2482 I am a shia imam Ali never gave alegencie to Abu Bakr Omar or Uthhman but he took prophet Mohammed advice to have patience and he did he was Khalifa for few years but he never really cared about that. He could be Khalifa from the start but he wanted to preserve Islam and the ummah from early destruction with Roman and Persians around. I feel sad to see sunni brothers putting lies saying a jew created shia Islam or other lies which only create division. I choose to live by my Imam Ali way and have patience and love for Islam and Allah and his messenger.
Sunni and Shias are brothers and are part of one Umma the Muslim community
Do not let outsiders divide us
Good video,
Liked it because had no bias and no interpretation of speaker. Only history.
Thanks for putting indonesian subtitle, actually, i watch this video to learning english
*Long live Shia-Sunni unity*
*May Allah destroy those who want to weaken Islam by division*
shiasm is teh divide, its made by ibn saba jew who said Ali is god to pretend to be Muslim and push paganism and violence, similar to how paul said Jesus is god and pushed violence too, shiasm mean to pretend to be Muslim & fight them!
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 rafizi pagans are mixture of judaism and majoos of faris.
@@zackgha5533 I wrote something aginst him as well but really brother sometimes I wonder even these people are Muslims. I think they are trained to create discord and they may be atheist agent of the west.
@@bahramzareie2447Salam Brother. We shia/sunni= Muslims and brothers but some people talks about the past pointing at each other mabe its the WAHABI's bro i dont know but for sure with negative attitude is just like a (Donkey)
That didn't age well...
As salaamu Alikum
Brother and sister
We are Muslim
And we should follow the Quran and sunnah...
Not the leaders...
Let us be united and follow our deen...
This is the only solution to this problem..
May Allah swt guide us all..
Ameen
Quran says different:اطیعوا الله و اطیعوا الرسول و اولی الامر منکم
Ali un wali Ullah 😍❤️ ALLUMDULLIAH
Thank you for this video I’ve learned a lot from this thank you so much!
I am sunni muslim of indonesia..i love all muslim's people in the world :)
@Debabrata Moulick he didn't mean to thou but Racist deserves worst
Something not mentioned here that seems important is the fact that Abu Bakr and the others that became caliphs pledged allegiance to Ali after Muhammed's speech.
I think Ali pledged to Abu Bakr who lead the salat during Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him's lifetime. shias made Ali into a "God" similar to how paul made Jesus into a God!
forget the past move on
false sects like shia are judeo made Mate you know nothing, imam ali never accepted abu bakr as a caliph , while they were praying when abu bakr became "caliph" imam ali was doing janaza to the prophet ( pbuh) .
redlander55 Ali can’t compare with Abu Bakar LoL
Both groups are primarily Muslims . Just because there is a little difference in ideology doesn't mean we have cast out different sets.
Instead look at the similar believes ,
Worship 1 God follow his messengers
very impressive, a ballance history of the Muslim split between the sunni and shia. imaam ibrahiym from Trinidad.
But his not that accurate... As a Muslim, its better if one to goes for a self investigation of their own history & tradition...without the influence of other interpretation or views, but strictly on the Quran & Authentic Hadith's.... ;)
I really liked your video that you done about Islam but I'm going to say this. if his companion were close to the prophet Muhammad wouldn't they help with his family setting up the funeral rather than talk about who should be the next leader?
Nour elcheikh. Your question is insignificant. If Mohamed had been the most important person in their lives what makes you think they would fail to bury him ? Of course they buried him.
What you don't understand is that the muslim nation was facing a rebellion the moment mohamed died. Without a leader it also faced a power vacuum with no one able to combat the rebellion and no one to fight off evil contenders for mohamed's position. If mohamed's followers did not install a leader immediately the enemies would have attempted to install their own leader. That would have been pretty bad for the muslims. We find that eventually this did happen after the four khalifa's had served their time as leaders. Their demise ushered in the sick demented amayyad tribe later to be followed by the just so sick and demented abbasid mob or the muawiyah's as they were known. Islam would spread under these two dynasties but we have to ask were they spreading islam or were they just expanding arabia. We have to ask this because they were evil. They pretended to be muslim and they expanded their borders by using islam to rally their troops. We see the same thing happening today when we look at terrorist mobs like ISIS who fight for money while pretending to fight for God.
We need to remember why Umar rushed to mosque to take decision of succession. Firstly, there were people who claimed prophecy and people were asking for someone to lead the state. By that time, only way Umar found was to call Abu Bakr and then we know he became Khalifat un Nabi.
@@hashirjaffry3165 you seem to be lying, Ali said Abu Bakr and Umar RAdiyallahu anhum are better then him. Thats why Ali married his daughter to umar and Prophet peace and blessings on him told Abu Bakr Radiyallahu anhu to lead salat. shiasm was made by ibn saba who said Ali is Allah similar to paul who said Jesus is Allah, and tried to change scripture to divide the ummah!
false sects like shia are judeo made that’s more precise it all started with Abdullah Bin Saba , although he was burnt alive by Hazrat Ali (RA) along with his 40 other followers but what he gave to Islam is something which will remain as a big deep scar .. may Allah guide us all to the right path
My brother please don’t ask such questions next time as it starts debates between Muslims, just go ask your imam or parents
Thank you so much for making this! I have two friends, one a Shia and the other a Sunni, so this helps me to understand it more. thanks! 😁💗
how is their relationship? where are they from may i ask?
My sunni friend is from India and my shia friend is from pakistan! They're good friends!
or we can teach the shias to be Sunnis as shiasm was made by a jew ibn saba and shia leaders like khomeini have said the Quran in incomplete whe the Quran itself says its perfect. this shows shias don't follow Islam's pillar!
