!!Update!! at 2:55 in this video I say to rename a file to libaccs.dll but on screen you see me type out libaacs.dll. I misspoke at this point and didn't catch it before posting the video live. To get this to work you want to name it libaacs.dll like you see on screen. Sorry for the confusion.
what does this mean? Error 'Scsi error - MEDIUM ERROR:L-EC UNCORRECTABLE ERROR' occurred while reading '/VIDEO_TS/VTS_07_1.VOB' at offset '0' Error 'Scsi error - MEDIUM ERROR:L-EC UNCORRECTABLE ERROR' occurred while reading 'DVD+R-DL hp DVD A DS8ACSH LHS3' at offset '0'
Not sure if you've figured this out yet, but concerning the English audio tracks, if you go into the Audio tab in HandBrake you'll see Audio Tracks, and an "Add Tracks" dropdown button you can click to change the audio track you wish to encode with the video. I noticed this after encoding Godzilla Vs. Hedorah when it chose Japanese audio by default. I switched it to English, and it worked. Just a heads up since you mentioned it in the video.
The best way to tell which track is which is by... Open the dvd or blu ray in VLC (open vlc, press media at the top > open disk and select the dvd or BR Play the movie that you want (English for example) via the on screen menu When it starts playing, go to playback and the top > title and it will tell you the title number that matches in handbrake. The one that is playing is the one with the dot next to it. The UK inbetweeners has 96 titles so this helped me there
How did you get vlc to play the BD? I put the keydb.cfg & aacs files in place and get 'Blu-ray error: No valid processing key found in AACS config file'.
One thing that you should always do with video transcoding in Handbrake is to work with the original frame rate. NTSC DVD’s are 29.97 interlaced frames per second, even though the theatrical movies they carry are 24fps. Blu-ray movies are typically 24fps. Select “Same as original”, and variable frame rate. In filters, you need to concern yourself with de-interlacing DVD content. Select “Decomb”. Most Blu-rays today have 1080p (progressive scan) content, so you can turn that feature off for those types of files. Blu-rays, however, can also have some standard def interlaced video (480i, the same as DVD) for special features, and if this is the case, use the settings previously described for DVD. In the end, matching frame rates and de-interlacing/decombing where necessary will make the movement in your renders look much smoother.
@@Robber7 If it is a Region 1 NTSC DVD, it will ALWAYS require de-interlacing. If it is A DVD, when you capture with MAKE_MKV, you will see the video format. If it’s MPEG-2, you’re most likely looking at SD interlaced video as the source…you are given all the specs when you highlight the title.
Just letting everyone know that in May 2021 THIS TUTORIAL WORKS!!!! both regular DVDs and Blu-ray. some DVDs are getting really old and worn so i need to convert those that are around 15- 20 yrs old to put them on my plex. Thanks Mraksot78. sending you virtual hugs
Curious if you've encountered any problems with Blu-ray since this post? DVDs work but every Blu-ray I've tried crashes Handbrake as soon as I launch the job. Completely uninstalled/reinstalled Handbrake and all dll's but stil no go.
@@bereantrb I've run into the same problem, I've narrowed it down to being an issue in the preferences of makemkv, you have to enable the use of the .dll file outside makemkv. But I that's all I've got so far, I'll let you know when I got the rest figured out.
Dang! You just saved me 36 hours of encoding. I was ripping from MakeMKV and then use HandBrake to do the encoding and that is going to take me 36+ hours. I found your method and it took me 50 minutes. What an amazing method you have. Thanks a lot and I Subscribed!
New to handbrake and this is the first video I've come across, out of dozens, that informs and explains how to use your graphics card to encode in handbrake. Liking and subscribing for that reason, great video!
You should know I also have a followup video to this one where I take look at the difference in the final output file sizes. Although GPU encoding is faster than CPU encoding the final output files are larger. ruclips.net/video/FsTtMERkFbE/видео.html
To change the audio overdub language to Espanol or Francais, the setting is on the "Audio" tab under the :Audio Tracks" dropdown menu. By default HandBrake is set to: 1 English (AC3) (5.1 ch) (448 kbps)
When it comes to selecting the best quality format for ripping Blu-ray, MKV is always the top choice since it can encompass audio, video, pictures, and subtitle tracks in one single file while keeping the quality almost intact to that of Blu-rays. What You Need to Rip a Blu-ray to MKV: ● Your Blu-ray discs. ● A Blu-ray disc drive. If your computer came with any disc drive at all, it was probably a DVD drive. However, you'll need a Blu-Ray reader in order to rip your Blu-Ray discs (obviously). An external good Blu-ray drive can be purchased for as little as $25. Note: If you want to rip 4K UHD Blu-rays, you'll need to get a 4K Blu-ray drive. ● A program to rip the files like EaseFab Blu-ray Ripper
Your videos are awesome basically I'm still a beginner when it comes to digitally recording my Bluray collection and updating my desktop for both gaming and processing videos, you make it simple to understand and put out subject matter that I'm curious about, .keep it up, thanks.
i was at work, and i wanted to watch the martian. and i realized it was only on services i'm not currently subscribed to... so now i'm learning how to set up a plex server or whatever and just rip my blu-rays, because like a dolt i sold all my download codes when i opened the discs. lol your video was super easy to follow and concise. hopefully i can get this all figured out and be able to stream my blu-ray movie copies from work now :)
I must be SUPER AWESOME cause I watched all the way through. No, really thanks for taking the time to do this & going over all the little details that most do not. And even gave the proper links to download all that's needed for digitizing all my DVDS. Would like to see you do something on the various codecs, aspect ratios, etc. Thanks a Bunch!!
It's still working in Windows 11 ver. 24H2 as of Nov. 2024. You had me for a moment, thinking it wouldn't work, until I found the typo (in comments) that solved my problem.
Thanks very much for your time and effort for this video.. still works today [june2023] as long as you have Handbrake v1.3.1, doesn't work with 1.6.1 for me anyway.. running some tests on the quality that it puts out compared to BD-Rebuilder, but they both use ffMpeg and NVEnc (Nvidia GFX card) so they should be the same... cheers [EDIT] only down side I can see is that the handbrake method needs to have the disc spinning continuously, whereas MakeMkv rip to a multistream .mkv file. no more use of the disc drive, as well as that .mkv can be played back at full quality, if required.
Very well done video, apprecazite your efforts. I did everything you described but got stopped at running HandBrake as it couldn't find a video on my BluRay. What I ended up doing was using MakeMKV to directly read the BluRay disc and then ran HandBrake to convert the MK4 file created into an MP4 file for my streaming pleasure. Hope this helps anyone out there with a similar problem.
I just used this to back my copy of Son of Godzilla so I can watch it on a tablet, or set top console blu ray player. (The one I encoded was an old AVI I had from years ago.) My factory copy is packed in the garage, in a box from moving. Thank you for this informative video it helped me tremendously! Especially in regards to encoding some of my physical factory discs to use with my tablet. Yes, I can watch them on the blu ray player, but it's in the bedroom, and the treadmill is not, lol. Cheers, and thanks again!
I subscribed because you seem to be a genuinely nice dude!! You were also a big help in helping me set up handbrake couldn't have done it without you! Thanks so much!!
For the 'identifying the correct track' thing you were talking about, most bluray titles usually have '100' as the last three digits in the mpls for the English version. Disney blurays (like Marvel or Star Wars), usually have *'800'* as the last three digits in an mpls list for the correct English version. Just look for the last three digits: 100 for most titles, 800 for Disney titles.
thanks! was trying handbrake and vlc on my ubuntu machine to rip a dvd b4 i saw this, it was a waste of time... will take what i saw here and give another shot and as a last resort duplicate what you did on my windows machine... thank you again
Is this really a better option to do than the first? Seems like a lot more steps than using MKV and then handbrake to compress. So you’re pretty much just use Make mkv to get the DDL file into handbrake and that’s it. You don’t use it anymore? I’m running a Mac is there any difference? Thanks again for everything in advance and thanks for your hard work. It really helps.
