The final boss might suck but Issac's delivery of 'FUCK YOU AND FUCK YOUR MARKER' always gets me. This man has HAD it with the Marker, being yanked around by everyone for some stupid fucking space rock that has brought nothing but death.
dead space 2 is one of those rare and beautiful sequels in which its reputation has changed from "it's a shame there was no story work from warren ellis this time" to "oh thank god, there was no story work from warren ellis this time"
@@SomeOne-vf1rsLooked up Warren Ellis. He’s some popular writer, worked on comic books and wrote for some shows. Apparently fell into controversy. No idea if OP is referring to the controversy or if Warren Ellis’s story (whatever it would’ve been) was pretty poor compared to what we got for Dead Space 2.
Something I loved about DS2 was that they justified the increase number of necromorphs you encounter compared to the first game. What do I mean? I mean, instead of a space ship with 1000 members; some of whom are still alive based on what others have observed. It’s now a immensely populated colony, god knows *how* many people were killed and reanimated, which adds a neat little “When you think about it” kind of horror.
A crew of 1300 on the ishimura (only a handful of whom survived until your arrival), a population of 30,000 on aegis VII, and titan station with a population of over one million
The thing that the marker does at the end of the game is called a Convergence Event which takes all the the mass from the necromorph bodies that are near by the marker to build a Brethren Moon. Brethren moons are big sentient necromorph moons that travel space and kill all life on any planet they can! Fun!
I want to say that I loved the gag at the very end. When Caramaldansen showed up in the music credits I was wracking my brain trying to figure out when you'd used it, and then bam.
I think you really hit the nail on its head about "fun" horror. I recently watched Apostle and I immediately drew parallels with this sense of urgency and exhilaration that DS2 generates. I love your videos, super high quality, can't wait for your channel to blow up! Would love to hear your thoughts on DS3!
10:26 - I know it's a wee bit late buuuut there actually was quite a number of survivours on Ishimura who went batshit, but still were intellegent people. Isaak is just the only one who managed to actually escape out of there.
Heard about your vids from Castle Super Beast and just wanted to say that you make some amazing vids and I hope you gain a bigger following in the future:)
OK, man, MAN...I love your style. Like, you're an awesome RUclipsr, who's able to coniugate tense moments with humor without EVER forgetting the soul of what you're analysing...BUT...Nicole was not Isaac's wife, but his girlfriend 😂
I played the mobile version and it was ahead of it's time for a mobile game especially that it was only 400-600mb and since that i didn't like the run and hide horror games i loved this one where i can kill and tear every monster i face
@@-AceItX- oh no I know that lol I’m just saying there’s a game that does it WAYYY better than that which imo is what doom 2016 or doom eternal does extremely well since you pretty much are the horror, absolutely eviscerating you’re enemy’s fast and brutal
I remember shidding myself during the first Stalker section Those necrofied pachycephalosaurus/raptor fuckers spooked me real good whenever they showed up
Me seeing caramel dansen in the music list: but there was no caramel danse... (*caramel dansen plays*) oh, now there was caramel dansen (srry for bad eng)
I would highly implore you to give Dead Space 3 a chance. But there is a catch. You need to play it in co-op. Which of course pretty much tosses all the leftover horror elements out of the window when you are laughing at your buddy being accosted by necromorphs. But still it is one of the best co-op experiences I had ever head. Is DS3 a bad DS game? perhaps. is it a bad game? Not at all. The push to action also is not as big as people claim. Like yeah there was cover mechanic added but I don't ever remember using it after tutorial since 80% of time you fighting necromorphs anyway and you need to stay mobile. The weapon crafting mechanic is enjoyable quite a lot and the in game store is absolutely not required and can be ignored. Eitherway thanks for the vid, it was very fun and hope you will give DS3 a chance at some point.
when I play dead space 2 I turn on we mod. Then I activate unlimited items, and rapid fire. I get the javelin gun, and then I spam the space bar, and the turn on a auto clicker. Then explosion happens.
