I recently watched the interview of Eva Hart, a survivor. And she said the worst part of the night wasn’t the screaming or the crying. It was the silence that came afterward
The silence that followed was probably as bad as it was because of the fact that they could have tried to rescue a few people, but couldn't because the boat could have capsized from panicking people. Key word is could, fear and guilt likely contributed to the horror. Husbands, little kids.
@@gatsbygoodwood2575 And 3 of the 6 die within days. 3 made it to NY alive, and 1 was indeed "Rosa" the woman the movie took (NAME) inspiration from. Meaning, the Cameron film actually did get the minute detail of "only 1 woman survived the sinking and her name was Rose" right if you think about it.
I really was traumatisied. Now, years later Imo it's of course on of the best and most classic movies. I only watched it with 6 because my Grandma promised me that a ship will sink at the end. And I waited and waited...the night after the movie I woke up and screamed so long till my grandpa came to make the lights on. It was terryfing
@@cinematic.fandom1221 hm 🤔 😌 😔 the last moment in titanic movie 🎬 was so ,terrific and painfull 😢😢😭😭 and more poor and innocent peoples(Man's,woman's 😢 with their baby 👶 😢 in their lapse) lost their lives for cruelity of rich peoples 😢 😥😭😭
There was a survivor in a documentary on the Titanic disaster and he said that for many years he lived near a school with a large football stadium. Whenever a game was played and the crowd would cheer, he would think of the mass of people in the water after the ship sank and said that was what it sounded like. 1500 people drowning and freezing to death in the waters of the North Atlantic.
All those screaming in the cold water, slowly fading to just one person and to absolute silence. Scariest thing to experience after jumping off the sinking ship.
And many Titanic survivors could not listen to absolute silence for all their life after the tragedy, as it was reminding them of when everything went silent in the water
@@siphonophoresThat's how Eva Hart said her mother described it. She would talk about how horrible the screams of those in the water were, but then her mother would reply, "But do you remember the silence that followed?"
The mother and baby are Anna Danbom and her son Gilbert, the youngest Titanic victim, from Sweden. The father also perished, Ernst Danbom, born in America, who returned to his ancestral homeland of Sweden to marry, and then intended to take his bride and baby back to the USA with him, to start a fruit farm in California. They were travelling with the Andersson family, also from Sweden, who all died in the sinking as well.
looking at this now as an adult really makes this scene haunting, as a kid I never realised the context of this scene was that all those people in the water are dead. Now that I have a more understanding mind, I can feel the officer's shock and sadness, knowing that only now that he came back instead of sooner meant all these people have died
How did you not know they were dead? Maybe my parents were much more truthful about reality but damn I remember first watching this scene as a 7ish-year-old and just being horrified. The mother with the baby stuck with me.
It was a tough choice. He has a responsibility to the protection of the lifeboat, and the people in the water would have risked capsizing it in their scramble to get on, risking everyone on the boat a cold death. It was either wait and search for survivors or go forward after the Titanic went and everyone die in the scramble. But the choice to wait definitely haunted everyone that survived.
The facial expressions of guilt sadness and the respectful way they moved the bodies. And then when the officer sees the mother and baby, that saddened him the most. The shock and then. "We waited too long" followed by anger and the refusal to give up looking for survivors. Class acting, so haunting and so respecfully done.❤❤❤❤
1:06 this woman's death is probably the most realistic depiction of what happened to third class passengers. she's the same lady that asked the captain where she should go after all the boats had already been lowered, she had only just found her way out of steerage far too late because third class passengers were forgotten in the chaos. they weren't locked downstairs, the fact that the ship was sinking wasn't properly communicated to them and by the time they finally found their way to the upper deck they had never been given access to, most of the boats were gone and the ones that remained had over a thousand people competing for entry.
They were locked downstairs, some of those gates are STILL there to this day. However they were not locked down there to drown, it was anti-theft measure to prevent the poor immigrants from wandering into first class and disrupting their evening/endangering possessions. When the sinking began, a lot of those gates--which were already locked as it was night time--simply remained shut during the confusion. We may never know how many potential survivors became trapped in the confusion with Noone coming back for them. Reminds me of Triangle Shirtwaist--which coincidentally happened one year before this. Money was put before safety and the impoverished paid for it when disaster struck.
apparently the titanic had maze-like corridors too, so a lot of them probably got lost in confusing areas they had never seen before leading to them not finding their way out before it was too late.
@@ketaminepoptartsI’d believe that to. At the museum where they had quotes from crew members one said it took him a whole 2 weeks of learning to be able to get from one end of the ship to the other without getting lost
What’s even more chilling to think about is that no one actually had a flashlight that night. Once the lights had gone out on the ship and it had gone under, they were in total darkness. There was no moon that night. I can’t even imagine the terror those people experienced.
From a filmmaking perspective, this scene is fantastic. All of the dead frozen bodies, lack of music, dark lighting, and hopelessness in the rescuer’s voice makes this so grueling and gritty! You’re like 😳
💐💐RIP Commander Harold Godfrey Lowe RD, RNR (21 November 1882 - 12 May 1944) (aged 61) and all the victims of the RMS Titanic you will truly all be missed and my prayers go out to you. He helped scores of women and children into lifeboats and was the only Titanic officer to go back to rescue people. The archive includes a telescope given to him by a survivor who had it inscribed: “To Harold G. Lowe... The Real Hero of the Titanic.” 💐💐
I also think the crew of the Carpathia that raced to their rescue were heroes, even though they didn't succeed. Captain Rostron pulled out every stop to try to get there, even ordering the heating and hot water turned off in his ship so every single drop of steam could go to the propellers. Her top speed was supposed to be 15 kn but Rostron got the boilers up to nearly 20, arriving in two and a half hours instead of the anticipated four. They pushed their ship past it's physical limits in a heroic effort to rescue the Titanic passengers. Sadly it was in vain.
