Redstone in MCPE is VERY Confusing..
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 окт 2024
- After 7 years of PC Redstone, I thought I would give it a go in the Windows 10 version.. It left me completely muddled.
Today we try out MCPE/Win10/console redstone. It was not an easy thing to get the hang of, but eventually we get the hang of it and build some interesting redstone builds!
The Mumbo Merch Store! It's beautiful!
www.awin1.com/c...
Become a Patron for a spot on the Patreon Server!
/ thatmumbojumbo
My INSANE PC was kindly provided by Chillblast, a company specialising in Performance systems. We have a full range available with 3 systems of varying price and power! Check them out here:
www.chillblast.com/mumbojumbo
My server is kindly provide by CubedHost free of charge!
Click this link to get a 25% discount off one of their servers!
cubedhost.com/t...
2ND CHANNEL: / thatmumbojumbo2
TWITTER: / thatmumbojumbo
INSTAGRAM: / officialmumbo
OFFICIAL MUMBO JUMBO PCS: www.chillblast...
-------------------------------------------------
My texture pack is Faithful and Codecrafted combined.
Faithful: www.minecraftfo...
CodeCrafted: • CodeCrafted Texture Pa...
Intro: ProleteR - Can't Stop Me
outro: ProleteR - April Showers
/ proleterbeats
/ proleter.beats
proleter.bandca...
Timelapse: LAKEY INSPIRED
/ lakeyinspired
Upload Schedule:
Tuesday - Redstone
Wednesday - Hermitcraft
Thursday - Redstone
Friday - Hermitcraft
Saturday - Redstone
Sunday - Hermitcraft
I know that a lot of you play on Minecraft Pocket Edition, so I thought I would see how redstone works over there.
I was shocked at how entirely different it actually is! I have new respect for you Pocket Edition redstone people!
I'm your first like
Mumbo Jumbo thanxxxx mumbs
BlackSpringlockedDoggo Ikr
Mumbo Jumbo k
Mumbo Jumbo now you know how I feel!!!
Mumbo: you can move chests! I have so many ideas!
Me: oh hes gonna make hidden chests
Mumbo:CHAIN GUN!!!!
He mentions dispensers, chests and furnaces.
Hai Dong and everything
Torch: no
Hai Dong he mentioned everything tho
@@xsnda He meant blocks not all entities.
Mumbo: I could do so much with this!
Mumbo 5 seconds later: *C H A I N G U N*
I over simplified his chain gun for redstone for dummies
LoL
Lol
C H A I N G U N!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.... it was his dream
@@the_twich_man328 when u can fit a chain gun in ur pocket, but not on ur 1b dollar pc
Bedrock redstone: broken af
Also bedrock: move block entities
A worthy exchange
trident killers are cool too
So true I use them in all my farms
I don't do redstone but I gotta say the bedrock edition marketplace content is pretty cool
@@pain-jz7vz how much did they pay you?
Java red stone: ‘destroys my flying machine from working’ me: Java red stone probably lives in a toilet
If you actually remember the original stonecutters and how they work, you deserve a veteran’s discount at the Minecraft Bedrock store
Geard Dhiamandi ...
Yes!!
And i thought the stone cutters were a newer block in the game i never saw it as an og block..
@@franciscomartinez4138 really...
I remember... I started with bedrock on apple then moved to java with VERY confused looks. I began Redstone by watching and reading tutorials and here i am now. Still bad yet better than before thanks to jumbo jumbo and learning.
"Anyone knows what's causing that?"
Trust me, we don't either
me. mcpe and mcje are different
If two repeaters have a difference in delay by one tick, the game basically randomly decides which one goes first. (In my experience)
c++
Tbh when i played mcpe (i started with it) i constantly asked that question when doing the same kinda redstone thing he was doing-
Like- im doing the same thing! Why is there a different result?! XD
ɪ ᴋɴᴏᴡ ʜᴏᴡ ᴛᴏ ғɪx ɪʏ
Mumbo Jumbo : Can build awesome redstone contraptions in Java edition
Minecraft Windows 10 Edition : I’m about to end this man’s whole career
@kaosGeima TV kool
How does windows 10 change his ability to build in java. You did it wrong mate
@@LSqre You don't get it do you?
@@LSqre windows 10 is a specific version because its bedrock you walnut
Yeah his 2x1 piston extender door thing doesn’t work in windows 10/pe so I had to completely engineer this stupidly over complicated system to make it work and sometimes it doesn’t even work properly, sometimes it doesn’t open all the way.
As a MCPE player this was a good laugh, the part i got the biggest laugh from was when you found out that we can move chests, hoppers etc. as until i watched you i thought moving those blocks with pistons was normal
Lol this guy is now good
Most of this are fixed I think. This is a outdated video.
