David, I would have loved that your 100% sus song hadn't end in a fade out. I would have loved to see a creative way to finally resolve the melody and harmony bringing closure to the song... al in sus chords.
I pay my respect to David for his willpower, as he hasn't broken down from his narration style a single time while talking about sus chords for the entirety of this video.
It's honestly kind of surreal watching an entire video about sus chords after 2021 without making a single amogus reference. Makes me nostalgic for a simpler time
Using both sus2 and sus4 is extremely common as a guitar player, especially noodling around an open D or A chord, because it's easy and always sounds great. Kickapoo is a pretty clear example that immediately comes to mind
I saw a Beck concert long ago where he called the little sus flourish on the D chord the "pinky of freedom". If anything, it's even easier on piano, just move that third one key to the left or right.
I’ve been doing this a lot since figuring out this technique a few years ago … to the point where, when I pick up a guitar, my fingers automatically fall into an Asus2 shape. A lot of my improvisation is modal stuff in Am or C since it lets me use all the open strings without having to retune.
As someone who as an amateur organ player plays a lot of hymns both at home and in church, sus chords are something I play a lot. Something very common is to play sus4 and then sus2 before playing the actual major or minor chord.
Well, not necessarily ending on a Picardy third but sure, if a piece is say in F minor, the final few moves can be something like Fsus4 - Fm - Fsus2 - F. And yes, I believe the Bach Toccata and Fuga in D minor does end that way maybe a bit more embellished. But yes, very common to use these sus chords in hymns.
1:04 For No One - Beatles Crazy - Gnarls Barkley Pinball Wizard - The Who Crazy little Thing Called Love Cold As Ice - Foreigner 4:07 Love Song - Sara Bareilles The Scientist - Coldplay Don't Dream It's Over - Crowded House Champagne Supernova - Oasis 6:57 Exit Music (For a Film) - Radiohead Summer of 69' - Bryan Adams Other Side of the World - KT Tunstall Free Fallin' - Tom Petty
Your piece built on sus chords at the end of the video so wants to resolve, but it keeps traveling alongside, above, and below any resolution. It evokes such a strange and wonderful emotion. Beautiful!
I think quartal harmony is my new favorite thing, after being a fan of accidented ambiguous chords for a long long time Thanks for another great video, David. This is one of your best IMHO.
Some missing that came to mind immediately: Black (Pearl Jam) uses a Dsus2 in the entire outro The opening riffs of Jump (Van Halen) and The riff of Black or White (Michael Jackson) are pivoting Sus2/major/sus4 Grunge, and Pearl Jam specifically, uses a lot of sus chords. Alive, Jeremy, Better Man, I am Mine all have sus chords in the chord progression (and there are probably many more). Black Hole Sun (Soundgarden) is built on a Gsus4. The sus chord is a very important part of the Grunge sound, and it usually never properly resolves.
I always enjoy when you compose your own pieces, but WOW! This one at the end was stellar in every sense of the word. I might be biased as a stringsman, but the use of nothing but suspended chords sounds wicked cool!
“When the World Is Running Down, You Make the Best of What’s Still Around” by The Police is probably the closest song I can think of to being all sus chords. It does have an Em11 chord in the sequence, but the harmony of the song feels very open and ambiguous much like a sus chord.
Can we get a video on quartal harmony. I've been struggling to get a full grasp of it, and would love to hear your explanation. Keep up the great work!
McCoy Tyner’s piano work would be the best primer to immerse yourself in the world of quartal harmony. “My Favorite Things,” “A Love Supreme - Part 1: Acknowledgement,” and “Passion Dance” all being great examples of this style of harmony.
3:26 I think it's slightly inaccurate to say that the sus2 chord's resolution is always weaker than a sus4. The strongest resolutions are the ones that contain half steps. When going to a major chord, the sus4 is stronger (4-3 suspension). But when going to a minor chord, the sus2 is always going to be stronger than sus4. But in that case, it's a 2-3 anticipation, resolving upwards. While not technically a suspension, it has a stronger resolution in this specific case
Half-step resolutions do usually sound stronger than whole-step resolutions, but downward resolutions also usually sound stronger than upward resolutions. So sus4 to major is a half-step resolution AND a downward resolution, making it stronger than sus2 to minor, which is a half-step but upward rather than downward. Additionally, major chords sound more resolved than minor chords, because a major third is a simpler ratio than a minor third (which is why the picardy third trick sounds so good), so that’s another count in sus4 to major’s favour. Of course all this stuff about what kind of resolutions sound stronger is kind of subjective, but the proof is in the pudding.
@@SirBenjiful downward resolutions sound stronger than upwards? The strongest resolution is leading up to tonic. And b2 resolving down to tonic isn't as strong as the classic leading tone resolution
@@liam1253 “b2 leading down to tonic isn’t as strong” well, I think it is. Try it out yourself! Db7 -> C sounds just as strong as G7 -> C to me, if not stronger. This is why the ‘tritone substitution’ trick popular in jazz works so well. But ultimately it’s just a matter of opinion. If it doesn’t sound good to you, don’t play it that way! Peace.
@@SirBenjiful in both examples you give the strongest resolution is leading tone resolving up to the tonic. And you're talking about resolving to a major chord. I was talking about minor chords. G7-Cm has a stronger resolution than Db7-Cm because the D in the G7 chord resolves up to the Eb in the Cm chord. And this is also the strongest resolution when using suspended chords.
