What makes this sadder in the book, is that when she falls and sees the train coming ,she regrets it and doesn’t want to die and tries to get away, but it was too late
Granted, film doesn't really allow for the same levels of expounding as books do. My recollection of the book is that this particular moment where Anna throws herself under the train took up a full 3 pages by itself. It's much trickier to express internal conflicts in a purely visual medium.
@@almaajdinovic5428 Thanks for informing me! It's been close to a decade since I read the book cover to cover, so my recollection should be taken with a grain of salt.
Kiera Knightley was so underrated for this movie. The sheer amount of pathos and range of emotion she was able to show throughout the movie but also in just this scene alone. She gets but one line at the very end and yet you can just feel every moment of her spiralling, as she cycles through shame, anger, humiliation, but above all just overwhelming pain and loneliness. Frankly I think the fact that with all the buildup the actual suicide and the line "Oh God, forgive me" is this little rushed scream of last minute panic, is a perfect choice and makes the moment feel real in a heartbreaking, horrific way. It's both something that was a long time coming, being pushed by the condemnation of society and her isolation and the jealousy issues and loneliness pushing her away even from the one person she did it all for...and yet also she has a moment where she hesitated at the end. But when she finally flung herself over it wasn't a pretty and poetic moment where she got to say a prayerful line full of pious remorse. It feels more like the frantic last ditch cry of a soul in pain just a second before the impulsive final push, like someone just snapping and rushing into a terrible decision before they can talk themselves out of it, before anyone can realize what's happening snd save them, because they just want the pain to stop. You know, like real suicide often is for an unfortunate amount of people.
The scene after be fall, after Vronsky's face is the best scene in the movie: Anna lying there while the train lights her face and moves rhythmically and symbolically. Keeping the sound of the train running over the track was a stroke of genius and made the scene so much more tragic, poignant and haunting.
Am I the only one upset about the lack of emotion on Vronsky's part? As my friend pointed out, he was is shock, but their romance was so dramatic and passionate, and yes, sad at the end, but it led us to expect him to be in utter despair. Maybe he was, it just didn't show it though...
Grace I think the film didn't really show how despaired and sad he was, in the book you can also read how empty his life was now after Anna's death, and his mother was even afraid of him killing himself. Even though I liked it, the film didn't give importance to a lot of facts that were determinate to understand the story and what Tolstoi wanted to express.
Jazmin F. In the book it was said that he basically killed himself. He went on the next train to the front lines of a war where the narrative makes it clear his chances of survival are slim to none. The last we see of him, he’s getting on a train towards his death.
Yeah i think so too.. I thought vronsky was just going to left anna in the end..i never really felt his great affections towards anna. But i think its different on the book..better read the book
In the movie Anna shows bipolar traits, something thats darker than love and passion. She leaves Vronski confused and drained. I dont remember the book, but I will eventually read it again.. The movie was good.
She's not bipolar. She's hallucinating things (like vronsky cheating on her) because she was taking opium to sleep every night and to comfort herself every day over being socially shunned by society. It muddled her mind severly, and caused severe mood swings.
I believe that the way Tolstoy made Anna commit poorly written suicide. If he had done as in the real case he was inspired, it would have been better. Anna being abandoned by a younger woman. and Vonrsky hardly cares about her. In the initial plan, Karenina was called Tatyana, and she parted with her life in the Neva. But a year before the start of work on the novel, in 1872, a tragedy happened in the family of Tolstoy's neighbor, Alexander Nikolaevich Bibikov, with whom they maintained good-neighborly relations and even started the construction of a distillery together. Anna Stepanovna Pirogova lived with Bibikov as common-law wife. Recently, however, Bibikov began to give preference to the German governess of his children and even decided to marry her. When Anna Stepanovna found out about his betrayal, her jealousy crossed all boundaries. She ran away from home with a bundle of clothes, and for three days wandered around the area beside herself with grief. Before her death, she sent a letter to Bibikov: “You are my killer. Be happy if the killer can be happy at all. If you wish, you can see my corpse on the rails in Yasenki ”(station not far from Yasnaya Polyana). However, Bibikov did not read the letter, and the messenger returned it. Desperate Anna Stepanovna threw herself under a passing freight train. The next day, Tolstoy went to the station when an autopsy was performed in the presence of a police inspector. He stood in the corner of the room and saw in every detail a woman's body lying on a marble table, bloodied and mutilated, with a smashed skull. And Bibikov, recovering from the shock, soon married his governess. This is, so to speak, prehistory. Now let's re-read once again the description of the unfortunate heroine's suicide.
@@ineffablegabe im sorry how do you know her taking opium wasnt the result of her having a mental disorder? At that time mental illness was something non existent. Even Levins constant dramatic questions about meaning of life and his depression is overlooked as something stupid. To me almost everyone in that novel suffers from some kind of illness
@@feedingfrenzy8126 You either get squashed or decapitated or even juiced on the spot. There's no way someone could be in one piece after being struck by a train lol
I don't know why, but I feel sorry for her anyway! Everything she's done such as stealing a man from another girl, cheating on her husband, hysterical behavior to Vronsky and jealousy has been forgotten by me by the end of the movie. Some may say 'it served her right', but I think the punishment has become much more serious than the 'crime'... And I'm so glad that Kitty has found her happiness, could see her falling in love with Levin at the end. They're such a perfect couple!!!
You do know her ex husband was abusive I am not excusing her affair but she did love Vronsky but everyone hated her so she had to kill herslelf why wouldn’t you be sorry for her?kitty never struggled she had a dream man lined up when Vronsky was Anna’s dream man but he wasn’t mentally ready to tell others that he was in love with her vs she was.
@@Hi-zr3ke when was he abusive with her ??? He didn’t love her but he respected her , he trusted her , he never cheated on her , never mistreated her but she decided to leave him with their son for her passionate love. She was the architect of her own destruction so I didn’t feel sorry for her.
@@donrog5035 read the book the movie made him out to be a saint and her a villain she was the victim of society, mental health matters and no one gaf about her.The book proves that comment different...
