The fight between the Borg and Species 8472 shows off the Borg's greatest weakness. If they can't directly assimilate something, they have no way of fighting it. In just a few days, the individual minds of Voyager find a solution that the Borg couldn't, even with their advanced tech. Basically, the Borg dont seem to have intuition and creativity.
Voyager is criminally underrated. I grew up watching TNG.. loved it. But after Voyager.. can never go back. Voyager must have written by true Star Trek fans
The Borg are one of my favorite characters in Sci-Fi but it was cool to see them get their asses kicked by Species 8472. "There's always a bigger fish." -Qui-Gon Jinn
After all these years I still have a special place in my heart for Species 8472. I just wish they would be ok to an alliance with humanity. Very special creatures with an anger management problem like the Borg.
I don't think they had much interest in our part of the galaxy once they were convinced that Starfleet or the Borg were no longer a threat to them and not going to enter their space anymore.
I have met Jeri Ryan in person and she is a super-nice person! In fact, I was killing time in the hotel lobby when she walked up to me and struck up a conversation. It took me a few seconds to realize who she was....she was in jeans, no make-up, and her hair was combed down straight. Very kind woman, she and I had a nice chat. I've also met (among MANY others), Susanna Thompson from Voyager. No Borg make-up and she looked and sounded like any other woman. So happy to have met many Trek stars over the years. My sons were called up onstage with Avery Brooks when they were little, and that was epic.
He is, I have met him 2 times. Last time would have been the 3rd but he was snowed in in Maine where he lives and the flew Gates McFadden out of CA to take his place. I was ectastic cause I'd never met her before and she was awesome to me and my sons. She was super-nice to my boys. It was a couple of days before Halloween when we met her and she talked with them a lot about their costumes for trick or treat, said her son had grown about about a foot in a year's time and towered over her now, lol. Very nice. I don't care for TOS people. And I never got into Enterprise, although we did meet Scott Bakula briefly and he was fine. Peace!
@guyverjay No, they wouldn't have. The Borg's adaptation always depended on being familiar with the technology they were facing through assimilation. Because they couldn't assimilate S8472's technology, they would have never been able to match them.
@guyverjay Figuring out how to modify the nanoprobes to be effective against S8472 required experimentation on the part of Voyager. The Borg don't experiment, they just assimilate. They lack the capacity for creative thought that is part of the experimentation process.
@@patrickstivers7387 They absolutely have the ability to experiment and learn. Thats the entire point of their character in the show. Where do you think they started?
If you ever wanted to see a clash of the titans, that battle scene was it! The Borg Collective, the picture of power, might, and evil; squaring off against the mysterious might of species 8472! Two races in a class by themselves, duking it out over thousands of light years of space. Without a doubt the best episode of Star Trek Voyager. That series may not have been great as a whole, but this storyline defined epic. I wonder what would come of a war between 8472 and the Shadows from Babylon 5...
If the Federation was smart, they´d try to turn all their enemies against each other: Borg vs. 8472 vs. Dominion. Maybe let the Cardassians & the Romulans join in the war, too. And then just sit on DS9 & enjoy the fireworks.
harpyion DS9 was just one of hundreds of of star bases. Also, there are a lot of colonies. Eventually, the crossfire of so much war would kill off some of those colonies and bases and it might even cost the federation more than it would cost to engage in war. Losing too much territory and research progress could set them back so far that they no longer pose any effective resistance. When that happens, any one of the factions could just take the remaining territory and render the federation and all its species extinct.
While a "resonance graviton beam" might not exist, those words all do, "resonance" deals with frequency, "graviton" describes a particle of gravity, or a way to describe it, and a "beam" of course is a beam. A singularity is a 2d point of infinite density, from which not even light can escape
correct Malou Franden but there designation by the borg is species 8472 the undine were never mentioned in the shows or were they mentioned in novels sto was the first time they were called undine
And imagine the shit that lives there! Species 8472 is so tough, they must have had a reason to be so. Forced to evolve in a universe much tougher than our own. Perhaps they are not even a powerful race where they come from. 😮
There is a serious problem with the physics of it since it would require that the entire unuverse there would have insanely high pressures or a fundamental difference in how gravity works which would mean that planets wouldn't be able to function and of course there would be no stars... One of the worst transgressions against science they ever made in all of Trek... Until STD Drek of course.
I love the idea of fluidic space. It seems like it's a dimension where gravity isn't cumulative, so the fluid doesn't collapse in on itself. Huge areas show algae like growths, shining with bio-luminosity. It's like the deep ocean, and one creature alone has become the apex species, unbroiled in a culture of violence and genocide because evolution became such a ferocious, punishing force in their dimension that only the most vicious survive.
Strange how they would be able to fly around in empty space so easily, you would think there propulsion designs would be fins and propellers like submarines.
@@ryry187 probably originally until they developed faster tech. They would encounter similar limitations as we do with submarines today. They're still aerodynamic with rear fins.
I always wished there would be movies with the Voyager cast. It might not have been the strongest Trek series, but because of my age when it aired, it's always been my favorite when seen through nostalgia goggles. It doesn't even matter that the cast has aged. The movie can take place a decade after Voyager got home; it can be their specific expertise that is needed to turn back an invasion directly from the Delta Quadrant.