What’s sad is that the officers that came back reported that they did hear voices throughout the sea of dead people upon coming back but because of all the debris, darkness, and overall difficulty of steering the small boat they couldn’t get to them on time/couldn’t get to them at all.
@@noorrougelewis6704 They had flashlights but it was pitch black out there. There wasn't any moonlight at all unlike the movie. Pure darkness is one hell of a scary thing, but also one hell of a hard thing to shift through, specially with their very old and not so good flashlights back then.
@@supersnow17 No, they didn't have any flashlights. Cameron addded them in the movie for the audience's sake. They only had flares and they are useless in such a search because they blind you and the light doesn't carry far.
@@supersnow17 You mean the cold mirage, due to which Carpathia spotted them from further away than it would normally. But thats not what I meant. Of course you see the flare from far away as you would see any source of light. But I meant the situation when YOU hold the flare and want to see thanks to its light into the darkness. The light gets scattered very close to you and thus won't illuminate anything far from you on the contrary it would shine into your eyes.
I became a Dad 2 years ago. Until you're a parent you never truly understand the wrench on your heart seeing the mother and baby in the water. I've watched this movie countless times before becoming a Dad, and it never got me like it does now. Just an awful feeling
I became a dad 4 years ago, I 100% agree with you brother. I've seen this movie 100 times but this was the 1st time I even thought again about that gal holding her infant. Anything with kids getting hurt puts my guts in a knot and can't bare it. You can hear it in the officers voice
The sad truth is it’s most likely true to life it’s not one of them scenes where you think they just used artistic license,most likely the same with the Irish lady and her 2 young kids and how she’s getting them off to sleep inside the ship in there beds with there mum holding there hands,can’t imagine how those parents trying to save there kids must have felt knowing they would not be saved 😢
Saddest thing is that he did the right thing in waiting. If he didn’t wait for a majority of people to die, it’s possible they would have swamped the boat and overturned it.
It wouldn’t have mattered. The moment people went into the water, they would’ve had no energy to even get in the boats let alone swamp them. It’s understandable though, this was a big first in Maritime Disasters and alot of lessons learned
Pardon my French, Andrew, but that’s the coldest most hardened awful screwed up thing I have ever heard after the titanic sink there was an uproar by lower class people because the rich people were prioritize instead of everyone being a priority horrid, absolutely horrid Andrew that was not the right thing to do letting regular people like me die just because I’m not some elite billionaire or some movie star. As of now I can’t get over the idea of that little titan minivan size sub no one can find them right now it’s horrible. And yes they are billionaires in rich people it looks to me like there’s a curse here the titanic needs to rest in peace and be left alone.
The mother and baby are Anna Danbom and her son Gilbert, the youngest Titanic victim, from Sweden. The father also perished, Ernst Danbom, born in America, who returned to his ancestral homeland of Sweden to marry, and then intended to take his bride and baby back to the USA with him, to start a fruit farm in California. They were travelling with the Andersson family, also from Sweden, who all died in the sinking as well.
My heart sinks everytime when he sees the mother & her baby Frozen in the water. he says they waited to long in his sad voice... then says well keep checking them keep looking! 😔
The only unrealistic detail in this scene is that on the night of the sinking, the lifeboats weren’t prepped with flashlights. Alas, officers did not have them either. When the last boats went back into the field of bodies, there were no lights to use. They had to use stars to guide their way through the mess of lifeless corpses. It was horrible, there was the fear of hitting them with the oars and of course the boats themselves. Rose has this throwaway line in which she says there were roughly (six) people saved from the water after the ship went down, and also says that only ONE lifeboat came back for them. This isn’t strictly true, although for the time it was pretty damn accurate. One of the last lifeboats to return to search for survivors after the sinking of the Titanic was Lifeboat No. 4, commanded by Fourth Officer Joseph Boxhall, and Lifeboat 14 commanded by Harold Lowe. Now, depending on who you ask, the amount of people who were REALLY plucked from the icy water varies with testimonies. According to reports, No.4 returned and found 8 survivor, 2 of whom succumbed to the cold later. 14 picked up roughly 4, one of whom also died. You might know Fang Lang, who was featured during a deleted scene. A Chinese passenger, he was one of the lucky few picked up by Lowe. He had balanced himself on a piece of floating debris. He later died at the age of 91. Pretty heavy stuff.
It's an irish woman from third class who was at the third class dance party, she's the 1 who goes "Jesus Mary and Joseph" after Rose done the toe stand showing off to all the third class passengers during the third class dance party but her frozen corpse and white eyes would give ya the creeps and nightmares.
It's not. It's the Irish woman with red hair who says "Jesus, Mary and Joseph" after her toe stand, and gives Rose a coat in a deleted scene after she recues jack from below deck. She's there in the dream scene too, on the same side as Trudy just before you get to Fabrizzio and Helga.
You can see the mother and baby during the scene with the Catholic priest praying to the Virgin Mary. She is sitting to the side of him holding her baby to her face and praying.
@@ryans413No. Capt Smith was notably larger and taller than the actor portraying him in the movie. Just because he had a white beard doesn’t make him his twin. Look at pictures of the real Captain Smith. You’ll see an older more rugged man than the actor.