@@AB-sm1qf Well that’s a long answer. But you know I study history to some extent and I know for sure the image we have about womenn in the past isn’t true. Women as men were active in society, both contributed to the wealth of their country. No country can develop and accumulate wealth if more than half of his population do nothing. Women work, in the field , they can run business like an inn , they work in different part of the industry. But legally, in taxes registers, the wealth of women were at the name of the male authority of the household. So today we have the impression that women weren’t an active part of society. For noble women or rich women they manage their big house or castle and it’s a huge work I mean even today people are paid to manage old castle, they have to host many events, sometimes help their husband to manage their business, etc... So you see women were more than just object than men can enjoy. In fact today or in the past there are some men who have a narrow minded view of women. So my first point is to tell you that society back then didn’t see women’s wellbeing in having nice things and look cute. Now in every society women and men have their role to play . You can’t just do whatever the fuck you want. So when it comes to a married couple the wife has to obey to her husband and the husband has to take care and honor his wife (Christians values of the marriage). So they have both a role to play and rules to respect. Now they are nobles so that means that perhaps they married out of familial obligations rather than love but it was normal at the time marriage was never about love. It’s a very new perspective of marriage. I mean in many thousands years of history of mankind love marriage is the norm since 150 years at best. So it was normal in noble society they find love and passion with extra conjugal affairs. They just have to keep it quiet and don’t show it in public light. Men as women has to respect this rule. A men couldn’t abandon his wife and children to just live his love life with her lover. He would have been shunned for that. And it is the same for the women. What she did wasn’t about freedom, she was irresponsible. And I think even today if a man or woman does that he/she will not be seen in a positive light. So yeah when you take the context of the time and even our current context what she did was wrong and she is the only one to blame for her downfall.
@@donrog5035 Of course women participated in labour, but it was mostly unpaid. Women did not own wealth, and their status in society was secondary. Those make all the difference. And so much for studying history when you believe gender roles (which are social constructs) are sacred. Also, please don't come with arguments of physiological differences between the sexes. All over the world, women do a disproportionately large share of physical labour, but get paid less, and have their capabilities still undermined. Having studied history, and the essential bit of anthropology, you should be knowing this already.
I know that many of us wanted the movie to show more emotion from Vronsky when Anna died, but the entire movie was so much like poetry, I think the producers and writers wanted to show the first shock, then just their girl with her husband, just as Vronsky wouldn't exist anymore without her. 💔
bir marşandiz yaklaşıyordu. ayaklarının altında toprak sallanır gibi oldu. kendisini yeniden trende sandı. birden vronski'yi ilk tanıdığı gün trenin altında kalıp ezilen adamı hatırladı. ne yapması gerektiğini anlamıştı artık. raylara götüren merdiveni koşar adım indi. trenin geçeceği yerin yakınında durdu. vagonların alt kısımlarına, zincir ve vidalara baktı. ön ve arka tekerleklerin arasını tasarlamaya ve tam önünden geçeceği zamanı kestirmeye çalıştı.
the more i see this film the more details i realized; the scene at 1:18 when she’s about to reach the door she looks at the men near it who don’t even react to her so she opens the door- and then notice how the man just slowly breaks out of his role (which is to stand still) to look at her? he doesn’t stop her. I think the fact that some people notice her and do nothing makes her fall even more into dispare as if it’s like they aren’t even going to try to stop her from ending her life
This is my favorite book of all time. But this movie although really good just doesn't do the book justice. The imagery in the book is just so difficult to capture on film.
She should had known, that even she was a cruel and evil woman, she had 2 men that seriously loved her deeply. Not to mention her son too, that still considered her as the best (better than his loyal dad), eventho his mom prefer her secret lover than himself
Vronsky showed her erotic love, which Karenin could not. He showed her love through work and making money. A pious husband who adhered to the customs and traditions of the time. Anna has followed her desires and brought misery to herself and her family.
Can anyone tell me did she hallucinate the part when the other Princess in the carousel looked up at her and giggled on purpose to make her jealous/ mad? Or did it actually happen
can someone tell me when he asked her the first time before leaving if she had something she wanted to tell him and the second most important time when we see him through the mirror with watery eyes? Like hear from her specific word or not ?
Eu fiquei meio confusa no final mas logo entendi, quando vi a cena dela no trem não entendi exatamente mas no final do filme me dei conta, pensei que fosse só uma alucinação da Anna mas mulheres sempre tem certeza de suas paranóias pq homens não sabem mas desconfiamos de tudo sempre e sempre estamos certas, Quando ela está pensativa no trem, a cena que não entendi é agora sei, retrata se da Traição do Conde Vronsky com a Princesa Sorokina, pois ela era virgem e existe sangue nessa cena. Me senti muito aflita e angustiada, chorei no final não pude crer que ele foi capaz de fazer isso mas tanto ele como ela nato tem muitos valores, sei que Anna a amava e ele talvez a amasse também em algum momento, não não sei se ambas atitudes justificam suas ações ….
I think yes,as it was the custom at that time. But they didn't and Anna felt it was because they had shunned her and thought of her as too low a disgrace for even basic courtesiesand that's why she is shown as angry and in tears as she opens the door herself
Kitty and Anna's characters basically progressed in opposite directions. Anna was originally the mature woman while Kitty was the helpless romantic. Kitty learned to mature overtime from Vronsky and now has a loving husband in Levin, while Anna gave up her life for a passionate and unstable love affair with Vronsky.
In the beginning? Sure. Kitty kind of lost her charm when she grew up, in my eyes. While I warmed up to Anna when she stopped being annoyingly perfect (or maybe it was the black dress).
in the book he is very depressed and doesn't forgive himself, he hates everyone and he thinks his life doesn't matter anymore, thats why decides to join the war
Dreams & Teddy Bears i think he felt really guilty of her death , even though he never really cheated on her or anything , she was actually being very “over-protective “ if I may say or “obsessing” over him, and he didn’t like of course and acted cold towards her after that. Tbh Anna Karenina’s character is quite confusing but loving at the same time.
