Agnipath Batch for UPSC 2024 - 3rd July 👉unacademy.com/store/batch/agnipath-course-for-upsc-cse-2024-prelims-and-mains-pathfinder-3rd-july/C8ARJ1XF Agnipath Comprehensive with Geography Optional Starting from - 3rd July 2023 👉unacademy.com/store/batch/agnipath-geography-optional-pathfinder-batch-227/PS3B07MJ Agnipath 2.0 Pathfinder Batch For UPSC CSE - 16th June 👉 unacademy.com/store/batch/agnipath-20-pathfinder-batch-for-upsc-cse/2GX0UI3P Samudra Manthan Weekly Test for UPSC CSE 👉unacademy.com/scholarship/weeklytest1 CSAT PathFinder Batch 👉unacademy.com/store/batch/csat-pathfinder-batch/RV2C72Y2 PathFinder - Bodh Hindi Course for UPSC CSE 2024 Prelims and Mains: 👉unacademy.com/store/batch/pathfinder-hindi-batch-for-upsc-cse-2024/T2Q0IIEH Geography Optional By Amit Kumar 👉Link - unacademy.com/store/batch/geography-optional-by-amit-kumar-272/P8A2J78Y PathFinder Prelims Test Series 👉unacademy.com/store/test-series/-/Z0MUWNN1 PathFinder Mains Test Series 👉unacademy.com/store/test-series/-/7IQVZJO4
As per my view, Subhash ji, ahead of that time. His dream was to make India, true socialist and democratic. In some point it portraits today's China(in the view of industrialisation). But Gandhi's view was too Utopian style of India that never ever happen. Note: Constructive criticisms are welcome.
If Subhas Chandra Bose ji was our first PM then the country leaders would be disciplined and moreover there had not being any corruption in our country and our country had lead to a great future but thanks to gandhi ji who kept our country under leadership of corruption
Andaman and Nicobar Islands was the first part of India to get Freedom under Subhash Chandra Bose..he invaded these islands and the First flag of Independent India was unfurled by Subhash Chandra Bose at Portblair 🇮🇳
Honestly, to me; ideas of Bose looked a lot realistic and practical while the ideas of Gandhiji were more utopian..also, in the realest sense there isn't much diff in their ideologies and vision The fyt between Gandhi followers and Bose followers is just like the fyt b/w Virat and Rohit fans...In the truest sense, both fyt and play for the country
But by the example of African countries we see that countries who obtain for militant Nationalism very likely to trap in civil war or authoritarian rule So in my view non violence is best method for independence movement
Kohli is more interested in black lives matter than Hindu lives in Bangladesh and Pakistan , wildness rather than nationalism , privilege rather than efforts and hard work , supporting other nations and Khalistan than India .Just like Gandhi and Congress.
Aaj agar SC Bose ka policy hota and Bose hote to aaj India china jaisa militrant hota and the economically India bhut strong hota..... US ke challenge me hota....... really I want like Bose type leader 🙏🙏🙏🙏
@@9859660581 socialism adopt korar bohut karon ase jetia kono eta systemr lagatkoi besi exploitation barhi jai tetia automatically xadhoran lok tar biporit systemr prati besi akorxita hoi... Aru xeii xomyat besibhag crony-capitailism solisil aru tak counter koriboloi communism,socialism adir jonmo hoisil.....
I like the point when BOSE ji said there should be authoritarian society in the initial stage and when the country established upto the mark, we should welcome the democracy after that, and best pasrt is that he proved by contribute in INC, in every higher positions. Thank you mahipal sir for the great lecture.
Covid is every where in INDIA, so I will suggest you not to worry to visit Our BENGAL, rather If YOU wear a mask, maintain COVID protocol and vaccinated properly then you might not be affected. So Come to Bengal, Feel Bengal, Live Bengal we will be overhelmed by Felicitating you. Thank you. Jai Hind.
Yes mother india has given birth of many galaxies Bose is one of them but in respect of culture Bose was a Bengali and I too.. Whatever We are indians. We believe in fraternity among us and thats make our India Great.
Netajis approach was more like what Meji restoration for Japan. If everything would had worked as in case of Japan, india would had developed long back.
