國外聲樂老師對比《
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 июн 2024
- Join this channel to get access to perks｜加入會員提前解鎖完整版影片:
/ @clubzeromedia
*Performance videos and instrumentals may have been censored due to copyright concerns. Please visit our Bilibili for full-versions of the reaction: space.bilibili.com/7295246
Stayed tuned for more professional vocal coach reaction videos!
Follow Rozette on RUclips: @RozetteSaaangs
Follow Rozette on TikTok: / rozettesaaangs
Artist Booking: clubzeromedia.com/rozette
#reaction #vocalcoach #reactionvideo #古巨基 #李聖傑 #袁娅维 #黄龄 #张紫宁 #陈咏桐 #胡彦斌 #thevoiceofchina #中国好声音 #声生不息家年华 
Развлечения
這首絕對是JC唱的最入人心，老師真的很會聽
jc紅歌不紅人，沒有遇到好的經紀公司
jc唱的所有歌都很好聽，為她加油💪🏽
每組的技巧都毋庸置疑，但只有JC能唱進心坎，用靈魂在唱的！
終於有李聖傑了😍
希望之後也能點評李聖傑自己的歌
《癡心絕對》、《很想說》、《眼底星空》、《手放開》、《最近》、《遠走高飛》、《原諒我沒有說》這幾首都很讚❤
同意，Sam真的是很有實力的歌手，我也很期待可以點評癡心絕對
或者是周興哲的-永不失聯的愛都很推
我也在等李聖傑🥰🥰🥰
@@victor-fe5rr 癡心絕對有超多現場
偷幸福❤❤❤
頂上去❤
The judges did not know she was the original singer of the song until she introduced herself after the performance.
JC是绝对被低估的香港女歌手，非常棒的
可惜她最近在香港的演唱會大走音
@@user-vt9ph2ik7k 我比較喜歡jc最初的幾首歌那種唱法，簡單粗暴 直接撞擊我的大腦
唱的很好聽❤
可惜他退休了
@@user-tf2uq2gz8y是喔 他不繼續音樂發展嗎
Only JC gives me goosebumps. The song is about (a girl) getting hurt in a relationship/a breakup, she deeply loves the person. In JC's interpretation, it's a monologue, she still loves the person, she could only comfort herself by saying that it is part of life/growth, but obviously that not what she truely wants.
我最喜歡的還是原唱 陳詠桐
終於有李聖傑，希望老師能夠多出李聖傑的講評
還有動力火車~
都是我喜歡的厲害歌手
李聖傑是那種技巧成熟，音色有好的歌手。周深的唱功了得，但音色太女性化。我更喜歡李聖傑這種男聲！南無阿彌陀佛！
@@everylifematters1234 周深的音色是因為沒有經歷過變聲期，所以還是童聲，而男生在沒有變聲的狀態下聲音和女生是比較接近的
敲碗動力火車
敲碗李聖傑 現場演唱也是無庸置疑
現場超完美，也是吃cd的歌喉❤❤❤
多年前無意間在一個頻道聽到這首歌是由tia主唱，覺得這歌的旋律非常好，好奇心驅使下去找找原唱是何人，當我聽過原唱後.我個人比較喜歡原唱的版本
想聽老師對許茹芸的評價
那獨一無二脆弱的氣音
感覺可以做李聖傑系列了！😂
青春永駐
JC完勝
KZ is the philippine singer. and this song was originally by a hong kong singer... which was make famous by Tia Ray
一直想聽老師評價聖傑😊終於出現了
李聖傑唱歌很有技巧😊
JC gave me chills; and understand the song the best, it's not a showy song, more like she is persuading herself, talking to herself to let all go
喜歡原唱JC的表達的情感方式
這首是典型的"紅歌不紅人"
終於有聖傑兄了
這首歌是伍樂城作為師傅作俾JC這個徒弟的。
選JC，
聽老師說她有帶著愛黛兒的音色，
才忽然發覺真的如此⋯
難怪當時JC演唱時我就很喜歡，
我超愛愛黛兒的⋯
Tia最後一段應該是完全沒伴奏了，無論現場或耳返。因為她說了一句「不管今天是不是『水逆』」，代表設備絕對出問題了。最後應該是徹底清唱沒錯了，強！
古巨基❤
感謝放上李聖傑
好期待老師聽胡彥斌!!!!