Any other RUclipsr: I couldn't find any examples of songs written entirely using sus chords. Thank you all for watching! David Bennett Piano: I couldn't find any examples of songs written entirely using sus chords...... so I wrote my own piece using just sus chords!
James Taylor uses sus4 chords in quite an unusual manner (see: You've Got A Friend, Carolina In My Mind, Sweet Baby James, many others). He often uses the sus4 chord _not_ as a temporary variation of a Major chord that resolves to the Major chord (such as the “D → D4 → D → D4 → etc” opening of Crazy Little Thing Called Love and hundreds of others). Instead, James uses the sus4 as a “softer” _replacement_ for the V chord in a perfect cadence (V → I). This “Taylorized” perfect cadence (Vsus4 → I) resolves more gently due to there not being a half-step movement from the 3rd of the V to the Root of the I. Taylor does this a lot (eg, G → A7sus4 →D), and he's the only one I can think of who does it. I like to imagine that he uses this “softened” cadence because it fits with his laidback easygoing personality.
There doesn't always have to be a resolution, or a destination... sometimes the journey is the destination in and of itself. After realizing I had been playing "Free Fallin'" wrong (with regular major chords as opposed to the sus chords here) I have never been able to look at the song the same way and now the sus chords stand out. I was hoping for this song to be in this video and here it was!
We use suspended chords a lot in Christian worship music. Common voicings are the IV and the V chords simply labeled sus so you get to pick sus4 or sus2. And players often use suspended chords when it is not written to do so either because they prefer the sound, or it’s easier, or both.
Your composition at the end is eerily beautiful. Tom Petty's "Free Falling" is an incredible song, although I pretty much think of that bass line as doubling the vocal, rather than changing the harmony of that part. I love your work on these videos! 🙏
I just wanted to say how much I appreciate your videos and how much they help me. Even though I have an Advanced Higher Music certificate, I have difficulty hearing intervals or chords, and these videos are assisting me in my learning!
Whenever I feel the urge to strum a guitar, Blue Rodeo “Hasn’t Hit Me Yet” is usually the first song to come out. It’s so fun dancing between the D, Dsus2, and Dsus4.
Just a side note: sus2 chords are really just the first inversion of a sus4 a 5th above the root, i.e. Csus2 = Gsus4 which is an interesting thing to play with if you're going for a perfect cadence. Also, those weird 9sus4 chords are inversions of a 6/9 chord a whole step down, i.e. C9sus4 = Bb6/9.
Yes, exactly. For example, I tend to hear the final chord in the Free Fallin riff not as Csus4, but as Fsus2 -albeit with a C in the bass (which I think is there because it foreshadows the eventual melody, as someone else here has pointed out.)
4:20 Love Song is, to my ears, very similar to a Shepard Tone illusion in the main piano sequence. It sounds like it resolves UP to the tonic and keeps rising. Obviously it does not, so there is either some tricky finger shuffling going on in the voicing for an approximation of the illusion or the motion just tricks my ears somehow.
There's a subjectivity involved in this kind of analysis as well. For instance, the Petty tune at 8:36 sounds like a Bbsus2 from the very beginning to me, just played in a second inversion. From that point of view, there's no "recontextualizing" when the bass enters, simply a switch to root position.
Great video. I've loved sus chords (and therefore songs that feature them )for as long as I can remember. Now I have an understanding of why. Another great song that alternates uses both the sus2 and sus4 is "Brass in pocket" by the pretenders. The song is beautiful. Just needed to finish on a major!
I always love the compositions at the end of your videos. I don't know if it's at all beneficial for you to put them on Spotify or anything, but there's so many I've longed to be able to listen to. Big fan of your Longest March!
Thanks for making this. I was founding what sus chords are for and their uses that says it straightforward and short like you. This was really a sus video!
1:59 you could also argue that the V gsus is just the first harmonics of the G cord (first and third) plus the tonic of I, so the tension is two near keys played at the same time, which then is unfolded to the stronger tonic I (V is more part of I than vice versa) 4:39 F sus2 = F + C, Dm7 = F + Bb, so I (F) + V(C) and I(Bb) and V(F)
Another great way to use the sus4 is to use its pull towards the major triad to change key. I believe there's an example of this in exit music by Radiohead and it's a really subtle key change Street Spirit also is a brilliant use of both the sus4 and sus2
I really like your composition at the end of the video. But I feel like at 12:09 it wants to finally resolve! And whatever harmonic move you may choose to insert there will sound all the more powerful due to how long you left the suspension hanging.
Sus4 on dominant (V): note how note 4 is the tonic, ie., the chord virtually SHOUTS that a perfect cadence is coming. Sus4 on tonic (I): note how the 4 note is the subdominant, ie., it may as well be a IV chord / a plagal cadence "feel" is coming.
I like how you made a tune built around sus chords…the transitions are very smooth!!!…I guess maybe because of the common notes in them!! Great as always David! 👏👏👏👏👏🙂
Enjoyed this, and very much your own composition. Nice work, mate! Sus2 chords are my fave chords that for reasons I can't fathom, appear on hardly any guitar chord box diagram posters. I dig all these tunes, so it shouldn't come as a surprise sus2 and sus4 chords appear in many of my own compositions. A couple of my main musical inspirations, Robert Smith and Pete Townshend, who you mentioned, feature *a lot* of sus chords in their compositions.
