Tales of Arise: PlayStation 5 vs Xbox Series X/S Tech Breakdown
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024
- Our new contributor - Oliver Mackenzie - strikes back with this second project for us, circling back to take a look at the excellent Tales of Arise, as it plays out on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series consoles.
Join the DF Patreon for pristine video downloads, behind the scenes content, early access to DF Retro, early access to DF Direct Weekly and much, much more: bit.ly/3jEGjvx
Subscribe for more Digital Foundry: bit.ly/DFSubscribe
Want some DF-branded tee-shirts, mugs, hoodies or pullovers? Check out our store: bit.ly/2BqRTt0
Love how Oliver came out of nowhere and produces videos, like as if he was part of the team for years! Great stuff
Wait, he isn‘t?
Love this game on xbox series x it's my first tales game
Welcome back digital foundry and welcome Oliver Mackenzie.
What happened?
@@Rohgamu they got hacked like 2 days ago but recovered in less than 24 hours
Series X basically runs Graphics Mode as well as PS5 runs Performance Mode.
Meanwhile Graphics Mode on PS5 is running with constant tearing because Sony can't get VRR working.
Seriesx destroyed PS 5 Here , massive diference , PS 5 30 fps 🤔🤔🤔😂😂😂😂🦾🦾
@@andrenascimento9112 It's more like a 10-15fps difference average but it's just the lack of VRR on PS5 that makes it look so bad.
@@budthecyborg4575 he doesn't recommend the graphics mode on PS 5 vs graphics mode on seriesx runs mostly at full native 4k 60 fps with drops to low 40 in some aéreas is already a huge advantage for Xbox seriesx , if you put VRR and the performance mode beeing Also superior its a massive W for Xbox Here.
Now that DF team got bigger, maybee somebody will find time to analyse Psychonauts 2.
Yeah, for a game that they all seemed to have loved, it's sad that they didn't cover it.
Why?...it's a totally lastgen looking game and there is no PS5 support, only Xbox Series.
@@kostasbousbouras2654 that could still be an interesting video for some people
@@kostasbousbouras2654 you’ll probably never be able to witness it, but Psychonauts 2 on Series X in Dolby Vision is absolutely beautiful. Not quite Ratchet & Clank beautiful, but it gets close.
One of the best platformers I've ever played!!! Graphics and fidelity top notch. Controls great. Overall world and game design was awesome!!
It's great to see DF is back after the highjacking. Welcome Olie! Hopefully this will allow for even more coverage.
What if it was just ollie all along? (cue suspenseful music)
what happened?
@UCxfuC8B97eGf7A1cGLMbjpg Someone got ahold of the df channel, then after they got it back youtube's system disabled the channel for a bit. I didn't see it, but apparently the channel broadcast a space x video with Musk and started streaming cryptocurrency scams after that.
@@Yodagamer1 I see , thank you.
@@Yodagamer1 Digital Foundry was a coin operated all along…
Can't imagine this industry without you guys ❤
My first tales game, playing it on the series x and I am loving it so much. The opening theme is kick ass and I never skip it when I start up the game!
Same I got a series x and have been loving this game
I wish the PS5 version wasn't so seemingly inferior. I want to get the game to my newly acquired PS5 (which was extremely hard work and effort to find and buy and finally realize), but seeing how the XSX performs noticably better for whatever reason and not identical, it's kinda of a bummer and discouraging. But I guess in the end it doesn't really matter and I'll play it on Performance Mode on the PS5. I can also get it on PC perhaps and use Custom Resolution like 80-90%, maybe 1800p or so. But I want to play a game like this on console.
I like the SECOND opening theme even more!!
If you are able to, i would recommend you to try the older games on PS3/4. My favourite is Tales of Xillia on PS3, if you like Arise, you will like this game too.
@@SlayerSeraph I run it on performance mode. 60fps matters to me in a game like this!
Oliver just fits into DF so seamlessly. Another incredible video! TY for covering this one :)
This was one of the best in the series. I put about 90 hours and got all acheivements in the game, loved it the whole time.
