How Facebook Marketplace Became SO Popular
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 апр 2023
- Facebook Marketplace has started to completely dominate the used exchange scene, becoming the place to go whether you’re looking for clothes, furniture, or used electronics - they’ve got it all. Marketplace is the only reason why many people are even still using Facebook, and we think there’s a good reason for that.
Support the channel on Patreon: / futureprooftv
Subscribe to Future Proof!
/ @futureprooftv
Follow Future Proof Health:
/ @futureproofhealth
Stay updated on our socials
Instagram: / futureprooftv
Facebook: / futureprooftv
TikTok: / futureprooftv
Reddit: / futureproof
For further reading, check out the sources for this video here:
docs.google.com/document/d/e/...
Script: Holly Maley
Editor: Matthew Veal
Lead Editor: Kirsten Stanley
Project Manager: Lurana McClure Rodríguez
Host: Levi Hildebrand
Want to work with Future Proof? Suggestions? Hate mail? Get in touch with the project manager, Lu: contact@befutureproof.ca
![KFF Singapore Badminton Open 2024 | Alfian/Ardianto (INA) [7] vs. Liang/Wang (CHN) | QF](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/g0QGafkoT2o/mqdefault.jpg)
Hey y’all! If you like the channel and what we do consider joining our Patreon! www.patreon.com/FutureProofTV
While I agree that the topics you are covering are true and important. The assertion that brands not wanting to associate with you is evidence that you are telling the truth about them is false. I could make up crazy lies about a brand and they would also probably want nothing to do with me. Patreon is a good way to diversify your income so good on you but try to stick to talking points that stand up to scrutiny. Your reputation for honesty is a strong point to make with brands that you do end up working with; as you endorsement does carry more weight (at least for me) than that of a typical RUclips channel.
Please consider offering RUclips channel membership as an alternative to Patreon.
Can you possibly apply a cheaper tier along with the €5 one? I know I can donate a custom amount but idk if I get the same benefits? 🤔 Anyway, love your content guys
I don't want to go through 3rd party apps to support you. Please put up a thanks button here on RUclips Future Proof dude.
I used to like fb marketplace. Now it is full of scammers. Also the UI got weird.
Facebook constantly screwing with their UI is something I'll never understand ... Feels like every time I jump on, it's wildly different
Yep. You’ll have to pry Craigslist from my cold dead hands
What's UI?
@@livenandlove1980 urinary infection
Is it still available?
The one thing I hate about fb marketplace is the location filter. The website just entirely disregards it. I set the filter to 40 miles and it shows me results from over 200 miles away, like what.
I've literally furnished my entire house through Marketplace, with the exception of a couch, a mattress, and a few area rugs. In a big city, even IKEA furniture is great to buy second-hand because its super easy to find someone selling the exact product you're looking for a fraction of the price. Over the years, I've even sold several items I bought from Marketplace (usually for the same price or higher) when my furniture needs changed. I absolutely love some of the unique vintage pieces I've managed to score over the years. It takes some patience to wade through the scammers and weirdos but 99% of my interactions with people have been just fine.
Honestly the team here is on the same page. Real humans usually make the experience pretty easy
My employer’s Slack has a “trading depot” channel where we buy/sell/exchange used items amongst ourselves, and it’s basically replaced FB marketplace for me. I’m lucky enough to work at a big enough organization full of motivated people to support this kind of ecosystem.
I think you're brave 😅 I'm not sure how to exchange what I'm selling. I don't want to give out my address and if I want to meet somewhere public, people usually flake.
Dude a second hand mattress is a no thanks for me personally 😅 however if I wasn’t able to receive one from my parents I’d probably be in the same boat
I used to like FB marketplace, mainly because I could buy and sell items in person within a close distance of where I lived. But then Facebook changed it so that local options are suppressed in favor of shipped items. Now most of the items on the feed are dropshipping products or bootleg stickers.
People were seriously complaining about the videos being too pessimistic? Wow people love to be coddled. I actually love your content and enjoy the take down videos. Eat the rich!
Thanks for being here!
That is the most grandma-est living room I have ever seen. I just want to chill there and eat freshly baked cookies.