我就知道老師會喜歡李聖傑選手
A HK singer, JC’s song which was originally released in HK, was used later as an OST for a movie made in Mainland China. Tia was then invited to sing this OST. Tia is a singer in China so naturally much more familiar to audience in China whereas JC is a singer in HK so not much heard about in China. This is the story.
@@kychau303 错。内地很多人都听过JC的版本，也非常喜欢。
反正我就喜歡JC proud of her❤
Hope she can react to one of my all time favourite singer, Taeyeon!
JC 的version 應該沒有幾多是因為修音修好 。這歌的作曲作詞都是有名的音樂人，只是JC 是新人 。Tia 在處理上也比較像原唱 (guess we cant say copy) JC 的音色比較多樣化，聲量大小的對比更能帶人進入歌曲 。I feel we owe JC. She deserves more recognition ❤. She was only 20 and she is still singing in hk.
周深也唱过
古巨基耶 好棒~~
我也覺得原唱比較好聽😂
老師 轉不轉是導演控制的🤣
JC已經有合約了😂😂
就上去跑個宣傳通告的
當然要劇情殺掉
多錄一集要加錢的😂😂
希望看老師聽聽JJ和胡彥斌合唱的黑夜問白天
老師今天的穿著讓我聯想到小時候阿嬤的桌巾😂😂
你好壞
好希望看到老師評論台灣的台語歌手！！
然後私心希望也能評論一下告五人。
聖傑選手聲林之王也是唱這首歌！
老师可以去听下JC的原版 就会发现她在好声音唱的带有R&B风格的版本其实TIA的版本 原版是没有的
超想看老師分析IU😂
Who is that? That’s KZ Tandingan!!! We have been requesting, suggesting, begging for a review of KZ’s epic performances and we are still waiting. Come on JKai and Rozette! Make us happy please 🎉🎉🎉
Definitely I will choose JC, she sings deep into my heart
期待胡彥斌系列❤
我喜歡JC的原版，重推出來的時候就是
我喜歡原唱唱出來的情感
拜託react KZ 老師一定會很開心
拜託react張雨生 木船演唱 或 without you 老師一定會喜歡的
Son Seungyeon
Wendy
Sohyang
I recommend you listen to the song 'I Have Nothing' by these three Korean singers~~~
JC's original version was actually popular in Hong Kong, but it didn't make JC herself famous…
希望给老师听歌的时候同时把翻译后的歌词也给老师看一下，网络上有很多英译歌词，都翻译的不错。
是不是應該準備英文歌詞啊😂
雖然我覺得看老師單純對唱法跟旋律做評價很棒也很真實，但一旦進到情緒跟的感情部分沒有歌詞會有點難理解歌手們想表達的意境。
非引戰單純建議，影片我也看的很開心，謝謝🙏
JC把我唱到歌裡去了😢
李聖傑同時還是個網球教練….
而且網球還很強😂
老師也會想跟李聖傑當朋友的啦❤❤❤❤❤
敲碗陳忻玥，大推
推+1
多點李聖傑給老師聽👍👍👍
This song is interesting and touching mainly because the melody is written closely to the speaking tones of the lyrics, and the emotion underneath. Discussing about the song without studying the meanings of each lines of lyric, for this particular song, will miss the essens of it. It is not a summary of past loves, it is talking about the that “end is end” moment. Please help the vocal coach to understand the lyrics better and more precisely.
杰凯有进步啊，懂得解释歌词意思了，很多老师的问题都有用心解答
想看看老師如何評價 Jessie J/CoCo李玟/KZ Tandingan。Bang Bang
推薦re一下Hyolyn韓國唱跳歌手的天花板啊
深深和小鬼也唱过一版
也评一评郑中基如何？do give your opinion on Ronald Cheng, who currently is finishing up his world tour. Thanks 😊
來了
李聖傑超級棒❤❤❤❤❤
Of all the songs you picked to give an example of a successful cover overshadowing the original. I'm surprised you picked "Killing me softly" instead of "I Will Always Love You". I listen to oldie quite a lot, and so was familiar with Roberta Flak's original even though I heard Lauren Hill's version first, but It wasn't until many many years later when I looked up on the wiki of "I Will Always Love You" that I know it's a cover, and I listened to Dolly Parton's original, and I feel like the song is already Whitney's. but for "Killing Me Softly", I think it still kind of holds up, even if you are familiar with the cover first, unless you really just don't like oldies in general.