Is it easy for a series newcomer to jump into this? I do love games like Persona 5, FF7
@@leonthesleepy I would say yes, it is its own contained story and characters. No need to have knowledge of past games. I think there might be a demo still available for Xbox/Playstation to try it out.
@@leonthesleepy There is absolutely no issue. The only thing you are missing out if you haven't played the previous games are a 2 or 3 cameo appearances in the post game dungeons.
People told me this but failed to mention that you will run into a cutscene every other damn minute. Like Christ’s sakes let me play, you just showed me a cutscene before I entered the area you don’t have to show me another one as I enter it.
Nice! Always good to have a clear sense of which version I should pick up. XSX it is!
Digital Foundry : “I never yielded! And as you can see: I am not dead!”
DF: "We respawn with one more in our team"
Omg! Was waiting for so long for DF to give this one justice! Its one of the best looking RPGs i played! Such a gorgeous looking world and environment,battle effects, just stunning! Best rpg i played since DQ11,such a masterpiece ,it was worth the wait, its been 5 years since Berseria! Tales of next gen was successful, brilliant Tales & brilliant rpg, love every second, so much to say about it really ❤
Yes awesome game i play also 🥳 God Bless You 🙏🙂👍
I’m on PS4 pro newbie to the game. It’s fun.
It's pretty but the game absolutely falls apart after the fifth lord area. It becomes a droning skit and cutscene simulator with dragged out content for the last 15 or so hours.
The enemy variety is also pitiful. Definitely not the best Tales game...
@@steel5897 it needs a horde or dungeon mode.
@@michaelschneider1365 it does have a dungeon mode. keep playing
Could really use that VRR support on PS5
Tell Sony that clown
I still don't get why Sony doesn't want to support VRR
@@METALFACEDOOMXXXX mostly just buying more on my SX for now but I'll consider yelling at them thanks
It's been almost a year, kind of unbelievable
@@kennethfegley7552 I got ps5 its terrible
XBSX version it is then. ^^
Glad to have the choice with 3rd party games.
Gotta love VRR.
How about covering another title past due like Lost Judgment? Would love to see a technical review of that game.
YES PLEASE.
I was commenting that for so long but lost judgment video never happened so i just gave up
Vrr is by far the best feature for me so far this gen. There are so many games that “feel” like a locked 60 to me but when I pull up the frame counter it’s bouncing around between high 40s and 60 most of the time. Thanks to vrr I wouldn’t know without the frame counter built into the tv
I have both PS5 and XSX and the Framerate advantages (locked 60fps on performance mode vs. constant dips on PS5) and better Framerate and VRR on Graphics mode for XSX, the choice was easy on which version to get 👌
This One of the easiest wins for seriesx , another One
@@andrenascimento9112 Imagine being a fanboy in 2021
I concur. Better on XSX. I barely use my PS5 now.
@@danwelch3775 they're not a fanboy they're just correct
PS5 got VRR april 2022 via update 😊@@LiteFightr
Still waiting for Psychonauts 2.
John said they not doing it
@@stephonhines6554 they did do a long discussion on it just not a tech breakdown
I just picked this game up and it gets better looking as you progress!!! I’m loving it
Can't wait for the analysis of the GTA Trilogy performance trainwreck. XSX can somehow run Forza 5 like butter at 60fps but GTA 3 at night with effects from 2008? Stutterfest. Now we know why no videos were released of the trilogy prior to release, only screenshots...
PS 5 is Also a stutter party ....
@@andrenascimento9112 no reason either console should be stuttering. They should be running this game 4k/120 with no issues. Hell, the base Xbox One should be able to run this at 1080p/60fps solid with every setting turned on. This has to be the worst optimized game I've seen in the last 5 years...
Sounds like a Rockstar problem to me
@@repobirdies4394 yes and it is
Unreal Engine 4 with that level of dynamic lighting, dynamic shadowing, the huge number of lights and screen space reflections is definitely not 2008 level ...
