Hey Zassar, Thank you for covering our game again and for the kind words in between. I do want to point out certain pointers that you missed covering in this video, I'll note them down since I am not going to make another reaction video this time: 1. We've announced that the first two games will be free of cost with no monetisation features in-game whatsoever. We are launching a total of 7 parts of the game, of which first two will be free and the remaining 5 will be paid. Also, even though we aim for a AAA quality game, we do realise that an Indie price point is what will work in our favour so that is very much our intent. 2. With regards to AO and SSAO, we have techniques in place to make the game much better looking but didn't get time to implement them during IGDC. Also, I believe perhaps your understanding of these technical aspects might be limited, which I understand, so please wait for further updates from us so we will be able to give a better looking build. Additionally, most of these features are also given to the player to tweak as per their likings since we are dealing with so much fragmentation in terms of PC specs for variety of players. 3. In terms of the demo feeling soulless, we had populated NPCs in the protagonist's home area and the mela. We will most certainly add more crowd to the game but that will differ based on areas. The area in between the home and fun fair area was a kind of an empty spot so thereby the crowd not being there was intentional. You will find diversity in areas in the game build in various areas though. 4. About the collisions part, of course that is something that we acknowledge is not finished. Since we are dealing with different areas and maps it becomes difficult for us to playtest each and every area and showcases like IGDC help us get that playtest feedback in place so we can improve it. During development we definitely try our level best to cover as many blind spots as possible but it is very difficult to cover all blind spots, which we encounter in gameplay as 'bugs'. Such gameplays being done in the wackiest way possible that try to break the game actually help us identify these blindspots. Companies like Rockstar Games and the biggies have large number of resources to test these things out. We are creating this game at the fraction of budget of what they have so such things are natural to come out during showcases, which actually help us get feedback and improve the game. 5. Thank you for the pointers you mentioned in the video, the game mechanics are definitely something we are striving hard to improve on. Especially the fighting mechanics. We plan to implement a unique and satisfying fighting system that we are currently working on that you will definitely love. I'm a gamer myself and have played a wide variety of games not just limited to GTA V but have also played Far Cry series, NFS series, Cult Of The Lamb, Assassins Creed and so on. Been gaming since my childhood so over 2 decades+ of gaming blood resides in me :) 6. Last, but definitely not the least, I believe a thank you from your side to me is long due as your channel has seen immense growth due to our game and as of now the first video you made on Mumbai Gullies is still the most watched video on your channel because of which your channel has grown. Wishing you all the best for your content ahead. Baaki do read all the comments on certain aspects of presentation style that other people have recommended to you, it will help you in the long run. Best, Nikhil Malankar
Are Nikhil Bhai, Mujhe Pata hai Ye Sab Chije Time Ke Sath Ye fix hojaengi ye sab maine video me bhi bataya hai but asli concern price ko leke hai jo maine video ke second part me kaha hai kyuki mechanics and graphics ye sab toh thik hi hojaenge but price waali chij bohot khatakne lagi . and don't worry about one special thing woh mai aap se personally milke kahunga because that thing is a very special moment . and haan mai apne aap ko bhi upgrade krne ki koshish kr rha hun tabhi is video mai or pehli video me bohot fark hai .
Bro zassar I understand that ur just giving criticism but the game is still in pre alpha, mocap is left, more detailing and many more things. About that Ao And ssao thing ofcourse the team of game Devs understand that better than you as you said you're only a gamer. Gameon knows what its doing so give it time pls.
Sir, U say u r making the game on a fraction of budget l, so sir u must know about HELLBLADE an indie game made by Ninja Theory. U should look at their graphics they are stunning and gmaplay is decent also.
@@zassar Are jab pata hai ye sab fix ho jayengi toh video banake mast views chaapo. Aur jo bhi points hai, aise bol raha hai ki jai Nikhil ko pata nai. 10 saal se game dev kar raha plus uske pehle se game khelne ka shauk hai. Matlab kuch bhi. Video ko controversial banake mast udd raha hai ladka. Aise hi desh aage badega. AO aur SSAO baat karke baada developer ban gaya ye na. Witcher aur Just Cause ke prices discounted hai jab launch hua tha uske prices dekh liyo. Mana ki duniya bhar ka game khel ke expectation badh gaya hai, Iska ye matlab nai hai ki, koi India mai start kar raha hai open world games for the first time, tu keh ke le raha hai. Kya matlab hai. Bade bade open world games jab chalu hue the tab aise hi start kiye the. Kuch bhi bolne se pehle soch toh le. Apna opinion de ke Views le ke nikal jao. Baaki log jaye paani mai.