Hello dear friend How are you
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 ruclips.net/video/RnWjGlVPvQg/видео.html
so the world was plunged to war for centuries and still is because of a one sentence phrase He made or worse still one word being misinterpreted?
we have "ISIS" today because people didnt want to follow that phrase.
One has to go through deep history its not so superficial......
And ghadeer e khum is not just one sentence ....its an event and 5 hours long sermon of prophet muhammad saww....which is often not revealed .....
So understanding shia narrative requires long hard work
yes thank you bro. Any Muslims who Listen to the Prophets last speech in Ghadir Khumm ? Any?
Beautifully explained. I just wanted to make it clear that Shias did not decide on their own, it was all by Allah swa that the Prophet of Islam be raised by His chosen one, Abu Talib father of Ali a.s and later Ali a.s was raised by Prophet Muhammad saww therefore becomes the first male Muslim! The Ayat in Quran does not mention compainions, but the Familyof Prophet Muhammad saww and that's what us Shi'as honor.
" Verily Allah swa desire is to remove blemish from you, O People of Household (Ahlul-Bayt) and purify you with a perfect purification" (33:33)
Your one of those humans that just knows everything🙃
We Shia Sunni are Brother to one an others we are Ummah
shiasm began as something deviant just like the christians who said Jesus is a "god". ibn saba started saying Ali is a "god" to divde Muslims as well!
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 No cursed bustred you who like scare rat do not put your name here - as this noble Sunni Shaykh says it in this lecture:
ruclips.net/video/9FU30nfjB5o/видео.html
In minute 8:22 he narrates Ibn Abbas (ra) who said by whom that my life is in his hand this is " the will " of messenger of Allah sawa and the shaykh continues that Messenger of Allah while being on a she camel gave this lecture and among things he said was this " this my will for you after me that if you follow it and cling to it you would not be misguided and that is the book of Allah and my Family (not the book of Allah and Sunnati that it is not mentioned in Bukhari and Muslim) that you the naasibi dogs used and it source is the servant of Ka'ab bin Ahbar who was the enemy of Imam Ali (as)
Then shaykh continues in minute 11:33 that messenger of Allah again gathered the Muslims in a place called Ghadeer khum and stood between five trees and again in minute 12:07 after the messenger of Allah says that I leave with you two weighty things the book of Allah and my Family...then he (sawa) continued to say: see how you treat them after me (recallectoin: you Nasibi dog and your ancestors cursed the Imam Ali (as) who prophet said that me and I am from Ali and Ali is from me, and me and Ali are from the same tree and other people from the other trees.
Wrong and truth cant mix we got to get it strait
Allah Bless Ali
Ali a.s
@@rajab4187 Ali ra*
May Allah bless them all... Ameen!
Max ماكس shutup no r.a Only A.S as Allah is raazi withe Ali A.S so there is no need to say r.a
Max ماكس Ali as*
Thank you very much, providing this information in a very simple way🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳
Oh man a simple different interpretation of a word "mawla" by two groups made all these confusion and it still good on.. breaking Islam into two..
The issue was that shia don't think logically. They don't think anyone else could be leader other than descendants of Nabi (A.S). So this problem gets its strong view against Caliphate although Ali was Supreme Judge and most important advisor to first two Caliphs. So the real source of divide between Muslims came after death of Uthman. Ali got stuck between demand to execute Uthman's killers and his desire to maintain peace in Islamic empire. His viewpoint got challenged by Uthman's relatives. There is good detail to these particular set events. But I think that's enough for a comment
@@twinklingstar2082
how exactly "The issue was that shia don't think logically",
1. Ghadir khum was not the only ceremony were he gave hints, before ghadir khom Prophet Mohammad gathered his companions, in his last pilgrimage to Mecca, in what is known as the Goodbye speech, were he said: " I am leaving you with 2 things, if you follow them you will never lose your path again.", after his companions asked him what are those 2 things, he said: ""the word/book of God(The Quran), and my household", what happened to said household, they were all assassinated at the hands of so called caliphs that came from the Ummayad day till the Abbasid.
2. and after the goodbye ceremony wene they were moving back towards Medina, Ghadir khum happened.
3. All Prophets left a successor, which prophet did not leave a successor before, in a ceremony.
4. Ali and his sons had Islamic knowledge unparalleled by anyone else except for Prophet Mohammad, because they were hand taught Islam by Prophet Mohammad himself, Ali was the first Muslim male to accept Islam, Ali have been by the side of Prophet Mohammad from the beginning, he risked his own life to protect prophet Mohammad, and after he got Hassan and Hussein, while other children were playing outside, they were both being taught Islam by Ali and Prophet Mohammad himself.
4. As the person in the video said, while Prophet Mohammad family were busy burying him, some of his companions were already discussing who would be a successor.
5. you claim that Shi'ia Muslims don't think anyone else could be leader than descendants/household of Nabi, yet a lot of Sunni Muslims claim that Abu bakr is the caliph because Aisha married Prophet Mohammad, really contradicting themselves, not wishing to start a fight or anything, but stop with those baseless accusations, and its not that they are the descendants of Prophet Mohammad, its just they are the only ones that had knowledge of Islam and people that you could ask them everything about Islam.
6. Shi'ia Muslims did not pick Ali because he is just the descendant or even picked household of Prophet Mohammad through Ali just because they were descendants, they Picked Ali and his family because at that time, it was only Ali and the household of Ali that were trained in the pure knowledge of Islam, after all look at the history which is usually overlooked of what happened to Prophet Mohammad household through Ali, they became scientists, Judges, Islamic Jurists, they even trained some Imams.