One use of sus chords that is worth mentioning is to soften the effect of a cadence. A perfect cadence, V->I, feels very strong, partly because of the leading tone to tonic resolution. If the V is a suspended chord, the overall effect is softened, and the cadence doesn't sound as strong or final. A classic example of this is "Tears in Heaven" by Eric Clapton. The chorus ends with a ii->V->I progression, where the V is a sus4 chord. The effect is that it feels like a perfect cadence, but doesn't feel like the end of the song. V7sus4->I feels less "final" than V7->I. The double suspended chord is where you omit the 3rd, but add both the 2nd and the 4th. No uses from popular songs come to mind, but the Raiders March by John Williams uses this to great effect on the tonic in C major. The notes of Csus2sus4 (what should you call it?) are the same as G7sus4 and F6sus2, the dominant and the subdominant respectively. So if you use I -> Isus2sus4 -> I, the second transition feels like a resolution, but to the ear, it's very ambiguous as to whether it's resolving suspensions, or a perfect cadence, or a plagal cadence. The overall effect is of an extremely "soft" progression, raising the tension just a little bit and then releasing it. Since it's Proms season at the moment, there's another example of the double suspended chord in "Jack's the Lad", the hornpipe from Henry Wood's "Fantasia on British Sea Songs".
So excited that you put in Tarkus as an example. Most music youtubers are surprisingly blind for 70ies prog rock even that time was probably one of the most experimental phase in music history.
Fooling around sus2/sus4 is relatively typical with guitar since it's just holding the main part of the chord but moving just one finger back and forth adds additional "texture".
In a major tone the sus4 chord is used on the V, being resolved then going to I. But on a minor tone, the sus4 is also used on the I degree, especially after a major V chord (which includes a major 7th of the tone), leading to a real suspens: are we going back to the minor tone or move to the major one. This kind of sus4 usage isn't covered here but is used to create an incertain resolution, like an ambiguous tonality. Quite often a sus chord is played as a IV/V or a IV/I. It in fact includes a 7th and a 9th on the first case or a 6th in the second. These chords sound differently than pure sus chords but have a similar effect (neither major or minor). Last comment: the sus4 in a V I progression is very common and even when it's not written on a music sheet it is often played like this.
Frank Zappa often used sus2 chords. In fact, if you search around , you can find a video in which Ruth Underwood demonstrates how “Redunzl” is all sus2 chords. I’m fairly sure too that the harmony on “The Black Page #2” is all sus2 chords.
David Bennett is the BEST music theory instructor on RUclips hands down. Breaking down popular tunes as examples has opened creative doors on piano for me
This might be the first one of these videos where not only do I know most of these songs (which is relatively normal), but I specifically enjoy most of these. Over and over again, stuff that’s on my playlists
David you once again do such wonderful example music. This time you seem to pick open the music from my dreams! It ia so nice ot know you can pull that out of my head!
Excellent video and explanations, thanks. Thanks for including Crowded House. Would be good to see Keane feature one day as their chord sequences seem very interesting to me.
oh man, this compo of yours was mindblowing! really eerie and hauntology-like, it almost felt like listening to Boards of Canada. Also adds a sense of nostalgy and serenity.
Another great video. When I think of suspended chords on guitar I always think of John Lennon's Happy Xmas and that 80s song A Little Respect (successfully covered by Wheatus).
I believe Don't Dream It's Over also goes to a Csus2 as the second chord in the verse progression in what would normally be a Cm in that key, and it's played as a Cm in the chorus.
This video got me thinking. Van Halen, who probably used sus4 as much as anyone, uses it heavily in the hard rock song "Unchained". Eb standard tuning with the lowest string dropped to Db. it's Db Dbsus4 A Asus4 B Bsus4 Db Dbsus4 E Esus4 B Bsus4. The verse is riff oriented, but basically the same type of progression. The "bridge" is sliding between Gb and E, and then Ab and Gb, which resolves to Db on the first note of the chorus and goes to sus4 right away. The whole song, he's leaving the listener hanging on the sus4 chord, and it never resolves to Db completely until the end of the song. I think that's what makes it a good driving/cruising song, as it seems to be constantly needing to travel somewhere.
Really nice explanation thank you! I like that piece at the end too. It has a feeling of floating or gently getting away from gravity and moving around from place to place
Nice video. Something that might make for an interesting follow-up video: the difference, if any, between a Sus2 and an add9. I'm guessing that the Add9 has the normal triad at the bottom (3rd included), with a ninth added in above, while the Sus2 gets rid of the third entirely. Even if that's the case, I wonder if they are functionally any different.
@@SirBenjiful I don't know if they are functionally different as you suggest. I think going from Cadd9 back to C does sound (slightly) resolved in the same way as going from Csus2 to C does. As David points out in this video, a Dsus2 chord would not necessarily have to resolve back to D at all. The same would go for a Dadd9. So, practically speaking, there may be no meaningful difference. Since the Dadd9 has one additional note, perhaps it's just a slightly more complex sound, but I wonder if I listener would really hear any difference?
1. Flesh out and release the closing track. Dreamy. Gorgeous. 2. Sus chords are basically what I call a "tweener". If you want a sub-dominant sound but want to cling to the root a bit, you plop a Sus4 chord in place of where a 4 might go. The same is true for Sus2 chords in place of dominant 5 chords. They can serve as harmonic substitutions for one another.
