What Classical Conversations Got Wrong

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024

Комментарии • 115

  • @josephalbatross5961
    @josephalbatross5961 3 месяца назад +8

    The realization that we have these negative holidays is so eye opening.

  • @VIsionsOfJenna
    @VIsionsOfJenna 3 месяца назад +16

    As a homeschool mom myself: women cannot be trusted alone with this. Husbands and fathers need to be involved.

  • @darrelljackson6175
    @darrelljackson6175 3 месяца назад +21

    "Truly free" in light of our secular worldview terrifies me.

  • @piscesrenewed479
    @piscesrenewed479 3 месяца назад +9

    Hello Jon. I am a member of the Classical Conversations community that used to meet at your church (we moved to another church this past year). Thank you so much for sharing this. I had no idea about this Facebook post, nor did anyone else that I know of in my community. We are appalled. I'm also really shocked and disgusted to see how many CC members liked the post. I plan on emailing the president of CC and sharing your video with him. I believe he will be very concerned. I listen to his podcast regularly and he is openly anti-woke. My community also had the opportunity to meet the founder, Leigh Bortins, last month and she seems patriotic, conservative, and anti-woke as well. Again, thank you for bringing this to the public eye. It needed to be done.

    • @standingonthepromises285
      @standingonthepromises285 3 месяца назад +3

      Agree! Fellow CC member

    • @dingotomtom
      @dingotomtom 3 месяца назад +2

      That's why john's channel is so important to get this information out

  • @jeanarmstrong4182
    @jeanarmstrong4182 3 месяца назад +20

    I'm feeling like it's a forced holiday, pushes an ideology more than a historical celebration.

    • @DM-dk7js
      @DM-dk7js 3 месяца назад

      ….forced holiday lol? Do you guys even listen to yourselves? What’s the problem with that?!

  • @cosmictreason2242
    @cosmictreason2242 3 месяца назад +16

    I've been leery of CC and this just makes me want to make my kids read a book. No co-ops.

    • @Naomi_OB
      @Naomi_OB 3 месяца назад +3

      Dont be too hesitant about coops. Not all co-ops are CC. I've always been suspect of CC as well.
      Our coop js super Biblically based and very strict standards against any of this sneaking in. Hopefully, you could find one like ours too 🙏🏻

    • @wef0711
      @wef0711 2 месяца назад

      We’ve been in CC for 12 years and this is the first time I’ve seen or been made aware of anything remotely woke in their ideology. A little concerning to say the least.

  • @lindsay.coggin
    @lindsay.coggin 3 месяца назад +11

    Our family was a part of CC from K-5 through Challenge 1 (9th grade). The curriculum itself is pretty good. With the right leaders to frame discussions around truth it can be a great program. However, the curriculum is broad enough that with the wrong leaders, it all becomes left leaning. So I would say don’t be afraid of CC. But choose your group wisely and ensure that it is filled with like minded, truth conscious people. We did leave to use the Omnibus curriculum which gives us a more in depth study of the Western tradition.

    • @smithmusicstudies
      @smithmusicstudies 3 месяца назад +3

      Thanks for the input. We are doing foundations this year for the first time. Seems like a good community, so I'm hopeful.

    • @lindsay.coggin
      @lindsay.coggin 3 месяца назад +3

      @@smithmusicstudies we loved it until the challenge years. Then the class becomes very discussion oriented. If you have a left leaning tutor and/students, those conversations are not framed in truth. That was a reason we left. I lead a small group currently that uses the Omnibus curriculum and we love that our families are all like minded!

    • @smithmusicstudies
      @smithmusicstudies 3 месяца назад +3

      @@lindsay.coggin I've heard from a few people they loved it for foundations, but not the latter years. My kids are all foundations age and quite frankly, I'm better teaching older children than younger. I mainly joined because I could use some help in engaging younger kids. I also like the classical model. It sounds like the quality is very community dependant.