7. What this small narration of events also overlooked is the fact that all 11 descendants of Prophet Mohammad that had the pure knowledge of Islam were killed at the hands of the caliphs that came from the Ummayad era till the Abbasid era, all of them got poisoned, except for Hussein which was decapitated and his head taken to Yazid I for some Golden coins, the killers of Hussein were hunted down and killed.
8. Do you know the reason for the downfall of the Ummayad Empire? wene people found out what Yazid and his ancestors have done to Prophet Mohammad household, a violent rebellion started and every suspected Ummayad was killed.
@@mohammadjaafar1496 " Its just they are the only ones that had knowledge of Islam and people that you could ask them everything about Islam."
When you say those were the only ones with knowledge, does it mean that other companions of prophet were not qualified at all?
Brother, when you talk of knowledge then Ibn e Masaud was also knowledgeful like Ali (A.S). Indeed Ali (A.S) was "key to city of knowledge" according to Hadith of prophet But His political decision of taking pledge for Caliphate before bringing Killers of Uthman caused trouble for him even when his son Hasan(A.S) advised against his decision to take pledge.
The first five rightly guided Caliphs were capable to rule Islamic State and they ruled it in best interest of Ummah.
Shia Muslims still think that only descendants of Nabi are capable to rule Islam although Nabi (Peace Be Upon Him) told that merit of superiority lies in piety and good action. Indeed household of Prophet were pious. I don't think we are disagreeing.
@@twinklingstar2082 following rasul is not logic to you? Did the prophet pbuh take abu bakr hand at ghadeer? Well no
@@mohammadjaafar1496 brother...can we discuss outside YT ? Would be a pleasure
Peace
If you're going to say you are mentioned these guys in the other videos, can you at least put a link to those other videos in the description?
Quite helpful for those who don't know!
@Islamist Reactionary إرتجاج الإسلامي why is that?
kinda similar to how the brand of christianity that the 12 disciples of jesus spread didn't spread wide but the romanized christianity that paul spread 50-100 years later was more popular in the roman world. less of a direct conflict but rather similar in popular alternative view.
I love how you took the time and research and how u setup you presentation I don't understand why you are not Muslim with the knowledge you can gain.
Mr. Khan is a Muslim.
The founder of khan academy is Muslim, kind of obvious based on his name of course but you can also search it up
I have one question why does there have to be 1 successor why can’t they just carry on the teachings and religion?
There was a ruling from God
Because that is the mercy of God. He does not leave the people without guidance and leave no excuse for our deviation.
We believe Muhammad (saw) clearly said that Ali should replace me, but the majority of Muslims ignored that.
Nice video!
I’m amaze how you kept track of all this
Sir, please give me a PDF of this notes about shia and sunni traditions
Greetings. May i recommend a PDF link of a great book which will clear all your doubts regarding shia-sunni stuff?
@@dominancepreserved8749 No, thanks 👍
I’ll say this for the Shia, they do have a certain sense of style.
Okay we have the better one mind it not like fake suadis
The style of the prophet inshallah
Shia and sunni are brothers ❤🙏👍
Then why abu bakr made injustice on the daughter of muhammad??
Why he burned the door of fatima??
Why he take the fidakk of fatima??
Why umar did not let the muhammad to write something, at last moment of him, in order to protect from fittnah??
@@ShiaNoorAhlBayt very true beshak...astagfirullah
I realy like the way you are explaining it ! 👍🏼
Peace be upon him
Who? Certainly not a savage degenerate who fabricated a sock puppet diety to conveniently lend license to all manner of his heinous behaviors.
@@sansdecorum4600 Plz stay away
@@sansdecorum4600 why did you click on this video???
this is the best video you have ever made
بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم
«« وَوَهَبْنَا لَهُم مِّن رَّحْمَتِنَا وَجَعَلْنَا لَهُمْ لِسَانَ صِدْقٍ عَلِيًّا »»
سورة مریم ، آیة 50 / sura maryam , Aya 50
And We bestowed Our mercy on them and
made Ali "the tongue of truth" (confirming the Prophet Ibrahim).
أشهد أن مولانا أمیرالمؤمنین علیاً ولي الله
This is not an unbiased video.It's the sunni version of events. They didn't invite Ali to their meeting to elect a new caliph because Omar wanted to make Abubakr caliph. Abubakr confiscated land that belonged to Fatima daughter of prophet who was a vocal opponent of Abubakr becoming caliph and Abubakr men in their attack on Ali's home slammed the door in flank of Fatimah which led to her death. Abubakr never punished those men. They physically assaulted Ali and only because a war with heretic tribes was going on and Ali didn't want a civil war on top of it he accepted Abubakr to become caliph. Abubakr also exiled Abazar another friend of prophet for supporting Ali. He died in exile.
Peace be upon our beloved prophet and the companions of the prophet pbu them
peace be upon the people that KNOW that Malachi was the last of the real prophets
and peace be upon the people that love God
cheers
First on family of muhammad then companion
For your kind information, Sunni and Shias are brothers, yes there is a question on Khilafat and Immamat. Shias followers of immamat and Sunnis Khilafat. Now where is bloodshed come from.
There is no difference among Muslims. Our prophet is one, Book of Allah is One, Our Kibla (The house of God is) is one.
The word sunni is not following the sunnah of the Prophet(saw), rather is sunnah of abu bakr which is totally wrong.
????
Rather the sunnah of Muawiyah!
@@tenybhai سنة اختك
@@ياالله-ن3ط هذه أخلاقكم يا أتباع بني أمية و ابن تيمية!