VRR on Series X means you can run graphics mode and not have to compromise between native 4k or 60 fps.
Clear win for Series X here.
Never felt a dip with 70+ hours of gameplay.
That said, the end of this game is horrid. It was clearly rushed/impacted by covid development, and the game doesn't even gave a real ending.
It rolls credits and shows you artwork.
Glad you mentioned that. I kept giving Tales games a try, and kept losing interest through the 'filler', but keep thing about giving this one a chance.
Thank god the channel has been restored, missed you guys.
What happened?
Hopefully i can pick it on sale during Black Friday on the Series X. Seems to run best there.
Really loved this game -- sometimes you just need some popcorn JRPG goodness, and this delivered in every regard. Bangin' soundtrack, gorgeous visuals, tight gameplay and lots of optional sidequests to get materials to make powerful endgame weapons. 80+ hours logged in my Steam library and this video made me want to jump in again.
Graphics: Xbox series X = PS5 > Xbox series S
Frame rate: Xbox Series X > Xbox series S > PS5
Lol you wish xbox series x beats everything
I literally just got this game on the Xbox Series X because I'm playing Scarlet Nexus on Xbox Game Pass and absolutely love it. I don't usually play JRPGs so I thank Game Pass for introducing me to this genre. I've yet to tear into Tales of Arise here as I want to finish Scarlet Nexus 1st but the game looks sooo good I just had to pick it up and I installed it and booted up just to take a look at the opening and man the opening cutscene looks absolutely incredible. I'm glad I went with the Xbox Series X version seeing as it's able to run the game at a mostly locked 4K/60 in graphics mode. I have a PS5 as well but this game looks too good to have to run in the the 1640p Performance mode just to get 60FPS so it's nice I don't really have to sacrifice frame rate to get a higher resolution altho I totally would have if need be. Can't wait to play this after I finsish Scarlet Nexus.
I'm right there with you, it's a great game you're going to love it 👌🏽
@@1AJBOOMER
Awesome did you see both games got Nominated for RPG of the Year at the Game Awards?
@@Fabio-ql5yf - It is not 4K30 on PS5...
Glad the channel is back online! I really don't know why someone would attempt to hack the channel,but I hope everything is better now! Keep the amazing content going!
I don't agree with it but I know who would crazy fanboys sometimes some of these analysis video really do fuel some of the crazies I noticed alot more hate happens with Alex's videos he does brilliant in-depth videos but it starts going into fanboy territory even though it might not come from that place or Intended but how Oli covered this analysis was great first time watching one of his and looking forward to more.
Also I noticed the comments section on this video seem to be quite nice complementing Oliver and the game and barely if any fanboy bs going on which is nice to see 😁
Thank goodness Alex did not review this, otherwise he would've been offended by the anime boobs in the game.
Lol his fake outrage was so cringe. Like he doesn't enjoy looking at ass as much as the rest of us.
Being offended = virtue, to some.
Sad part about it is the character model was realistic and did not actually side with traditional anime tropes. It was an athletic body type that is achievable in the real world.
Which game was he whining about?
@@mitsuhed project eve
The snow area is definitely the most demanding area for framerates. Even on my pc, I had to turn the graphics settings down in that area since the fans were really picking up
wat? this game is not demanding at all, actually it looks like shit.
Hope you don't mind me asking, but what Graphics card and CPU are you using? I'm looking to build a new PC soon.
@@drumjod yeah no problem. I'm actually using a gaming laptop that has a 3050 ti and a ryzen 5000 series processor. Perfectly capable of running this game no problem. My main issue is that the fan gets loud when a game has a lot of particle effects since it pushes your computer a lot. That is why the second area is the most demanding area
@@bluegrave4376 Thanks for the details! The downside of gaming on a laptop is that you can't upgrade it. I wouldn't worry about the fans though. Every part in that computer is designed to shut down if the load ever becomes too much, so it's not going to break on you. You can let those fans run loud and it just means it's at peak performance. Sounds like you've got a great setup. If the sound of the fans bothers you, just plug in a pair of headphones and enjoy the experience :)
I never understood how "fans ramping up" was a measure of anything really.
