Baylan Skoll's Recasting - My Thoughts

Поделиться
HTML-код

Комментарии • 132

  • @runningthemeta5570
    @runningthemeta5570 14 дней назад +328

    I’ve also heard that Ray and Rory were friends IRL. So this means so much more that Rory is willing to step in a finish the story of his friend’s character.

  • @ae112r8
    @ae112r8 14 дней назад +265

    I'm glad they're not just dropping his storyline or trying to do some CGI bs. Hope this starts to encourage them to recast more often. Disney seems scared of it since Solo, but I thought that recast was great too. Let some new actors pick up these roles! These stories deserve a longer life than we all get in this galaxy.

    • @eagc7
      @eagc7 14 дней назад +22

      I think part of the reason they were afraid of recasting is because of how vocal people are online when it happens, like screaming that it's "Disrespectful" if you give the role to someone else and I am like.....how it is disrespectful?

    • @comicop2513
      @comicop2513 13 дней назад +1

      Massive difference between recasting someone like Solo, and Skoll.

    • @SkyTreeStudio
      @SkyTreeStudio 13 дней назад +11

      @@comicop2513still tho if you want to tell a story with a younger Solo ai or cgi is the worst way to do it
      Hire a good actor and just pretend it’s ok

    • @eagc7
      @eagc7 13 дней назад +14

      @ I agree, even if its someone as big as Han Solo or Luke or Leia, they shouldn't be afraid of recasting especially if you wanna tell stories with younger take on the characters or if you wanna do stuff with them before The Force Awakens, like with the Mandoverse stuff, instead of doing a Mark Hamill deepfake, just get a new actor
      Or in the case of Leia in Rise of Skywalker, if you are gonna still keep her around, then recast instead of having to write around a bunch of deleted scenes that were filmed and written for a different context than what they ended up being used for.

    • @lyndsaybrown8471
      @lyndsaybrown8471 12 дней назад +1

      Right? Recasting> AI/CGI

  • @MTTT19
    @MTTT19 14 дней назад +79

    It's always sad when an actor who played a role so well passes away. However, the fact that Rory McCann was good friends with Ray Stevenson is something that is nice to hear. A good friend stepping in to finish his friend's work.

  • @BobbyM817
    @BobbyM817 14 дней назад +110

    Great casting. Horrible circumstances of course, but I’m really happy they’re continuing Baylan’s story. It would have been a huge disservice to the character and to Ray Stevenson to just forget about the character and not do anything with him.

  • @Magdalena8008s
    @Magdalena8008s 14 дней назад +40

    Great casting. And awesome they were friends and Rays family is on board with this. Simple as that.

  • @antjtw
    @antjtw 14 дней назад +85

    Goated casting

    • @MeanBlackjack47
      @MeanBlackjack47 14 дней назад +9

      Yarp.

    • @espenstoro
      @espenstoro 14 дней назад +7

      GOTed

    • @chewy99.
      @chewy99. 13 дней назад +3

      He just needs a wig cause his hairline is definitely off from Baylan’s lol

  • @jacobwilson9800
    @jacobwilson9800 14 дней назад +13

    I’m so glad that they aren’t doing a CGI thing or just simply writing him out.

  • @Iceskyguy
    @Iceskyguy 14 дней назад +15

    If this is true, I'm happy! I'll always miss Ray and cherish his performance but Rory is a class actor and I'm happy they're continuing the character. Honestly he was a surprising choice, not who I would have thought of but the more I think about it, the more on board I am! He was one of the best in Game of Thrones IMO, one of my absolute favourites too so I can definitely see him pulling it off! No question he has the acting chops for it, he also has the physicality and the fact he and Ray were friends makes it meaningful. It feels right.
    Baylan Skoll lives on🧡🐺

  • @madisonwhovian943
    @madisonwhovian943 14 дней назад +8

    If he's at Celebration this year, he'll receive a very warm welcome.

  • @OrionInSpace
    @OrionInSpace 14 дней назад +16

    I think the two things that everybody loves about this particular choice of the recasting is that for one, apparently he and Ray were good friends in real life so it adds some emotional weight to why he would take up this role. on top of that, as far as I remember, when people were theorizing, who would take up the recast, I don’t think a single person ever mentioned this guys name. It was always the same three people, but Rory was not on that list.