Amazing narrative and voice. Regards
The question that arises is how the Prophet Muhammad may God’s prayers and peace be upon him and his family, who is the most knowledgeable of the people ,how he did not appoint a successor for the Muslims after him? Knowing that people have asked him even about how to enter the bathroom, and how to perform ablution many many times , so how can they not ask him about the fate of Muslims after his death? the answer is that they asked him and of course it is impossible that the prophet would leave such an important decision which is who will be the successor of the Muslims after him to the people, but rather appointed Imam Ali who is his cousin, and his daughter’s husband the Lady of the Women of Paradise (Lady Fatima al-Zahra). The evidence is what happened in Ghadeer Khum when the Prophet raised the hand of Imam Ali and said:any one whom iam his leader then Ali is his leader, ((((Allah is my leader (mawla) and I am the leader (mawla) of the faithful and I have superior right on and control over their lives, and Ali is the mawla of those of whom I am mawla, he said it three times ,The Holy Prophet then continued to say: “O’ God, love those who love him, and be hostile to those who are hostile to him”. Once the Holy Prophet (peace be upon him and his household) completed his speech this verse of the Holy Quran was revealed to him,{Today I have perfected your religion and completed my favor upon you, and I am satisfied that Islam be your religion})))).
■Now as for the Sunnis, they follow people who did not follow the commandment of the Prophet Muhammad may God’s prayers and peace be upon him and his family, and they distinguished between Muslims. Some of the Muslim didnot accept this matter and followed Imam Ali and his family(Shia), and some of them followed Omar and Abu Bakr (Sunni)who didn't follow the Prophet’s commandment.
***Evil Is With Those Who Will Extinguish The Light Of Truth ***
We are followers of Muhammad.
They are followers of Ali, so Sunni Islam is the only true religion
The narratar has only mentioned one daughter Hazrat Fatima but there are other daughters and sons who have died at early stage
Ali Zain he did have other children who were his own blood but died at a young age
@MIke Zandi they are bibi khadija's sister daughters after sister died bibi khadija adopted him after prophet Mohammed s.a.w marriege they called prophet Mohammed s.a.w dauggters understand hazret mohammed habe only one blood daughter called bibi fatima a.s she is a real sister of hazret mohammed s.aw and bibi khadija a.s and other 3 are bibi fatima a.s cousine sisters not a real sister
Ali Zain sunis know nothing chill bro
Abudajana Ansari how you calling shia kafir? go and learn that islam isn't about judging other people's beliefs. don't know how your a sunni👏🏻
Syed S R Rizvi i agree with you but let them judge shia islam as one ummah and ahlubayt we have been tought
makasih
udah di terjemahkan
i am shia
Good
I m Shia
@@ShiaNoorAhlBayt
Where are u from?
Dubbed it in urdu
Indian Sub continent has 60 millions of Muslims who understand urdu and 120 millions of other people
😁😂
@@nishikakumari9615 kya huwa
As I understood from what I read, although the Sunni - Shia difference was visible immediately after Muhammed's death, the distinct Sunni and Shia dividing identities were formed much later.
@Islamist Reactionary إرتجاج الإسلامي who are you, why are you trying to spread this falsehood upon the people. While the truth stands clear with the people. May Allah(saw) silence your lying breath. Luqman a. Alim
F@Islamist Reactionary إرتجاج الإسلامي
Ali (AbPH) said " you are my shia"
meaning followers
@@cliftonpowell6418 what falsehood, shia books even say ibn saba formed shiasm, go see anit majus productions. ibn saba said Ali is a "God" similar to how crypto judeo paul lied and made Jesus one! they try to divde ppl.
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 Imam Ali "As" imprisoned then killed and burned Abdullah ibn Saba for calling Imam Ali a God. We is cursed in Shia Islam. Your hatred and falsehood will not change anything. We are followers of Ali on this day and until last day of this Universe. May Allah curse fall on your forehead you shitiyan.
We may differ in a few matters, but our differences are only limited to discussion or debate which can be resolved, not a conflict or hatred, and our differences were merely a political dispute and should not be a theological dispute. Despite this, our ancestors remained united under one umbrella [i.e. Islam] and they shared the same Aqidah because of the Qur'an and the teachings of our Beloved Prophet (ﷺ). We too can unite. ❤️
Great video, so very helpful, thank you very much!!!
Shia or Sunni we are one. Love my shia brothers and sisters.
U can’t love the shia they hate u
Thank you so much for videos!😊
Muslims Are Always Together!
There is a little bit confusion here.Mohammad(saww) and Khadijah(sa) had only one daughter i.e Hazrat Fatima(sa)
No
Her name was Fatimah and was killed by second Khalifa Omar
Bro I request you, say Sallallahu Alayhi Wasallam after saying our last prophets name.
Great structure and presentation, great pronunciation and speed of voice. Good stuff!
Ok I know next to nothing about Islam, please stop me if I got it wrong - Ali is Mohamed's first cousin, right? Fatimah is Mohamed's daughter, right? So to Ali, Fatimah is his first cousin once-removed (or niece), right? The video is amazing but explains very little on how the Muslim world views and treats incest and what the Muslim society is doing to prevent that.
Who Loves Shia Community?
Mujhe Islam Bahut Pasand Hai , Mujhe Ye Quran ke 9:5 , 33:27 , 4:89 ki baatein samjhado please
Muhammed PBUH
I am a sunni muslim but according to my knowledge Ali E.S/R.A is the first muslim. Cause he never converted, he was raised muslim.
you post maths VIDEOS we WATCH u at SCHOOL
I am a Muslim and I am ashamed of that sunni-shia split, it's embarrassing.
