Thank you so much if you watch this through guys! This is the first Scorsese film I've reviewed and it proved to be a big personal challenge & my longest review to date! That's what the movies are about! I can't wait to hear everyones thoughts on how this important story was portrayed, and as always, here are some resources to support the ongoing strike. The WGA may have reached a deal, but SAG-AFTRA still needs our support⬇ SAG-AFTRA info resource: t.co/EE6qPXDi3T Donations: sagaftra.foundation/emergencyfinancialassistance/ entertainmentcommunity.org/am-i-eligible-help secure2.convio.net/afa/site/Donation2?df_id=8117&8117.donation=form1&mfc_pref=T
Thanks for bringing a bit of nuances in the avalanche of dithyrambic reviews. This is definitively an excellent and necessary movie but I also feel that the point of view (indeed, diverted from the first idea of placing it from the eyes of Tom White but ending up focusing a lot on the DiCaprio character) removes a bit of the light that needs to be placed on the Osage character and though Lily Gladstone gives a stellar performance, a greater place for her would have been even more appreciated. Nothing to annihilate the appreciation of the film but just a few spices of disappointement over this well-crafted dish of a movie.
Saw this in IMAX! Didn't feel like 3.5 hrs tbh when we got at the end I honestly thought we were like 2/3rds of the way then it ended pretty abruptly but the cameo at the end was cool.
I’m glad they didn’t go the mystery route. I feel like it’s more respectful that way so people aren’t so focused on the investigation and reveals of it all and just focus on the story and lay it out like it is from the jump. But that’s just me.
I finally watched this movie today. I got through without peeing too lol. I think it's the best film I've seen this year. I agree with your criticisms that the Osage should have got more screen time.
@@SydneyVolpe Watching a morning or matinee viewing is probably recommended for most people because of the long runtime. I hope this film turns a profit. It might get an extended run if it does well at the Oscars. Hopefully, the strike would have ended by then.
Great review. I'm in a similar boat as you (liked it, but did not love every part of it). I have seen it twice now and I do think for those not familiar with the source material (myself included), a rewatch greatly helps. I would have liked to see more Gladstone/DiCaprio and their relationship rather than the De Niro/DiCaprio relationship that dominates much of the film. The dinner scene where Mollie and Ernest are just sitting there at the table during the thunderstorm without much dialogue or anything happening is an example of a brilliant little nugget that I wish there was more of. So while I do think the 3.5 hour runtime is earned, I didn't always love what the film devoted that time to. Overall, I personally enjoyed Oppenheimer more. The frenetic rhythm and cuts through time in that film were consistent throughout the runtime. Conversely, KOTFM's emotional stillness juxtaposed with the speed of the police procedural final act felt at times more in conflict with each other than synergistic. These observations are tough to nail down precisely on first viewing(s) though as you said, and will be interesting to see how both films age.
Totally with you on this one Sydney, great review! Your video quality stays winning as always. Loved the disclaimer at the beginning too. Congrats on GMA btw!!! So freaking cool
Per usual, excellent review! I really enjoyed this film overall, though I didn’t love it. Impeccably made in so many ways, but it isn’t as rewatchable compared to other films from Marty.
Got around to watching KOTFM yesterday and had alot of mixed feelings about it, but honestly your entire review are exactly my thoughts. Especially the part about how an Osage filmmaker can tell the story better but doesn’t the opportunity (unfortunately) so Scorsese did the best he could for a story deserves to be told. So perfectly worded and great review syd !
..... It IS Mr. Scorsese's story to tell. He immersed himself in the subject matter and cowrote the script and directed it. He's a master. Can't wait to see this!! Good review too. Bravo.
It's easy to have the "in an ideal world" conversation but realistically, what Osage filmmaker has the proven experience and talent to handle a 200-million-dollar production? Scorsese made the wise choice to use actual Osage people in the film, and while it's lovely, it's not hard to tell who the non-professional actors are. While not ideal, I think Scorsese being chosen as the director is ultimately the best outcome since 1. he is probably the greatest living director and 2. the reach of the film is now probably 1000x that of what it would have been if it were given to a first-time filmmaker and a cast of unknowns. Reservation Dogs was the first mainstream wide-release Native American film project so I can definitely see a future where we see growing talents but for this film, I think Scorsese was the right choice.