@@1993bahamut :"... aand it says here that you yourself... you also devolved intlo a newt?" "Well, we're not sure about the 'devolved' part. It could be a future form of our species, too." "Ookay... and what happened n- ... (Beat) ..captain, am I reading this right?" "There was offspring, if that's what you mean, sir."
Did you read the part about them wanting to exterminate all life in the galaxy Anyway take a chill pill and skip to the report about the station with a holographic replica of Starfleet. An where we formed a kind of understanding with Species 8472.
Oh man, I can see that being a series now, lol. Maybe a parody episode on The Orville...ha-ha. "Captain Mercer, we've entered fluetic space." Captain Mercer, "Don't you mean fluidic space?" "No. Fluetic space. This universe is composed entirely of phlegm. And I'm picking up another ship in the vicinity. Scanning now." "It seems to utilize a sort of sneeze drive." Captain Mercer, "Sneeze Drive?...really...that's what you're calling it?" "Correction. It's some kind of hybrid drive...it seems to employ mushrooms in some capacity." Captain Mercer, "A mushroom drive?" "It appears to use the mushroom spores to initiate a sneeze reaction in the twin drive chamber, thereby moving the ship at a low rate of speed from place to place." Captain Mercer, "So it's a spore drive?"
i can watch the first 10 seconds of this video all day. i dont really like voyager, but by god i LOVE seeing the Borg get their cybernetic asses kicked!
"You are erratic. Conflicted. Disorganized. Every decision is debated, every action questioned, every individual entitled to their own small opinion. You lack harmony, cohesion, greatness. It will be your undoing."
+The Dark master The general idea is that Janeway made an alliance with the Borg because after everything was over, the Federation could fight the Borg more effectively than Species 8472.
Well. If they wanted too the Species could probably Destroy the Entire Galaxy. Plus the one Positive Meeting that Anyone ever had with Species 8472 was when the Voyager Saved a member of the Species from some Hirogen hunters but than the Bitch Seven of Nine Killed it.
Wanna see the Borg take on an even scarier enemy? Check out the underrated graphic novel "Assimilaton2". (And guess WHO arrives to help Piccard & Co...?)
MrVonKruger Drones have personal shields. The shielding would have to encompass the microphone for the communication system. It does kind of seem like a blooper though.
+MrVonKruger ...because a Borg wouldn't be able to interface directly with a starship's communication system and reconfigure it to broadcast her words in an approximation of her voice?
To be fair, there have been a number of instances you can count on one hand where the Borg actually have to make deals with people. They are often direct in their intentions and don't go around "betraying" people.
Shows you how vulnerable the borg are when their only strategy fails - without assimilation they are unable to learn or adapt. Species 8472's natural immunity to assimilation made them the perfect ones to take down the biggest threat in star trek.
That was the thing, 8472 was more advanced than anything they had ever seen. They were trying to adapt, but they couldn't adapt fast enough. Most species we see the borg assimilate were less advanced or equal, 8472 was far, far more advanced.
They decompressed the cargo bay to blow all the Borg out of there. When Seven of Nine used the comm system, the bay she was in was still depressurized.
lol did anyone else's jaw drop the first time they saw this with the borg stating their standard line and suddenly they're destroyed with one phaser burst
God bless you, Species 8472. You might look stupid as all hell, and you might have the shittiest CGI effects on television outside of 2005 NuWho, but you gave us more than enough material with which to prove that the Borg aren't anywhere near as invincible as fanboys make them out to be. For that, you're forever in our hearts.
By that logic, the Ent crew should've killed Picard instead of surgically removing his implants and making him human again once his connection to the Borg was gone.
ShadowSonic2 I don´t think so. Picard was a human for most of his life. Trying to save him was logical. But I´m sure if they found out they couldn´t turn him back into a human, they would`ve killed him. Also for his own sake. They would have done him a favour. The Voy crew, on the other hand, was attacked by Borg. None of the Borg had been their captain or crewmate in the past. And the Borg were trying to take over the ship & bring it into unknown territory. So of course they tried to kill them all, or at least throw them off the ship. If they tried to save them, they should have done it with all of them. But no, first they blow them into space, and then they make the only survivor a member of their crew. I guess the scrip required a very dramatic entry of Seven, the new regular character. Under normal circumstances, I´m sure everyone, esp. Tuvok, would have continued to try killing the surviving Borg. It would be the only logical thing to do.
harpyion Just saw this an thought I'd throw my 2 cents in. You are of course entitled to your opinion but since you threw yours out there... Going backwards, responding to what you stated. It would not have been logical at all because that's not what happened. The crew/chakotay stopped his attack because one, the bay was already vented and two she had already succeeded and it was over. So guarded and angry and on the verge of putting her off ship they kept her on. As you watch the series she plays the line between being incarcerated and flat out pushing it to the point where they will kill her to defend themselves UNTIL she loses the majority of what makes her borg and starts to revert back to being a human, ANY of the borg that happened to would have been kept and treated. If you watch the series it really does explain what happened and why. You may think it's wrong but Im really not sure how but anyway. Spare them when possible and if not use alternate options which means killing usually. It's not being trite it's being pretty straight forward about it. Anyway my view on it, which follows the story. Not perfect but pretty good.