Pride of Odisha??? Pride of India... But if you say that then he was from Kolkata...he was a Bengali...he was born in Cuttack cz his father lived there for his work (lawyer)
Apka lecture ata late hai per ata bhut gajab ka hai ,,apke lecture me bhut kuch nya Hota hai aur sabse hat kr hota hai......thanks for this knowledge...
@@Stoner2562 of course but economic policy and totalitarian measures in initial years of independence is very much common. They are good friends and young enthusiastic socialist leader.
Sir such aj ye lecture dekh k acha lga... Gandhiji or neta ji k beech m koi clash ni tha bulke ideological differences the bs Baki Gandhiji, netaji, jawaharlal nehru, Maulana Abul kalam Azad or sardar patel or remain freedom fighter real patriotic the hai or rhege.. Aj jo hmra desh hai bas inlogo ki bhut sacrifice hai.. desh kabhi ni bhuk skta aplogo ko
For me Subhash Chandra Bose is a real hero , he was a true nationalist freedom fighter and not a British stooge like Ghandhi , our independence was actually delayed atleast by two decades due to Nehru and Gandhi....
It is not so easy to understand Subhash...He never came forward, thinking of the welfare of the people of the country..He knew very well that if he came forward, all the conspiracies would be exposed... There would have been riots in the country....So he spent his last life in disappearance...But I believe the truth will come out one day, because the truth is like the sun....It is not too late for that day to come... I also want everyone to know the truth and give him the respect he deserves ... but let it all be done in peace....Otherwise his norm will be violated...He was a worshiper of complete peace...joi bharot mayer joi...bonde Matorom...
I wish Authoritarianism in inrial independence phase would have been better. Then democracy, if necessary. Bose would have been great. He was visionary and futurist. If I were present at that time, I would have supported Bose, diplomatically, armed and secret service.
Implications of this crisis can be felt even today when we see economic power china adhead of us , we truely lost a gem in choice for gold. Bose was boss , a true , smart and futurestic leader. Jai hind🇮🇳🇮🇳
Sir... Kindly make a video on INA's History too. Because folks of india are thoroughly aware about gandhi's movements. Youth of this country should know about who was Kana Kanta!! What he did within the span of 1941-45. And what happened to him after 1945(surely, no plane crash had occurred, saying on the basis of evidences). Not just youth, but the elders ones should be aware about this man who dared british raj. Jai hind, Jai Subash. 🇮🇳🙏
apart from this i really like the way he displayed various colours in each slide while delineating. colours were perfectly associated with each topic. hats off sir.
Not exactly. Too many anglo-saxons were killed in the world war. They recalled their remaining surviving population to homeland. The colonies were beyond their capability to control, so they left. They didn't actually wanted to, the situation forced them.
@@ajaykumarsingh702 well, to some extent, yes but that was not the main reason.. It was INA trails at the red fort which triggered the mutiny among the defense Forces of British India..
@@hreeshikeshdutta9756 They destroyed Axis powers in the world war. They weren't scared of INA at all to be honest. They would had won easily like they did in 1857. INA didn't had any industrial complex behind them to support a massive long term war.
@@ajaykumarsingh702 bro you are not getting the point.. Just read what former British Pm Clement Atlee had said to the then Governor of West Bengal PB Chakraborthy about Indian independence when he visited India in 1956..
if Sardar Patel ya Subhash Chandra Bose became the PM of india...India's fate would have been better.. these two leaders can be called ' the best PM India never had'
If you will look how india is transitioning from ghandhi philosophy to Bose philosophy Eg: 1.We want to manufacture weapon. 2. We wanted to export more. 3.indian are fed-up of defensive military approach. 4. Against social inequality. 5. Indian wanted fast industrialization. 6. We also wanted state of the art machine manufacturing product just like china. 7. Most of indian think if we would have invested more in science and technology, india would be much better. 8. In 1992 we have ultimately ditch gandhian economic policy(Licence Raj) and introduced LPG reform and opened our economy. 9. Who are going to do advocacy for varna systems in today's india. 10. Our society transformed form being man centric to equality of gender. Now everyone knows when women work it increase the overall family income as well as it give much dignified life to women.