@@leadharsh0616 oh I don't play pe but I play normal console bedrock and it isn't fixed on that
@@leadharsh0616 They aren't fixed because that isn't a bug, it's a feature
@@Xhepyxopila are you dumb? I'm not talking about moving chests but the other bugs that mumbo faced.
This is why us PE people always love when the tutorial people say it only works for java at the start of a video
Tutorials from java in 2012-2013,
Java players trying: *Doesn’t work*
Bedrock players trying: *Works fine*
Wait…
What’s even worse is when they don’t say and you build it... just to find that it doesn’t work.
Indeed.
I have both versions, but I started out recently in windows 10 edition. learned and experimented with a lot of redstone contraptions. Then I got java edition for my laptop running an older version of windows and I was trying to just do the simple act of making a piston work and I was like wtf?! LOL several things don't work in both versions, however there are builds and ways of doing the same task that will work in both versions using circuits like the quad repeater on/off switch that work in both editions.
it is nice that both java and bedrock editions are finally on the same build 1.16.2 versions now and being updated at the same time. Though I do find java edition to be significantly buggier and slower than windows 10 edition. And I'm sure it was not always that way to begin with, but it's definitely a smoother faster less buggy and more enjoyable experience in windows 10 edition. However java still gets features that windows 10 edition doesn't...like being able to make roads out of lava in the nether using blue ice and soul sand with a flying machine...that blue ice and soul sand converting lava functionality doesn't even exist in bedrock edition.
@@tatos529 that's illegal
Blue Hyper i know right, that happend to me, but with a iron farm built in survival. I shouldve tried it first in creative lol
Microsoft and mojang: stonecutters are new!
Bedrock players: am I joke to you?
THANK YOU BUT THEY FINALLY HAVE A USE I WAS SOO EXCITED WHEN I SAW!
On bedrock edition they had a function before the 1.14 update. If you placed stonecutters in a 3x3 square with a hole in the middle on a stone surface, you could place tnt in the middle, light it with flint and steel, and have a perfect square.
@@ravioliravioli118 they had the same exact functions from what I remember but now they work in creative
@@adeus_sinister I played when it was like that too
Finally they have a use again B-) O:-):-P :-D
Mumbo: *Always Confused*
Real MCPE Players: First Time.
Pistons and redstone torches are weird
@@justinbognot7468u must work I became a redstone expert in mcpe after 8 years of practicing
@@theeagleoftheeye4830 8 years?! you played this game for that long time?
@@theeagleoftheeye4830 respectfuly, i feel bad for you
@@theeagleoftheeye4830 u kidding?! Do you know how much 8 years is lol
java red stone: is easy for mumbo
PE redstone: okay then, my turn
XD
lol
BE redstone: my redstone is better 😎
(Ik they are the same lol)
Its a revengance for "Its a simple build"
Just wait until he realizes you can put leavers on pistons
Hariaj Watches stuff LOL True
Or shoot fireworks horizontally...
Ikr
Or keep area(s) loaded without being in the said area(s)
how do you do that?
PE player: he’s making things work
Mumbo: *makes a double piston extender*
Me: write that down
WRITE THAT DOWN
ikr
Alexander nannini yes exactly. I have tried for ages to make one of those work, and I cannot succeed in a space small enough to work
Just want to say I made a 50 piston extendor in PE
Cory Crombie placing a lever on every individual piston doesn’t count
GiantCrayfish28 if you want proof ask for my reddit username and it’s on there
Me: Ooh! He's playing pe? What will he build first?
Mumbo: A chaingun!
And that’s why I get your videos, take it all in, then build it a complete different way on my iPad. I am so glad I now have it on my switch
Mumbo Jumbo: Is confused about Redstone
*We're in the endgame now.*
ColbyH258 nice
Nice
nice
noice
nice
Mumbo: I'm a god at redstone
Pocket edition: I'm about to end this mans whole career
he never said he was a god at redstone but ok
Hunzala08 He never said but he IS the god at redstone!
Not to brag but I think I am pretty good at redstone in bedrock edition, before 1.16 I was more better until now cause I have left Minecraft alone until 1.16 so I almost forgot about redstone
@@tatos529 same
SethBling is the best
Only old MCPE players remember the OG stonecutter, and the OG players (myself included) remember the Nether Reactor
Geard D same here! I was quiet sad when they removed the nether core reactor although I found an old world where I had filled my inventory with them.
And sand or gravel door, when there was no redstone yet in MCPE
Yessss! I remember looking up how to go to the nether in pocket edition, and stumbled upon a tutorial where they put magenta wool in some obsidian and made a hole you could fall into that took you to a nether-like room 😂
@@chickennuggetpaw1017 Yeah, that's so nostalgic
I remember how happy I was when they added the full nether to pocket edition. Now I kinda miss the ol’ reactor.
