Dr Ayesha Siddiqa ji is a brilliant military analyst and a great political scientist. Admire the way she was able to connect the dots by bringing correlation with similar situations in the region. I liked her underlying message that civilian issues are better solved by civilians (police + politicians). Militaries have only 2 actors, friends and enemies; *Baloch and KP will not find solution as long as military thinks Punjab as their friends and rest of the country as enemies. *
No offence to lady Ayesha but her analysis is clearly one sided and against Asim Munir?? I think she is aiming to be included in the list of IK affectees?? Asim Munir in fact is trying to clean the mess made by not just one general but several and over the past decade or so! Ans BTW, PTI is in power for the past 13 years and almost a full term in Punjab and Islamabad so what positive change they could bring. Thoughts??? People who consider themselves as intellects, must not be influenced by populism rather they should talk more about the root causes and present realities and facts! It’s not just the quality of generals who have gone down rather the quality in analysis, intelligence, intellect, journalism etc , everything has gone down including very respectable lady Ayesha! Thanks
Madam Ayesha failed to spell biggest achievement of General Munir. He successfully tackled fierce civilian challenge posed by Imran Khan in pre and post election periods. When he took over from General Bajawa , he looked so vulnerable, gheraoed by Imran Khan, Faiz Hamid , Retired guys including Bajawa ! No military general has faced such a toughest challenge. He has guaranteed the military grip over Pakistan for next 25 years !
I must say very intelligent and insightful comment I am sorry that even though I try to listen to Ayesha Sahiba carefully, she seems to lack real understanding and substance, bookish knowledge okay but otherwise sound bites only
The only success is obtaining IMF Loans. The 2 year Rule of Asim Munir has been disastrous for all the Institutions of the State. He will have to change his policies or then either Resign or be removed for the country to progress.
Agreed madam...... I personally feel that pak army has more control on Pakistan than ever without imposing martial law. Ye bus aisay he hy........ Jinho ne 1947 se fauj ko Pakistan ka malik banaya Hua hy, vohe in a elaaj kary ge. Hum awam k bus ki baat nahe hy.😢
She is prejudice about Pak army since long hr entire analysis is based on hear saying and hr internal biases and grudges she is so called self created defence anaylist
Aayesha ji, I understand ur point abt talking to Balooch’s, but should we even expect Army Generals to bring solutions that requires highly skilled political & diplomatic maneuvers. Army’s training & culture builds use of force as their default response. In such a situation only an exceptional General could go beyond it, but by definition they will be few & far between.
PTI mein sirf IK he agitation ki call de sakta hy....... People knows Gundapur bcoz of PTI....... Gundapur is joking, trying 2 mask and hide his escape 4m Islamabad😅 Face saving...... But he has done a good job, so he would remain CM.
With respect, generalship ki quality issue nahe hy......... they have just become 2 powerful, arrogant & shameless. BUT They know their proxy role in global and regional politics. This give them confidence that their time will go on.
Even according to state bank that pakistan's economy is getting better now , alhumdullillah, don't know y Ayesha saddiqa is backing imran khan who's only a sports man n absolutely not a statesman....
ڈاکٹر صاحبہ دانشور رھی ھونگی۔۔۔اب تو پی ٹی آٸی کی محبت میں مری جا رھی ھیں۔۔۔یہ بھی بتا دیتی کہ جنرل عاصم کے آفس میں آنے سے پہلے ھی عمران نے انکو اپنا دشمن ڈیکلیٸر کر لیا تھا۔۔
@@kishwerchaudary-n4g Agreed agar hafiz hain tu ja ke imam masjid ban jain per army chief bannay ke liye jo intellect aur qualifications chahiye hoti hain yeh hafiz sahab us mayar pe pora nahin utartey
Raza Sahib Please get another analyst who has different experience and knowledge of the army, Ayesha Sahiba seems too biased and conflicted I am not an Army apologist, never was but it has become an easy choice to score points without careful evaluation of the ground realities For your own program get another analyst
Pakistan me koi bhi leader agar Saaf tareekey se election jeetkar aane ki koshis karega to haalat yahi honaa hai. First time imran dhandli se aya isliye fojiyo me allow kar dia. Is baar sach me jeeta isliye uthakar jail me faink diyaa gayaa.
