When I first learnt about verdict of SC introducing basic structure doctrine, it gave me the goosebumps!! Indeed the greatest judgement in the history of Indian judiciary to protect republic!!!
तारीख का ये एपिसोड वाकई शानदार था। हम लोग lucent में कितने दिनों से पढ़ते आ रहे थे केशवानंद भारती बनाम केरल राज्य । लेकिन आज तक कुछ खास समझ में नहीं आया था। लेकिन आज के बाद संभवतः दुबारा पढ़ने की आवश्यकता नहीं पड़ेगी। बहुत बहुत आभार The Lalantop ❤️
Many lawyers today don't know about Nani Palkihvala and his contribution to the Indian legal system. Every lawyer worth His salt should read about Nani Palkihvala.
I regret for having studied in English Medium School & used to listening to English News Channel. I opened this channel by chance but I felt so happy because wanted information on great Jurist Nani Palkhivala & the most famous Case in Jurisprudence. God Bless
Thanks for providing the episode on shri nanipalkiwala ji. Great person, great soul, great lawyer. He will definetly rank in top lawyers of the world as mentioned in your video🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Indebted to Palkhivala... Judges of the SC were bought by Indira Gandhi to turn the decision in her favour ... It was the thriller at the end which turned the tide.
Sir ye constitution kesa hota hai kuch paper hain ya kitaab ya granth...aur....ye sirf sarkar ke paas hi rehta hai ya hum aam public bhi dekh padh skte hain plz reply?
Nice article sir. We are happy that no government of previous period tried to defame him. Call him antinational,. His name was written in golden words and all the governments kept it as it is , no one destroyed his image , at that time media was not biased and spoke the truth . If Nana palhakhiwala incident happened in current situation, then he would have been treated as pro china , pro Pakistan, anti Indian , corrupt etc
Nope he fought for hindu temples as keshvananda was the seer of hindu math and kerala antihindu govt wanted to occupy it and eliminate hinduism and implement christianity and islam on india
Nikhil.... Kamal.... Jatin.... Best combination ever ✌ Its very ctitical topic to explain and understand also... My MPSC teacher also can't explain it properly... 🤷♂️
Such a great person is out from our school history books where Keshwanand Bharti case we study in ncert but no seperate chapter for Nani Palkiwala in History or law
बेवक़ूफ़ लोगो को पता नहीं है न्यायिक प्रणाली imperial power and domination over others for their wrongful gains hurting rights of others imperialistic structure Anti Democracy not acceptable to people in Democracy. Pil No.224 of 2017 सुप्रीम कोर्ट में याचिका अंतरिम संविधान 1950 से ब्रिटिश कालोनी विधि structure ढांचे उन्मूलन हेतु दायर लेकिन सुप्रीम कोर्ट चीफ जस्टिस जगदीश सिंह केहर और Dy Chandrachur अभी चीफ जस्टिस इन्कार दिनाँक 10,07,2017 क्यों कि ब्रिटिश colonialist न्यायिक प्रणाली सुप्रीम कोर्ट हैं जो संविधान का आवश्यक मौलिक ढांचे के रूप में बिना समीक्षा प्रोफेसर केटी शाह संविधान drafting कमिटी के सदस्य के समीक्षा प्रस्ताव ठुकरा कर लार्ड माउंट बेटन वायसराय अंतरिम आजाद भारत गणराज्य द्वारा मनमानी शामिल हैं जिसका दुष्प्रभाव अवैध शराब जुआ अश्लीलता अवैध जमीन कब्जा अवैध निर्माण अवैध खनन आर्थिक अपराध MP Minister MLA IAS IPS के साठगांठ माफिया लोगों और बाहुबलियों द्वारा मनमानी उगाही करते हैं सुप्रीम कोर्ट colonialist संचालक banned Parliament from changing essential basic structure of constitution which is undefined British colonial legislation structure temporarily incorporated in interim constitution.
Kafi galat ho tum Aise bahut sare judge h sc me jo openly anti-government hain Tumhe kya lagta h ye collegium system pe itna vivad kyon ho rha h Cool dikhne ke liye tum log kuch v likh dete ho
Us waqt supreme court 56 muslim countries ke kabje main under control kaam kar rahi thi jiska bada example ki Kashmir genocide ko sunane se mana kar diya tha...learn first SC verdict since independence..than say bogus .👍
Aisa kaha jata hai ki jab Nani Palkhivala Samvidhaan ke basic structure ke liye argue kar rahe the to lag raha tha jaise God khud aakar court mein argue kar rahe hain.
