Unlike the PS1 original, they didn't make all the colours dull and faded in the ending before the song started. So it seems like the nightmare energy that's been spreading across the land didn't really do much damage, other than making a few flowers wilt.
They also cued the instrumental music for Huepow's confession right from the outset at the beginning of the scene. In the original, the silence except for the somber breeze was peaceful but filled with tension because something uncertain underlined it. Once Huepow breaks out the revelation that Klonoa isn't a part of Phantomile and the music kicks in is when the utter shock and despair hits you like a Mach truck and doesn't let go as Huepow explains why. Having it play early in this version while Klonoa's all cheery ruins the transition.
One of the saddest endings in video game history... With this song, the animations of Klonoa and Hewpoe, the acting of the voice actors... it hurts my heart, this kind of final cutscene 😞
Tbh the ps1 ending makes my cry because that's such a beautiful cgi scene 😢 it's such a shame that Namco didn't remake the cgi cutscenes for this remake
I hear you. There’s a hell of a lot more emotion in the original just through how frantic the animation and camerawork is and how it contrasts with how distant the in-game cutscene that plays beforehand is.
I like this version more because of Klonoa crying out for Huepow when he gets sucked into the portal It feels like there's more emotion put into it but that's just me
This ending made me feel sorry for Klonoa. He went through so pain in the story. Klonoa doesn’t deserve this. No one does. What did you guys think of the original PS1 CGI cutscene compared to this one? To me, it felt like some things were lost in translation porting it to modern consoles with a real time cutscene. But at least it is still more faithful to the PS1 game then the Wii remake. That’s my opinion.
Yeah, I definitely prefer the CGI cutscenes. Wished they at least convert them to HD or something. The in game cutscenes are good. But I agree with you.
The area in the PRS version doesn't really look dead and drained from life, which kinda lessens the impact that the ending could had when compared to the PS1 version. Also the usage of the particles could had been amplified just like the PS1 version so it looks like there's a big struggle between Klonoa and the force (the wind) that's forcing him back to his world. Finally in the PRS version, Huepow looks like he decided to give up easily on clinging onto the wind ring at 3:20, where as in the PS1 version, the force was too much for Huepow to hold on and maintain his grip on the wind ring. Other than that, it's indeed faithful to the PS1 version, something that the Wii version always dreamed of being.
Still as sad as I remember it. But I actually regard this in a different way now. Mainly being the first step in Klonoa embracing his role as the dream traveler. It was a painful and sad experience, but everything he went through here helped him understand his own powers and what he could do to help others, hence why in later games when he is a bit older, we see him as a much more mature and calm character. He even seems to make amends with Huepow in other games so the fact that this is how they said goodbye after his first big adventure makes Klonoa seem like that much more of a kindhearted character and how he isn't one to hold grudges with people he cares about, like with Lolo after she practically used him to become a priestess. Klonoa understands very well that these are good people who are just desperate and need help, and he does his best to do so without letting any negative feelings get in the way. And he owes a lot of it to his first friend and adventure he went on with him. A great example of a rough patch being a valuable experience. MAN I wish more people knew about this series.
I wish there was an English dub of this. I know the Wii version had one, but I think Tara Strong could've REALLY brought Klonoa to life in a way that Erik Stitt probably can't. This isn't a knock against Erik since he had no idea about how Klonoa was originally voiced & I still like the Sonic style Erik went for, but if Tara can voice Timmy, then voicing Klonoa would be a walk in the park for her.
It doesn't really make sense since Phantomile is a world beyond our own because it's a dream world. The fictional dream language the characters speak adds to it.
@@PKSuperStar256 True, but still. It would've been a nice addition. And heck, I don't see why Tara Strong couldn't speak in Phantomilian. She'd still probably do good at it. Maybe not COMPLETELY match the voice, but still.
This ending looked and felt better on the Playstation. I would've felt Klonoa's pain and sadness more with the original graphics there should've been a setting to play this with the OG graphics.
This. This right here is the only video game to make me cry. Klonoa just solidified itself as my favorite game series of all time. I knew what would happen, I played the original game and I was close to crying. I knew exactly what would happen, but seeing it a second time really screwed with me. This is the first game to make me feel genuine emotions for the characters.
I don’t really prefer the models of the remake replacing the original Fully animated ending but they must have gotten the ending lines redubbed as in the original Klonoas voice doesn’t crack at the end which is just soul destroying to hear in the remake. I prefer the remade audio but not the remade animation
The way that this happens to Klonoa... my comrade said that it reminded him of Roxas at the end of the KH2 tutorial. I know Klonoa Works has asserted that Klonoa was more inspired by Mario than he was Sonic, but upon hearing the comparison to Roxas, I feel tempted to call Klonoa "Sonic's Nobody" ROFL
I was hoping the remake would have had newly made CGI cutscenes to replicate thebppwerful devastating emotional visuals of the PS1's ending. While also using the voices of the Wii's Phantomile language. 😢
Yeah I played the remake version just a week ago, and I am aware this game didnt do justice to the ending because it was definitely taken from the Wii version, but still, cant deny it is still just as emotionally effective as the original one
Damn, I wish that they would have spent more time on the ending like they did in the original PS1 version. This new version does not feel nearly as impactful
I kinda wished they could have polished the ending a little bit. Maybe this is their intended design but its so different from PS1 where the world looks all destroyed.