Also just the sheer numbers of borg coming through would have easily overwhelmed the whole federation. Starfleet only had like 6000 ships. The borg probably have more than that in cubes alone.
i cannot imagine the federation fighting the borg better than 8472 i mean 8472's fluidic antiproton beams tore apart everything the borg threw at them with only a few ships and shots while at the battle of wolf 359 it took more than 40 ships and a crapton of phasers and torps for only 1 cube i know that it was an improved one but u get my point
+Vatai Akos From a purely strategic POV, the Federation has less of a disadvantage versus the Borg than it does versus Species 8472. For one thing, the Federation has a not-inconsiderable amount of information about the Borg, whereas they know next to nothing about 8472. For another, Species 8472 would have an enormous advantage as far as knowledge about our dimension--they're used to fighting the Borg on their turf in non-fluidic space. Even if the Federation somehow gained the advantage in non-fluidic space over 8472, they would be initially at a severe disadvantage if the fight should shift to fluidic space. TL;DR version: better the devil you know than the devil you don't.
The borg are a massive challenge for a writer. They are one, therefore they have no need for expository dialogue. They are the ultimate “show not tell” challenge. I am certain that I do not write as well as people who get paid for it, but I can clearly see that they were not up to the challenge.
Gavin Helgeson All this time as a fan, and not once did that thought ever occur to me about 7 of 9's "implants". Kudos and thanks for a much-needed laugh.
I loved how Voyager actually did something different with the Borg. One of the best two part episodes ever. This arc could've been 5 episodes long tbh.
Wikipaedia - Jeri Lynn Ryan (born Jeri Lynn Zimmermann; 22 February 1968) is an American actressbest known for her role as the liberated Borg, Seven of Nine, on Star Trek: Voyager, for which she won two Saturn Awards.
The biggest crime Janeway ever done was side with the Borg. Every time any species was finding a way to destroy the Borg, Janeway would stop it Same way the Enterprise didn't destroy the Borg when they could. When it comes to morality and saving the galaxy from destruction, the federation will always choose morality. Even if it just means just one individual being saved (Hugh). "The needs of the many, outweigh the needs of the few" Logic that the Enterprise and Voyager clearly didn't abide by
I finally started watching Voyager a couple weeks back I never really gave it a chance I’ve always loved the next generation, it’s one of the only series I haven’t seen and I’m gonna force myself to watch it and people say it’s very good and underrated
8472 1: ''eh, sir? who is the enemy? those boxes or the balls? or maybe that spoon looking thing?'' 8472 2: ''listen, private. get it straight. the ''balls'' are planets the ''boxes'' the Borg and that ''spoon'' looking thing is 'Voyager''
@@DavidKnowles0 "No. You don't fuck with Voyager. We blow Voyager up, the universe will rewind time and change the course of events to prevent Voyager's destruction. Look at the Krenim Imperium for example. Before Voyager got destroyed, they had her crippled and under near constant attack, preventing the crew from making repairs and had the technology to manipulate time itself. But after Voyager blew up, it was like that entire year never happened and the Krenim lost that technology. No. Leave Voyager alone. Q is watching over that ship. We don't want him finger clicking us out of existence."
It continues to bother me that Starfleet never developed protocols for fighting or containing the Borg, given they were a completely known threat. By the time of _STP_ , any plot they could have come up with should have been stopped by the phrase "this is Captain Shaw of the _USS Titan_ . All ships, activate Beta Protocol."
I think you're right. Another person said the borg can survive in space. That reminded me of an episode where un-suited Borg are fighting w/ suited humans on the outside of a ship. W/ that said, this isn't the only time someone survives depressurization. There's an episode where Janeway survives a depressurization.
No one on star trek thought of it, but build an army of "data" androids to beam into borg ships and destroy borg ship and borg in combat. Play "everyone was kung fu fighting" song as androids destroy borgs. Play song on subspace in the future to scare off borgs. It would work.
+shogun harlem (Bigsexy1234567) Decomissioning Data wouldn't have made sure they could rebuild him. Data's positronic brain was a technological riddle that only Noonian Sung fully understood. To fight the Borg, it would be a lot easier to simply take a small shuttle, fill it with anti-matter and fly it remote controlled with high warp directly into the cube. The kinetic force of the high velocity impact would already destroy any cube and if not, the anti-matter will do the rest.
As the other comments pointed out, the episode 'Measure of a Man' explores building an army of Data's. They concluded Data was in fact alive, a new species, and that producing an army of disposable people was akin to slavery.
Voyager was/ is an awesome series. The characters in the next generation may(!) have been more memorable, but I much preferred the setting and storyline of Voyager. Feel free to disagree :)
The fight between the Borg and Species 8472 shows off the Borg's greatest weakness. If they can't directly assimilate something, they have no way of fighting it. In just a few days, the individual minds of Voyager find a solution that the Borg couldn't, even with their advanced tech. Basically, the Borg dont seem to have intuition and creativity.
Communism, in a nutshell.
Well, there's also the _ludicrous_ firepower those bioships were packing.
@@lukebaines7785 They fought off Nazis.