آپ سب تجربہ کاروں کا رویہ پاکستان میں سکون کے لئے ہونا چاہیے مگر آپکی اور آپکی دوست خاتون اسکے برعکس بات کرتی ہیں عمران پہلے بھی کچھ نہیں کرسکے سوائے دوستوں کو نوازہ اور ٹائگر فوج بنوائ لڑائی جھگڑے کے قدم ۔سیاستدان کی ضرورت ہے عمران خان کو سیاست کی کوئی خبر نہیں؟ فوج کیا کرے ملک خطرہ میں ہے دنیاکی نکلیئر پر آنکھ ہے
Imran khan ki total aukaat rehmat Ullah col liaqat aur dam darood tha. Ye uska ka spill over hai sirf. People have been carried away only. They don't think rationale or pragmatic. Total following is either cult or crush or result of negative campaign against pppp and pmln due to charter of democracy/ 18th ammendment. This is total reality of Imran khan popularity. He should not be given an unconditional certificate of being the popular please.
She is the most overrated so called expert analyst. She is neither, just an anti army loud mouth and her utterances are completely baseless and a figment of her one sided mind...The more you bring her here the more peope will stop coming here
This duo (A&R) seems so frustrated on the issue of their incarnated messiah, that they even resort to lunacy of claiming that the people of Pakistan is looking for a leader who can deliver for them. That is why they want him, the one presently incarnated, in power. Albeit his tenure as PM was the longest in the history, they so pretend, it didn’t occur at all, or they think he was on a probation/training for more than 3 years as PM. What happened in that period is now history, but it is not forgotten. Not to mention the price of wheat, a staple food, that went up from Re 45.- to Re 150.- per Kg. The country recorded the highest financial debts. The corruption was so rampant and phenomenal that even the cabinet record shows the corruption of £160 million. That is merely a trickle, if one considers the enormous costs that country was made to pay in all other fields. And yet they want to see him in power again. This is called insanity. They remind us of the colonial origin of Pakistan Army, but both of them are now working for the colonial champions of the world. This is called an irony. If this is the credence of their presentation, they do think they can judge the quality of the performance of generals and of bureaucracy. This is called narcissism.
Totally agree with ayesha siddiqa post musharaf quality of generals nechey se nechey hi gai hai aur yeh lout tu bilkul hi worst hai ajeeb pathar ke zamane ka banda lagta hai yeh aur humare jaise mulk mein jahan pehle se hi itni extremism hai us mein tu kisi mullah ko kisi top post pe hona hi nahin chahiye aik institution jis ka head hi extremist aur hard core islamist ho woh institution apne aap ko modernize kaise kar sakta hai kaise waqt ke sath chal sakta hai aur is bandey ke plans kam se kam 10 saal tak rehne ke hain tu is mein tu yeh humare mulk ko 18th century mein le jai ga aur is ka intellectual level bhi itna low hai yeh kaise world powers ke sath deal kar sakta hai kaise mulk ke barey mein sahi faislay le sakta hai mujhay tu ab pakistan ka future bilkul hi dark nazar araha hai Allah reham kare is mulk pe bohat ziyadti ki hai nawaz sharif ne aik incompetent bandey ko army cheif bana ke us waqt ke generals ki list mein mere khayal se azhar abbas best option thay army chief ki post ke liye kafi well educated aur polished general lagtey they woh agar is waqt woh is post pe hotey tu shayed mulk ke halaat aaj ke halaat se kaafi behter hotey per nawaz ne competence ke bajay apne sath loyality dekhi loyal banda tu mill gaya usay per adarey aur mulk ka bera gharak ho gaya
Just as one was grappling with the dismal and often beyond disappointing journalistic standards both print and in electronic media in Pakistan, just as one was recovering from dog and pony show of some very established and purportedly respectable journalistic names one realizes with horror that they are not just compromised but complete sell outs and would be ready to spin the yarn any which way so long as their RUclips related money streams are guaranteed. But the cohort Ayesha and some others belong to they make it their sworn business to somehow say something nasty about the establishment even if that has nothing to do with the price of eggs that day … they thrive in the reflection of their criticism of the Pakistani establishment especially when they bolt off to cooler foreign climes does their criticism reach a very high crescendo primarily for self-preservation and for their existence as part of