Thank you for clarifying all of that. I'm one of those rare lifelong fans (I was 7 in '77!) who absolutely loves TLJ. It feels like pure Star Wars to me, and creates the kind of "Wow! That is so weird!" tone that ESB struck for me in 1980. I also think one of the joys of this universe is that you can come up with your own answers, your own head canon. As a kid all we had were Marvel comics and a handful of books... but we all created new stories in our own homes with Kenner action figures! It was there, through the magic of toys, that we imagined our own explanations for all the mysteries of Star Wars. I appreciate the facts about how other writers have explained things, but in the end the answers are up to each and every fan.
22:09 The reason why the "Holdo Maneuver" isn't used more often and wasnt used before on screen is because it's incredibly easy to dodge. To jump to hyperspace, a ship has to lock in its coordinates and then wait a decent chunk of time before it takes off in a straight line. Ordinarily, a ship's captain could see if an enemy ship was pointed straight at it, revving up its hyperdrive, and simply move slightly to evade its path which was already locked in. The reason why The Supremacy can't move out of The Raddus' path is because they're locked onto the Raddus and following it in autopilot. That's why you hear the captains yelling to deactivate the tracking after they realize The Raddus is headed their direction.
I always found it funny how nobody came to help the resistance in TLJ, but all it took was Lando Calrissian to come out of retirement to rally the whole galaxy against Sidious in episode IX 😅
I would too but I don't trust Disney they would break some lore and create new stupid lore probably. Maybe they would create a good book but I wouldn't think so.
I kinda don't tbh. For something so ancient and significant, they'd have to put an insane amount of effort into it for it to be worth it, and then future content would either have to refer back to it or retcon it. I'd prefer the bulk of the texts remain a mystery
Luke's Jedi Academy is something that I really hope we see more of in the future, perhaps as part of the next animated series, or perhaps a young readers book saga like Jedi Apprentice. That was my one real complaint I'd have regarding the story is that the flashback didn't show more. But otherwise I think Luke's arc nailed it for me. People as they age will live with serious regrets...I know I do. But regret is a part of life. I definitely don't think the film is as bad as a lot of people say, as it still has some of my favorite moments in the saga.
I don’t understand why people questioned logic in Star Wars when Star Wars has never followed real world logic. It’s a sci-fi fantasy franchise with aliens, magic and laser swords and hyperspace. Star Wars has never followed real science.
Yes, people get grumbly as they get older, but I think Sci-Fi itself has also aged into the Sci-side more and more. SW may be one of the few leaning into fantasy more and more, which people either forget its fantasy or expect it to grow more Sci with the times. I for one enjoy the fantasy and hope it never dies for future generations of little nerds.
THANK THE FORCE you answered that Resistence Bomb physics question. I have been trying to explain that to people for 7 years now. It was drivng me bananas. Really disturbed me how people have a totally back-asswards understanding of space, momentum, gravity, etc. I sound like a snob, I know. But it really is taxing on the soul addressing the same misunderstanding over and over again. And half the time they didnt accept the answer. "Nu uh" was essentially the response. 🙄
My head canon is that the Holdo maneuver isn't commonly used due to the consequences of the great hyperspace disaster depicted in Light of the Jedi. The hyperspace shards would do way too much damage to be relied upon, causing immeasurable harm and a temporary closure of hyperspace. And since there's no Jedi to slow the pieces...
if the ST can get a clone wars style series supporting it, the same thing that happened to the PT can happen here. but that does rely on disney not shitting the bed as soon as some loud people on the internet start moaning.
ok, i can't believe i have to explain it but it's seldom used because the cost is quite high; you have to sacrifice your ship & at least one person onboard
It doesn’t matter how much undeserved blowback this movie gets: The Last Jedi will always remain as one of my top 2 favorite Star Wars movies ever made and alongside Andor as the best piece of media in the Disney era of Star Wars.
@@smollgeez9034 If you get a chance to see The Last Jedi in Concert where they play the score live alongside the movie, you get the same goosebumps. :)
@@TrainerNomed they had one for the force awakens near me recently but it was pretty inconvenient. If it was TLJ however I would have moved heaven and earth to be there.