Informative and well made video Maraksot! One seeming discrepancy appears around the 2:55 mark when you were renaming the dll file that was copied from the Make MKV folder to the Handbrake folder. You spoke that the file should be renamed "libaccs.dll" , but what was typed was "libaacs.dll". Which is the correct filename?
Fantastic YT video Maraksot78! Thank you. I can finally say goodbye to doing it the hard way, which I have been doing for years. DVD Decrypter > Avidemux > Handbrake. This compacts the process to one app. Thank you Thank you Thank you. Liked & Subscribed
As someone who uses Handbrake to soft code subtitles (able to turn em on/off) fiddling with the settings i found that if left alone it should auto select the files for your language but there is a way to manually specify languages for audio and subtitles. Within the tabs there is a setting for SELECTION BEHAVIOUR
Question, when there is a new version of MakeMKV, would you just repeat this process? Would you have to repeat this if Handbrake does an upgrade? Great video! Thanks for doing this and I am also enjoying your EGO reviews.
I don't know for sure if you'd need to repeat the process or not when the current beta key expires. I haven't been using this method long enough to find out yet. I don't think you will though because you're not using the MakeMKV application. You're just 'borrowing' the .dll files from MakeMKV that contain the info on how to decrypt Blu-Ray disc allowing Handbrake to read and rip discs. The way I believe it works is you won't have to update MakeMKV until a new type of encryption is used the .dll files you have don't contain, and you're no longer able to read or rip a disc. At that point you'll need to update MakeMKV and hopefully they will have updated the .dll files allowing you to circumvent that new type of encryption. At least that's the way I think it works. I guess I'll find out in another week as the current beta key will expire at the end of this month. :D
Great video , I have been using the older way . You show us on the older video . Am not that great with all the newer way but using MKV and Handbrake work OK for me but Going to put this video in my favorites . To try when I feel daring Thank you again for all u do for all of us..Stay Safe...
Thanks for checking out the video. I like this method a lot because once you've got things set up you only need to use HandBrake to both rip and encode. And of course using GPU encoding is a HUGE time saver which is very exciting to me. :D
Love the content. It was the driving factor that made me upgrade from my AMD 5700xt to the Nvidia RTX 3080 so I could access the Nvenc encoder. The AMD encoder was OK but the size to quality ratio is nothing like the Nvenc. I really want to try the Intel encoder but I don't have anything Intel in my house at the moment since I run the 5900x. The 12900k will be my next upgrade (or next generation after 12th gen). Thanks!
This is a brilliant explanation as I have wanted to do this as my Panasonic dvd recorder will only read certain blu rays so experimentation is needed as the videos seem to be of a Different file format only read by these player/recorders is AVCHD
I got it to work. I uninstalled Handbrake 1.3.3 then downloaded and installed 1.3.1. Moved the .DLLs over then I right clicked the Handbrake application icon and ran as administrator.
Does this work for every Blu-Ray you've tried it with? HandBrake recognizes one movie I tried but when I attempted to backup the first disc of a TV Show it failed to recognize it, even though MakeMKV had no problem with the same disc.
They always want us to subscribe but wont respond to a valid question. Same here. Handbrake will say "No valid Source Can be found" and of one of the reasons is DRM. If you make videos like this please address everything.
To make sure you have the correct audio track open the dvd in vlc player and click on play movie then click on audio in the top bar and highlight audio track it will show track number and time stamp this also works for the video file i had a dvd that i had to use this method with because the automatically selected audio and video tracks did not line up
Hello again. I watch your two videos related to digital copy and now I want to rerip my movie collection with your suggested settings (HQ 1080p30) but I have one question about the audio tab, do you stick with stereo aac and 5.1 ac3. And if yes, why?why not EAC3 because is better then AC3. In the past i just kept Ac3 640 no stereo track. Love your video !!!
Hey man one question - Why do you recommend gpu encoding? because everyone like on reddit/a lot other yt videos say that the quality is very bad in comparision. I also tested the legend of tarzan and NVEnc produces red artifacts for me with h26510bit CQ20 Medium (the movie is 4K HDR) The beginning is very gray but gpu encoding produces red artifacts there
Awesome video. I have one question: how do the file sizes compare? I'm researching this a lot for my Plex server. Currently have 12TB of data on it, and I want to convert them to H265. All the responses I've come across have said NVENC takes a lot of storage as opposed to x265. What are the file sizes for the original BR and the H265 one?
Most blu-ray movies are between 20GB and 30GB on the disc and just using MakeMKV gives you an uncompressed rip of the movie close to the same size it is on the disc. Using H.265 my copy of The Rise of Skywalker is now 9.98GB. You can always experiment if you want and try H.265 without using GPU encoding and even use other codecs like H.264 and see what works best for you. :)
@@Maraksot78 Thank you!! Ordered an RTX 2070 last night. The slightly higher file size compared to CPU encoding is well worth the vastly superior time to complete.
I go .MKV for 20-45 minutes to rip, then to Handbrake for H.265 custom Preset for a VERY LONG (8-10 hours) handbrake completion...older dell AIO with 4400 Quad-Core and integrated graphics. The results are PERFECT and MUCH MUCH smaller in size. Most file sizes when done now are only 1.9 to 3.4 GB and again, look and sound PERFECT like I was playing the Blu-Ray disc itself !!!
@@ntvtexan5015 using GPU encoding is so much quicker it's amazing. I'm actually working on a video showing the difference between QuickSync, Nvidia NVENC and AMD VCE encoding right now and I'm impressed how much of a difference using QuickSync makes over just using CPU encoding. Thanks for the comment. Cheers. :)
H265 is HVEC codec which takes less space and keeps quality high. NVENC is Nvidia gpu codec to rip the file in Handbrake faster. I've also found that also using custom settings for 10 bit further reduces space used, while keeping quality higher. Instead of copying dll files, I take the MakeMKV ripped file and directly drop into Handbrake. In Handbrake I use MKV, framerate same as original. I decode or encode to 1080p, hevc x265 10bit (nvenc) or if it's 4k, the same thing except 2160p, instead of 1080p. I use avg bitrate between 11500 kbps and 20000 kbps depending on what movie it is. The higher the bitrate, the better the quality. I have speed set to slow. I use pass-through for audio tracks and retain chapters and forced closed captions and usually the first English available. I saved a preset for 1080p and 4k 2160p to save time.
This video has helped me greatly. I moved into an RV fulltime. And with my home movie collection being so large that it doesnt fit in the RV, this is an awesome alternative. Watching this video, I did notice the only involvement MakeMKV has in your video is to copy .dll files to HandBrake .... is this correct, or am I missing something to use MakeMKV more effectively?
update: I viewed the original video you created. it looks like you used MakeMKV to rip the movie, then HandBrake to transcode (compressing it). does this new process, outlined in this video, override the old process?
2024 - I've now updated both Handbrake and MakeMKV, copied the file mentioned in this video, twice (and renaming as directed) and am using the same libdvdcss.dll file from the description's link. I did go through all of the folders and there was not dll file, just project files. I'm not sure if there's a way to generate it from those, but it doesn't matter, because it still worked. MakeMKV would not update through the software, I had to download a new installer for it, which removed the old copy and installed the new. Handbrake updated through the existing software. I likely hadn't updated the software in a year or two, I'm guessing that since my last comment two years ago, I didn't try this. I can confirm that I was able to open up a Blu-ray that I'd just received, that was giving me a DRM error before updating. I'm sure YMMV depending on the DVD/Blu-ray disc.
Well I'm very happy to hear that. I imagine it's a little better than what you were gaming on before? 😅 I really like the 5600XT, it's a great card; lots of power for 1080p and even 1440p gaming.