OKAY SO, Dead Space 3. It has far more action for sure. And shamefully inferior to the second instalment, there are some wonderful moments. And where the horror shines is funnily enough in the Co-op only levels. If you can, get yourself a friend to play through it with you. And the Awakened DLC while not perfect is still pretty fun. Worth a shot. Not as good as 2. pick it up on sale maybe
With all due respect, but personally I found ''Inside'' a confusing mess, which starts well with an interesting premise, but gets ridiculous towards the end due to the characters becoming quite braindead (an opinion I think applies to the first Human Centipede as well). Therefore, out of the movies you mentioned (I havent seen the 3rd one), "Martyrs" is the recommendation I truly agree with you on, since imo it is a true and consistent horror experience. I mean, I doubt I will ever be able to watch that movie ever again, but I am glad I did, as it is a journey like no other. Oh, right... Dead Space 2.... Yeah - I replayed it recently, and I still think it is the best one out of the 3, but in retrospect there are some issues with it. The biggest one for me is that some of the dialogue was quite cliche and/or corny even before it was released, so I dont consider it the masterpiece I did when it came out. If you want fun, though, I think DS 3 gameplay wise is the one Ive replayed the most, and probably due to the fact it is more of an action game, but the setting and atmosphere overall, as well as the lore imo was equally as great as the first 2 games. What drags it down, unfortunately is the developers doubling down on the cheese in the story, and since the cutscenes arent skipable, they really make repeat playthroughs a slight chore. Anywho, Im new to your channel, and your videos have been wonderful thus far. *SUBSCRIBED*
I liked ds1. Being alone the whole time really pumped the anxiety. And being a silent protagonist really makes you feel more alone. Fills one with dread. The sequel wasn't the same though... People. People stopping to talk with you. To send you on quests for them, and Isaac having something to say about the matter... Just wasn't the same.
Great video, I've come from the iron lung video and been watching all your content it's all great you earned a subscriber.👍 But I got a gripe with a part of your video, using fnaf as an example saying this about it 3:21 I couldn't disagree more here's why. ↓↓↓↓ c'mon fnaf is more than that, it has strategy and learning the animatronics movements there's a lot of effort put into the the sound design then just loud jumpscares, I highly recommend a video by scruffy about it. Also about the jumpscares in fnaf are handled very well imo they don't just happen out of nowhere they're the players fault for not keeping an eye or ear out for the animatronics and so the animatronic got in. The jumpscare doesn't just pop up to make your ears bleed then leaves, it's like getting shot in the head in a multiplayer shooter it kills you it's and you have to restart the night it's a consequence. It's fair to say that the more you die in fnaf it's not as scary anymore which is true, but that goes with every horror game but with fnaf if you beat the night, the next one gets harder and adds more enemies. That you know nothing about and that can be tense having to learn they're mechanics and movements. Fnaf has great atmosphere I can understand if fnaf doesn't scare people because different things scare different people, like I found layers of fear and other P.T clones don't scare me at all and kind of boring, but fnaf scares me and I find the gameplay engaging and fun Also the whole fnaf made specifically made for youtube thing can suck my dick, I 100% believe fnaf would not be where it is now if youtubers didn't play it. But still just because it got popular on youtube doesn't mean all the games are made so markiplier can over react and matpat can make theories, the only game made like that are hello neighbor and poppy playtime.
i always found it funny how dead space and FEAR both died the same way. FEAR 1 and Dead space 1 i would consider the best of them for horror, though dead space 2 suceeded there where FEAR 2 did not as well, the sequels were faster but still decent horror dead space 2 being superior too FEAR 2 in this regard. and then FEAR 3 and Dead Space 3 happened , though dead space 3 story was decent it was the gameplay that changed in fairness isaac by that time would be so tired he wouldnt be afraid anymore but it was too fast and FEAR 3 definitely felt more like COD
I love DS2 so much, even moreso than DS1 and I adore that game. That being said, do not play DS3. The gun wielding enemies and repeated corridors were enough reason to never touch it again. The story and dialogue are so bad I wish I never experienced it.
if you play dead space 3 please dont do it co-op, everyone who only played the co-op always says "the co-op is goo because one of you experiences the visions etc,etc,etc," but people like me who played both realize how shit the games hit detection gets with this games netcode and it ruins the satisfying gunplay.