Its sad that in the end death was the only way she could be free from her pain, I personally feel like she didn't really love that man what she loved was the passion that being with him brought, shes impulsive so she didn't think about the consequence of her actions she threw away her life for passion and it didnt make her happy, it was only a temporary satisfaction
Je suis tellement triste pour Vronsky qui l'aimait avec une telle ardeur ! et là elle se tue comme ça T.T...bon ok elle l'aimait aussi et souffrait des consequences mais je me sens tellement mal pour le gars...vraiment dommage qu'on ne voit pas sa reaction
Vronsky was just a womanizer who was getting bored of Anna, his death made him feel guilty. As with Dmitri Ivanovich Nekhlyudov in Resurrection by Tolstoy when what happened to his first crush Katyusha (Katerina Mikhailovna Maslova), made him feel remorse for his actions. Remember how Prince Andrei was unfair to his wife Lise in war and peace and his death and made him feel remorse. Natasha's regret faced breaking up with Andrei to escape with Anatole Kuragin. Guilt comes at the last moment and remorse for your choices.
À notre époque, Anna aurait divorcé, aurait pu voir son fils et ne serait pas une paria de la société. Les conventions sociales me semblent plus blâmables qu'elle.
They tried, a lot of times actually, it's just they were not able to handle living a life were people don't accepted them ( for example people in Europe refused them 'cause they were not married)
someone please explain to me the ending when it showed her ex husband, her son, and her daughter . I had the idea they were in heaven since her son was sick but that wouldn't make any since as to why her husband or daughter would be there, i would figure her ex husband killed himself also and the daughter died when she drank alcohol in that one scene? I'm so confused lmfao
WHAT 😂 🤣 NO. Karenin did not kill himself. Her son was sick just once, and only from a cold. He was not in any danger of dying, and so he didn't die. Same for the husband. Why should Mr Karenin kill himself over his unfaithful cheater wife, who didn't deserve his love and devotion?! In both the book and the movie Anna was still married to Mr Karenin till she committed suicide. So any children she gave birth to were lawfully Mr Karenin's. In the book Vronsky couldn't deal with the guilt of driving Anna to her ruin, and he reenlisted in the army in the hope of dying in the war, so he could finally be free of his perpetual guilt by dying a heroic death in war. He was too immature to, and just plain didn't want to, raise his own child by his dead mistress, so in the books Vronsky gave his daughter Annie forever to Mr Karenin before going to get himself killed in war. In the movie, Vronsky and Anna left their daughter Annie with Karenin, to be a happy unburdened couple in France, and they never took baby Annie back when they returned to Russia. So when Anna killed herself and Vronsky went off on his suicide mission, Mr Karenin, who already had been raising Annie, and legally had her custody, continued to raise her as his own daughter with his son, because legally, as I explained above, he IS her legal father and only living parent. This scene simply shows that despite Anna's grave betrayal, Mr Karenin, their son and her daughter, are able to be a happy family together. He's clearly raising the kids well. Karenin, his son and his daughter have all gotten over Anna and Vronsky's hurtful actions, and are living the best life possible, as they should. Karenin and Anna never got divorced, so he isn't her ex husband. He is, after her suicide, her widower. Anna never married Vronsky, she was just his mistress in a long line of others. Anna died as Karenin's wife and Karenin's wife alone. There's a reason the novel and all the movies based on it are titled Anna Karenina, not Anna Vronskaya.
@@ineffablegabe I hated Anna. I didn’t even feel sorry for her death. However I do feel empathy for his husband. Even if he didn’t love his wife he cared for her , he never cheated on her , never mistreated her but Anna decided to abandon him with their son and even her daughter she had with Vronski. For what ? LOVE ? PASSION ? What kind of love is this ? A love who cause harm to you and your loved ones, it isn’t love. It’s selfishness.
@@donrog5035 I fully agree!!! She and vronsky nearly ruined so many innocent lives, and all for what? They couldn't even be happy with each other in the end.
I’m so confused about the scene when the princess shows up and Vronsky goes with her. I’m not sure if it was real or Anna was hallucinating. I want to know that.
From what everyone was saying it’s a hallucination. He really was only getting papers from his mother who I don’t think wanted to be seen with and hoped he would date her. But Anna was paranoid she lost her status, her friends, and her children the ONLY thing she had was the love of an eligible good looking formerly known as a player may I add count. She didn’t feel safe with him and I think she also knew deep down that what goes around comes around
@@Thekawaiiasian101vid then you talk to someone , suicide is a coward and selfish act. But she was already a selfish woman so her suicide is just logic
@@donrog5035 you have no understanding of how mental health works and to deem it as a selfish act is kind of low. I won't bother arguing about it. Doing some research really opens your eyes as to why suicidal people do the things that they do. Have a nice day, Don.
Correct me if I’m wrong I don’t think she was pregnant I’m pretty sure the stomach pain was just a reference from the guy who was severed from the stomach when he died by train at the start of the movie.
Anna can't stand the shame she created over her image for her adulter with Vronskij and she has an unjustified jealousy towards her lover, so she decides to commit suicide jumping off the railway. It's a chronicle fact happened in 1877 in Moscow, if I remember well: a woman killed herself under a train after a love affair bad ended; that inspired Tolstoj to make Anna die
I don't know about the movie, but in the novel Vronskij had no interest whatsoever in other women or in leaving Anna. His love never wavered even in the lows of their relationship. He feels like his destiny is bound to hers in a marriage-like way, and there's no going back.
Norman Brenes Anna killed herself because she thinks that she is a burden to Vronsky (and she thinks that he's cheating on her). She also cannot be seen in public because she is shamed. Her husband took custody of their children so she cannot see them either.
Thanks for the answer. I did understand that. I read the book, like 5 years ago, but I don't understand why is everyone like paralyzed in this movie. What's the purpose of that?
Norman Brenes the tableau part is (in my opinion) probably an artistic representation of how time stopped in Anna's mind. (meaning that she thinks that there's no future for her) Also, it is showing that Anna is alone, and that no one cares enough to stop her from killing herself
For the pg ratings I get it, but if anyone wants to commit not alive like that, I'm pretty sure you'll end up looking like mush and not what was shown in this movie, suicide by train is a god awful way to go
So basically Anna killed herself because she thought that Vronsky was cheating on her with another woman as seen on 0:58 but really she’s just mentally unstable and she was hallucinating.