@@DavidBennettPiano So I just realized how cool the voice leading is on maybe I’m amazed. And how the use of the chromatic bassline works so well with the appropriate chords above. Perhaps you could discuss in one of your future videos how the song works, and more importantly on how to employ a similar technique for composing? Thank you for the time and consideration. Your channel rocks! 🤘
thanks. sus2 is also often used with the IV chord to keep some sort of ambiguity around aeolian vs dorian : in Boulevard of Broken dreams (Fm Ab Eb Bbsus2) or Mad world (same), the latter introducing the major Bb chord only when the chorus comes ("... kinda find it FUN-ny"), with a D note instead of C, bringing a dorian spotlight on this particuliar line
@@sylvainleotard7340 I’m talking about the piano melody that opens the song. The notes of that melody are, in order: Ab C G Bb F Ab Eb D That final D is immediately followed by a Bb major chord. I don’t know how you can say there’s any ambiguity as to what mode we’re in when the first bar of the song contains every single note of F dorian. It’s as clear as it could possibly be.
For no one is my absolute favorite Beatles song, so it is the cherry on top of an already good day that it was the first example here. In addition it was crazy to hear Sarah bareilles mentioned for the 1st time in the David Bennett videos I've watched anyway. I worked with her when she was still in high school.. A coworker asked her one day what she was gonna do after graduating and she said right and perform songs. The CO worker said that's cute but what's your backup plan? She replied with "nope that's what I'm going to do" .
Seems like prog rock/metal uses alot of sus2 chords to give a song an ethereal feel, much like you demonstrated in your last song. "Distant Early Warning" by Rush is made up of Sus2 chords almost exclusively, although I think he does throw in a few major chords in the pre-chorus. Sus2 chords are also really easy to play on guitar so I know I like to use them a lot when riffing because they sound a little more interesting than a major or minor chord but tend to work in place of either.
“Distant Early Warning” is a great example of that sound. By this point in Rush’s career, Alex Lifeson was taking a lot of influence from Andy Summers.
The sus4 chord has the same "flavor note" as the regular old V7 chord, except it's hidden inside the triad. Gives it a smoother, mellower sound--less flamboyant.
Enjoy full access to over 40,000 sheet music works with a Tomplay 14 day free trial: tomplay.com/premium-trial?ref=davidbennett6 🎼
David, I would have loved that your 100% sus song hadn't end in a fade out. I would have loved to see a creative way to finally resolve the melody and harmony bringing closure to the song... al in sus chords.
There is the Sus2 for example The Show Must Go On by the Queen in Bmin ?
It's BminSus2 or F#majSus2.
I pay my respect to David for his willpower, as he hasn't broken down from his narration style a single time while talking about sus chords for the entirety of this video.
i don't think he knows what sus means *_amogus_*
@@majman446 he referenced it in another video so he does
maybe because it was funny in 2019 and we're in 2022
@@SilentAttackTV I dunno, I still shiver every time I hear "sus" in a formal situation
@@SilentAttackTV still tho… you can’t help but think
It's honestly kind of surreal watching an entire video about sus chords after 2021 without making a single amogus reference. Makes me nostalgic for a simpler time
seeing absolutely no among us references in this comment section is very soothing to the soul
I totally forgot this existed while I was watching it haha
That's two years ago, what's there to be nostalgic for 😂
Using both sus2 and sus4 is extremely common as a guitar player, especially noodling around an open D or A chord, because it's easy and always sounds great.
Kickapoo is a pretty clear example that immediately comes to mind
I saw a Beck concert long ago where he called the little sus flourish on the D chord the "pinky of freedom".
If anything, it's even easier on piano, just move that third one key to the left or right.
I’ve been doing this a lot since figuring out this technique a few years ago … to the point where, when I pick up a guitar, my fingers automatically fall into an Asus2 shape. A lot of my improvisation is modal stuff in Am or C since it lets me use all the open strings without having to retune.
i thought of the same song as well!
Two others that always come to mind are the Byrd's "I'll Feel A Whole Lot Better" and Shonen Knife's "I Am A Cat."
Lifeson uses sus2s all over Rush songs
Mad respect for the song you made at the end. Positively beautiful and serene. Admittedly I could definitely see this being a minecraft music disc.
😊
As someone who as an amateur organ player plays a lot of hymns both at home and in church, sus chords are something I play a lot. Something very common is to play sus4 and then sus2 before playing the actual major or minor chord.
I have that pattern in my head as the default ending to any song on a pipe organ.
Pigerty third?
Does Toccata And Fugue use that? It sounds like it.
YES! I kept thinking church organ hymn endings.
With the last chord adding a deep heavy bass tonic note too.
Well, not necessarily ending on a Picardy third but sure, if a piece is say in F minor, the final few moves can be something like Fsus4 - Fm - Fsus2 - F.
And yes, I believe the Bach Toccata and Fuga in D minor does end that way maybe a bit more embellished.
But yes, very common to use these sus chords in hymns.
1:04
For No One - Beatles
Crazy - Gnarls Barkley
Pinball Wizard - The Who
Crazy little Thing Called Love
Cold As Ice - Foreigner
4:07
Love Song - Sara Bareilles
The Scientist - Coldplay
Don't Dream It's Over - Crowded House
Champagne Supernova - Oasis
6:57
Exit Music (For a Film) - Radiohead
Summer of 69' - Bryan Adams
Other Side of the World - KT Tunstall
Free Fallin' - Tom Petty
for more old school: The Wind Beneath My Wings (Bette Midler), and She Believes in Me (Kenny Rodgers)
That composition at the sounds so Ethereal.