Mumbo: I am the king of redston
Mumbo after seeing PE: finally a worthy opponent.
Wait until he finds out you can put redstone on pistons
Mumbo: Nani?!
You copied that.
Wtf??? The redstone doesnt break?
Ow hell no
Me who has never played the pc edition: Wait you can't do that?
Also underwater
Now you understand our pain Mumbo! We have to convert almost EVERY contraption over into pocket edition/windows edition redstone xP
On a side note, I'm super excited to see what you could do with redstone in this version of Minecraft!
PineappleTyrant his brewing station works in Minecraft PE.
awesome! thanks for letting me know! :D
Matthew player Thanks! I was hesitant to try it in case I wasted a heap of time on it
yah i agree to you because i always do that. i first try if it works in pe but if no im just recreate the redstones but ones that its imposible i just give up. one thing i always want to make button as lever but i cant do it because the t-flip flop contraption does not work but i make one finally. a real one that works when i figure it out im very happy.
I love how he screams every time he finds something
Some say that bedrock edition runs smoother, because the deleted half of the redstone code
It does seem like they deleted half the ticks!
Its coz they put more optimization (coz for phone players and console players)in the game hints why it looks diffrent and some things are cut out from the game
@@KaziKami it's actually because it's a completely different coding language! (Java for java, c++ for bedrock) different languages are better at different things, so there often ends up being big differences. In general, bedrock (C++) runs faster, but java is more easily modded!
@@antjecramer5324 Bedrock could have the exact same behavior regardless of language, but it was probably implemented in a different way with different subtle bugs and behaviors for performance reasons OR because all the behavior in Java is undocumented / not part of the requirements. I'm guessing both reasons played a role.
Java redstone was made by Notch’s shit code, bedrock doesn’t have it, causing oddities to appear on both platforms
I remember when the nether reactor was in the game and the stonecutter actually did something. The normal monostable circuit doesn't work because the redstone powers the block which powers the piston, I always use that as a clock
- WoolyMelon - I remember the nether reactor too!
TheBe5tWon - Bike Race, Minecraft, and more omg I used to stack them on top of each other!
RealWhovianGamer nice
I cant update it it just not comming up that i can update i paid money for that game!
Nether Reactor....
The thing that I could only complete on certain seeds because of diamonds I think...
One thing we want in the next updates of Minecraft:
Consistency...
Agreed it’s so annoying how u can’t easily change plateforms without relearning the game 🥵🥵🥵
I have only played on 3ds and pocket edition so I am used to this stuff.
There's plenty of consistency, as long as you stick to either Bedrock or Java. They're development teams are different, so gameplay is guaranteed to be different.
Consistency, as long as it favors the Java Edition of the game.
I play on Xbox 360 pe and bed rock edition 😎
4 years ago.
Me: tries to copy Mumbo in Pocket Edition while he is in Java
The build: easy
Pocket Edition: *no*
@@stevenquinlivan7096 i was trying to make that simple elevator and it didnt work. A waste of time it is when we didnt know java redstone cant be copied on pe.
You have no idea how many times I have had to change the designs for mumbo's builds. He should try MCPE more often!
I was so confused why it didn't work
Ash Dakki i have to do some redesigning
just play java
I love how he can't make a facial expression so he just wrote "confused" in the thumbnail
I wish they made everything consistent throughout all versions
I agree as an MCPE player it is so hard
You know it's hard to make java and bedrock same?
Yes but they have had different versions for a long time. Don’t you think they would have figured out a way to convert bedrock to java or vice versa?
Me too
bedrock and java use different code languages.Java uses Java and bedrock uses C++
When he finds redstone doesn’t pop off pistons when he activates them...
He’ll have a seizure
they know dont in java
Heh i still sometimes forget that used to be a small thing that pretty much only mcpe had.
shhhhh
@late4thegameNOW the old xbox edition is still playable. not sure about downloading tho
Late to the party, but old xbox 360 minecraft builds have quasi conectivity and block updates. Truly, a wonderful port of redstone to consoles.
Dunno about the newest xbox builds but at least the old ones work like that
Mumbo: says he has no idea what he's doing
Also Mumbo: _uses terms like mono-stable circuits and quasi-connectivity_
Come again?
@@JupiterKnight ...
@@JupiterKnight ok dude see you on Saturday again mom will pick you up this time okay and also bring cookies
@@tatiana2133 yes dadi
@@JupiterKnight yeah also here are some lollipops cause you helped me with the tree house, bye Fred :D
I’d love to see more of these. I play bedrock and enjoy Mumbo’s videos. As a new ish MC player it’d be fun to see him learn with me.
In the olden days of Minecraft PE and MCPE, Like if you've experienced these...