If you have children, and you fear for their life as a parent, whenever you read a news story or see a depiction of a baby dying a horrible death like this, it rips your heart in half. Every single time. And you feel the fear for your own child. The dread is hard to bear. I have a one year old and a three year old and the thought of anything harming them is deeply uncomfortable. It was much easier to read all the human suffering as terribly tragic, but it wasn't a personal tragedy, it was just general humanity suffering, which moves me very much. But it's very haunting when I see dead children now. It terrifies me.
Our daughter is presumably not much older than the baby at 1:05. I have seen the movie several times since 1997. But now that I am a father, this scene gets me and tears go down my face. 😭
Same here. I’m a mom to my baby boy who’s 1 month old and I can’t imagine losing him. It makes me emotional to think of the children,the people, and animals that perished on the Titanic. May they all rest in peace😢🤍✝️🙏🏽
Fan fact all those actors were actually in cold water. They couldn’t heat the water because it started giving off steam. So all those extras including Leo and Kate had to act in cold water.
For the curious- three men were ultimately saved because Lowe went back: steward Harold Philimore, third class passenger Fang Lang, and No one is quite sure who the third was, but some sources suggest it was second class passenger Emilio Portaluppi
I read that there were people (most likely) still alive when Officer Lowe arrived to seek for the survivors, but they were too far from the boat. it would take too long to row the boat towards them or the survivor was too weak to swim. after such long time I doubt there were many people still alive, however those who still were...I dont even want to imagine the despair they must have felt.
In the real situation, very likely. One of the symptoms of being in the water that cold for prolonged time is paralysis. You lose all sensation in your hands and legs. There were likely people in the water who could hear the boat but were unable to swim or wave or indicate. And keep in mind it was almost pitch dark, so those who lost the ability to shout or move, would be very unlikely to be able to alert the life boat. In the dark they would be impossible to tell apart from the dead. It's really gruesome to think about
I remember seeing this in theaters for the first time as a prepubescent teen, the feeling of dread and the images of frozen bodies lingered on for weeks.
That line of his gave me Goosebumps, it's like hes sure that they're dead but he doesn't want any undo movement or force on them as they row the boat past them
Yes Ioan Griffudd absolutely killed it here. The resolve to go back, the grief when he realises they're all dead and the desperation to keep looking all come through perfectly. He only had a small role but he nailed it
For whatever reason, I watched this movie hundreds of times as a kid. First time I watched it I was probably 4 years old. That scene where he picks up the ladies body in the water always scared the absolute life out of me. Seeing it now is still terrifying.
It's moving, but also going through so many corpses in absolute silence and in total darkness must have been very scary too... lifting frozen bodies is terrifying. I think that in that area where those bodies were floating today it must be phantasmagorical 🥶
1:05 I've watched this film multiple times and have never really felt a real emphatic connection with the people in the fill because I know it's just a film. This is the first time watching this (or scenes rather) since becoming a parent, my daughter is probably a similar age to this infant and this scene is fucking gut wrenching.
That's deffo a third class passenger from the third class dance party scene she goes "Jesus Mary and Joseph" when Rose does the toe stand in front of the third class passengers and they were all shocked and impressed.
She's the third class passenger that's seen at the 3rd class party scene. She appears more in the deleted scenes, mostly alongside Jack, Rose and other 3rd class passengers when they are trying to find a way up from the lower decks during the sinking. In one deleted scene, it's revealed that she's the person who gave Rose the blanket to keep warmth after saving Jack from the handcuffs, up until when Cal replaces the blanket on Rose with his coat with the diamond in it.
@I made an account To comment he was born in Wales but is of Scottish descent. Lots of Scots live in Wales and England because of better opportunity for work.
Is more creepy because this was real. Actually in real life it was probably even worse. Lowe didn’t had any flashlight as portrayed in the movie … so you can imagine heading into a mass of 1,500 dead in the pitch dark ocean …
Lowe launched his boat, then when afloat put his passengers into a second boat so he could go search for survivors. He waited until it was quieter in the mass of splashing people and arrived too late rescuing 4 of whom 3 survived. But that his passenger's, and that boats people filled that second boat leaving a lifeboat empty...
I think that dead woman at 0:33 was Helga. To those who don't know who Helga was, she was that pretty Norwegian that was Fabrizio's girlfriend. She was also the same young girl seen on the poop deck clinging to the bars before she falls to her demise. I am not Sherlock Holmes but the reason I think that person was Helga was because the body has blonde hair & is wearing a black top which Helga wore. And in a blink and miss it moment the dead mother with her dead baby was the same mother going into labour just before Jack, Fabrizio & Tommy break down the gate and who asked Captain Smith where she should she go.
Não, eu pensei que era a empregada de rose por que parece, mas tão dizendo que é aquela que ajudou rose com o casaco, e essa com o bebê é uma que ela perguntou ao capitão do navio pra onde que ela deveria ir, e foi vista tbm quando estavam rezando, mas é triste
My grandmother said it's a classic and a ship sinks at the end. I was littlr and waited and waited and she was alreqdy crying. And this scene comes on. The mom with their baby. The fear and panic in their eyes. Or the people who knew they'll never catch up a boat outside and just go to bed (mom tells her kids a story)...the old couple go "sleeping" for ever
I could only imagine the horror, the crew on this life boat and the crew from other ships who collected body’s in the days after the disaster felt seeing floating corpses, people with hopes and dreams 😢
Man that scene with the baby gets me every single time. We know that happened 😞. The babies should have been the only ones on the boats with their mothers if they knew they were short life boats.
