Quale dei due (Aikido e WC) ti piace di più ? Perché ? Quale dei 2 ti sembra più efficace per la difesa personale ? Perché ? Quale dei 2 presenta la maggior frequenza di infortuni alle articolazioni per chi lo pratica ? Ritieni che ambedue siano praticabili dopo i 60 anni (perdita di elasticità, articolazioni arrugginite, protrusioni discali) ? Grazie se vorrai rispondere.
A real battle with somebody who is good at wing tsun would likely end with the wing tsun guy destroying the attacker. A real battle with somebody who is good at Aikido would likely end with both sitting at a bar drinking a beer together.
Ottima preparazione dei maestri. Tecniche precise e un video piacevole da vedere. Inutile lasciare commenti per cui un'arte doveva vincere perché è migliore. Non è la tecnica che decide ma l'atleta.
Yes, this was the first compact and we are trying to improve, fighting established between various martial arts are not easy! And in any case it's a friends game and not a technical virtuosity of disciplines! Thank you, ciao
Both wingchun and aikido are very effective styles, and yes, maybe a real battle would look differently, but you can clearly see that it was a setup. And a very successful one, I would say..:)
Ciao, Il video è un gioco tra Maestri di diverse arti marziali appartenenti alla stessa palestra. La parte più difficile è unire capacità così diverse e forse la cosa piu bella è stata conoscerci combattendo (anche se per gioco). la coreografia si base su una base combinata e il resto improvvisazione. il montaggio è amatoriale...come tutto il resto. NON ha lo scopo di dimostrare tecniche particolari ma solo di confrontarsi tra amici. grazie per i vostri commenti Oneghesimasu
Una de las mejores cosas de este video es como está editado :-). Me pregunto si tenían planeada la coreografía o es algo que salió de forma espontanea.
Andrew Owl Only people who don't practice martial arts (or haven't practiced it for a long time) say and think a martial art to be better than another…
Actually, Judo is much more a Combat Sport than a martial art. Nevertheless, it's the fighter who makes the difference, not the way he's practicing. One can practice "the best martial art ever" and be defeated by an opponent who trained himself to the bones.
First things first: I definitely don't think on martial art to be better than another in an absolute way. It depends on how your body's shaped and mainly on how confident you are with the moves the chosen martial art teaches you. BUT, there's one thing that really made me laugh in this video: I've been practicing Wing Chun for over 15 years and THIS IS DEFINITELY NOT Wing Chun. Neither the stance, nor the steps, nor the freaky jumps you see on this video are Wing Chun. Oh yeah you'll say it's inspired by the Tekken character Marshall Law, who was inspired from Bruce Lee. Let's set things clear once and for all: Bruce Lee learned Wing Chun from great master Yip Man during about for years. When he left Hong Kong he only did know very few about how Wing Chun works and didn't find it effective. He developed his own martial art, known as Jeet Kune Do (way of intercepting fist), in order to overcome his lacks.Off course, his Jeet Kune Do was strongly inspired by Wing Chun, but that's it. Furthermore, what you see in Bruce Lee's films isn't real Jeet Kune Do. It's an adapted form of his martial art to fit on screen in a film. So, now all this being said, where's the Wing Chun in this video? Elbows centered on the middle line, no high kicks, no jumps, no spectacular nor useless moves, tell me: do you see anything of what I've listed in this video? In the end, I'll also tell: I've got a friend practicing Aïkido and I'm sure she'll laugh out loud if I show her this (just like I did). By the way, if you ask yourselves what Wing Chun means, it means eternal spring or beautiful spring. It used to be the Wing Chun creator's daughter's name: Yim Wing Chun.
who said wing chun didn't have high kicks and Bruce Lee trained mostly off Willem cheung and thats how the traditional wing chun martial artists thought watch ip man 3 he developed high kicks in wing chung from ip chun in the film watch it ud understand wing chun more
I can't find the meaning of aikido and wing chun in this video. This is just better than fake street fight. Please make respect for aikido and wing chun. May be you guys know martial art and street fight techniques, but you should not use the name of aikido and wing chun. You guys are just playing on the grasses. Thank you. My writings may be rude but I respect martial artist and martial art. So I write this. If I am rude ,I apologize.