the liberal corp who wish to be seen in a certain light for their captive audience. This in no way means one is papering over the establishment’s excesses and their undue dabble in politics in Pakistan. But ask Ayesha and her ilk the if she had breakfast in the morning, she’ll respond to it by making it about the army or whoever is the army chief, just an oldest trick in the book to keep that specially able audience alive and well fed with this fare to seem different and to look critical. She just now compared todays establishment with the one Zia spearheaded, and please don’t trot out that oft repeated line that “this is also a tacit latent martial law “ and contrasting PPP with PTI in explaining how they are similar especially if the entire premise of the argument is flawed and incommensurate with the subject at hand…. Nobody in the world could do such a perfunctory and mindless analyses and also get away with it, only in Pakistan and only on Pakistani platforms where people like her are celebrated instead of questioning her line of argument and challenging her with an alternate discourse… she just embarrassed herself and confirmed my doubts… god, i shiver to imagine she even teaches in some institution in London. Raza even you cannot raise enough gumption as the majordomo of the platform to question such people and fact check them… you are also a keen adherent of typical Lahori elite chatter houses expressing concerns over the plight of Bhatta mazdoors sipping coffee and partaking prawn salad…you also only have one cap in hand answer to and for such bias & lightweight point of view, which is jeeeee aap ne bilkul sahee kaha… tomorrow if there was no establishment, there would be no Pakistan, like it or not at least in todays geopolitical settings Pakistan finds itself in , and voila, no Ayeshas and no Sarmad’s and by extension no Raza Rumi either… phir kya banega iss platform ka, foreign teaching assignments ka, sinecures ka, aur iss poray establishment centric narrative ka? Yeh chooran kaisay bikkay ga… have you seen Indians commit such self-goals ? despite Narendra Modi’s abhorrable and praetorian policies but not a word from them, they somehow don’t have these ayesha’s and Sarmads and Nussi’s to endear themselves to a certain audience via Rumi’s platform… laggay raho munna bhai at times we learn the real hard way
Dr Ayesha Siddiqa ji is a brilliant military analyst and a great political scientist. Admire the way she was able to connect the dots by bringing correlation with similar situations in the region. I liked her underlying message that civilian issues are better solved by civilians (police + politicians).
Militaries have only 2 actors, friends and enemies; *Baloch and KP will not find solution as long as military thinks Punjab as their friends and rest of the country as enemies. *
Excellent analysis by madem Ayesha.
Imran 100% Anti Pakistani only, and 100% Anti Muslim only Imran not Muslim
Please tell ayesha sadiqa that asim munirs tenure started before may 9th. He was quite before that.
No offence to lady Ayesha but her analysis is clearly one sided and against Asim Munir?? I think she is aiming to be included in the list of IK affectees?? Asim Munir in fact is trying to clean the mess made by not just one general but several and over the past decade or so! Ans BTW, PTI is in power for the past 13 years and almost a full term in Punjab and Islamabad so what positive change they could bring. Thoughts??? People who consider themselves as intellects, must not be influenced by populism rather they should talk more about the root causes and present realities and facts! It’s not just the quality of generals who have gone down rather the quality in analysis, intelligence, intellect, journalism etc , everything has gone down including very respectable lady Ayesha! Thanks
Asim is doing all this by creating two supreme court and Increasing his tenure to 5 years like Pharaoh 😂
Bughze imrani ki bemar hr jaga warey huay hain, ghulqm ibne ghulam ibne ghulma 1857 sey warey huay hain
Madam Ayesha failed to spell biggest achievement of General Munir. He successfully tackled fierce civilian challenge posed by Imran Khan in pre and post election periods. When he took over from General Bajawa , he looked so vulnerable, gheraoed by Imran Khan, Faiz Hamid , Retired guys including Bajawa ! No military general has faced such a toughest challenge. He has guaranteed the military grip over Pakistan for next 25 years !