**Inhales Deeply..**
no caves
no andesite
no diorite
no granite
no flat worlds
no infinite worlds
no chat
no commands
no redstone
no sneaking
no hunger
no enchantments
no anvils
no naming items
no potion effects
no nether
working stonecutter
nether reactor cores
the dog was the only tameable mob
"Minecraft Demo" was out on mobile
the bow and bonemeal glitch
**Exhale**
*Props to anyone who has experienced these, and a personal pat on the back for anyone who have had/played the Minecraft Demo*
I PLAYED THE DEMO ALL THE TIME WHEN I WAS LIKE 6 AND THEN FINALLY GOT THE WHOLE GAME AND REMEMBER EVERY SINGLE THING YOU LISTED. AGH THE NOSTALGIA!!!
i remember all off those things
Oh man, i almost forgot about nether reactor cores... oh, and there was also a cloning glitch... i think the first time i played minecraft pe was like in the 0.3.0 version or something...
Remember when we all freaked the fuck out when nether portals were added? Those where the days. I miss our beautiful reactors ;n;
Oh and don't forget roses. The beautiful roses just shoved aside by poppies. Why? Why mojang? why not just add poppies separately?? WHYYYY???
"ah, I can move everything!"
Obsidian: we got a problem?
And also bedrock
@@onyx_exists furnaces.
@• Glxxmy.- -.Sunshine • lol I screen shotted it
@@qie2iqee373 You can move furnaces
That's soooo true! Lol!
Only true PE fans remember the Nether Reactor...
VultureArmy ah yes, and the stonecutter, lack of caves, limited worlds, cyan flowers and creepy faceless pigmen.... It felt like such a beta game back then.
_Nadiki_ Ikr Its incredible how much Minecraft PE has actually evolved. It's getting closer to Minecraft PC
Ah yes, the old Minecraft PE Edition. I started play soon after buckets and animal spawn eggs came, and the sand started actually getting affected by gravity. It really felt like an unfinished game. I did never get the nether reactor to work tho... Oh, and shift wasnt a thing either, and for some reason I really loved making tall buildings in survival, so when I wanted to build a balkony (idk how its spelled), I had to get one of the blocks, and yolo out to the corner and hope that I would not fall. Ah, the good ol days...
Ha-ha. I'm so old that I remember not only Nether core and this structure (it was cool that quartz and other stuff just dropped out), but even the time when tools didn't take any damage and when you couldn't contact with chests, workbenches and stonecutters in creative cause there was no creative.
Hah yes the nether Reactor
Please do more BEDROCK Redstone builds in the future!
I loved watching you (Redstone master) learning the differences on the vid. it has taught me more than A LOT that I previously didn't know or didn't understand!
Mumbo: *makes chain gun*
Us army would like to know your location
@мясной пирог yes
Mumbo being a redstone genius
MCPE: you are utterly powerless here!
still made a 3x3 piston door pretty fast
Chain gun
@@draganalexandru6912 yea ikr that was pretty impressive
But....Bow Tie Man isn't!!
considering that over 50% of minecrafters are on bedrock...
Mumbo: (To pocket edition/Windows 10 version) What is going on here?
Me: (Plays Minecraft pocket edition) Ohhhh, that's why none of his Redstone contraptions work when I try.
I hear you there i never fully realised the difference but non of his builds work in my world. xD
Exactly! I tried his useless device in PE the other day and was SO disappointed when it didn't work! So then I made it myself from scratch which wasn't actually that hard 😂
Yup
The stonecutter wasn't always just for decoration. In the early days of Minecraft Pocket edition(I'm talking before they removed the Nether Reactor Core old, btw), it was used as a crafting table for stone blocks. In fact, the ONLY way to make stone slabs, bricks, staircases, etc., was on a stonecutter.
Thank you
I can’t build any of your builds so I just watch it
Someone finally understands my pain
Yeah I have To use my Tiny logical brain and copy and modify it
I build the elevator he did in MCPE
But it's quite different
Use repeater
No one knows MY pain....cuz even i dont know my pain lol
I only have half a brain cell left
I couldn’t do this if I tried
XD it's like watching grian try redstone
it would be even more hilarious if grian tried redstone on windows 10 xD
Why
Would grian try a harder version
Why
True so true 😂🤣😂🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂
As a Bedrock player, I really appreciate that he didn't just say it was trash.
Same. I really appreciate the RUclipsrs who don't just dump on bedrock at every chance they get. Like, yes, some things work better in Java, but there's things that are nicer about bedrock as well. People having their preference and not being condescending jerks about it is always refreshing to see online.
@@princessluna2698 Yes!
@@princessluna2698 THANK YOU! That's sooo trueeee pe/be/java is just minecraft but with different mechanics... They're all just the same! If you're a true mc fan... You will think that all versions have pros and cons
It isn't trash.. It's just incomplete as of now
RESPECT
Mumbo: WHAT IS THIS!