If a man came out trying to attack me in a white Gi dress I would put my hands up and directly in front of me, bend my back leg some and angle my front leg straight in front of me too! It's such a natural position for Martial Arts. That's why Bruce Lee took that horrid stance out of his curriculum.
There is no correct translation from the Chinese to romanian Letters, so yeah, i know it. Most WT schools spell it in some different way, in mine it is Wyng Tsun, some spell it wing chun.... Just look at the Video-Title, it is also spelled differently to mine and differently to yours...
+Luca Scanzioli ...forse si...ma era solo un gioco per noi e non ho troppo curato l aspetto NERD ;-) tra l altro era per la nostra zona...con un milione di visualizzazioni tra tutti credo che tra poco li elimino perché da uno scherzo si sta trasformando troppo in una roba seria ahahaha
Even if this was real, I think aikido would still win. That may just be because I do it myself. That being said, every martial art has it's strengths and weaknesses. Good video, if a bit cheesy.
that's not wing chun, the weapon of wing chun is butterfly knives and i don't see any arts of wing chun in that fight and the aikido performer, that is not aikido, because i don't see aikido technique in that fight also.
ottimo video, ma non ci hai azzeccato con le tecniche dei combattenti tekken.. Paul Phoenix è un kick boxer Marshall Law è un combattente Jeet Kune Do (l'arte marziale fondata da Bruce Lee). Good Video, but I disagree with the Tekken Fighter matching style: Paul Phoenix is a Kick Boxer Marshall Law is a Jeet Kune Do fighter (the martial art founded by Bruce Lee)
does it make you sad that everyone is trying to judge everything as being fake or not? As if every video that exists is entered into some phantom hardcore youtube competition? It makes me want to forsake my practice and smack some people, though I would never do it.
Ah, entonces se durmio un poco. Porque cuando quedó a brazo pelado no metió ni un golpe. Yo practiqué Aikido de Aikikai varios años y entiendo la actitud de espera del aikidoka ante el winchun-man.
so stupid...a Wing Chun fighter does not do arm break and leg locks like in Jujitsu and flying punches like in Muy Thai. First off, no one would be stupid enough to let themselves get hit by Wing Chun close combat punches, and Aikido is about balance and bringing the opponent off balance by dodging their hits and using their force not standing in front and getting smacked.
Kuma kun Why do you think that wing chun does not use breaks or kick or what ever. That is just bullshit. Wing chun show no mercy, just efficiency. Only idiots thinks it is all about straight punch.
If this guy practices aikido, so i am the pope ! MWAAHAHAHAHAHA !!! a real aikido practising will kick the ass of bruce lee, Noris and van damme at same time !
? hehe yo practique wing tsun, y es un buen estilo, el del video no efectua buen wing tsun y el de aikido que es un estilo que respeto mucho y me agrada, tampoco note que efectuara realmente el potencial del estilo.
![Excellent Aikido Demonstration Ueshiba Moriteru Doshu - 植芝守央道主 - 合気道 - [HD]](/img/1.gif)
i like how they both show the art's different unique style in armed, disarming, and hand-to-hand combat.
grazie mille, SI...avere la fortuna di conoscere tanti maestri di diverse discipline è sicuramente un buon modo di crescere.
mi piace ho praticato aikido per anni (5) adesso wing chun e anche escrima kali , avete fatto un bel lavoro :)
Quale dei due (Aikido e WC) ti piace di più ? Perché ? Quale dei 2 ti sembra più efficace per la difesa personale ? Perché ? Quale dei 2 presenta la maggior frequenza di infortuni alle articolazioni per chi lo pratica ? Ritieni che ambedue siano praticabili dopo i 60 anni (perdita di elasticità, articolazioni arrugginite, protrusioni discali) ? Grazie se vorrai rispondere.
A real battle with somebody who is good at wing tsun would likely end with the wing tsun guy destroying the attacker. A real battle with somebody who is good at Aikido would likely end with both sitting at a bar drinking a beer together.