It is not about Muhammad's family. It is because Muhammad nominated Ali as his wazeer, with the status of Aaron to Moses without being a prophet. May God bless them all. Additionally the prophet says that he is the most knowledgeable and noble and is the waly/mawla and khalifah of the Muslims in a way that the prophet was. Additionally, Ali's two children are are called two leaders in paradise. Sunni hadeeth also say that the blood family of the prophet would never separate from the Quran and that the prophet let behind these two to guide the Muslims.
Well shia most religious al kaafi says Ali has Happy Abu bakr being ist caliph...read ist your own books then talk about others
First you should mention that Khadijah in not a widow in Shia tradition
Also in Sunni sources Imam Ali was the real First khalifa (successor) chosen by the prophet long before Ghader khom event. that event was one and not the only evidence. but many hypocrites didn't allow this to happen therefore Muslims got divided.
قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم لعلي عليه السلام: انت مني بمنزلة هارون من موسى الا انك لست نبيا وانت خليفتي في كل مؤمن بعدي
السنة لابن ابي عاصم ص799/800 حديث 1222
In which Sunni source? Unfortunately The context of Ghadir Khum does not support your case.
@@DrXoz Read the Arabic text mentioned above.
@@blakz28 You should be ashamed of your self. You left out our most authentic sources and ran straight to some fabricated hadith. Sahih Muslim 2404
Sa'd b. Abi Waqqas reported that Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) left 'Ali b. Abi Talib behind him (as he proceeded) to the expedition of Tabuk, whereupon he ('Ali) said: Allah's Messenger, are you leaving me behind amongst women and children? Thereupon he (the Holy Prophet) said: Aren't you satisfied with being unto me what Aaron was unto Moses but with this exception that there would be no prophet after me?
We can clearly see that the Prophet left Ali in charge of the people, just like how Musa left Harun to look after the people after he went to Allah SWT for forty days. And it cannot mean khilafat because Harun died before Musa.
@@DrXoz You should be ashamed of yourself for being ignorant even in your own Hadiths and books the one i mentioned your scholars said its correct (Sahih) to say its fabricated you're being stupidly blinded. just because it's not from bukhari or Muslim does not mean its not Sahih or authentic you can twist the story as much you like but the truth is the word "Khalifa after me" is clear for anyone who understand Arabic whether Harun died or lives the point is the Prophet chosed Imam Ali as his Khalifa after him whether you like it or not.
@@blakz28 Your dishonesty is of the chart. The reason I quoted Sahih Muslim was to show you that the last part of the hadith you mentioned (Khalifah) is not original. You are brushing off the most authentic, and running straight to variants which you think supports you Shirki religion. It is well established that the successor to the prophet Moses was Yusha bin Noon, so it would make more sense for the prophet to say "You will be to me, as Yusha was to Moses" had he intended to name Ali as his successor. Dishonesty is a trait among you and your forefathers.
Also Turkeys are believing to Sunni....
Most of them sufism
Any Muslims who Listen to the Prophets last speech in Ghadir Khumm ? Any?
Sufism if I may say
SAA Well exuse me who are you to judge?
@SAA drinking alcohol doesn't take one out of Islam but it does make them a sinner
If they believe/ deem it to be halal, then and only then, will they leave Islam
Brother go in the Quran sourat Al Imran 3:103 read it yourself and came back
This is interesting thank youuuu
I am from Bangladesh. Mostly we are all Sunni Muslims. But I don’t like this difference. So little difference is turning us against each other. Is it worth it? NO.
I am a Practicing Muslim who follows our Rasul (SM)‘s Sunnahs. That’s it.
Then why abu bakr made injustice on the daughter of muhammad??
Why he burned the door of fatima??
Why he take the fidakk of fatima??
Why umar did not let the muhammad to write something, at last moment of Muhammad , in order to protect from fittnah??
Why fatima did not talk to the three caliph till death???
@@ShiaNoorAhlBayt your definitely a Shia
Sunni or Shia were all Muslims we should read our prayers and the Qur'an and be stead fast... focus on our deen our eternal life in jannah Rather then who should be next in line thy all had the same beliefs we should concentrate on that more the beliefs...
For that you need to follow Sirat Al Mustaqim...
Islam have no division there is no shia sunni in the Quran
yo I use khan academy to learn math and now I find this 😂 great video tho
Im a muslim, thats it!
i am not a muslim i love jesus but i love all people and GOD loves me and you my brother AND I LOVE YOU MY BROTHER AND WITCH EVER GOD WE LOVE HE WILL LOVE YOU AND ME SO BE OF GOOD HEART AND SOUL AND WE SHOULD ALL SHOW LOVE MY BROTHER TO ALL PEOPLES ON EARTH
But you have to follow one of the two sides of Islam Sunni/Shia or any other group for example when Aisha and Ali fought in the battle of the camel you couldn’t have been on both sides because one of them had to be wrong. And there is different rules in different Muslim groups for example Sunnis pray with their arms to their stomach while Shi’a pray with their arm to their legs so you have to choose on of the ways
Annichiru! Sunni or Shia?
If first 3 caliphs was on right path,
Then why abu bakr made injustice on the daughter of muhammad??
Why he burned the door of fatima??
Why he take the fidakk of fatima??
Why umar did not let the muhammad to write something, at last moment of Muhammad , in order to protect from fittnah??
Why fatima did not talk to the three caliph till death???
Fake stories
@@gmc1413 fake? Are you sure? Because these stories are actually in sahih Muslim and sahih bukhari! So unless you're saying that sahih Muslim and bukhari are fake, you have to accept those "fake stories"!
Fake😂
Thank you very much for the information. As we all learn about Islamic History, I believe its safe to say that Muslims today would not follow the Bani Umayyad or Abbasids like Muslims back then did. This is evident as the Axis of Resistance grows and non-Muslims flock to Islam by day. MashAllah!