    • @lindsay.coggin
      @lindsay.coggin 3 месяца назад +3

      @@smithmusicstudies you nailed it! The guides/curriculum for upper levels are good. But the success of those years is extremely tutor and community dependent. If you can tutor the upper level and lead the class how you want it could be great. We have a couple of very conservative groups here but also several squishy and left leaning groups. Good luck! Enjoy the foundations years. We still sing our songs! They come in handy!

    • @lindsay.coggin
      @lindsay.coggin 3 месяца назад +2

      @@smithmusicstudies good luck! The memory work is fantastic. My kids are HS and we still sing our songs. I’m teaching grammar to some younger kids and I’m always singing the parts of speech songs I made up. Haha.

  • @wwad18
    @wwad18 2 месяца назад +1

    I’m sorry that CC is going to be known for this post alone by many. My son just graduated this year. We used CC as our curriculum for 8 years. It was an amazing experience for us in many ways. They teach critical thinking. Kids read books and discuss and in our classes there truly was diversity of thought expressed and the kids were encouraged to research and debate. The curriculum is heavy on debate and I was constantly amazed at the students, including my son, and their ability to reason through a topic. I have been so blessed to be present in class and to continue those discussions at home. I am very thankful for this curriculum.

  • @standingonthepromises285
    @standingonthepromises285 3 месяца назад +6

    Wow! We are in CC since age 4 😢. My oldest just graduated. You are right Jon, we should be able to see through!

  • @standingonthepromises285
    @standingonthepromises285 3 месяца назад +7

    I shared American Monuments for a debate we do in Challenge 2. ❤ Its great for our art studies.

  • @betty8173
    @betty8173 3 месяца назад +6

    Thapnk you, always common sense with gidliness, may God continue to bless you

  • @keeperofthedomus7654
    @keeperofthedomus7654 3 месяца назад +7

    Four years in and people still haven't heard of it. People were surprised when a court case I was following had a holiday that day and they asked what holiday it was. These are intelligent and patriotic Americans.

  • @kathleensanford1950
    @kathleensanford1950 3 месяца назад +4

    Thanks Jon. We'll said.

  • @johfu4705
    @johfu4705 3 месяца назад +2

    Thanks brother for your discernment ministry!

  • @carolberubee
    @carolberubee 3 месяца назад +4

    My work week begins on Sunday evening and ends on Thursday evening. This year, the company removed Easter Sunday from our holiday list and added Juneteenth. Aside from the obvious hit against a Christian holiday, it also means we now have no Spring holidays. We have no days off from New Year's Day until Memorial Day. Five full months. And then, we have Juneteenth and Independence Day right on the heels of Memorial Day. Stupid. All in the name of D E I.

  • @ericthehalfmexican9187
    @ericthehalfmexican9187 3 месяца назад +5

    I had been searching for a new homeschool curriculum after canceling time 4 learning. CC will definitely not replace it.

    • @piscesrenewed479
      @piscesrenewed479 3 месяца назад +2

      The CC curriculum is solid and patriotic, though I can understand your caution. This post does not match anything expressed by the founder, Leigh Bortins, or her son and current president, Robert Bortins, who is as anti-woke as they get. I am emailing them about this today for an explanation. I am outraged by it and so are the others in my CC community. It is a complete contradiction to what is taught in CC.

    • @2024nehemiah
      @2024nehemiah 3 месяца назад

      @@piscesrenewed479good on you for messaging them. Hopefully it will help. My reaction to something like this is that if a post like this somehow made it out, even if it was just one employee, how did that person get hired and stay employed? How many more are there? When something this ridiculous rises to the surface, the rot is always much deeper. Even if they respond in the right way, unless there is essentially an internal inquisition to purge the org of the people who have leftist/regime views, the direction of CC remains unchanged.

    • @ericthehalfmexican9187
      @ericthehalfmexican9187 3 месяца назад +3

      @@piscesrenewed479 Hopefully it’s just a rogue intern or social media manager. Executives really need to keep an eye on their company’s public facing presence to make sure it always in line with their values.