I must say very intelligent and insightful comment
I am sorry that even though I try to listen to Ayesha Sahiba carefully, she seems to lack real understanding and substance, bookish knowledge okay but otherwise sound bites only
The only success is obtaining IMF Loans. The 2 year Rule of Asim Munir has been disastrous for all the Institutions of the State. He will have to change his policies or then either Resign or be removed for the country to progress.
totally agree with you
یہ تو یوتھیوں کی بولی بول رہی ہے
نیازی کراؤڈ پلر ضرور ہے مگر لیڈر نہیں
لیڈر کے پاس ویژن ہوتا ہے
جادو ٹونے کے اثرات اس کے فیصلوں پر اثرانداز نہ ہوتے
This is not an extention but an original Tenure of the Army Chief as per the Law.
Agreed madam......
I personally feel that pak army has more control on Pakistan than ever without imposing martial law.
Ye bus aisay he hy........
Jinho ne 1947 se fauj ko Pakistan ka malik banaya Hua hy, vohe in a elaaj kary ge.
Hum awam k bus ki baat nahe hy.😢
Okara cantonment
Aisha siddiqua the great
Sorry to say that your expert looking clearly biased against coas. I think it is the effect of overseas pti.
She is prejudice about Pak army since long hr entire analysis is based on hear saying and hr internal biases and grudges she is so called self created defence anaylist
Please Raza Rumi sahib don't invite this lady again in ur talk shows please
YOU THANK AIDHA FOR HER TIME BUT MORE IMPORTANT IS HER STRATEGIC THOUGHTS WHICH SHIULD ALSO BE ACKNOEDGED.
Aayesha ji, I understand ur point abt talking to Balooch’s, but should we even expect Army Generals to bring solutions that requires highly skilled political & diplomatic maneuvers. Army’s training & culture builds use of force as their default response. In such a situation only an exceptional General could go beyond it, but by definition they will be few & far between.
PTI mein sirf IK he agitation ki call de sakta hy.......
People knows Gundapur bcoz of PTI.......
Gundapur is joking, trying 2 mask and hide his escape 4m Islamabad😅 Face saving......
But he has done a good job, so he would remain CM.
With respect, generalship ki quality issue nahe hy......... they have just become 2 powerful, arrogant & shameless.
BUT
They know their proxy role in global and regional politics. This give them confidence that their time will go on.
Even according to state bank that pakistan's economy is getting better now , alhumdullillah, don't know y Ayesha saddiqa is backing imran khan who's only a sports man n absolutely not a statesman....
ڈاکٹر صاحبہ دانشور رھی ھونگی۔۔۔اب تو پی ٹی آٸی
کی محبت میں مری جا رھی
ھیں۔۔۔یہ بھی بتا دیتی کہ جنرل عاصم کے آفس میں آنے
سے پہلے ھی عمران نے انکو
اپنا دشمن ڈیکلیٸر کر لیا تھا۔۔
General Asim Munir is Hafiz e Quran , he will lead the country
IS IT A "QUALIFICATION"? I DO NOT THINK SO.
Stupid
@@kishwerchaudary-n4g Agreed agar hafiz hain tu ja ke imam masjid ban jain per army chief bannay ke liye jo intellect aur qualifications chahiye hoti hain yeh hafiz sahab us mayar pe pora nahin utartey
Raza Sahib
Please get another analyst who has different experience and knowledge of the army, Ayesha Sahiba seems too biased and conflicted
I am not an Army apologist, never was but it has become an easy choice to score points without careful evaluation of the ground realities
For your own program get another analyst
Fauj k under IK ka supporter or voter basically pro Taliban mindset hy😮
Pakistan me koi bhi leader agar Saaf tareekey se election jeetkar aane ki koshis karega to haalat yahi honaa hai.