I am extremely glad that I found your channel at the right time, I was never a PGP Player I always used to play different genres of games and by you I found our community of doing the same thing!! This honesty will help improve the game significantly just like last time I will support this game whole heartedly but I won't stand a mediocre game where I knew it could have been the best. ❤
Few Suggestions 1. they should provide a early access game 2. do not use DRM that deteriorates performance 3. aim for mastering gameplay mechanics rather than graphics 4. Make environment denser rather then huge 5. try to accomodate the various local languages, festivals and food in the game 6. explore TTS and AI for generating unimportant NPC dialogue 7. Extra wishlist - VR with AI but you can reply to NPC using microphone like skyrim mod - herika
They should definitely go for a Yakuza like approach instead of GTA. Yakuza always has small cities, many of them are the same used in multiple games, but they populate it with good content and make the environments dense and memorable. That's what they should go for imo.
One thing i would love you to include in the next feedback video is cinematics and GUI cuz they don't stand up to the standards and they play a big role in user experience
it's good to see someone is criticizing the game as Nikhil bhai himself said they require criticism as they become bias overtime. Some pathetic youtubers are dick riding insanely and they call themselves gaming journalists
My honest feedback: As you mentioned the mechanics feel like straight out of a 90mb mobile game, the player doesn't feel like he has got some weight, the fighting, player models and the environment(only at some areas) feel not that great. But i hope it will be fixed....
One thing they should fix the key aspect of 3rd person games, is the animations. They need a lot of work. Without good animations, the game feels very low standard. They also need to fix the framrate. India mein hardware he jo 30 fps se upper frames ke games chala sakhe 😅😅
Indian market is heavily based on mobile, for bigger platforms it's necessary to build a quality for global audience. All this need a lot time, expertise and experience.
Price point ko leke ekdum sahi kaha. agar mujhe RE4 remake jaisa game Rs.2500 me mil raha hai to main kyu is game ke liye Rs. 3000 kharch karu. Price should be between 500 to 1000. Or India me to sab pirate he karne wale hai. American ke prespective se dekho koi GTA SA jaisa game ke liye $50 nahi dega. chalo GTA definitive edition ke liye de diya but koi naya title ke liye nahi dega.
Mumbai gullies got more competition now as rockstar just announced a new GTA game ,GTA 6 game probably its they should take time and make ghe game ground breaking because it can change the gaming community in india
I doubt it considering most would have potato pcs or top end pcs where Ambient Occlusion would be disabled in potato pcs or cranked upto max in top end pcs until the highest preset without looking at the benefits. As someone with a mid-end pc, I look at every setting and know what they do.
@@speedforce8970 same but yea I have potato pc for gaming but I got remember every setting in game so that those setting which take high amount of gpu uagae and ram usage and didn't give much improvement in visual then I immediately turn it off and vice versa.
Bhai simple se baat hai Mumbai Gullies ka nam India se judda hua hai agar nai judda hota to gta4 iss se better hai jo sale me definitive edition 299₹ ka mil jata hai Mumbai Gullies mujhe personally impress nai kar pai and agar 1000-1500₹ se jyada ki aaii to nahi le paunga Mumbai Gullies ne bohot bohot disappoint Kiya bhai mujhe 🙏🙏🙏...(My personal Opinion)
You should seriously consider adopting a more respectful attitude. In India, there are gamers who are not only older but also more dedicated than you can imagine. They manage to maintain maturity and avoid insulting others. It's crucial to acknowledge the diverse demographics in our country and understand that not everyone can afford to be a console or PC gamer. The mobile gaming industry in India has seen significant growth due to its accessibility, along with RUclipsrs streaming popular games. Consequently, many kids and new-age gamers are primarily exposed to these titles. You can educate them but insulting is not a way to make things work. I, personally, have been gaming on PC for the past 30 years, and I'm aware of individuals who have been gaming since the 1980s. Some of us have invested in high-end rigs with components like the 4090, but we don't feel the need to boast about it or take pride in playing on a PC while others use mobile devices. Such an attitude is rather immature. There are more respectful ways to express your opinions, without resorting to insults. Now, concerning "Mumbai Gullies," it appears that the game requires significant improvements. Both the graphics and gameplay currently seem inadequate to compete with AAA or even AA games. If the game were to be priced as an indie title, around $15-20 USD, it might be a different story. By the way SSAO is inferior AO tech at this point, HBAO+,Fidelity FX CACAO and RTAO are the superior forms of AO in modern AAA games.