Few corrections 1) HM seervai was his senior and 14 years elder than him 2) his first famous case was not Anglo Indian school case. His first famous case was Advani case in 1948
Palkhiwalla came up against a Powerful PM, but she had respect for the Constitution. She was powerful, but believed in the fabric of a constitutional democracy. The situation is different in todays India.
![Jack Harlow - Hello Miss Johnson [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Q86_nlRoIGw/mqdefault.jpg)
बहुत ही शानदार, नानी पालकीवाला जी के बारे में जानने की बहुत उत्सुकता थी जो आज पूरी हुई, बहुत ही अच्छा संकलन है
When I first learnt about verdict of SC introducing basic structure doctrine, it gave me the goosebumps!! Indeed the greatest judgement in the history of Indian judiciary to protect republic!!!
😢
उन महाशय का कोटि कोटि धन्यवाद
आज हम स्वतंत्र हवा में सांस ले रहे है इसके लिए ऐसे महानुभाव का धन्यवाद।
तारीख का ये एपिसोड वाकई शानदार था। हम लोग lucent में कितने दिनों से पढ़ते आ रहे थे केशवानंद भारती बनाम केरल राज्य । लेकिन आज तक कुछ खास समझ में नहीं आया था। लेकिन आज के बाद संभवतः दुबारा पढ़ने की आवश्यकता नहीं पड़ेगी। बहुत बहुत आभार The Lalantop ❤️
Kya Aaj aysa sambhaw hai?
@@shamimuddinali3968 bilkul
Beta kitab se padhna sikho... Har chiz par video nahi milega 😂
ye to trailer samjho. puri kahaani sunni hai to vikas divykirti sir ki video dekho.
Isne to kuchh aesa nhi btaya jo aapko sab kuch smjh aagya is se, sirf basic structure ka hi to nam liya h
भारतके सर्वोच्च न्यायालयके वकील नानी पालखीवाला को कोटी कोटी प्रणाम!
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
Many lawyers today don't know about Nani Palkihvala and his contribution to the Indian legal system.
Every lawyer worth His salt should read about Nani Palkihvala.
every lawyer knows about nani palkhiwala
I regret for having studied in English Medium School & used to listening to English News Channel.
I opened this channel by chance but I felt so happy because wanted information on great Jurist Nani Palkhivala & the most famous Case in Jurisprudence.
God Bless
आपने विधिज्ञ नानी पालखीवाला के बारेमे बहोत दिलचस्प जानकारी दी . आपका दिलसे शुक्रिया अदा करता हूं
Such a historic and brave person he should be in our textbooks too. Another awesome episode Sir ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Thanks for providing the episode on shri nanipalkiwala ji. Great person, great soul, great lawyer. He will definetly rank in top lawyers of the world as mentioned in your video🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Thanks for remembering the Legend....Such Legends are rare in today's world.
Historic episode 👌 और मतलब समझ आ गया इस बात का कि इतिहास वही लिखते है जो जीतते है
Thank you for making me aware of the great LAWYER Mr. Nani Palkhivala
Dont discontinue this history series because right history knowledge is very necessary at that time
Very well written. Came to know about some unknown facts of the legendary Nani Palkiwala.
आपने तो अध्यापकों से भी अच्छा समझाया 🙏🙏🙏
And the unholy alliance continues.....Thoroughly researched Taarikh with unassuming clarity of Nikhil....What a treat
शानदार एपिसोड,नानी पालकी बाला अपनी विद्वता के कारण इतिहास में अमर रहेंगे।
बहुत बहुत ही ज्ञानवर्धन एपीसोड धन्यवाद ललनटाप टीम कमल बहुत ही अच्छा लिखता है लिखिल का प्रस्तुतिकरण अनुकरणीय है
Fantastic.....The anecdotes were simply awesome.....Keep up the good work, Team....Will follow you from today onwards...
As an ardent student of Constitution, I believe that we should be ever indebted to the Supreme Court for saving our Constitution time and again. 🙏🙏🙏
Strongly agree 💪⚖️
Indebted to Palkhivala... Judges of the SC were bought by Indira Gandhi to turn the decision in her favour ... It was the thriller at the end which turned the tide.
@@Daily_Facta used
Sir ye constitution kesa hota hai kuch paper hain ya kitaab ya granth...aur....ye sirf sarkar ke paas hi rehta hai ya hum aam public bhi dekh padh skte hain plz reply?
"बिना petition के review हो ही क्यों रहा है!" Epic 👏🏻
Your narration is simply superb, am an advocate at SCBA and i am unaware of these facts, I wish I could gift you a bottle of Chivas regal.