First time imran dhandli se aya isliye fojiyo me allow kar dia.
Is baar sach me jeeta isliye uthakar jail me faink diyaa gayaa.
HOW WAS "ZANI" IMRAN KHAN NIAZI WAS ELECTED FIRST TIME? EXPLAIN WITH PROOF
Ayesha is so boring……
آپ سب تجربہ کاروں کا رویہ پاکستان میں سکون کے لئے ہونا چاہیے مگر آپکی اور آپکی دوست خاتون اسکے برعکس بات کرتی ہیں عمران پہلے بھی کچھ نہیں کرسکے سوائے دوستوں کو نوازہ اور ٹائگر فوج بنوائ لڑائی جھگڑے کے قدم ۔سیاستدان کی ضرورت ہے عمران خان کو سیاست کی کوئی خبر نہیں؟ فوج کیا کرے ملک خطرہ میں ہے دنیاکی نکلیئر پر آنکھ ہے
Imran khan ki total aukaat rehmat Ullah col liaqat aur dam darood tha. Ye uska ka spill over hai sirf. People have been carried away only. They don't think rationale or pragmatic. Total following is either cult or crush or result of negative campaign against pppp and pmln due to charter of democracy/ 18th ammendment. This is total reality of Imran khan popularity. He should not be given an unconditional certificate of being the popular please.
Baloch leaders were against Bhutto so it was natural for them to side with Zia ul Haq.
This lady has lost memory. There are talks so many times. These are just criminals. Deal accordingly.
Mere kheal me quality aur general achi hwi he.ayse qom k lye aysa hi general hona chahiye
Why should people even PTI followers,come out on the Road? All the demands were to benefit only Imran Khan. What was there for people??
Excellent ❤
She is the most overrated so called expert analyst. She is neither, just an anti army loud mouth and her utterances are completely baseless and a figment of her one sided mind...The more you bring her here the more peope will stop coming here
Leder ship na 4sal laga ke dak lay kaya kaya ha pti na be to kuch ni kaya
یوتھیا وائرس کو کلٹ کو یہ عورت جذبہ کہہ رہی ھیں 😂😂
Sitting in America talking b shit it easy
Article-6
This duo (A&R) seems so frustrated on the issue of their incarnated messiah, that they even resort to lunacy of claiming that the people of Pakistan is looking for a leader who can deliver for them. That is why they want him, the one presently incarnated, in power. Albeit his tenure as PM was the longest in the history, they so pretend, it didn’t occur at all, or they think he was on a probation/training for more than 3 years as PM.
What happened in that period is now history, but it is not forgotten. Not to mention the price of wheat, a staple food, that went up from Re 45.- to Re 150.- per Kg. The country recorded the highest financial debts. The corruption was so rampant and phenomenal that even the cabinet record shows the corruption of £160 million. That is merely a trickle, if one considers the enormous costs that country was made to pay in all other fields. And yet they want to see him in power again. This is called insanity.
They remind us of the colonial origin of Pakistan Army, but both of them are now working for the colonial champions of the world. This is called an irony.
If this is the credence of their presentation, they do think they can judge the quality of the performance of generals and of bureaucracy. This is called narcissism.
Retired fauji diyariyan lagatay thay. Jo Asim Munir ne band ki. Retired fauji apni rotiyon kay ghusay main hain under the umbrella of Imran khan.
All pages were black.