Mk gandhi and Nehru ke bajaha se desh ko tukro me batt diya gaya,, humara freedom fighter netaji or sardar bollav bhai patel after independence me hote pm or president hote ,,,to aj humare desh no 1 hota,,,economally or strongally,,we always remember sardar ji or Bose ji,,proud to be indian,,thank you both you bcs giving our life for freedom
Gujarat public service commission will held class 1 and 2 preliminary exam on 19 the December We hearty request to make video on Vijaynagar samrajya Bhakti and sufi movement Governor general and viceroy Please sir I will verry beneficial to us
So All the girls here your minds must be clear after hearing distinctions in ideologies of gandhi and bose on women....u must be knowing atleast whom not to make ur inspiration....
@@Vishal-lo5px not left. Subhash Chandra Bose never endorsed left nor did Sardar Patel. It's called benovalent dictatorship. It's not against the nation and it's culture and history unlike the communism. It is for progress and development. Communism is only for destruction. Look at the condition of communist countries and Kerala. Pathetic.
@@mathematician849 bakwaas karne ka time chala gaya. Emotional hone ka time chala gaya. Aaj facts ka time hai. Congress dynasty is worse than any dictatorship, that's a fact.
🙌What was right wing ideology 1930s is now became left wing and what was left wing became right today. Everyone would agree that what subhash chandra bose said for full control of the nation is freedom not having Dominion state. But, after understanding the comparison between bose and the gandhi , both were aiming for the same thing. Now after 74 years we want Ram rajya where villages develop own goods "Aatma nirbhar" but this idea after independence would be helpful but here i disagree with gandhi that central power should be there.
It's sad people in comment section praise bose....If india was made based on bose ideology now India will be like pakistan with authoritariani regime... I don't like gandhian ideology personally but i too not in favour of bose ideology.......But gandhia mass movement is unquestionable and no one can ever unite India on this level...
You have all forgotten who the man is who never thought of looking back on his life for the country, Exactly one hundred years ago today, despite taking fourth place in the civil service exam, he didn't think twice about quitting his job. That man and his Azad Hind Bahini snatched independence on October 21, 1943 and formed the Azad Hind government at Shaheed and Swaraj. This freedom was the freedom we fought and snatched away..The freedom we got in 1947 is the freedom we got from begging. All our dear leaders begged for independence from the British so that it would not be difficult for them to get their throne in India piece by piece.Netaji was declared dead despite being alive to serve their own interests. Who was supposed to be the first Prime Minister? Who was supposed to be the first Prime Minister? Netaji remained out of the country behind the scenes, Till now wiki shows the date of his death : 18 th August, 1945.... which is completely wrong... original date of his death: 16th August of 1985... Only for the leaders of that prosperous opportunist Congress, Despite surviving until 1985 he remained dead officially to the public. I wrote this today because it is time for renaissance, From the time of that freedom we have been walking with the taste of freedom of submission, And when will we wake up? Many real truths have been deliberately hidden in the pages of history, We are growing up knowing some distorted truth in its place.. The present stands on the past history and the future stands on this present..And we've read the history of Congress-inspired history ... which is mostly distorted...The stage of our country is such that if one seeks history as a truth seeker, he gets lost ..Lal Bahadur Shastri was one of them ... so maybe he had to die suddenly....Then think about what is happening in the country ... Really distorted politics goes on... And when think of us, want to die in shame...Many of us do not know the day of our true independence... And we have forgotten who Netaji was, what he did and who his Azad Hind Bahini was...Are we really independent today?
Lal Bahadur Shastri was murdered by Russia, because at that time the nationalism was on the peak, which did not allow USSR ,look at Yuri Benzonov's video, how's communist Marxist ideological subversion work
Agnipath Batch for UPSC 2024 - 3rd July
👉unacademy.com/store/batch/agnipath-course-for-upsc-cse-2024-prelims-and-mains-pathfinder-3rd-july/C8ARJ1XF
Agnipath Comprehensive with Geography Optional Starting from - 3rd July 2023
👉unacademy.com/store/batch/agnipath-geography-optional-pathfinder-batch-227/PS3B07MJ
Agnipath 2.0 Pathfinder Batch For UPSC CSE - 16th June
👉 unacademy.com/store/batch/agnipath-20-pathfinder-batch-for-upsc-cse/2GX0UI3P
Samudra Manthan Weekly Test for UPSC CSE
👉unacademy.com/scholarship/weeklytest1
CSAT PathFinder Batch
👉unacademy.com/store/batch/csat-pathfinder-batch/RV2C72Y2
PathFinder - Bodh Hindi Course for UPSC CSE 2024 Prelims and Mains:
👉unacademy.com/store/batch/pathfinder-hindi-batch-for-upsc-cse-2024/T2Q0IIEH
Geography Optional By Amit Kumar
👉Link - unacademy.com/store/batch/geography-optional-by-amit-kumar-272/P8A2J78Y
PathFinder Prelims Test Series
👉unacademy.com/store/test-series/-/Z0MUWNN1
PathFinder Mains Test Series
👉unacademy.com/store/test-series/-/7IQVZJO4
As per my view, Subhash ji, ahead of that time. His dream was to make India, true socialist and democratic. In some point it portraits today's China(in the view of industrialisation).