When the prophet (Peace be upon him) was dying, rather than staying by his side they were busy choosing who would be the new leader.
He died on the lap of mother A'isha.
No this didn't happen.
Muhammad Ahzam u r wrong
@@syedatimsaalzehrazaidi4157 he's right.
@@syedatimsaalzehrazaidi4157
Maybe you haven't been taught about that. After all, how could you have hated her.
Shia' is not based on Islam anymore but Saidina Ali does..the followers of Ali can't accept Muhammad as the prophet or messenger of Allah
There is no "Sunni" or "Shiah" in my holy book.
There is just "Muslim".
👍
❤
Read it again!
@@talibshah9210?
Dear muslims, please do research on the differences between m'utazila Islam and A'shari Islam and the history thereof. Then do yourself a favour and study Islamic history to see what happened to the family of the Prophet (SAW) after his death. Also, try and find out how his companions behaved on his deathbed and how his body was treated after his death. Who washed it and how long was it left to lie unburied. If you can please come and leave a comment here after you've done your research. To make this easy good Google: Incident of Qirtas, Event of Ghadeer Khum, Hadith ul Manzilah, Dawatul Ashira, Mubahila and Hadith al Kisa.
Are you a convert?
@@dominancepreserved8749 a revert because all people are born Muslim
@@RocketAfriqueZA that's great. I am a shia too. I was wondering if i could recommend you great hadith PDF which has knowledgeable and informative hadith by the Holy Ahlulbayt (pbut) regarding tawheed, morals and ethics so on and so forth.
@@RocketAfriqueZA fot instance,
*Imam Ali Al Riza's (a) (8th Imam) Sermon On The Unity/Oneness Of God*
Al-Ma’mun (May God Curse him) sent someone after him and he came. The Hashemites told him, “O Abul Hasan (Imam Riza)! Climb up the pulpit and display for us a sign whereby we may worship God.” So he (a) climbed up the pulpit and sat there for a long time with his head bowed down in silence. Then he trembled - a great trembling - and stood up straight, praised the Sublime God, and recited God’s praises and asked for His blessing for His Prophet and the Members of the Holy Household.
Then he (a) said, “The first element in the worship of the Sublime God is His recognition. The root of recognition of God is to profess to His Unity. The order for professing the Unity of God is to deny He has any attributes, since the powers of reasoning testify that every attribute and everything which possesses an attribute are created. Everything that is
created testifies that it has a Creator which is neither an attribute nor does it possess any attributes. Every attribute and everything possessing
an attribute testify to the association between the attribute and that to which it is attributed. Any association testifies to temporality.
And temporality testifies that it accepts not the Beginningless which accepts not the temporal. So it is not God whose Essence is recognized through striking similitude. It is not His Unity that is professed by someone who attempts to fathom Him. It is not His reality (haqiqa) that is attained by someone who strikes a similitude for Him. It is not He who is confirmed (tasdiq) by him who professes an end for Him. If one points to Him, it is not God that is pointed to. It is not He who is meant by him who compares Him
(to something). It one ascribes parts to God, he has not indeed humbled himself in the presence of God. And it is not God who is desired by one who conceives of God in his imagination. Everything that can be known in itself is fashioned.
All that stands apart from Him is an effect. God is inferred from what He fashions, the recognition of Him is expedited by the powers of reasoning, and the argument for Him is established by (man's) primordial nature. God's creating of the creatures is a veil between Him and them. His separation (mubayana) from them is due to the fact that He is disengaged from their localization. That He is their origin is proof for them that He has no origin, for none that has an origin can originate others. That He has created them possessing means (of accomplishing things) is proof that He has no means (adapt) for means are
witness to the poverty of those who use them. So His names are an expression, His acts are (a way) to
make (Him) understood, and His Essence is Reality. His innermost center separates Him from Creation, and His otherness limits what is other than Him. Therefore ignorant of God is he
who asks for Him to be described!Transgressing against Him is he who seeks to encompass Him!Mistaken is he who imagines to have fathomed
Him! Whoever asks 'how?' has compared Him (to something). Whoever says 'why?' has professed for Him a cause. Whoever says 'when?' has determined Him in time. Whoever says 'in what?' has enclosed Him. Whoever says 'to what?' has professed for Him a limit. Whoever says 'until what?' has given Him an end. Whoever gives Him an end has associated
an end with Him. Whoever associates an end with Him has divided
Him. Whoever divides Him has described Him. Whoever describes Him
has deviated from the straight path concerning Him.
God does not change with the changes undergone by Creation, just as
He does not become limited by delimiting that which is limited.
He is One, not according to the explanation offered by number; Outward, not according to the explanation of being immediate (to the senses); Manifest, not through the appearance of a vision (of Him); Inward, not through separation; Apart, not through distance; Near, not through approach; Subtle, not through corporealness; Existent, not after nonexistence; Active, not through coercion; Determining, not through the activity of thought; Directing, not through movement; Desiring, not through resolution; Willing, not through directing attention; Grasping, not through touch; Hearing, not through means;
and Seeing, not through organs.Times accompany Him not, places enclose Him not, slumber seizes
Him not, attributes delimit Him not, and instruments are of no
use to Him. His Being precedes time, His Existence
precedes non-existence and His Beginninglessness precedes beginning. By His giving sense to the sense organs it is known that He has no sense organs. By His giving substance to substances it is known that He
has no substance. By His causing opposition among things it is known that He has no opposite. By His causing affiliation among affairs it is
known that He has no affiliate. He made darkness opposite to light, obscurity to clarity, moisture to dryness, and heat to cold. He joins together
those things which are in total contradiction with one another and separates those which are near. They prove (the existence of) their Separator
by their separation and their Joiner by their junction. That is (the meaning of) the Sublime (God’s) words, ‘And of every thing We have created
pairs: That ye may receive instruction.’ So through them He separated 'before' and 'after' that it might be
known that He has no before and after. They testify with their temperaments that He who gave them temperaments has no temperament. They
prove by their disparity that He who made them disparate has no disparity. They announce by their subjection to time that He who subjected
them to time is not subject to it Himself. He veiled some of them from others, so that it might be known that there is no veil between Him and them other than them. His is the true meaning of lordship when there was none over whom
He was Lord; the reality of Godhood when there was nothing for whom He was God; the true meaning of All-Knower when there was
nothing to be known; the true meaning of m Creator when there was nothing created and the interpreter of hearing when there was nothing to be
heard. It is not because He created that which makes Him deserve the
true meaning (of the term) 'Creator' and not because He brought the
creatures into being that the true meaning of 'making' is derived.