![어느 날 갑자기 쓰나미가 부산을 덮쳤다 [뭅뭅픽] 해운대 | Haeundae | 설경구 하지원 박중훈 엄정화 이민기 강예원 김인권 송재호 김지영](/img/1.gif)
I'll never forget him saying "We waited too long." Sent chills down my spine the first time I heard it.
and he almost started crying after saying it but stayed strong
What makes it worse is that it’s a poor lady with her baby
Seriously they cld have saved many more of those who died on the water by adding more people to the lifeboats ..most of them were nt even full ..
He knew it deep down that they did waited too long and in that moment he doesn’t even want to keep looking
You can really hear the guilt in his voice as he says it
The writing in this movie is so moving. The integrity and dignity for those that didn’t survive in his line “be careful, don’t hit them!” 😢
😢😢😭😭😭
He had respect for the dead.
I just burst in to tears at that bit.. It really hit me hard especially after that disaster recently. All those people dead. ❤😢
People had some grace and actual respect and decency back then
"We waited to long"
I recently watched the interview of Eva Hart, a survivor. And she said the worst part of the night wasn’t the screaming or the crying. It was the silence that came afterward
“Once the lights had gone, the ship had gone, the sound had gone… It was as if the whole world stood still that night.” - Eva Hart.
@@Knappa22 yes!! So powerful. Her father died that night. So tragic
She died in 1996, a year before this came out. It would've been so hard for her to watch it if she had the chance to watch it.
The silence that followed was probably as bad as it was because of the fact that they could have tried to rescue a few people, but couldn't because the boat could have capsized from panicking people. Key word is could, fear and guilt likely contributed to the horror. Husbands, little kids.
The most eerie scene in the entire movie, just a mass of bodies laying there lifeless in the water with the suspenseful music. Heartbreaking
And they were shouting for help earlier
@@gatsbygoodwood2575 And 3 of the 6 die within days. 3 made it to NY alive, and 1 was indeed "Rosa" the woman the movie took (NAME) inspiration from. Meaning, the Cameron film actually did get the minute detail of "only 1 woman survived the sinking and her name was Rose" right if you think about it.
He tried…he was too late but he tried when no one else would!
@@Lilypad_qqprobably the best option in that situation
@@bradleywilson5641 It was the only choice he could make, if he'd return sooner, then they all would've join them in the water.
Yes😢😢😢
Yes 😢😢😭😭
@@Lilypad_qq”a smart move” 😂😂😂
A haunting scene that cannot be erased from your mind.
Yes 😢😢
Yes 😥😢😢😭😭 so,horrible and so,saddest scene
It’s scary to think that this is what they would of saw when they went back
I really was traumatisied. Now, years later Imo it's of course on of the best and most classic movies. I only watched it with 6 because my Grandma promised me that a ship will sink at the end. And I waited and waited...the night after the movie I woke up and screamed so long till my grandpa came to make the lights on. It was terryfing
@@cinematic.fandom1221 hm 🤔 😌 😔 the last moment in titanic movie 🎬 was so ,terrific and painfull 😢😢😭😭 and more poor and innocent peoples(Man's,woman's 😢 with their baby 👶 😢 in their lapse) lost their lives for cruelity of rich peoples 😢 😥😭😭
There was a survivor in a documentary on the Titanic disaster and he said that for many years he lived near a school with a large football stadium. Whenever a game was played and the crowd would cheer, he would think of the mass of people in the water after the ship sank and said that was what it sounded like. 1500 people drowning and freezing to death in the waters of the North Atlantic.
Yes I remember seeing that documentary. The poor man had PTSD and he would get flashbacks. It would have been terrible for him.
Frankie Goldsmith, that was his name.
All those screaming in the cold water, slowly fading to just one person and to absolute silence. Scariest thing to experience after jumping off the sinking ship.
And many Titanic survivors could not listen to absolute silence for all their life after the tragedy, as it was reminding them of when everything went silent in the water
@@siphonophoresThat's how Eva Hart said her mother described it. She would talk about how horrible the screams of those in the water were, but then her mother would reply, "But do you remember the silence that followed?"
Lowe is one of the biggest heroes from the Titanic, and its heartbreaking to see him so upset about waiting too long
As a 27 year old man I have no shame in saying this song with the movie combined can still bring me to tears. A timeless masterpiece.
Which song?
The dead baby gets me every time :(
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
That was real, some people saw the woman and baby when they passed by the scene of the wreck on another ship some days later
Where I don't see it 😢
@@zacksderiyardm1262at here 01:05
@@thelouisfanclub I heard that the last two survivors of the Titanic were not only the two only babies saved, but the only babies on board period.
The mother and baby are Anna Danbom and her son Gilbert, the youngest Titanic victim, from Sweden. The father also perished, Ernst Danbom, born in America, who returned to his ancestral homeland of Sweden to marry, and then intended to take his bride and baby back to the USA with him, to start a fruit farm in California. They were travelling with the Andersson family, also from Sweden, who all died in the sinking as well.
Well, that just sucks.
Isn’t that the woman who asked captain smith about not knowing what to do in the earlier scene on the ship? She was holding a baby
@@slapshot68 yes.
hmmmmmm...it is well
Ernst is buried in my hometown, it says he died in the Titanic disaster on his headstone
looking at this now as an adult really makes this scene haunting, as a kid I never realised the context of this scene was that all those people in the water are dead. Now that I have a more understanding mind, I can feel the officer's shock and sadness, knowing that only now that he came back instead of sooner meant all these people have died
How did you not know they were dead? Maybe my parents were much more truthful about reality but damn I remember first watching this scene as a 7ish-year-old and just being horrified. The mother with the baby stuck with me.
