One of us is lying

[@tlou.wbb.softball.]

OML SAMMEE

[@wellness.for.y]

omg really?

[@tlou.wbb.softball.]

ya this was one of my fav books and I watched the show after and was like “huh?

[@Cartoonist-love]

Hey where can i read the book?

[@shahanahsan05]

the dude playing Simon looks more like Nate than the guy playing Nate does

[@wellness.for.y]

so true! my friend literally mixed them up 😂

[@Renaryze]

Right

[@avdreydreams]

RIGHT?? I THOUGHT HE WAS NATE AT FIRST

[@Adria-Paulin6283]

FR!

[@dana9537]

I imagined Simon as Timothee Chalamet

[@Thearoace_fizzy]

Agreed cooper is supposed to be super southern and nate is supposed to have black hair.

[@wellness.for.y]

yes completely agree with you

[@imshassan5436]

ikr

[@drlhottest3071]

Ikr

[@normarijuaneira]

Exactly and didn't Coooer have longer hair?

[@Thearoace_fizzy]

@@normarijuaneira ya i think so, ALSO LOVE YOUR PFP,are you aroace too!!!

[@LeShortArtist]

How is everyone imagining bronwyn as asian? She's COLUMBIAN

[@snigdhaadavi]

Real!!

[@kyryloschaeffer3435]

Literally!

[@_capybara-]

her last name is literally rojas 😭 like yall obv she is Hispanic

[@ConstanceHunter12249]

I know it literally says 💀

[@barfwizard]

FRL WHAT

[@esdieedits]

Kit Connor as Cooper is literally perfect. On point. Could solve childhood trauma.

[@CheddarCheese5]

I imagined bronwyn with long, brown, silky hair, black rectangle glasses, and brown eyes.

[@Annabel77]

So real the actors are not anything I was expecting from the book (except Addy)

[@ArtsyNerd4]

addy is always on point

[@julianbracey778]

I imagined Bronwyn perfectly tho, and Addy was Spot on!
Also this series show/books are sooooo good!

[@0MGITSPANDA]

Same. I imagined cooper as the guy from you belong with me by Taylor swift’s music video.

[@treat.yo.self.2023]

Yea but Bronwyn was described as Latina

[@ruebakarue]

I read it recently and i don't know why i kept imagining jenna Ortega for browyn 🏃‍♂️

[@henrymoyle6730]

Yes

[@purebubblyboba]

Same! I think either Jenna or Olivia Rodrigo would be a good Bronwyn but I do think that the Bronwyn now is pretty good tho but I don’t like how they changed Cooper and Nate. Like I’m ok that they changed a few things but I really wish they gave Cooper that southern accent lol😅

[@Taylorswiftfaneditor]

I totally agree except for the cooper one

[@user-hy4wq9nk1t]

I pictured cooper and Nate the exact same as you did, Addy was as I imagined her in the films

[@switchcraft906]

cooper is described as darkskin bruh

[@sereneceline]

@@switchcraft906there’s literally a line which said ‘Cooper turned red’ and another saying his friend luis’ hair was many shades darker than his…

[@billie4149]

same! i read the book first and pictured them totally different!

[@sophia-hn4le]

bronwyn is described as colombian and irish in the book im pretty sure

[@kyryloschaeffer3435]

Yeah, she is

[@Cap_Dancer]

NOT THE LAARAA JEEEAAANNN THO
I IMAGINED THE SAME LMAO

[@The_kats_pumpkin]

Wait.... WAIT HOLD ON- I have only read the books...And I have the cover that has the show characters.... I ALWAYS THOUGHT THAT WHAT COOPER LOOKS LIKE IS WHAT NATE LOOKS LIKE AND WHAT NATE LOOKS LIKE IS WHAT COOPER LOOKS LIKE LMAO-

[@Cheddar-the-Chaos-Editor]

Addy is always on point

[@moose_rubi]

Omg kit wouldve made me love the show even moree😭

[@dulcx_24]