    • @piscesrenewed479
      @piscesrenewed479 3 месяца назад +2

      @@ericthehalfmexican9187 That is my prayer. And I completely agree: as hard as it may be and no matter how big their companies get, executives really do need to watch that stuff. Those are the little doses of rat poison that can bring a quality organization down. I hope that does not happen with CC. I really do love their curriculum and community model and would hate to have to move on to something else.

  • @joybarcus2792
    @joybarcus2792 3 месяца назад +4

    Thank you for this

  • @TheChristianImperialist
    @TheChristianImperialist 3 месяца назад +5

    As a Texan, let me help with the geography. During the 1860s the majority of the population were in East Texas, that's where the plantations were. Ports were obviously important so the rest of the population was along the Gulf (hence the day the news arrived to Galveston Bay).
    Central Texas scarcely settled due to it recently being Comanche territory. West Texas was still very Indian.

  • @bc5441
    @bc5441 3 месяца назад +10

    44 days off for federal workers.
    I had to work on Juneteenth, but I missed my mail that day.

    • @mrleemrleeohmrlee
      @mrleemrleeohmrlee 3 месяца назад +1

      What are these 44 days? I'm a federal worker and I'm not sure where this number comes from. I only count 10 federal holidays.

    • @smithmusicstudies
      @smithmusicstudies 3 месяца назад

      ​@@mrleemrleeohmrleeyup. Only 10

    • @solideomusical
      @solideomusical 3 месяца назад

      Banks were closed, state buildings open, post office closed...

    • @bc5441
      @bc5441 3 месяца назад +1

      @@mrleemrleeohmrlee the 44 days are a combination of the average number of vacation days, sicks days and holidays available to a federal employee.

  • @PanhandleFrank
    @PanhandleFrank 3 месяца назад +4

    I used to not care about Juneteenth, one way or the other. Neither fer nor agin.
    Then this year, Facebook showed me dozens of different T-shirt designs, all with this slogan: “Free - _ish_ since 1865”
    And when I Googled that phrase, I found this:
    "But Juneteenth is not just a day of celebration and education. It’s also a day of agitation. It is a day of recommitting ourselves to the ongoing Black freedom struggle. We know that *while slavery was legally abolished in 1865, it was never fully eradicated.* Sadiya Hartman argues that we are dealing with the afterlife of slavery. Slavery takes on new forms and permutations. White supremacy, anti-blackness, state-sponsored and vigilante violence, captivity, and Black death still plague us day in and day out. While we celebrate freedom on Juneteenth, we know that Juneteenth reminds us that *for Black Americans, full freedom has always been denied, delayed, or diluted.* That’s why we have Juneteenth shirts that say “Free-ish” since 1865. *We’ve never been fully free,* just free-ish, but every day, we’re fighting to get free-er and free-er."
    ~ Michael Brandon McCormack, “Free-ish Since 1865: The Meaning of Juneteenth”

    • @RaptureReadyPam
      @RaptureReadyPam 3 месяца назад +1

      Insightful. Truth is we are a slave to sin or a slave to righteousness. I’ll take my slavery in Christ:). God bless

  • @katherinecornette5315
    @katherinecornette5315 3 месяца назад +3

    Happy Independence Day 🇺🇸 💥
    I wish more parents would spend time discussing these things with their kids. Sitting at the dinner table and listening to each other would make stronger kids who can discern what is happening and not just learning by TikTok videos.

  • @JamesRiddle_Christ_is_King
    @JamesRiddle_Christ_is_King 3 месяца назад +3

    Considering Jason Whitlock enjoyed Larkin Rose's "Jones Plantation" and is critical of Martin Luther King, he might be interested in the 1607 project. A lot of people are knocking down the final idol, Lincoln.

  • @eurekahope5310
    @eurekahope5310 3 месяца назад +5

    Create your own co-op!

  • @ericthehalfmexican9187
    @ericthehalfmexican9187 3 месяца назад +3

    I’m a life long Texan and I never heard of juneteen until recent times.

  • @kmhemeyer
    @kmhemeyer 3 месяца назад +6

    I really wanted to like cc but something seemed off to me. We joined a co op and on orientation day a mom whose kids were my kids age was wearing a shirt that said "just a mom raising little marxists." Then i decided that it wasnt wasnt the group for me. Thankfully we found a different classical christian co op. Praise God!

