The green indicator light is physically wired on the same circuit as the camera. So this means that if the camera is flipped on, then the light will also flip on. No exceptions. However the orange indicator in the menu bar on macOS is, as you know, all software. So there's potential here for this to be hacked so that it is disabled even though your microphone is in fact turned on.@@williamtcastro
@@williamtcastro Yeah, but it would be more consistent, and more noticeable, a bright light in a dark background gets attention quicker. Apple should also make the mic and camera indicators on iphones with dynamic island, remain in the dynamic island, regardless of the state of the island. (if you are playing music and you use the mic, the mic indicator moves to the side.)
@@Alt-Key_Here i think it would be really distractioning, as I usually play or talk with friends via discord and the fact of seeing the bright orange indicator would drive me crazy
Fun fact: Its usually not tape that breaks these. Its those metal and adhesive sliders they sell on ebay/amazon that adds just enough thickness to put all the pressure on that point.
Yeah; God forbid they tape over their incredibly fragile TrueDepth Camera that could break whenever you so much as nick it, especially if your iPhone doesn't have a case! FaceID? Forget about it! And don't even get me started on the tape-sizing hassle you'd have to go through to tape over the Dynamic Island for iPhone 14 Pro and higher!
@@Aomicplane I was just giving off an iPhone example because we're talking on a channel that tends to stay in the Apple ecosystem... I know about the competition, though...
@@AvidSonicFan Not everyone uses an iPhone. And as shown in the video, Macbook displays break due to people taping over the webcam causing an uneven pressure on the screen when the lid is closed, yet people still tape over their Macbook webcam and not their iPhone front cams. Was simply giving an example of the idiocy of people who tape over their webcams because they're afraid of being spied through it, yet they don't care at all when it comes to phones, tablets and other devices...
Because we actually use the selfie cam on the iPhone 😂 With my MacBook Air M1 I taped it when I got it and never once used the webcam. Also never had problems, but after this video, I'm probably going to take the tape off just to be safe.
The fact that finally convinced me to stop covering the camera is that the green light is physically connected. Camera can’t be triggered without it turning on. And if someone wonders why ever cover the camera: that is not the fear of Apple spying (😂), but the fear of unofficial/pirated software doing that.
So, you are telling me, that even a screen protector could crack that screen? Sounds like a bad design then. It does the same thing. Get in between screen and keyboard, when closed. Laptops are fragile devices and the middle of the screen frame is on of the weakest points. The issue is not the tape. Throwing it in your fancy bag, with barely any protection is. Think about how it my bump around, while you walk, or what other things in your bag may hit it. Hard cases FTW.
I'm surprised I haven't found anybody bring this up yet (not that I would justify taping up webcams)! Some of the biggest counter-arguments people would have for taping up their webcams for "privacy" is because despite Apple telling people they care about their privacy, these people believe Apple (like any other corporation) is lying to them about it, and that they also believe that hackers may activate the webcams without also activating the green active light next to it. I'm not a pro-privacy conspiracy theorist (anymore), so I can't say specifically what else drives them to do it despite all the physical damage doing this causes...
Okay when I click on the video and see 5k subscribers, my expectations were low. But you're amazing! Keep up the good work and I'm sure you'll grow greatly c:
when you got to the sponsor bit my finger went to the arrow button reallll quick xD this is the first video I have watched of yours, and I absolutely loved it, subscribing :D
Very good video, Mr. Rotten Apple. But we can’t be 100% sure about the green camera light, can we? If the green light is controlled by software, then we definitely can’t be sure that no one is watching us right now.