अब इस समय
एक और नानि पालकीवाला की आवश्यक्ता है ,
आज भी सविंघान संकट में है ।
Best joke ever
Kya likha hai 🫡.. isse behatareen likhai Bahut samay se na Dekhi hai na suni hai .. Adbhut .. Dhanyawaad Lallantop
Aap ka tarikh section bhut acha h...keep continue
Well done lallantaop
Nice article sir. We are happy that no government of previous period tried to defame him. Call him antinational,. His name was written in golden words and all the governments kept it as it is , no one destroyed his image , at that time media was not biased and spoke the truth . If Nana palhakhiwala incident happened in current situation, then he would have been treated as pro china , pro Pakistan, anti Indian , corrupt etc
Nope he fought for hindu temples as keshvananda was the seer of hindu math and kerala antihindu govt wanted to occupy it and eliminate hinduism and implement christianity and islam on india
Dont omit your ommission here without any example .
Dont be a script writer too.
बहुत सुन्दर निखिल जी।
one of the best decisions ever taken by supreme court. salute to both hr khanna and nani palkhiwala
Itne badiya aur mahan vakil ke baare me kabhi kyu nhi suna maine. Thank you lallantop for this story.
Desh me Aap jaise meadia Wale ki Bahot zarurat Hai...
Yaha Pakistan ki baat nahi ho raha hai
शानदार ऐतिहासिक किस्सों को लाने के लिए श्री कमल जी और उनकी टीम को मेरी तरफ से खाने की लिए आमंत्रण।
Ekdam badhiya episode...for the great NANI...sadar vandan..🙏. Aap ko aur aapki team ko dhanyawad
Superb writing by Kamal 👌👌
A very great personality nani palkiwala sir🙏🏻🙏🏻..... feeling very excited to know about him and his wonderful works 🙏🏻🙏🏻
Excellent knowledge building reporting
Thanks a lot
Thank you so much sir 👏 you are a very good anchor 👏👏
Thanku tarikh lallantop team😍
Behtareen episode maja aa gaya
Nikhil.... Kamal.... Jatin.... Best combination ever ✌ Its very ctitical topic to explain and understand also... My MPSC teacher also can't explain it properly... 🤷♂️
Nikhil sir
Mere Nana Hon'ble Justice S.N. Dwivedi ji is mamle m 13 judges ki bench m se ek Judge the......
Outstanding writing and presentation...
Very nice 👌 sir, every years ke sc ke case ka faisla ka ak series ho ske to la dijiye. Please 🙏🙏
Such a great person is out from our school history books where Keshwanand Bharti case we study in ncert but no seperate chapter for Nani Palkiwala in History or law
Proud to be GLC student
THIS IS THE BEST EPISODE OF TARIKH
Very good informative video 💐thanx nikhil sir
Great explanation 👌
भाई आप कमाल हो आप बहुत अच्छा बोलते हो
Marvellous presentation
बहुत शानदार विश्लेषण
Excellent presentation kudos 👍
Nikhil bhai...wo case R. C Kapoor nhi R.C Cooper v. Union of india tha....jis bank nationalization ke naam se bhi jaante hain.
निखिल सर बहुत अच्छी प्रस्तुति
@5.50 dobara bata diya taki yaad rahe. Waha kya pose diya Nikhil bhai. Bahut badhiya 😄
Bharat desh loktantra ko bachane Wale nanipalkhivala ko sadar pranam 🙏💐
Bharat Desh ke log sadahi apke runi rahenge
Bahut khub nikhil bhai. A great episode.
नानी पालखीवाला और केशवानंद भारती जी को धन्यवाद.
बेवक़ूफ़ लोगो को पता नहीं है न्यायिक प्रणाली imperial power and domination over others for their wrongful gains hurting rights of others imperialistic structure Anti Democracy not acceptable to people in Democracy. Pil No.224 of 2017 सुप्रीम कोर्ट में याचिका अंतरिम संविधान 1950 से ब्रिटिश कालोनी विधि structure ढांचे उन्मूलन हेतु दायर लेकिन सुप्रीम कोर्ट चीफ जस्टिस जगदीश सिंह केहर और Dy Chandrachur अभी चीफ जस्टिस इन्कार दिनाँक 10,07,2017 क्यों कि ब्रिटिश colonialist न्यायिक प्रणाली सुप्रीम कोर्ट हैं जो संविधान का आवश्यक मौलिक ढांचे के रूप में बिना समीक्षा प्रोफेसर केटी शाह संविधान drafting कमिटी के सदस्य के समीक्षा प्रस्ताव ठुकरा कर लार्ड माउंट बेटन वायसराय अंतरिम आजाद भारत गणराज्य द्वारा मनमानी शामिल हैं जिसका दुष्प्रभाव अवैध शराब जुआ अश्लीलता अवैध जमीन कब्जा अवैध निर्माण अवैध खनन आर्थिक अपराध MP Minister MLA IAS IPS के साठगांठ माफिया लोगों और बाहुबलियों द्वारा मनमानी उगाही करते हैं सुप्रीम कोर्ट colonialist संचालक banned Parliament from changing essential basic structure of constitution which is undefined British colonial legislation structure temporarily incorporated in interim constitution.