My first reaction when i played this on PS1 years ago "No words... credits roll" then i say (REALLY THIS IS MY REWARD!! Whyyyy). But seriously this is a bold ending
It doesn’t hit the same without Huepow’s smile at the end. He decides to be happy he met Klonoa rather than sad that he must leave. It’s kinda beautiful
Want to make this more emotional? Play "Final Ascent" from No Time to Die over this, followed by "We Have All the Time in the World" over the end credits.
@@theadventurechu4546 Yeah but I don't think Namco will go out of their way to give us voice acting in two remakes for next and last gen consoles Also I think they wanted to make this collection as authentic as they possibly can
Because it would sound horrible, i mean have you heard the Wii version lol. You can tell by emotions by hearing or seeing without understanding it fully. Thats the power of language
Unlike the PS1 original, they didn't make all the colours dull and faded in the ending before the song started. So it seems like the nightmare energy that's been spreading across the land didn't really do much damage, other than making a few flowers wilt.
They also cued the instrumental music for Huepow's confession right from the outset at the beginning of the scene. In the original, the silence except for the somber breeze was peaceful but filled with tension because something uncertain underlined it. Once Huepow breaks out the revelation that Klonoa isn't a part of Phantomile and the music kicks in is when the utter shock and despair hits you like a Mach truck and doesn't let go as Huepow explains why. Having it play early in this version while Klonoa's all cheery ruins the transition.
hearing "HUEEEEEEEEEPOWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW!!!" as klonoa fades away always makes me drop a tear... ;w;
One of the saddest endings in video game history...
With this song, the animations of Klonoa and Hewpoe, the acting of the voice actors... it hurts my heart, this kind of final cutscene 😞
I teared up even tho I played this years ago! But I couldn't help it! Lol
Tbh the ps1 ending makes my cry because that's such a beautiful cgi scene 😢 it's such a shame that Namco didn't remake the cgi cutscenes for this remake
I hear you. There’s a hell of a lot more emotion in the original just through how frantic the animation and camerawork is and how it contrasts with how distant the in-game cutscene that plays beforehand is.
I agree too but when Klonoa Huepow yell each other's name really gave it that kick.
Totally. I would've felt this more if they kept the Playstation 1 graphics
In voice acting
Phantasy Reverie Series > PSX
In Animation
PSX > Phantasy Reverie Series
@@keomaelgato4332L. PS1 is superior to both
I like this version more because of Klonoa crying out for Huepow when he gets sucked into the portal
It feels like there's more emotion put into it but that's just me
Klonoa still did that in the original.
@@PKSuperStar256 Yeah but it feels like he is ACTUALLY crying out for Huepow more than the original
@@Vaffle_1231, I see. What about the frantic and unstable movements of the camera and the characters in the original?
@@PKSuperStar256 I don't think the camera and movement in the original game is bad in all honesty
@@Vaffle_1231, okay. Just mentioning that.
Yep! It still hurts!
This ending made me feel sorry for Klonoa. He went through so pain in the story. Klonoa doesn’t deserve this. No one does.
What did you guys think of the original PS1 CGI cutscene compared to this one? To me, it felt like some things were lost in translation porting it to modern consoles with a real time cutscene. But at least it is still more faithful to the PS1 game then the Wii remake. That’s my opinion.
Yeah, I definitely prefer the CGI cutscenes. Wished they at least convert them to HD or something. The in game cutscenes are good. But I agree with you.
The area in the PRS version doesn't really look dead and drained from life, which kinda lessens the impact that the ending could had when compared to the PS1 version. Also the usage of the particles could had been amplified just like the PS1 version so it looks like there's a big struggle between Klonoa and the force (the wind) that's forcing him back to his world. Finally in the PRS version, Huepow looks like he decided to give up easily on clinging onto the wind ring at 3:20, where as in the PS1 version, the force was too much for Huepow to hold on and maintain his grip on the wind ring. Other than that, it's indeed faithful to the PS1 version, something that the Wii version always dreamed of being.
