I think this is up in the top 3 worst cases from Milian, Where she spoke over the litigants assuming she knew what the whole case was without letting either speak or present evidence. It was hard to watch
Agree I'd like to have heard why the defendant thought he was able to charge the prices he did. Did he maybe have a more updated document with the current charges?
She allowed the plaintiff to present his case but not the defendant. He’s 100% correct. He should have been allowed to present his rebuttal. That’s what court is for.
@froglog1002 right. I'm not getting how people can be this dense. The only reason the defendant got to talk as long as he did was bc she needed facial evidence from him.
Hes was a federal attorney and then a judge in Miami! He's in charge all day! I think he loves coming home to a place he doesn't have to be in charge of. And I agree, he seems to LOVE her more than life!
Just starting the video but putting my money down that Harvey asks - "In general, are tow companies sleezy?" (or something to that effect) - going to see if I am right!
It bothers me when people take time to come to court to be heard and the judge over talks the parties so much that neither party is able to fully present their main points. It was very dismissive!!
She told him that he going to lose the case in the beginning because there no legal ground for his law suit she just decided to be nice and listen. In real life the case would get thrown out and you won't even be able to see a judge.
I’ve been driving a tow truck in a large college town and tow around 1000 cars a year for parking where they aren’t supposed to be. People constantly assume I have a spotter, I’m watching them, or paying off a property owner when I honestly do not do that. The property owners make money by charging for parking on their property to residents and other people. I make money by towing the cars. People park in the lots all the time I can literally drive by every 15 minutes and find a car that’s not supposed to be there. Every lot I tow from has posted signs and cars that are allowed to be there have permits. The really busy lots I know exactly what cars go there and what don’t because I memorize the cars since I see them multiple times a day everyday of the year. Towing laws vary state to state but here in Michigan there just has to be a sign posted at each entrance. Property owners have every right to have cars towed and most of the lots I tow from are on a patrol basis. People call me a POS and many other names and accuse me of so many things but they can do whatever they want. If I didn’t do my job these parking lots would be a mess. People pay $250 or more a month for their spots and they want them open and every spot gets sold out. If people want to call tow companies scammers or think I’m a POS that’s fine. If people want to dispute it they can take it to small claims court. I do my job so throughly and take such good photos documenting everything the company has never once given back a dollar in court for anything I’ve towed. I also do plenty of other stuff like roadside assistance and will save you off the side of the highway in the middle of a snowstorm or change your tire and get you on your way. People either hate me or love me depending on the situation. I get a lot of satisfaction out of my job and try to be as professional as possible. 99% of the people on this earth wouldn’t last more than a week doing this job and I see it all the time with the turnover rate. It’s also one of the most dangerous jobs out there. On average at least one driver gets hit and killed every week on the side of the highway trying to help someone. I lost a coworker in 2018 who was hit and killed by a drunk driver while he was doing his job. He left behind his wife and 2 young children. Please just take responsibility for your actions when you park and don’t be surprised when your car gets towed out of a private parking lot. It’s no one’s fault but your own. At the end of the day I make extremely good money and support my family which is all that matters to me so if you want to look down on me or other tow truck drivers that’s fine. Just remember our services aren’t free and new tow trucks cost at least 150-200 grand and that doesn’t include crazy high insurance and other overhead costs. Please try to understand we are just doing a job and we risk our lives everyday while doing it.
The judge is probably upset that the plaintiff did his homework and the plaintiff had more but the judge immediately closed the case 😂and walked out not letting anybody to talk
Winch charge. Thats loading the car. Thats part of the tow. If he had a wrecker it would be wheel lifted. Hate greedy tow guys,in Florida its $500 hook up $5 mile n thats police tow,so every company in the area is charhing. Thats crazy for a tow.
Plaintiff is the worst. Half a brain trying to work the system cause of a typo. If I misspelled the words "private property - no parrrwking" on a sign on my lawn, in his world, he can come park of my lawn.
I wonder how many people they rip off who either don't know they law or who can't fight them to get it back. I guarantee the tow company knows they're capped they just don't care
What a lot of people don’t know is that the judge is familiar with the street codes and regulations on every state before the case happens. It’s the reason why she doesn’t need to hear a lot from the plaintiff and defendant
THE PLAINTIFF SHOULD BE ASHAMED OF HIMSELF. HE'S TO OLD TO BE TRYING TO GET OUT OF TAKING ACCOUNTABILITY FOR HIS WRG DOING. HE HAD ABSOLUTELY NO RIGHT TO PK THERE. SO THE DEFENDANT HAS BEEN OVER CHARGING CUSTOMERS SO FOR ANYONE WHO'S BEEN TOWED I BET THEY'RE LOOKING UP THE CODES IN THEIR CITY TOO. THE DEFENDANT HAD NOTHING TO ADD THE CODES SPOKE FOR THEMSELVES NOW REFUND THAT MAN BK A PORTION OF HIS $$
The plaintiff is a narcissist and I’m not one of those ppl who uses this word but come on now man. You know you was in the wrong pay it up!!! He’s like I been doing it for years that doesn’t make it okay to do fool!!!