Not gonna lie, you seem a lil . . . *too giddy* about the "fun horror" (cue montage of gibs bloods and guts everywhere) . . . yeeeeeaahhhh....... Edit: Da fuk is the PUBG universe???
First i want to make a counter point to the statement at 2:08 God of war did it first at least 2 did (never had the chance to play 1) Gow2 had one continuous adventure actually im pretty sure every god of war did so no, deadspace didnt do it first and gow reboot just continued its tradition. As for my experience with deadspace When i got into deadspace i wanted to find a proper horror game that would actually scare me because i just finished sillent hill 2 back then and all horror games didn't hold a candle anymore and i couldnt get that same dread feeling from sh2 in any other horror game So i went to play deadspace. For some reason i started with 2 because more or less i knew how 1 went down so i didnt bother back then, and well i definitely did not find any good horror in that game... What i did find instead was probably the best fucking third person action shooter i ever played that game was so fucking fire i didnt even care no more that it didnt fulfill the purpose of which i wanted to play it.
The microtransactions for dead space 3 is non existent. Why would you pay for it when literally get everything you need. The story is decent and their are plenty of horror moments it's just not as intense as dead space 1 and 2. Don't listen to the mob of people and just play it yourself. It's not bad and it's fun
Your opinion on Dead Space, and how you praise DS2 mmmm... I'm not in your boat. DS1 was a masterpiece the horror the tension and was the classical game were your protagonist doesn't talk thus not having the chance of becoming a moron and yet able to tell you the story of the ishimura. The second game neither knew how to build the horror nor to create a story and well... at least Isaac doesn't become a moron. The action wasn't as fun as expected, the problem for me is that it took all the good stuff of the first game and make it like cheap, probably what happens when you use the thinks that liked to people but is just fan service. Monsters weren't scary as the first game because no matter how many of them the game throws you always have enough ammo or resources to fight because the game is an "action" game. And the cinematics of some big necromorphs or tendrils that come at you, that is what I meant for fan service, the tentacle in the corridor of DS1 is legendary first time in history that someone made that shit, but it becomes some how cheap in the second game, again not because the encounter is bad perse but because the building pf tension is blow of the window as well of the horror when the main focus is action. To emphasise this last point, you said there's different kinds of horrors but gore horror is not horror, you yourself just pointed how "fun" it is. The first game is not gore, is bodyhorror the kind of horror you can see in a Cronenberg movie and masterfully merged with cosmic horror like in Event Horizon. The idea that a alien is not physical but a force that can twist your flesh, your mind and your soul. I understand that if the story must continue Isaac must become something more than a vehicle to drive the plot and be part of the plot but to me was a complete disappointment nonetheless your video is cool enough to make me want to play again the game because I forget a lot, if I remember more probably I would rant more about it but ok I just gonna give it another try and I will come back when I finish the game.
DS1 is overrated, it didn't know whether to be a slow burning horror game like System Shock 2 or loud as RE4. DS2 is better in every regard except for the atmosphere. DS1 was annoying because of how much fetch quest you have to do, the story is basically Event Horizon if the characters weren't so likeable. And the tentacle scene isn't needed to be honest in 2, it quickly lost its novelty once you know its behavior.
This review was in the making before the Babylon's Fall video. Glad I can finally get it out. Genuinely a fantastic game.
Nice chanel +1 sub
The final boss might suck but Issac's delivery of 'FUCK YOU AND FUCK YOUR MARKER' always gets me. This man has HAD it with the Marker, being yanked around by everyone for some stupid fucking space rock that has brought nothing but death.
dead space 2 is one of those rare and beautiful sequels in which its reputation has changed from "it's a shame there was no story work from warren ellis this time" to "oh thank god, there was no story work from warren ellis this time"
Sorry but what does this mean?