Love this video and everything was working perfectly until a few days ago. When the latest update was pushed (1.6.1) I lost the ability to directly rip my DVDs. It appears that the update has somehow blocked the use of the .dll or altered how it utilizes them? Anyone else have this problem or found a solution? I tried reinstalling the .dlls but with no success. I am still able to rip with MakeMKV and then convert using Handbrake, but it sure was nice to be able to do both in one step!
Nope. You just need it to get the .dll files that contain the blu-ray disc decryption data so you can rip the discs with Handbrake. I'm sure there are other ways to get them but this is an easy way to get them and I trust MakeMKV where as I don't know if I can trust other sites that may have the necessary .dll files. Anyway the point of the video was to show how to use GPU encoding to speed things up and how to make Handbrake rip and encode a disc all at once so you don't have to rip with MakeMKV and then import the 20-30GB uncompressed MKV file into Handbrake and then transcode/compress it to a 5-10GB .mp4
That's actually this enclosure I bought on Amazon www.amazon.com/dp/B01MRUN0HQ?tag=onamzaraksoev-20&linkCode=ssc&creativeASIN=B01MRUN0HQ&asc_item-id=amzn1.ideas.35KP63KCPU1OH&th=1 I had an Asus Blu-ray drive in my old PC and when I upgraded I pulled the blu-ray drive out, bought the enclosure and installed the drive into it.
@@Alaa.M945 I bought it on Amazon in 2018. Don't know if they sell the same model I bought anymore but the model number is BC-12B1ST. It is just a regular blu-ray drive. It does not burn blu-rays and it does not support 4K (aka UHD) blu-ray either.
How far we've come...I have a 5950X and an RTX3090 and encoding a movie from BR to 1080p takes all of not even 25 minutes. Sorry, but as a nerd, this is cool af. 🤣 It always AMAZES me to see how much more powerful stuff gets over time. Maybe it's time to build a new 7950X or i9-13900 + 4090 machine! Hahaha
I've used cpu encoding and nvenc encoding. I noticed so little difference that I'll keep using nvenc and save 7 hours when encoding to 2160p .x265 10 bit.
DVDs work but sadly Blu-ray ripping does not work for me. As soon as I start a Blu-ray job Handbrake immediately crashes. I uninstalled/reinstalled Handbrake and all the dll's but still no luck. The other method I've seen works, it just takes A LOT longer (rip full video with MakeMKV, then convert with Handbrake). This looks great. I hope I find a solution.
@maraksot78, care to make an external BD recommendation? I am starting my journey into digital and have seen most of your videos on the subject. A lot easier to comprehend versus other hosts. Thank you.
Thanks so much for your kind compliment. As for a recommendation for an external blu-ray drive... I don't know. I haven't used any personally. I had an Asus internal bru-ray drive in my old PC and when I upgraded to a new case without 5.25" bays I bought pretty much the only enclosure available on Amazon that will accommodate a 5.25" DVD or blu-ray drive. Personally I like to stick with brands I've heard of or just go with something that has good reviews/a good rating. Sorry I'm not more help. :)
I'm a little confused about MakeMKV. It looks like you only used the program for a file that HandBrake needed. Was that all the program was needed for or did I miss a step where the beta key was needed?
yes, the beta key is needed, but since I already had the beta key input into MakeMKV I didn't realize the key was needed until the beta key expired and went to do this again.
Thank you for this detailed video, any chance you can share what external blu-ray drive model # and firmware you used? I've been using 123CopyDVD for about 10 years now, until my last W10 update botched the key & password. And at this moment it looks like the maker is gone and no longer supports this product. If this doesn't fit the bill, I might give WinX ripper platinum a try.
Can you recommend a decent external Blu ray/DVD drive? I would like to start ripping my movie collection. I first want to make sure that the external Blu ray/DVD drive will be compatible with Handbrake.
Hey man Love your videos AWESOME! One question though. When I copy the vlc file into handbrake it works but when I push start encode it always cuts out like at a min or so? What am I doing wrong? Thanks again for all the work you do.
First of all thanks so much for the very kind compliment. I ran into the same issue using a Ryzen 3 1200 CPU when working on another video. I'm sad to say I didn't investigate it further because I didn't have the time to really sort it out and for the video I didn't really need to. I had that CPU overclocked to 3.8Ghz and I wonder if that overclock wasn't quite stable but like I said I didn't really investigate it so I don't know for sure what was causing it. Sorry I can't be of more help.
Whenever I use the GPU encoding all of my monitors turn red or white and I have to repeatedly reload the GPU drivers in order to see my screens. The encoding process continues throughout this. I'm not sure if it's a driver issue or what is causing it. I have GTX 1080 on latest drivers that works perfectly for gaming.
Since I use Plex for my CD and Bluray rips listening/watching, I prefer to rip my movie Blurays with MakeMKV only. I only need to use Handbrake to transcode if the video is output as a VC type instead of H264 since Plex doesnt like VC and will then take up more CPU and transcoding time on your server to change the quality to a format (H264) that it CAN handle. This saves me extra time and MakeMKV can export the movie with only the ONE or TWO sound fields I want incuded and nothing else in a much faster time than Handbrake which takes a LOOOOONG time
The encoder does not utilize the full GPU. You also typically don't see much of a difference between high end and low end cards either. GeForce cards are capable of doing up to 3 simultaneous encodes so you may find increased performance if you run two separate copies of handbrake. Depends on how much CPU overhead you have I suppose. I have two going right now and it's using 100% of i7-5960x 4.5ghz and 75% of RTX 3080.
Thanks for the video, it's very instructive. I just upgraded to a new PC that does not have an internal Blu-ray disk drive. I noticed you have an external drive and was wondering what model you have. Thanks.
Glad you enjoyed the video. I actually had a Blu-ray drive in my previous PC but when I upgraded my new chassis didn't have space for one so I found this drive enclosure on Amazon. www.amazon.com/dp/B01MRUN0HQ?ref=exp_maraksot78_dp_vv_d It will fit any 5.25 inch DVD or Blu-ray drive so if you have one lying around you can just pop it in the enclosure and go. :D
Is the file copying process the same for macOS? Like someone else mentioned, I, too, was using both MakeMKV and Handbrake separately on macOS, but if the file-copying process is the same, I’ll try that instead.
I’ve ripped some DVDs with makemkv thinking nothing was wrong but sometimes in the middle of the film it just skips ahead 10 seconds, or skips to the end of the film and stops playing. I’m not sure what I am doing wrong.
Really? That's very strange. I haven't had this problem at all. In fact, if my film doesn't rip properly the entire process is bust. I don't even know how what you're describing is possible. You do go through a verification process at the start don't you? And, maybe your drive is defective. I mean the disk reader.
Merry Christmas....Do you have a time per gig estimate that a person could use as a comparison? I have Terabytes of SD quality Mp4 that I would like to reduce the file size of..I am going to be looking at the after xmas sales and would like to know what specs to look for?
Unfortunately I do not have an answer for that question. Haven't yet made the transition to 4K blu-ray and haven't looked into making backups of 4K blu-ray discs. Sorry.
I need to upgrade my computer. The one I have is 10 years old and it takes 24 hours or more to backup a 4k disc with handbrake. Could you recommend what I need for efficient hardware to create in the time frame you stated in this video. Is their a computer that comes with everything in the cabinet? Please be specific for I am not computer literate.
To be fair though I think you only need to update that Kia Rick up Lemans if you’re ripping Blu-rays if you’re ripping DVDs on there you don’t have to do anything the system will need to be updated every once in a while as they make changes and updates but I don’t think you have to update that key
Just found this and wondering if this still works now in 2022? Also, this seems more geared to ripping blu rays - is make mkv needed still or can this be done easier with VLC? Also, would it be faster to do a straight whole copy rather than just selecting certain files to copy?