  • @TheMaxRebo
    @TheMaxRebo 14 дней назад +6

    Star Wars seems so hesitant to recast rolls so I am glad that they decided to do that here rather than just cut the storyline short or use deep fake or something

  • @charlestownsend9280
    @charlestownsend9280 14 дней назад +5

    I'm glad that they're not just writing out the character and are continuing the story that was started. Sometimes the best way to honour an actor is to finish their work.

  • @TheBoldpPointe
    @TheBoldpPointe 14 дней назад +4

    Never would have guessed Rory but now that I see this, he seems like an excellent choice. He'll bring that gentle, yet imposing aura to the role.

  • @RyanHaney55
    @RyanHaney55 13 дней назад +1

    Since Baylan had a story to tell, we needed a recast. I feel the same way about T'Chala in the MCU. It's really sad the actors have passed, but they can be honored by continuing their legacy.

  • @smag5689
    @smag5689 14 дней назад +4

    The first place I saw Rory McCann was a British dramedy TV show called Book Club starring American actress Anne Dudek (White Chicks) as a woman who moves to Scotland and starts a book club to make friends. RM played a disabled gay man in a wheelchair. Has proved to me that he has range.

  • @johnsexton8759
    @johnsexton8759 13 дней назад +1

    So brilliantly said Alex. Ray Stephenson was a huge loss and he played the character of Bylan so well, as you explained. We look forward to what Rory McCann can bring to the role.

  • @darkspectre1
    @darkspectre1 13 дней назад +1

    Fantastic choice for Baylan, 100% agree! RIP Ray!

  • @SolarE845
    @SolarE845 14 дней назад +3

    Loved Ray's performance and the character in s1. Recast was the right decision and I think Rory McCann has the acting shops and the physical presence to pull it off. Hearing that they were friends is also a nice touch. Baylan has the potential to be a generational character and Ray's contribution will never go under appreciated

  • @SeaLion8488
    @SeaLion8488 13 дней назад +2

    Don’t forget his role as the punisher and judge dread. Two excellent movies and roles.

    • @stevenbreach2561
      @stevenbreach2561 12 дней назад

      Judge Dread?,When,where?

    • @SeaLion8488
      @SeaLion8488 11 дней назад

      @ my bad. That was Karl Urban. Okay I’ll plug Rome then. Excellent show

  • @disneyplusreviews
    @disneyplusreviews 11 дней назад

    I'm glad the story will continue. Baylin was my favorite character on the show.

  • @kenshin_151
    @kenshin_151 13 дней назад +1

    McCann is a perfect person for the role. Looking forward to S2 even more now that it's all but confirmed we'll be seeing more of Skoll, an outstanding character in Ahsoka. RIP to Ray Stevenson 🙏🏽

  • @benreilly9513
    @benreilly9513 14 дней назад +1

    He’s also one of our best Megatrons, in the excellent Transformers EarthSpark. Knowing his work there, I had the same reaction- he’s an excellent choice.

  • @sdswood3457
    @sdswood3457 12 дней назад

    I loved Ray in Black Sails and Ahsoka, and for many reasons its bittersweet to hear his role is being recast. But when I heard its going to Rory, beyond the fact they were friends and it will be very poetic for Rory to finish what Ray started, besides the fact it prevents a large part of the story having to be reworked, besides all of this I am truly excited for one thing not mentioned here. We get to see RORY with a LIGHTSABER! BEING a BAD/GOOD/BAD GUY! How COOL is that!!

  • @StuartLugsden
    @StuartLugsden 14 дней назад +6

    I’m hoping Greef Karga won’t be recasted. I would rather they just leave him out of Mando and let the EU storytellers take over.

  • @cathyk9700
    @cathyk9700 13 дней назад +2

    Great casting. And, Rory will already be skilled at wielding a broad sword… Ahem, I mean, light saber.

  • @hammerman199374
    @hammerman199374 14 дней назад +1

    My first choice was Liev Schreiber, but this will work fine.

  • @auntvesuvi3872
    @auntvesuvi3872 14 дней назад +1

    Thanks, Alex! 🌟

  • @Bionickpunk
    @Bionickpunk 14 дней назад +3

    Now they can eat all the chicken they want.