Totally agree on the run time thing, and to an extent I understand the reservations regarding that for some people but it’s like…just go watch the movie and don’t worry about it lol. I thought this was a beautiful film, just got out of my showing and it’s resonating in me like crazy, esp not knowing the story beforehand. Lily was incredible, particularly in those scenes of loss. Also def go get yourself checked out after throwin back a dasani
@SydneyVolpe I just think it's neat that he's willing to learn from ppl who have obviously studied him. I just listened to your pod. It seems asteroid City has climbed in your estimation. Welcome to the asteroid City hype wagon. There's plenty of room lol
Pushover Sling Blade meets unyielding Mona Lisa. Oppie might have had higher highs but I found this to be a more consistently fascinating watch. It could've been longer with an intermission.
I have yet to hear a complaint about the run time. Everyone critic seems to think it does not drag on --surely some of that has to do with the remarkable direction/ editing partnership with Scorsese and Schoonmaker. I am currently reading the book and can't wait for the film in the theatre. Sydney will your second viewing be at home or in the theatre?
I finally watched this film recently and its a mid kinda watch for me, that raised a few questions (mainly to do with why the Osage were in that situation with europeans controlling their money, why the Osage women felt for these men and how they could see the KKK as part of the solution to name a few). The runtime wasn't a problem for me at all however. The third act seemed iffy at first as it felt like it was focusing too much on humanising caprios character but I felt it balances out the feelings of the couple against each other well in the end. Now to check out Napoleon
What is the least important part of the movie so I can get up for a minute and go to the concessions and move around a bit? Really though, it's funny how Grace Randolph didn't like this movie or Oppenheimer which are both directed by famous male directors.
Big fan of your reviews Sydney. I've been following your reviews since the time of 'Pathaan.' I was just wondering, have you seen any Tamil movies or any Non-Bollywood films from India, other than 'RRR'?"
Great review! I felt conflicted about the adaptation too, but who are we kidding it’s a classic Scorsese story. He loves that thwarted ambition storyline. Do you think they should’ve done it more like the book? If they did it that way Mollie would probably have to be the main character.
Movie was good, but make no mistake with the runtime. Don’t be like me, I saw it the day it came out at 10:30 at night, was nearly 3 am when I left the theater.
I am probably part of the 1 percent that dont like the movie but I feel like it was a bit of a slog, maybe I just don't like Scorsese's 3 hour epic dramas. It feels way too similar to the irishman imo, where it feels way too much like a mob movie (with deniro and dicaprios interactions and how they go about their business). Although the story itself is interesting, the Scorsese style epic hurts it, the way they shoot and setup the murders feels very bland and bleak (although that might be what its going for). The 2nd half definitely felt more engrossing than the first.
“REVOLUTIONARY ROAD,” with Kate Winslet and DiCaprio is another great film as well. Leo is amazing in it, better than Kate I think. It’s based on the book of the same name. It’s very VERY good. Don’t miss it
This is an excellent film, timeless in both its filmmaking techniques and the haunting story it narrates. In my opinion, 'Oppenheimer' is the superior film. I sincerely hope Lily Gladstone wins an Oscar. I concur wholeheartedly that Ernest knew exactly what he was doing. He didn't initiate his pursuit of Molly until Hale suggested it, despite having driven her around earlier. Regarding the scene you referenced, where Molly 'comes to terms' but isn't shown on screen, are you referring to the moment near the end, in the small room, where Molly rises from her chair and walks away after Ernest deceives her about disclosing everything related to her injections? Also, I'm curious about your interpretation of the scene where Ernest pours the remaining "medicine" from the vial (presumably the lethal dose) into his drink, finishes it, and then lies down at the foot of Molly's bed, falling asleep as she lies there dying. It's a profoundly disturbing betrayal, further underscored by the complicity of the entire white community. Even Hale used the derogatory term 'Blanket' when referring to Rita. The conclusion is symbolic, representing how this story, like many others, was concealed and denied as if it never occurred.