I always thought the Holdo manoeuvre was possible on this occasion because Poe had communicated with Finn onboard of the Supremacy, so they had a coordinate to calculate the exact point to enter lightspeed and time the collision. You saw Poe inputting data before he was stunned by Leia so Holdo just used that
My headcanon is that the Raddus's shields had some unique property to allow that to happen. It would explain how it went through the Supremacy's shield, as well as how it managed to survive up until that point
Luke using the blue lightsaber is also a full circle moment after he threw it away at the start of the film. He is now ready to take up the mantle of the Jedi once more, knowing what it means to the rest of the galaxy.
It’s funny cause now with High republic you could almost say the reason for not weaponizing hyperspace was “huh what if the thing we threw into it came out in multiple pieces and we weren’t able to easily calculate when and where the pieces would exit, potentially damaging all our valuable planets to us “😂
I don’t care, the bombing scene in the last Jedi is one of my favorite scenes in the franchise, it’s a fantasy sci fi world, I don’t need realism to explain dropping bombs in space
I actually think Luke’s cybernetic hand being left behind and falling down could have been very poignant. It would have I think more clearly demonstrated that Luke truly did die. I can imagine that the hand falling down in almost slow motion, rolling across the stone and falling into the sea could have been a very dramatic moment.
My biggest question that was not mentioned is why didn't the first order have several star destroyers hyperspace away from the chase and then hyperspace back to the chase directly in front of the resistance ships. I know why, it would have ended the movie in just a few minutes. I can't have been the only person to think of this.
My personal canon after The Last Jedi is Resistance Reborn and then the events that take place during the Rise of the Resistance ride at the Disney Parks. You come out of that experience feeling so engaged and hopeful, and it felt like a polar opposite to the glum I felt after Rise of Skywalker.
I don't know if this was the reasoning by the filmmakers, but I always took Luke having the blue lightsaber at the end as a way that kind of countered what he did at the beginning of the movie by chucking the lightsaber. It is much more symbolic for him to use the same saber he threw away as his way of showing that he is taking up the call Rey gave him at the end of force awakens.
There’s a lot of things in this movie that I hate, but an equal number of things I love. It’s a very complicated film. I don’t really understand either the unabashed praise or the vitriolic hatred that this movie gets. It’s on the lower end of my Star Wars ranking, but it’s far from a bad movie.
@ probably the prequels, tbh I wasn’t around for them but it does seem that it was more controversial at that time, remember the fandom nearly made an actor end himself for jar jar being in the movie
@@Jedi_Spartan Yes and no. I was around for the prequel movies. The people who were around for the original trilogy did not like them. The big difference is social media influence. They've got a much bigger platform to scream their rage from now. Personally, The Last Jedi is my favorite Star Wars movie of the Disney era.
3:08 "i dont understand why this gets asked so much when it happened in Empire Strikes Back" Really, you dont understand? Its because Star Wars "fans" are so blinded by rage for Disney's content that they hold them to an impossibly high double standard
I think what was lost, with everyone arguing was, the kesson.Yoda was, trying to tell luke .Failure, the greatest teacher is.That is a powerful, lesson anyone needs to learn.
My biggest question about the Rise of Skywalker is; what is wrong with the fandom that they can't just enjoy the movie or anything new for what it is? I loved TROS and find the micro-criticisms fans have overly frustrating and even a little stupid. For example the how did palpatine return was clearly answered throughout the movie but wasn't telegraphed, but was suggested in a way that allowed the audience to understand it.
@@gaznottingham9652 no matter what happened in the final films people would still complain trying to wrap up a 9 film saga is impossible to please everyone. I have my issues with all star wars films but whenever i watch rise of Skywalker i always have fun with it and thats enough for me.
Tbh Tallie as a chatter is just weird, she got a tonne of attention and merchandise before the movie and was even a hero in BF2 yet had the seconds of screen time
My biggest question is what exactly is a “cloaking scan” and why did the First Order never just use is in the first place? I think the line should have been removed and it sounds dumb
2:11 Alternatively why (in universe) do the Resistance Bombers exist the way they do? How did the Resistance expect those ships to get away from the explosion with how slow they were AND how close to the Dreadnought the last one was?