It would have been a much better idea if Vronsky had abandoned Anna for her as it happened in the real story that inspired Tolstoy. In the initial plan, Karenina was called Tatyana, and she parted with her life in the Neva. But a year before the start of work on the novel, in 1872, a tragedy happened in the family of Tolstoy's neighbor, Alexander Nikolaevich Bibikov, with whom they maintained good-neighborly relations and even started the construction of a distillery together. Anna Stepanovna Pirogova lived with Bibikov as common-law wife. Recently, however, Bibikov began to give preference to the German governess of his children and even decided to marry her. When Anna Stepanovna found out about his betrayal, her jealousy crossed all boundaries. She ran away from home with a bundle of clothes, and for three days wandered around the area beside herself with grief. Before her death, she sent a letter to Bibikov: “You are my killer. Be happy if the killer can be happy at all. If you wish, you can see my corpse on the rails in Yasenki ”(station not far from Yasnaya Polyana). However, Bibikov did not read the letter, and the messenger returned it. Desperate Anna Stepanovna threw herself under a passing freight train. The next day, Tolstoy went to the station when an autopsy was performed in the presence of a police inspector. He stood in the corner of the room and saw in every detail a woman's body lying on a marble table, bloodied and mutilated, with a smashed skull. And Bibikov, recovering from the shock, soon married his governess. This is, so to speak, prehistory. Now let's re-read once again the description of the unfortunate heroine's suicide.
The Sophie Marceau version is 1000 times better. Sean & her had amazing chemistry and her dead body at the station still makes me feel physically ill when I think about it. It was very intense 🤢😵
It's just a movie but there is real ladies defend her awful horrible behaviour. This is not even a proper love story. They just love the revenge plot to the husband.
Read the book i Love this novel my best Love Story novel... Leo tolstoy .. u will see the heart Inside.. of the story. U will Watch this all Time...all movie from this story
well not only because she thought he was cheating. she couldn’t even go out without getting shamed and criticized, her husband won custody etc. Also dont forget how badly women were treated in the 19th century.
![Jelly Roll - Dead End Road (From Twisters: The Album) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_Mb8CqKW4R8/mqdefault.jpg)
What makes this sadder in the book, is that when she falls and sees the train coming ,she regrets it and doesn’t want to die and tries to get away, but it was too late
Granted, film doesn't really allow for the same levels of expounding as books do. My recollection of the book is that this particular moment where Anna throws herself under the train took up a full 3 pages by itself. It's much trickier to express internal conflicts in a purely visual medium.
@@josh420masterB it's actualy not that long in the book,i've just read that part today,and it was like a half of a page,but I get your point
@@almaajdinovic5428
Thanks for informing me! It's been close to a decade since I read the book cover to cover, so my recollection should be taken with a grain of salt.
And the name of the soundtrack was too late
omg, that would be awful!!! : (
Kiera Knightley was so underrated for this movie. The sheer amount of pathos and range of emotion she was able to show throughout the movie but also in just this scene alone. She gets but one line at the very end and yet you can just feel every moment of her spiralling, as she cycles through shame, anger, humiliation, but above all just overwhelming pain and loneliness.
Frankly I think the fact that with all the buildup the actual suicide and the line "Oh God, forgive me" is this little rushed scream of last minute panic, is a perfect choice and makes the moment feel real in a heartbreaking, horrific way. It's both something that was a long time coming, being pushed by the condemnation of society and her isolation and the jealousy issues and loneliness pushing her away even from the one person she did it all for...and yet also she has a moment where she hesitated at the end. But when she finally flung herself over it wasn't a pretty and poetic moment where she got to say a prayerful line full of pious remorse. It feels more like the frantic last ditch cry of a soul in pain just a second before the impulsive final push, like someone just snapping and rushing into a terrible decision before they can talk themselves out of it, before anyone can realize what's happening snd save them, because they just want the pain to stop. You know, like real suicide often is for an unfortunate amount of people.
Вы просто так хорошо описали её чувства либо вы психиатр, либо вы прл
0:03
Anna doubles over in pain as she hears the noise made by the worker who died when she arrived in Moscow.
Thank you!! I didnt know
ohh! thank you! i couldn't understand that part
i thought she was having menstrual pangs, or something, haha
... despair is the biggest human hell ...
Claudiu Cont I totally agree this scene is so graphic it touches my heart and makes my cry !
No, being without God's love and mercy is eternally worse.
The scene after be fall, after Vronsky's face is the best scene in the movie: Anna lying there while the train lights her face and moves rhythmically and symbolically. Keeping the sound of the train running over the track was a stroke of genius and made the scene so much more tragic, poignant and haunting.
Am I the only one upset about the lack of emotion on Vronsky's part? As my friend pointed out, he was is shock, but their romance was so dramatic and passionate, and yes, sad at the end, but it led us to expect him to be in utter despair. Maybe he was, it just didn't show it though...
Grace I think the film didn't really show how despaired and sad he was, in the book you can also read how empty his life was now after Anna's death, and his mother was even afraid of him killing himself. Even though I liked it, the film didn't give importance to a lot of facts that were determinate to understand the story and what Tolstoi wanted to express.
Could vronsky sense that Anna died
It wasn’t love. She was just obsessed
Jazmin F. In the book it was said that he basically killed himself. He went on the next train to the front lines of a war where the narrative makes it clear his chances of survival are slim to none. The last we see of him, he’s getting on a train towards his death.
Yeah i think so too.. I thought vronsky was just going to left anna in the end..i never really felt his great affections towards anna. But i think its different on the book..better read the book
In the movie Anna shows bipolar traits, something thats darker than love and passion. She leaves Vronski confused and drained. I dont remember the book, but I will eventually read it again.. The movie was good.
She's not bipolar. She's hallucinating things (like vronsky cheating on her) because she was taking opium to sleep every night and to comfort herself every day over being socially shunned by society. It muddled her mind severly, and caused severe mood swings.
I believe that the way Tolstoy made Anna commit poorly written suicide. If he had done as in the real case he was inspired, it would have been better.
Anna being abandoned by a younger woman. and Vonrsky hardly cares about her.
In the initial plan, Karenina was called Tatyana, and she parted with her life in the Neva. But a year before the start of work on the novel, in 1872, a tragedy happened in the family of Tolstoy's neighbor, Alexander Nikolaevich Bibikov, with whom they maintained good-neighborly relations and even started the construction of a distillery together. Anna Stepanovna Pirogova lived with Bibikov as common-law wife.