Seems great, though I got an error within the first few seconds or so, then re-verified I put the copied .dll file x2 into the folder with the proper name for each (and libaacs.dll for the one as in your description), and put the proper one downloaded into the same HandBrake directory. The movie ripped with MakeMKV with no problem. My question is, will Handbrake still do the encoding fast afterward? I'm new to this and have a computer in the other room that's been going since last night decoding a file on Handbrake (per a comment on another video to set the speed to very slow) and will run about another 10 hours or so to finish. If I can get something that'll work anywhere nearly as quick as a couple hours I'll be very happy. I guess I'll find out quickly if doing the Handbrake part with gpu enabled to deal with the file after MakeMKV's part works okay. :D
It may be that an update to HandBrake has changed something, and I noticed you have additional files in your HandBrake directory besides the 3 .dll files added in. On another brand new disc, I'm getting the same type of error, queue finished with 1 errors or cancellations after less than a minute. But I was able to take advantage of the information regarding using the GPU and matching output with hvec.265 to do the second half after ripping the files with MakeMKV. Very helpful, and much appreciated! :)
Thanks.. I assume burning 3D blueray is just a matter of selecting the correct 3D track.. (Assume) is that correct? I so far have ripped a standard blue ray, still trying 3D side by side. My Player (internal sata to MB) seems to see all the tracks. Do I need a special DVD player to read 3D?- update: both available tracks on imax under the sea - 3D came out non-side by side?.Thanks..
Hmmm...for some reason even though I did all three DLL's and made sure I named them correctly, Handbrake works for DVD's but I still get the "No valid source" error on Bluray's. ☹
Thank you for this video, I was wondering why I could not rip blue rays. Now I know. QUESTION: How do I make the rip complete with subtitles? Every time I rip anything with handbrake I do not get the subtitles. Thanks
Handbrake will burn in one subtitle track from the disc or MKV file. (When using MakeMKV be sure to include any subtitle tracks you want) In order to “optionally” include subtitles, you have to import them. You can extract subtitle files from MKV files using MKV Cleaver. depending on the disc type, it will export the subtitle files with different extensions. These files are then Imported into a program called Subtitle Edit, where you do an OCR scan of the file(s), which may require correction as there are occasion interpretation issues. You save the complete OCR scan as either an .srt or .ass file. These subtitle files can now be imported into Handbrake., and you can now include multiple subtitle files, selecting one as the Default. Do not “Burn in” any subtitles. You can also rename the subtitle (English, Commentary, etc...)
I noticed when I went to get a copy of the file libdvdcss.dll, the file became BZ2 file where as on your video it stayed a dll file. Also my computer warned me this file could harm my device. Do you have any thoughts on this?
Makemkv does not recognize the BluRay. VLC won't play the Blu-ray either. I updated the drivers and my computer. I had to download a program called Leawo BluRay player and I was able to play the BluRay. I am using an external Blu-ray player. I did the steps for Handbrake once I found that the BD play worked. How long does the BluRay take to rip typically? It has been sitting at scanning title 1 of 1 (0%) for about 15 mins now. Also, I am using windows 10 and I was able to Rip a standard DVD with no problem. I am wondering if it is something with my computer that I am missing... Update** I just reset my computer and it works...The old turn it off and on bit lol.....Makemkv still does not work though
Did you copy the .dll files from MakeMKV to the HandBrake folder like I show in the video? At 2:55 in the video I say to rename a file to libaccs.dll but on screen you see me type out libaacs.dll. I misspoke at this point and didn't catch it before posting the video live. To get this to work you want to name it libaacs.dll like you see on screen. Sorry for the confusion.
Maraksot78 I really appreciate the help. The video was so helpful thank you thank you thank you for putting this together! Now I will start the journey of backing up my dvd collection and figure out how to build my in home server 🤔✌🏼
I have been doing it the way you showed in the older video, and after It’s sometimes I get no audio with the movie, or it’s in French or there’s someone narrating the whole movie. What step/steps am I missing
First of all, thank you for such a great video!. However, I am 2 questions 1. is it libaccs or libaacs.dll? You said "accs" but the screen shows "aacs". 2. When i pressed the BD drive in Handbrake , it says "No Valid source or titles found." for some BD discs please help >0
Yah, I misspoke at that part and didn't catch it when I was editing. You want it to be libaacs.dll. What I did on screen is correct, what I said is not. Sorry about the confusion. As for your other problem I don't know what's going on there. I've never encountered that. So is it just with certain discs it does this or does it do it with all blu-rays?
@@Maraksot78 thanks for the reply! i just tried two so far, one isn't, and one is working, gonna finish the first rip soon. Each of the passes last for around 1 hour. Is that normal? The movie length is 140 min
Ripping a disc takes my Blu-Ray/DVD Combo drive about 20 minutes and then it depends on what GPU you're using. In tests I've done AMD VCE is the slowest, Intel QuickSync is 2nd and Nvidia NVENC is the fastest... That is unless you have a newer AMD Radeon 5000 series graphics cards, i.e. RX 5600XT, RX 5700 etc. then AMD VCE is the fastest, NVENC is 2nd and Quick Sync is slowest. But I did only test using hardware I have access to which includes an RTX 2070, my laptops 1050ti, a RX 570, a RX 5700XT and my laptops IGPU which is an Intel UHD 630 graphics.
!!Update!! at 2:55 in this video I say to rename a file to libaccs.dll but on screen you see me type out libaacs.dll. I misspoke at this point and didn't catch it before posting the video live. To get this to work you want to name it libaacs.dll like you see on screen. Sorry for the confusion.
How do you complete this process on a mac?
what does this mean?
Error 'Scsi error - MEDIUM ERROR:L-EC UNCORRECTABLE ERROR' occurred while reading '/VIDEO_TS/VTS_07_1.VOB' at offset '0'
Error 'Scsi error - MEDIUM ERROR:L-EC UNCORRECTABLE ERROR' occurred while reading 'DVD+R-DL hp DVD A DS8ACSH LHS3' at offset '0'
Not sure if you've figured this out yet, but concerning the English audio tracks, if you go into the Audio tab in HandBrake you'll see Audio Tracks, and an "Add Tracks" dropdown button you can click to change the audio track you wish to encode with the video. I noticed this after encoding Godzilla Vs. Hedorah when it chose Japanese audio by default. I switched it to English, and it worked. Just a heads up since you mentioned it in the video.
I would just use vudu disc to digital but that costs a lot quick
If you can used DVDShrink, you can see which track is what.
The best way to tell which track is which is by...
Open the dvd or blu ray in VLC (open vlc, press media at the top > open disk and select the dvd or BR
Play the movie that you want (English for example) via the on screen menu
When it starts playing, go to playback and the top > title and it will tell you the title number that matches in handbrake. The one that is playing is the one with the dot next to it.
The UK inbetweeners has 96 titles so this helped me there
Thanks man. :)
How did you get vlc to play the BD? I put the keydb.cfg & aacs files in place and get 'Blu-ray error: No valid processing key found in AACS config file'.
One thing that you should always do with video transcoding in Handbrake is to work with the original frame rate. NTSC DVD’s are 29.97 interlaced frames per second, even though the theatrical movies they carry are 24fps. Blu-ray movies are typically 24fps. Select “Same as original”, and variable frame rate. In filters, you need to concern yourself with de-interlacing DVD content. Select “Decomb”. Most Blu-rays today have 1080p (progressive scan) content, so you can turn that feature off for those types of files. Blu-rays, however, can also have some standard def interlaced video (480i, the same as DVD) for special features, and if this is the case, use the settings previously described for DVD. In the end, matching frame rates and de-interlacing/decombing where necessary will make the movement in your renders look much smoother.
How do you determine if you need de-interlacing and fps on the special features of a disk? Can some program tell you this info?
@@Robber7 If it is a Region 1 NTSC DVD, it will ALWAYS require de-interlacing. If it is A DVD, when you capture with MAKE_MKV, you will see the video format. If it’s MPEG-2, you’re most likely looking at SD interlaced video as the source…you are given all the specs when you highlight the title.