Defendant didnt need to say anything. theres nothing you could say. I wish he didnt win anything because hes a snake, but he proved you overcharged...so you gotta return some.
Right?! My partner can there's three apples in the fridge, that she was just in there and there's three. We'll go look and see there's only two. She'll refuse to concede. "Did you take one?" or "I never said there were three, I said two and you said three". I love her but I know I'll never win; I could have security footage showing I didn't take one and audio recording of her saying three and rather than saying she's wrong, it'll be "It doesn't matter. We need more apples". lol
Plaintiff said I’m leaving here with SUMTHIN 😂
Lol Denzel
The judge was 100% correct in this case: Those suits looked GREAT!
Church style
8😊😊😊8😊99
😂
"Sometimes you have spotters, right? Like skinny guys standing behind the sign." 😂 Judge is hilarious. ❤
Skinny guy is sexy!!!😍❤️👑
His face when he found out he had to return some money! 😩😂
He’s right. She never listened to anything from the defendant.
She should have asked the defendant about the fees.
Too late.
she did.
The plaintiff had no right to park in a public parking lot like that, especially with a sign that says that you will be towed.
If it had been a public parking lot he'd have the right, this was a private lot. Also, some 'no parking' signs are unenforceable.
@DonziGT230 yes the unenforceable part I meant.
They never see the sign in front of them saying "you will be towed at your expense. LOL!
@@trekgirl65 exactly.
@@trekgirl65 Those signs aren't always legal/enforceable.
Some people think they know the law because they can read the words. Comprehension and application is the backbone of the law.
Right
I think this is up in the top 3 worst cases from Milian, Where she spoke over the litigants assuming she knew what the whole case was without letting either speak or present evidence. It was hard to watch
Plus the yelling
Pretty simple case
Don’t watch
Agree I'd like to have heard why the defendant thought he was able to charge the prices he did. Did he maybe have a more updated document with the current charges?
@@tessat1656you can’t charge someone on a different price if what you gave them was an old document
Jm has been doing this for such a long time she doesn’t even have to hear both sides 😂. Defendant was gutted
Okay now! We have Pete the Cat Daddies with the beige suits on!
The defendant has beautiful eyes. Periodt😃
She allowed the plaintiff to present his case but not the defendant. He’s 100% correct. He should have been allowed to present his rebuttal. That’s what court is for.
Yes! Totally unfair.
There was no rebuttal. He overcharged.
@froglog1002 right. I'm not getting how people can be this dense.
The only reason the defendant got to talk as long as he did was bc she needed facial evidence from him.
Anything he said would've been a waste of time. He had nothing.
Even if he exceeded the amount he could charge under the one statute that actually applied, he still should have had his chance to speak.
She far , can’t be towing someone car and charge them a lot of money to get it out
Her husband must be a wimp she is too loud😡
He is a wimp.... And not in a bad way. He seems to love it (and her).
Hes was a federal attorney and then a judge in Miami! He's in charge all day! I think he loves coming home to a place he doesn't have to be in charge of. And I agree, he seems to LOVE her more than life!
Just starting the video but putting my money down that Harvey asks - "In general, are tow companies sleezy?" (or something to that effect) - going to see if I am right!
She yell to much for me sometimes!!!
You yelling here too
Old man needs help 😩
Plaintiff should be a lawyer and not a bail bondsman. Guy is on the ball and did his homework.
It bothers me when people take time to come to court to be heard and the judge over talks the parties so much that neither party is able to fully present their main points. It was very dismissive!!
She told him that he going to lose the case in the beginning because there no legal ground for his law suit she just decided to be nice and listen. In real life the case would get thrown out and you won't even be able to see a judge.
She lowkey over spoke and ran over both of them in this case lol
must have been lunch time lool
HIGH KEY
Lowkey????? 😆
I think she made the right decision however she could have let the defendant respond to the over charge.
There was no need for it; the rules are the rules.