Sadly no grandma on the premises but yeah that would have been choice 🙏🏼
That's actually insane how little options does US and Canada have to sell used things peer to peer. There are ebay, craigslist and fb marketplace, OfferUp + Kijiji and that's it. It worth mentioning that most of them are complete trash with ui/ux from early 2000th and lack of normal search, sorting, filters and etc. In Europe there are much better options like OLX and others
Tbh, I find Amazon's user experience outdated and not predictable as well. Everything is built on search which have some complicated algorithms preventing you from seeing what you want, but rather what they want you to see.
Very interesting! It is sad that the platform that we need to share stuff is the largest one on earth 😕
@@FutureProofTV I don't really care too much about corporations, collected personal data and everything else in this direction unless my experience is comfortable. I find all of mentioned options not good enough, at least for me, as not American. Maybe I have other expectations because I wasn't born with them and it's hard to accept. The same applies to internet/cellular prices, banking, taxi, delivery and many other areas where North America have a lot of space for improvements
@@AtalantaTheHunter I wonder why there are no good options in such a popular and easy to implement niche. You can also monetize it for profit without being greedy and people will love it.
I will definitely try it someday)
Issue is they exist but a platform is only as good as the community that even uses it for me and my area. All of those sites are dead not much people on there selling and same thing if you list something not a lot of buyers looking.
@@mrpw1402 I see it as a lack of demand. Like before Uber was established everyone was just paying insane money for taxis or food deliveries. Than they came and changed everything.
Now people use outdated and awful from ui/ux standpoint services just because they don't know that it can be done in a better way.
The same applies to other stuff, like banking, internet and carrier services, etc. Look what Mint made to cellular market in US, it looks amazing
Buying and flipping is genius. If people buy a item that needs fixing and they restore it and sell it to make a profit then good for them!
I don't mind it for furniture, since the materials and know how to repair and refinish furniture isn't something everyone has easy access to (mostly in terms of the tools), but resellers for clothing I feel less inclined to support.
I LOVE how you tell us how it is and don't sugar coat things. You all are a breath of fresh air. Keep up the reporting negative and all!
Also, Facebook groups has revitalized website forums and really has gone to a place where all these community groups either local or interest based can convene and discuss
Fun fact selling used items on ebay still charges sales tax
I love your content! I literally stalk both Future Proof and Future Proof Health. Don't feel pressure to change your content style :) I think its super informative and helps me be more aware of what I am buying into. Thanks guys!
As a mom of a baby and a toddler, i don't have time to shop for things in my house in any other way so it has been lifesaving for me. Plus i saved a fortune on baby essentials and i got the exact non toxic high quality stuff i wanted. I'm all in for it
The issue is that people try to make top dollar, prices can be ridiculous
FB really wanted me to look at Marketplace. I opened the front page and-right at the top of the push list-saw identical postings for the same phone/accessories from posters in different locations. I immediately understood that Craigslist was over. Because scams (the driver of the market) have much better advantages on FB Marketplace, and no threat of safety policies you'd become accustomed to from the old network of "just some people with email addresses."
Bless this man doing gods work! Protecting and informing the consumers! Can't do patreon rn, but will do my part in liking, sharing, subscribing and commenting for the algo!
If future proof is looking for more positive topics, y'all should look into buy nothing groups.
People in NYC at least use buy nothing heavily and it is a pure gifted economy/ dumpster diving/curb stooping. The rule is things must be free.
Buy nothing groups have their flaws, but overall if the neighborhood is active and there is a strong community presence, you can get a lot of cool things for free like furniture, random food ingredients, party supplies, clothing, etc.
Yes! Love this in Baltimore, too
I got my 1960 singer sewing machine on fb marketplace. I restored it myself and its become my main machine. Now, fb keeps showing me more vintage sewing machines and im fighting the urge to buy and restore another. I already have 3 sewing machines, i dont need more!!
The toilet paper definitely should hang as a beard; HOWEVER, as a parent of a toddler I have quickly learned that the mullet keeps the little one from unrolling the entire roll onto the floor 👏🏼 I’ll gladly make that sacrifice for now 😅
Hahaha noted! Our writing team is childless so we didn’t think of that!
Cats do the same!@@FutureProofTV
I'd love to see a video about Pact. They sell mid range clothing made with organic cotton in a fair trade factory...but I got 3/5 things in my order damaged or just not sewn correctly. What's up with that?