  • @elliottquinton2084
    @elliottquinton2084 13 дней назад

    I liked him in Star Wars then I watched Rome and wow, I couldn’t believe it was him, he was a unit. RIP to pullo the legend

  • @maxkwiatkowski1232
    @maxkwiatkowski1232 14 дней назад +12

    “He’s not going to reference Yarp”
    30 seconds later
    “HE DID THE THING!”

  • @gr8tbigtreehugger
    @gr8tbigtreehugger 13 дней назад

    Loving y'all rocking the SM58s 🎤

  • @Fork1
    @Fork1 14 дней назад +1

    I think this is good! We mustn't let a character be only tied to one actor/actress. Because this mythological universe will continue past someones lifespan and then that character can't be off limits, especially if their story isn't done!

  • @Daniel-Strain
    @Daniel-Strain 14 дней назад +2

    I'm surprised how much McCann looks like Stevenson. Once they get the hair do on him it will be even closer. Maybe they'll even do a little prosthetics or something. But what would work REALLY well, is if they make him look younger and give him brown hair. Then have something about that light he was headed for regenerate him and make him younger. Then the difference would be a lot more smooth.

    • @StuartLugsden
      @StuartLugsden 14 дней назад +1

      They could do what they did in Breaking Bad to make Bryan look younger.

  • @adcon00
    @adcon00 13 дней назад +2

    Yeah, this is so much better and more respectful to all the actors involved than some ghoulish digitial "resurrection" with deep fakes and AI voices.

  • @RayOfTruth
    @RayOfTruth 13 дней назад

    I'm glad his story will not remain unfinished.

  • @nfalls75
    @nfalls75 14 дней назад +1

    You're right. He does bring the right vibe to this role. And, I'm glad they didn't just reflexively go with some serviceable actor who looks like Ray, or God forbid go the CGI route. I like it!

  • @JBTriple8
    @JBTriple8 9 дней назад

    yeah im intrigued by this as well there's more also with recent rumors of Anakin,Obi-Wan and Young Ahsoka comingback means that Baylan Skoll will be threatening the existence of All life with the Force.

  • @josemaiz1651
    @josemaiz1651 13 дней назад

    Perfect casting there rumor that Embo will be the main villain of the Mandi and grogu film

  • @FilonisHat
    @FilonisHat 14 дней назад +1

    I'm glad Lucas recast him, instead of doing whatever the heck they did with Carrie in Ep. IX, or going with some AI deepfake abomination like in Fett. My opinion is that characters last forever, and the living, breathing humans who play them have a limited time in those characters' shoes. I am always open to recast characters, even if their shoes are monumentally hard to fill. Let talented artists get a shot at becoming characters we know and love, and if they whiff, then bring out the next artist and try again.

  • @Stablemable2
    @Stablemable2 14 дней назад +1

    Sometimes Stevensons, seasoned appearance reminds me of Sean Connery from the 90s.
    But the recasting is a surprise but Im looking forward to the next Ahsoka series.

  • @yodasdad
    @yodasdad 13 дней назад +1

    Ray Stevenson’s performance was the standout of that series

    • @amdi8966
      @amdi8966 13 дней назад +1

      1 could easily argue he carried 🤷🏻‍♂️

  • @VegasGoldenJediKnight
    @VegasGoldenJediKnight 13 дней назад

    RIP Titus Pulo of the 13th

  • @ObligedUniform
    @ObligedUniform 14 дней назад

    1:13 agreed. I am very intrigued by the news!

  • @kzilla8864
    @kzilla8864 14 дней назад +1

    I'm glad they are continuing Baylan Scolls' story by recasting instead of just killing him off. If this was Marvel, they would straight up refuse to recast like what they did with Tchalla or Kang.

  • @CaterillarBrows
    @CaterillarBrows 13 дней назад

    I honestly thought they would have continued his story through animation or comics, but this is great to see! We will always appreciate Ray.

  • @VideoclipsNI
    @VideoclipsNI 14 дней назад

    My first introduction to Rory McCann was a to show called Book Club! Ray had a gravitas in the role I hope he can bring.

  • @zacharymccoy7091
    @zacharymccoy7091 14 дней назад +1

    I was really hoping for Liev Schrieber to take the role, but he's a good actor, too.