Recently, however, Bibikov began to give preference to the German governess of his children and even decided to marry her. When Anna Stepanovna found out about his betrayal, her jealousy crossed all boundaries. She ran away from home with a bundle of clothes, and for three days wandered around the area beside herself with grief. Before her death, she sent a letter to Bibikov: “You are my killer. Be happy if the killer can be happy at all. If you wish, you can see my corpse on the rails in Yasenki ”(station not far from Yasnaya Polyana). However, Bibikov did not read the letter, and the messenger returned it. Desperate Anna Stepanovna threw herself under a passing freight train.
The next day, Tolstoy went to the station when an autopsy was performed in the presence of a police inspector. He stood in the corner of the room and saw in every detail a woman's body lying on a marble table, bloodied and mutilated, with a smashed skull. And Bibikov, recovering from the shock, soon married his governess.
This is, so to speak, prehistory. Now let's re-read once again the description of the unfortunate heroine's suicide.
Don't know about bipolar but she seems to have bpd (borderline personality disorder) to me.
Actually this is Borderline personality disorder
@@ineffablegabe im sorry how do you know her taking opium wasnt the result of her having a mental disorder? At that time mental illness was something non existent. Even Levins constant dramatic questions about meaning of life and his depression is overlooked as something stupid. To me almost everyone in that novel suffers from some kind of illness
What she says in the end is one of the best lines in all of the movies I have seen..💔
Actually it is in the novel and more
She said: Forgive me!
There is no forgiveness for that! Only the pit of Hell.
@@honestaf6165 :you are so wrong!
Ana is in heaven.Maybe shes not real but theres a lot of real examples like Ana.
@@honestaf6165 , lol... Okay, loser
Is it just me or that is the softest death by a train i've ever seeb
How many deaths by train have you seen...? O.o
@@feedingfrenzy8126 You either get squashed or decapitated or even juiced on the spot. There's no way someone could be in one piece after being struck by a train lol
@@Luxiebestie She wasn't in one piece lmao, she was in 2.
Well I mean The Director wanted everything to be like a play in the theater.. so all the gore makes sense to be toned downed
@@alexanderboleyn2058 everything toned down....besides the man split in half 💀
Kiera lived the character indeed 😢😍
this scene is just a masterpiece
I don't know why, but I feel sorry for her anyway! Everything she's done such as stealing a man from another girl, cheating on her husband, hysterical behavior to Vronsky and jealousy has been forgotten by me by the end of the movie. Some may say 'it served her right', but I think the punishment has become much more serious than the 'crime'... And I'm so glad that Kitty has found her happiness, could see her falling in love with Levin at the end. They're such a perfect couple!!!
You do know her ex husband was abusive I am not excusing her affair but she did love Vronsky but everyone hated her so she had to kill herslelf why wouldn’t you be sorry for her?kitty never struggled she had a dream man lined up when Vronsky was Anna’s dream man but he wasn’t mentally ready to tell others that he was in love with her vs she was.
@@Hi-zr3ke when was he abusive with her ??? He didn’t love her but he respected her , he trusted her , he never cheated on her , never mistreated her but she decided to leave him with their son for her passionate love.
She was the architect of her own destruction so I didn’t feel sorry for her.
@@donrog5035 read the book the movie made him out to be a saint and her a villain she was the victim of society, mental health matters and no one gaf about her.The book proves that comment different...
@@AB-sm1qf Well that’s a long answer. But you know I study history to some extent and I know for sure the image we have about womenn in the past isn’t true. Women as men were active in society, both contributed to the wealth of their country. No country can develop and accumulate wealth if more than half of his population do nothing. Women work, in the field , they can run business like an inn , they work in different part of the industry. But legally, in taxes registers, the wealth of women were at the name of the male authority of the household. So today we have the impression that women weren’t an active part of society. For noble women or rich women they manage their big house or castle and it’s a huge work I mean even today people are paid to manage old castle, they have to host many events, sometimes help their husband to manage their business, etc... So you see women were more than just object than men can enjoy. In fact today or in the past there are some men who have a narrow minded view of women. So my first point is to tell you that society back then didn’t see women’s wellbeing in having nice things and look cute.
Now in every society women and men have their role to play . You can’t just do whatever the fuck you want. So when it comes to a married couple the wife has to obey to her husband and the husband has to take care and honor his wife (Christians values of the marriage). So they have both a role to play and rules to respect. Now they are nobles so that means that perhaps they married out of familial obligations rather than love but it was normal at the time marriage was never about love. It’s a very new perspective of marriage. I mean in many thousands years of history of mankind love marriage is the norm since 150 years at best. So it was normal in noble society they find love and passion with extra conjugal affairs. They just have to keep it quiet and don’t show it in public light. Men as women has to respect this rule. A men couldn’t abandon his wife and children to just live his love life with her lover. He would have been shunned for that. And it is the same for the women. What she did wasn’t about freedom, she was irresponsible. And I think even today if a man or woman does that he/she will not be seen in a positive light.
So yeah when you take the context of the time and even our current context what she did was wrong and she is the only one to blame for her downfall.
@@donrog5035 Of course women participated in labour, but it was mostly unpaid. Women did not own wealth, and their status in society was secondary. Those make all the difference. And so much for studying history when you believe gender roles (which are social constructs) are sacred. Also, please don't come with arguments of physiological differences between the sexes. All over the world, women do a disproportionately large share of physical labour, but get paid less, and have their capabilities still undermined. Having studied history, and the essential bit of anthropology, you should be knowing this already.
1:06 The original mannequin challenge.
I love this movie! and the ending is so fantastic!
It's from a Russian novel in the 19th century
No the ending don’t have a meaning , she just give up
I know that many of us wanted the movie to show more emotion from Vronsky when Anna died, but the entire movie was so much like poetry, I think the producers and writers wanted to show the first shock, then just their girl with her husband, just as Vronsky wouldn't exist anymore without her. 💔
Tbvh vronsky didn't have much emotions for her in the book as well
Imagine being so in love u let it ruin your life, no thanks.
@@yodadday8_1 Then learn to control them to save your life.
Be in lust not love, just be careful not to have AIDS.