Ottima preparazione dei maestri. Tecniche precise e un video piacevole da vedere. Inutile lasciare commenti per cui un'arte doveva vincere perché è migliore. Non è la tecnica che decide ma l'atleta.
Přesně tak 👍 moje řeč.
Yes, but this is only a movie among friends without claiming to be a technical tutorial! Thank you for your comment.
Yes, this was the first compact and we are trying to improve, fighting established between various martial arts are not easy! And in any case it's a friends game and not a technical virtuosity of disciplines! Thank you, ciao
Both wingchun and aikido are very effective styles, and yes, maybe a real battle would look differently, but you can clearly see that it was a setup. And a very successful one, I would say..:)
Ciao, Il video è un gioco tra Maestri di diverse arti marziali appartenenti alla stessa palestra. La parte più difficile è unire capacità così diverse e forse la cosa piu bella è stata conoscerci combattendo (anche se per gioco). la coreografia si base su una base combinata e il resto improvvisazione. il montaggio è amatoriale...come tutto il resto. NON ha lo scopo di dimostrare tecniche particolari ma solo di confrontarsi tra amici. grazie per i vostri commenti
Oneghesimasu
An aikidokan never attacks.
Un aikidoka nunca ataca, es absurdo este video, realmente.
Una de las mejores cosas de este video es como está editado :-). Me pregunto si tenían planeada la coreografía o es algo que salió de forma espontanea.
How is it wing tsun when it seems more like its aikido vs eskrima in the beginning pictures and first few seconds of the fight scene?
All the martial arts are useful and serve to improve ourselves ... all practiced for decades lead to self-defense and to satisfaction!
There is no "vs" in this video. This is a cooperative demonstration.
with any martial arts its not so much which is best but a question of who applies the techniques with power and efficiency
Aikido is the best
Damn right!!
Andrew Owl Only people who don't practice martial arts (or haven't practiced it for a long time) say and think a martial art to be better than another…
Not quite. I'm pretty sure kung fu's better than judo...
Actually, Judo is much more a Combat Sport than a martial art. Nevertheless, it's the fighter who makes the difference, not the way he's practicing. One can practice "the best martial art ever" and be defeated by an opponent who trained himself to the bones.
aikido? bullshito
Este vídeo de que es, de donde se sacó por que parece que es algo haci como un torneo
Combattimento o visualizzazione?
First things first: I definitely don't think on martial art to be better than another in an absolute way. It depends on how your body's shaped and mainly on how confident you are with the moves the chosen martial art teaches you.
BUT, there's one thing that really made me laugh in this video:
I've been practicing Wing Chun for over 15 years and THIS IS DEFINITELY NOT Wing Chun. Neither the stance, nor the steps, nor the freaky jumps you see on this video are Wing Chun. Oh yeah you'll say it's inspired by the Tekken character Marshall Law, who was inspired from Bruce Lee.
Let's set things clear once and for all: Bruce Lee learned Wing Chun from great master Yip Man during about for years. When he left Hong Kong he only did know very few about how Wing Chun works and didn't find it effective. He developed his own martial art, known as Jeet Kune Do (way of intercepting fist), in order to overcome his lacks.Off course, his Jeet Kune Do was strongly inspired by Wing Chun, but that's it. Furthermore, what you see in Bruce Lee's films isn't real Jeet Kune Do. It's an adapted form of his martial art to fit on screen in a film.
So, now all this being said, where's the Wing Chun in this video? Elbows centered on the middle line, no high kicks, no jumps, no spectacular nor useless moves, tell me: do you see anything of what I've listed in this video?
In the end, I'll also tell: I've got a friend practicing Aïkido and I'm sure she'll laugh out loud if I show her this (just like I did).
By the way, if you ask yourselves what Wing Chun means, it means eternal spring or beautiful spring. It used to be the Wing Chun creator's daughter's name: Yim Wing Chun.
who said wing chun didn't have high kicks and Bruce Lee trained mostly off Willem cheung and thats how the traditional wing chun martial artists thought watch ip man 3 he developed high kicks in wing chung from ip chun in the film watch it ud understand wing chun more
+Ehsan jabar wing Chun never had high kicks, you watch to much movies
@@ehsanjabar6904 Bruce Lee had high kicks from karate, not from wing chun.