Very nicely prepared and presented
Very beautifully described!
Ham to samj rahe the 16th January ko sirpha aam aadmi hi janma lete hai...magar ye kahani sunkar feel proud...😇
Bahut shandar prastuti.
So so so thank you for remembering the legend ❤️❤️
some people got and spread the best of knowledge and how it works.
hatts-of for those who understand the meaning of what is right... 🙏🙏...
So beautiful explanation i really like a lot this video 😊😊😊
Republic doesn't means presence of constitution. It simply means that head of state will be elected and not monarch.
Y....we have been taught same. Republic is where Head of State is elected.
Exactly! He was wrong at the start.
Nice video
Jai Hind
Jai Badri Vishal
Episode तो शानदार है
लेकिन UPSC वाले ईत्तू से के लिए ये VIDEO थोड़ी देखेंगे
असल मे ये सिर्फ LAWYERS के लिए है...😀
Ye upsc walo ke liye or jada perfect hai ..law ke liye or jada pdhna parta
कमल जी(इतना बढ़िया लिखने के लिए) और निखिल जी(इतनी सुंदर प्रस्तुति के लिए) की सैलरी बढ़ाई जानी चाहिए.🙏
Great knowledge
Nanibhai Jijibhai Palkhivala par ek hit and best movie ban sakti hai.... he was the best...😍😍
@3:27 R C कपूर नहीं *कूपर* है ।
Best story teller ❤️with awesome content
Kaha se latey ho yarrr
Saurabh sair achhi analysis kartey ho
Wow! Cool work
J R D TATA, R A T A N TATA, N A N I P A L K H I W A LA ARE ALL THE JEWELS OF OUR NATION AND ARE ALL EVER-REMEMBERED PERSONS IN THE HISTORY OF INDIA.
Even Feroze Ghandy (not gandhi) ,we must read his contribution in indian politics...Pl check wiki n other sources.
Ese hi knowledgeable apisode banate rahe good job
बहुत शानदार पुरानी जानकारियां
Ukpsc ke bharti ghotale pr report bnaye sir
Bche presan h pcs se lekr constebl tak sbhi papr phle se leek ho jate h
Or koi kuch nhi krta
Thank you sir 🙏📖🙌
Aap bahut acha bolte hai..❤❤❤🙏🙏
Nani palkhiwala ki Jai ho
So knowledgeable, thanks
उस समय उच्चतर कोर्ट सरकार के कब्जे में नहीं हुआ करती थी? आजकल कोर्ट के कई जजों पर सरकार का कब्जा है।
अच्छा 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Haan bhai ye wahi evm wale mamle jaise lag raha hai aagar election hae gaye to EVM hack ho gaya tha aur aagar Jeet Gaye to sub theek tha 😂😂😂😂
Kafi galat ho tum
Aise bahut sare judge h sc me jo openly anti-government hain
Tumhe kya lagta h ye collegium system pe itna vivad kyon ho rha h
Cool dikhne ke liye tum log kuch v likh dete ho
नादान बालक है ये
Us waqt supreme court 56 muslim countries ke kabje main under control kaam kar rahi thi jiska bada example ki Kashmir genocide ko sunane se mana kar diya tha...learn first SC verdict since independence..than say bogus .👍
Outstanding work !!!
Aisa kaha jata hai ki jab Nani Palkhivala Samvidhaan ke basic structure ke liye argue kar rahe the to lag raha tha jaise God khud aakar court mein argue kar rahe hain.
Nice information 🙏🙏🙏.
Shaandar episode ❤️
Bahut badhiya.
Great episode like always!!!
Very Nice description
Few corrections
1) HM seervai was his senior and 14 years elder than him
2) his first famous case was not Anglo Indian school case. His first famous case was Advani case in 1948
Wooooow great presentation by Nikhil
Nani Palkhivala legend❤
भाई साहाब
कमाल की प्रस्तुती थी 😍😇😇gbu
According to Dr Vikas divyakirti sir, kesavananda Bharati case ka faisla 709 ka tha nahin ki 703.
In one word... thankyou .
Shandar 👌👌👏👏
Palkhiwalla came up against a Powerful PM, but she had respect for the Constitution. She was powerful, but believed in the fabric of a constitutional democracy. The situation is different in todays India.
Accha....
Leftist gang initiated the chat....😅
Very nice episode created by Lallantop
Thank you ❤❤❤❤