    • @JasonModar
      @JasonModar 3 месяца назад +1

      Well, that was nice of her to clearly display her insane ideology. Saved you some trouble.

  • @gccfp
    @gccfp 3 месяца назад +1

    Keep fighting the good fight!

  • @Jacob-pu4zj
    @Jacob-pu4zj 3 месяца назад +6

    The rainbow rot has come for CC, but I'm certain it hasn't seeped all the way in. Older editions of the curricula should be fine to use.

    • @standingonthepromises285
      @standingonthepromises285 3 месяца назад

      Juneteenth isn't in the curriculum. CC isn't truly a curriculum really. They use other text and living books. Their curriculum is really piecing together the year in a guide.

  • @mrleemrleeohmrlee
    @mrleemrleeohmrlee 3 месяца назад +3

    I read through my sons' History and Geography LifePac curriculum from Alpha and Omega and it has post-war consensus written all over it.

    • @deannajunkin3696
      @deannajunkin3696 3 месяца назад

      Oh dear. I just bought that curriculum for 5th grade.

    • @mrleemrleeohmrlee
      @mrleemrleeohmrlee 2 месяца назад

      @@deannajunkin3696 5th grade is probably not too bad, but you may need to spend a little more time with your child for guidance. My 8th and 11th grade sons just wrapped up their US History curriculum that concluded with the Biden presidency. Even my kids were sharp enough to detect a liberal bias in how they described it.

  • @Susan-f5u
    @Susan-f5u 2 месяца назад

    My family went to church on Thanksgiving when I was a kid.

  • @NeanderthalWoman-ou8ev
    @NeanderthalWoman-ou8ev 3 месяца назад +3

    This is a timely post.
    I work for a classical Christian school, and I have been using CC history cards as the backbone for my history curriculum. Last year (Age of Exploration to 1850s), I felt it was a pretty good guide. This year (Abe Lincoln to present), I'm finding some problems. The U.N. is presented as a good thing. There is no mention of Tinnennamen Square, Woodstock, the Jesus People movement, Francis Schaefer, Raegan, the Contras War, feminism, or Roe v. Wade. I'm having to think through modern history and add stuff. Particularly the way the U.N. and the E.U. are presented do not inspire my trust.

  • @ZephaniahL
    @ZephaniahL 3 месяца назад +12

    Absolutely --and you're too kind. Rabid black nationalism is being rewarded as though it's the most natural thing in the world.

    • @DM-dk7js
      @DM-dk7js 3 месяца назад

      What black nationalism?

  • @designbuild7128
    @designbuild7128 3 месяца назад +8

    truly free- you mean everyone got saved?

    • @carolberubee
      @carolberubee 3 месяца назад

      That was my first thought. I thought that was the angle Jon was going to take, but I also appreciate the things he explained.

  • @tommcmichael8679
    @tommcmichael8679 3 месяца назад +1

    One of my biggest complaints about the Left is that they never know when to stop. The lines are constantly moving. What they fight for now is the ability to fight for something far worse later.

  • @sarahfreeman5325
    @sarahfreeman5325 3 месяца назад +2

    Freedom for all except the unborn babies 😢

  • @jankragt7789
    @jankragt7789 3 месяца назад +1

    Well said. It's like we now have two different CIVIC religions. There is this idea that Kamala threw out in her recent campaign ad that's supposed to be cute and black: "WE NOT LIKE THEM."
    That's an ugly sentiment for a Vice President to try to make into something proud and loud. It's hate, claiming righteousness by demanding shame & blame on the other skin color. It's at best a highly questionable push that never stops. (Not to mention, Kamala has white skin.)
    I've been happy to see-or imagine-a lack of enthusiasm for the holiday among blacks I know. On some level they must know its tainted. Healthy people know the present leftist movements play to the negative side of human nature, but many are falling in with these attitudes and mental habits of self-righteous pride any way; the temptation is strong.