@@Jedi_Spartan You can drop them from any height. They didn't need to be that close to the Dreadnought. Being far away would give it a chance to move, though.
My guess is that these bombers are for ground attacks. First send in the x-wings to take out the defensive weapons, then send in the bomber to obliterate the target. And because the resistance wasn't exactly drowning in ships, this was the only defence they had.
The bombers existed for destroying imperial holdouts late in the GCW (after Endor) so would almost always have support vessels and numbers on their size. Basically the Resistance was using scraps and that was the best option at the time. For the second question, there's no given answer, but it's likely the pilots knew it was a one way trip and weren't planning on escaping (which I see as likely given the tactics and general nature of the rebel/resistance factions in star wars.
Something not a lot of people consider too about the Holdo Maneuver is the fact that it doesn't honestly do as much damage as an object traveling at the speed of light should. The Raddus was the second largest ship in that film and definitely manages to cripple the Star Destroyer, but it's still functional and really only took out a wing on that ship. If we go by this logic, trying a hyperspace ram on the Death Star would prove to be ineffective; the X wings which were practically microscopic compared to the Death Star, they would barely be able to do anything against it. It's not only a waste of resources and money, it just doesn't prove to be that effective.
I can still remember the midnight showing watching the Holdo Maneuver for the first time. The fully packed theater was DEAD SILENT. It's the guitar solo of that movie. It was unexpected, beautiful, and powerful.
Since you quote books and comics a lot what does an author have to do in order for their writings to be cannon and worthy of being quoted as fact in videos like this? I am guessing George Lucas doesn't know half of these "facts", which for whatever reason matters to me.
Star Killer base was essentially an adaptation of that Galaxy Gun from Dark Empire. Also the Great Hyperspace Disaster tangentially was the Holdo maneuver used to hit planets from the High Republic.
The film that lost me to the sequel trilogy. The screening I attended, the audience laughed at the 'Leia Poppins' scene. Never good. Just so many rushed plot points that make no sense unless you read the novelisations and the comics, which is fine for those who do, but leaves the rest of us sitting there baffled. I hope the new films, whenever we get them, do better. At least Disney doesn't seem to be rushing them out any more, so hopefully the scripts will be getting enough time to 'cook' this time.
@@lunakingsley.7247 Sure, Star Wars has a very fast and loose approach to physics, but something about the way that was depicted just made everyone laugh at a moment that should have been many things, but not a moment of mockery.
22:55 There is also canon precedent for weaponizing the hyperdrive as well. In The Clone Wars episode Shadow of the Malevolence, Anakin rams the Malevolence into a planet at lightspeed to destroy it.
My interpretation of the cave scene is that she sees that all that she is made from all the actions she has made. Just her. She doesn't have a family, she is alone, so she is her past her present and her future. And when she tries to see her origin, her parents, it's just her. She made herself. It's a projection of her feeling of not having a family, not having parents and a hint that her parents are not important to how she got where she is.
To be clear, I don’t HATE The Last Jedi, it’s just that Rian Johnson ruined the whole franchise for everybody by ruining people’s expectations in the movie and using WAY too many subverted expectations. If Lucasfilm stuck with their previously expected director, the film’s story would’ve been different, and everybody would’ve LOVED it because it would’ve been written and made better.
ty for clarifying all the misleading hate to the movie(se) they wernt that bad for starwars fans, it shows that fans fear change, witch im one of the lucky few who invite it.
I wish I liked The Last Jedi, but it just seems it tried so hard to throw out everything TFA started and really leave nothing to build on. Also it "resets" what happens to the characters in TFA, so there's no growth between movies: for example at the end of TFA Rey can use the force, at the start of this she can't but can again at the end. Or Finn gets badly injured, but at the start of this he's fine and it's never mentioned again. The actors did the best they could, and it has some great visuals - but the sequels make sense even if you skip this, which isn't how it should be. I don't get most of the hate this movie got, to me it's just a matter of story - and Ryan soo wanting to do his own thing it is completely disconnected from the series it is in. They should've just let him do a standalone SW movie instead.