How (could it not be so)? For using such words as ‘ago’ conceals Him not, 'already' brings Him not near, ‘perhaps’ veils Him not, 'when' limits Him not in time, 'at the time of' contains Him not, and 'with' associates Him not.
Instruments limit only themselves and means are only effective upon
other similar means. Their activities are found only in things. The word
‘ago’ keeps things from being eternal; the word 'already'
shields them from beginninglessness; and the words 'if only'
wards off perfection. Things become separate and thus they
prove (the existence of) their Separator. They become distinguished and thus they prove their Distinguisher Through them their
Maker manifests Himself to the powers of reasoning, and He becomes
veiled to the sight through these powers. To these powers of reasoning imaginations appeal for a decision. And in them is substantiated (only) other than Him. From them is suspended the proof and through them He has revealed to them the acknowledgement of His Unity.
Confirmation of God is made fast by the powers of reasoning,
and faith in Him attains perfection through acknowledgment. There is
no religiousness except after recognition, no knowledge except through sincerity and no sincerity along with striking similitude. If one ascribes attributes for God, then he has indeed drawn a
similitude. So nothing in Creation is found in its Creator. All that is possible in it
is impossible in its Maker. Movement and stillness do
not affect Him. How should that which He affects (in others) have any
effect upon Him, or that which He has originated recur for Him?Then
His Essence would be disparate, His innermost center would be divided
and His being Eternal would become an impossibility. How would then
the Creator have a meaning different from the created?
If something from behind limited Him, then something in front would limit Him. If perfection were seeking Him, imperfection would be upon Him. How should that which does not transcend temporality be worthy of (the Name) 'Beginningless'? How should that
which does not transcend being produced, produce the things (of
the world)?There they would have arisen in Him a sign of having been
made and He would become a proof after having been the proven.
There is no argument in absurd opinions; there is no answer
when it (absurdity) is asked about; and there is no glorification of Him in its meaning. Nor is there any absurdity in distinguishing Him from Creation, unless it be that the Independent accepts not to be made into
two, nor does the Beginningless accepts to have a beginning.
There is no god but God, the All-High, and the Tremendous. They have cried lies that ascribe equals to God! They have gone astray into farreaching error and suffered a manifest loss!May God’s Blessings be upon Muhammad and his Pure Household.
Uyoon Akhbaar Imam Al Riza (a) vol.1 p.142
@@RocketAfriqueZA for instance,
*The Commander Of The Believers Imam Ali ibn Abi Taalib (pbuh) Describes The Qualities Of A Believer*
Once a man called Hammam, a devout worshipper practicing religious rules and a hardworking man came to The Commander Of The believers Imam Ali ibn Abi Taalib (pbuh) during his speech and said, ‘ O Commander of the believers, describe for us the qualities of the believer as if we see him before our eyes’.
'The commander of the believers Imam Ali (pbuh) said:
‘O Hammam, a believer is a smart, intelligent one whose delight is on his face and whose sadness is in his heart, his chest is vastly open, his soul is most humble, he criticizes one’s leaning to every mortal, exhorts to everything good. He is not hateful, quarrelsome, scandalous, faultfinding or backbiting. He dislikes high positions (leadership) and is an enemy of fame and publicity.
His sadness remains for a long time, his ambition is far reaching. He very often remains silent, dignified, ever remembering (the Lord), exercising patience, grateful, sad due to his thoughts, happy with his poverty, easy in his nature, kindhearted, of strong loyalty, of very little trouble, not a liar or insulting, ‘When laughing, he does not burst. When angry he does not rush. His laughing is smiles, his question is to learn, his review is to understand, his knowledge is plentiful, his forbearance is great and his blessing is a great deal.
He is not stingy, he does not hasten, irritate or acts as an extremist, is not unjust in his judgement, or unfair due to his knowledge. His soul is more solid than a rock, his labour is sweeter than honey. He is not greedy, intolerant, violent, conceited, pretending or exaggerating. He is graceful in disputed matters, of honourable visitation, a man of justice when angry, and a friend when asked.
He is not adventurous, or insulting and intimidating. His love is pure, he is of solid promise, of fulfilling commitment, affectionate, a keeper of good relations, and forbearing, calm, of very little that is extraneous, happy with Allah and opposes his own desires. He is not rough toward his inferiors and does not indulge in what is not his business.
He is a supporter of religion, a defender of believers; a stronghold for Muslims, and admiration does not affect him negatively, greed does not hurt his heart, playfulness does not change his judgement and ignorant ones cannot find the limits of his knowledge. ‘His words are many and he is a determined scholar.