That should read if a BLU-RAY…
Just letting everyone know that in May 2021 THIS TUTORIAL WORKS!!!! both regular DVDs and Blu-ray. some DVDs are getting really old and worn so i need to convert those that are around 15- 20 yrs old to put them on my plex. Thanks Mraksot78. sending you virtual hugs
Curious if you've encountered any problems with Blu-ray since this post? DVDs work but every Blu-ray I've tried crashes Handbrake as soon as I launch the job. Completely uninstalled/reinstalled Handbrake and all dll's but stil no go.
@@bereantrb I've run into the same problem, I've narrowed it down to being an issue in the preferences of makemkv, you have to enable the use of the .dll file outside makemkv. But I that's all I've got so far, I'll let you know when I got the rest figured out.
I am resorting to using the 'backup' option of makemkv and then import that into handbrake.
OMG, I have just started backing up my massive Blu-Ray collection. This video will save SO MUCH time! Thank you!!
Dang! You just saved me 36 hours of encoding. I was ripping from MakeMKV and then use HandBrake to do the encoding and that is going to take me 36+ hours. I found your method and it took me 50 minutes. What an amazing method you have. Thanks a lot and I Subscribed!
bro what are you even encoding taking over 36 hours 💀
and I don't even encode AV1 movies that long
@@simulping4371 I think he is talking about the time of a bunch of them
New to handbrake and this is the first video I've come across, out of dozens, that informs and explains how to use your graphics card to encode in handbrake. Liking and subscribing for that reason, great video!
You should know I also have a followup video to this one where I take look at the difference in the final output file sizes. Although GPU encoding is faster than CPU encoding the final output files are larger. ruclips.net/video/FsTtMERkFbE/видео.html
@@Maraksot78 does winxdvd ripper work for blurays?
To change the audio overdub language to Espanol or Francais, the setting is on the "Audio" tab under the :Audio Tracks" dropdown menu. By default HandBrake is set to: 1 English (AC3) (5.1 ch) (448 kbps)
When it comes to selecting the best quality format for ripping Blu-ray, MKV is always the top choice since it can encompass audio, video, pictures, and subtitle tracks in one single file while keeping the quality almost intact to that of Blu-rays.
What You Need to Rip a Blu-ray to MKV:
● Your Blu-ray discs.
● A Blu-ray disc drive. If your computer came with any disc drive at all, it was probably a DVD drive. However, you'll need a Blu-Ray reader in order to rip your Blu-Ray discs (obviously). An external good Blu-ray drive can be purchased for as little as $25.
Note: If you want to rip 4K UHD Blu-rays, you'll need to get a 4K Blu-ray drive.
● A program to rip the files like EaseFab Blu-ray Ripper
I honestly can't believe I didn't know about copying the DLLs from MakeMKV! I don't currently want to keep full backups, so this saves me a step!
Your videos are awesome basically I'm still a beginner when it comes to digitally recording my Bluray collection and updating my desktop for both gaming and processing videos, you make it simple to understand and put out subject matter that I'm curious about, .keep it up, thanks.
i was at work, and i wanted to watch the martian. and i realized it was only on services i'm not currently subscribed to... so now i'm learning how to set up a plex server or whatever and just rip my blu-rays, because like a dolt i sold all my download codes when i opened the discs. lol your video was super easy to follow and concise. hopefully i can get this all figured out and be able to stream my blu-ray movie copies from work now :)
I must be SUPER AWESOME cause I watched all the way through. No, really thanks for taking the time to do this & going over all the little details that most do not. And even gave the proper links to download all that's needed for digitizing all my DVDS. Would like to see you do something on the various codecs, aspect ratios, etc. Thanks a Bunch!!
It's still working in Windows 11 ver. 24H2 as of Nov. 2024. You had me for a moment, thinking it wouldn't work, until I found the typo (in comments) that solved my problem.
Thank you! Been looking for an easy straight forward break down of this process!!
Thanks very much for your time and effort for this video.. still works today [june2023] as long as you have Handbrake v1.3.1, doesn't work with 1.6.1 for me anyway.. running some tests on the quality that it puts out compared to BD-Rebuilder, but they both use ffMpeg and NVEnc (Nvidia GFX card) so they should be the same... cheers [EDIT] only down side I can see is that the handbrake method needs to have the disc spinning continuously, whereas MakeMkv rip to a multistream .mkv file. no more use of the disc drive, as well as that .mkv can be played back at full quality, if required.
thank you soo much for this reply. i have been trying to get this to work for HOURS. v1.3.1, really did the trick.
Great video! Helped me speed things up by choosing the right encoder for my GPU! I knew I was missing something from my previous handbreak transcodes!
Very well done video, apprecazite your efforts.
I did everything you described but got stopped at running HandBrake as it couldn't find a video on my BluRay. What I ended up doing was using MakeMKV to directly read the BluRay disc and then ran HandBrake to convert the MK4 file created into an MP4 file for my streaming pleasure. Hope this helps anyone out there with a similar problem.
I just used this to back my copy of Son of Godzilla so I can watch it on a tablet, or set top console blu ray player. (The one I encoded was an old AVI I had from years ago.) My factory copy is packed in the garage, in a box from moving. Thank you for this informative video it helped me tremendously! Especially in regards to encoding some of my physical factory discs to use with my tablet. Yes, I can watch them on the blu ray player, but it's in the bedroom, and the treadmill is not, lol. Cheers, and thanks again!
I subscribed because you seem to be a genuinely nice dude!! You were also a big help in helping me set up handbrake couldn't have done it without you! Thanks so much!!
For the 'identifying the correct track' thing you were talking about, most bluray titles usually have '100' as the last three digits in the mpls for the English version. Disney blurays (like Marvel or Star Wars), usually have *'800'* as the last three digits in an mpls list for the correct English version. Just look for the last three digits: 100 for most titles, 800 for Disney titles.
thanks! was trying handbrake and vlc on my ubuntu machine to rip a dvd b4 i saw this, it was a waste of time... will take what i saw here and give another shot and as a last resort duplicate what you did on my windows machine... thank you again
Thank you for this update. How do I paste the files into Handbrake on a Mac?
Is this really a better option to do than the first? Seems like a lot more steps than using MKV and then handbrake to compress. So you’re pretty much just use Make mkv to get the DDL file into handbrake and that’s it. You don’t use it anymore? I’m running a Mac is there any difference? Thanks again for everything in advance and thanks for your hard work. It really helps.
Glad this method still works but, you make to register MKV first
Genio. Funcionó de maravilla. Gracias. Me suscribo.
Wow! It worked just like you said it would. Greatly appreciated!
Informative and well made video Maraksot! One seeming discrepancy appears around the 2:55 mark when you were renaming the dll file that was copied from the Make MKV folder to the Handbrake folder. You spoke that the file should be renamed "libaccs.dll" , but what was typed was "libaacs.dll". Which is the correct filename?
dang man... I totally missed that... nice catch. You want to name it the way I show, libaacs.dll, NOT the way I said it. Sorry about that.
Fantastic YT video Maraksot78! Thank you. I can finally say goodbye to doing it the hard way, which I have been doing for years. DVD Decrypter > Avidemux > Handbrake. This compacts the process to one app. Thank you Thank you Thank you. Liked & Subscribed
I know this video is 3 years old, but just did this with my i-9-12900k and RTX 4090, it did the whole process for a 3 hour movie in 10 minutes.
Did you use the GPU NVEnc or intel quick sync for that speed?
As someone who uses Handbrake to soft code subtitles (able to turn em on/off) fiddling with the settings i found that if left alone it should auto select the files for your language but there is a way to manually specify languages for audio and subtitles. Within the tabs there is a setting for SELECTION BEHAVIOUR
this is an amazing guide! thanks so much
Love It. I want to build a PC and that Ryzon processor looks like it will help me cut my time. My 4K movies take like a day to finish in Handbrake .