But Gandhi's view was too Utopian style of India that never ever happen.
Note: Constructive criticisms are welcome.
👍👍👍
No criticism, can't agree more.
If Subhas Chandra Bose ji was our first PM then the country leaders would be disciplined and moreover there had not being any corruption in our country and our country had lead to a great future but thanks to gandhi ji who kept our country under leadership of corruption
Pk he kya??
All Indians should watch the film called "Gumnami"
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose ❤️
Andaman and Nicobar Islands was the first part of India to get Freedom under Subhash Chandra Bose..he invaded these islands and the First flag of Independent India was unfurled by Subhash Chandra Bose at Portblair 🇮🇳
All Indians should watch the film called "Gumnami"
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose ❤️
Honestly, to me;
ideas of Bose looked a lot realistic and practical while the ideas of Gandhiji were more utopian..also, in the realest sense there isn't much diff in their ideologies and vision
The fyt between Gandhi followers and Bose followers is just like the fyt b/w Virat and Rohit fans...In the truest sense, both fyt and play for the country
But by the example of African countries we see that countries who obtain for militant Nationalism very likely to trap in civil war or authoritarian rule
So in my view non violence is best method for independence movement
Virat and Rohit play for bcci and bcci is a private club
Kohli is more interested in black lives matter than Hindu lives in Bangladesh and Pakistan , wildness rather than nationalism , privilege rather than efforts and hard work , supporting other nations and Khalistan than India .Just like Gandhi and Congress.
Gandhi was not even a right winger. He had no knowledge of anything especially India and Sanatana Dharma. He was an Islamist. Father of Pakistan.
@@reconquistahinduism346 bhai history whatsapp University se padhte ho kya😁
Gandhiji is on Notes but Bose is in our Heart. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Wah kya bat kehdi❤️🇮🇳
nope they both belongs to our heart
U have, present pm of india
😂😂shut up bc
'Bose' baas name hi kafi h goosebumps ke liye.. Netaji ❤️
Aaj agar SC Bose ka policy hota and Bose hote to aaj India china jaisa militrant hota and the economically India bhut strong hota..... US ke challenge me hota....... really I want like Bose type leader 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Aur tumhari bhasa aur grammar ki itni buri halat nahi hoti.
But he was socialist
@@9859660581 woh samajhdar admi the samajh jaate konsa policy adopt kare....
@@googlekalita7228 jiye nohok but socialist sytem aram karone val nohoi Nehru prove korise so joto kunobai socialism follow kori blind devotee hobo khuje tenehole dekh sesb
@@9859660581 socialism adopt korar bohut karon ase jetia kono eta systemr lagatkoi besi exploitation barhi jai tetia automatically xadhoran lok tar biporit systemr prati besi akorxita hoi... Aru xeii xomyat besibhag crony-capitailism solisil aru tak counter koriboloi communism,socialism adir jonmo hoisil.....
I like the point when BOSE ji said there should be authoritarian society in the initial stage and when the country established upto the mark, we should welcome the democracy after that, and best pasrt is that he proved by contribute in INC, in every higher positions. Thank you mahipal sir for the great lecture.
Do you think authoritarian society will give its power back to its citizens? Lol
Boss is always Boss.
Greetings from West Bengal.
Is Bengal Is Safe For Travel ?
@@Dong_Zhongshu covid thore bad rahe hai abhi mat ayiye
@@joydip9044 okk
@@Dong_Zhongshu Mask to koi pehenta nahi...khud soch lo.