The people who do bedrock edition Minecraft: welcome to my world, only now it is your world. :)
I get that reference
“I’ve also found a bit of an inconsistency” welcome to bedrock edition how can I help you today
I'd have a plate of broken contraptions with an infuriating inconsistency for the dessert please
I'll take a game crashes trying to open a world and closing the game please with a side of lag.
Can I have some choppy framerates and game breaking glitches and my main course
Can I have an unpredictable circuit and a side of lag spikes after more than 8 players to go?
Can I have a friends lest that sometimes shows people and sometimes doesn't
"Very gradual, but it does function."
*You literally just described my entire computer.*
No, but seriously, it can barely handle any of my games.
I feel ya, man.
I can play Star Wars bf2 and Minecraft
I feel bad, I feel bad
Same bro
My pc is a literal potato
I felt that
whos gonna tell him you can put Redstone on pistons?
I'm pretty sure that's a thing on Java as of 1.15.
Edit: yup. Was added in 20w06a.
I had to retract my like in order to keep I at 69
@@josephwodarczyk977 not the sides, on bedrock you have always been able to place any component on any side
@@jared4575 u cant
@@DramaticBatu you can, I literally just did like a minute ago when I was building a 4x4 lava door. Maybe you skipped over the bedrock part of my sentence. By bedrock I mean Minecraft bedrock edition
He should really give this another go, bedrock has really improved a massive ton in the last 3 years
I don't play BE so I don't know if it has or hasn't but...
I suspect that unless the inconsistent redstone pulse thing has been fixed, there's nothing that makes it better than Java
Redstone requires more consistency than anything else, so... if it has, maybe it can interest Mumbo more than the create mod currently is but part of me doubt that anything but the create mod interests Mumbo in Minecraft right this moment ^^'
So... has the inconsistent redstone behaviour been fixed?
@@ArgentumEmperio ...
I guess the random redstone hasn't but stuff like observers have really changed for the better
It's true that he's probably not gonna try it again cuz the create mod is way more interesting. But I mean, I wasnt really expecting mumbo to read this comment on a 3 year old video anyways so...
5 now
9:04 It's weird to see him not use wool in this
Concrete?
it's because he doesn't have codecrafted, so he uses the next best thing
could you do another redstone series on mcpe
Derpy_Horse4 He hasn't got his amazing texture pack.
Lol ikr
I play on this version and I’m like “ya that happens”
Same
Me too
me too
and I tried to make 2 pistons move at once for myself years ago like this 1:14
only to get back to minecraft years later right here and realise I could've just done it with one piece of redstone
Do u th
Me tooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo.
Mumbo: Struggles to do MCPE redstone
Me: Welcome to my life
Ya
Yes my dude
true very relatable
Redstone mcpe is easy
Mcpe ew
*me seeing him build a double piston extender*
“No no, where’s the observer?”
Do you play spaceflight simulater?
This was 3 years ago. Observers didn't exist back then
@@HopeButMiserable they did
@@HopeButMiserable he litteraly placed an observer in the video
another way to do it that i know very well and use all the time and is always consistent, the 3:6:1 ratio. how to build it is you have your 2 sticky pistons, like always, and then you make a 3x3 platform off to the side of them, you have a 3 tick repeater running into the first sticky piston ( the one in the back) and a 4 tick repeater with a 2 tick repeater running into the second sticky piston. The last row on the 3x3 is just regular redstone dust. flick the lever to active all the redstone and you have a double piston extender.
Just wait until he finds out about the broken flying machines!
Yess... I tried making one. Was so disappointed in PE cause it was not at all working...
right lol
But I wanted a flying machine.
So I got creative and tried making one.
AND I DID IT!
Was (I guess) 2 hours to make the smallest possible flying machine. It has 7 blocks. Easy.
Yeah, that pain.
The small 7 block flying machine is bad though. It is not really that good. It is not pushing a lot. So annoying. But I don't care.
Me: has been playing mcpe for a really long time
Mumbo: Figures out redstone faster than I figured out that dirt is useless
Edit: all of the people replying are saying things like terraforming and scaffolding. I was like 7 years old. I wasn't going to be terraforming. I wasn't going to be building huge structures. I probably made a dirt hut with no door. I was 7 years old and on pocket edition.
dirt isn't useless tho
Without dirt no trees
No trees no diamond pick axe
To mine and then only have an inventory full of dirt is what i meant. No room for tools, chests, crafting tables to make tools and chests, and i just held on to that inventory full of dirt.
Dirt is the default scaffolding block
@@nathing_here for terraforming too
Mumbo's "clueless" is way past my skill level.