    • @josephalbatross5961
      @josephalbatross5961 3 месяца назад

      Well said. The pushing a “black national anthem” on people echoes this same agenda.

  • @Susan-f5u
    @Susan-f5u 2 месяца назад

    In Mechanicsburg, PA, they have a Juneteenth street celebration every year for years. Main Street is closed and there are venders set up selling food and crafts and activities. I don’t know what this holiday designated for.

  • @terry1230
    @terry1230 2 месяца назад

    Black heroes day... is what i grew up with in the Month of February... My community celebrated the heroes in black History and affirmed the US origins of our people, good bad and ugly

  • @MeadeFatLoss
    @MeadeFatLoss 3 месяца назад +4

    I remember seeing this from so called Republicans and they were posting happy Juneteenth memes on X . Just really off.

  • @CAT-zt4ef
    @CAT-zt4ef 3 месяца назад +5

    As an American who happens to be black and a redeemed rescued ransomed sin forgiven and grace called to proclaim The True Gospel of Jesus The Messiah/Christ
    Division has always been marketed promoted as right when wrong as good when bad or uniting when its aim is to divide
    Let us who claim allegiance to His/Jesus’ Name be more Biblical than anything else

  • @standingonthepromises285
    @standingonthepromises285 3 месяца назад +3

    Its not part of CC curriculum- Juneteenth

  • @LucianaPelota
    @LucianaPelota 3 месяца назад +6

    I didn't realize CC had this bent. What a disappointment!

    • @the4musketeers134
      @the4musketeers134 3 месяца назад +3

      I would not say that the curriculum does. In fact, many of books in the Challenge years do talk about what a great nation we are.

    • @lindsay.coggin
      @lindsay.coggin 3 месяца назад +4

      The curriculum doesn’t. But the people involved could lean left. I’m surprised because Robert Bortins is anti all left things. So use CC, but find a group of like minded people to do it with.

  • @clintonstephens273
    @clintonstephens273 3 месяца назад +5

    Juneteenth is a Texas thing, and everybody knows Juneteenth ment somebody was going to shot in a riot during a Juneteenth celebration.

    • @engelberthumberdinkel5162
      @engelberthumberdinkel5162 3 месяца назад +10

      I live in Texas and nobody celebrates this where I live.

    • @keeperofthedomus7654
      @keeperofthedomus7654 3 месяца назад +2

      That happened in Austin, TX this year!

    • @ericthehalfmexican9187
      @ericthehalfmexican9187 3 месяца назад

      @@engelberthumberdinkel5162lived here 38 years and never heard of this fake holiday until now.

    • @nykka3
      @nykka3 2 месяца назад +1

      It was celebrated when I was a kid/teen during the 80-90’s in Austin, TX.

    • @ericthehalfmexican9187
      @ericthehalfmexican9187 2 месяца назад

      @@nykka3 The rest of Texas does not acknowledge Austin as part of Texas.

  • @designbuild7128
    @designbuild7128 3 месяца назад +2

    33:00 'gas lighting' that goes back to the early 1800's. Unlike then, it is more arguable today that they know the game their playing.
    "Socialism, like the ancient ideas from which it springs, confuses the distinction between government and society. As a result of this, every time we object to a thing being done by government, the socialists conclude that we object to its being done at all. We disapprove of state education. Then the socialists say that we are opposed to any education." -Bastiat

  • @kellyhiller3977
    @kellyhiller3977 3 месяца назад +1

    In our area banks/schools r open on Columbus day yet all closed on Juneteenth. Need I say more?

  • @banemaler
    @banemaler 3 месяца назад +1

    I have been in Nebraska for a decade and it was the first time I heard of Juneteenth when we moved here. I have since heard testimonies of its celebration in several other states. What the federal government wants to define it as is mostly irrelevant to its history. I get the same sideways looks for celebrating Mardi Gras with my cajun wife.

  • @Susan-f5u
    @Susan-f5u 2 месяца назад

    Black History Month exists, but only liberal Blacks were presented at grandson’s middle school. Moody Radio does Black Christians for that month and it is interesting to learn.