You need to load/run MakeMKV FIRST before Handbrake and it will show all the different languages and tracks so you know which one to backup.
This video should be named 'How to make ripping a dvd as difficult as possible'!
i thought my mouse was making the video scroll at the end. :') Haha
Question, when there is a new version of MakeMKV, would you just repeat this process? Would you have to repeat this if Handbrake does an upgrade? Great video! Thanks for doing this and I am also enjoying your EGO reviews.
I don't know for sure if you'd need to repeat the process or not when the current beta key expires. I haven't been using this method long enough to find out yet. I don't think you will though because you're not using the MakeMKV application. You're just 'borrowing' the .dll files from MakeMKV that contain the info on how to decrypt Blu-Ray disc allowing Handbrake to read and rip discs. The way I believe it works is you won't have to update MakeMKV until a new type of encryption is used the .dll files you have don't contain, and you're no longer able to read or rip a disc. At that point you'll need to update MakeMKV and hopefully they will have updated the .dll files allowing you to circumvent that new type of encryption. At least that's the way I think it works. I guess I'll find out in another week as the current beta key will expire at the end of this month. :D
Great video , I have been using the older way . You show us on the older video . Am not that great with all the newer way but using MKV and Handbrake work OK for me but Going to put this video in my favorites . To try when I feel daring Thank you again for all u do for all of us..Stay Safe...
Thanks for checking out the video. I like this method a lot because once you've got things set up you only need to use HandBrake to both rip and encode. And of course using GPU encoding is a HUGE time saver which is very exciting to me. :D
Love the content. It was the driving factor that made me upgrade from my AMD 5700xt to the Nvidia RTX 3080 so I could access the Nvenc encoder. The AMD encoder was OK but the size to quality ratio is nothing like the Nvenc. I really want to try the Intel encoder but I don't have anything Intel in my house at the moment since I run the 5900x. The 12900k will be my next upgrade (or next generation after 12th gen). Thanks!
This is a brilliant explanation as I have wanted to do this as my Panasonic dvd recorder will only read certain blu rays so experimentation is needed as the videos seem to be of a Different file format only read by these player/recorders is AVCHD
I got it to work. I uninstalled Handbrake 1.3.3 then downloaded and installed 1.3.1. Moved the .DLLs over then I right clicked the Handbrake application icon and ran as administrator.
Awesome. But note that in 2024 you need the old Handbrake v1.3.1, for it to work on windows at least. other than that, you da MAN!
using 1.8.1 works fine. Using AV1 codecs on a 12700k right now.
Does this work for every Blu-Ray you've tried it with? HandBrake recognizes one movie I tried but when I attempted to backup the first disc of a TV Show it failed to recognize it, even though MakeMKV had no problem with the same disc.
They always want us to subscribe but wont respond to a valid question. Same here. Handbrake will say "No valid Source Can be found" and of one of the reasons is DRM. If you make videos like this please address everything.
To make sure you have the correct audio track open the dvd in vlc player and click on play movie then click on audio in the top bar and highlight audio track it will show track number and time stamp this also works for the video file i had a dvd that i had to use this method with because the automatically selected audio and video tracks did not line up
The best way I've found to pick the English version is to encode a single chapter and listen to the dialog in the output file.
Hello again. I watch your two videos related to digital copy and now I want to rerip my movie collection with your suggested settings (HQ 1080p30) but I have one question about the audio tab, do you stick with stereo aac and 5.1 ac3. And if yes, why?why not EAC3 because is better then AC3. In the past i just kept Ac3 640 no stereo track. Love your video !!!
Hey man one question
- Why do you recommend gpu encoding? because everyone like on reddit/a lot other yt videos say that the quality is very bad in comparision. I also tested the legend of tarzan and NVEnc produces red artifacts for me with h26510bit CQ20 Medium (the movie is 4K HDR) The beginning is very gray but gpu encoding produces red artifacts there
I wish videos like this would explain how to find the right playlist to movies :/
Awesome video. I have one question: how do the file sizes compare? I'm researching this a lot for my Plex server. Currently have 12TB of data on it, and I want to convert them to H265. All the responses I've come across have said NVENC takes a lot of storage as opposed to x265.
What are the file sizes for the original BR and the H265 one?
Most blu-ray movies are between 20GB and 30GB on the disc and just using MakeMKV gives you an uncompressed rip of the movie close to the same size it is on the disc. Using H.265 my copy of The Rise of Skywalker is now 9.98GB. You can always experiment if you want and try H.265 without using GPU encoding and even use other codecs like H.264 and see what works best for you. :)
@@Maraksot78 Thank you!! Ordered an RTX 2070 last night. The slightly higher file size compared to CPU encoding is well worth the vastly superior time to complete.
I go .MKV for 20-45 minutes to rip, then to Handbrake for H.265 custom Preset for a VERY LONG (8-10 hours) handbrake completion...older dell AIO with 4400 Quad-Core and integrated graphics. The results are PERFECT and MUCH MUCH smaller in size. Most file sizes when done now are only 1.9 to 3.4 GB and again, look and sound PERFECT like I was playing the Blu-Ray disc itself !!!
@@ntvtexan5015 using GPU encoding is so much quicker it's amazing. I'm actually working on a video showing the difference between QuickSync, Nvidia NVENC and AMD VCE encoding right now and I'm impressed how much of a difference using QuickSync makes over just using CPU encoding. Thanks for the comment. Cheers. :)
H265 is HVEC codec which takes less space and keeps quality high.
NVENC is Nvidia gpu codec to rip the file in Handbrake faster. I've also found that also using custom settings for 10 bit further reduces space used, while keeping quality higher. Instead of copying dll files, I take the MakeMKV ripped file and directly drop into Handbrake. In Handbrake I use MKV, framerate same as original. I decode or encode to 1080p, hevc x265 10bit (nvenc) or if it's 4k, the same thing except 2160p, instead of 1080p. I use avg bitrate between 11500 kbps and 20000 kbps depending on what movie it is. The higher the bitrate, the better the quality. I have speed set to slow. I use pass-through for audio tracks and retain chapters and forced closed captions and usually the first English available. I saved a preset for 1080p and 4k 2160p to save time.
This video has helped me greatly. I moved into an RV fulltime. And with my home movie collection being so large that it doesnt fit in the RV, this is an awesome alternative. Watching this video, I did notice the only involvement MakeMKV has in your video is to copy .dll files to HandBrake .... is this correct, or am I missing something to use MakeMKV more effectively?
update: I viewed the original video you created. it looks like you used MakeMKV to rip the movie, then HandBrake to transcode (compressing it). does this new process, outlined in this video, override the old process?
I like this video, very informative, he is amusing well worth watching
I will to one of these day..have a great night brother....THanks...
2024 - I've now updated both Handbrake and MakeMKV, copied the file mentioned in this video, twice (and renaming as directed) and am using the same libdvdcss.dll file from the description's link. I did go through all of the folders and there was not dll file, just project files. I'm not sure if there's a way to generate it from those, but it doesn't matter, because it still worked.
MakeMKV would not update through the software, I had to download a new installer for it, which removed the old copy and installed the new. Handbrake updated through the existing software. I likely hadn't updated the software in a year or two, I'm guessing that since my last comment two years ago, I didn't try this.
I can confirm that I was able to open up a Blu-ray that I'd just received, that was giving me a DRM error before updating. I'm sure YMMV depending on the DVD/Blu-ray disc.
Thank you for the video and making it easy to understand
You're welcome Charles. Been getting some good use out of that PC I hope. :D
Maraksot78 Of course Star Wars Jedi fallen empire on Epic settings I’m getting 98 FPS at 1080p
Well I'm very happy to hear that. I imagine it's a little better than what you were gaming on before? 😅 I really like the 5600XT, it's a great card; lots of power for 1080p and even 1440p gaming.