I'm about the same. I have almost no comprehension of how the redstone works, and I've been playing for 6+ years... I mean, I can do things, and I learn more about functionality every time I take on a project, but that doesn't mean I'm an expert by ANY definition.
Me too
Mumbo's clueless is the peak of my Redstone.
Two way flying machines don't work in Bedrock so I have to use Block Swappers to switch the pistons, and that part caused the most issues.
my old memory:every time i watch redstone tutorial in java i always confused why isn't this work???
@@stevenquinlivan7096 they're so random in MCPE
Me: Been playing on windows for years.
Mumbo: Wait. So Redstone redirects into pistons?!?!!
Everyone who plays mcpe: I'm somthing of a scientist myself
Me: how to make a creeper farm
Me after 1 hour of building it: why the hell it didnt worked?!
Me after 10 mins of brainstorming: oh, i forget the 'bedrock'
Oh God why so relatable tho xD
Relatable, but instead of "bedrock" put "java"
@@X-Ternal what do you mean? Without the magic word 'bedrock' while searching for a tutorial, recommended tutorials will only work on java
@@gulliblegerman I found out about this the hard way
Lol so true i spent 5 hours making a mega iron golem farm then it did not work my me👿👿👿👿👿
Mumbo: I have a new respect for bedrock edition redstone engineers
Me who built a 2 by 2 piston door: :D
I built a 4x4 vault door on xbox, not so much as challenging, just confusing
ItsJJstyles [GD] yeah I can’t even make a 3x3 pistón door but I’ll give it a try
@@LieutenantByrd the bottom center block and the center block are the hardest, but observers make the whole process WAYYY easier
ItsJJstyles [GD] thanks for the tips
@@LieutenantByrd you're welcome m8
0:14 in recent versions of mcbe, pistons is twice the speed compared to this clip (but still no qc or sticky pistons spitting blocks, and twice slower pistons than java)
Oh...so THAT'S why I've always been TERRIBLE at redstone (I only play on PE)
No, your just bad and making excuses LOL
ME TOO
I FEEL YOUR PAIN
Same
No, that's just an excuse, i've made every thing I've ever seen him and more in pocket edition
Yeah but you probably spend all your time on Minecraft
MCPE players : finally somebody understands us.
yeah
Yes
Yep
😂😂😂
Yes
Wait hold on... you're telling me that redstone didn't connect to pistons??
Yeah that's why he always had to use redstone torches or repeaters to make redstone connect to pistons.
I know I was just sitting there like: tf??? You mean you DONT have that????
@@salem-01 Welcome to bedrock!
As a Bedrock user, this makes everything more confusing
Yes, I think that was pretty obvious. That’s literally why he loves target blocks, because redstone dust connects to it. At least I think that’s why he loves target blocks, and I am fairly certain.
mumbo: finally plays pe
all the mobile players: YESSS
mumbo: calls it windows 10 edition
mobile players: *unimpressed observer face*
Minecraft PE and Windows 10 are both Bedrock edition. So its one and the same.
Me, who plays switch edition: *dispenser face*
I was ignorant that there was a difference in the redstone for a really long time....
Yeah....
Yeah
@Pee Pee me after seeing your comment: deopper face
dropper*
I've never played on Java before, only Bedrock edition. When I watched this video I kept thinking to myself "wait that doesn't work in Java?"
Same
Victoria Eide Berg as a bedrock player, I cringed when he used hoppers in the 3x3 piston door, because ethoslab made 3x3 piston door years ago with a hole in the middle, and it worked on bedrock! I’ve used the one ever since. Also, imagine what his reaction would be to a nether reactor core XD
@@VeryWetPaper imagine xD
Same! I didn't know redstone doesn't redirect into pistons in Java. But one thing I am EXTREMELY happy they changed is that observers detect piston retraction and extension. Even to me, a person that's been doing bedrock redstone for a few years now, that seems really weird.
Lol same
In pocket edition the stone cutter was used to make stone stairs and slabs back in the old days
hey added the useback in 1.14 which is good it has fair recipies
holy frick what the hell is you profile name
fortnite rlly? i have a question for you fortnite gamer which game is the best for you? minecraft or fortnite
@@whatthebeeepp4517 fuck off swine.
Also it made polished Diorite andesite.
I’m surprised of how different this is, I’m still surprised that redstone doesn’t connect to pistons on Java
"It's actually pretty simple"
-Mumbo but in java
As a mcpe our redstone is pretty confusing
Nah mcpe redstone is more simple
@@derpybird5629 yea
@@derpybird5629
No it's awful
@@floppademon1506 Imo it's more just different than bad, but yeah it's certainly inconsistent, hopefully it gets tweaked in the future
Redstone torches on mcpe are basically just decorations at this point
No
@@MrDonut-ch8dr Right, they are useable
They only work machinery wise for a 3 x 2 door with pressure plates at this point
They still light TNT
@@skyedreemurr-patiencesoul6171 indeed. They arent for much any more
Mumbo: Makes a giant triple piston extender
Me: Has a real small simple one.
