EF 24-105 F4L vs EF-S 18-135!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 авг 2014
- L series kit lens vs entry level kit lens! How do they compare?
Intro Music by WolfsteR.
/ xxmarksomexx
audiojungle.net/user/WolfsteR
_____________
Royalty-free music I'm using for my videos (2 months FREE if you sign up using my link!):
artlist.io/artlist-70446/?art...
You can also license stock footage from Artgrid.io (same 2 bonus months applies!):
artgrid.io/Artgrid-114820/?ar...
exactly the comparison I was looking for. thanks for this
Nice video. I was trying to find a comparison between the two
What about naming them John and Bob to better reference them? :) thanks for the review, helpful
this was great! thanks for the video!
Thanks for your review bud.
Hi, thanks for the comparison,
But i don't understand how the 24-105 at f/8 has the same luminosity as the 18-135 at f/4, does it mean a picutre at exactly same parameters between the lenses will be much more brighter on the 24-105 ?
thanks
Excellent review.
really good review, thanks
i want ask a question. so i had the 18-135 lens and i put it on dry cabinet, so when i test the auto focus, the focus ring is sound so weird. it sounds like you were moving a chair. but it's not jammed
Hi! I am planning on buying a canon 80D. I will mainly use it for video, and I wonder what lens is the best for me. The 80D is known for very good dual auto focus, and I wonder if one of those lenses are better at AF than the other ome. If someone could help me out, it would be highly appreciated!
You have confirmed likely what we all already new! Thank you!
Minimum aperture at 24mm and 105mm for efs 18-135 to compare with the constant f/4 for the ef 24-105?
I've used both and have gotten great pictures out of both but you get more reach with the 18-135
at 3:50 when you were comparing the text on the paper... isn't it a bit unfair that the 24-105 vs on f/8? compared to the 18-135 which was on f/4?...
Yes, fuck that comparison.
Would you recommend the best lens for photographing shoes from Canon lens 100
thanks very helpful
What about the focusing sound
Excellent review, I have the 18/135 USM , was gonna possibly get the 24/105, For double the money , I can’t justify the purchase
Where do you get this nice canon tshirt
According to what you showed in this video my thoughts is for the price gap between these two lenses there is less than a slight edge that separate them and I was considering to invest in the 24-105 but except the build quality I am so disappointed from is overall performance :( I would expect a bigger difference in image quality; that's a shame for canon when you think about the price! but anyway thank for sharing this video and your thoughts on it. thumb up
BTW, thanks for the info.
Canon 24-105mm....lans price?
Переведите пожалуйста. Или подскажите какой лучше? Я снимаю свадьбы, юбилеи и тд. В ночное время тоже снимаю
So I have a Canon 70D with the 18-135 lens and I got this camera kit to start making cinematic films should I stick with the 18-135 or upgrade to the 24-105 or just save my money and buy a glidecam?
If you're shooting cinematic films, I would just invest in more lights and keep using that 18-135. The sharpness is very similar, but 24mm is not very wide on a Canon 70D.
I have both lenses and EF 24-105 L IS USM is heavy, it slides in to zoom by itself, and at zoom is not sharp at all. The price is totally out of this world and all you get in return is red ring on the lens indicating you paid a lot for it. The EF-S 19-135 is just as good, actually sharper at full zoom and a for lot less $$$$ including less weight !
One lens on f4 and other on f8....yeees - very helpfull review :D jesus..
Not to mention - if you decide to buy a full frame sensor camera you can still use your lens with the 24-105.
What's the point in stopping down the the 24-105? That's more than likely going to give better results than of you left them wide open.
Hi i'm going to ask is the canon 24-105 suit for canon 700d camera?
My Trinh Huynh Yes
I'm about to upgrade from the t3i to canon 6D mii.. is there an adapter if I buy the 18-135, so I can use that lens?
There is not. EFS lenses usually produce an image circle that isn't large enough to cover the entire sensor even if you found a way to attach it.
The STM 18-135 is silent when autofocusing. The 24-105 isn't. I don't do much zooming while filming so the jerky STM zoom ring is fine for me. I'm using a Canon C100 and the image quality is still great on the 18-135.
Both lenses come in the STM version. STM = silent. Both come in the non-STM version. Non-STM = noisy on video. The sound variable is STM.
The 18-135mm STM is awesome on the C100. I have the MKII with the 18-135mm STM and all of the STMs are quiet. You cannot beat the Sigma AF 18-35mm f/1.8 in sharp images on the C100. The Sigma AF 17-50mm f2.8 OS also provides great images. The Sigmas AF are louder than the STMs. You can overcome that with a good shotgun mic.
My favorite feature about the Canon STM lenses on the C100 MKII is the autofocus facial lock. They do bite in low light so keep a pancake Canon STM 24 & 50mm in your pocket. The pancakes don’t allow for facial lock but the regular dual pixel AF works just fine.