Great work my friend.
yeah sounds like some video game music or something
To me it sounds like closing credits music for an old science fiction show.
I'd pay for a full version of it
Was going say the same lol. That openness is awesome.
At the… ? What?! The suspense is killing me
Your piece built on sus chords at the end of the video so wants to resolve, but it keeps traveling alongside, above, and below any resolution. It evokes such a strange and wonderful emotion. Beautiful!
@ghost mall totally agree! It still leaves the listener "hanging" enough away from a full resolution to be slightly tense.
the what chords?
Have you heard bands in the shoegaze/dream-pop genre? I got the same vibe from this piece, strange and wonderful)
@@AlexanDrMoskalenko definitely feel it, yes. Also reminds me of some ambient music artists.
I think quartal harmony is my new favorite thing, after being a fan of accidented ambiguous chords for a long long time
Thanks for another great video, David. This is one of your best IMHO.
Some missing that came to mind immediately:
Black (Pearl Jam) uses a Dsus2 in the entire outro
The opening riffs of Jump (Van Halen) and The riff of Black or White (Michael Jackson) are pivoting Sus2/major/sus4
Grunge, and Pearl Jam specifically, uses a lot of sus chords. Alive, Jeremy, Better Man, I am Mine all have sus chords in the chord progression (and there are probably many more).
Black Hole Sun (Soundgarden) is built on a Gsus4.
The sus chord is a very important part of the Grunge sound, and it usually never properly resolves.
Black hole sun is actually built on a G half sharp chord.
Rush !! Alex Lifeson uses a lot of sus chords on many songs. Sus chords is part of his guitar signature.
Pompeii by bastille, notice that there is a sus4 chornd in the synth riff
I always enjoy when you compose your own pieces, but WOW! This one at the end was stellar in every sense of the word. I might be biased as a stringsman, but the use of nothing but suspended chords sounds wicked cool!
“When the World Is Running Down, You Make the Best of What’s Still Around” by The Police is probably the closest song I can think of to being all sus chords. It does have an Em11 chord in the sequence, but the harmony of the song feels very open and ambiguous much like a sus chord.
Can we get a video on quartal harmony. I've been struggling to get a full grasp of it, and would love to hear your explanation. Keep up the great work!
up up up
No podría estar mas de acuerdo. Armonía cuartal explicada por David Bennet, si si.
pls
He’s literally taught me more than any teacher from school can
McCoy Tyner’s piano work would be the best primer to immerse yourself in the world of quartal harmony. “My Favorite Things,” “A Love Supreme - Part 1: Acknowledgement,” and “Passion Dance” all being great examples of this style of harmony.
3:26 I think it's slightly inaccurate to say that the sus2 chord's resolution is always weaker than a sus4. The strongest resolutions are the ones that contain half steps. When going to a major chord, the sus4 is stronger (4-3 suspension). But when going to a minor chord, the sus2 is always going to be stronger than sus4. But in that case, it's a 2-3 anticipation, resolving upwards. While not technically a suspension, it has a stronger resolution in this specific case
i was thinking more about this as the video went on, happy to see it put into words
Half-step resolutions do usually sound stronger than whole-step resolutions, but downward resolutions also usually sound stronger than upward resolutions.
So sus4 to major is a half-step resolution AND a downward resolution, making it stronger than sus2 to minor, which is a half-step but upward rather than downward.
Additionally, major chords sound more resolved than minor chords, because a major third is a simpler ratio than a minor third (which is why the picardy third trick sounds so good), so that’s another count in sus4 to major’s favour.
Of course all this stuff about what kind of resolutions sound stronger is kind of subjective, but the proof is in the pudding.
@@SirBenjiful downward resolutions sound stronger than upwards? The strongest resolution is leading up to tonic. And b2 resolving down to tonic isn't as strong as the classic leading tone resolution
@@liam1253 “b2 leading down to tonic isn’t as strong” well, I think it is. Try it out yourself!
Db7 -> C sounds just as strong as G7 -> C to me, if not stronger. This is why the ‘tritone substitution’ trick popular in jazz works so well.
But ultimately it’s just a matter of opinion. If it doesn’t sound good to you, don’t play it that way! Peace.
@@SirBenjiful in both examples you give the strongest resolution is leading tone resolving up to the tonic. And you're talking about resolving to a major chord. I was talking about minor chords. G7-Cm has a stronger resolution than Db7-Cm because the D in the G7 chord resolves up to the Eb in the Cm chord. And this is also the strongest resolution when using suspended chords.
Any other RUclipsr: I couldn't find any examples of songs written entirely using sus chords. Thank you all for watching!
David Bennett Piano: I couldn't find any examples of songs written entirely using sus chords...... so I wrote my own piece using just sus chords!
Damn, Innersloth needs to hire this man
Beautiful and ethereal song there. Major and minor tonality at the same time. Very airy and harmonious as well. Very nice.
What I Am, is very close.
Beautiful melody in your piece at the end.
Great vid as always.
Thank you.
Thank you!
James Taylor uses sus4 chords in quite an unusual manner (see: You've Got A Friend, Carolina In My Mind, Sweet Baby James, many others).
He often uses the sus4 chord _not_ as a temporary variation of a Major chord that resolves to the Major chord (such as the “D → D4 → D → D4 → etc” opening of Crazy Little Thing Called Love and hundreds of others).