Lol
@@SomeOne-vf1rsLooked up Warren Ellis. He’s some popular writer, worked on comic books and wrote for some shows. Apparently fell into controversy. No idea if OP is referring to the controversy or if Warren Ellis’s story (whatever it would’ve been) was pretty poor compared to what we got for Dead Space 2.
Friggin love your use of Rules of Nature for the campy action scenes in the game. Great touch.
Something I loved about DS2 was that they justified the increase number of necromorphs you encounter compared to the first game. What do I mean? I mean, instead of a space ship with 1000 members; some of whom are still alive based on what others have observed. It’s now a immensely populated colony, god knows *how* many people were killed and reanimated, which adds a neat little “When you think about it” kind of horror.
A crew of 1300 on the ishimura (only a handful of whom survived until your arrival), a population of 30,000 on aegis VII, and titan station with a population of over one million
16:20 Dude!! What a sick execution of how awesome that moment was, the song is awesome. Love it!
Mal: What does that make us?
Zoe: Big damn heroes, sir!
Mal: Ain't we just.
That Rules of Nature edit at the end has no business being as good as it is.
Alright, this has easily become my favorite Dead Space 2 video at this point...
The thing that the marker does at the end of the game is called a Convergence Event which takes all the the mass from the necromorph bodies that are near by the marker to build a Brethren Moon. Brethren moons are big sentient necromorph moons that travel space and kill all life on any planet they can! Fun!
I want to say that I loved the gag at the very end. When Caramaldansen showed up in the music credits I was wracking my brain trying to figure out when you'd used it, and then bam.
I think you really hit the nail on its head about "fun" horror. I recently watched Apostle and I immediately drew parallels with this sense of urgency and exhilaration that DS2 generates.
I love your videos, super high quality, can't wait for your channel to blow up! Would love to hear your thoughts on DS3!
It’s kinda funny seeing so much quality from a smaller channel, but I’m here for it
The most surprising part of this video is the fact that pubg has a story
I think this is the first youtuber I've seen that didn't make the Alien analogy with the trilogy of games.
10:26 - I know it's a wee bit late buuuut there actually was quite a number of survivours on Ishimura who went batshit, but still were intellegent people. Isaak is just the only one who managed to actually escape out of there.
Dude. You need more subs. Subbed~ your voice is clear and concise and your videos are very entertaining! Keep up this great fucking work man!
In case you didnt know..your old videos are still getting watched! love your story telling style.
7:35 "There are times when you're visited by your dead wife"
Nicole is his girlfriend actually.
Heard about your vids from Castle Super Beast and just wanted to say that you make some amazing vids and I hope you gain a bigger following in the future:)
You get a sub just for that edit from 15:33 onwards, fuck me, that made me punch the air in joy
Thoroughly underrated channel! Absolutely great content, I can't wait to see you blow up because it's bound to happen
Literally all of the music you choose is pure Kino brother. Dusk hit me like a truck when I heard its music.
16:20 very nice. i wish it was longer
OK, man, MAN...I love your style. Like, you're an awesome RUclipsr, who's able to coniugate tense moments with humor without EVER forgetting the soul of what you're analysing...BUT...Nicole was not Isaac's wife, but his girlfriend 😂
I always love hearing about my favorite silly space haunted house games
I played the mobile version and it was ahead of it's time for a mobile game especially that it was only 400-600mb and since that i didn't like the run and hide horror games i loved this one where i can kill and tear every monster i face
That’s doom
@@supasyanide no, there was a mobile dead space app that was extremely well optimized and was a full single player campaign
@@-AceItX- oh no I know that lol I’m just saying there’s a game that does it WAYYY better than that which imo is what doom 2016 or doom eternal does extremely well since you pretty much are the horror, absolutely eviscerating you’re enemy’s fast and brutal
@@supasyanide Doom 2016 and Eternal are absolutely not horror games.