Totally agree with ayesha siddiqa post musharaf quality of generals nechey se nechey hi gai hai aur yeh lout tu bilkul hi worst hai ajeeb pathar ke zamane ka banda lagta hai yeh aur humare jaise mulk mein jahan pehle se hi itni extremism hai us mein tu kisi mullah ko kisi top post pe hona hi nahin chahiye aik institution jis ka head hi extremist aur hard core islamist ho woh institution apne aap ko modernize kaise kar sakta hai kaise waqt ke sath chal sakta hai aur is bandey ke plans kam se kam 10 saal tak rehne ke hain tu is mein tu yeh humare mulk ko 18th century mein le jai ga aur is ka intellectual level bhi itna low hai yeh kaise world powers ke sath deal kar sakta hai kaise mulk ke barey mein sahi faislay le sakta hai mujhay tu ab pakistan ka future bilkul hi dark nazar araha hai Allah reham kare is mulk pe bohat ziyadti ki hai nawaz sharif ne aik incompetent bandey ko army cheif bana ke us waqt ke generals ki list mein mere khayal se azhar abbas best option thay army chief ki post ke liye kafi well educated aur polished general lagtey they woh agar is waqt woh is post pe hotey tu shayed mulk ke halaat aaj ke halaat se kaafi behter hotey per nawaz ne competence ke bajay apne sath loyality dekhi loyal banda tu mill gaya usay per adarey aur mulk ka bera gharak ho gaya
Simply corrupt......
بھدی یوتھنی
Sorry miss ayesha apka tajziya personal wishes pe base hai and bilkul bhi impressive nai
Imran kh bullshit &Dr is youthia
Youthiay
Just as one was grappling with the dismal and often beyond disappointing journalistic standards both print and in electronic media in Pakistan, just as one was recovering from dog and pony show of some very established and purportedly respectable journalistic names one realizes with horror that they are not just compromised but complete sell outs and would be ready to spin the yarn any which way so long as their RUclips related money streams are guaranteed.
But the cohort Ayesha and some others belong to they make it their sworn business to somehow say something nasty about the establishment even if that has nothing to do with the price of eggs that day … they thrive in the reflection of their criticism of the Pakistani establishment especially when they bolt off to cooler foreign climes does their criticism reach a very high crescendo primarily for self-preservation and for their existence as part of the liberal corp who wish to be seen in a certain light for their captive audience.
This in no way means one is papering over the establishment’s excesses and their undue dabble in politics in Pakistan. But ask Ayesha and her ilk the if she had breakfast in the morning, she’ll respond to it by making it about the army or whoever is the army chief, just an oldest trick in the book to keep that specially able audience alive and well fed with this fare to seem different and to look critical. She just now compared todays establishment with the one Zia spearheaded, and please don’t trot out that oft repeated line that “this is also a tacit latent martial law “ and contrasting PPP with PTI in explaining how they are similar especially if the entire premise of the argument is flawed and incommensurate with the subject at hand….
Nobody in the world could do such a perfunctory and mindless analyses and also get away with it, only in Pakistan and only on Pakistani platforms where people like her are celebrated instead of questioning her line of argument and challenging her with an alternate discourse… she just embarrassed herself and confirmed my doubts… god, i shiver to imagine she even teaches in some institution in London.
Raza even you cannot raise enough gumption as the majordomo of the platform to question such people and fact check them… you are also a keen adherent of typical Lahori elite chatter houses expressing concerns over the plight of Bhatta mazdoors sipping coffee and partaking prawn salad…you also only have one cap in hand answer to and for such bias & lightweight point of view, which is jeeeee aap ne bilkul sahee kaha… tomorrow if there was no establishment, there would be no Pakistan, like it or not at least in todays geopolitical settings Pakistan finds itself in , and voila, no Ayeshas and no Sarmad’s and by extension no Raza Rumi either… phir kya banega iss platform ka, foreign teaching assignments ka, sinecures ka, aur iss poray establishment centric narrative ka?
Yeh chooran kaisay bikkay ga… have you seen Indians commit such self-goals ? despite Narendra Modi’s abhorrable and praetorian policies but not a word from them, they somehow don’t have these ayesha’s and Sarmads and Nussi’s to endear themselves to a certain audience via Rumi’s platform… laggay raho munna bhai at times we learn the real hard way