Addy from the show and your imagination of Nate is on pointtt

[@manicdoodles775]

We can all agree that addy was on point and exactly how we imagined

[@koalazaa1717]

WHY DOES EVERYONE THINK BRONWYN IS ASIAN SHE’S COLUMBIAN

[@Nicole-137]

Addy is what I thought her sister would look like

[@annapearl6226]

I LITERALLY PICTURED THE EXACT SAME THING WITH COOPER. I ALWAYS PICTURED NICK FROM HEARTSTOPPER LIKEEE 😭 but if u havent watched the show its pretty good, i recommend

[@beninesidaty8306]

How could you imagine bronwin as an asian ??

[@ShelbyPixie]

For me
Brownyn : Lana condor
Addy: Sydney Sweeney
Nate: Taylor perez
Cooper: Noah schnapp
Janae: Jenna Ortega
Simon: Christopher brinney

[@twix8989]

Omg I could totally see Sydney Sweeney as Addy. They kinda look alike. Glad I'm not the only one who thought about that 😃

[@athomewithnika6459]

Agree about Nate, immediately thought of young Depp too

[@Itsreallynotthathard]

Nate in the imagination is so fine tho.

[@avdreydreams]

i mean idk thats not rly how i imagined them exactly but you are so write ab addy’s, she is sooo on point

[@stateofgrace4]

i agree with cooper he gives nick energy and i literally picture him that way

[@thatNPC1]

i feel like i imagined bronwyn to be what she actually looked like bc it said she was hispanic

[@thatNPC1]

but i imagined nate EXACTLY like how u did it’s like the exact copy

[@Randomperson18998]

Agree with everyone except Bronwyn cause she’s not korean obviously 😂

[@_capybara-]

I imagined Bronwyn as this more curvy, shorter girl with about shoulder length wavy hair, wire framed glasses, and really young and innocent looking

[@bliqss_]

I imagined cooper as kit conner as well but the actor playing cooper acted really well in my opinion

[@ruchavaidya7465]

This is so exact 😭🙌

[@eshasahu2033]

Noo I did not imagine addy like that. She was more pretty and soft in my imagine

[@Ava-lp5mw]

for me Nate is exactly how I imagined him to be honest

[@barfwizard]

I Imagined bronywn with silky short hair, brown eyes . the actor in the show is sooo pretty but I was kinda disappointed when she didn’t look like what I pictured but I guess that’s kinda unrealistic lol

[@Repgirlieforlife]

they did nate DIRTY

[@ConstanceHunter12249]

I thought Nate was blonde because the cover for “One of Us is Back” has Nate on the cover and he has blonde hair?? Also brown is Colombian & Irish, it’s described in the book. Y’all need to pay attention 😭

[@raena_emerituscobain]

Yes. The imagination for Nate. Just yes.

[@Kpopwithluv]

My Nate's imagination was like the real cooper

[@evacisneros1614]

BRO I EXPECTED EVERYONE TO BE LIKE THAT TOO
and the nate actor kinda disappointed me

[@beth3413]

Bro I thought copper looked like Simon in my head

[@no-mi6vx]

I imagined cooper as Georgie from young Sheldon

[@poppygrace9480]

I’ve recently got the book “Two can keep a secret” and it’s soooooo good and now I’m watching one of us is lying so I rlly want the book!

[@MRM-x3q]

Get it it’s my fav book of all time!!!!!

[@poppygrace9480]

@@MRM-x3q yeah maybe but I got it spoiled from the series. :/

[@joaovilares1439]

Yes young Johnny depp vibes 👑

[@stellastar7979]

bronwyn was super on point for me ngl

[@MayYang-cg1gw]

Thats exactly how I thought Nate would look

[@JuniorKittyCorn]

Why is this so realtable

[@cosmic....]

absolutely with nick nelson and cooper lol!