If I have the 18-135 for the Canon Rebel t4i is there any point to getting the 24-105 or should I look for a different type of lens?
The wide end of the 24-105 at 24mm can be quite tight for crop sensors. If you're looking for a better standard zoom you can look into something like a Sigma 17-50 F2.8.
Thanks! I'm trying to learn about all this stuff and improve my equipment going forward so I appreciate the help!
Its ef unlike efs 18-135.
How is it with noise (IS and AF)? I am interested in buying one of these lenses for filmmaking and usually like to shoot with the external microphone directly on top of the Camera. Thanks :)
I use the EF-S 18-135 IS STM on my Canon C100 mk2 and the autofocus and stabilization make no noise at all when working. This video was shot with the lens on my C100 mk2 with autofocus on. ruclips.net/video/ERg4y1Q4Tck/видео.html
Ditto
I also have a C100 MKII and use the 18-135mm STM as it’s AF is super fast and quiet. I have the 24-105 (L) and it’s not bad but the dual pixel AF on the C100 MKII works well with the STMs.
Your sharpness tests in Lightroom show F/4 for the 18-135mm but F/8 for the 24-105mm which pretty kills the test. DXO mark has the 24-105mm slightly higher rated, but in their sharpness graph they're amazingly close. Maybe the 18-135 is slightly sharper even at 50mm. It seems like there's little justification except the constant F/4 for paying up for the 24-105mm. EXCEPT: Because it's a kit lens for full frame, you can find some great deals where it is being sold as white box - removed from the kit. About half price at Abes of Maine now (9/30/14). Probably still not worth it if you already have the 18-135 - but maybe if you're deciding between the 2.
*******STAY AWAY FROM ABES OF MIANE************ #CROOKS #RIPOFF #FRAUD #SCAMMERS
I'm thinking of buying a Canon 70D and was wondering if I should just buy the body and get the 24-105 or should i get the 18-135 kit?
If you're going for long-term serious photography, I would not recommend the 18-135. The 24-105 would be a good choice but of course, there are many alternatives out there that you can also take into consideration :)
Probably if you have the money for the 24-105 you should get the 17-55 cause it has same image quality as the L while being one stop brighter and having a wider zoom range while still being enough for bokehlicious photography
what about af vídeo focusing ?
How is the 24-105 comparing to the stm ?
Luis Miguel Silva STM was designed for video AF. For AF the STM is smoother. However if you're gonna do any MF at all, the STM will be a nightmare to focus with.
+ZY Productions how is 24-105 l with crop sensor againts 55-250?
what about sharpness? is big difference?
Not big, but the contrast is way better for 24-105mm
min 3:50 -> why you put 18-135 at f/4 and 24-105 at f/8 ?? thats not fair...
beacuse its not sharp at f4 :D
WHAT LENS WOULD YOU SUGGEST FOR A 70d FOR PORTRAIT PHOTOGRAPHY
canon 70-200mm
70-200 is like a 112-320 on a 70D. I guess you could use it, but I'd rather go for a shorter focal range.
Don't you think it would have been fairer if you'd used the 24-105 non l
Berni Moulang It wasn't released yet when I made this video.
OK, do you think youll ever make that comparison?'
From your image quality test I do not see all that much of a difference. Certainly not enough to justify the price difference unless you need a rugged lens.
From sharpness, 24-105 is a bit sharper and better contrast. But, yeah, just a bit
as a user of 18-135 for more than a year...f3.5 is a shit, image is sharp from F6.3 sometimes F7.1 and this is bloody dark! L series allow you to have sharp image from F4! thats a massive diffrence
24-105 f/4 L is pointless... only if you have an APS-C DSLR. 1.6x crop factor means 24-105 is 38-170 equivalent and 38 is by no means wide angle... personally if i wasn't using full frame i would pick the 18-135
Agree.
I wish I had a full frame so I could have the 24-105, which is imo a much more practical range on full frame than 18-135 offers on crop. Also, the aperture drop on the 18-135 kills me. I would much prefer something like a 16-70mm constant f/4 or f/3.5 on crop!! That seems like a much more similar experience like the 24-105 offers on full frame.
and he forgets that 24-105 F4 when using with aps-c sensor F4 becames f6.4
wtf?
GamerAtHertz I think you're confused! The aperture of a lens has nothing to do with the size of the sensor! F4 remains F4 and so on... Go read a bit before criticizing someone's video. I agree there was some flaws in the comparison, but that was not one of them!
save money and buy a glidecam, i'ts better to get practice in photography and filmmaking than spending all your money on high budget gear, i would focus more on audio and lighting ;D but it's your chose after all
Weird comparison, there ain't no doubts that 24-105 is better.
Agree, that it's strange comparison. The 18-135 is an all-in-one lens, the 24-105 isn't. At least not on an APS-C body.
they're both kit lenses
No, only one of them is.
Do you hear anything about 70D, 5D Mark iii or IV?
誰か翻訳してくれ
24-105 is far more expensive than 18-135