Bruh what they literally say multiple times they’re dead 😂
I think that woman with the baby was the woman who was trying to ask Captain Smith what to do as he was giving up.
@@ZOSO900😢
It was a tough choice. He has a responsibility to the protection of the lifeboat, and the people in the water would have risked capsizing it in their scramble to get on, risking everyone on the boat a cold death. It was either wait and search for survivors or go forward after the Titanic went and everyone die in the scramble. But the choice to wait definitely haunted everyone that survived.
The facial expressions of guilt sadness and the respectful way they moved the bodies. And then when the officer sees the mother and baby, that saddened him the most. The shock and then. "We waited too long" followed by anger and the refusal to give up looking for survivors. Class acting, so haunting and so respecfully done.❤❤❤❤
1:06
this woman's death is probably the most realistic depiction of what happened to third class passengers. she's the same lady that asked the captain where she should go after all the boats had already been lowered, she had only just found her way out of steerage far too late because third class passengers were forgotten in the chaos. they weren't locked downstairs, the fact that the ship was sinking wasn't properly communicated to them and by the time they finally found their way to the upper deck they had never been given access to, most of the boats were gone and the ones that remained had over a thousand people competing for entry.
Working class left to rot as usual. It wasn't even their fault.
They were locked downstairs, some of those gates are STILL there to this day.
However they were not locked down there to drown, it was anti-theft measure to prevent the poor immigrants from wandering into first class and disrupting their evening/endangering possessions.
When the sinking began, a lot of those gates--which were already locked as it was night time--simply remained shut during the confusion. We may never know how many potential survivors became trapped in the confusion with Noone coming back for them.
Reminds me of Triangle Shirtwaist--which coincidentally happened one year before this. Money was put before safety and the impoverished paid for it when disaster struck.
@@leiderhosen7110 "they were not locked down there to drown"
You are aware the rest of your comment contradicts yourself
apparently the titanic had maze-like corridors too, so a lot of them probably got lost in confusing areas they had never seen before leading to them not finding their way out before it was too late.
@@ketaminepoptartsI’d believe that to. At the museum where they had quotes from crew members one said it took him a whole 2 weeks of learning to be able to get from one end of the ship to the other without getting lost
What’s even more chilling to think about is that no one actually had a flashlight that night. Once the lights had gone out on the ship and it had gone under, they were in total darkness. There was no moon that night. I can’t even imagine the terror those people experienced.
Not being able to yell loud because of being so cold and weak... imagine if the rescue boat passed you.
Probably unconscious within 10 minutes and dead within 20.
You had a better chance surviving a night in a Meat Freezer than you did in that North Atlantic water
From a filmmaking perspective, this scene is fantastic. All of the dead frozen bodies, lack of music, dark lighting, and hopelessness in the rescuer’s voice makes this so grueling and gritty! You’re like 😳
Actually, we do hear music here ... At least musical sounds ... But it's rather quiet and scary music.
💐💐RIP Commander Harold Godfrey Lowe RD, RNR (21 November 1882 - 12 May 1944) (aged 61) and all the victims of the RMS Titanic you will truly all be missed and my prayers go out to you. He helped scores of women and children into lifeboats and was the only Titanic officer to go back to rescue people. The archive includes a telescope given to him by a survivor who had it inscribed: “To Harold G. Lowe... The Real Hero of the Titanic.” 💐💐
How did he pass away?
I also think the crew of the Carpathia that raced to their rescue were heroes, even though they didn't succeed. Captain Rostron pulled out every stop to try to get there, even ordering the heating and hot water turned off in his ship so every single drop of steam could go to the propellers. Her top speed was supposed to be 15 kn but Rostron got the boilers up to nearly 20, arriving in two and a half hours instead of the anticipated four. They pushed their ship past it's physical limits in a heroic effort to rescue the Titanic passengers. Sadly it was in vain.
@@chooseyourpoison5105il Carpathia ha fatto tutto quello che poteva, secondo gli strumenti a loro disposizione un quegli anni.
He witnessed the messy ww2
@@chooseyourpoison5105
At least he got there much faster than the projected 4 hours before anyone else in the lifeboats dies just from the cold.
"We waited too long"... 😭😭😭
What’s sad is that the officers that came back reported that they did hear voices throughout the sea of dead people upon coming back but because of all the debris, darkness, and overall difficulty of steering the small boat they couldn’t get to them on time/couldn’t get to them at all.
I wish they had brought lamps or something...
@@noorrougelewis6704 They had flashlights but it was pitch black out there. There wasn't any moonlight at all unlike the movie. Pure darkness is one hell of a scary thing, but also one hell of a hard thing to shift through, specially with their very old and not so good flashlights back then.
@@supersnow17 No, they didn't have any flashlights. Cameron addded them in the movie for the audience's sake. They only had flares and they are useless in such a search because they blind you and the light doesn't carry far.
@@CzechMirco Actually in the real sinking a green flare saved them because of....some kinda phenomenon I don't remember the name.
@@supersnow17 You mean the cold mirage, due to which Carpathia spotted them from further away than it would normally. But thats not what I meant. Of course you see the flare from far away as you would see any source of light. But I meant the situation when YOU hold the flare and want to see thanks to its light into the darkness. The light gets scattered very close to you and thus won't illuminate anything far from you on the contrary it would shine into your eyes.
I became a Dad 2 years ago. Until you're a parent you never truly understand the wrench on your heart seeing the mother and baby in the water. I've watched this movie countless times before becoming a Dad, and it never got me like it does now. Just an awful feeling
I became a dad 4 years ago, I 100% agree with you brother. I've seen this movie 100 times but this was the 1st time I even thought again about that gal holding her infant. Anything with kids getting hurt puts my guts in a knot and can't bare it. You can hear it in the officers voice
I'm a teen and seeing this broke my heart too.