The thing is, there are ways of turning on the camera without the light turning on. Virus for macos do exist, and I might activate the camera by accident! I get the reason, but tolerances that tight are unnecesary and unrealistic in a laptop. Don't get me wrong, I love macbooks as much as the next guy, but some things are not okay and this is one of many
Nah man the FBI really be a tracking a random 13 yr old like me. So nah I’ll go ahead and place tape over my imaginary MacBook I’ll never be able to afford
i didn't know this could cause an issue like that for the macbook, i haven't done it to my macbook because of the green light indicator. Dark Mode is the best mode
You do realize, hackers can access your camera without the green light coming on. If I want to see you with your device camera, I’m sure I can find a low flying way to. If hackers can hack major companies like Sony and other major tech companies, they can hack random people.
Short answer, not anymore*, with an asterisk. The origin of this thinking was in 2018, when the retina MacBook Air was first released. Case manufacturers assumed the design was similar in function to Apple’s previous hinge designs, so they made cases which wrapped too far around in the back. I’m not sure the exact mechanics of how it worked, but it was causing screens to crack from pressure being applied from an unanticipated angle. This was quickly remedied by case makers, so by the time the 2019 MacBook Air came around, almost no case on the market would cause this issue anymore. With that said, the asterisk comes in because there is still some argument that cases put extra strain on your Mac’s hinges, because Apple’s engineering is so finely tuned that even the weight of a case is enough to throw the hinge off over time, but in my experience as a repair technician, loose hinges and case users don’t seem to correlate, so I’m willing to say that one is probably a misconception, just very difficult to disprove.
the new RottenOS update finally came with dark mode. what do you guys think?
goes hard.
Darkmode go harddddd
it looks better
Very cool
Linux had this period
What I just realized is that the green indicator is consistent across devices. There should be an orange led as well for microphone usage.
Actually it is on macs but on the right side of the topbar when mic is in use
The green indicator light is physically wired on the same circuit as the camera. So this means that if the camera is flipped on, then the light will also flip on. No exceptions. However the orange indicator in the menu bar on macOS is, as you know, all software. So there's potential here for this to be hacked so that it is disabled even though your microphone is in fact turned on.@@williamtcastro
@@williamtcastro Yeah, but it would be more consistent, and more noticeable, a bright light in a dark background gets attention quicker. Apple should also make the mic and camera indicators on iphones with dynamic island, remain in the dynamic island, regardless of the state of the island. (if you are playing music and you use the mic, the mic indicator moves to the side.)
Heck, while we’re at it, the location indicator should also be there. Also ALL the indicators should be visible when used.
@@Alt-Key_Here i think it would be really distractioning, as I usually play or talk with friends via discord and the fact of seeing the bright orange indicator would drive me crazy
Man you had me at "this videos sponsor" I legit already skipped 15 seconds forward faster, than you said just kidding.
Same
Fun fact: Its usually not tape that breaks these. Its those metal and adhesive sliders they sell on ebay/amazon that adds just enough thickness to put all the pressure on that point.
People put tape over their laptop camera's yet never over the selfie cams on their phones. Never got that one.
Yeah; God forbid they tape over their incredibly fragile TrueDepth Camera that could break whenever you so much as nick it, especially if your iPhone doesn't have a case! FaceID? Forget about it!
And don't even get me started on the tape-sizing hassle you'd have to go through to tape over the Dynamic Island for iPhone 14 Pro and higher!
@@Aomicplane I was just giving off an iPhone example because we're talking on a channel that tends to stay in the Apple ecosystem...
I know about the competition, though...
@@AvidSonicFan Not everyone uses an iPhone. And as shown in the video, Macbook displays break due to people taping over the webcam causing an uneven pressure on the screen when the lid is closed, yet people still tape over their Macbook webcam and not their iPhone front cams.
Was simply giving an example of the idiocy of people who tape over their webcams because they're afraid of being spied through it, yet they don't care at all when it comes to phones, tablets and other devices...
Because we actually use the selfie cam on the iPhone 😂 With my MacBook Air M1 I taped it when I got it and never once used the webcam. Also never had problems, but after this video, I'm probably going to take the tape off just to be safe.
@@Razertw But why tape it off in the first place lmao?