Thank you for clarifying all of that. I'm one of those rare lifelong fans (I was 7 in '77!) who absolutely loves TLJ. It feels like pure Star Wars to me, and creates the kind of "Wow! That is so weird!" tone that ESB struck for me in 1980. I also think one of the joys of this universe is that you can come up with your own answers, your own head canon. As a kid all we had were Marvel comics and a handful of books... but we all created new stories in our own homes with Kenner action figures! It was there, through the magic of toys, that we imagined our own explanations for all the mysteries of Star Wars. I appreciate the facts about how other writers have explained things, but in the end the answers are up to each and every fan.
22:09 The reason why the "Holdo Maneuver" isn't used more often and wasnt used before on screen is because it's incredibly easy to dodge. To jump to hyperspace, a ship has to lock in its coordinates and then wait a decent chunk of time before it takes off in a straight line. Ordinarily, a ship's captain could see if an enemy ship was pointed straight at it, revving up its hyperdrive, and simply move slightly to evade its path which was already locked in. The reason why The Supremacy can't move out of The Raddus' path is because they're locked onto the Raddus and following it in autopilot. That's why you hear the captains yelling to deactivate the tracking after they realize The Raddus is headed their direction.
I always found it funny how nobody came to help the resistance in TLJ, but all it took was Lando Calrissian to come out of retirement to rally the whole galaxy against Sidious in episode IX 😅
Yea I wish they were able to better incorporate the idea that Luke’s sacrifice was able to inspire people to action and help the resistance in ep IX
Lando is simply Him.
I so want real in-universe releases of the Sacred Jedi texts.
we kinda had that! "the jedi path" neat book with annotations by characters
I would too but I don't trust Disney they would break some lore and create new stupid lore probably. Maybe they would create a good book but I wouldn't think so.
I kinda don't tbh. For something so ancient and significant, they'd have to put an insane amount of effort into it for it to be worth it, and then future content would either have to refer back to it or retcon it. I'd prefer the bulk of the texts remain a mystery
The “light side” Snoke design. Jesus Christ 😅
Luke's Jedi Academy is something that I really hope we see more of in the future, perhaps as part of the next animated series, or perhaps a young readers book saga like Jedi Apprentice. That was my one real complaint I'd have regarding the story is that the flashback didn't show more. But otherwise I think Luke's arc nailed it for me. People as they age will live with serious regrets...I know I do. But regret is a part of life.
I definitely don't think the film is as bad as a lot of people say, as it still has some of my favorite moments in the saga.
I don’t understand why people questioned logic in Star Wars when Star Wars has never followed real world logic. It’s a sci-fi fantasy franchise with aliens, magic and laser swords and hyperspace. Star Wars has never followed real science.
It seems like people lose their suspension of disbelief more and more as they get older.
Yes, people get grumbly as they get older, but I think Sci-Fi itself has also aged into the Sci-side more and more. SW may be one of the few leaning into fantasy more and more, which people either forget its fantasy or expect it to grow more Sci with the times. I for one enjoy the fantasy and hope it never dies for future generations of little nerds.
My favorite Star Wars movie :)
THANK THE FORCE you answered that Resistence Bomb physics question. I have been trying to explain that to people for 7 years now. It was drivng me bananas.
Really disturbed me how people have a totally back-asswards understanding of space, momentum, gravity, etc.
I sound like a snob, I know. But it really is taxing on the soul addressing the same misunderstanding over and over again. And half the time they didnt accept the answer. "Nu uh" was essentially the response. 🙄
0:40 Ah yes, Rian Johnson, famously concerned with how ep 9 was going to play out... 🙃
My head canon is that the Holdo maneuver isn't commonly used due to the consequences of the great hyperspace disaster depicted in Light of the Jedi. The hyperspace shards would do way too much damage to be relied upon, causing immeasurable harm and a temporary closure of hyperspace. And since there's no Jedi to slow the pieces...
@@slimdiddyj5969 Do love me some High Republic.