Im 23 i have 1 yo daughter and when i saw baby and mother i was done..Truly biggest horror u can experience..RIP to all of souls there✝️
The sad truth is it’s most likely true to life it’s not one of them scenes where you think they just used artistic license,most likely the same with the Irish lady and her 2 young kids and how she’s getting them off to sleep inside the ship in there beds with there mum holding there hands,can’t imagine how those parents trying to save there kids must have felt knowing they would not be saved 😢
@chrismark7817 that part tore me up that mom tucking her kids in. I'm sorry but I'd be getting those kids on a boat or die trying with or without me.
Saddest thing is that he did the right thing in waiting. If he didn’t wait for a majority of people to die, it’s possible they would have swamped the boat and overturned it.
Shouldn't you fill the boat and allow late-comers to hang on the sides while repelling those who try to board?
@@TeddyBear-ii4yc staying in the water at all is still likely to kill
@@andrewli6606
Yes i see that. It makes me want to go back in time... 👍
It wouldn’t have mattered. The moment people went into the water, they would’ve had no energy to even get in the boats let alone swamp them. It’s understandable though, this was a big first in Maritime Disasters and alot of lessons learned
Pardon my French, Andrew, but that’s the coldest most hardened awful screwed up thing I have ever heard after the titanic sink there was an uproar by lower class people because the rich people were prioritize instead of everyone being a priority horrid, absolutely horrid Andrew that was not the right thing to do letting regular people like me die just because I’m not some elite billionaire or some movie star. As of now I can’t get over the idea of that little titan minivan size sub no one can find them right now it’s horrible. And yes they are billionaires in rich people it looks to me like there’s a curse here the titanic needs to rest in peace and be left alone.
This scene is so disturbing, especially that dead infant
My favorite scene
It's so disturbing, but there's something so magnetic to this scene that makes me watch it over and over again
The mother and baby are Anna Danbom and her son Gilbert, the youngest Titanic victim, from Sweden. The father also perished, Ernst Danbom, born in America, who returned to his ancestral homeland of Sweden to marry, and then intended to take his bride and baby back to the USA with him, to start a fruit farm in California. They were travelling with the Andersson family, also from Sweden, who all died in the sinking as well.
@HorrorQueen125 Someone is disturbed by the fact that 1500 people just died and you're calling them edgy. See for yourself
@HorrorQueen125 Oh. My bad.
1:05 this scene make my heart crying
Imagine in the real moment 🥺
Crybaby
Same lady that asked the captain where she should go and the captain just walked away
@@ryans413
he was in Trance.
her brain was away.
idk. because his carrere or the ship?
My heart sinks everytime when he sees the mother & her baby Frozen in the water. he says they waited to long in his sad voice... then says well keep checking them keep looking! 😔
The scene with the mom and baby always gets me. So many people died a horrible death. It truly is heart what happened to the titanic.
Why
1:08 "We waited too long...well, keep checking them! Keep looking!" I can feel that moment is full of sadness and frustration! What an excelent actor!
Salute for his effort.
"Is anyone alive out there?!" Goosebumps
"Careful with your oars, don't hit them" genuinely broke me, he's being so respectful and gentle even though they are all dead.
The only unrealistic detail in this scene is that on the night of the sinking, the lifeboats weren’t prepped with flashlights. Alas, officers did not have them either. When the last boats went back into the field of bodies, there were no lights to use. They had to use stars to guide their way through the mess of lifeless corpses. It was horrible, there was the fear of hitting them with the oars and of course the boats themselves.
Rose has this throwaway line in which she says there were roughly (six) people saved from the water after the ship went down, and also says that only ONE lifeboat came back for them. This isn’t strictly true, although for the time it was pretty damn accurate. One of the last lifeboats to return to search for survivors after the sinking of the Titanic was Lifeboat No. 4, commanded by Fourth Officer Joseph Boxhall, and Lifeboat 14 commanded by Harold Lowe. Now, depending on who you ask, the amount of people who were REALLY plucked from the icy water varies with testimonies. According to reports, No.4 returned and found 8 survivor, 2 of whom succumbed to the cold later. 14 picked up roughly 4, one of whom also died. You might know Fang Lang, who was featured during a deleted scene. A Chinese passenger, he was one of the lucky few picked up by Lowe. He had balanced himself on a piece of floating debris. He later died at the age of 91.
Pretty heavy stuff.
That's impossible. They did have have some sort of light.
It's pitch black in the ocean.
You won't be able to see anything out there.
Ioan Gruffudd did excellent as Lowe. Stellar performance.
Sad fact: the first body the find with the white eyes is actually Rose's maid Trudy
I never know
Trudy had brown dark hair…
It's an irish woman from third class who was at the third class dance party, she's the 1 who goes "Jesus Mary and Joseph" after Rose done the toe stand showing off to all the third class passengers during the third class dance party but her frozen corpse and white eyes would give ya the creeps and nightmares.
@@dennisdirkson6518 There's ice on her hair
It's not. It's the Irish woman with red hair who says "Jesus, Mary and Joseph" after her toe stand, and gives Rose a coat in a deleted scene after she recues jack from below deck. She's there in the dream scene too, on the same side as Trudy just before you get to Fabrizzio and Helga.
I cant imagine how it felt to see all those bodies especially the babies
He looked traumatized when he saw the baby 😢😢. And I can’t blame him.