Zassar Bhai Ek Baat Bata Yrr Jaise tune bhi Build Dekha hoga maine dekha toh mujhe Aisa laga ki kuch Naya ni hai yrr Mtlb jaise Watch Dogs Mai Futuristic Thoda....sleeping dogs mai game mechanics aur fighting mechanics ...Mafia ka vintage style Aur baaki open world games mai kuch special hai Mtlb woh Kisi mechanic ke liye famous hai toh agar Mumbai gullies mai kuch Naya innovative Ya kuch special bana Diya jata hai phatt jayega Global Market Mai According To Me .... Bakki love bhai You are representing us ❤❤❤
Pls review Project Madras i recently discovered about it and would love to know your opinion about it. It's a pc game under development like Mumbai gullies and GTA but I think it would turn out better than Mumbai gullies. 😊
In my opinion, they should to keep Mumbai gullies as original and unique as possible rather than calling it Indian GTA. People in India who wanna try this out will try it anyways even if the word GTA is not included. And you're absolutely correct brother. If Mumbai gullies wants to compete, it has to be good moreover at a competitive price point if it wants to capture international market. And i think its a good start at this time cause AAA titles(ex Forsbroken, pew pew wars) have disappointed the gamer community and so people are trying more and more indie games and games as well as the ones from small studios.
Bhai, mumbai gullies ke creator ne kbhi bhi iss game ko "INDIAN GTA" claim kiyaa hi nahi Nikhil always asks his viewers to embrace the originality of this game rather than comparing it from the products of the big budget studios Ye to typical indian youtubers hai jo attention gain karne ke liye thumbnail mai baar baar GTA ka reference dete hai.
According to me the game feels a little bit fortnitish and a little bit blant like not so immersive but if I look at it overall this game is improving and slowly its getting soulfull instead of soulless
bhai bilkul sahi points nikaale ho... indian gaming market is just trash...iss market main game bikna bahut mushkil hai bahut kam kam log hain jo kabhi games buy karte hain actually.. most times pirate hoti hain ya kisi ek bande se chaar paanch bando mai felti hai....foriegn mai bik sakti hai but competition bahut zyada hai...... abhi kuchh time pehle saints row ka nya game bhi aaya tha... naye gameplay mechanics and feel ke saath with satrting price of like 1500 i guess but ab jaake dekhoge to bahut kam ho gya hai kyonki game was not good and people just didnt bought it and forgot about it... mere hisaab se kuchh or cheezien iss game main add ho jayien jo indian feel deta hai to game will blend even more i=with indian culture like....i might sound silly here but a option to do a chant or puja whenever a temple comes or character just pray or nods the head whenever comes across a temple here like the game SLEEPING DOGS where u can visit shrines and get health for praying in between of a fight XD...but cool concept just saying...
developers khud mumbai gullies ko mumbai gullies maante hi nahi hai, 'indian gta' maante hai. saara focus unke demo mein is baat pe hai ki wo dekho hindi likhi hui hai billboard pe! fir log comment karte hai, "INdIa mEentIOned?😳😳😳 RAAAAAHHHHHHHHH 🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣ProudD TO Be IndIAn🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩".
I just found out that gta 6's trailer is about to get released somewhere like next week, this poses a threat to mumbai gullies now, if they would not be able to provide similar quality to even gta 5 then i think all hype of mumbai gullies will be gone in like just matter of days. Now no matter when mumbai gullies will be released only gta 6 will rule the web for like next five years.