@@marsneedstowels Stalin or Hitler: who killed more? Mao or Hitler? Yeah...
@@lukebaines7785 Yea I think I would take Hitler because I like being gassed more than worked and starved to death.
Loved these episodes. Voyager is still my favorite series. This scene still holds up, 20 years later
Voyager is criminally underrated. I grew up watching TNG.. loved it. But after Voyager.. can never go back. Voyager must have written by true Star Trek fans
These particular episodes were good.
Im rewatching voyager on netflix
@@ginjopowder Its too bad they ended Voyager in Netflix at least for the US.
Has it been 20 years!???
The Borg are one of my favorite characters in Sci-Fi but it was cool to see them get their asses kicked by Species 8472. "There's always a bigger fish." -Qui-Gon Jinn
lol
+SteveSabbai If that's true...
Who's the bigger fish to 8472? *shudders*
+yaburu Q
+BiohazardCrow Who's bigger than Q?
Gene Roddenberry :D
After all these years I still have a special place in my heart for Species 8472. I just wish they would be ok to an alliance with humanity. Very special creatures with an anger management problem like the Borg.
Yep, they just needed a far more badass name.
Anyone who can give the Borg pause is pretty awesome.
@@donarthiazi2443 i believe they're called the undine
I don't think they had much interest in our part of the galaxy once they were convinced that Starfleet or the Borg were no longer a threat to them and not going to enter their space anymore.
..you. probably don't get out much eh?
I have met Jeri Ryan in person and she is a super-nice person! In fact, I was killing time in the hotel lobby when she walked up to me and struck up a conversation. It took me a few seconds to realize who she was....she was in jeans, no make-up, and her hair was combed down straight. Very kind woman, she and I had a nice chat. I've also met (among MANY others), Susanna Thompson from Voyager. No Borg make-up and she looked and sounded like any other woman. So happy to have met many Trek stars over the years. My sons were called up onstage with Avery Brooks when they were little, and that was epic.
+Diane G My brother-in-law got to (briefly) meet Jonathan Frakes a few years ago and says he was a very nice guy.
He is, I have met him 2 times. Last time would have been the 3rd but he was snowed in in Maine where he lives and the flew Gates McFadden out of CA to take his place. I was ectastic cause I'd never met her before and she was awesome to me and my sons. She was super-nice to my boys. It was a couple of days before Halloween when we met her and she talked with them a lot about their costumes for trick or treat, said her son had grown about about a foot in a year's time and towered over her now, lol. Very nice. I don't care for TOS people. And I never got into Enterprise, although we did meet Scott Bakula briefly and he was fine.
Peace!
+Diane G cool I met Harry Kim. I forget his real name I was a kid when it happened. He was at the fair and I talked to him he was a nice guy.
@@demarcusfaulkner7411 Garret Wang if i remember correctly....
Appearing like ordinary people... that's how they begin their infiltration.
The Borg picked on someone bigger than them. It was a mistake. The scary space zombie thing only gets one so far...
@guyverjay No, they wouldn't have. The Borg's adaptation always depended on being familiar with the technology they were facing through assimilation. Because they couldn't assimilate S8472's technology, they would have never been able to match them.
@guyverjay Figuring out how to modify the nanoprobes to be effective against S8472 required experimentation on the part of Voyager. The Borg don't experiment, they just assimilate. They lack the capacity for creative thought that is part of the experimentation process.
@guyverjay To stuff they have assimilated before. If they haven't assimilated it, they are incapable of adapting to it.
Did Janeway f***** up I'm making a deal with them ain't that a b**** they were winning they finally went up against Mike Tyson and was losing big time
@@patrickstivers7387 They absolutely have the ability to experiment and learn. Thats the entire point of their character in the show. Where do you think they started?
"And Tuvak, make sure to bring that hot catsuit I've working on for my Etsy shop"
If you ever wanted to see a clash of the titans, that battle scene was it! The Borg Collective, the picture of power, might, and evil; squaring off against the mysterious might of species 8472! Two races in a class by themselves, duking it out over thousands of light years of space. Without a doubt the best episode of Star Trek Voyager. That series may not have been great as a whole, but this storyline defined epic.
I wonder what would come of a war between 8472 and the Shadows from Babylon 5...
If the Federation was smart, they´d try to turn all their enemies against each other: Borg vs. 8472 vs. Dominion. Maybe let the Cardassians & the Romulans join in the war, too. And then just sit on DS9 & enjoy the fireworks.
harpyion now THAT would be a show...
harpyion
DS9 was just one of hundreds of of star bases. Also, there are a lot of colonies.
Eventually, the crossfire of so much war would kill off some of those colonies and bases and it might even cost the federation more than it would cost to engage in war.
Losing too much territory and research progress could set them back so far that they no longer pose any effective resistance. When that happens, any one of the factions could just take the remaining territory and render the federation and all its species extinct.
That would have been one hell of a fight. It would be interesting to see Sheridan and the rest of Babylon 5 caught in the middle somehow.
So much yes
A " resonance graviton beam! " that creates a "singularity". They came up with the coolest words. That's why I love Star Trek.
Technobabble at its finest ^^
Star Trek didn't come up with any of those words, but it sure does use sciency sounding words well.