Levi I don't know if you ever did this but as a kid growing up in the 90's. I loved dumpster diving and going to the dump. I can't remember how much treasures I've managed to save and reuse. It actually makes me mad now that they don't let you go through the landfill. Every time I go I see so much stuff like bikes that just need some work and they'd be back to like new. I understand the safety factor of letting people go climbing over mountains of garbage and metal but to me that's unacceptable when there's perfectly fine thing's that might need a little work but still serve their purpose.
Marketplace has made garage sales SO hard to find. I followed several of those signs and they led nowhere with no one. Maybe the garage sale had listed hours on Marketplace, maybe not. I have no idea. Some friends went on a garage sale hop, and I couldn't join because I couldn't figure out where they were; they didn't think to carpool or even share addresses in the group chat because they were "just going down the FB Marketplace listings in order."
Facebook marketplace is awful. You get people that are replying on a whim because it popped into their feeds and then never show up. Craiglist people found it because they looked.
Also on the roommate front I had great success with Craiglist. 😁
i am one of those people who keeps pressing X on all marketplace on FB. and then, i once made a mistake of listing my old phone to sell...ended up getting fake messages from "buyers" all day long...
never bothered with it again
I love Marketplace for baby stuff. You can find so much for free when overwhelmed mamas just want junk gone, and on the flipside, as the overwhelmed mama myself😂 I can list outgrown stuff for free/cheap and have someone come take it off my hands within the day!! It’s been great.
It's only reason I have facebook too :D I have been basically inactive for many years, I have not posted or watched any posts for many years. But I have used messenger couple times and marketplace more than couple times.
4:02 Is the world filled with more bad actors than good ones? I believe the world is filled with way more good actors than bad ones. The main issue is that one bad actor can significantly ruin things for most of us.
Also noteworthy that people aren't inherently good or bad. Almost everyone is bad at some point and good at others. Most people are fairly neutral though. It's not really black and white 😅
The last couple times I tried using Craigslist I realized it isn’t usable anymore. I found myself having to scroll through 10+ pages of spammed posts for new $30 mattresses to find a legit post from another person. If I tried searching a different category for something else, say a bookshelf, I was bombarded by page after page of the same spammed posts. Seems like the lack of moderation is what killed Craigslist in my area.
FB Marketplace is great because it doesn’t have that problem.
Yeah sadly craigslists glory days are behind us 🥺
When I've sold used cars they require $5 to put an ad up. Not true for lower priced items?
Craiglist looks even better after watching this. My personal details arent given away and Im not bombarded with ads. It costs a few bucks to put an ad up on Craigslist but I LIKE that because it cuts down on sellers putting up thier ad 10 times per hour pushing everyone else's ad down the list.
I definitely enjoyed this video a lot more than a lot of recent ones that were a little bit more on the world is evil theme if you wanna call it that, but I will say the end of this video started transitioning back to that especially when you started talking about the gentrification of thrift goods where still somebody is Buying the good that may end up in another landfill refurbishing it, which is renewing that item, getting it out of the hands of becoming trash, which this channel sometimes supports the renewing of items. That is just my opinion though. 😊
Thanks for being here and leaving a comment 🙋🏻♂️👍🏼
@@FutureProofTV definitely! I always enjoy your weekly videos. Just wanted to provide some feedback :)
That flowery room, though.
*IT SCREAMS COOKIES AND TEA*
I sell old stuff on Marketplace and there are so many lowballers and weirdos 😭💀
Yeah it’s a minefield but it’s the best we got 😢
Hmmm I'm a medium sized Poshmark seller. Maybe I should give Marketplace a try.
You should
It’s a whole new world. 🌎
12:26 there is 100% nothing wrong with this. they put their labor into it. even if it's a crap renovation, that's up to the buyer to determine. Antique shops and restoration shops literally function on doing this. Not everyone has the time or skills to refurbish old furniture.
I got a free wine fridge on Facebook marketplace last night
Perfect. That’s what the platform is made for haha
@@FutureProofTV yeah. My girlfriend just looks at it in her free time. Lots of great used electronics on it. No need to spend $300 new when it can be had for a third of the price
I hadn't used FB Marketplace in quite a while, favouring Kijiji the last few years. But I just sold two old computer part thingies on FB and not only did I get my asking prices, they took less than a day to sell them both. Way better than Kijiji, where stuff sits for months without any bites and then all people want to do is haggle the price down to almost zero.
