Making music: HUMAN vs A.I.
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
- Welcome to Nebula Studio based in Warsaw, Poland.
Need to record something, maybe mix/master?
📩 nebulastudiopoland@gmail.com
🔴 Instagram: / thatpolishrocker
🔴 Tides From Nebula (my band): cutt.ly/LjiIHlV
No AI would replace the rush of feelings you get when playing instruments together with people in a room.
? ok but people would be out of a job. Imagine explaining to your kids you cant find work in the music industry anymore, but dont worry kids I still get a "rush of feelings when I play with my friends in a room"!!!
@@ZachBuckley move on and work with whatever gives you money. Nobody is complaining that they cannot live connecting phone lines anymore or driving carriages etc. Progress is just that.
What exactly would ai be ‘progressing’? In any field that is not artistically based, you would have a point. Ai could hugely progress modern medicine to make new vaccines that cost less for example. But music isn’t about progress it’s about expression. The industry wouldn’t be ‘progressed’ if every song that was played on the radio was made by a robot… is that your idea of progress? Sounds like a dystopia. Also what do you mean ‘move on’ songwriters mixers master engineers are all at risk by software like this, what role in the industry do they move to?
I think technology such as A.I. will give birth to a "renaissance" in arts.
especially in music.
I don't know how, when or even if the "renaissance" is already here.
The first sign of a "renaissance" could/can be:
A trend in acoustic music streams on streaming platforms and maybe more people will go watch live music then before. (if its not already happening now already)
The IDENTITY of the artists cannot be easily replaced by AI.
How would they sell the album?
Who is the singer?
What is the "name" of that AI? A product name? A human name?
Will they advertise the AI as an "individual"? An "AI"? Or an AI company?
So many questions to be sorted out.
Most of those questions have already been answered with the Hatsune Miku mascot. There are people who are perfectly happy going to a concert with an animated artist.
@@DuTuben32 Yeah, so 1 AI = 1 individual artist. Thousands of us using the same AI = still 1 individual AI artist. ONE ONLY.
10 AIs = 10 individual artists.
The way people make 1 AI popular is the same as how people make 1 artist popular. 1 AI cannot replace thousands of individual artists easily.
Gorillaz
Relax, soon people will realize that authentity is the thing .. there will be a short period of it, then people will loose interets .. it'll become a part of an artistic inspiration source just like the radio was :)
I hope 😔
@@collector1767 Humans can't live without authencity - You saw in during the pandemic, it was ok with 'onlive live shows' for a very short period, and then people was fed up not being able to participate in-person :-)
Ai still has a hard time to do artistic stuff - it sticks to the common denominator that the industry has paved the way for.
So as long as we avoid any common formula, we ought to be good!
Also it's easy to spot if it is a classic band/constellation performing together or if it is the equivalent to Nilli Vanilli thing.
kind of starting at the same point as image AI like midjourney. Where it was not so good at first, then it gets better and people start getting actually good results. but it is always low quality(in terms of pixel resolution, the results can be stunning) and has to be upscaled for it to be usable commercially. but for getting drafts and inspiration for actual graphical artists to base their work off is viable. I assume it is trained the same way by analyzing a bunch of songs/images to train the prompts, however the issue with this is always the artists do not get compensated even if the algorithm is heavily influenced by their styles
At this point you could have it write the song, and then cover it w better fidelity. But as you say, it's a matter of time.
That is why live gigs are important, direct feedback between artist and audience is something that AI is not able to recreate, at least yet
AI gets constant feedback during training, and through users as well. Plus the more it practices, the better it gets.
Todays machine learnig based tools like suno just generate sound bits second for second based on probability. Unless there's real AI that understands what it's doing, there's no creative process. This means you can't adapt and change aspects of a song. So there's background music that's it can do well and personalized fun stuff. And inspiration for song writing of course.
We're quite far away from a real AI. And as these tools don't understand what they're doing the sound quality will always be mushy. No wonder metal sounds best, because or all the distortion.
It's good for inspiration and tool, but it should be illegal if they use real music to Train
yeah... its music, but not like a heart warming connection with a musician. Art should never have been about money anyway, I feel very sorry for those who will loose work, really I do, fuck this shit for those people. But artists, nothing can replace the value of human art, this is a whole other 'thing', without the elements of what connects us with any kind of art...the human. But yeah, fuck AI
There is one thing that AI will never be able to do: take away the joy of creating for creating's sake. (Unless we let it.) I do wonder about ownership of AI-generated music, how it could possibly be licensed for commercial use by anyone. In my experience exclusive music publishers and libraries are very concerned about these things.
Most songs in my country are undocumented.. Good luck AI
0 AI FOR MY STUDIO!
Excelente
AI has no creativity, if your music in on par with music a AI can replicate than youre not really a musician, as someone that makes music your just a person that has a job of playing instruments and puting together arrangements that lack creativity enoughto claim youre creating music
Nobody will pay for composition no more, no label will pay for it and no producer will care about it...I know cuz they don't pay for it now, it's all recycled