Since the entertainment industry gives out awards based on what will soothe their guilt complex, I will predict with 92% certainty that this film will win Best Picture.
When I finished Grann's book a couple of weeks ago I was shocked that Scorsese undertook this bit of Osage history. I'm really looking forward to watching it but I know that my bar for doing the story justice is very high. My biggest worry is that the Osage won't feel bigger than the things that happened to them. Indigenous representation is really hard to come by in mainstream cinema so I'm keeping my fingers crossed that this is a good one... but it is already very disappointing that Ernest is the main character. I'm getting tired of evil and morally conflicted white men in the forefront.
i think the "slog" was intentionally done to impart some sense of the killings, how many and how long the went on for. I agree about focal on Ernest and his screen time but if the films draws more viewers the better.
Thank you so much if you watch this through guys! This is the first Scorsese film I've reviewed and it proved to be a big personal challenge & my longest review to date! That's what the movies are about! I can't wait to hear everyones thoughts on how this important story was portrayed, and as always, here are some resources to support the ongoing strike. The WGA may have reached a deal, but SAG-AFTRA still needs our support⬇
SAG-AFTRA info resource:
t.co/EE6qPXDi3T
Donations:
sagaftra.foundation/emergencyfinancialassistance/
entertainmentcommunity.org/am-i-eligible-help
secure2.convio.net/afa/site/Donation2?df_id=8117&8117.donation=form1&mfc_pref=T
You drink Dasani?! They put all kinds of chemicals in it just the same way they secretly put poison in her insulin injections
This is going to be my ‘Return to Cinema’ movie after getting surgery last month. The long runtime is thrilling to me.
Wow!! Wishing you a continued recovery, pretty epic way to return to the theater.
You will enjoy it!
Thanks for bringing a bit of nuances in the avalanche of dithyrambic reviews. This is definitively an excellent and necessary movie but I also feel that the point of view (indeed, diverted from the first idea of placing it from the eyes of Tom White but ending up focusing a lot on the DiCaprio character) removes a bit of the light that needs to be placed on the Osage character and though Lily Gladstone gives a stellar performance, a greater place for her would have been even more appreciated. Nothing to annihilate the appreciation of the film but just a few spices of disappointement over this well-crafted dish of a movie.
Thanks for watching, and excellently stated!!
Saw this in IMAX! Didn't feel like 3.5 hrs tbh when we got at the end I honestly thought we were like 2/3rds of the way then it ended pretty abruptly but the cameo at the end was cool.
Yeah i had gotten the cameo spoiled for me after it premiered at Cannes but it’s been so long i forgot and freaked out haha
Same
The fact that we are blessed enough to get a new Scorsese in 2023 is amazing. Very excited for this
Just watched it yesterday. Watched it with my mama, she said that she's so happy to see DiCaprio again in the big screen since she saw Titanic in 1997
Excellent review, Sydney - was waiting for this upload! Seeing the movie Friday night and currently working on finishing the book. Can’t wait.
Woohoo hope you enjoy it!! Thanks so much for watching!
I’m glad they didn’t go the mystery route. I feel like it’s more respectful that way so people aren’t so focused on the investigation and reveals of it all and just focus on the story and lay it out like it is from the jump. But that’s just me.
You should also see “THIS BOY’S LIFE,” with DiCaprio and De Niro.
It’s their first film together, and it’s excellent
I finally watched this movie today. I got through without peeing too lol. I think it's the best film I've seen this year. I agree with your criticisms that the Osage should have got more screen time.
So glad you liked it!! Trying to get my fam to see it but i do think that runtime is doing a number on its box office lol
@@SydneyVolpe Watching a morning or matinee viewing is probably recommended for most people because of the long runtime.
I hope this film turns a profit. It might get an extended run if it does well at the Oscars. Hopefully, the strike would have ended by then.
I finished the book a couple days ago. Seeing the film tonight.