  • @Alfje17
    @Alfje17 14 дней назад +1

    Casting McCann was the best choice... for the greater good!

  • @Arauto_Kagnos
    @Arauto_Kagnos 12 дней назад

    I don't know much about the actor but I'm just glad they're continuing Baylan's storyline.

  • @MM-vs2et
    @MM-vs2et 13 дней назад

    Thank the gods. I swear, I've had it up to here with CG remodels

  • @PatrickWDunne
    @PatrickWDunne 14 дней назад

    RIP Ray Stevenson

  • @davidratcliffe5000
    @davidratcliffe5000 13 дней назад

    Yeah I never saw GOT so I only know McCann from The Book Group and Hot Fuzz. This isn't helpful in imagining him in the role of Skoll, but I'm glad the character is being properly recast rather than being replaced with a CGI version or something. Studios need to know that they can, and often times should, do this rather than rely too much on the technology. This also makes me realise I'm looking forward to Ahsoka S2 more than I thought I would be. S1 was patchy, in my opinion, but I think the potential is there to make something excellent moving forward.

  • @generalbutterscotch4887
    @generalbutterscotch4887 9 дней назад

    On the bright side, it looks like Force Hounds are canon again

  • @shaneoconnell9279
    @shaneoconnell9279 14 дней назад

    Bowing saved The Hound when he stopped the madness in the name of his King
    Such loyalty to his friend taking up the role, eating all the scenery in the room

  • @kevinsteets5019
    @kevinsteets5019 14 дней назад

    RRR!!! Such a fun movie

  • @Arkham_Prisoner
    @Arkham_Prisoner 14 дней назад +2

    Definitely not a casting choice I considered but I really think McCann can pull it off

  • @depreseo
    @depreseo 13 дней назад

    My thoughts on the recasting: Yarp.

  • @badenhowell3312
    @badenhowell3312 13 дней назад

    Speaking of which, my Dad doesn't live too far away from the village where they filmed Hot Fuzz.

  • @LeatherRebel75
    @LeatherRebel75 14 дней назад

    I feel the same way. I hate that we lost Ray Stevenson, but I think Rory McCann is an excellent choice.

  • @nexpose1
    @nexpose1 14 дней назад

    Ahh not George Clooney. 😁 I still say for a look they'd nail it with Clooney but I understand and sounds good.

  • @Bazemoremusic
    @Bazemoremusic 12 дней назад

    talk about an actor that can swing a sword!!!! Cant wait to see him with a saber in hand!!!

  • @Tinkerbe11
    @Tinkerbe11 13 дней назад +1

    I'm not a big fan of recasting, but Baylan is the absolute exception. The storyline was too interesting to just stop it. And it could not be given to another character. And Rory McCann was a good friend of Ray Stevenson, so he will be respectful to his work and character. A good choice for the recast!

  • @thorakvideos2495
    @thorakvideos2495 13 дней назад

    I think this was one of the best choices in the worst possible situation.

  • @Jay-mx6bg
    @Jay-mx6bg 14 дней назад +1

    Good while I do miss his old actor I would like to see where the rest of Baylon’s story instead of killing him off because his actor died

  • @StuartLugsden
    @StuartLugsden 14 дней назад +1

    It won’t be the same without Ray but Rory will do his best I know.

  • @Flynn01979
    @Flynn01979 13 дней назад

    Baylan Skoll vs Captain Phasma brutal fist fight!! I don't care if it breaks the timeline line. Do it!

  • @fmluta
    @fmluta 14 дней назад

    I still think Kieran Bew would have been great. He could have portrayed the subtlety of Baylan, especially how Kieran looked in HotD

  • @khronokraze
    @khronokraze 13 дней назад

    I think the news of this recasting should work out pretty well. However, looks wise, I think this actor, Liev Schreiber, may have made a better match visually, in terms of his overall look especially around the face. Anyways, I just hope they develop season 2 of ahsoka well.

  • @orinanime
    @orinanime 12 дней назад

    In terms of who I was hoping for... He wasn't my first choice. But he is a good actor. My top choices were:
    Richard Armitage
    Pierce Brosnan
    Graham McTavish
    Gerard Butler
    Russell Crowe
    Kurt Russell
    Liev Schreiber
    David Harbor
    Jeffery Dean Morgan
    But... As much as I had hoped for Richard Armitage, I hold out hope that Rory McCann portrays the character/performs the role well.