My god, this makes my heart broken. I still can't put myself together after that scene :(
bir marşandiz yaklaşıyordu. ayaklarının altında toprak sallanır gibi oldu. kendisini yeniden trende sandı.
birden vronski'yi ilk tanıdığı gün trenin altında kalıp ezilen adamı hatırladı. ne yapması gerektiğini anlamıştı artık. raylara götüren merdiveni koşar adım indi. trenin geçeceği yerin yakınında durdu. vagonların alt kısımlarına, zincir ve vidalara baktı. ön ve arka tekerleklerin arasını tasarlamaya ve tam önünden geçeceği zamanı kestirmeye çalıştı.
Passion and love. Why we are alive.
Yes but make it lawful, and not cheating
i wish the movie was more detailed
the more i see this film the more details i realized; the scene at 1:18 when she’s about to reach the door she looks at the men near it who don’t even react to her so she opens the door- and then notice how the man just slowly breaks out of his role (which is to stand still) to look at her? he doesn’t stop her. I think the fact that some people notice her and do nothing makes her fall even more into dispare as if it’s like they aren’t even going to try to stop her from ending her life
sad end
This is my favorite book of all time. But this movie although really good just doesn't do the book justice. The imagery in the book is just so difficult to capture on film.
2:56
Oh God, FORGIVE ME!!
The 1997 version with Sophie Marceau and Sean Bean was so much better. Their chemistry was electrifying.
Felt so bad for her💔
I dont understand Vronsky part, why did he turned around?
It's a theatrical way of representing people's life: everyone knows everything and he comes to know of Anna's death
She should had known, that even she was a cruel and evil woman, she had 2 men that seriously loved her deeply. Not to mention her son too, that still considered her as the best (better than his loyal dad), eventho his mom prefer her secret lover than himself
Vronsky showed her erotic love, which Karenin could not. He showed her love through work and making money. A pious husband who adhered to the customs and traditions of the time. Anna has followed her desires and brought misery to herself and her family.
With This i understood the phrase of the beggining...
“Mine is the revenge i will pay
Okay but she would have looked way more mushed surely
It's not a horror film.
Brilliant movie in every way
Even he didnt cheat on her , he hadnt adapted his daughter .so upset
Because he killed him self
Can anyone tell me did she hallucinate the part when the other Princess in the carousel looked up at her and giggled on purpose to make her jealous/ mad? Or did it actually happen
I want to know that too!
Those are self-destructing imaginations that pop up in a weak state of mind.
can someone tell me when he asked her the first time before leaving if she had something she wanted to tell him and the second most important time when we see him through the mirror with watery eyes?
Like hear from her specific word or not ?
La mejor peli de keira
Read the book !!!!!!!
I feel a lot of pain. They want be happy. But the society of that time, don't want.. 😢
Anna karenina by leo tolestoy the beautiful story in the world. This movie is so amazing and I love 😍 this movie
Eu fiquei meio confusa no final mas logo entendi, quando vi a cena dela no trem não entendi exatamente mas no final do filme me dei conta, pensei que fosse só uma alucinação da Anna mas mulheres sempre tem certeza de suas paranóias pq homens não sabem mas desconfiamos de tudo sempre e sempre estamos certas, Quando ela está pensativa no trem, a cena que não entendi é agora sei, retrata se da Traição do Conde Vronsky com a Princesa Sorokina, pois ela era virgem e existe sangue nessa cena.
Me senti muito aflita e angustiada, chorei no final não pude crer que ele foi capaz de fazer isso mas tanto ele como ela nato tem muitos valores, sei que Anna a amava e ele talvez a amasse também em algum momento, não não sei se ambas atitudes justificam suas ações ….
The best version of this movie
so sadly
Versione molto poetica del meraviglioso capolavoro di Tolstoj
Molto commovente...❤
So beginning at 1:10, was she expecting the men to open the door for her?
I think yes,as it was the custom at that time. But they didn't and Anna felt it was because they had shunned her and thought of her as too low a disgrace for even basic courtesiesand that's why she is shown as angry and in tears as she opens the door herself
After reading I don't felt anything. But now this ...
who like KITTY more than ANNA..? Only me..
I thought she was annoying.
Kitty and Anna's characters basically progressed in opposite directions. Anna was originally the mature woman while Kitty was the helpless romantic. Kitty learned to mature overtime from Vronsky and now has a loving husband in Levin, while Anna gave up her life for a passionate and unstable love affair with Vronsky.
I sir !
In the beginning? Sure.
Kitty kind of lost her charm when she grew up, in my eyes. While I warmed up to Anna when she stopped being annoyingly perfect (or maybe it was the black dress).
I wish we knew how he reacted ??
in the book he is very depressed and doesn't forgive himself, he hates everyone and he thinks his life doesn't matter anymore, thats why decides to join the war
@@fjolle.8186 To kill himself too as to join her?
Dreams & Teddy Bears i think he felt really guilty of her death , even though he never really cheated on her or anything , she was actually being very “over-protective “ if I may say or “obsessing” over him, and he didn’t like of course and acted cold towards her after that. Tbh Anna Karenina’s character is quite confusing but loving at the same time.
@@fjolle.8186 iM CONFUSED wasn't anna upset because he was "going out" with that princess? so, basically cheating on Anna ?
playitsafe2 he wasn’t going out with her he was meeting his mother
No way that a body which was just hit by a train looks that unbruised
Le désespoir
0:53 literally gave me flashbacks to the time I remember my ex husband cheated on me, THAT SHIT REALLY DOES MAKE U WANNA GET HIT BY A TRAIN
Sorry 😔
I know , it feels as if you are being disemboweled with a blunt knife , hope you have managed to rebuild your life ❓💐
I haven't read the book, but I don't think Vronsky ever cheated on her(?)
yes he never cheated on her
What’s the song called? I really love the music
ruclips.net/video/HKRzDTgcr38/видео.html Anna's Last Train
Its sad that in the end death was the only way she could be free from her pain, I personally feel like she didn't really love that man what she loved was the passion that being with him brought, shes impulsive so she didn't think about the consequence of her actions she threw away her life for passion and it didnt make her happy, it was only a temporary satisfaction
Ağladım işte
At 1:00, is that Anna or is that someone Vronsky cheated with? I thought he didn’t cheat on her, she just suspected it?