Covid is every where in INDIA, so I will suggest you not to worry to visit Our BENGAL, rather If YOU wear a mask, maintain COVID protocol and vaccinated properly then you might not be affected. So Come to Bengal, Feel Bengal, Live Bengal we will be overhelmed by Felicitating you. Thank you. Jai Hind.
Subhas Chandra Bose the living hero in our hearts.❤️ Proud to be a Bengali.
Indian*
Yes mother india has given birth of many galaxies Bose is one of them but in respect of culture Bose was a Bengali and I too.. Whatever We are indians. We believe in fraternity among us and thats make our India Great.
Indian bengali
Netajis approach was more like what Meji restoration for Japan. If everything would had worked as in case of Japan, india would had developed long back.
Also like kim jong un 😙
All Indians should watch the film called "Gumnami"
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose ❤️
That's why I love Subhas Chandra Bose
Sir we need the whole biography of Netaji..
Needs to cover Netaji's untold stories too.
@@yashmishra1024 yupp 100%
Yes bro
See anuj dhar whole analysis of bose untold story
Can everyone understand Thora Bengali?...then I can share links of some vedios... factual vedio...then tell me...
Even mahipal sir know about theories of whatsApp university students, good that you clarified..
You are truly a teacher to be known to all..
I kinda agree with most of the points by bose.
Now i understand why Bose was si brutally sidelined by compromisers
Pride of Odisha 🙏
The modern day think tank architecture 🙏
Pride of Odisha??? Pride of India...
But if you say that then he was from Kolkata...he was a Bengali...he was born in Cuttack cz his father lived there for his work (lawyer)
Pride of oddisha , pride of bengal, pride of Maharashtra , pride of akhand hindustan.
"'সুভাষ কে বোঝা শক্ত""🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
বাঙালির দের জন্যে সুভাষ কোনো নাম নয় সুভাষ এক অনুভূতি।।
বাঙালি😊
All Indians should watch the film called "Gumnami"
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose ❤️
কিন্তু নেতাজীর প্রতিষ্ঠিত ফরওয়ার্ড ব্লক থাকতেও ভোট দাও দিদি ফেকু পাপ্পু দের৷ 😀😀
ইনকিলাব জিন্দাবাদ 💪
Bro not only bangali but also for everyone Indian🇮🇳🇮🇳
Sir Subash chandra Bosa is the real king of politics, we love him a lot
Apka lecture ata late hai per ata bhut gajab ka hai ,,apke lecture me bhut kuch nya Hota hai aur sabse hat kr hota hai......thanks for this knowledge...
Ye bakwas teacher hai ...
@@UPSCCSE-xk5hn toh maat dekho🙄 aise bol rahei ho jaise khudko saab paata hei
Bose was Right that's why they wiped him out of the place???????
I am not an aspirant but like ur lectures. Hated history at school, wish had teachers like u. This is better than watching a movie any day.
Gandhi was all about Ram Rajya somebody should have told him that "This is Kalyug & people here are morally and ethically corrupt"
Humans has been always corrupted.
Buddha faced the same thing.
He prevailed because he had the true enlightenment.
@@ajaykumarsingh702 budha didn't prevailed till he was backed by ashoka a strong leader
Enlightened people need strong backing
Bose ❤️
One of my fav figure
Technically Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose was First Prime minister of free INDIA.🇮🇳
Mohammad Barkatullah bhopali was first prime minister of India
Man Mahipal Singh Rathore is just too good, very well explained, just exceptional!
🤘🤘
Bose was great visionary leader... Kash wo apna 1st PM hota...😢😢😢😢
For us he is still our 1st PM.. 💜
Nehru and Bose are both socialist and they are carbon copy
Kaash ab v vo hote
@@thejuggernaut6174Bose's ideology regarding India's freedom was very much different from lehru
@@Stoner2562 of course but economic policy and totalitarian measures in initial years of independence is very much common. They are good friends and young enthusiastic socialist leader.
Unfortunately Bose is not among me..but his policy is always inspire me...... 🙏🙏
Jay Hind from Bengal.🙏🏻🙏🏻
We Bengali we proud for Netaji ❤️ he is the prime minister ❤️🇮🇳
Bengali kyo kah rahe ho sara desh ko proud h unpar
Pura Bharat ko garv hai " Neta Je Bose " pr.