Honestly, I think this song really is best sung by Tia, I really don't hear the uniqueness to the original you're saying, I appreciate the riffs she put into the song, but her singing felt very "meh". like it has. a lot of what the a song needs, but she's not making me want to really listen to the song. It sounds in a way "generic" , and maybe it's the vibe and all that you mentioned, but I mean that's kind of what separates a good singer right. I mean even when someone sings without being sings, and more speech like, it's all about the vibe, the ability to captivate your audience and make them want to listen to you.
I heard JC's original first way earlier and it is so raw and powerful. I loved it. So Tia's later version didn't do much for me despite being skilled and very polished. Matter of preference I guess.
JC才有唱出這首歌的感覺～ 其他都沒有記憶點
那時候可以點評 金鐘國《Speechless》
同意！金鐘國聲音真的跟他樣子很有反差 老師一定會很好奇他講話聲音😂
想要看費玉清
希望老师可以评价一下李安的《逝去的爱》
😂突然看到张韶涵…不知道会不会做她的系列呢？
原唱+111111111
火星人要來台灣咯！
每次聽JC都想哭
希望可以看到你对ateez 在 killing voice 的点评。虽然只有我一个人的请求，但是，他们的歌唱真的很不错。强力推荐🙏🏼👍🏼
提到DEMO歌手就不得不說說 在台灣很有名的一位"鄧福如"當初他也是個DEMO歌手把自己唱的COVER歌放上網結果突然爆紅
B.o.B feat. Bruno Mars - Nothing on you - Cover by 阿福
ruclips.net/video/4oPw63oVqpA/видео.html
Please react to "one ok rock" one more time. The last one was too old. I hope you do the latest version this time.
JC❤ is the best
我覺得原唱比Tia唱得好聽，聲音有特色
想聽老師們講張雨生😢
Can you react female singer from Malaysia..Her name is LIZA HANIM
敲碗張韶涵✨
I only hear JC version 😊
ask jessie j to come back and invite sia as well. so it will have the uk and oz singers invasion😂😂😂
想让老师多听听黄龄的歌？
說散就散這首歌無論誰唱，還是原唱的版本最好，這亦是jc 出過最好的一首歌，後期她也是出了一些不錯的歌，但這首還是最好，她的代表作！
紫寧!!!!!
大陸綜藝節目都有劇本，聽歌好了
好想讓老師聽聽看蘇打綠的青峰
阿不~~~是魚丁糸的青峰
不知道老師會不會喜歡
歌手唱功方面不說了，作為一個普通人，那些太高端，呵呵，但jc那聲音很特別啊，這麽多版本，就她的聲音唱出來，聽著就很難忘記
I watch and subscribe to all you reviews as you really are knowledgeable and add so much to my enjoyment of music.
Do you want to be completely blown away doing another comparison?????
I thought it was IMPOSSIBLE for ANYONE to channel Karen Carpenter, but I was SOOOO WRONG.
PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE check out "we've only just begun" by Tori Holub and James Wilkas.
You will be sitting with an open mouth - promise.
為什麼他們不轉，有毛病嗎
笑死我了😂😂😂😂
26:24 還好啦😂😂JC卻實很多自作曲
google那個應該有地域差異，香港人搜的話大多會先出來JC的版本
jc好幾首歌都很好聽 可惜人沒紅
Can we do 鄭中基next time
jc的說散就散 之前，還有一首現任朋友，這首歌明明很好聽的，可是至今仍還是 ..
喜歡李聖傑
因為JC 是新人 沒太多人注意 Tia 翻唱又配合了劇集在中國 更多人聽才火起來 我覺得兩個人都唱得好好 當然Tiia 技術同經驗比Jc 高
這個男的已經不是第一次錯資訊 😅 JC 在 RUclips 首發已經火遍 👉 華人地區 ( 除了內地 )
华人一共15亿，内地14亿，这叫红遍华人圈哈哈😊
其實只有北方不知道而已 哈哈 😂
這首JC比較有味.他唱沒紅單純因為在香港.
bullshit
是因為在黎明的公司