Ooo I’d love to hear your thoughts then
@@SydneyVolpe I much preferred the film over the book. It’s focus on the relationships helped me to connect to the story a lot more.
Great review. I'm in a similar boat as you (liked it, but did not love every part of it). I have seen it twice now and I do think for those not familiar with the source material (myself included), a rewatch greatly helps. I would have liked to see more Gladstone/DiCaprio and their relationship rather than the De Niro/DiCaprio relationship that dominates much of the film. The dinner scene where Mollie and Ernest are just sitting there at the table during the thunderstorm without much dialogue or anything happening is an example of a brilliant little nugget that I wish there was more of. So while I do think the 3.5 hour runtime is earned, I didn't always love what the film devoted that time to.
Overall, I personally enjoyed Oppenheimer more. The frenetic rhythm and cuts through time in that film were consistent throughout the runtime. Conversely, KOTFM's emotional stillness juxtaposed with the speed of the police procedural final act felt at times more in conflict with each other than synergistic. These observations are tough to nail down precisely on first viewing(s) though as you said, and will be interesting to see how both films age.
Purposely didn't research it until afterwards, and now I wanna buy the book. Great review as always!
I agree, the last line was absolutely killer. Great review Syd!
This movie was Epic. No complaints. And better than Oppenheimer.
definitely
Yeah I agree, better than Oppenheimer
Based
naaaaah
THANK YOU 😊😊😊😊
Totally with you on this one Sydney, great review! Your video quality stays winning as always. Loved the disclaimer at the beginning too.
Congrats on GMA btw!!! So freaking cool
Haha thanks Danny!! Loved your Letterboxd review.
Haha thanks Danny!! Loved your Letterboxd review.
Per usual, excellent review! I really enjoyed this film overall, though I didn’t love it. Impeccably made in so many ways, but it isn’t as rewatchable compared to other films from Marty.
Got around to watching KOTFM yesterday and had alot of mixed feelings about it, but honestly your entire review are exactly my thoughts. Especially the part about how an Osage filmmaker can tell the story better but doesn’t the opportunity (unfortunately) so Scorsese did the best he could for a story deserves to be told. So perfectly worded and great review syd !
Aw thanks Rid!! Yep I totally agree🩷🩷
I love your reviews. Keep it up.
Means the world thank you!!
..... It IS Mr. Scorsese's story to tell. He immersed himself in the subject matter and cowrote the script and directed it. He's a master. Can't wait to see this!! Good review too. Bravo.
I think it’s his story to tell because he made Leo the center. if he was honed in on just Mollie, I think it would be harder to defend
Seeing it tomorrow and again Friday! I also have a copy of the book but I’m waiting to read after
Hope you love it!!!
I"ll come back and watch your spoiler review. I liked the trailer for this. I'll probably watch it today.
It's easy to have the "in an ideal world" conversation but realistically, what Osage filmmaker has the proven experience and talent to handle a 200-million-dollar production? Scorsese made the wise choice to use actual Osage people in the film, and while it's lovely, it's not hard to tell who the non-professional actors are. While not ideal, I think Scorsese being chosen as the director is ultimately the best outcome since 1. he is probably the greatest living director and 2. the reach of the film is now probably 1000x that of what it would have been if it were given to a first-time filmmaker and a cast of unknowns.
Reservation Dogs was the first mainstream wide-release Native American film project so I can definitely see a future where we see growing talents but for this film, I think Scorsese was the right choice.
Great review Sydney, look forward to seeing this now! New to the channel and now a fan!
Thanks so much for watching, happy to have you here!🙌🏼
Totally agree on the run time thing, and to an extent I understand the reservations regarding that for some people but it’s like…just go watch the movie and don’t worry about it lol. I thought this was a beautiful film, just got out of my showing and it’s resonating in me like crazy, esp not knowing the story beforehand. Lily was incredible, particularly in those scenes of loss. Also def go get yourself checked out after throwin back a dasani
I’m dead lol, and yeah completely agree. Sad that it won’t perform as well as it could at the box office because people know they can just wait
Those who see this in a theater should be warned it's near 3/1-2 hours without an intermission.