While a "resonance graviton beam" might not exist, those words all do, "resonance" deals with frequency, "graviton" describes a particle of gravity, or a way to describe it, and a "beam" of course is a beam.
A singularity is a 2d point of infinite density, from which not even light can escape
@@rawhidelampJust call it a black hole bro.
@@codename495 🤓
Species 8472 are also known as the "undine". They have ships made of organic material (flesh) rather than metal. Very odd species
Not the first time, even in Star Trek, that organic ships were used. Tin Man is an example from TNG.
I'm pretty sure they were never referred to as "undine" on the show. It's not canon. I know they use that term on STO and maybe some of the novels?
oregonflatland
sto is were they are mentioned in the early 25th century they were at war with the undine
correct Malou Franden but there designation by the borg is species 8472 the undine were never mentioned in the shows or were they mentioned in novels sto was the first time they were called undine
Brad AWESOMIZED They were also called that in the StarTrek Online
fluidic space sounds terrifying to be trapped in
you're stuck in a universally-sized living ocean
And imagine the shit that lives there! Species 8472 is so tough, they must have had a reason to be so. Forced to evolve in a universe much tougher than our own. Perhaps they are not even a powerful race where they come from. 😮
There is a serious problem with the physics of it since it would require that the entire unuverse there would have insanely high pressures or a fundamental difference in how gravity works which would mean that planets wouldn't be able to function and of course there would be no stars...
One of the worst transgressions against science they ever made in all of Trek... Until STD Drek of course.
They mention it as a passing line and do nothing to explain the implications of all of space being filled with fluid.
"Do it". I love a Starfleet officer with guts, so many of them just want to talk.
I love the idea of fluidic space. It seems like it's a dimension where gravity isn't cumulative, so the fluid doesn't collapse in on itself. Huge areas show algae like growths, shining with bio-luminosity. It's like the deep ocean, and one creature alone has become the apex species, unbroiled in a culture of violence and genocide because evolution became such a ferocious, punishing force in their dimension that only the most vicious survive.
Strange how they would be able to fly around in empty space so easily, you would think there propulsion designs would be fins and propellers like submarines.
@@ryry187 probably originally until they developed faster tech. They would encounter similar limitations as we do with submarines today. They're still aerodynamic with rear fins.
I always wished there would be movies with the Voyager cast. It might not have been the strongest Trek series, but because of my age when it aired, it's always been my favorite when seen through nostalgia goggles.
It doesn't even matter that the cast has aged. The movie can take place a decade after Voyager got home; it can be their specific expertise that is needed to turn back an invasion directly from the Delta Quadrant.
Imagine having a movie everytime a Star Trek series came out
I love 8472. :o)
One of the best ideas in Trek history.
When the big fish got curbstomped by the even bigger fish.
Or in this case when the big fish got curbstomped by a tactical nuclear warhaed
7 of 9 is/was/still is one of my all time favorite characters in Star Trek Universe.
And we all know why haha
@@theplayerofus319 Well, if Neelix (Star Trek's Jar Jar) could fit into 7 of 9's outfit I'm sure he would be the favorite.
Doctor to 7 of 9: "How are you implants?" LOL!
Voyager arrives home
Admiral Paris reads reports.
"Janeway, were you drinking"?
Can only imagine his face reading the report on tom transforming into a giant newt
Tensa Zangetsu - you make a very good point! 👍🤣🤣
@@1993bahamut :"... aand it says here that you yourself... you also devolved intlo a newt?"
"Well, we're not sure about the 'devolved' part. It could be a future form of our species, too."
"Ookay... and what happened n- ...
(Beat)
..captain, am I reading this right?"
"There was offspring, if that's what you mean, sir."
Did you read the part about them wanting to exterminate all life in the galaxy
Anyway take a chill pill and skip to the report about the station with a holographic replica of Starfleet. An where we formed a kind of understanding with Species 8472.
They might think its unbelievable until they read the ship logs lol.
It's fluidic not fluetic space. Fluetic space is a dimension where all matter is composed of phlegm and other sinal discharge.
Oh man, I can see that being a series now, lol. Maybe a parody episode on The Orville...ha-ha.
"Captain Mercer, we've entered fluetic space."
Captain Mercer, "Don't you mean fluidic space?"
"No. Fluetic space. This universe is composed entirely of phlegm. And I'm picking up another ship in the vicinity. Scanning now."
"It seems to utilize a sort of sneeze drive."
Captain Mercer, "Sneeze Drive?...really...that's what you're calling it?"
"Correction. It's some kind of hybrid drive...it seems to employ mushrooms in some capacity."
Captain Mercer, "A mushroom drive?"
"It appears to use the mushroom spores to initiate a sneeze reaction in the twin drive chamber, thereby moving the ship at a low rate of speed from place to place."
Captain Mercer, "So it's a spore drive?"
Fluetic space is where all scheming cheating ex wives go to crow
Ha ha! That made me giggle. 😆
Mucus-y space?
I think I've been there
Shows there's always someone else out there stronger. Borg got owned and experienced fear.
Only made them stronger.
i can watch the first 10 seconds of this video all day. i dont really like voyager, but by god i LOVE seeing the Borg get their cybernetic asses kicked!