You set your fans to whatever you want. Depends on room cooling, case and case cooling. If you undervolt/underclock your GPU, its vastly easier to keep temps in check.
GPU fan speed doesn't mean anything
Great video! This is the kind of video that i like the most. Concise , to the point but full of information and technical analysis. Great job Oliver.
Love this game on my XBox Series X 👌🏽👍🏼
So it is Series X graphics mode with VRR then, as per usual, nice
Guess who's back
Back again
Df's back
Tell a friend
Df's back fits better!
@@Daniel189HLL noted
Shout out to oliver 2 videos in and loving it great work
This game most likely built for the last gen Consoles PS4 & XB1X and was just ported to PS5 & XSX
I know this might not get a lot of views but I love that they do these pieces for people that like these types of games! super!
I need to get into this. It looks great
gamepass bro
I keep thinking that too, so I added it to the top 10 games I might love playing after I finish the few games I'm currently focused on. Glad people keep mentioning this one, because it makes it more likely I'll get to it :)
man series s is amazing machine for 1080p tv people, enjoying the hell out of it
Or FHD freesync monitor much Better.
I’m glad I took the time to watch this two years after the fact. This game was just added to gamepass and I would have just played in frame rate mode had I not seen that the graphics mode on series x was visible with vrr. To be fair I probably wouldn’t have noticed a huge difference but still, the actual specifics of the visual modes aren’t detailed within the game so this video is very helpful.
Great video new guy! Really wanted a in depth video on Tales of Arise, and I'm glad we got it!
22hrs in so far...great game, looks and plays amazing
This is a great freaking game
@@lutzaby1997 cuz it wouldn't be legally binding an i wouldn't get benefits 😂😂😂
yeah, till you reach second act and then it turns to dogshit
Is the story good?
@@mitsuhed 8/10 till you reach the second part or second act of the game. then it goes to 4/10.
Welcome back guys! We missed you.
Pretty please do a video about the gta trilogy remasters
What a fantastic video, Oliver, thank you for covering this, I can´t wait to get the game.
Idk why people always say. Series s games won't look good on a 4k tv. I use mine on my 4k tv and i can't even tell if something is 4k or not. And that's really do to the fact of how far i sit. And really that way for everyone.
Woah, new editor. Welcome Oliver!
GTA TRILOGY ANALYSIS SOON? PLEASE
Yes all versions cause driving fast on One X drops graphics and Causes FPS Spikes which makes the target spike with it and you stay placed
The XSX is really flexing it's extra power here. Those 12 TFLOPs are just brute forcing their way through this game.
I'm willing to go as far as to say that Xbox sx's raw power is too overpowered, microsoft could have used a weak and similar hardware as the ps5 but they truly wanted their console to be next gen 💪💪
@Michael Failbox? Really? Grow up Michael.
@Michael why are you so salty ponie?
I maxed everyrhing on this game including max devil arms for all and I clocked 160hrs with 5 playthrus I just freaking love this. Best game of this year
Been waiting for this vid. Thank you!
Awesome video and great cover of the game. Keep it up DF and especially Oliver!
Can't wait to see you cover more and more games
Draw distance in this game on ps5 is horrendous, there is so much pop in it's crazy.
Even in ratchet and Clank Rift Apart there is a lot of po in on PS5. Just finished it and I said - WTF...Where are those next gen graphics everyone was saying?
@@sawomirkazimierczak6715 I genuinely cannot say I saw any pop in during R&C.
@@sawomirkazimierczak6715 Lmao, what the hell are you going on about LMAO!!!!
I have never played a Tales game before and bought it on a whim. I cant believe how much I am loving it.
Another banger Ollie, it's like you've been on the crew for years :)
Looks like it needs a 30 fps v synch on graphics mode for PS5
They should implement the 40fps mode like in Ratched. The 4k mode would bw much more playable.
Yes! I hope more games implement the 40 fps mode. I'm actually enjoying it in Clatchet and Rank.