Every time there's an atrocity in history i always ask "whos ancestors are these?" doing all these horrible things.
Seeing it Saturday morning, can't wait!
Have so much fun!!
Thoughts on Scorsese saying his editing (w Thelma ofc) for this film was influenced by Beau Is Afraid?
I think that’s cool! I’m not the biggest Aster fan but his films are undeniably idiosyncratic and well made
@SydneyVolpe I just think it's neat that he's willing to learn from ppl who have obviously studied him.
I just listened to your pod. It seems asteroid City has climbed in your estimation. Welcome to the asteroid City hype wagon. There's plenty of room lol
Pushover Sling Blade meets unyielding Mona Lisa. Oppie might have had higher highs but I found this to be a more consistently fascinating watch. It could've been longer with an intermission.
I have yet to hear a complaint about the run time. Everyone critic seems to think it does not drag on --surely some of that has to do with the remarkable direction/ editing partnership with Scorsese and Schoonmaker. I am currently reading the book and can't wait for the film in the theatre. Sydney will your second viewing be at home or in the theatre?
It didn't feel long like people say, or trying to say. The pace was fine for the story to be told.
Have you ever thought about doing a blu ray/4K/Criterion collection video?
Yes! People have been asking for years haha. I want to do either that or a q&a for 10k subs!
@@SydneyVolpeawesome, Good luck to you!
I finally watched this film recently and its a mid kinda watch for me, that raised a few questions (mainly to do with why the Osage were in that situation with europeans controlling their money, why the Osage women felt for these men and how they could see the KKK as part of the solution to name a few). The runtime wasn't a problem for me at all however. The third act seemed iffy at first as it felt like it was focusing too much on humanising caprios character but I felt it balances out the feelings of the couple against each other well in the end. Now to check out Napoleon
What is the least important part of the movie so I can get up for a minute and go to the concessions and move around a bit? Really though, it's funny how Grace Randolph didn't like this movie or Oppenheimer which are both directed by famous male directors.
listened to the audiobook a whopping 5 times 😇 it was well worth it
I want to see this movie so bad, but I can't sit inside the theater for 3 1/2 hours, sorry. Great review.
I hope my theater plays it, if not, gotta wait for streaming. Would HATE to miss Scorsese on the big screen.
Big fan of your reviews Sydney. I've been following your reviews since the time of 'Pathaan.' I was just wondering, have you seen any Tamil movies or any Non-Bollywood films from India, other than 'RRR'?"
Great review! I felt conflicted about the adaptation too, but who are we kidding it’s a classic Scorsese story. He loves that thwarted ambition storyline.
Do you think they should’ve done it more like the book? If they did it that way Mollie would probably have to be the main character.
Can't wait to watch it tomorrow.
I think you’ll love it!!
Lily killed it so hard, she’s so beautiful
Seriously glowing. She’s a superstar
Movie was good, but make no mistake with the runtime. Don’t be like me, I saw it the day it came out at 10:30 at night, was nearly 3 am when I left the theater.
I am probably part of the 1 percent that dont like the movie but I feel like it was a bit of a slog, maybe I just don't like Scorsese's 3 hour epic dramas. It feels way too similar to the irishman imo, where it feels way too much like a mob movie (with deniro and dicaprios interactions and how they go about their business). Although the story itself is interesting, the Scorsese style epic hurts it, the way they shoot and setup the murders feels very bland and bleak (although that might be what its going for). The 2nd half definitely felt more engrossing than the first.
I loved Grann's remarkable book. I love auteur Scorcese. I can't wait to see it.
Thank you for your knowledgeable and honest review!
Awesome review! I subbed!
Wow thank you, welcome!!🙌🏼
Fr cant wait for this
Amazing Review Sydney ❤️
Thanks Jose!💚
@@SydneyVolpeyou’re welcome Sydney !❤️
I'm so hyped to finally see this! Very good review!
Thanks for watching!! Hope you love it
“REVOLUTIONARY ROAD,” with Kate Winslet and DiCaprio is another great film as well. Leo is amazing in it, better than Kate I think. It’s based on the book of the same name.