I hated Voyager but powered through the episodes and it became my favorite show, love Janeway
SPECIES 8472 HAS PENETRATED MATRIX 010, GRID 19. 8 PLANETS DESTROYED. 312 VESSELS DISABLED. 4 MILLION 621 BORG ELIMINATED.
I loved species 8472! Anything that panics the Borg makes me smile. I hated the episode when Janeway joined the Borg against them.
「生命体8472」のエピソードは特に印象的でした。
あのボーグを上回る生命体8472が登場した時はびっくりしたな。
後のレギュラーメンバーになるセブン・オブ・ナインの初登場の回でもありましたね。
(日本国内放送時の題名「生命体8472」)
"You are erratic. Conflicted. Disorganized. Every decision is debated, every action questioned, every individual entitled to their own small opinion. You lack harmony, cohesion, greatness.
It will be your undoing."
One if my favorite lines
Should've made an alliance with Species 8472
+Amit Divecha EXACTLY!
+The Dark master The general idea is that Janeway made an alliance with the Borg because after everything was over, the Federation could fight the Borg more effectively than Species 8472.
+Corbin Davenport Species 8472 can be reasoned with... i think they actually called this episode "scorpion" in referance to the "nature" of the borg.
Well. If they wanted too the Species could probably Destroy the Entire Galaxy. Plus the one Positive Meeting that Anyone ever had with Species 8472 was when the Voyager Saved a member of the Species from some Hirogen hunters but than the Bitch Seven of Nine Killed it.
How often has Janeway ever made a good diplomatic choice?
When the Borg forget how to analyze and adapt, Scorpion is the result.
They missed a HUGE opportunity with Species 8472.
🌹
Wanna see the Borg take on an even scarier enemy? Check out the underrated graphic novel "Assimilaton2". (And guess WHO arrives to help Piccard & Co...?)
the species 8472 vessels have one hell of a punch, 8 of them and a dreadnought and they've destroyed an entire planet!
Borg queen: "why do we only send one cube to attack the federation when 5 could easily destroy them"
Ryan george: *"so the movie can happen"*
So the Cargo Bay is depressurized...yet 7of 9 can talk to the Bridge.
...oops...
MrVonKruger Drones have personal shields. The shielding would have to encompass the microphone for the communication system. It does kind of seem like a blooper though.
MrVonKruger When I watched that scene, I imagined Seven still clinging on to the wall while casually speaking to the bridge. Hilarious, but plausible.
InspHCallahan lol! My thought's exactly.
+MrVonKruger ...because a Borg wouldn't be able to interface directly with a starship's communication system and reconfigure it to broadcast her words in an approximation of her voice?
+MrVonKruger 2:13 "Decompression cycle complete." So it was repressurized after already.
Love the opening of the clip. Great music and the Borg look suitably menacing.
With the Borg, at the FIRST sign of betrayal is when you blow them all out of the airlock.
To be fair, there have been a number of instances you can count on one hand where the Borg actually have to make deals with people. They are often direct in their intentions and don't go around "betraying" people.
Says the guy with the Shadow ship as his avatar. 🤣
Shows you how vulnerable the borg are when their only strategy fails - without assimilation they are unable to learn or adapt.
Species 8472's natural immunity to assimilation made them the perfect ones to take down the biggest threat in star trek.
That was the thing, 8472 was more advanced than anything they had ever seen. They were trying to adapt, but they couldn't adapt fast enough. Most species we see the borg assimilate were less advanced or equal, 8472 was far, far more advanced.
I see may comments about the scientific validity of certain stuff in ST. All I can say is "Suspension of Disbelief" is key.
The universal quote “There’s always a bigger fish”
7 of 9 does a good job of talking in a vacuum, before the cargo bay is repressurised!
I was thinking the same thing.
She is hot.......Hot girls can do anything.
There were sufficient levels of PLOTonium in the cargo bay to allow speech.
I love how Species 8472 just goes full Warhammer 40k levels of overpowered.
4,000,621 individual's freed from a fate worse than death.
Seven of Nine is such a BadAss!! Love her!!
The maintenance shaft has handrails and somehow Seven of Nine fails to understand what they are for.
Chakotay almost killed his future wife.
Alimony and child support out the airlock bruh...
Just another day in GoT
Yeaaah
Wow this takes me back
They decompressed the cargo bay to blow all the Borg out of there. When Seven of Nine used the comm system, the bay she was in was still depressurized.
damn, sometimes it do be like that and you talk to people with no air around.
She was using the "Plot Transceiver".
She is part machine. She could have made a digital interface with the system and simulated her voice using code.
It's the Borg vs the Vorlons....we have Si-Fi crossover...I repeat, we have Sci-Fi crossover!!
lol did anyone else's jaw drop the first time they saw this with the borg stating their standard line and suddenly they're destroyed with one phaser burst
God bless you, Species 8472. You might look stupid as all hell, and you might have the shittiest CGI effects on television outside of 2005 NuWho, but you gave us more than enough material with which to prove that the Borg aren't anywhere near as invincible as fanboys make them out to be. For that, you're forever in our hearts.