The fact that finally convinced me to stop covering the camera is that the green light is physically connected. Camera can’t be triggered without it turning on.
And if someone wonders why ever cover the camera: that is not the fear of Apple spying (😂), but the fear of unofficial/pirated software doing that.
You got a team behind you? This is like 10/10 production quality.
nope, just me lol thanks!
So, you are telling me, that even a screen protector could crack that screen? Sounds like a bad design then.
It does the same thing. Get in between screen and keyboard, when closed. Laptops are fragile devices and the middle of the screen frame is on of the weakest points. The issue is not the tape. Throwing it in your fancy bag, with barely any protection is.
Think about how it my bump around, while you walk, or what other things in your bag may hit it.
Hard cases FTW.
that potential sponsor segway was smooooth
I'm surprised I haven't found anybody bring this up yet (not that I would justify taping up webcams)! Some of the biggest counter-arguments people would have for taping up their webcams for "privacy" is because despite Apple telling people they care about their privacy, these people believe Apple (like any other corporation) is lying to them about it, and that they also believe that hackers may activate the webcams without also activating the green active light next to it.
I'm not a pro-privacy conspiracy theorist (anymore), so I can't say specifically what else drives them to do it despite all the physical damage doing this causes...
These videos just keep getting better and I am here for it! I just hope this channel grows! 10/10 editing, animation and detail. 🔥
So true, get this man 100k subs!
You just keep getting better man. The introduction was so entertaining hahahahaha
The Final Cut bit calling out MKBHD really got me good ✌️
The real question is why is tape enough to throw the whole pressure of a Mac off?
Did you even watch the video? 🤦♂️
His point was it seems like bad design on apple's part considering most laptops don't have this issue
@@pazu3979 most laptops dont have this issue cos most laptops can be opened with a little flinch. most laptops dont bind very good
Because Apple prioritizes thinness over durability.
@@LennySharer9tape isn't that thick tho
The moment you pulled that graph up you had me hitting the subscribe button! Amazing video!
3:45 HE USED ARC!!! Letsgoooo arc is the best
My computer blue-screened watching this video
Dude I just found your channel today and I think your my favorite tech RUclipsr of ALL TIME. And that’s saying a lot to me
the controversial part is that if you are not out of warranty and does not cover it.
"I'm looking at you Marques" LMFAOOOOOO 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
The quality is improving 🤝
Okay when I click on the video and see 5k subscribers, my expectations were low. But you're amazing! Keep up the good work and I'm sure you'll grow greatly c:
I really like these videos, the quality is outstanding! Really wish this channel grows!!
easily my best youtuber , keep it up
I thought this already had 100K subscribers or so because of the quality. I hope you get more subscribers soon. You got yourself a new sub
Oh Damn I Should've Known This...
when you got to the sponsor bit my finger went to the arrow button reallll quick xD this is the first video I have watched of yours, and I absolutely loved it, subscribing :D
I've broken a laptop like this, when I realized, i faced palm so hard
this is my favorite youtuber so far. everything is so perfect 😁
My God you even have the Intentionally Vague Apple Graphs! Awesome work man!
This channel really deserves to blow up. Hope the algorithm blesses you soon.
Super underrated. Here before 100k
Being at uni, I always have to bite my tongue whenever I notice that someone has one of these silly covers on their MacBook
Love this video! Very fun to watch. The tape that people put over their MacBook camera always annoyed me.
Very good video, Mr. Rotten Apple. But we can’t be 100% sure about the green camera light, can we? If the green light is controlled by software, then we definitely can’t be sure that no one is watching us right now.
Thanks! Really helpful video. Keep up the good work!
That first graph was so funny
take a look at this chart gets me every time 😭
I was already missing your videos!