It’s very VERY good. Don’t miss it
I have the exact same posters in my room lol
Cannot wait! Gonna be epic
Hope you enjoy!!
I can’t wait! Scorsese is my 2nd favorite director of all time! I know this will be a masterpiece!
So exciting!! Who is your #1?
@@SydneyVolpe Quentin Tarantino for not just the quality of his work but the passion he has for cinema. He and Scorsese both LOVE cinema.
bookmarking this for now as I'm seeing the film tomorrow. But Commenting just to help with the algorithm :)
Thanks Joe!! Hope you enjoy it :)
This is an excellent film, timeless in both its filmmaking techniques and the haunting story it narrates. In my opinion, 'Oppenheimer' is the superior film. I sincerely hope Lily Gladstone wins an Oscar. I concur wholeheartedly that Ernest knew exactly what he was doing. He didn't initiate his pursuit of Molly until Hale suggested it, despite having driven her around earlier.
Regarding the scene you referenced, where Molly 'comes to terms' but isn't shown on screen, are you referring to the moment near the end, in the small room, where Molly rises from her chair and walks away after Ernest deceives her about disclosing everything related to her injections?
Also, I'm curious about your interpretation of the scene where Ernest pours the remaining "medicine" from the vial (presumably the lethal dose) into his drink, finishes it, and then lies down at the foot of Molly's bed, falling asleep as she lies there dying. It's a profoundly disturbing betrayal, further underscored by the complicity of the entire white community. Even Hale used the derogatory term 'Blanket' when referring to Rita.
The conclusion is symbolic, representing how this story, like many others, was concealed and denied as if it never occurred.
I didn’t feel the run time🤷♂️
Hii Sydney... How r u... See within a minute I replied but still waiting for my favorite movie review
Wait what is your favorite movie review?!
😂😂😂 woow... Told u many times
@@deogiriyadav8399 ohhh sardar udham😂 sorry your username is not easily recognizable haha. I will definitely try and watch it soon for you
@@SydneyVolpe Eagerly waiting for that
What's this Priscilla: The Killer? Sounds interesting!
Now THAT sounds like a masterpiece
I am watching this tonight.
Have fun bleak!!
@@SydneyVolpe thank you 🙏🏼 will return to this review afterwards
Great review. This is cinema. ❤
my fav critic 👊
💙💙
Also kotfm >> Oppenheimer if you're taking public polling.
I have kotfm at #2 for the year rn and Oppenheimer at 4, so it's not like a huge gap
Saw it yesterday, glad I can have an opinion now
Also hot take: I didn’t love Leo in the movie
Fair tbh that’s how i felt about RDJ in Oppy
Scorsese ranking when??
just saw it, it was good, not great. oppenheimer is better imo
This is better than oppenheimer. The last part of oppenheimer seemed tacked on. Killers' last act was prob the best part of the movie.
I wanted it to be longer tbh
Does leo get in any fight scenes or kill anyone? I like when he gets in on some action lol
definitely
Sydney I miss u on my fyp
Lol on TikTok?
@@SydneyVolpe yea
Since the entertainment industry gives out awards based on what will soothe their guilt complex, I will predict with 92% certainty that this film will win Best Picture.
FAIL
I am a Scorcese fan so I'll watch it. Oppenheimer was the most boring overrated movie I've ever seen. And I love Christopher Nolan films.
Agree with you there
agreed
When I finished Grann's book a couple of weeks ago I was shocked that Scorsese undertook this bit of Osage history. I'm really looking forward to watching it but I know that my bar for doing the story justice is very high. My biggest worry is that the Osage won't feel bigger than the things that happened to them. Indigenous representation is really hard to come by in mainstream cinema so I'm keeping my fingers crossed that this is a good one... but it is already very disappointing that Ernest is the main character. I'm getting tired of evil and morally conflicted white men in the forefront.
i think the "slog" was intentionally done to impart some sense of the killings, how many and how long the went on for. I agree about focal on Ernest and his screen time but if the films draws more viewers the better.