That´s right Voyager! Try to eliminate all Borg on the ship, and if any of them should survive, make them member of your crew. Excellent plan guys ;)
seven was no longer a borg
4everanarsenalfan Really? What was she then?
2:20 (Tuvok): "Commander, a single Borg has survived."
By that logic, the Ent crew should've killed Picard instead of surgically removing his implants and making him human again once his connection to the Borg was gone.
ShadowSonic2 I don´t think so. Picard was a human for most of his life. Trying to save him was logical. But I´m sure if they found out they couldn´t turn him back into a human, they would`ve killed him. Also for his own sake. They would have done him a favour.
The Voy crew, on the other hand, was attacked by Borg. None of the Borg had been their captain or crewmate in the past. And the Borg were trying to take over the ship & bring it into unknown territory. So of course they tried to kill them all, or at least throw them off the ship. If they tried to save them, they should have done it with all of them. But no, first they blow them into space, and then they make the only survivor a member of their crew.
I guess the scrip required a very dramatic entry of Seven, the new regular character. Under normal circumstances, I´m sure everyone, esp. Tuvok, would have continued to try killing the surviving Borg. It would be the only logical thing to do.
harpyion Just saw this an thought I'd throw my 2 cents in. You are of course entitled to your opinion but since you threw yours out there... Going backwards, responding to what you stated. It would not have been logical at all because that's not what happened. The crew/chakotay stopped his attack because one, the bay was already vented and two she had already succeeded and it was over. So guarded and angry and on the verge of putting her off ship they kept her on. As you watch the series she plays the line between being incarcerated and flat out pushing it to the point where they will kill her to defend themselves UNTIL she loses the majority of what makes her borg and starts to revert back to being a human, ANY of the borg that happened to would have been kept and treated. If you watch the series it really does explain what happened and why. You may think it's wrong but Im really not sure how but anyway. Spare them when possible and if not use alternate options which means killing usually. It's not being trite it's being pretty straight forward about it. Anyway my view on it, which follows the story. Not perfect but pretty good.
After everything the borg has done it was very cathartic to see them finally pick a fight with the wrong species, a species they couldn’t defeat
"It's creating another singularity!" lol
Ah yes, the famous Borg vs psuedo-Vorlons episode. How they got away with the Vorlon ship design from Babylon 5 is impressive.
I can believe a borg surviving in a vacuum for some time. But how is she talking?
Wondering that as well.
They can, like in first contact.
they probably have some kind of transmitter.
Their mechanical parts might be able to produce oxygen and pressure for the body to make it safe from any environmental danger.
The Borg had both the ability to survive in space and use a device that modifies their vocal cords to allow them to work in space
To call my species, 8472, is highly offensive, for we are actually species 8473.
Also just the sheer numbers of borg coming through would have easily overwhelmed the whole federation. Starfleet only had like 6000 ships. The borg probably have more than that in cubes alone.
Species 8472: you mess with the wrong species mate! We will hunt you down !
i cannot imagine the federation fighting the borg better than 8472 i mean 8472's fluidic antiproton beams tore apart everything the borg threw at them with only a few ships and shots while at the battle of wolf 359 it took more than 40 ships and a crapton of phasers and torps for only 1 cube i know that it was an improved one but u get my point
+Vatai Akos From a purely strategic POV, the Federation has less of a disadvantage versus the Borg than it does versus Species 8472. For one thing, the Federation has a not-inconsiderable amount of information about the Borg, whereas they know next to nothing about 8472.
For another, Species 8472 would have an enormous advantage as far as knowledge about our dimension--they're used to fighting the Borg on their turf in non-fluidic space. Even if the Federation somehow gained the advantage in non-fluidic space over 8472, they would be initially at a severe disadvantage if the fight should shift to fluidic space.
TL;DR version: better the devil you know than the devil you don't.
I Cheered when I saw the Borg being overrun
Well, not only that Species 8472 is stronger than the borg, they Borg are, as far as i know, not able to assimilate them.
Hmmm singularity ? Is that exact science ? I first heard that on Dr Who, Jon Pertwee. Trying to outwit Omega.
Plot summary:
"It's BIGGER Jaws!"
Velius lol. I read somewhere that the Borg was originally supposed to be some sort of insect like so so pretty much.
The borg are a massive challenge for a writer. They are one, therefore they have no need for expository dialogue. They are the ultimate “show not tell” challenge. I am certain that I do not write as well as people who get paid for it, but I can clearly see that they were not up to the challenge.
I don't think the word "matter" gets used quite as dramatically as when B'Elanna uses it.
Gavin Helgeson All this time as a fan, and not once did that thought ever occur to me about 7 of 9's "implants". Kudos and thanks for a much-needed laugh.
I wonder if Yoda felt those Borg's death too?
I loved how Voyager actually did something different with the Borg. One of the best two part episodes ever. This arc could've been 5 episodes long tbh.
when the borg fell out i was thinking "CATCH MEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!"
Chakotay and Seven dating: Remember that time I tried to blow you out the airlock?
Seven: That's not what I meant by blowing you....
everybody gangsta till 8472 shows up
Star Trek Voyager had the best directors of any of the series.
Because they are Borg (Trek's equivalent of "Because I'm Batman").
Borg: You will be assimilated
Species 8472: No...I don't think I will...