Love this video and everything was working perfectly until a few days ago. When the latest update was pushed (1.6.1) I lost the ability to directly rip my DVDs. It appears that the update has somehow blocked the use of the .dll or altered how it utilizes them? Anyone else have this problem or found a solution? I tried reinstalling the .dlls but with no success. I am still able to rip with MakeMKV and then convert using Handbrake, but it sure was nice to be able to do both in one step!
I also had problem with latest handbrake version. I just downloaded the version shown on this video (v1.3.1) from archives and now works fine
Thanks for a great guide.
But, silly question: So you don't actually use the MakeMV program itself in the process?
Nope. You just need it to get the .dll files that contain the blu-ray disc decryption data so you can rip the discs with Handbrake. I'm sure there are other ways to get them but this is an easy way to get them and I trust MakeMKV where as I don't know if I can trust other sites that may have the necessary .dll files. Anyway the point of the video was to show how to use GPU encoding to speed things up and how to make Handbrake rip and encode a disc all at once so you don't have to rip with MakeMKV and then import the 20-30GB uncompressed MKV file into Handbrake and then transcode/compress it to a 5-10GB .mp4
Actually, you do need MakeMKV installed. The dll that gets copied actually opens an instance of MakeMKV in the background.
Do you know if all of your dll tricks will work the same way in VidCoder since that program is just a GUI for Handbrake?
Hi ! Thanks for this great informative Video. I noticed your ripper Blu-ray have enclosure but what’s Asus model ? Does it ripping UHD ?
That's actually this enclosure I bought on Amazon www.amazon.com/dp/B01MRUN0HQ?tag=onamzaraksoev-20&linkCode=ssc&creativeASIN=B01MRUN0HQ&asc_item-id=amzn1.ideas.35KP63KCPU1OH&th=1
I had an Asus Blu-ray drive in my old PC and when I upgraded I pulled the blu-ray drive out, bought the enclosure and installed the drive into it.
@@Maraksot78 Thanks again, just I need to know the Asus ripper drive model Number .
@@Alaa.M945 I bought it on Amazon in 2018. Don't know if they sell the same model I bought anymore but the model number is BC-12B1ST. It is just a regular blu-ray drive. It does not burn blu-rays and it does not support 4K (aka UHD) blu-ray either.
@@Maraksot78 Thanks ..so appreciated..wishing you all the best 🤝
Hi ! Thanks for this excellent video. Question : Is it possible to back up cd that are copyrigt also ?
Great tour in the program :-)
How far we've come...I have a 5950X and an RTX3090 and encoding a movie from BR to 1080p takes all of not even 25 minutes. Sorry, but as a nerd, this is cool af. 🤣 It always AMAZES me to see how much more powerful stuff gets over time. Maybe it's time to build a new 7950X or i9-13900 + 4090 machine! Hahaha
Except that GPU encoding looks like absolute garbage compared to software encoding.
@@BlownMacTruck Wut?
@@rmp5sYou’re gaining speed at the cost of quality.
@@BlownMacTruck ...of course speed is at the cost of quality...that's ALWAYS true...
I've used cpu encoding and nvenc encoding. I noticed so little difference that I'll keep using nvenc and save 7 hours when encoding to 2160p .x265 10 bit.
DVDs work but sadly Blu-ray ripping does not work for me. As soon as I start a Blu-ray job Handbrake immediately crashes. I uninstalled/reinstalled Handbrake and all the dll's but still no luck. The other method I've seen works, it just takes A LOT longer (rip full video with MakeMKV, then convert with Handbrake). This looks great. I hope I find a solution.
@maraksot78, care to make an external BD recommendation? I am starting my journey into digital and have seen most of your videos on the subject. A lot easier to comprehend versus other hosts. Thank you.
Thanks so much for your kind compliment. As for a recommendation for an external blu-ray drive... I don't know. I haven't used any personally. I had an Asus internal bru-ray drive in my old PC and when I upgraded to a new case without 5.25" bays I bought pretty much the only enclosure available on Amazon that will accommodate a 5.25" DVD or blu-ray drive. Personally I like to stick with brands I've heard of or just go with something that has good reviews/a good rating. Sorry I'm not more help. :)
I'm a little confused about MakeMKV. It looks like you only used the program for a file that HandBrake needed. Was that all the program was needed for or did I miss a step where the beta key was needed?
yes, the beta key is needed, but since I already had the beta key input into MakeMKV I didn't realize the key was needed until the beta key expired and went to do this again.
Thank you! You are much appreciated!!
in handbrake it scans the titles of my blu ray and reaches 100%( scanning the titles) but never goes away further. Any idea what could be happening?
Thank you for this detailed video, any chance you can share what external blu-ray drive model # and firmware you used? I've been using 123CopyDVD for about 10 years now, until my last W10 update botched the key & password. And at this moment it looks like the maker is gone and no longer supports this product. If this doesn't fit the bill, I might give WinX ripper platinum a try.
Can you recommend a decent external Blu ray/DVD drive? I would like to start ripping my movie collection. I first want to make sure that the external Blu ray/DVD drive will be compatible with Handbrake.
Thank you for sharing the very helpfull information
On handbrake you can go to audio tab and subtitles, and you will be able to see the tracks languages
Thanks for the helpful video my friend
No problem 👍
Hey man Love your videos AWESOME! One question though. When I copy the vlc file into handbrake it works but when I push start encode it always cuts out like at a min or so? What am I doing wrong?
Thanks again for all the work you do.
First of all thanks so much for the very kind compliment. I ran into the same issue using a Ryzen 3 1200 CPU when working on another video. I'm sad to say I didn't investigate it further because I didn't have the time to really sort it out and for the video I didn't really need to. I had that CPU overclocked to 3.8Ghz and I wonder if that overclock wasn't quite stable but like I said I didn't really investigate it so I don't know for sure what was causing it. Sorry I can't be of more help.
Whenever I use the GPU encoding all of my monitors turn red or white and I have to repeatedly reload the GPU drivers in order to see my screens. The encoding process continues throughout this. I'm not sure if it's a driver issue or what is causing it. I have GTX 1080 on latest drivers that works perfectly for gaming.
Since I use Plex for my CD and Bluray rips listening/watching, I prefer to rip my movie Blurays with MakeMKV only. I only need to use Handbrake to transcode if the video is output as a VC type instead of H264 since Plex doesnt like VC and will then take up more CPU and transcoding time on your server to change the quality to a format (H264) that it CAN handle. This saves me extra time and MakeMKV can export the movie with only the ONE or TWO sound fields I want incuded and nothing else in a much faster time than Handbrake which takes a LOOOOONG time
Thanks for the help! Is it weird that my GPU only gets to 3-4% utilization? Is there a way to force it to use more and make the process quicker?
The encoder does not utilize the full GPU. You also typically don't see much of a difference between high end and low end cards either. GeForce cards are capable of doing up to 3 simultaneous encodes so you may find increased performance if you run two separate copies of handbrake. Depends on how much CPU overhead you have I suppose. I have two going right now and it's using 100% of i7-5960x 4.5ghz and 75% of RTX 3080.
Thanks for the video, it's very instructive. I just upgraded to a new PC that does not have an internal Blu-ray disk drive. I noticed you have an external drive and was wondering what model you have. Thanks.
Glad you enjoyed the video. I actually had a Blu-ray drive in my previous PC but when I upgraded my new chassis didn't have space for one so I found this drive enclosure on Amazon.
www.amazon.com/dp/B01MRUN0HQ?ref=exp_maraksot78_dp_vv_d
It will fit any 5.25 inch DVD or Blu-ray drive so if you have one lying around you can just pop it in the enclosure and go. :D
Watch til the end. Liked & Subscribed.
Is the file copying process the same for macOS? Like someone else mentioned, I, too, was using both MakeMKV and Handbrake separately on macOS, but if the file-copying process is the same, I’ll try that instead.
06:06 when you are on the tab for the 'audio' the language is displayed there. I'm sure 4 or 5 dozen people already pointed this out though.