She drank opium to help her cope which made her hallucinate
i guess he didnt cheat on her
He didn’t she hallucinated it
Such stiff and proper people!
These are the extracts.
Je suis tellement triste pour Vronsky qui l'aimait avec une telle ardeur ! et là elle se tue comme ça T.T...bon ok elle l'aimait aussi et souffrait des consequences mais je me sens tellement mal pour le gars...vraiment dommage qu'on ne voit pas sa reaction
Vronsky was just a womanizer who was getting bored of Anna, his death made him feel guilty. As with Dmitri Ivanovich Nekhlyudov in Resurrection by Tolstoy when what happened to his first crush Katyusha (Katerina Mikhailovna Maslova), made him feel remorse for his actions.
Remember how Prince Andrei was unfair to his wife Lise in war and peace and his death and made him feel remorse.
Natasha's regret faced breaking up with Andrei to escape with Anatole Kuragin. Guilt comes at the last moment and remorse for your choices.
Même pas un peu désolé pour Vronski et Anna. Ils étaient égoïstes et furent les architectes de leurs propres destructions
À notre époque, Anna aurait divorcé, aurait pu voir son fils et ne serait pas une paria de la société. Les conventions sociales me semblent plus blâmables qu'elle.
How is that Anna's body is still in one piece even after the train runs over her?
I would ran away with him.
They tried, a lot of times actually, it's just they were not able to handle living a life were people don't accepted them ( for example people in Europe refused them 'cause they were not married)
505 I also think she loved her children to much
Hi
2021: 2058
2:52 what does she say?
Lily-Rose Guerin "oh God forgive me" she immediately regrets jumping and tries to stand up but is hit by the wheels and instantly dies
Oh God, forgive me!
She said " Oh God forgive me " because she knew that she did a sin and asked God to forgive her .
someone please explain to me the ending when it showed her ex husband, her son, and her daughter . I had the idea they were in heaven since her son was sick but that wouldn't make any since as to why her husband or daughter would be there, i would figure her ex husband killed himself also and the daughter died when she drank alcohol in that one scene? I'm so confused lmfao
WHAT 😂 🤣 NO. Karenin did not kill himself. Her son was sick just once, and only from a cold. He was not in any danger of dying, and so he didn't die. Same for the husband. Why should Mr Karenin kill himself over his unfaithful cheater wife, who didn't deserve his love and devotion?! In both the book and the movie Anna was still married to Mr Karenin till she committed suicide. So any children she gave birth to were lawfully Mr Karenin's. In the book Vronsky couldn't deal with the guilt of driving Anna to her ruin, and he reenlisted in the army in the hope of dying in the war, so he could finally be free of his perpetual guilt by dying a heroic death in war. He was too immature to, and just plain didn't want to, raise his own child by his dead mistress, so in the books Vronsky gave his daughter Annie forever to Mr Karenin before going to get himself killed in war. In the movie, Vronsky and Anna left their daughter Annie with Karenin, to be a happy unburdened couple in France, and they never took baby Annie back when they returned to Russia. So when Anna killed herself and Vronsky went off on his suicide mission, Mr Karenin, who already had been raising Annie, and legally had her custody, continued to raise her as his own daughter with his son, because legally, as I explained above, he IS her legal father and only living parent. This scene simply shows that despite Anna's grave betrayal, Mr Karenin, their son and her daughter, are able to be a happy family together. He's clearly raising the kids well. Karenin, his son and his daughter have all gotten over Anna and Vronsky's hurtful actions, and are living the best life possible, as they should.
Karenin and Anna never got divorced, so he isn't her ex husband. He is, after her suicide, her widower.
Anna never married Vronsky, she was just his mistress in a long line of others. Anna died as Karenin's wife and Karenin's wife alone.
There's a reason the novel and all the movies based on it are titled Anna Karenina, not Anna Vronskaya.
@@ineffablegabe I hated Anna. I didn’t even feel sorry for her death. However I do feel empathy for his husband. Even if he didn’t love his wife he cared for her , he never cheated on her , never mistreated her but Anna decided to abandon him with their son and even her daughter she had with Vronski. For what ? LOVE ? PASSION ? What kind of love is this ? A love who cause harm to you and your loved ones, it isn’t love. It’s selfishness.
@@donrog5035 I fully agree!!! She and vronsky nearly ruined so many innocent lives, and all for what? They couldn't even be happy with each other in the end.
I’m so confused about the scene when the princess shows up and Vronsky goes with her. I’m not sure if it was real or Anna was hallucinating. I want to know that.
From what everyone was saying it’s a hallucination. He really was only getting papers from his mother who I don’t think wanted to be seen with and hoped he would date her. But Anna was paranoid she lost her status, her friends, and her children the ONLY thing she had was the love of an eligible good looking formerly known as a player may I add count. She didn’t feel safe with him and I think she also knew deep down that what goes around comes around
Moral: Never cheat your spouse
what do you think about adaptation with Vittoria Puccini. I think Vittoria is the best Anna!
Well, your actions have consequences
She could have thought what this would do to her kids.
She's a selfish woman tbh
well when you’re depressed and already thinking of suicide, you can’t help but feel miserable. you don’t call people like this “selfish”
Her ex wouldn’t let her see her son and she was to mentally unstable to know Annie. So honestly it didn’t affect them.
@@Thekawaiiasian101vid then you talk to someone , suicide is a coward and selfish act.
But she was already a selfish woman so her suicide is just logic
@@donrog5035 you have no understanding of how mental health works and to deem it as a selfish act is kind of low. I won't bother arguing about it. Doing some research really opens your eyes as to why suicidal people do the things that they do. Have a nice day, Don.
Why does her stomach hurt while sitting on the train?
She’s pregnant
@@ellam3702 she is?
If you’re in pain emotionally, your stomach is obviously gonna hurt
@@alinaespinoza8931 yes she is in the movie she gets pregnant from her affair with a count
Correct me if I’m wrong I don’t think she was pregnant I’m pretty sure the stomach pain was just a reference from the guy who was severed from the stomach when he died by train at the start of the movie.
0:11 what happenned ? Is she sick?