No perfect Aikido techniques, but still a very nice show ;)
I can't find the meaning of aikido and wing chun in this video. This is just better than fake street fight. Please make respect for aikido and wing chun. May be you guys know martial art and street fight techniques, but you should not use the name of aikido and wing chun. You guys are just playing on the grasses. Thank you. My writings may be rude but I respect martial artist and martial art. So I write this. If I am rude ,I apologize.
If a man came out trying to attack me in a white Gi dress I would put my hands up and directly in front of me, bend my back leg some and angle my front leg straight in front of me too! It's such a natural position for Martial Arts. That's why Bruce Lee took that horrid stance out of his curriculum.
choreographed!
Choreographed....all fake.
Wow...you are a genius!
How could you see that it is choreographed?
I thought it was a real life and death fight...
Shan Rafnezden What is the point of your comment?
No to show sarcasm to someone who deserves it!
You are the Moron!
Shan Rafnezden Ya....ok pal.
And by the way boy, if you want to have an intelligent discussion With me come on, bring it on lets see who's the moron.
This is neither Wyng Tjun nor Aikido, this is total crrap...
Dude.......the guy in the Hakama does aikido
Well, the other guy does not do WT
Yea that is true..i think he does kali,eskrima
But do you do wing chun since you sure don't know how to spell it! XD
There is no correct translation from the Chinese to romanian Letters, so yeah, i know it. Most WT schools spell it in some different way, in mine it is Wyng Tsun, some spell it wing chun....
Just look at the Video-Title, it is also spelled differently to mine and differently to yours...
non capisco il collegamento tra paul e l'aikido... non era più logico scegliere wang?
+Luca Scanzioli ...forse si...ma era solo un gioco per noi e non ho troppo curato l aspetto NERD ;-) tra l altro era per la nostra zona...con un milione di visualizzazioni tra tutti credo che tra poco li elimino perché da uno scherzo si sta trasformando troppo in una roba seria ahahaha
Many closed minded critics but nice vid.
el aikido nunca le gana al win chung demasiada paz
mauricio funes el aikido demasiada pz ? eso es respeto si queria ya le uviese partido el brazo en 3
que hacen que no estan en UFC o algo por el estilo?
Even if this was real, I think aikido would still win. That may just be because I do it myself. That being said, every martial art has it's strengths and weaknesses. Good video, if a bit cheesy.
I bet on wing chun. At least ithas strikes and kicks.
not realistic but fun....nicely done..!
Very Cool!!!...
Secondo me queste 2 tecniche combinate anche con il muay thay sarebbero micidiali
Music Please? ^_^
that's not wing chun, the weapon of wing chun is butterfly knives and i don't see any arts of wing chun in that fight and the aikido performer, that is not aikido, because i don't see aikido technique in that fight also.
Not my style of AIK'ido…… he was sloppy!!!!!!! kinda embarrassing....
What is black? It is kung fu but something has not passed to it right I think it is kung fu combat
I don't know what wintsun is, but it's definitely not Wing Tsun. :D
どちらの武術も武器の使い方から生まれた武術だっけ？
Of course it's choreographed. What do you expect?? Head rolling on the pavement?? Unless it's tournament then it is a different story
Les arts martiaux c’est la vie
This is not wing chun, I practice this style and know!
"ACADEMIA WING CHUN KUEN PINHEIRO"
They both are wing tsun Fighter ... Only one have aikidio cloths
haha i dont think spinning kicks/tornado kicks are used in wing tsun
ottimo video, ma non ci hai azzeccato con le tecniche dei combattenti tekken..
Paul Phoenix è un kick boxer
Marshall Law è un combattente Jeet Kune Do (l'arte marziale fondata da Bruce Lee).
Good Video, but I disagree with the Tekken Fighter matching style:
Paul Phoenix is a Kick Boxer
Marshall Law is a Jeet Kune Do fighter (the martial art founded by Bruce Lee)
does it make you sad that everyone is trying to judge everything as being fake or not? As if every video that exists is entered into some phantom hardcore youtube competition? It makes me want to forsake my practice and smack some people, though I would never do it.