Instead, James uses the sus4 as a “softer” _replacement_ for the V chord in a perfect cadence (V → I). This “Taylorized” perfect cadence (Vsus4 → I) resolves more gently due to there not being a half-step movement from the 3rd of the V to the Root of the I.
Taylor does this a lot (eg, G → A7sus4 →D), and he's the only one I can think of who does it. I like to imagine that he uses this “softened” cadence because it fits with his laidback easygoing personality.
That ending track may have been my favorite composition of yours yet.
There doesn't always have to be a resolution, or a destination... sometimes the journey is the destination in and of itself. After realizing I had been playing "Free Fallin'" wrong (with regular major chords as opposed to the sus chords here) I have never been able to look at the song the same way and now the sus chords stand out. I was hoping for this song to be in this video and here it was!
Respectfully, without any intention of being rude, I don't know how you could possibly play Free Fallin' without suspended chords.
We use suspended chords a lot in Christian worship music. Common voicings are the IV and the V chords simply labeled sus so you get to pick sus4 or sus2. And players often use suspended chords when it is not written to do so either because they prefer the sound, or it’s easier, or both.
Thank you for keeping us in suspense!
👌🏼🥳
Wow, I love your "Exit Music (For The Patrons Credits)"
As a guitar player, these chords are the best. They sound so ethereally good, and has a sort of sense of mystery and melancholy.
I rarely comment on youtube videos but the composition at the end is really good. Thanks for that.
Sus 2 and major 9ths (unresolved) are my bread and butter of writting! Your fully sus song made me very happy! Thank you.
At 11:00 your song built just from suspended chords sent my vivid scene imagination into a spin. It sounded really interesting.
Another great video David!! When i saw the title i just KNEW you were going to use "Free Fallin". Nice little outro piece by the way.
Another classic suspended fourth intro is "Carry on" by Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young (Deja vu).
I enjoyed the closing instrumental.
I love your composition! It's really cool how the Ebsus2 chord could act as an almost-tonic. Also, you did a good job explaining sus chords.
I really like your composition, David. I really love the atmosphere.
Your composition at the end is eerily beautiful. Tom Petty's "Free Falling" is an incredible song, although I pretty much think of that bass line as doubling the vocal, rather than changing the harmony of that part. I love your work on these videos! 🙏
I just wanted to say how much I appreciate your videos and how much they help me. Even though I have an Advanced Higher Music certificate, I have difficulty hearing intervals or chords, and these videos are assisting me in my learning!
Whenever I feel the urge to strum a guitar, Blue Rodeo “Hasn’t Hit Me Yet” is usually the first song to come out. It’s so fun dancing between the D, Dsus2, and Dsus4.
In John Denver’s Annie’s Song, the primary chords within the song and verses are the D and Dsus4.
The main riff of 'love will tear us apart' uses a Dsus4 chord also. Great video.
Just a side note: sus2 chords are really just the first inversion of a sus4 a 5th above the root, i.e. Csus2 = Gsus4 which is an interesting thing to play with if you're going for a perfect cadence. Also, those weird 9sus4 chords are inversions of a 6/9 chord a whole step down, i.e. C9sus4 = Bb6/9.
Yes, exactly. For example, I tend to hear the final chord in the Free Fallin riff not as Csus4, but as Fsus2 -albeit with a C in the bass (which I think is there because it foreshadows the eventual melody, as someone else here has pointed out.)
4:20 Love Song is, to my ears, very similar to a Shepard Tone illusion in the main piano sequence. It sounds like it resolves UP to the tonic and keeps rising. Obviously it does not, so there is either some tricky finger shuffling going on in the voicing for an approximation of the illusion or the motion just tricks my ears somehow.
You're quartle harmony piece at the end really works. Well done!
Beautiful melody, dear David!
There's a subjectivity involved in this kind of analysis as well. For instance, the Petty tune at 8:36 sounds like a Bbsus2 from the very beginning to me, just played in a second inversion. From that point of view, there's no "recontextualizing" when the bass enters, simply a switch to root position.
Great video. I've loved sus chords (and therefore songs that feature them )for as long as I can remember. Now I have an understanding of why. Another great song that alternates uses both the sus2 and sus4 is "Brass in pocket" by the pretenders. The song is beautiful. Just needed to finish on a major!
I always love the compositions at the end of your videos. I don't know if it's at all beneficial for you to put them on Spotify or anything, but there's so many I've longed to be able to listen to. Big fan of your Longest March!
Thanks for making this. I was founding what sus chords are for and their uses that says it straightforward and short like you. This was really a sus video!
1:59 you could also argue that the V gsus is just the first harmonics of the G cord (first and third) plus the tonic of I, so the tension is two near keys played at the same time, which then is unfolded to the stronger tonic I (V is more part of I than vice versa)
4:39 F sus2 = F + C, Dm7 = F + Bb, so I (F) + V(C) and I(Bb) and V(F)
Another great way to use the sus4 is to use its pull towards the major triad to change key. I believe there's an example of this in exit music by Radiohead and it's a really subtle key change
Street Spirit also is a brilliant use of both the sus4 and sus2
Love the melody of your composition at the end. 😄
I really like your composition at the end of the video. But I feel like at 12:09 it wants to finally resolve! And whatever harmonic move you may choose to insert there will sound all the more powerful due to how long you left the suspension hanging.