  • @lanceshadow5582
    @lanceshadow5582 14 дней назад +2

    I think people are too obsessed with keeping the same actor in the same role in perpetuity when it comes to star wars. Yes, recasting should be done with great care but i don't think the very idea of recasting is a bad thing.
    CGI Peter Cushing and especially CGI Young Carrie Fisher made rogue one worse. There was no good reason to show leias face at the end and if they needed tarkin in the movie just bring back the actor who played him in episode 3. It worked for Genevieve O'Reilly and mon mothma and look at where the character and that actress are now.
    Alden ehrenreich was great as young han solo, but even if you disagree I will die on the hill that recasting is better than a cgi Harrison Ford (especially when Anthony ingruber exists)
    The luke skywalker cgi in mandalorian and book of boba wasn't too bad, and im glad it was used sparingly but never seeing Luke's face and letting mark Hamill do the voice would have been better imo. He's a brilliant voice actor he could have pulled it off.
    Limiting themselves to archival footage made leias role in rise of skywalker clunky and awkward in an already clunky and awkward movie. They either should have written leia out or recasted the character if they wanted her to have a bigger role

  • @DJMarcO138
    @DJMarcO138 14 дней назад

    RIP Ray! This should be a good recast though, as good as it can be anyway.

  • @rhaenatargaryen8061
    @rhaenatargaryen8061 14 дней назад

    Not sure about this recast yet tbh, but if you like ray's work you should check out Black Sails. He shows up in the third season, but it's one of the best shows ever made regardless.

  • @Vulcanerd
    @Vulcanerd 13 дней назад

    I will always think fondly of Ray Stevenson as Baylon, but I think and hope Rory does a good job stepping into the role.
    edit: And agree that I think it's good to see the character's story through.

  • @dustrahne
    @dustrahne 14 дней назад

    Ray Stevenson's loss is definitely felt. Every Pop or image of Skoll I find, I collect. McCann will be a Skoll, I hope. He has the demeanor needed for the role. The physicality. Stevenson will definitely be missed though.

  • @TwelveCat
    @TwelveCat 14 дней назад +1

    I don't know anything about Rory McCann, I'm not a GOT fan and I've not seen them in anything else so I'm hesitant if he can hold up to Ray Stevenson but if star wars has taught me anything, it's to have hope. And I trust Dave Feloni to find someone right for the role. Though it does beg the question if we ever saw the character in animation like in a Tales of episode, who would they be modelled after?

    • @Alfje17
      @Alfje17 14 дней назад +1

      Watch Hot Fuzz, McCann has a small role, which doesn't really show his range, but the movie is great!

    • @TwelveCat
      @TwelveCat 13 дней назад

      ​@alfje5492 I have seen hot fuzz. However, his roles too small to get an idea on his range so I don't really count it in this instance

  • @graemehirstwood670
    @graemehirstwood670 13 дней назад

    I think about him in porridge adverts

  • @laverniustucker8198
    @laverniustucker8198 14 дней назад

    i love the recast choice

  • @BladedFish
    @BladedFish 10 дней назад

    B A Y L A N B O W L

  • @TLhikan
    @TLhikan 14 дней назад

    Baylan’s story was my favorite part of Ahsoka season 2 and I think continuing the story with another great actor is more respectful to Mr. Stevenson than awkwardly dropping the thread.

  • @malphasblackwing420
    @malphasblackwing420 14 дней назад

    Can I just point out a few things? 1: I literally can’t think of a single better re-casting choice given the circumstances… Like Rory already has the physical appearance to be in the role and has the right vocal pitch. 2: I am soooo hoping that we get Abeloth. Like you have no idea how badly I want Abeloth! 2.5: Could you imagine if we got all four Mortis gods on screen together?! 3: I had extremely high hopes for the Ahsoka show and so far I have nothing but excellent things to say about it.
    Rest In Peace Ray. May the Force be with you always. Your villainousness on screen could never conceal the light in your heart.

  • @punkypink83
    @punkypink83 14 дней назад

    hold on. how have i never clocked that the hound is also "YARP man"???