You can see the mother and baby during the scene with the Catholic priest praying to the Virgin Mary. She is sitting to the side of him holding her baby to her face and praying.
This scene breaks my heart 💔.
The man who played Lowe has to be the best look alike in the movie.
Bernard Hill who plays the captain looks just like Smith
@@ryans413No. Capt Smith was notably larger and taller than the actor portraying him in the movie. Just because he had a white beard doesn’t make him his twin. Look at pictures of the real Captain Smith. You’ll see an older more rugged man than the actor.
That's Ioan Gruffud, of Hornblower fame.
@@m.h.7364I knew him first as Mr. Fantastic.
He and his team would not give up trying to find who still alive. Kudos!
He is my favorite officer in this movie, Harold Godfrey Lowe.
Harold Lowe is the same actor who played Reed Richards.
If you have children, and you fear for their life as a parent, whenever you read a news story or see a depiction of a baby dying a horrible death like this, it rips your heart in half. Every single time. And you feel the fear for your own child. The dread is hard to bear. I have a one year old and a three year old and the thought of anything harming them is deeply uncomfortable. It was much easier to read all the human suffering as terribly tragic, but it wasn't a personal tragedy, it was just general humanity suffering, which moves me very much. But it's very haunting when I see dead children now. It terrifies me.
I don't think I would survive losing my child.
How much i agree with you!!! Well said!
Our daughter is presumably not much older than the baby at 1:05. I have seen the movie several times since 1997. But now that I am a father, this scene gets me and tears go down my face. 😭
I have a new baby and i felt the same when i saw the mother and baby. :(
Same here. I’m a mom to my baby boy who’s 1 month old and I can’t imagine losing him. It makes me emotional to think of the children,the people, and animals that perished on the Titanic. May they all rest in peace😢🤍✝️🙏🏽
That women holding her little baby🥺🥺❤️!!
This is so well done, that my heart actually hurts watching this scene. Things like that makes me realize why movies are also art.
Fan fact all those actors were actually in cold water. They couldn’t heat the water because it started giving off steam. So all those extras including Leo and Kate had to act in cold water.
no body understand how brave this is , if he found many alive people he could end up in water
Somewhere in the water there was a wasted baker just enjoying his night.
The site of the mother holding that baby sends a chill up your spine once you have a baby of your own.
For the curious- three men were ultimately saved because Lowe went back: steward Harold Philimore, third class passenger Fang Lang, and No one is quite sure who the third was, but some sources suggest it was second class passenger Emilio Portaluppi
Inclusive, tem a cena do chinês sendo resgatado nesse filme mas foi deletada
@@ddss7Yeah, that’s Fang Lang who’s scene didn’t make it to the final cut.
This scene always make me cry 😢
Wonder how many people in the water actually were alive but couldn't catch their attention like Rose? 😮
I read that there were people (most likely) still alive when Officer Lowe arrived to seek for the survivors, but they were too far from the boat. it would take too long to row the boat towards them or the survivor was too weak to swim. after such long time I doubt there were many people still alive, however those who still were...I dont even want to imagine the despair they must have felt.
In the real situation, very likely. One of the symptoms of being in the water that cold for prolonged time is paralysis. You lose all sensation in your hands and legs. There were likely people in the water who could hear the boat but were unable to swim or wave or indicate. And keep in mind it was almost pitch dark, so those who lost the ability to shout or move, would be very unlikely to be able to alert the life boat. In the dark they would be impossible to tell apart from the dead.
It's really gruesome to think about
As a father the shot of the mother and baby is just too much for me 😢
That welsh bloke was a hero… may heaven be with him.. ❤
I remember the first time I saw this scene as a kid. I was horrified by the amount of frozen dead bodies in the water.
I remember seeing this in theaters for the first time as a prepubescent teen, the feeling of dread and the images of frozen bodies lingered on for weeks.
1:08
The look on his face and tone of his voice says it all...
Over confidence was the main reason for the sinking of Titanic
I like how one of them said “be careful, don’t hit them”
That line of his gave me Goosebumps, it's like hes sure that they're dead but he doesn't want any undo movement or force on them as they row the boat past them
@@Defender78 yeah
Lowe said that
@@ryans413 oh sorry idk who ur talking about and I didn’t know anyone commented this
0:33 I never realised that was Rose’s maid Trudy! You can see a glimpse of her white pinafore under her lifejacket 😢
It's not her. The nose is different and Trudy had a beauty mark.
No it's not her. It's the lady who goes "Jesus, Mary and Joseph" when Rose goes up onto her toes en pointe during the party.
sometimes I don’t fully compute that this actually happened in real life.
I cried when they showed the lady and her baby dead floating in the water 😭😭😭
What a great actor!!
Yes Ioan Griffudd absolutely killed it here. The resolve to go back, the grief when he realises they're all dead and the desperation to keep looking all come through perfectly. He only had a small role but he nailed it
For whatever reason, I watched this movie hundreds of times as a kid. First time I watched it I was probably 4 years old. That scene where he picks up the ladies body in the water always scared the absolute life out of me. Seeing it now is still terrifying.
Saw this movie for the first time when I was 6
God how horrifying.
Especially seeing all those bodies that died wirh their eyes open.
Dont Forget To subscribe and Like
That mother holding her baby in her arms dead in the cold water gets me chocked up every time
Can't imagine how traumatizing that must have been. A sea of dead bodies.
It's moving, but also going through so many corpses in absolute silence and in total darkness must have been very scary too... lifting frozen bodies is terrifying. I think that in that area where those bodies were floating today it must be phantasmagorical 🥶
The fact that this actually happened… the gruesomeness of it all… I can’t even begin to fathom.