That's a great point, would love a side Holdo maneuver holdover unintended consequence smaller disaster type story
After time I have come to appreciate the last Jedi more. that is just me of course
And Im sure many others. The cycle of Star Wars hatred then acceptance for everything continues in perpetuity.
if the ST can get a clone wars style series supporting it, the same thing that happened to the PT can happen here. but that does rely on disney not shitting the bed as soon as some loud people on the internet start moaning.
ok, i can't believe i have to explain it but it's seldom used because the cost is quite high; you have to sacrifice your ship & at least one person onboard
People aren't smart enough to figure out something so basic. I mean, someone complained about bricks in Star Wars.
It doesn’t matter how much undeserved blowback this movie gets: The Last Jedi will always remain as one of my top 2 favorite Star Wars movies ever made and alongside Andor as the best piece of media in the Disney era of Star Wars.
Take me back to 2017 getting to watch this on the big screen was so special.
@@smollgeez9034 If you get a chance to see The Last Jedi in Concert where they play the score live alongside the movie, you get the same goosebumps. :)
Clone Wars season 7: :/
I agree 💯👍🏾 this is my favorite of the sequels fs
@@TrainerNomed they had one for the force awakens near me recently but it was pretty inconvenient. If it was TLJ however I would have moved heaven and earth to be there.
As much as TLJ has its flaws, I think it's at least as good as the Prequels.
I always thought the Holdo manoeuvre was possible on this occasion because Poe had communicated with Finn onboard of the Supremacy, so they had a coordinate to calculate the exact point to enter lightspeed and time the collision. You saw Poe inputting data before he was stunned by Leia so Holdo just used that
My headcanon is that the Raddus's shields had some unique property to allow that to happen. It would explain how it went through the Supremacy's shield, as well as how it managed to survive up until that point
25:48 this was also covered in the novel resistance reborn and serves as one of three-ish main plots
There are so many details here I didn’t know about, this is awesome! Thanks Alex!
I'm so glad your still doing these videos for the sequel movies, they remind me of going to the cinema with my grandad
Just read Bloodlines and had no idea Ben solo wrote the napkin note to Leia, that’s super cool to find out!
Luke using the blue lightsaber is also a full circle moment after he threw it away at the start of the film. He is now ready to take up the mantle of the Jedi once more, knowing what it means to the rest of the galaxy.
Well actually surviving for up to 2 minutes in space is possible, and that’s around the time that Leia was in space for
It’s funny cause now with High republic you could almost say the reason for not weaponizing hyperspace was “huh what if the thing we threw into it came out in multiple pieces and we weren’t able to easily calculate when and where the pieces would exit, potentially damaging all our valuable planets to us “😂
My favorite movie. I've been watching the movie January first each year. This will be the third.
My favourite Star Wars movie.
Mine too!
I don’t care, the bombing scene in the last Jedi is one of my favorite scenes in the franchise, it’s a fantasy sci fi world, I don’t need realism to explain dropping bombs in space
I actually think Luke’s cybernetic hand being left behind and falling down could have been very poignant. It would have I think more clearly demonstrated that Luke truly did die. I can imagine that the hand falling down in almost slow motion, rolling across the stone and falling into the sea could have been a very dramatic moment.
Great video. The Last Jedi is my favorite of the sequel trilogy.
BEST STAR WARS MOVIE SINCE STAR WARS AND EMPIRE
I WILL DIE ON THIS HILL
No lies detected.
I love this movie always have always will. These FAQ videos are awesome hope you can do the shows at some point as well.
My biggest question that was not mentioned is why didn't the first order have several star destroyers hyperspace away from the chase and then hyperspace back to the chase directly in front of the resistance ships. I know why, it would have ended the movie in just a few minutes. I can't have been the only person to think of this.
These are fun. Hope we get the series
I love Last Jedi. The hate it gets is ludicrous. So wish we could have gotten part 9 under Rian's direction.
My personal canon after The Last Jedi is Resistance Reborn and then the events that take place during the Rise of the Resistance ride at the Disney Parks. You come out of that experience feeling so engaged and hopeful, and it felt like a polar opposite to the glum I felt after Rise of Skywalker.
Or directed by Colin Trevorrow as they originally planned
I want to mention that while making Glass Onion Rian mentioned not knowing Jess Pava survived TFA
Thankfully, I don't think Porgs can be considered an invasive species!