He is not abusive or furious. He reaches out without harshness, is generous not a spendthrift, is not deceitful or treacherous, is not a faultfinder or unjust to a human being. He is a friend of the creatures, effortful on Earth, assistant of the weak and a helper of the helpless. He does not violate what is hidden or uncover secrets; his trials are a great deal but his complaints are very little.
He remembers the good that he had seen, covers up the evil that he may observe, hides the defects, safeguards the unseen, corrects slips and forgives mistakes. He does not walk away from an advice that he can give, and he does not give up reforming an unjust instance. He is trustworthy, steadfast, pious, clean, purified and consenting. He accepts excuses, speaks of someone with grace and he is good and expects good from people.
He accuses his soul of defects, loves for the sake of Allah;with understanding and knowledge, cuts-off relations for the sake of Allah with firmness and determination. Happiness does not trespass upon him and intense happiness does not make him excited. He is a reminder for the scholar and a teacher for the ignorant. He is not expected to cause a calamity. He is not feared for causing a tragedy, every effort to him is more sincere than his own and every soul is more correct than his own.
He knows his defects. He is busy with his own sadness. He does not rely on anyone except his Lord. He feels a stranger, lonely, dispossessed and sad. He loves for the sake of Allah, strives for the sake of Allah to follow His Happiness. He does not revenge by himself for his ownself. He does not make friends to make his Lord angry.
He sits with the poor, is a friend of the truthful ones, a supporter of the people of truth and an assistant for those near to him. He is like a father for the orphans, like a guardian for the widows, the first hope for the destitute, expected to remove every resentful matter and to relieve every difficulty.
He is light and happy, is not frowning or sly, and is strong, controlling of anger, smiling, sharp-sighted and greatly cautious. He does not ignore, and if ignored, he is forbearing. He is not stingy and if stinginess, is used against him he exercises patience. He understands, thus he is conscious, is content, independent and is self-sufficient. His abstinent is higher than his lust, his love is higher than his jealousy and his forgiveness is higher than his hate.
He does not speak without correctness and does not dress unless it is economical. He walks humbly, is submissive before his Lord in obedience and is happy with Him in all conditions. His intention is pure and sincere. His deeds are free of fraud and deceit. His observations are good lessons, his silence is thoughtful and his words are wisdom. He is advising, charitable and brotherly.
He gives good advice in public and in private. He neither abandons his brother nor backbites and nor plots against him. He does not regret what he has missed, and does not become sad for whatever befalls him. He does not hope for what is not lawful. He does not fail in hardships and does not perpetrate in comfort.
He mixes forbearance with knowledge and reason with patience. He is not lazy but is always active, of very short longing and of very few slips. (Good) is expected through him, his heart is fearful, he always speaks of his Lord, his soul is content, his ignorance is negative, his affairs are easy, he is sad for his sins, his lust is dead, his anger is controlled and his moral behaviors are lucent.
His neighbours live safely with him, he has suppressed his pride, he is content with whatever is determined for him, his patience is strong, his affair is well established and his remembering (the Lord) is a great deal. He meets with people to learn and remains silent for safety, he asks questions to understand, and he trades to earn. He does not remain silent for good to be subjected to injustice, and does not speak to be used in doing injustice to others.
His soul is tired of him and people are comfortable with him. He has tired his soul for the gains of the next life and has provided comfort to others by means of his soul. If rebellion is committed against him he exercises patience until Allah finds support for him. His distancing when distancing is needed comes in overlooking and in graceful disregard, and his closeness when closeness is needed comes as kindness and blessings. His distancing is not out of boastfulness or greatness and his closeness is not a plot or deceit. It is because he follows the footsteps of those before him, the people of goodness. Thus, he is the leader for those after him.’
‘The narrator has said that Hammam breathed very deeply and fell down unconscious.
Imam Ali (pbuh) said: ‘By Allah I was afraid of its effect for him. This is how effective advice works on people deserving such advice.
Someone said:
‘Why does it not apply to you, O Commander of the believers?’
The Imam (pbuh)said: ‘For everything there is an appointed time that is not surpassed and a cause that does not fail. Wait, and do not transgress. It was a blow that Satan made to flow through your tongue’.
What happened with Fatima bint Muhammad??? Why is her grave not known??? Who was present at the funeral of Muhammad and his daughter?
Tufail Khalo abubakr told umar to go and rush his home
Tufail Khalo imam the closest person to mohmad paece be upon him
Waht happened was Fatima told Ali to wash her then bury here in a secret place. The grave is only known to Ali, Hassan and Hussain and Allah.
The word "fight" maybe much offensive word for some folks. It is due to translation of Arabic to English..The best word which can be used is " Combat".. If They combat you combat...If they cease you cease...For sure God is merciful....
There are many verses in Bible that people may seem offensive...But it is all due to translation....
In the story of Noah (p.b.u.h) where God finished a whole nation... And it really doesn't matter which religion you follow unless you pray to one God almighty and at the end of the day we all going to same God...For God doesn't see you face ,color or race but faith in him alone.United we stand.Divided we fall....
Nothing but truth, man. You're spot on. Muslims are one group of descendants of the tribes of God that God allowed to repopulate the Earth after the flood. Every group of people around the world that survived the flood all worshipped the Sun God, as the Sun is the closest physical incarnation of divine power to us. No matter what religion or spiritual belief anyone follows, we must all recognize with utmost respect and honor that there is *one* true divine, incomprehensible force that drives the universe. Materialistic/Atheistic scientists could not disprove 'God' in the past and they cannot disprove 'God' now. The way I view 'God' is non-religious, but rather personal and unique. I view God as simply the supreme being that all of reality derives from and is a part of. I view God as everything, an eternal intelligence, an infinite force of endless possibility. Not 'he' or 'she', but rather 'God' singularly on it's own.