[@tousiaansari4230]

Me imagining every character as asian 😂

[@Waffl3214]

I was imagining Bryana Salaz as addy

[@AnnaLaufeyson]

OMG DOES EVERYONE LIKE ONE OF US IS LYING BECAUSE I'M READING IT RNNNNN!!! ❤❤

[@f1lmsbyareej]

Rip addy

[@MollytheHufflepuff]

Is no one going to talk about HOW SIMILAR Nate and TJ look??? Like I GENUINELY thought TJ was Nate 😅

[@shadeisblind]

Bro Bronwyn had me so sad

[@immyy2]

I pictured them the same as in the series tbh but Cooper had longer hair

[@vibhagovind9676]

So true ...I imagined them like this ...

[@indiarose248]

Literally pictured it the exact same, so on point xx

[@xxiqraxx4408]

Why did they make simon look better than nate

[@Zainabdukadr]

OMG SAME LIKE WHY

[@SunsetBrooke]

Just finished it and ready to watch the movie!

[@Broski-Man12]

The first one fr

[@ariowens202]

FR ESPECIALLY NATE

[@blooming_rei]

Cooper was described as black tho think

[@Hepoxni]

how did you make this video?

[@Jojosiwawasabadgirl]

The only one we had the same was nate

[@yawningjoon-]

READ MY MINDD

[@Lov3stay58]

Okay but like they said browyn was Colombian so that’s doesn’t add up but everything else is accurate

[@TheAnglichanka]

Simon should be Nate and Nate should be cooper and cooper should be Simon😭

[@Starzie_skyz]

Real though!

[@RumanaAhamed-pj1dm]

None of them look like how I imagined them 😭

[@amyross2364]

Cooper and Nate same bronwyn I thought she’d be black

[@OceanIce4]

Same here 😅

[@drlhottest3071]

BRO SAME

[@Reese0511]

I imagination of addi was a blonde preppy girl

[@Anxietysucks126]

I thought Bronwyn was blonde 😭😭. Guess I missed a part 🤷‍♂️

[@bizzerker8467]

Idk if the series is good or not and is it the same as the book?

[@Xpsid3dowX]

Same with Nate

[@sophavak]

tbh i like the cast

[@elinkoch9252]

Like cooper is crazy 😭 (DEFINITELY NO HATE IM JS SAYING LIKE WHY DID HE SWITCH TEAMS)

[@ZandH09]

NAH CUZ FR ITS DISAPPOINTING😭

[@Appledog01]

OMG U are sooo right,

[@Bluewhale666]

OMG NATE IS NICK

[@maggiethorburn4969]

Same!

[@ciinamongirl]

BRUH YES. i think nate is good tho

[@lambchop29]

wasn’t bronwyn spanish, not vietnamese like lana condor?

[@HunterLNCPlaysRoblox]

I imagined browyn to be black/Asian mixed not full Asian 🤷🏽‍♂️ that might just be me though

[@xx.juju.9737]

REAL

[@Lux.v433]

OMFG SAMEEEEEE

[@Lux.v433]

Wait pls do kris I imagine hot blond not visibly German

[@ridinkasim6911]

It's seems that the author was the liar 🤣

[@wilxa]

No way was Bronwyn asian in my imagination

[@Rayasauruss]

Sameeee

[@xoxo_emma]

Why does simon have to be hotter than nate in the show

[@Editliferules]

Omg same

[@Cavetownmyluv]

SAMEEEE

[@Cavetownmyluv]

but i did think bronwyn looks the way she does because it said in the book she was spanish

[@Crochet.with.anonymous]

Sameee

[@wellness.for.y]

what are your opinions on one of us is lying?

[@catarinaazinheirinha5022]

I really liked the book and the series. My favourite character is Addy

[@Thearoace_fizzy]

Love it got me out of a reading slump

[@wellness.for.y]

@@Thearoace_fizzy it got me out of a reading slump as well, because it was so fast paced

[@Thearoace_fizzy]

@@wellness.for.y agreed 👍