शत शत नमन।
Im also bengali but Netaji is for whole INDIA..thik hay wo Bengali community se belong karte hay doesnt mean copyright sirf bengali ko hay...জয় হিন্দ
@@ManishKumar-wb7vj yes
Subhash chander bose .A true legend.
Sir such aj ye lecture dekh k acha lga...
Gandhiji or neta ji k beech m koi clash ni tha bulke ideological differences the bs
Baki
Gandhiji, netaji, jawaharlal nehru, Maulana Abul kalam Azad or sardar patel or remain freedom fighter real patriotic the hai or rhege..
Aj jo hmra desh hai bas inlogo ki bhut sacrifice hai.. desh kabhi ni bhuk skta aplogo ko
इतना ज्यादा भिन्नता के बाद भी दोनो विचारधारा को एक कैसे कहा जा सकता है🤔
For me Subhash Chandra Bose is a real hero , he was a true nationalist freedom fighter and not a British stooge like Ghandhi , our independence was actually delayed atleast by two decades due to Nehru and Gandhi....
Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose Zindabad 🇮🇳❤️,, Freedom not given that is Taken ❤️❤️🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
26.15
Bose the true futurist of my motherland.
TRUE INDIAN WILL ALWAYS REMEMBER YOU.
What Bengal thinks world thinks is completely suitable on hero like Netaji Subash Chandra Bose.
It is not so easy to understand Subhash...He never came forward, thinking of the welfare of the people of the country..He knew very well that if he came forward, all the conspiracies would be exposed...
There would have been riots in the country....So he spent his last life in disappearance...But I believe the truth will come out one day, because the truth is like the sun....It is not too late for that day to come...
I also want everyone to know the truth and give him the respect he deserves ... but let it all be done in peace....Otherwise his norm will be violated...He was a worshiper of complete peace...joi bharot mayer joi...bonde Matorom...
Point to be noted during old age thinking capacity deteriorate so ,leader should not be on power after 60
Lol 60 is young. Try maybe 75.
I wish Authoritarianism in inrial independence phase would have been better.
Then democracy, if necessary.
Bose would have been great.
He was visionary and futurist.
If I were present at that time, I would have supported Bose, diplomatically, armed and secret service.
Childhood: Gandhi
Adulthood: Subhash Charda Bose
From childhood only subhash chandra bose
both
you are forcefully fed Gandhiji even if you dont want it from childhood
2day India was out of form in wc but Mahilpal sir is in full form..Back 2 back lectures 😄
Great lecture Sir !
2:46 Sir, By mistake you told 1929 but it was 1928 when Calcutta session presided by Motilal Nehru.
I think he wanted to say, Jawahar lal Nehru instead of Motilal Nehru... Since the 1929 session was presided by JL Nehru
How strange CR DAS was present in 1929 snap 🤔as per my knowledge he was died in 1925🤔
Implications of this crisis can be felt even today when we see economic power china adhead of us , we truely lost a gem in choice for gold.
Bose was boss , a true , smart and futurestic leader.
Jai hind🇮🇳🇮🇳
Thanks for your lecture about सुभाष चंद्र बोस
Sir... Kindly make a video on INA's History too. Because folks of india are thoroughly aware about gandhi's movements. Youth of this country should know about who was Kana Kanta!! What he did within the span of 1941-45. And what happened to him after 1945(surely, no plane crash had occurred, saying on the basis of evidences). Not just youth, but the elders ones should be aware about this man who dared british raj. Jai hind, Jai Subash. 🇮🇳🙏
Thanks alot for this series. I will likely to pay one time amount for such great details. I'm not UPSC aspirant. Just a curious mind.
Both policies were admirable we should use both the policies for the development of country and country men.
Very good lesson, i loved this one 👌👍
apart from this i really like the way he displayed various colours in each slide while delineating. colours were perfectly associated with each topic. hats off sir.
NETAJI SUBHAS CHANDRA BOSE is real HERO of INDIA.
NOT Gandhi or Nehru or Patel.
Bose ka ideology sahi tha, education and industrialisation aur lagbhag sabhi point pr sahi h bose
I was thinking sir may bring another video of this series...
Thank you..❤
It's notable that even understanding Gandhis thought a crap still people try to justify Gandhi because Indians are compelled to respect Gandhi... 🙄
Krishna in Gita never says the concept of rigid varna system. There was allowance of inter-movability.
Manusmriti effed up Indian society.