In Europe we have Vinted which I think had a big impact in making buying second hand goods very convenient
Just so everyone knows, you can manually change the date your pictures have been updated on your Facebook profile. Like you could see some pic saying « 8 years ago » when in actuality it’s been 5 minutes. Beware ‘cause scammers use this.
Thank you! I hate how flipping has taken over. Makes thrifting pointless.
Also we need more dance breaks, you rock 😊
I use it occasionally but will always give preference to buying and selling on Craigslist over it- I do first come first served for selling but Craigslist ALWAYS gets priority, and I’ll even make less or spend more just to avoid Facebook.
Chronological lists are just so much better for society than individual algorithms pushing engagement.
Agreed! We want Craigslist to win! 🥹
Craigslist doesn't sell your info. Scammers are on both platforms, so it's a wash there. Ebay keeps track of your sales for the taxman and charges sales tax on used items. Craigslist for the win.
Fb mp is easily the best thing about fb right now. I’ve made close to 50K reselling items that people throw away it’s insane how many crt TVs I’ve sold that have been tossed amongst hundreds of other items. 🎉
In Argentina Fb Market is used a lot as a p2p market, many people sell handmaid products, offer services or put their vehicles to sell...
I once had a woman message me on FB marketplace and tell me that she was out of gas and could I come help her. Haven't used the platform since, that was just too weird.
She thought you were a good fellow
Bro who complain about the negativity on your video ? I always smile watching them
Craigslist is my go to place to buy cars, bikes , and other random stuff. Fb market place needs Fb so im out of luck.
The same thing haopened in the UK but FB Marketplace replaced Gumtree as we've never had Craigslist.
About the toilet paper thing, I just realized it depends on how many hands you're using to cut the paper. For hand solo, mullet is way easier but if you have your two hands available, beard is definitely better.
If I wasn't already subscribed I would subscribe now as an endorsement of your objectively correct position on toilet paper mounting.
Aside from the constant scammers, I was shadow banned on there and have no idea why. I tried to buy a switch game through the market and had to buy it via PayPal invoice.
its interesting that marketplace is there but the groups still have a better experience to buy and sell, wish that they put more effort in this
I prefer Craigslist. Honestly have never had a bad experience there, and I loathe Facebooks interface, the algorithm, and the ads. Give me a simple, old-school interface with a basic timeline any day.
The lack of proper category and specification standards (for a given category), a chaotic and bad UX, and the amount of scammers makes it an awful platform to sell/buy. The only positive is the reach on the FB marketplace.
Holy F. Levi's such a vibe I literally just paused to subscribe post three sec dance then got subsequently disappointed realising I can't subscribe twice.😭
Man I just stumbled on this channel and I can’t stop watching. I’m also a marketing major so these videos are giving me great perspectives on future jobs. Keep up the great work
Craigslist is way behind and missing the boat. I still sell peer to peer on CL, but Craig has an opportunity to cashout big time if he could update his site.
Nice light green wall paint
hahahaha at the expression for your add
I Latinoamérica is the most used cuz mom's have Facebook and my mom sells and buys my brothers clothes there, specially the school uniforms since in my country even the poorest school has uniform
Is that gray book in the background the large print New World Translation?
Marketplace sucks. No customer service. No accountability. It's a scammer's paradise and full of deadbeat buyers - those who say they want to buy something, then never show up or cancel last second, never to be heard from again. It's worse than Craigslist.
The only reason I really use Facebook is for the marketplace. If there was a better option to FB marketplace, I'd probably rarely log onto FB.
Could you do one on Henson Shaving (HS) razor? It’s made in Canada. I just bought one on ebay as I tried one from zero waste club and after you posted about leaf I bought one from Poshmark which I had a bloody time with….literally. The Henson razor took no time to learn and I haven’t cut myself yet, even putting a blade in it. And such a close shave! You may be able to do an entirely positive future proof! I have no affiliation with this company, I just think it’s wonderful and don’t want them to go out of business as part of their advertising is it’s a razor to pass down through the generations and we need more products built to last. Plus this razor is so lightweight, and balanced and well engineered so that it’s almost idiot proof.
I got in trouble for trying to sell M4 magazines cause my gun broke and I was trying to get rid of them lol.
At the end I traded my rifle for a sweet guitar.
I really loved marketplace but Facebooks UI made it unable for me to list and makes sales. So now it’s just a dead button on my app that used to be great.