That's a beautiful song you wrote at the end of the video
David - our greatest music teacher
Sus4 on dominant (V): note how note 4 is the tonic, ie., the chord virtually SHOUTS that a perfect cadence is coming.
Sus4 on tonic (I): note how the 4 note is the subdominant, ie., it may as well be a IV chord / a plagal cadence "feel" is coming.
Ooo I really like that piece you wrote yourself at the end of the video!
Another great video. I've watched so many of your stellar videos I feel like I've earned a music degree.
Some things never change as far as sheet music goes. "For No One" is in B major. The band Chicago used both of these chords quite a bit.
Thank you David!
I like how you made a tune built around sus chords…the transitions are very smooth!!!…I guess maybe because of the common notes in them!! Great as always David! 👏👏👏👏👏🙂
thanks!
Thanks David, once again. I don't think you've ever made an uninteresting video!
Enjoyed this, and very much your own composition. Nice work, mate! Sus2 chords are my fave chords that for reasons I can't fathom, appear on hardly any guitar chord box diagram posters. I dig all these tunes, so it shouldn't come as a surprise sus2 and sus4 chords appear in many of my own compositions. A couple of my main musical inspirations, Robert Smith and Pete Townshend, who you mentioned, feature *a lot* of sus chords in their compositions.
One use of sus chords that is worth mentioning is to soften the effect of a cadence. A perfect cadence, V->I, feels very strong, partly because of the leading tone to tonic resolution. If the V is a suspended chord, the overall effect is softened, and the cadence doesn't sound as strong or final.
A classic example of this is "Tears in Heaven" by Eric Clapton. The chorus ends with a ii->V->I progression, where the V is a sus4 chord. The effect is that it feels like a perfect cadence, but doesn't feel like the end of the song. V7sus4->I feels less "final" than V7->I.
The double suspended chord is where you omit the 3rd, but add both the 2nd and the 4th. No uses from popular songs come to mind, but the Raiders March by John Williams uses this to great effect on the tonic in C major. The notes of Csus2sus4 (what should you call it?) are the same as G7sus4 and F6sus2, the dominant and the subdominant respectively. So if you use I -> Isus2sus4 -> I, the second transition feels like a resolution, but to the ear, it's very ambiguous as to whether it's resolving suspensions, or a perfect cadence, or a plagal cadence. The overall effect is of an extremely "soft" progression, raising the tension just a little bit and then releasing it.
Since it's Proms season at the moment, there's another example of the double suspended chord in "Jack's the Lad", the hornpipe from Henry Wood's "Fantasia on British Sea Songs".
Happy Xmas (War is over) is a great example of a song that uses a lot of sus chords.
So excited that you put in Tarkus as an example. Most music youtubers are surprisingly blind for 70ies prog rock even that time was probably one of the most experimental phase in music history.
Agreed!
This is such an informative and well put together video keep up the high quality good work
Brilliant analysis as always, David. I'm in your debt. You've taught us all so much. ❤️🔥
Fooling around sus2/sus4 is relatively typical with guitar since it's just holding the main part of the chord but moving just one finger back and forth adds additional "texture".
10:43 everlong by foo fighters is based on sus2
In a major tone the sus4 chord is used on the V, being resolved then going to I. But on a minor tone, the sus4 is also used on the I degree, especially after a major V chord (which includes a major 7th of the tone), leading to a real suspens: are we going back to the minor tone or move to the major one. This kind of sus4 usage isn't covered here but is used to create an incertain resolution, like an ambiguous tonality.
Quite often a sus chord is played as a IV/V or a IV/I. It in fact includes a 7th and a 9th on the first case or a 6th in the second. These chords sound differently than pure sus chords but have a similar effect (neither major or minor).
Last comment: the sus4 in a V I progression is very common and even when it's not written on a music sheet it is often played like this.
Loved your composition at the end.
These chords seem kinda sus
bro, that all-sus song you wrote for the end is giving me some emotions and feels 😢🔥
Frank Zappa often used sus2 chords. In fact, if you search around , you can find a video in which Ruth Underwood demonstrates how “Redunzl” is all sus2 chords. I’m fairly sure too that the harmony on “The Black Page #2” is all sus2 chords.
Nice sus4 action in Abacab (Genesis). I particularly like the lead synth part that uses a constant two note 4th interval - very gritty.
U2 - Bad, one of the best songs ever, great example of vamping on the sus4 and sus2
David Bennett is the BEST music theory instructor on RUclips hands down. Breaking down popular tunes as examples has opened creative doors on piano for me
This might be the first one of these videos where not only do I know most of these songs (which is relatively normal), but I specifically enjoy most of these. Over and over again, stuff that’s on my playlists
David you once again do such wonderful example music. This time you seem to pick open the music from my dreams! It ia so nice ot know you can pull that out of my head!
Excellent video and explanations, thanks. Thanks for including Crowded House. Would be good to see Keane feature one day as their chord sequences seem very interesting to me.
The song you made would be a cool opener for an album
oh man, this compo of yours was mindblowing! really eerie and hauntology-like, it almost felt like listening to Boards of Canada. Also adds a sense of nostalgy and serenity.
Dear David, thank you for providing valuable information.