Thank You! Was waiting for this one.
*And once again, Xbox Series X wins.*
*Xbox is the best box.*
Theres no winning. Its a little sad that some of you need to think your console is winning something like everything is a race. He said it looks great across all 3 . And this coming from someone with both next generation consoles.
Phew… Glad to see you got the channel back!
Man another Monster win for seriesx .🦾🦾🦾
Here's your L Michael
@Michael man you take the PS5 L personally eh?
You've commented so much about how it's a win. Thought you'd be more interested in actually playing your Xbox?
Imagine still being a fanboy in 2021. It's GENUINELY pathetic.
I just finished this game this week, bought it on launch day. I loved every minute of it and was blown away at the story and depth of characters. Easily in my top games list. Anyone who enjoys JRPGs and skips this is doing a disservice to themselves.
How does it compare to DQ11?
@@josephscottadams39 In my opinion it's no contest, Tales of Arise is by far the better game. That said, i didn't like DQ11 much and i don't really get why people do. The characters are bland stereotypes and the story is very predictable. Tales of Arise does predictable thing very well in my opinion, not so much of the larger plot, but in the details, especially in the first half. After you reach the second area you realize that each area has it's own issues and you have no clue of what to expect. Especially the 3rd area really hit home for me on a meta level (i won't explain further to avoid spoilers).
Also, i'm not really a fan of silent protagonists and the DQ humor never clicked with me. I finished 3 or 4 different DQ games, and i never really liked any of them, i won't buy any more in the future. So if you like DQ, take what i wrote with a grain of salt.
Basically, SX > PS5 > SS as usual.
Just played the demo on my Xbox Series S and it’s gorgeous. Runs very smoothly and the game is really good.
Holy crap I was beginning to lose hope on digital foundry covering this lol
series x have best spec and ps5 have best controller
I choosed series x because of better fps, quick resume, vrr
@Michael yes he does...just like me, he hasn't touched it since Jun due to no games, so it seems like he doesn't have it. 🤣
You say like keena bridge of the spirit is a top notch game 🤣🤣🤣🤣, it gets boring real soon but what to expect from a guy who said that a PS3 remastered game is next gen
@Michael Deathloop with get a definite Ultra version on Gamepass next year and Kena is also timed exclusive and will perform better and cheaper when the XSX version is out.. No rush in wasting unneeded money on them when I have bangers after bangers to play on XSX and GP.
I'm definitely ready to play this game. And coming from someone with both system the Xbox SX is a beast at all types of games.
Digital Foundry reviewed my Game of the Year 2021 "Tale of Arise"?!!!! Holy heaven!!!!
Massive Win for Xbox Series X ! Again and Again and Again 😈😏
PS5: 8:00
XBOX: 8:14
Competition benefits us.
10:10 😂😂
@@savenyx3193 Xbox still better + VRR 😏
You guys gonna test out Skyrim's next gen upgrade differences? Curious what actually changed
Simply put, this is game of the year material. In my case, the best game I have played in 2021.
Before I was a Digital Foundry subscriber, I thought this channel was shallow because they talk about video games on the subject of graphics. I see the error of my ways now! These guys are very educated in the field of graphic design, gameplay design and overall performance. I'm learning a lot from you guys and I love this channel! Thank you!
For sure, I love learning about game design and the technology of game engines from these guys.
This game is absolutely beautiful on the ps5 the way it flows. I was excited for this one and tried it on ps4 first, sadly to say it's the first time I ever got nauseous playing a game. The speed of the colors and battle with the low framerate was killing me. Tried it on the ps5 and all that went away. Such a phenomenal title.
Better on series x ps5 is inferior
@@METALFACEDOOMXXXX I always find people like you funny. Someone says anything about their PS5 or X and you guys have to say something negative for whatever reason. If it makes you feel better then ok that's cool I guess.
@@METALFACEDOOMXXXX It's backcompat game so PS5 is limited with that one.
Xbox is the best box! 💚
@@adrianhosein7698 ps5 is just trash.