Bro Covering up tatti written in Gita
Very significant topic , thanks to Mahipal Sir 🙏
Britishers left India because Indian soldiers in British Indian Army started revolting against them..
Not exactly.
Too many anglo-saxons were killed in the world war. They recalled their remaining surviving population to homeland.
The colonies were beyond their capability to control, so they left.
They didn't actually wanted to, the situation forced them.
@@ajaykumarsingh702 well, to some extent, yes but that was not the main reason.. It was INA trails at the red fort which triggered the mutiny among the defense Forces of British India..
@@hreeshikeshdutta9756
They destroyed Axis powers in the world war.
They weren't scared of INA at all to be honest.
They would had won easily like they did in 1857.
INA didn't had any industrial complex behind them to support a massive long term war.
@@ajaykumarsingh702 bro you are not getting the point.. Just read what former British Pm Clement Atlee had said to the then Governor of West Bengal PB Chakraborthy about Indian independence when he visited India in 1956..
@@hreeshikeshdutta9756 The same interview where he insists that Gandhi's role independence was minimal, right?
Bose was main architecturer of Indian freedom struggle, where Gandhiji's contribution was almost zero.
Correct
Shut up you anti natnl. Thora Gyan le lo. Gandhi stayed years in jail for India. You should be in hell
Almost 0?? Whatsapp forward waale ho kya? Tere puri nasal mila Kar bhi unke jitna nahi Kar sakte.
Awesome Lecture Of A Great Personality. ❤️❤️
Thanks sir for your support
if Sardar Patel ya Subhash Chandra Bose became the PM of india...India's fate would have been better..
these two leaders can be called ' the best PM India never had'
Thanks for being unbiased by calling him Gandhi..
If you will look how india is transitioning from ghandhi philosophy to Bose philosophy
Eg:
1.We want to manufacture weapon.
2. We wanted to export more.
3.indian are fed-up of defensive military approach.
4. Against social inequality.
5. Indian wanted fast industrialization.
6. We also wanted state of the art machine manufacturing product just like china.
7. Most of indian think if we would have invested more in science and technology, india would be much better.
8. In 1992 we have ultimately ditch gandhian economic policy(Licence Raj) and introduced LPG reform and opened our economy.
9. Who are going to do advocacy for varna systems in today's india.
10. Our society transformed form being man centric to equality of gender. Now everyone knows when women work it increase the overall family income as well as it give much dignified life to women.
Brilliantly summarised 👌
Mk gandhi and Nehru ke bajaha se desh ko tukro me batt diya gaya,, humara freedom fighter netaji or sardar bollav bhai patel after independence me hote pm or president hote ,,,to aj humare desh no 1 hota,,,economally or strongally,,we always remember sardar ji or Bose ji,,proud to be indian,,thank you both you bcs giving our life for freedom
I think aapne pura lecture nhi suna... NEHRU and BOSE were on same page.. and PATEL & GANDHI was on same page...
Best history lectures ❤️ thank you so much sir
Thanks a lot Sir for this wonderful class. Lots of love and respect 🙏🙏
Bose had economically progressive ideas and Gandhi had regressive one...
I agree with both of them. They both are correct but it depends on the situation.
You are the best teacher for history Sir , Thank you for this series Sir .
Please make video on navy mutiny in 1946 and reason of indian freedom
this is a detailed video. learnt a lot. thank you. keep making videos like these.
Sir I am getting your knowledge at free, I am very grateful to you , but can i ask you a favor, please polity ki bhi vedios bna dijiya. 😅
Long live Mahatma Gandhi
Long live Netaji Subhash
You are the best teacher , Thank you so much Sir .
Dil se dhanyawad sir...
Sir I appreciate your incredible effort plz provide lecture on ancient history also
Thaku so much sir for providing this informative series 👏
Thank you so much sir for this 👍👍👍
You are doing great work for students like us ...hats off
Gujarat public service commission will held class 1 and 2 preliminary exam on 19 the December
We hearty request to make video on
Vijaynagar samrajya
Bhakti and sufi movement
Governor general and viceroy
Please sir
I will verry beneficial to us
Bahaut Bahaut dhanyawad sir.
Neta g is the my role model
So All the girls here your minds must be clear after hearing distinctions in ideologies of gandhi and bose on women....u must be knowing atleast whom not to make ur inspiration....