  • @RobertJohnMetcalfe
    @RobertJohnMetcalfe 14 дней назад

    Just wanted to chime in with my 2c that the zoom-in edits, to me, seem ominous and distracting. I would rather the camera be static when Alex is speaking.

  • @chewy99.
    @chewy99. 13 дней назад +1

    He just needs a wig cause his hairline is definitely off from Baylan lol

    • @gingergaming2694
      @gingergaming2694 13 дней назад

      Wigs are used for most characters in films or tv shows

  • @AaronKelley1969
    @AaronKelley1969 14 дней назад

    As it had to be done it's probably as good as they could have managed. Just a shame really. I'm glad that Rory & Ray were friends and that Ray's family has endorsed Rory in the role.

  • @MCLegoboy
    @MCLegoboy 14 дней назад

    I don't know anything about the guy or the characters that he's played, so all I can say is that I hope he was the right choice and wish him the best of luck.
    Personally, when I first thought about who could play the character of Baylan Skoll for Season 2, I thought of Liev Schreiber, and if I'm being honest, I still prefer that pick. I know his skills as an actor, he has experience doing action, and he's a very similar age, height, build, and even shared a very similar facial structure to Ray Stevenson.
    But like I said, since Rory McCann is the reported recast, I hope he was the right choice and things go well. Nobody will ever be able to quite match what Ray did for the character, so I can only hope that I can be immersed in the story and not lose focus on how right or wrong things are with his absence.

  • @Playitcool_1963
    @Playitcool_1963 14 дней назад

    Im genuinely heartbroken still because of his death, however im sure the new baylan will honour his predecessor

  • @erikwegner8758
    @erikwegner8758 11 дней назад

    I REALLY wish they didn't recast him. He can't be replaced by another actor. They should have had him ascend to another level of the force and just use CG to give glimpses to conclude his story.

  • @fightingfalcon777
    @fightingfalcon777 14 дней назад

    Honestly, aside from Rory McCann’s talent as an actor, his appearance in the Knuckles mini-series looked like an almost disheveled Baylan, so I could see both appearance wise and talent wise him working perfectly in the role

  • @michaelsatterfield2021
    @michaelsatterfield2021 14 дней назад

    Are you going to review the shadow drops like seeds of starlight?

  • @danprentice7073
    @danprentice7073 14 дней назад

    "Who does he look look like, His mother or sister?"
    " Same person. "
    Joking aside great casting its just a shame that we never got to see anymore of Ray Stevenson in the roll.

  • @macgonzo
    @macgonzo 14 дней назад

    Yarp!

  • @Blanzalot
    @Blanzalot 14 дней назад

    He just got meaner now that he is The Hound. Ray will be missed.

  • @ddwalker3744
    @ddwalker3744 14 дней назад +1

    I love Ahsoka ❤️

  • @jordanwhite352
    @jordanwhite352 14 дней назад +1

    Also, I rather they use a great actor in recast than using CGI to Zombie them back to life. Looking at you Rogue One and Alien Romulus...

  • @The1Madox
    @The1Madox 14 дней назад

    What if baylen is trying to get to the world between worlds to save the Jedi and then releases or is being played by abaloth to trick him into releasing her

  • @richlynch9068
    @richlynch9068 14 дней назад +4

    I'm a little worried about the fandom taking this in some weird directions and trying to rationalize a canonical reason for Baylan being different rather than accepting this whole situation for the tragedy it is

  • @ObiClon
    @ObiClon 14 дней назад +3

    This is the best news I could hear coming out of the Ashoka series for me . What they planned to do with Baylan Skoll was something I was wondering about since I heard Ray Stevenson's passing but now with Rory McCan stepping in I don't need to

  • @robpyoung
    @robpyoung 13 дней назад

    Yarp. It’s an excellent casting decision. I just hope they don’t write the recasting into the script. Everyone should act like he’s always been this way. Not so much as a “Huh. You look different, somehow.”

  • @StephenSepulveda
    @StephenSepulveda 14 дней назад

    They should have used the guy who played garp in one piece live action

  • @witchfynder_finder
    @witchfynder_finder 13 дней назад

    It's obviously a tragedy that Skoll had to be recast, but recasting is the best way to handle it and I like McCann for the role.