Still as sad as I remember it. But I actually regard this in a different way now. Mainly being the first step in Klonoa embracing his role as the dream traveler. It was a painful and sad experience, but everything he went through here helped him understand his own powers and what he could do to help others, hence why in later games when he is a bit older, we see him as a much more mature and calm character. He even seems to make amends with Huepow in other games so the fact that this is how they said goodbye after his first big adventure makes Klonoa seem like that much more of a kindhearted character and how he isn't one to hold grudges with people he cares about, like with Lolo after she practically used him to become a priestess. Klonoa understands very well that these are good people who are just desperate and need help, and he does his best to do so without letting any negative feelings get in the way. And he owes a lot of it to his first friend and adventure he went on with him. A great example of a rough patch being a valuable experience. MAN I wish more people knew about this series.
I finished this game. I was not ready for depression
I wish there was an English dub of this. I know the Wii version had one, but I think Tara Strong could've REALLY brought Klonoa to life in a way that Erik Stitt probably can't. This isn't a knock against Erik since he had no idea about how Klonoa was originally voiced & I still like the Sonic style Erik went for, but if Tara can voice Timmy, then voicing Klonoa would be a walk in the park for her.
It doesn't really make sense since Phantomile is a world beyond our own because it's a dream world. The fictional dream language the characters speak adds to it.
@@PKSuperStar256 True, but still. It would've been a nice addition. And heck, I don't see why Tara Strong couldn't speak in Phantomilian. She'd still probably do good at it. Maybe not COMPLETELY match the voice, but still.
@@theadventurechu4546, eh. I prefer other voices for Klonoa to be in spinoffs like Beach Volleyball.
This ending looked and felt better on the Playstation. I would've felt Klonoa's pain and sadness more with the original graphics there should've been a setting to play this with the OG graphics.
This. This right here is the only video game to make me cry. Klonoa just solidified itself as my favorite game series of all time.
I knew what would happen, I played the original game and I was close to crying. I knew exactly what would happen, but seeing it a second time really screwed with me. This is the first game to make me feel genuine emotions for the characters.
I don’t really prefer the models of the remake replacing the original Fully animated ending but they must have gotten the ending lines redubbed as in the original Klonoas voice doesn’t crack at the end which is just soul destroying to hear in the remake. I prefer the remade audio but not the remade animation
The way that this happens to Klonoa... my comrade said that it reminded him of Roxas at the end of the KH2 tutorial. I know Klonoa Works has asserted that Klonoa was more inspired by Mario than he was Sonic, but upon hearing the comparison to Roxas, I feel tempted to call Klonoa "Sonic's Nobody" ROFL
I was hoping the remake would have had newly made CGI cutscenes to replicate thebppwerful devastating emotional visuals of the PS1's ending. While also using the voices of the Wii's Phantomile language. 😢
It hits different without Huepow's smile
The new version loses a lot of feeling by not having more facial expression and the world is not so dull due to the consequence of the nightmares. 😢
Yeah I played the remake version just a week ago, and I am aware this game didnt do justice to the ending because it was definitely taken from the Wii version, but still, cant deny it is still just as emotionally effective as the original one
Damn, I wish that they would have spent more time on the ending like they did in the original PS1 version. This new version does not feel nearly as impactful
Bro it sad
I kinda wished they could have polished the ending a little bit. Maybe this is their intended design but its so different from PS1 where the world looks all destroyed.
Oh, god. No again.
My first reaction when i played this on PS1 years ago "No words... credits roll" then i say (REALLY THIS IS MY REWARD!! Whyyyy). But seriously this is a bold ending
It doesn’t hit the same without Huepow’s smile at the end. He decides to be happy he met Klonoa rather than sad that he must leave. It’s kinda beautiful
i feel for people who experience this for the first time
It so sad i think I get to cry 😭
Want to make this more emotional? Play "Final Ascent" from No Time to Die over this, followed by "We Have All the Time in the World" over the end credits.
What?
@@MrOnepiecem7 Just something from watching No Time to Die...
@@SolCresta3405 Ñ
@@MrOnepiecem7 I already put Rambo music over the ending of the second game.
@@SolCresta3405 VALV.
I can't begin to describe how inferior this scene is to its PS1 counterpart...
So many ungrateful brats who complains about the remaster versions of this game!
rip that this ending still sucks in this game because it doesn't feel like DTP, just wiimake with PS1/DTP designs and voicelines.
Nada le gana a la versión original de PS1😢
Why this doesn't have the English voices from the Wii game?
That definitely won't fit Klonoa it's like hearing a kid with a adult voice
It'll be very odd and probably uncomfortable to listen to
@@Vaffle_1231 There was a simple solution to it: Have Tara Strong voice Klonoa.
@@theadventurechu4546 Yeah but I don't think Namco will go out of their way to give us voice acting in two remakes for next and last gen consoles
Also I think they wanted to make this collection as authentic as they possibly can
@@theadventurechu4546, nah.
Because it would sound horrible, i mean have you heard the Wii version lol. You can tell by emotions by hearing or seeing without understanding it fully. Thats the power of language
sorry, this one doesn't do the original, Justice
I'm sorry but this is a joke compared to the og one
What
still worse than orignal