I don't know if this was the reasoning by the filmmakers, but I always took Luke having the blue lightsaber at the end as a way that kind of countered what he did at the beginning of the movie by chucking the lightsaber. It is much more symbolic for him to use the same saber he threw away as his way of showing that he is taking up the call Rey gave him at the end of force awakens.
There’s a lot of things in this movie that I hate, but an equal number of things I love. It’s a very complicated film. I don’t really understand either the unabashed praise or the vitriolic hatred that this movie gets. It’s on the lower end of my Star Wars ranking, but it’s far from a bad movie.
Most overhated Star Wars project
I wasn't around for the Prequel release but has ANY Star Wars film divided the fanbase more than The Last Jedi?
@ probably the prequels, tbh I wasn’t around for them but it does seem that it was more controversial at that time, remember the fandom nearly made an actor end himself for jar jar being in the movie
@@Jedi_Spartan Yes and no. I was around for the prequel movies. The people who were around for the original trilogy did not like them. The big difference is social media influence. They've got a much bigger platform to scream their rage from now. Personally, The Last Jedi is my favorite Star Wars movie of the Disney era.
3:08 "i dont understand why this gets asked so much when it happened in Empire Strikes Back"
Really, you dont understand? Its because Star Wars "fans" are so blinded by rage for Disney's content that they hold them to an impossibly high double standard
My fav videos
I knew this was coming today lol
I think what was lost, with everyone arguing was, the kesson.Yoda was, trying to tell luke .Failure, the greatest teacher is.That is a powerful, lesson anyone needs to learn.
My biggest question about the Rise of Skywalker is; what is wrong with the fandom that they can't just enjoy the movie or anything new for what it is?
I loved TROS and find the micro-criticisms fans have overly frustrating and even a little stupid.
For example the how did palpatine return was clearly answered throughout the movie but wasn't telegraphed, but was suggested in a way that allowed the audience to understand it.
@@gaznottingham9652 no matter what happened in the final films people would still complain trying to wrap up a 9 film saga is impossible to please everyone. I have my issues with all star wars films but whenever i watch rise of Skywalker i always have fun with it and thats enough for me.
Question for Biggest Questions Answered Star Wars The Rise of Skywalker: Did Kix participate in that battle?
Tbh Tallie as a chatter is just weird, she got a tonne of attention and merchandise before the movie and was even a hero in BF2 yet had the seconds of screen time
I love the last Jedi was one my favorite film it sad this film let to Star Wars fandom be divided
My biggest question is what exactly is a “cloaking scan” and why did the First Order never just use is in the first place? I think the line should have been removed and it sounds dumb
So is the probability infinite? 🤪
2:11 Alternatively why (in universe) do the Resistance Bombers exist the way they do? How did the Resistance expect those ships to get away from the explosion with how slow they were AND how close to the Dreadnought the last one was?
@@Jedi_Spartan You can drop them from any height. They didn't need to be that close to the Dreadnought. Being far away would give it a chance to move, though.
My guess is that these bombers are for ground attacks. First send in the x-wings to take out the defensive weapons, then send in the bomber to obliterate the target. And because the resistance wasn't exactly drowning in ships, this was the only defence they had.
The bombers existed for destroying imperial holdouts late in the GCW (after Endor) so would almost always have support vessels and numbers on their size. Basically the Resistance was using scraps and that was the best option at the time.
For the second question, there's no given answer, but it's likely the pilots knew it was a one way trip and weren't planning on escaping (which I see as likely given the tactics and general nature of the rebel/resistance factions in star wars.
@@floppiethethirth You are pretty much spot on there xd
wait, so there were only four students at his academy?
Answer to all these questions: Because Rian Johnson and JJ Abrams did not collaborate at all between films 🤷🏾♀️
What happened to Kylo Rens tie silencer?
Something not a lot of people consider too about the Holdo Maneuver is the fact that it doesn't honestly do as much damage as an object traveling at the speed of light should. The Raddus was the second largest ship in that film and definitely manages to cripple the Star Destroyer, but it's still functional and really only took out a wing on that ship. If we go by this logic, trying a hyperspace ram on the Death Star would prove to be ineffective; the X wings which were practically microscopic compared to the Death Star, they would barely be able to do anything against it. It's not only a waste of resources and money, it just doesn't prove to be that effective.