Me: I HAVE POWER!!!
My favorite little thing that I happen to just throw together one day in PE has to be my pop-up dispenser trap. Flush to the ground and it's almost impossible to see the pressure plate. I collect so much loot from mobs that get killed just overnight wandering on to it, I'm kind of thinking about attempting to implement it into some type of farm.
Stone cutteres used to be a crafting table for stone based items!
Wendy Olsen ah I remember those days were you had to use those for stone but then go back to the crafting table for other things!
the nostalgia
I miss the old days when it was actually usable...
Who remembers the Nether Reactors, which was the only way on getting some items.
@@annihilus3681 Oh my god I remember that! Do you remember that weird "Nether" they had where it was just a block of netherack, like 10 mad zombie pigman, and quarts and glowstone thrown around on the floor?
To Mumbo: I learned how to fix the inconsistency in the double piston extender:
Double the repeater ticks.
(also this is my schematic for it):
|SP|SP| |
|R4| |RD|
|R4| |R4|
|RD|R2|RD|
|RD|RD|LV|
SP: Sticky Piston | R# = repeater with # of tick delay | RD = Redstone Dust | LV = Lever
Props to you if that works.
Noob double piston extender
|SP| |SP| | |
|RD| |R3| |RD|
|R3| |R3| |RD|
|RD| |LV| |RD|
Thanks! I’ve made very little red stone in PE that works, so this will help!
guys make this blow up so he can see this
Why are you speaking the enchanted table language
I’m a old pocket edition player the stonecutter was a old block or crafting station you used to make stone slabs and polished stuff
TheRealCatGamer same i rerember that in short its a crafting table for stone which was pointless
And neather reactor was a mini neather for mcpe
_I REMEMBER THIS_
TheRealCatGamer
I confirm.
Oh my God I remember those days
TheRealCatGamer I remember those days...
Now you know how hard it is to watch your vids and try and translate them
Its a 70% chance so we usually use it as a randomizer
I hate it I passed weeks making a very compact and fast without air in the circuit 4x4 vault piston door only to found out when the 30% comes all the circuit is destroyed
by the way this is for 3:53 the 70 percent chance is with 3 tick and 4 tick repeaters
New kind of ramdomizer
@@peglin5117 you should test piston doors 10 times before building them in survival mode
I tested It, but I still spent weekd, AND The door relies on observers so changing repeqters wouldnt work sorry por spelling
Me playing PE: Yes see the way we use redstone Mumbo
SEEE THEE WWAAAYYY!!!!
And imagine when he figures out that slime elevators don't work
SUFFER MUMBO
@@sadistfurret4205 and the flying machine do not work too
same
When you can build something Redstone that Mumbo can't: achievement unlocked
Achievement unlocked "It's quite simple really" lol it should have been like this
@@xboxonexguy8326 what can you acctually build?
I mean he did build a 3×3 piston door so can you build a 4×4?
@@vatsalsrivastav5195 I know to build an 8x8
I watched so many tutorial that I learned redstone lol
I managed a 13 block piston extender in mcpe, and though it takes forever to build, once you figure it out there is kind of an infinitely expandable design that only works on mcpe. It is weird to think that mumbo struggled to build a simple 3 piston extender
I play Minecraft Windows 10 Edition but I still watch all of your redstone tutorials and videos even though I will never be able to use them on my own!!
The stone cutter was used to make slabs and staircases out of stone, it worked like a crafting table, now it is just a decorative block...
A sad reminder of our lost block that probably will never see the sun of day again :(
Basically Me
Yes.
I remember playing MCPE about 4 years ago in it’s baby stage... no redstone, no hunger, only zombies, skeletons, spider and creepers (also zombie pigmen), tiny worlds, no caves, nether reactor cores, nether fortress/castle thingy... and alot of other stuff... i just love thinking back at minecraft and how it has changed...
Nether reactor core
I remember that time. Also the Nether Reactor thingy
“Wait! What?! Hold up! What?!?!”
My new favorite Mumbo Quote
Timestamp?
6:10
Mumbo - that's a huge redstone contraption
Me - that's tiny for pocket edition
James Thomson Pancake 123 ikr lol
James Thomson Pancake 123 unless your smart!
lol I guess pocket edition doesn't mean pocket-sized redstone :P
James Thomson Pancake 123 yeah kinda.
James Thomson Pancake 123 I saw a 7x3x10 design before.