How the hell 7of9 could say anything before the cargo bay's repressurization?
Luv how Seven orders Chakotay to the Cargo Bay after he tries to blast her into space. It was the first time of many.
that battle scene reminds me of star trek armada 2 :D
Wikipaedia - Jeri Lynn Ryan (born Jeri Lynn Zimmermann; 22 February 1968) is an American actressbest known for her role as the liberated Borg, Seven of Nine, on Star Trek: Voyager, for which she won two Saturn Awards.
Jeri Ryan.... in another world, the perfect Lara Croft!
How about a Charlies Angel.............
The biggest crime Janeway ever done was side with the Borg.
Every time any species was finding a way to destroy the Borg, Janeway would stop it
Same way the Enterprise didn't destroy the Borg when they could.
When it comes to morality and saving the galaxy from destruction, the federation will always choose morality. Even if it just means just one individual being saved (Hugh).
"The needs of the many, outweigh the needs of the few"
Logic that the Enterprise and Voyager clearly didn't abide by
i love the Undine aka Species 8472 they are AWESOME
What good are "security protocols" if they van be accessed and breached so easily?
Hey...this isn't Borg vs 8472, this is Voyager vs 8472. Liar!
0:00-0:12
What about species 90210...... they are from the hills....
we need to get 8472 Likes... not more not less!
I finally started watching Voyager a couple weeks back I never really gave it a chance I’ve always loved the next generation, it’s one of the only series I haven’t seen and I’m gonna force myself to watch it and people say it’s very good and underrated
Bah, between Picard and Janeway, Q owes enough to snap 8472 out of existence if they invaded the Federation.
What fun is that for Q?
@@johnv5156 if he doesn’t help they ask sisko to pinch him again.
Only this time he’s a being theoretically closer to par with a Q.
Is it just me that there seems to be something of the Vorlon about the Undine ships?
8472 1: ''eh, sir? who is the enemy? those boxes or the balls? or maybe that spoon looking thing?''
8472 2: ''listen, private. get it straight. the ''balls'' are planets the ''boxes'' the Borg and that ''spoon'' looking thing is 'Voyager''
So which one should I destroy?
Let keep this simple. All of them.
@@DavidKnowles0 "No. You don't fuck with Voyager. We blow Voyager up, the universe will rewind time and change the course of events to prevent Voyager's destruction. Look at the Krenim Imperium for example. Before Voyager got destroyed, they had her crippled and under near constant attack, preventing the crew from making repairs and had the technology to manipulate time itself. But after Voyager blew up, it was like that entire year never happened and the Krenim lost that technology. No. Leave Voyager alone. Q is watching over that ship. We don't want him finger clicking us out of existence."
Why didn't the borg adapt by making their feet magnetic when the deck was depressurised
The Borg cant operate in space remember First contact where The Borg work on the deflector dish
Error: Seven-of-Nine was talking through via comm system from the cargo bay, a room that had been depressurized. Sound doesn't travel in a vacuum.
When you're a level 100 paladin in a level 10 zone.
That feel
It continues to bother me that Starfleet never developed protocols for fighting or containing the Borg, given they were a completely known threat. By the time of _STP_ , any plot they could have come up with should have been stopped by the phrase "this is Captain Shaw of the _USS Titan_ . All ships, activate Beta Protocol."
8 planets, 4 millions.
Damn, that's a pathetic population density, borg-kun.
And ineffective use of planet destroyer. Half a million per planet is one small town on each. You can destroy it with a simple bomb.
4 billion
I think you're right. Another person said the borg can survive in space. That reminded me of an episode where un-suited Borg are fighting w/ suited humans on the outside of a ship. W/ that said, this isn't the only time someone survives depressurization. There's an episode where Janeway survives a depressurization.
Don't forget the deflector dish scene from st first contact
No one on star trek thought of it, but build an army of "data" androids to beam into borg ships and destroy borg ship and borg in combat. Play "everyone was kung fu fighting" song as androids destroy borgs. Play song on subspace in the future to scare off borgs. It would work.
+shogun harlem (Bigsexy1234567) Decomissioning Data wouldn't have made sure they could rebuild him.
Data's positronic brain was a technological riddle that only Noonian Sung fully understood.
To fight the Borg, it would be a lot easier to simply take a small shuttle, fill it with anti-matter and fly it remote controlled with high warp directly into the cube.
The kinetic force of the high velocity impact would already destroy any cube and if not, the anti-matter will do the rest.
+Ed Walker It wouldn't work. The Borg would just simply adapt to that Tactic.
As the other comments pointed out, the episode 'Measure of a Man' explores building an army of Data's. They concluded Data was in fact alive, a new species, and that producing an army of disposable people was akin to slavery.
Or just find a way to beam them all to Fluid Space. That would Kill them rather quickly.
I wish we would see more of the war
Voyager had SO MUCH potential. I just hate how magically the Borg create new tech
Agreed. She should've waited until the borg were destroyed, and then deployed the bio weapon.
Voyager was/ is an awesome series. The characters in the next generation may(!) have been more memorable, but I much preferred the setting and storyline of Voyager. Feel free to disagree :)
Took me a long time but now I feel you
There should have been another couple episodes with these creatures.