I think that's because she drank water with morphine, so she feels pain; yet I'm not 100% sure
mariasbanana it goes back to the foreshadow at the beginning of the story. Where that dude gets ran over by the train.
Поэтому и дом у меня разбился вчера 8 Мая раковина с трещеной 79 прослужила
Wow...looks like an old movie
Аня, Аня. Достоевский, тебя запретили кста
Can someone please explain this scene? Jist so I could compare it to my understanding😅
Anna can't stand the shame she created over her image for her adulter with Vronskij and she has an unjustified jealousy towards her lover, so she decides to commit suicide jumping off the railway. It's a chronicle fact happened in 1877 in Moscow, if I remember well: a woman killed herself under a train after a love affair bad ended; that inspired Tolstoj to make Anna die
@@ele_99 thank youuuu☺️
@@emperoralexei1872 you're welcome 😊
I saw the movie in Italian yesterday and I liked it very much. I always love Keira ❤
Keiraaaa😍
@@emperoralexei1872 have you seen Colette? And The nutcracker and the Fuor Realms? 😍
Did Vronsky really cheat on Anna or was that just her imagination?
Just her imagination
@@putriaulia9398 thank you
The director says it’s open to interpretation idk about the book though
@@magnolia4147 yeah, I haven't read the book either but thanks anyway :)
I don't know about the movie, but in the novel Vronskij had no interest whatsoever in other women or in leaving Anna. His love never wavered even in the lows of their relationship. He feels like his destiny is bound to hers in a marriage-like way, and there's no going back.
So vronsky did not cheat on her? Do someone knows that by a chance
Etleva Lafleur
He didn’t cheat on her. She hallucinated that part.
She was paranoid and depressed making it all up.
Quien el único escribió español
I didn't understand this ending. Can someone please explain?
Norman Brenes Anna killed herself because she thinks that she is a burden to Vronsky (and she thinks that he's cheating on her). She also cannot be seen in public because she is shamed. Her husband took custody of their children so she cannot see them either.
Thanks for the answer. I did understand that. I read the book, like 5 years ago, but I don't understand why is everyone like paralyzed in this movie. What's the purpose of that?
Norman Brenes the tableau part is (in my opinion) probably an artistic representation of how time stopped in Anna's mind. (meaning that she thinks that there's no future for her) Also, it is showing that Anna is alone, and that no one cares enough to stop her from killing herself
spelling english
Bianca Santos did vronsky cheated on her..
Дети под моим и Папиным Руководством Панова Михаила
For the pg ratings I get it, but if anyone wants to commit not alive like that, I'm pretty sure you'll end up looking like mush and not what was shown in this movie, suicide by train is a god awful way to go
well, the film is theatrical. and romance/drama at that, so any gore stuff is... toned down, i think?
жди...
Я не буду смотреть мне больно и страшно
0:58 someone explained me this part Why Alixes was the princess?
So basically Anna killed herself because she thought that Vronsky was cheating on her with another woman as seen on 0:58 but really she’s just mentally unstable and she was hallucinating.
Не ходи там Дьявол
Обираловка
Aïe, erk, crazy
Utterly unconvincing and forgettable. Sophie Marceau's Anna Karenina is the real deal.
2:57
Tired of being a poor puppet in the horror freak show that actually the Life is. Everyday i ask me a good reason for not do that
Is that kitty she sees kissing Vronsky I can't tell
No. It's Princess Sorokina (Cara Delevigne). She was the same girl in a cart who giggled while looking at Anna.
Vodka Flask Genie thank you I hadn’t watched but I have now but thx anyway
@@JollyWanker What a bitch, she did it on purpose to give Anna a false idea drive her towards the edge
It would have been a much better idea if Vronsky had abandoned Anna for her as it happened in the real story that inspired Tolstoy.
In the initial plan, Karenina was called Tatyana, and she parted with her life in the Neva. But a year before the start of work on the novel, in 1872, a tragedy happened in the family of Tolstoy's neighbor, Alexander Nikolaevich Bibikov, with whom they maintained good-neighborly relations and even started the construction of a distillery together. Anna Stepanovna Pirogova lived with Bibikov as common-law wife.
Recently, however, Bibikov began to give preference to the German governess of his children and even decided to marry her. When Anna Stepanovna found out about his betrayal, her jealousy crossed all boundaries. She ran away from home with a bundle of clothes, and for three days wandered around the area beside herself with grief. Before her death, she sent a letter to Bibikov: “You are my killer. Be happy if the killer can be happy at all. If you wish, you can see my corpse on the rails in Yasenki ”(station not far from Yasnaya Polyana). However, Bibikov did not read the letter, and the messenger returned it. Desperate Anna Stepanovna threw herself under a passing freight train.
The next day, Tolstoy went to the station when an autopsy was performed in the presence of a police inspector. He stood in the corner of the room and saw in every detail a woman's body lying on a marble table, bloodied and mutilated, with a smashed skull. And Bibikov, recovering from the shock, soon married his governess.
This is, so to speak, prehistory. Now let's re-read once again the description of the unfortunate heroine's suicide.
maneqin
challenge
She had it coming.
I hate the ending so much
The Sophie Marceau version is 1000 times better. Sean & her had amazing chemistry and her dead body at the station still makes me feel physically ill when I think about it. It was very intense 🤢😵
Best ending for a cheaters
It's just a movie but there is real ladies defend her awful horrible behaviour. This is not even a proper love story. They just love the revenge plot to the husband.
I would say its her fault. The ability to resist infidelity runs in the family it seems
Read the book i Love this novel my best Love Story novel... Leo tolstoy .. u will see the heart Inside.. of the story. U will Watch this all Time...all movie from this story
“From the streets did she emerge, to the streets she shall return return” Book of Niggalations 2:17 😂
Good acting but disappointing movie
Sorry but I didn't understand. She killed herself because of a MAN ?? Seriously? !
well not only because she thought he was cheating. she couldn’t even go out without getting shamed and criticized, her husband won custody etc. Also dont forget how badly women were treated in the 19th century.
No she didn't. Simple as that.
she died ?
Rina G yep
What do you think?
Well... what do you think?
It will be me soon...
Why mg
Hey, are you alright? Please tell me your alright.
I hope you alright
I hope you're okay.
People care about you.
Hope you are still here and that you are happy and found love and peace