Great review, Olie!!
Before: "Xbox has no games"
Now: "PS has no vrr and no games"
@Michael Playstation is dry this holiday. Cry about it. Xbox has forza horizon 5 and is getting the gunk and halo infinite in december. Where are your quality exclusives? Oh yeah that's right you have to wait until february. Look who's playing the waiting game now.
@@dtf.editzz The same could be said about Xbox at the start to mid 2021 when PS released Returnal and R&C. It's swings and roundabouts. Don't be a fanboy virgin.
@@dtf.editzz LMAO look at this clown. It's taken a year for MS to start releasing games, and now you're bragging?? LMAO!
@@frankvandermerwe1487 shut up playstation has no games 😂😭
@@dtf.editzz If playstation has no games, then xbox is a barren wasteland by comparison.
Glad to see DF back.
im really sad with the ps5 performance :(
Ps5 sucks
I dont think this game is native PS5 game, seems to be backcompat game.
@@adrianhosein7698 no its native i have it it also takes a bit advantage of the ps5 haptics but performance isn't good
I was genuinely interested when I misread the title as Tales Of Arse!!!
I needed this video a couple of months back but hopefully we'll get more JRPGs on DF
The game dropped a lot of frames in end game on my series s. But still so much better than on last gen. Tried the same battles on series x later and the thing doesn't even hitch.
Did you play in Performance mode or Graphics mode?
@@selohcin Performance mode all the way. Graphics mode looks sharper but is very inconsistent unless you have VRR (don't have it, lol).
Welcome back folks! Glad the channel is back! As far as this game, I really didn't care for any previous tales game I played other than Symphonia, but I can't deny this looks damn good. Just waiting on a sale or gamepass appearance.
The PS5 is really starting to struggle this gen. It needs VRR support asap.
Ps5 will become obsolete in few years sony might have to release a pro version
It's a weak console as expected 🤷♂️
More like Japanese Devs have always sucked at optimization outside Square Enix lol
The ps5 is not struggling at all it has outperformed xbox sx in lots of games and going forward it will take over the xbox sx when the devs start use the ssd tech it can hit up 20gigs of io thoughput that is a big deal you will see in the future when Sony first party studios start pushing out those massive games
@@shyamkumarsasi3577 it's a weak console
Sony is just garbage at hardware
Series X version sounds amazing!!!
Awesome video Oliver!!!
I love these comparisons.
Those beginning battles seem so.... tame compared to the end-game screenfilling attacks
Is it just me or did the series x version look better
YEEEEEESSS!! I’ve been waiting on this vid since the release of the game. So hype and happy.
I was waiting for you guys to make a video about tales of arise
This is my first tales game and I’m in love with it. If you have any interest in it I highly recommend buying the game.
If you are able to, i would recommend you to try the older games on PS3/4. My favourite is Tales of Xillia on PS3, if you like Arise, you will like this game too.
@@Korryptos thanks for the suggestion, I do own a PS3 so I’ll look into that.
Oliver is kicking ass right off the bat. I love it
That intro song is iconic
Series X beats PS5 easy, Both in power and Game Pass
Lame Pass
@@MisterReen it's not lame Pass it's Game Pass
You can tell when pony’s are hurt. They bring up hardware sell numbers; as if they hold stock in Sony 🤣🤡
PS5 controller and exclusive games beats Series X easy.
@Michael No it's Day One Pass
This is my next JRPG after Shin Megami Tensei V. I wanted to wait on that since it was long awaited and highly anticipated.
I've heard that RUclips are going to forcefully privatise the dislike ratio on videos.
Nice, I thought this game wouldn't get a video at this point but glad to see I was wrong. Great video as always!
It's worth mentioning that the game also uses SSGI from what I noticed on the video.
Great dive into this Oliver, you are making a fan out of me with your breakdowns. You seem to be able to hit the sweet spot of non-bias commentary and recognize that you aren't passing things on behalf of a feature a minority would have or a feature that you like over not. Keep up the good work and I look forward to more of your breakdowns.