@@supasyanideYou’re thinking of Doom 3.
I remember shidding myself during the first Stalker section
Those necrofied pachycephalosaurus/raptor fuckers spooked me real good whenever they showed up
Your channel blew up congrats
Absolutely amazing review man I love it. I swear the shooting a hole in mars section of Eternal had to be inspired by Dead Space 2.
This is a master piece
8:36 i love how u said this sm
Me seeing caramel dansen in the music list: but there was no caramel danse... (*caramel dansen plays*) oh, now there was caramel dansen (srry for bad eng)
I subscribe because rule of nature
RULES OF NATURE
AND THEY RUN WHEN THE SUN COMES UP
As soon as I hear Friday Night in the background, Yakuza 0 video next?
Absolutely amazing review, you deserve more subscribers. Can you make an Alien Isolation review?
If you do try to play DS3, only way to play it is in co-op. It’s actually kinda fun that way.
more of this I really loved these horror games review
If Dead Space is Alien, Dead Space 2 is Aliens and I'm saying it as a huge Aliens fan.
I would highly implore you to give Dead Space 3 a chance. But there is a catch. You need to play it in co-op. Which of course pretty much tosses all the leftover horror elements out of the window when you are laughing at your buddy being accosted by necromorphs. But still it is one of the best co-op experiences I had ever head. Is DS3 a bad DS game? perhaps. is it a bad game? Not at all.
The push to action also is not as big as people claim. Like yeah there was cover mechanic added but I don't ever remember using it after tutorial since 80% of time you fighting necromorphs anyway and you need to stay mobile. The weapon crafting mechanic is enjoyable quite a lot and the in game store is absolutely not required and can be ignored.
Eitherway thanks for the vid, it was very fun and hope you will give DS3 a chance at some point.
Underattedd
a sub for you kind sir
when I play dead space 2 I turn on we mod. Then I activate unlimited items, and rapid fire. I get the javelin gun, and then I spam the space bar, and the turn on a auto clicker. Then explosion happens.
OKAY SO, Dead Space 3. It has far more action for sure. And shamefully inferior to the second instalment, there are some wonderful moments. And where the horror shines is funnily enough in the Co-op only levels. If you can, get yourself a friend to play through it with you. And the Awakened DLC while not perfect is still pretty fun.
Worth a shot. Not as good as 2. pick it up on sale maybe
But..But what if you dont have friends :(
@@Drgeorgi123 then make yourself a couple of Friends =)
@@Drgeorgi123 Kidnap someone and brainwash them into being your friend :D
in the music credits i see caramel dansen.
"when the hell he put caramel dansen?... Oh, nevermind."
Gotta follow the rules of the Wild...
Magnificent review
I like to call 'fun horror'
Horror game but you get a sword
*[unsheathes blade]*
Les dance mo fug ar
I love dead space 2 it was fantastic
First song?
Rules of nature from metal gear rising revengeance
With all due respect, but personally I found ''Inside'' a confusing mess, which starts well with an interesting premise, but gets ridiculous towards the end due to the characters becoming quite braindead (an opinion I think applies to the first Human Centipede as well). Therefore, out of the movies you mentioned (I havent seen the 3rd one), "Martyrs" is the recommendation I truly agree with you on, since imo it is a true and consistent horror experience. I mean, I doubt I will ever be able to watch that movie ever again, but I am glad I did, as it is a journey like no other.
Oh, right... Dead Space 2....
Yeah - I replayed it recently, and I still think it is the best one out of the 3, but in retrospect there are some issues with it. The biggest one for me is that some of the dialogue was quite cliche and/or corny even before it was released, so I dont consider it the masterpiece I did when it came out.
If you want fun, though, I think DS 3 gameplay wise is the one Ive replayed the most, and probably due to the fact it is more of an action game, but the setting and atmosphere overall, as well as the lore imo was equally as great as the first 2 games. What drags it down, unfortunately is the developers doubling down on the cheese in the story, and since the cutscenes arent skipable, they really make repeat playthroughs a slight chore.