I agree with most of Netaji's idea except millitary rule.
Military rule was far better than Gandhi and Congress dictatorship, tyranny and dynasty.
@@reconquistahinduism346 left ❤️
@@reconquistahinduism346 kuch bhi
Jaara akkal bhi istmal karo
@@Vishal-lo5px not left. Subhash Chandra Bose never endorsed left nor did Sardar Patel. It's called benovalent dictatorship. It's not against the nation and it's culture and history unlike the communism. It is for progress and development. Communism is only for destruction. Look at the condition of communist countries and Kerala. Pathetic.
@@mathematician849 bakwaas karne ka time chala gaya. Emotional hone ka time chala gaya. Aaj facts ka time hai. Congress dynasty is worse than any dictatorship, that's a fact.
Thanks sir...he is foundation father of our nation...
Bose was a Legend. The most influential and popular leader India have got.
Thank you so much sir ...🟣💜
This lecture is the best of all...
Gandhi ji is nowhere infront of Bose..he is an iron strong man with realistic and practical ideology.a soldier,a lion.
🙌What was right wing ideology 1930s is now became left wing and what was left wing became right today.
Everyone would agree that what subhash chandra bose said for full control of the nation is freedom not having Dominion state.
But, after understanding the comparison between bose and the gandhi , both were aiming for the same thing. Now after 74 years we want Ram rajya where villages develop own goods "Aatma nirbhar" but this idea after independence would be helpful but here i disagree with gandhi that central power should be there.
Agree with everything but didn't understand why you said left ideology of 1930s is today's right and vice versa.
Thankssss sir
Isi ka intezar tha
Ultimately Bose defeated Gandhi in 1939 now we can imagine his popularity
It's sad people in comment section praise bose....If india was made based on bose ideology now India will be like pakistan with authoritariani regime... I don't like gandhian ideology personally but i too not in favour of bose ideology.......But gandhia mass movement is unquestionable and no one can ever unite India on this level...
Awesome charts, so beautiful, thx for making, lots of respect for you man.
2:40 Can someone clarify ?
1929 - we can see C R Das here 🤔( But he died in june 1925)
Yes he died even I don’t understand it and 1929 president of congress was j l Nehru
Awesome research ... really a nice video..
Thank you sir jii..👌👌
Thank you sir
👑👑🇮🇳🇮🇳
Korbo lorbo jitbo ra 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
You have all forgotten who the man is who never thought of looking back on his life for the country, Exactly one hundred years ago today, despite taking fourth place in the civil service exam, he didn't think twice about quitting his job. That man and his Azad Hind Bahini snatched independence on October 21, 1943 and formed the Azad Hind government at Shaheed and Swaraj. This freedom was the freedom we fought and snatched away..The freedom we got in 1947 is the freedom we got from begging.
All our dear leaders begged for independence from the British so that it would not be difficult for them to get their throne in India piece by piece.Netaji was declared dead despite being alive to serve their own interests. Who was supposed to be the first Prime Minister?
Who was supposed to be the first Prime Minister? Netaji remained out of the country behind the scenes,
Till now wiki shows the date of his death : 18 th August, 1945.... which is completely wrong... original date of his death: 16th August of 1985...
Only for the leaders of that prosperous opportunist Congress,
Despite surviving until 1985 he remained dead officially to the public. I wrote this today because it is time for renaissance, From the time of that freedom we have been walking with the taste of freedom of submission, And when will we wake up? Many real truths have been deliberately hidden in the pages of history, We are growing up knowing some distorted truth in its place..
The present stands on the past history and the future stands on this present..And we've read the history of Congress-inspired history ... which is mostly distorted...The stage of our country is such that if one seeks history as a truth seeker, he gets lost ..Lal Bahadur Shastri was one of them ... so maybe he had to die suddenly....Then think about what is happening in the country ...
Really distorted politics goes on...
And when think of us, want to die in shame...Many of us do not know the day of our true independence...
And we have forgotten who Netaji was, what he did and who his Azad Hind Bahini was...Are we really independent today?
❤
Lal Bahadur Shastri was murdered by Russia, because at that time the nationalism was on the peak, which did not allow USSR ,look at Yuri Benzonov's video, how's communist Marxist ideological subversion work
💔💔💔💔
Give me blood I will give u freedom 🔥🔥