Thanks for watching 😊😊
I really like that track you made with just sus chords at the end, sounds super cool
Jimmy Eat World’s “Lucky Denver Mint” forms sus2 and sus4s as the lead guitar hangs on an E with the main chord progression vamping on D, A, Bm
That last original composition you made on the end credits, is super pretty. 🥰
Another great video. When I think of suspended chords on guitar I always think of John Lennon's Happy Xmas and that 80s song A Little Respect (successfully covered by Wheatus).
I seriously love this channel!
I believe Don't Dream It's Over also goes to a Csus2 as the second chord in the verse progression in what would normally be a Cm in that key, and it's played as a Cm in the chorus.
Wow! I really like your song at the end
Cheers!
This video got me thinking. Van Halen, who probably used sus4 as much as anyone, uses it heavily in the hard rock song "Unchained". Eb standard tuning with the lowest string dropped to Db. it's Db Dbsus4 A Asus4 B Bsus4 Db Dbsus4 E Esus4 B Bsus4. The verse is riff oriented, but basically the same type of progression. The "bridge" is sliding between Gb and E, and then Ab and Gb, which resolves to Db on the first note of the chorus and goes to sus4 right away. The whole song, he's leaving the listener hanging on the sus4 chord, and it never resolves to Db completely until the end of the song. I think that's what makes it a good driving/cruising song, as it seems to be constantly needing to travel somewhere.
Really nice explanation thank you! I like that piece at the end too. It has a feeling of floating or gently getting away from gravity and moving around from place to place
Wow ❤ so useful & application based!!! Nothing better than theory explained with examples of songs 🔥✨💯
Thank you 😊
Your composition sounds amazing!
Nice video. Something that might make for an interesting follow-up video: the difference, if any, between a Sus2 and an add9. I'm guessing that the Add9 has the normal triad at the bottom (3rd included), with a ninth added in above, while the Sus2 gets rid of the third entirely. Even if that's the case, I wonder if they are functionally any different.
That’s it, that’s the difference. You got it.
They are functionally different because if the third is there it doesn’t sound ‘suspended’.
@@SirBenjiful I don't know if they are functionally different as you suggest. I think going from Cadd9 back to C does sound (slightly) resolved in the same way as going from Csus2 to C does. As David points out in this video, a Dsus2 chord would not necessarily have to resolve back to D at all. The same would go for a Dadd9. So, practically speaking, there may be no meaningful difference. Since the Dadd9 has one additional note, perhaps it's just a slightly more complex sound, but I wonder if I listener would really hear any difference?
1. Flesh out and release the closing track. Dreamy. Gorgeous.
2. Sus chords are basically what I call a "tweener". If you want a sub-dominant sound but want to cling to the root a bit, you plop a Sus4 chord in place of where a 4 might go. The same is true for Sus2 chords in place of dominant 5 chords. They can serve as harmonic substitutions for one another.
Hey David! Thanks for your always awesome content. Great video today!
Cheers!
@@DavidBennettPiano So I just realized how cool the voice leading is on maybe I’m amazed. And how the use of the chromatic bassline works so well with the appropriate chords above. Perhaps you could discuss in one of your future videos how the song works, and more importantly on how to employ a similar technique for composing? Thank you for the time and consideration. Your channel rocks! 🤘
thanks.
sus2 is also often used with the IV chord to keep some sort of ambiguity around aeolian vs dorian : in Boulevard of Broken dreams (Fm Ab Eb Bbsus2) or Mad world (same), the latter introducing the major Bb chord only when the chorus comes ("... kinda find it FUN-ny"), with a D note instead of C, bringing a dorian spotlight on this particuliar line
That is absolutely not true about Mad World, the piano’s melody even lands on a D natural, the dorian 6th. There’s no ambiguity there.
@@SirBenjiful yep but on the chorus only. in the verse the melody keeps with IVsus2 instead of IV
@@sylvainleotard7340 I’m talking about the piano melody that opens the song. The notes of that melody are, in order:
Ab C G Bb F Ab Eb D
That final D is immediately followed by a Bb major chord.
I don’t know how you can say there’s any ambiguity as to what mode we’re in when the first bar of the song contains every single note of F dorian. It’s as clear as it could possibly be.
The Way Home by The Devin Townsend Project is pretty close to being completely sus2. Great video as always David
For no one is my absolute favorite Beatles song, so it is the cherry on top of an already good day that it was the first example here.
In addition it was crazy to hear Sarah bareilles mentioned for the 1st time in the David Bennett videos I've watched anyway. I worked with her when she was still in high school.. A coworker asked her one day what she was gonna do after graduating and she said right and perform songs. The CO worker said that's cute but what's your backup plan? She replied with "nope that's what I'm going to do" .
Seems like prog rock/metal uses alot of sus2 chords to give a song an ethereal feel, much like you demonstrated in your last song. "Distant Early Warning" by Rush is made up of Sus2 chords almost exclusively, although I think he does throw in a few major chords in the pre-chorus. Sus2 chords are also really easy to play on guitar so I know I like to use them a lot when riffing because they sound a little more interesting than a major or minor chord but tend to work in place of either.
Time Stand Still also uses Sus chords in the verses
“Distant Early Warning” is a great example of that sound. By this point in Rush’s career, Alex Lifeson was taking a lot of influence from Andy Summers.
So great to see The Who in one of your videos! Keep up the good work! 🎸🤘🎵
The sus4 chord has the same "flavor note" as the regular old V7 chord, except it's hidden inside the triad. Gives it a smoother, mellower sound--less flamboyant.
Your stairway lies on the whispering wind.