3:45 Ah yes, the final Jedi rite of destroying the entire order...
That's what makes it 'final'.
I can still remember the midnight showing watching the Holdo Maneuver for the first time. The fully packed theater was DEAD SILENT. It's the guitar solo of that movie. It was unexpected, beautiful, and powerful.
Was Popeye a Jedi?
My favorite star wars movie
Since you quote books and comics a lot what does an author have to do in order for their writings to be cannon and worthy of being quoted as fact in videos like this? I am guessing George Lucas doesn't know half of these "facts", which for whatever reason matters to me.
Star Killer base was essentially an adaptation of that Galaxy Gun from Dark Empire. Also the Great Hyperspace Disaster tangentially was the Holdo maneuver used to hit planets from the High Republic.
The film that lost me to the sequel trilogy. The screening I attended, the audience laughed at the 'Leia Poppins' scene. Never good. Just so many rushed plot points that make no sense unless you read the novelisations and the comics, which is fine for those who do, but leaves the rest of us sitting there baffled. I hope the new films, whenever we get them, do better. At least Disney doesn't seem to be rushing them out any more, so hopefully the scripts will be getting enough time to 'cook' this time.
The Leia poppins moment has happened in multiple Star Wars stories since the 70s.
@@lunakingsley.7247 Sure, Star Wars has a very fast and loose approach to physics, but something about the way that was depicted just made everyone laugh at a moment that should have been many things, but not a moment of mockery.
“Why is this movie so terrible?”
22:55 There is also canon precedent for weaponizing the hyperdrive as well. In The Clone Wars episode Shadow of the Malevolence, Anakin rams the Malevolence into a planet at lightspeed to destroy it.
That planet didn't have shields though
Still my favorite Star Wars movie!
Chewbacca, Porg Slayer, nightmare to all porgs on Ahch-to.
My interpretation of the cave scene is that she sees that all that she is made from all the actions she has made. Just her. She doesn't have a family, she is alone, so she is her past her present and her future. And when she tries to see her origin, her parents, it's just her. She made herself.
It's a projection of her feeling of not having a family, not having parents and a hint that her parents are not important to how she got where she is.
To be clear, I don’t HATE The Last Jedi, it’s just that Rian Johnson ruined the whole franchise for everybody by ruining people’s expectations in the movie and using WAY too many subverted expectations. If Lucasfilm stuck with their previously expected director, the film’s story would’ve been different, and everybody would’ve LOVED it because it would’ve been written and made better.
Most surprising thing is that Hondo is still alive. Dude is like a cockroach.
“How does Rey know how to swim” so there’s this thing called the Mammalian Dive Reflex…
Also where are my Holdo/Leia shippers at?
Tell don’t show the movie
Most of these questions were about things that were shown.
@@rody73 not really but go off king
This movie gets better every time I see it… compare to the other Disney movies which don’t necessarily get better with each watch.
ty for clarifying all the misleading hate to the movie(se) they wernt that bad for starwars fans, it shows that fans fear change, witch im one of the lucky few who invite it.
I wish I liked The Last Jedi, but it just seems it tried so hard to throw out everything TFA started and really leave nothing to build on. Also it "resets" what happens to the characters in TFA, so there's no growth between movies: for example at the end of TFA Rey can use the force, at the start of this she can't but can again at the end. Or Finn gets badly injured, but at the start of this he's fine and it's never mentioned again. The actors did the best they could, and it has some great visuals - but the sequels make sense even if you skip this, which isn't how it should be. I don't get most of the hate this movie got, to me it's just a matter of story - and Ryan soo wanting to do his own thing it is completely disconnected from the series it is in. They should've just let him do a standalone SW movie instead.
It really doesn’t throw out anything at all though does it, thats a very (common) thin criticism.
The changes were jarring but I felt they coulda been accepted...if not for the following movie.
The Crap Jedi. There I fixed the title for you.
You thought 😂
Wow you really got him there!
Room temperature iq
Omg he’s so funny!!! You’re so funny bro!!!