Anywho, Im new to your channel, and your videos have been wonderful thus far. *SUBSCRIBED*
you know the crazy guy is crazy not because he is crazy but because he says reeeee
I liked ds1. Being alone the whole time really pumped the anxiety. And being a silent protagonist really makes you feel more alone. Fills one with dread.
The sequel wasn't the same though... People. People stopping to talk with you. To send you on quests for them, and Isaac having something to say about the matter... Just wasn't the same.
dead space is overrated lol. it had an identity crisis with its horror
Isaac is a better character when he opens his fucking mouth.
Ellie had the most sane and frankly intelligent motivations: Fuck this shit I'm out.
huh this video was certainly more agreeable than the first video
Great video, I've come from the iron lung video and been watching all your content it's all great you earned a subscriber.👍
But I got a gripe with a part of your video, using fnaf as an example saying this about it 3:21 I couldn't disagree more here's why.
↓↓↓↓
c'mon fnaf is more than that, it has strategy and learning the animatronics movements there's a lot of effort put into the the sound design then just loud jumpscares, I highly recommend a video by scruffy about it. Also about the jumpscares in fnaf are handled very well imo they don't just happen out of nowhere they're the players fault for not keeping an eye or ear out for the animatronics and so the animatronic got in. The jumpscare doesn't just pop up to make your ears bleed then leaves, it's like getting shot in the head in a multiplayer shooter it kills you it's and you have to restart the night it's a consequence. It's fair to say that the more you die in fnaf it's not as scary anymore which is true, but that goes with every horror game but with fnaf if you beat the night, the next one gets harder and adds more enemies. That you know nothing about and that can be tense having to learn they're mechanics and movements.
Fnaf has great atmosphere I can understand if fnaf doesn't scare people because different things scare different people, like I found layers of fear and other P.T clones don't scare me at all and kind of boring, but fnaf scares me and I find the gameplay engaging and fun
Also the whole fnaf made specifically made for youtube thing can suck my dick, I 100% believe fnaf would not be where it is now if youtubers didn't play it. But still just because it got popular on youtube doesn't mean all the games are made so markiplier can over react and matpat can make theories, the only game made like that are hello neighbor and poppy playtime.
You really like Rules of Nature don't you... it is a great song 😄.
Rules Of Nature playing made me laugh my ass off, well done.
I haven't watched Event Horizon..
Didnt know that PUBG has a story lore too hahaha
Martyrs is a heartwarming film with an uplifting message, everyone should watch it at least once before they die.
i always found it funny how dead space and FEAR both died the same way. FEAR 1 and Dead space 1 i would consider the best of them for horror, though dead space 2 suceeded there where FEAR 2 did not as well, the sequels were faster but still decent horror dead space 2 being superior too FEAR 2 in this regard. and then FEAR 3 and Dead Space 3 happened , though dead space 3 story was decent it was the gameplay that changed in fairness isaac by that time would be so tired he wouldnt be afraid anymore but it was too fast and FEAR 3 definitely felt more like COD
“WHAT”
I prefer Dead Space 1 for all the reasons you prefer Dead Space 2
you gotta review metal gear rising: revengeance
Turns out Callisto Protocol is garbage.
I think you would enjoy bits of dead space 3. it has really great atmosphere and the DLC especially you would love for how damn scary it is
I never played any of the dead space games.
You probably should
@@tanker00v25 I would if they had a console port
@@flamingcat1101 that's rather unfortunate
@@tanker00v25 we're stuck with DS3 on ps now 😭
@@flamingcat1101 my condolences
I am just as surprised that pubg has a story.
1 year later, Callisto was disappointing to say the least...
I love DS2 so much, even moreso than DS1 and I adore that game. That being said, do not play DS3. The gun wielding enemies and repeated corridors were enough reason to never touch it again. The story and dialogue are so bad I wish I never experienced it.
