Watched from India....Thanks for explaining in practical manner ..I don't know why our school don't teach in that way all they want to only learn and pass the exam...Big Thanks to Dr Keith ....
@@abhijithshaju8963 In india every one wants to be a part of upper hierarchy, doesn't matter through which field they go, if teachers like this Sir, use similar funny methods, growing children would not be attracted to imbecile bollywood, 'holy sacred' male female gap, etc.
Haha no man I am definitely not going to use those boring pattern of using lecture method...... Trends these days are now changing and more cool 😎 teachers in India are now evolving...
Why? Because not all students are like this. It is extremely frustrating, being a teacher, and trying to do things like this with kids that just don't care and want to do nothing but socialize and goof off (middle schoolers)
This is a wonderful and fun demonstration. I've used the slinky, but this demonstrates the shearing effect on fluids so well. I brought my 8th graders to the wrestling room (padded), and did this. They LOVED it. Thank you so much for sharing this!
Gerald -- S waves are body waves in which the motion is perpendicular to the direction of wave propagation. Don't think in terms of up and down or side to side as much as perpendicular. Think of the difference between snapping a rope (s wave) and sending a compression wave down a slinky (p wave).
I have been doing a similar demonstration with my 8th graders for years. We just bump shoulders to pass the P-waves, but other than that, it's the same! Thanks for posting this. I was sad I wouldn't be able to this particular demo this year, what with virtual learning and social distancing. Now I can show them this. Thank you so much!
Great visualization of this difficult topic. When you do not have a visual of this concept it is hard to wrap your head around it. This was a lifesaver! Thanks so much!
Whenever I have to revise the concepts of seismic waves...I simply watch this one video! Brilliantly explained...watched it multiple times.. Thanks Doc! Love from India.
Splendid example for understanding the whole process of earthquake and kinds of waves so easily... I liked the way the teacher explained. Great help... Gratitude!! 🙂
This is great. Without explaining the different body waves on the atomic level specifically the presence or lack of atomic bonds, S waves inability to perpetuate through liquids does not make sense. Love it.
I used this demonstration to help my 8th graders understand the difference between S and P waves. Thanks a lot, it helped them better grasp the concept.
Наука
![Seismic Slinky-An analogy for P & S waves [educational]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KZaI4MEWdc4/mqdefault.jpg)
who come here after amit sengupta sir's recommendation?
Me !!!!!!
@@kisoredamelodies5670 me
Haha same
Me
I'M
P wave(through solid) - 2:55
S wave(through solid) - 4:44
P wave(through liquid/gas) - 6:26
S wave(through liquid/gas) - 7:56
Ashish Bisht, Thanks
Noobs
F wave (through..) 3:00
S wave (through liquid/gas) should be zero...
S-waves can only travel solid u see the demonstration it cannot send the energy..
im here thanks to Amit, also thank ou dr.
u mean amit sengupta ?
Same here
Same
Same👍
All the same here
Watched from India....Thanks for explaining in practical manner ..I don't know why our school don't teach in that way all they want to only learn and pass the exam...Big Thanks to Dr Keith ....
Yeah bro...our schools are only worried about the results they dont care if we understood the topic or nit
Because in india need marks not understanding
He is a professor and not a metric school teacher 🙄
@@abhijithshaju8963 In india every one wants to be a part of upper hierarchy, doesn't matter through which field they go, if teachers like this Sir, use similar funny methods, growing children would not be attracted to imbecile bollywood, 'holy sacred' male female gap, etc.
Haha no man I am definitely not going to use those boring pattern of using lecture method...... Trends these days are now changing and more cool 😎 teachers in India are now evolving...
I like the fact how this is still helpful even after 9-10 years.
We need cool teachers like you sir!!
hahahahaha i loved whenn the teacher hit the last guy, hilarious, great teacher, why can't teachers be like this?
Some of them are! I'm studying in Brazil (UFRGS) and my teacher explained it to me the exact same way!
hahaha
Why? Because not all students are like this. It is extremely frustrating, being a teacher, and trying to do things like this with kids that just don't care and want to do nothing but socialize and goof off (middle schoolers)
Exactly... Only if our teachers were this cooperative
@@marcobonifacioschuldes9833 really??
Teaching is really an art, and not all teachers are artists. Thanks!
i really like this method to tell about seismic waves.....nice...
This is a wonderful and fun demonstration. I've used the slinky, but this demonstrates the shearing effect on fluids so well. I brought my 8th graders to the wrestling room (padded), and did this. They LOVED it.
Thank you so much for sharing this!
damn keith, your jump and push got me laughing.
Gerald -- S waves are body waves in which the motion is perpendicular to the direction of wave propagation. Don't think in terms of up and down or side to side as much as perpendicular. Think of the difference between snapping a rope (s wave) and sending a compression wave down a slinky (p wave).
Thank you so much :D
+Alexandra Silva neyazarsam nesistermciksinistiyrum
what about the surface waves like love waves and rayleigh waves?
I am here because of Amit sen gupta sir, I they recommend it for good understanding about earth quake.
Thank you sir, I I got a clear understanding.
Finally got the concept. Wow what a demonstration. Thanks sir.
I have been doing a similar demonstration with my 8th graders for years. We just bump shoulders to pass the P-waves, but other than that, it's the same! Thanks for posting this. I was sad I wouldn't be able to this particular demo this year, what with virtual learning and social distancing. Now I can show them this. Thank you so much!
Great visualization of this difficult topic. When you do not have a visual of this concept it is hard to wrap your head around it. This was a lifesaver! Thanks so much!
The most helpful 9 minute video I have ever seen.. thank you so much! Love from PH ..
I was confused about this for a long time. what a great way of teaching. Awesome!