Omg! This channel is so underrated 😢
YAAAA DARKMODE THANK YOU
2:41
I was really about to skip ahead oh mah gud
why did you look back here
The thing is, there are ways of turning on the camera without the light turning on. Virus for macos do exist, and I might activate the camera by accident! I get the reason, but tolerances that tight are unnecesary and unrealistic in a laptop. Don't get me wrong, I love macbooks as much as the next guy, but some things are not okay and this is one of many
How about a screen protector?
Nah man the FBI really be a tracking a random 13 yr old like me.
So nah I’ll go ahead and place tape over my imaginary MacBook I’ll never be able to afford
This video was awesome, hope to see more from you in the future. :)
i didn't know this could cause an issue like that for the macbook, i haven't done it to my macbook because of the green light indicator. Dark Mode is the best mode
really funny and informative video 🤣💯💯 you got a new sub bro!
Thoughts on screen protectors? I've had one on my Air for over 2 years now and I'm worried if it may cause issues if I remove it
You do realize, hackers can access your camera without the green light coming on. If I want to see you with your device camera, I’m sure I can find a low flying way to. If hackers can hack major companies like Sony and other major tech companies, they can hack random people.
i am a windows user and i still watched it till the end!
Hi rotten apple. can you make a video about Jailbreaking or Sideloading.
You are my new favorite channel.
these videos are way too good.
use arc browser instead of safari
god tier videos keep it up man
Dude’s rizz is smooth as his shorts
i dont even have a webcam or a microphone lol
brillient video!
What about keyboard covers?
silicon not silicone...
Very, very, very good vid!
gotta spend 30000000 dollars on a replacement screen i love mac
ok fed
this is a great video
or just buy a dell laptop for half of the price and get a integrated camera privacy cover
Does ssds worn out faster in macs? Specially the 2020 m1 base version(8gb 256gb)? Is there a way to minimize or stop the ram swap?
Nope because integrated memory!!!!
@@jorgeorge06 So what do I do? Kinda bummed about it, can’t change the ssd
There’s nothing you can do. It is what it is
Thank you for dark mode
Best wishes. Nice info you provide.
This made me subscribe
What about hard cases for macbooks, are they bad?
Short answer, not anymore*, with an asterisk. The origin of this thinking was in 2018, when the retina MacBook Air was first released. Case manufacturers assumed the design was similar in function to Apple’s previous hinge designs, so they made cases which wrapped too far around in the back. I’m not sure the exact mechanics of how it worked, but it was causing screens to crack from pressure being applied from an unanticipated angle. This was quickly remedied by case makers, so by the time the 2019 MacBook Air came around, almost no case on the market would cause this issue anymore. With that said, the asterisk comes in because there is still some argument that cases put extra strain on your Mac’s hinges, because Apple’s engineering is so finely tuned that even the weight of a case is enough to throw the hinge off over time, but in my experience as a repair technician, loose hinges and case users don’t seem to correlate, so I’m willing to say that one is probably a misconception, just very difficult to disprove.
i used electrical tape its been working for a while now
The NSA is still spying on me, so this advice doesn’t help.
Teach me how to uninstall the camera driver instead.
even better: unplug the camera cable from the inside
me who uses galaxy book 2:
Wrong, the cheapest way to break it is to drop it!
gold
MEOW i love these videos
i never cover my laptop camera.. i just dont open my laptop 😜
I do not have a mac
wow. Nice video
just dont buy from apple
I think if someone is skilled enough to hack into my camera, he would also know how to just turn off the green light…
You should have more subscribers.
Cool video but too many jokes for how long it is IMO
W video
Actually Macbook with Apple Silicon has very good quality camera. There isn't probably better on any PC laptop
The framework has switches to permanently disable ur camera and mic on a hardware level. You don't see that on a macbook
@@pazu3979 How is that related to the camera image quality?
The one on the M1 is ass
they still suck though, even if it's better than all other laptops
@@awii.neocities Probably because they are mainly meant for video meetings and bandwidth is limited.
Bro i really fell for that video sponsor thing i was about to skip ahead like srsly!!! Good quality videos bro....🤌🏼