I'll recommend a lore channel for those who are interested in DS2 deep dives:
ruclips.net/user/TheBritishRunnervideos
16:11 this go crazy
if you play dead space 3 please dont do it co-op, everyone who only played the co-op always says "the co-op is goo because one of you experiences the visions etc,etc,etc," but people like me who played both realize how shit the games hit detection gets with this games netcode and it ruins the satisfying gunplay.
Not gonna lie, you seem a lil . . . *too giddy* about the "fun horror"
(cue montage of gibs bloods and guts everywhere) . . . yeeeeeaahhhh.......
Edit: Da fuk is the PUBG universe???
First i want to make a counter point to the statement at 2:08
God of war did it first at least 2 did (never had the chance to play 1)
Gow2 had one continuous adventure actually im pretty sure every god of war did so no, deadspace didnt do it first and gow reboot just continued its tradition.
As for my experience with deadspace
When i got into deadspace i wanted to find a proper horror game that would actually scare me because i just finished sillent hill 2 back then and all horror games didn't hold a candle anymore and i couldnt get that same dread feeling from sh2 in any other horror game
So i went to play deadspace. For some reason i started with 2 because more or less i knew how 1 went down so i didnt bother back then, and well i definitely did not find any good horror in that game... What i did find instead was probably the best fucking third person action shooter i ever played that game was so fucking fire i didnt even care no more that it didnt fulfill the purpose of which i wanted to play it.
They kinda botched dead space 3 in everyones eyes, but I still enjoyed it. Its just sad they ruin every franchise like this.
You don't know the story of dead space 2 wtf were you even paying attention MATE! Watch the dead space movies and timeline
The microtransactions for dead space 3 is non existent. Why would you pay for it when literally get everything you need. The story is decent and their are plenty of horror moments it's just not as intense as dead space 1 and 2. Don't listen to the mob of people and just play it yourself. It's not bad and it's fun
2 is the best in the serious, 3 complete garbage
aaand this guy doesnt understand fnaf...
Your opinion on Dead Space, and how you praise DS2 mmmm... I'm not in your boat. DS1 was a masterpiece the horror the tension and was the classical game were your protagonist doesn't talk thus not having the chance of becoming a moron and yet able to tell you the story of the ishimura. The second game neither knew how to build the horror nor to create a story and well... at least Isaac doesn't become a moron. The action wasn't as fun as expected, the problem for me is that it took all the good stuff of the first game and make it like cheap, probably what happens when you use the thinks that liked to people but is just fan service. Monsters weren't scary as the first game because no matter how many of them the game throws you always have enough ammo or resources to fight because the game is an "action" game. And the cinematics of some big necromorphs or tendrils that come at you, that is what I meant for fan service, the tentacle in the corridor of DS1 is legendary first time in history that someone made that shit, but it becomes some how cheap in the second game, again not because the encounter is bad perse but because the building pf tension is blow of the window as well of the horror when the main focus is action.
To emphasise this last point, you said there's different kinds of horrors but gore horror is not horror, you yourself just pointed how "fun" it is. The first game is not gore, is bodyhorror the kind of horror you can see in a Cronenberg movie and masterfully merged with cosmic horror like in Event Horizon. The idea that a alien is not physical but a force that can twist your flesh, your mind and your soul. I understand that if the story must continue Isaac must become something more than a vehicle to drive the plot and be part of the plot but to me was a complete disappointment nonetheless your video is cool enough to make me want to play again the game because I forget a lot, if I remember more probably I would rant more about it but ok I just gonna give it another try and I will come back when I finish the game.
DS1 is overrated, it didn't know whether to be a slow burning horror game like System Shock 2 or loud as RE4. DS2 is better in every regard except for the atmosphere. DS1 was annoying because of how much fetch quest you have to do, the story is basically Event Horizon if the characters weren't so likeable. And the tentacle scene isn't needed to be honest in 2, it quickly lost its novelty once you know its behavior.
“It plays that animation every single time”
You’re just shit... I’ve never seen it, because I’m not shit.
Seriously though great video.