A mi si me pagaran, tmb me dejo vencer por el de WINTSUN
Si jaja! A veces estos vídeos están hechos para favorecer a uno y mostrar que es mejor esa arte marcial que la otra! Muy pocos son reales
*Modern Wing Chun vs Aikido i suppose
Ah, entonces se durmio un poco. Porque cuando quedó a brazo pelado no metió ni un golpe. Yo practiqué Aikido de Aikikai varios años y entiendo la actitud de espera del aikidoka ante el winchun-man.
certainly fun to watch - but the music kills me :D
el estilo del aikidoka es el keiten ryu o iwama ryu , ese estilo si se le permite golpear..
your comment ?
Goodah nice
so stupid...a Wing Chun fighter does not do arm break and leg locks like in Jujitsu and flying punches like in Muy Thai. First off, no one would be stupid enough to let themselves get hit by Wing Chun close combat punches, and Aikido is about balance and bringing the opponent off balance by dodging their hits and using their force not standing in front and getting smacked.
Kuma kun Why do you think that wing chun does not use breaks or kick or what ever. That is just bullshit. Wing chun show no mercy, just efficiency. Only idiots thinks it is all about straight punch.
El pobre Aikidoka quedo en el piso. Un detalle a tener en cuenta con respecto al aikidoka es que este no suele atacar.
……… both of them skilled fighters …
Y donde esta el wing chun???????
Oo
If this guy practices aikido, so i am the pope ! MWAAHAHAHAHAHA !!!
a real aikido practising will kick the ass of bruce lee, Noris and van damme at same time !
Depends on wich form of aikido, traditional aikido might not yet perhaps it will. Also the most skilled practioner will win no matter wich art
and thats steven seagal lord of aikido
No mamen con un cote bien hecho adios muñeca y el otro jamas se vuelve a parar........
You really think that it's fake detective? ..
whats with the stick
CAN I GET A LITTLE MORE COWBELL
Aikido Good Sport but Wing Chun fucking amazing
good kati.
Lol, in real akido we wait for someone to attack us, and it would be way different, also, it's bad luck to act like your a tuff ass in akido.
? hehe yo practique wing tsun, y es un buen estilo, el del video no efectua buen wing tsun y el de aikido que es un estilo que respeto mucho y me agrada, tampoco note que efectuara realmente el potencial del estilo.
isso não é wing tsum sou graduado neste estilo que não ataca desta forma ...
IN TEKKEN ASUKA KAZAMA PRACTIQUE AIKIDO, AND LILI ROCHEFORT PRACTIQUE WIN CHUN! :D
hmm,. Paul phoenix? I'd prefer Jun kazama
Der Aikidoka hat eine schlechte Technik. Er macht keinen Abschlußhebel. Warum??
non è wing tsun...non esistono calci volanti!!
Good job - great athletic skill.
its not wing chun its what u called street fight !! LOL !
paul es judo no aikido- los kazama son los que practican aikido
This is not wing chun
TWO GAYS PERFORMANCE PICK UP EACH OTHER.... GET A ROOM FOR YA
AverGe thai boxer would flop himeself to death before any of them had to do anything
Terrible - no strategy on either side. I do like the parallel universe stuff
stop posting choreos and start posting real fights
i want realness and you support choreo shit so YOU are the fool
jamas en la vida
nice promo!like the video,you ned a good master for best results
es lo mas boludo que vi hasta ahora
Una vergüenza, para el wing chun y para el juego también
lol....nonsense...… nice dancing though...
video ingannatorio
In this thread....fucking MORONS!
law de teken sabe jkd (jeet kune do)
two very master high level!
average thai boxer would destroy both
Ahahah, but he won using BJJ
Wing chun
No
ridicolo...è dire poco.. cmq se questi sono i maestri..allora meglio lo ZUMBA
The man in black is a clown...the aikido man is not so much better
con tekken poi.... non si puo guardare
FX are cool. But still bs.
An aikido master is much better than this
Aikido is beter
muy malo . así
no es el aikido
Una vergüenza el aikidoca una verguenza ahi mejores...
queste aikidoka es uno molto stupido. uno falshe justo como la mia lingua italiana.