  • @mikabrera
    @mikabrera 2 месяца назад +1

    Man, the ignorance about Juneteenth is incredible. It is a true celebration of the victory of The Union. Also, it has been a Texas holiday for a long time and everyone celebrates them.

  • @conceptualclarity
    @conceptualclarity 3 месяца назад +1

    "steps we continue to take toward freedom for all"
    if was hearing this blindly I would think that it was someone whose next sentence will talk about how sadly "marginalized" are the rainbow battalion folks.

  • @NikkiSchumacherOfficial
    @NikkiSchumacherOfficial 3 месяца назад +3

    Classical conversations is not classical education. It is neo classical- the ages and stages have no basis in science or based it reality. It was literally made up by someone who had their degree in marketing. I still think it’s a good curriculum, (though the mlm like tactics are annoying) but anyone who has read more than a smattering of old books by Charlotte Mason contemporaries would know that it’s not classical.

  • @terry1230
    @terry1230 2 месяца назад

    When he called NAT TURNER A TERRORIST I KNEW😂😂😂 we dont read the same history... i love it! He is wrong but i am still learning

  • @solideomusical
    @solideomusical 3 месяца назад +3

    Subversive holiday next in order

  • @estroup06
    @estroup06 3 месяца назад +2

    Federal workers only have 11 paid holidays 31:05

    • @josephalbatross5961
      @josephalbatross5961 3 месяца назад

      Federal employees typically receive pay for 11 federal holidays, 13 sick days and 20 vacation days per year.

  • @banemaler
    @banemaler 3 месяца назад

    Technically the Declaration was voted on the 2nd of July and it's news was distributed to the newly formed states on the 4th, was mostly signed on the 2nd of August and completed in 1781 😂
    But it is interesting how many days of remembrance we have that seem to follow this pattern.

  • @Susan-f5u
    @Susan-f5u 2 месяца назад

    Thanksgiving is all about football games!

  • @debbiefocht1907
    @debbiefocht1907 3 месяца назад

    I just saw my son's high school in VA has been renamed io Unity Reed...he graduated years ago but now his school doesn't exist

  • @dingotomtom
    @dingotomtom 3 месяца назад

    Can someone please tell me how to find the 16 0 7 project that John Harris talks about all the time? Because isn't there more than one with the same name? I don't wanna watch any other one, but the 1 that John Harris talks about. So if someone could, please help me, thanks

  • @Susan-f5u
    @Susan-f5u 2 месяца назад +1

    What’s Kwanza? Another divider

  • @leahunverferth8247
    @leahunverferth8247 16 дней назад

    I agree that Juneteenth is based essentially on a myth (it wasn't the end to slavery) and is used as propaganda. However, I cannot agree with necessarily taking such a "positive" view of history that you seem to be proposing. We need a real view of history which includes the good yes, but also the bad.
    I would add the Confederate monuments which were "reconciliatory" were not truly reconciliatory. It was a "reconciliation" which demanded the acceptance of the South's rewriting of history (things like the civil war wasn't about slavery - it absolutely was and the South proclaimed this loudly and proudly prior to and throughout the war, read the secession documents and secession commissioners' letters and speeches and look into the secession conventions of each state to start with). Again, I agree they are being torn down and replaced with other foolish things. I just got you aren't leaning into the lost cause myth.

  • @slawrence999
    @slawrence999 3 месяца назад +1

    Celebrating for the umpteenth time how terrible the nation is.

  • @johntobey1558
    @johntobey1558 3 месяца назад +1

    We do not use classical conversatiins.

  • @tommcmichael8679
    @tommcmichael8679 3 месяца назад

    So many of these weak Left holidays are on the calendar now that it looks a lot like National Hot Dog Day or National Cycling Day.

  • @jamesmay217
    @jamesmay217 3 месяца назад

    Man don't think too much about the history of Columbus Day

    • @josephalbatross5961
      @josephalbatross5961 3 месяца назад

      Columbus is a great man. The colonizer rhetoric has really done a number on him, but the war criminal they write about is a fiction from a few letters about him.