Y’all playing with us! Bring us some earlier seasons of Judge Marilyn! 😂
The defendant thought he would win completely 😂😂
It really kills me when she doesn't allow folks to speak. She needs to tone it down a bit.
She had the paperwork from the city stating exactly what the tow co can charge what was the man going to say? "I'm a victim I deserve to charge more"
Exactly
Don’t watch
Why let them speak BS and waste time when they are wrong over something HE did? Wrong is wrong
Why is Judge M screaming so much?!
Ratings and she is naturally animated.
@@atlienrider6048bc she is low key ghetto.
Now I'm curious as to what the tow guy had for evidence. 🤔
It happened to me once and it's the worst feeling thinking my car was stolen when it was towed. It was a P O S car anyway. 😂
VERY entertaining case.👍
Uh oh.
I wonder if that city ordinance applied to city/public property like roads only.
Why on earth would he park there? Park on the street near the business. lol. Of course you have to be towed.
He probably just doesn’t want to pay for parking
Where do people get the idea that spotters exist in towing? take responsibility and dont park where you cant park
Because they absolutely do. I worked for a tow company for years and we had spotters on the payroll.
It's not an idea, it's a fact. Just because you don't know about spotters, you shouldn't assume that they don't exist.
5:32 the hollering she does! Sounds like a raging alcoholic 😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂
It's the case of "I snatch, you snatch, we all snatch". 😂
Jesus Christ car cases are absolutely hilarious 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣my pops had a story about someone's car got repossessed which it was absolutely hilarious. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Yeah sure sounds like it with all those excessive emojis.
Please don't Jesus's name it's so disrespectful.
The defendant has beautiful skin
I came for that comment. I was just staring at him because of the perfect skin! 🥰
I’ve been driving a tow truck in a large college town and tow around 1000 cars a year for parking where they aren’t supposed to be. People constantly assume I have a spotter, I’m watching them, or paying off a property owner when I honestly do not do that. The property owners make money by charging for parking on their property to residents and other people. I make money by towing the cars. People park in the lots all the time I can literally drive by every 15 minutes and find a car that’s not supposed to be there. Every lot I tow from has posted signs and cars that are allowed to be there have permits. The really busy lots I know exactly what cars go there and what don’t because I memorize the cars since I see them multiple times a day everyday of the year. Towing laws vary state to state but here in Michigan there just has to be a sign posted at each entrance. Property owners have every right to have cars towed and most of the lots I tow from are on a patrol basis. People call me a POS and many other names and accuse me of so many things but they can do whatever they want. If I didn’t do my job these parking lots would be a mess. People pay $250 or more a month for their spots and they want them open and every spot gets sold out. If people want to call tow companies scammers or think I’m a POS that’s fine. If people want to dispute it they can take it to small claims court. I do my job so throughly and take such good photos documenting everything the company has never once given back a dollar in court for anything I’ve towed. I also do plenty of other stuff like roadside assistance and will save you off the side of the highway in the middle of a snowstorm or change your tire and get you on your way. People either hate me or love me depending on the situation. I get a lot of satisfaction out of my job and try to be as professional as possible. 99% of the people on this earth wouldn’t last more than a week doing this job and I see it all the time with the turnover rate. It’s also one of the most dangerous jobs out there. On average at least one driver gets hit and killed every week on the side of the highway trying to help someone. I lost a coworker in 2018 who was hit and killed by a drunk driver while he was doing his job. He left behind his wife and 2 young children. Please just take responsibility for your actions when you park and don’t be surprised when your car gets towed out of a private parking lot. It’s no one’s fault but your own. At the end of the day I make extremely good money and support my family which is all that matters to me so if you want to look down on me or other tow truck drivers that’s fine. Just remember our services aren’t free and new tow trucks cost at least 150-200 grand and that doesn’t include crazy high insurance and other overhead costs. Please try to understand we are just doing a job and we risk our lives everyday while doing it.
Judge didn’t have time today😂😂
The judge is probably upset that the plaintiff did his homework and the plaintiff had more but the judge immediately closed the case 😂and walked out not letting anybody to talk
Winch charge. Thats loading the car. Thats part of the tow. If he had a wrecker it would be wheel lifted. Hate greedy tow guys,in Florida its $500 hook up $5 mile n thats police tow,so every company in the area is charhing. Thats crazy for a tow.
And I certainly do not wear plaid
Towing fee are regulated in every town
Once they walk off the property
It's irritating to 👀 see a cars parked in illegal parking
I feel bad for the defendant. Plaintiff played the game.