Wow, the Piston-Redstone-Dust Behaviour really impressed me. This might actually be quite handy in some scenarios
This is ACTUALY the compactest and fastest triple puston door I've ever seen in windows 10 minecraft minute 8:50
ruclips.net/video/CnmDVRgS3-I/видео.html
1 wide door thank me later
Drago X, bruh that’s a small 3 X 3
The stone cutter was actually a block used to craft things made of stone since Mojang couldn't fit all of the coding into one block. (The crafting table.) after Mojang coded all crafting recipes into the crafting table instead of removing the stone cutter, they just removed its functionality and left it for decoration.
Hayden Cash i remember that
Wasn't that at 0.11 or 0.12
Hayden Cash Dude.. Nostalgia... I remember I kept up with all the MCPE updates... remember when they first removed the round buttons on the controls and everyone freaked out before realizing it was better? Remember when the added that nether block that you had to build a shrine around to summon netherrack, ghasts, and zombie pigmen? Do you remember where there was secret entrances people made out of sand and lava before red stone in MCPE was a concept? So many memories....
Mohammed Husain yeah
Mohammed Husain // R.I.P Nether core reactor. You will be missed
My brother: makes calculator in Minecraft pocket edition
Mumbo: It's so confusing
Wait, fo rizzle?
PS4 version now changed into pocket edition, and all my redstone contraptions now are fuckin useless
@@bryanfongo327
All the redstone in ps4 was bugs so if cannot do them that mean your buildings are just a bug
@@xrafter PS4 redstone worked well
@@bryanfongo327
Yes but there worked because there was a bugs trust me every update that comes fixes some if these bugs and when after the update non of my redstone will work
"Redstone Goes into pistons!?" that was seriously the first thing I ever learn't about Redstone
Mumbo: I Fear no man... But That Thing... Its Scares me.
"Redstone Bedrock Edition"
You should try playing MCPE now, in 2019. It's had a serious update over time
Frik i deleted it on accident a couple years ago. I downloaded it wen it was free and i saw you had to buy it now i am so Mad xD
Milan Geerts can’t u redownload it fro free
Its not PE anymore, its just Bedrock edition now. As of the Better Together update in 2017.
Oof
@@plazmikpond I was looking for you where were you? This is the comment I was looking for like....... *5 minutes*
Ughh finally I know why all ur things I try to do is not working...
I'm using pocket edition
Mac_h 5 same I'm using windows 10 and pocket edition lol
Why? If you have windows 10 why not just play the Java version?
He just said windows 10 on accident, I think.
Mac_h 5 lol me too
Correct
I just know that recently I started playing with friends, and I’m the Redstone guy of the server, so I ended up learning about bedrock Redstone, and I can say, it take a bit of adjusting but your builds do (sometimes kinda) work
Finally, he realizes how we feel,
“It’s an easy fix”
Also the Redstone: *bigger than the Eiffel Tower*
Lmao
Roses are red
Violets aren’t green
What is this game!?
Mumbo-2017
Adapt,improvise,overcome
Zníper Vutron yes
But violets *are* green, it's a damn plant
👏🙌👏🙌👏🙌
@@ahmadjalal5017 wow that rhymes bit makes no semse
Mumbo:"wait, you can direct it into the side of pistons?!"
Wait you didn't know? That's not normally a thing?!
Java is lagging.
It is not a thing in bedrock
@@ruatfela2966 it is
@@Near1-1 i meant to say java😅
@@ruatfela2966 edit that
Wait til he finds out you can light a campfire with a fire aspect book 😂😉
Love your vids mumbo plz do more bedrock video
I remember watching Mumbo's 3x3 piston door tutorial, and trying to recreate it on bedrock edition at 1:00 in the morning. I couldn't understand why it wasn't working, which was infuriating.
Same
*Mumbo plays on MCPE
me: this is how we suffer*
It's not that hard, there are good bedrock edition RUclipsrs out there like silentwisperer, navynexus, the bow tie man and so on
Yes
True
I have a channel for minecraft pe
@@vishalbhat8602 iboxytoycat or something
Stone cutter used to be used to make stone bricks and all of the special stone/sandstone/quartz items but the feature was removed because of the crafting table
That's interesting. Never realised how different the games were!
Yeah, back when MCPE wasn't a load of trash.
Mumbo Jumbo and console edition needs to update to pocket edition and I got a world with redstone contraptions :(
BTW I builded señor bumbo cactoni in my world
Mumbo Jumbo really wacky...they are two different games that just share a name as you said in your video, i play pocket edition so i really feel it
Future MFX now it is more like Java Edition with the crafting recipe being the same.
Finally jumbo feels the confusion we feel when we watch him
Nah we still more confused
Stonecutter used to be used to craft things with stone ;-;
Makes sense! I got very excited when I first saw it :D
Kenneth Wong You remember the good days
i remember those days...
Kenneth Wong I also remember those days
Kenneth Wong
Yup