I love the saying "Money Can't Buy You Happiness" specially when said by millionaire and billionaire on national TV 😂
It can until past 500k
Loving the new air bnb
What a cute sitting room!
Isn't there a difference between buying something cheaply and selling it on as for 4x as much as getting paid for your time when you restore something?
Is so useful but also it frustrating how people lie here, in my country some people puts "free" and then when you contact them they tell you a price, (here the cash functions in $1000 is like a bit more than a USD, so people out on the price tag 1234 or 1111 so their announcements apear by the filter of lower price since $1000 Chilean pesos is cheap, and the worst kind is the people who put believabe cheap prices and then in the chat they tell you that the true cost is like 10.000 more than the price listed, it makes search so hard and wasting time, and is being dishonest
Never used F marketplace, left Fbook like 2011 ?
You’re missing out 😬
I collect antique ivory carvings and taxidermy from endangered species like sea turtles, but neither of these things are allowed to be sold on Facebook Marketplace as stated specifically in their TOS. That doesn't stop the algorithm from showing me numerous postings of exactly what I'm looking for along with other prohibited items I didn't know I wanted, almost like the algorithm knows exactly what is being posted and doesn't remove it on purpose.🤔😁
I personally don't have a problem with your past videos taking a somewhat negative bent. Even on products or services that I like.
Many of your reasons why “facebook marketplace worked” could apply to facebook dating too. Why didn’t facebook dating work then?
Good question? Maybe it was too transparent? Don’t wanna see people you know?
Re: "negative tone", I've found Future Proof's takes really balanced. I mean... Things like coffee pods and Coca-Cola do suck, so what else can you say in the video.
I like the positive balance
Nextdoor is pretty good, especially for furniture! Trash site otherwise, but minimal scams.
I hate the $100 scams
carousel app is kinda cool place for 2nd hand stuff
Craigslist is still around? had no idea...
my dad found the house me and my parents rent still to this day we found it on Facebook marketplace
Surprised there's not more mention of eBay in these comments
Is it still available?
Maybe do like a month out of the year with only good new positive vibes type vids?
Video idea: toilet paper vs bidet
I got scammed out of 4k on Facebook market place last August lol. Or well, I also got a car but I ended up paying more to fix the damn thing since they lied about what I was getting. Oh well haha
Bring an inspector next time. I've done that too. Not inspecting the vehicle good enough.
@@dannydaw59 fr, def learned my lesson 😅😂 ill be way more weary next time, if there even is a next time haha
I got my wedding dress on UsedVictoria!
I sold 3 items on FB marketplace :)
The main problem with facebook marketplace is the lack of moderation; all the posts where i am are listed with the wrong price lol
Was the price wrong because it was more than you wanted to pay?
I hate when they set the price to free and then put the real price in the description
1:36 well, if you'd be spreading false information about all kinds of brands then most companies would also not want to sponsor you. I don't know exactly which logical fallacy applies to the argument you made, but I know for sure that it's not logically sound.
From what I can tell it definitely doesn't seem like you're spreading false information, so the fact that less companies want to sponsor you is indeed a good sign.
The logic in the argument was the wrong way around. It doesn't show that what you're saying is true, but when the things you're saying is true then it shows that those companies are afraid of valid critique. That is definitely a good sign 😊
Ps, after I learned about logical fallacies I've been seeing them all over the place. Avoiding them helps us all make better arguments. So while the argument I mentioned is very insignificant, I still think it's a good opportunity to learn ❤
Ps2, When I get an income I'll become a patron again!
Craigslist has become nothing more than junk. Doesn't matter what I search for the only results that come back are 20 ads for led garage lights. FB market makes it easier to suss out scammers. If a too good to be true item is listed in 50 cities and the owner is on vacation it's a dead giveaway.
Much prefer negative videos, this just felt wrong. Also wouldn't use FB Marketplace if you paid me 😂😂😂. (Love your content though)
Marketplace is literally the only reason I still have Facebook
I've heard there is a lot of ripoffs and scams on FB Marketplace!
Im on marketplace while watching this. lol
No taxes, thats why
I hate FB marketplace because it requires an FB account. The last thing anyone who cares about their digital footprint should want is an FB account. I prefer Craigslist because I don't need an account.
What it FB Marketplace carries over into the Metaverse instead of Facebook proper?
I quit FB years ago
That 3 second dance break turned into pelvic thrusting real quick
He’s got one move…