I actually understood the P and S waves, through your demonstrations. I thought I wouldn't intially. You are a good teacher
Thank you for demonstrating P & S waves in such a direct way. I'm going to try this among kids in a popular science class, hope it work well.
This kind of explanations are needed for every concept..I think I will never forget this concept in my whole life
Whenever I have to revise the concepts of seismic waves...I simply watch this one video! Brilliantly explained...watched it multiple times.. Thanks Doc! Love from India.
Amazing explanation, thank you from the bottom of my heart Prof. Keith Miller
wish i had a teacher like him, all my doubts are clear thanks Dr.Keith
Woow this really help me..this video is 8-9 years ago but still can help student from 2020..thnks
So thankful to you Professor. This is absolutely amazing demonstration 🌻
Excellent 👍
Watching from India
Great demonstration, now in my whole life I can't forget P and S wave. Thanks Miller Sahab
Very calm and brilliant teacher... Many thanks to the students who took their tasks so well... Av learnt a lot
the endevour by which sir taught is fantastic. . . practical enough
Splendid example for understanding the whole process of earthquake and kinds of waves so easily... I liked the way the teacher explained. Great help... Gratitude!! 🙂
Anyone can clear their doubt related to P&S wave after watching this video...! Excellent sir👏
This is the way that should be used in teaching.
Thanks for amazing video professor.
It shows how we can learn effectively by way of visually stimulating our brain for such complex concepts.
A great video indeed!
I can not thank you enough! I learn better visually and after reading so much, this has helped so much more.
Great demonstration! Im using it at classes and the kids love it! Thanks!
This was very helpful, I am a visual learner as well as hands on and this helped me a lot. Thank you.
12 years later but still impactful, love from Africa
Cleared the concept so well...thanks Dr Keith
This guy is clearly a great teacher. Well done.
Great demonstration sir! Finally i can use this one so that my class can better understand the s and the p waves
I finally figured out that why S wave does not pass through liquid.....mind blowing demonstration sir👏👏😇😇
I will definitely use this to explain to my students. Thank you ever so much for this wonderful explanation
Thanks Dr. Keith. Your demonstration helped my son Karthik studying in 7 th grade understand the waves better
The best explanation of seismic waves I have ever seen total hands down
great representation! and a fun way of teaching also. Thanks!
Thank you professor for giving good concept about seismic waves.🙏
Wonderful demonstration +wonderful teacher=wonderful understanding…. Thank u so much sir
The best teaching ever... I have understood it perfectly.. Thanks Sir..
SUPER helpful. Thank you so much for this demonstration!!
This was a wonderful and fun demonstration. This visual learner says thanks!
Thank you Amit for suggesting a wonderful explanation. This helps us a lot.🙏
Best explanation about seismic waves propagation ever!
This is great. Without explaining the different body waves on the atomic level specifically the presence or lack of atomic bonds, S waves inability to perpetuate through liquids does not make sense. Love it.
Its amazingly awesome and so much easy to understand...truly reflects your passion for physics...its fun to learn from teachers like u..thanks alot
Thank you Dr. Keith Miller this is so helpful for my presentation thank you so much
Best Demonstration. Thanks Prof.
Thankx to his amazing skills and to Amit Sengupta sir for such a recommendation 🙏💜
Thank you Mr. Miller.
This demo was very helpful.
Much obliged to keith sir for practical demostration it was fun and knowledgeable
Godly explanation, thank you professor 👍🏻
It makes my concept clear, Thank you Sir.
Im a grade 10 student and this is our lesson today. This really helps me to understant p wave and s wave.
Thank you so much!
This video helped me to understand my school lesson completely.
Thanks, from India
This is an amazing illustration - Thanks a lot
Absolutely brilliant explanation!
Awesome and simple illustrations of confusing things....always remember it
Thanks for this Helpful Demonstration!❤️🙏
Thanks for the recommendation Amit Sir♥️ and also Miller
Amazing illustration .... it is easy and well understood
I really enjoy this video a lot. I think you should do more like this. You are amazing as a techer. Gos bless you a lot.
I am in 8th std but still can understand it perfectly.Thank you so much for making it so easy😊
Thank you sir for making my concept very clear about seismic wave.
Valuable information...
Love from India ♥️
Hahahaha now I know and probably will never forget why S-waves don't travel throgh liquids
wow, amazing demonstration.thank you sir
Thanks Dr Keith! For some stupid reason my book defines s and p waves but does not explain why the come to be so. Props to you
It will really help me a lot for the discussion tomorrow. thank you!
Greatest Job for understanding P S waves
great demonstration and explanation, this is the best.
thank you very much sir.
now i can understand abut p wave and s wave.
that's so good video.
Thankyou so much sir for your efforts to explain us the concept clearly
thanks sir. very interesting way to learn the seismic waves.
I like his teaching style. Well done
Such a wonderful explaination😍😎
I wish Indian students would be lucky to get same kind of teachers in India 🇮🇳
wow! impressive!!! this short video taught me more about the seismic waves than geography text book :D
Great demonstration Sir
excellent explanation
Awesome representation 👍👍👍
I used this demonstration to help my 8th graders understand the difference between S and P waves. Thanks a lot, it helped them better grasp the concept.
epiceminence I'm grade 1 and I learn this
Great Demonstration and explanation.
I now have a better understanding of p and s Waves. Thanks sir
Thanks for this demonstration AmitSengupta suggested. Superb
Thank You Anit for recommending this valuable stuff🙏
Excellent demonstration Professor Keith
Also thanks to Amit Sengupta ji for recommending this video
Great job Sir.Thanks.
i love this demonstration, very clear and fun.
This is better than the demo I was doing. I am going to incorporate some of your demonstrations into mine. Thanks
I didn't understand my teacher's notes. Now I do, thank you very much!
Impressively explained.Thanjs a ton Miller