I’ve ripped some DVDs with makemkv thinking nothing was wrong but sometimes in the middle of the film it just skips ahead 10 seconds, or skips to the end of the film and stops playing. I’m not sure what I am doing wrong.
Really?
That's very strange.
I haven't had this problem at all.
In fact, if my film doesn't rip properly the entire process is bust.
I don't even know how what you're describing is possible.
You do go through a verification process at the start don't you?
And, maybe your drive is defective.
I mean the disk reader.
Merry Christmas....Do you have a time per gig estimate that a person could use as a comparison? I have Terabytes of SD quality Mp4 that I would like to reduce the file size of..I am going to be looking at the after xmas sales and would like to know what specs to look for?
Great video, Can you use this on 4k Blu-ray. If so what would be a good internal or external player to get for 4k.
Unfortunately I do not have an answer for that question. Haven't yet made the transition to 4K blu-ray and haven't looked into making backups of 4K blu-ray discs. Sorry.
@@Maraksot78 no sorry sir its ok
I need to upgrade my computer. The one I have is 10 years old and it takes 24 hours or more to backup a 4k disc with handbrake. Could you recommend what I need for efficient hardware to create in the time frame you stated in this video. Is their a computer that comes with everything in the cabinet? Please be specific for I am not computer literate.
Very helpful! Thx!
Also, why did you choose Index of /pub/libdvdcss/1.2.12/win64/ instead of the newer versions?
The newer vesions are just Linux downloads
To be fair though I think you only need to update that Kia Rick up Lemans if you’re ripping Blu-rays if you’re ripping DVDs on there you don’t have to do anything the system will need to be updated every once in a while as they make changes and updates but I don’t think you have to update that key
Just found this and wondering if this still works now in 2022? Also, this seems more geared to ripping blu rays - is make mkv needed still or can this be done easier with VLC? Also, would it be faster to do a straight whole copy rather than just selecting certain files to copy?
I set it up exactly as you showed. but Handbrake did not work for GOT season 6 bluray. Makemkv did decode it though.
Same - all Blu-ray's I try crash Handbrake.
Seems great, though I got an error within the first few seconds or so, then re-verified I put the copied .dll file x2 into the folder with the proper name for each (and libaacs.dll for the one as in your description), and put the proper one downloaded into the same HandBrake directory. The movie ripped with MakeMKV with no problem. My question is, will Handbrake still do the encoding fast afterward? I'm new to this and have a computer in the other room that's been going since last night decoding a file on Handbrake (per a comment on another video to set the speed to very slow) and will run about another 10 hours or so to finish. If I can get something that'll work anywhere nearly as quick as a couple hours I'll be very happy. I guess I'll find out quickly if doing the Handbrake part with gpu enabled to deal with the file after MakeMKV's part works okay. :D
It may be that an update to HandBrake has changed something, and I noticed you have additional files in your HandBrake directory besides the 3 .dll files added in. On another brand new disc, I'm getting the same type of error, queue finished with 1 errors or cancellations after less than a minute. But I was able to take advantage of the information regarding using the GPU and matching output with hvec.265 to do the second half after ripping the files with MakeMKV. Very helpful, and much appreciated! :)
Thanks.. I assume burning 3D blueray is just a matter of selecting the correct 3D track.. (Assume) is that correct? I so far have ripped a standard blue ray, still trying 3D side by side. My Player (internal sata to MB) seems to see all the tracks. Do I need a special DVD player to read 3D?- update: both available tracks on imax under the sea - 3D came out non-side by side?.Thanks..
I would imagine so. I've never ripped a 3D blu-ray before.
Hmmm...for some reason even though I did all three DLL's and made sure I named them correctly, Handbrake works for DVD's but I still get the "No valid source" error on Bluray's. ☹
Thank you for this video, I was wondering why I could not rip blue rays. Now I know. QUESTION: How do I make the rip complete with subtitles? Every time I rip anything with handbrake I do not get the subtitles. Thanks
Handbrake will burn in one subtitle track from the disc or MKV file. (When using MakeMKV be sure to include any subtitle tracks you want) In order to “optionally” include subtitles, you have to import them. You can extract subtitle files from MKV files using MKV Cleaver. depending on the disc type, it will export the subtitle files with different extensions. These files are then Imported into a program called Subtitle Edit, where you do an OCR scan of the file(s), which may require correction as there are occasion interpretation issues. You save the complete OCR scan as either an .srt or .ass file. These subtitle files can now be imported into Handbrake., and you can now include multiple subtitle files, selecting one as the Default. Do not “Burn in” any subtitles. You can also rename the subtitle (English, Commentary, etc...)
@@videoplusdvdThanks for the information, I watched this video (and many other vids) seeking what you wrote in this comment. 👍🙏
just curious what external bluray burner would you recommend
I noticed when I went to get a copy of the file libdvdcss.dll, the file became BZ2 file where as on your video it stayed a dll file. Also my computer warned me this file could harm my device. Do you have any thoughts on this?
What would be the best way to rip the highest quality you can from a DVD? I imagine just choosing a high resolution would mess with the quality.
I usually rip several BD's with MKV, then batch endode them in Handbrake.
Makemkv does not recognize the BluRay. VLC won't play the Blu-ray either. I updated the drivers and my computer. I had to download a program called Leawo BluRay player and I was able to play the BluRay. I am using an external Blu-ray player. I did the steps for Handbrake once I found that the BD play worked. How long does the BluRay take to rip typically? It has been sitting at scanning title 1 of 1 (0%) for about 15 mins now. Also, I am using windows 10 and I was able to Rip a standard DVD with no problem. I am wondering if it is something with my computer that I am missing...
Update** I just reset my computer and it works...The old turn it off and on bit lol.....Makemkv still does not work though
Did you copy the .dll files from MakeMKV to the HandBrake folder like I show in the video? At 2:55 in the video I say to rename a file to libaccs.dll but on screen you see me type out libaacs.dll. I misspoke at this point and didn't catch it before posting the video live. To get this to work you want to name it libaacs.dll like you see on screen. Sorry for the confusion.
Maraksot78 I really appreciate the help. The video was so helpful thank you thank you thank you for putting this together! Now I will start the journey of backing up my dvd collection and figure out how to build my in home server 🤔✌🏼
Why would Make MKV have an error " Automatic SDF downloading is disabled or failed."?
I have been doing it the way you showed in the older video, and after It’s sometimes I get no audio with the movie, or it’s in French or there’s someone narrating the whole movie. What step/steps am I missing
First of all, thank you for such a great video!. However, I am 2 questions
1. is it libaccs or libaacs.dll? You said "accs" but the screen shows "aacs".
2. When i pressed the BD drive in Handbrake , it says "No Valid source or titles found." for some BD discs
please help >0
Yah, I misspoke at that part and didn't catch it when I was editing. You want it to be libaacs.dll. What I did on screen is correct, what I said is not. Sorry about the confusion. As for your other problem I don't know what's going on there. I've never encountered that. So is it just with certain discs it does this or does it do it with all blu-rays?
@@Maraksot78 thanks for the reply!
i just tried two so far, one isn't, and one is working, gonna finish the first rip soon.
Each of the passes last for around 1 hour. Is that normal? The movie length is 140 min
Ripping a disc takes my Blu-Ray/DVD Combo drive about 20 minutes and then it depends on what GPU you're using. In tests I've done AMD VCE is the slowest, Intel QuickSync is 2nd and Nvidia NVENC is the fastest... That is unless you have a newer AMD Radeon 5000 series graphics cards, i.e. RX 5600XT, RX 5700 etc. then AMD VCE is the fastest, NVENC is 2nd and Quick Sync is slowest. But I did only test using hardware I have access to which includes an RTX 2070, my laptops 1050ti, a RX 570, a RX 5700XT and my laptops IGPU which is an Intel UHD 630 graphics.