That’s ridiculous pay to park at the meter what a jerk!!!!!!!
Why is nobody saying how nice the defendants skin is? 😂
Right
Defendant was a con tower, and price gouging. Trying to make a con profit. LOL!
Dude tried to apply every statute he could find. And he did find a way to get some 💲 back.
I'm surprised. I thought he would lose.
There's no such 30 dollars towing fees here in Canada is 300 dollars per towing
Wow
“I didn’t get to say anything”!
The plaintiff: 😜😜😜😜😜
😂😂😂
Plaintiff is the worst. Half a brain trying to work the system cause of a typo. If I misspelled the words "private property - no parrrwking" on a sign on my lawn, in his world, he can come park of my lawn.
The kid should've done some research before randomly "starting" a towing business
That’s a grown man not a kid. Who says he didn’t? No business is an expert in everything and knows the law frontwards and backwards
That's crazy he didn't get to say one word what kinda 💩 is that
I wonder how many people they rip off who either don't know they law or who can't fight them to get it back. I guarantee the tow company knows they're capped they just don't care
What a lot of people don’t know is that the judge is familiar with the street codes and regulations on every state before the case happens. It’s the reason why she doesn’t need to hear a lot from the plaintiff and defendant
But it's leaving the viewers with questions when she makes a decision and one of the parties hasn't been heard much.
The defendant is handsome
THE PLAINTIFF SHOULD BE ASHAMED OF HIMSELF. HE'S TO OLD TO BE TRYING TO GET OUT OF TAKING ACCOUNTABILITY FOR HIS WRG DOING. HE HAD ABSOLUTELY NO RIGHT TO PK THERE. SO THE DEFENDANT HAS BEEN OVER CHARGING CUSTOMERS SO FOR ANYONE WHO'S BEEN TOWED I BET THEY'RE LOOKING UP THE CODES IN THEIR CITY TOO. THE DEFENDANT HAD NOTHING TO ADD THE CODES SPOKE FOR THEMSELVES NOW REFUND THAT MAN BK A PORTION OF HIS $$
Don't scream
@@Jsarmy87124its capital letters you’ll live
Whyyyy tf else would he be on his phone! Be fr! 🙄🙄
The plaintiff is a narcissist and I’m not one of those ppl who uses this word but come on now man. You know you was in the wrong pay it up!!! He’s like I been doing it for years that doesn’t make it okay to do fool!!!
Defendant didnt need to say anything. theres nothing you could say. I wish he didnt win anything because hes a snake, but he proved you overcharged...so you gotta return some.
Wow I Made It First lol I Never Do
Judge wasn't in the wrong for refusing to hear what the litigants had to say.
I agree, but people are complaining, because they wanted to hear what the plaintiff and defendant wanted to say.
The judge is sometimes v cute. Hahaha
More than sometimes
I agree. Her sex appeal is of the charts.
Great day everyone.
Let's go!!!!!
What was a driver 50 years ago and I treated them fairly I'm over 70 years of age
"what was a driver" ??
What are you trying to say?
Ld
America got to many laws
I know.
I guess I'll take "3rd"..comment 😂
Milian completely disrespect the defendant in this case at the end when she walked out on him not being able to counter the plaintiff.
once again ur totally wrong...get a fn life
She didn't have to do him like that. Whether he had something to counter or not is beside the point. She didn't need to disrespect dude like that.
She's not there to kiss his ass. She did her job. If he needs to be coddled, tell him to go to therapy.@@adrianknight1406
@@adrianknight1406ok cupcake
Defendant dissed the plaintiff by overcharging. That is why we are here!
Asking a woman to just concede. Hahaha. Jokes on you
Right?! My partner can there's three apples in the fridge, that she was just in there and there's three. We'll go look and see there's only two. She'll refuse to concede. "Did you take one?" or "I never said there were three, I said two and you said three". I love her but I know I'll never win; I could have security footage showing I didn't take one and audio recording of her saying three and rather than saying she's wrong, it'll be "It doesn't matter. We need more apples". lol
They are rocking the "Obama tanned suit".....Republicans be crying
How could you possibly make this political 🙄
@@oldageisdumb Kamala rocking the tan suit last night!
Another poor decision by judge Milian
Why explain? Because you complain a lot are you a judge no
@@Jsarmy87124
The plaintiff was wrong in the story
Why don't you like their suits?
@@lukerinderknecht2982
Tow guy was right shouldn’t pay anything plaintiff was 💯 wrong
Nothing for the Defemdant to counter
Ooooooo Adriane gonna have a field day with this one 😮