Fifth Officer Lowe, not many were more badass than you. ❤
There could be nothing more horrifying then rowing in a sea of silent floating people.
Am I the only one that knows that Ioan Gruffard was in Fantastic Four (2005)
It took me a few months to make the connection after seeing fantastic four.
I knew him from Hornblower but it actually took me a couple of watches to recognize him!
👩🏻this is jennie
👕 every like makes her 1 year older
👖 she is currently 0 years old
Let's see how old she can get
The ultimate deafening silence…
The look of utter pain and heartbreak when he sees the dead woman and her child.. instant regret for not coming back sooner
Never noticed the guy who played hornblower was in this
That's probably one of the few roles where he was allowed to keep his natural accent
He was badly affected by this moment and blamed himself for all but 6 people in the water dying.
I know everybody loves Jack ( myself included) but this officer is sooooo handsome and his accent......oh my god❤😊😍
Yah...very well said dear💓👍
Ioan Gruffudd, a Welsh actor
I had a crush with Billy Zane (Cal)😅. He was so handsome.
@@acidobarbiturico439 Same!!
@@acidobarbiturico439 😅 i know
1:05
I've watched this film multiple times and have never really felt a real emphatic connection with the people in the fill because I know it's just a film. This is the first time watching this (or scenes rather) since becoming a parent, my daughter is probably a similar age to this infant and this scene is fucking gut wrenching.
1:05 This scene right here will always be stuck in my mind.
This would be horrifying to witness. I betcha at least some of those rescuers were never the same again.
1:14 he the same actor who played as horatio nelson hornblower in hornblower movie
0:50 The most heartbreaking quote on this movie
“Can anyone hear me?” “Silence” 😭😭😭
I feel bad for Miss Trudy she’s the first body to be filmed followed by the line “These are dead sir”
That looks like a Third Class passenger, and Trudy didn't have red hair
That's deffo a third class passenger from the third class dance party scene she goes "Jesus Mary and Joseph" when Rose does the toe stand in front of the third class passengers and they were all shocked and impressed.
She's the third class passenger that's seen at the 3rd class party scene. She appears more in the deleted scenes, mostly alongside Jack, Rose and other 3rd class passengers when they are trying to find a way up from the lower decks during the sinking. In one deleted scene, it's revealed that she's the person who gave Rose the blanket to keep warmth after saving Jack from the handcuffs, up until when Cal replaces the blanket on Rose with his coat with the diamond in it.
The "We waited too long" hit so hard..
I remember, in this scene I cried 😭😭😭
I came here to make a Fantastic Four joke. And there's nothing I can say.
What a truly awful way to die. Alone, cold and in the middle of the dark Atlantic ocean. Their families couldn’t even get bodies to bury or cremate.
Officer Lowe makes me proud to be Scottish. 🏴
🫡 salute to you, b'ye.
Isn’t he Welsh though?
@I made an account To comment he was born in Wales but is of Scottish descent. Lots of Scots live in Wales and England because of better opportunity for work.
All the horror movies....pls hold the beer for the Titanic,this scene more creppy than any horrors nowdays
Is more creepy because this was real. Actually in real life it was probably even worse. Lowe didn’t had any flashlight as portrayed in the movie … so you can imagine heading into a mass of 1,500 dead in the pitch dark ocean …
This make me cry every time I watch titanic
Such a touching scene, you couldn't even imagine it
Lowe launched his boat, then when afloat put his passengers into a second boat so he could go search for survivors. He waited until it was quieter in the mass of splashing people and arrived too late rescuing 4 of whom 3 survived.
But that his passenger's, and that boats people filled that second boat leaving a lifeboat empty...
I think that dead woman at 0:33 was Helga. To those who don't know who Helga was, she was that pretty Norwegian that was Fabrizio's girlfriend.
She was also the same young girl seen on the poop deck clinging to the bars before she falls to her demise.
I am not Sherlock Holmes but the reason I think that person was Helga was because the body has blonde hair & is wearing a black top which Helga wore.
And in a blink and miss it moment the dead mother with her dead baby was the same mother going into labour just before Jack, Fabrizio & Tommy break down the gate and who asked Captain Smith where she should she go.
Não, eu pensei que era a empregada de rose por que parece, mas tão dizendo que é aquela que ajudou rose com o casaco, e essa com o bebê é uma que ela perguntou ao capitão do navio pra onde que ela deveria ir, e foi vista tbm quando estavam rezando, mas é triste
E Helga tem cabelo loiro
This scene breaks my heart.
Lowe had enough respect to say don’t hit them even though there dead.
That’s it, i have cried 😢 Man !
My grandmother said it's a classic and a ship sinks at the end. I was littlr and waited and waited and she was alreqdy crying. And this scene comes on. The mom with their baby. The fear and panic in their eyes. Or the people who knew they'll never catch up a boat outside and just go to bed (mom tells her kids a story)...the old couple go "sleeping" for ever
44-48 were pulled from the water, out of the 2240 people onboard, 700 survived.
I could only imagine the horror, the crew on this life boat and the crew from other ships who collected body’s in the days after the disaster felt seeing floating corpses, people with hopes and dreams 😢
Man that scene with the baby gets me every single time. We know that happened 😞. The babies should have been the only ones on the boats with their mothers if they knew they were short life boats.
Only if Mr Fantastic used his powers
Lowe in that moment when he said “we waited too long” knows he’s just coming back is already in vain
The scene with the mother and the baby…. Once I became a parent this scene hits differently
💔