First the first, guys ALAN WAKE 2, isska prize bhi 2700 hai, and that game is literally next gen, RDR2 ke baad agar koi next gen bolu toh ALAN WAKE 2 hi hoga, and zassar you r absolutely right, bro bhara ke market me toh bohot hi jyada competition hai.
1:40 I'd prefer HBAO also it needs better PBR implementation, better scaling of assets and better use of lumen also yes,, when it comes to actual spending we should be seen as a market of 80 million people with as much growth potential as China, NOT as a market of 1 biillion people
1:55 attitude deko bhai ki 😂 haa bhai me bi hate karta hu audience par fir bi game ko nahi.. SSAO kya ade log ko FPS k matlab nahi pata hota uska kya matlab ki o game nahi khelega.. Whaa 📉 O hota hai na bachpan me jo 10 game khel k 9 game khelne bale ko bolta tha ki tu kya janta hai gaming me 😂
Mumbai gullies mein abhi bhi jo problems what I found after watching igdc clip 1. Vehicle driving mechanics 2. Shooting mechanics 3. Object collision what you pointed out 4. walk and run mechanocs want smooth and realistic I support Nikhil Sir, hope you will improve it soon
I absolutely and totally agree with each and every point you mentioned about the game in this video. But there is one thing about you. There are some words you use and the way you use them seem very inappropriate. Although I love all the knowledge and facts you provide but I am not able to ignore those things and it sorta created a negative impact on me. I still wish you the best and keep making these kind of videos because the Indian audience don't event wanna experience how beautiful the world of gaming actually is and you are trying your best to educate them about it. So Thank You for that!
Bhai mai ek mobile lekin har genre ke game try karta hu aap ne sahi bola mobile pe bhi bht hee ache ache game hai lekin logo ko ek doo hee game dhek the hai totally agree with your point I don't have pc per one will buy and buy and play it on pc I don't I'm mobile user consider my self as a hardcore gamer but i love to play games besides only bgmi and other
Agree with your points bro, just hope that they take the feedback from the actual gaming community and work on their game, they can take as much time as they want, we just want a good game which is finished and optimized unlike some recent "big AAA games" we have seen this year. Fingers crossed🤞 And btw, bro have u played spider-man 2 yet? If yes, when are we getting spider-man 2's review? Though i have already played the game, but your reviews are just🤌
i mean they do have alot of time to improve, what they showcased is an early early prototype, and it's obvious theyre still working on the mechanics, it'll take time to improve and we can definitely see new improvements the next time they'll reveal the footage
I need that Mumbai Gullies International Audience ke Benchmark ke Level se Upar ki Hu kyuki In India Mostly Less Audiences is of PC, So if Games goes Hype in International Market, Then can the Game Can recover its cost.
Excellent Video, I hope Nikhil Sir bhi yeh video ko dekhke isko positively le. Mai bhi ek solo game dev hu so mai yaha pe apna prespective rakhna chahata hu. (3 Category mai) 1) The Assets department have done wonderful Job uske liye 100 marks hai jinhone ne bhi like Environment aur Characters banaya hai unhone acha kaam kiya hai. (Good thing) 2) I think gameplay ka itna masla nhi hai, main reason I'm surprised ki aapne bhi apne video pe miss kardiya ki game abhi bhi properly Optimized nhi hai. It should feel smooth but game bahut lag kar rahi hai because game have low fps and I'm pretty much sure ki Nikhil Sir ke pass Latest High Budget PC hogi toh agar unke PC mai itna lag kar rahi hai toh hum jaiso ka kya hoga. So kuch karo naa karo optimize phele karo game ko. (Must be done Asap) 3) Game mai kuch minor bugs, souless NPC behaviour, Animations inko thoda aur acha kar sakte ho. (Should be in to do list)
UE5 inko use nahi karna chahiye tha, UE4 se ye ek decent game bana sakte thee jaise ki Kena bridge of spirits. UE5 abhi new hai aur devs ko itni knowledge nahi ki kaise isko dhang se use kiya jaye par UE4 ki knowledge 10 saal se hai toh optimization aur graphics dono zyada easy hoti.
@@speedforce8970 Exactly, Yeh maine last time mention kiya tha. But abb kya kar sakte hai unhone toh yeh kardiya toh maine bhi socha ki baar baar same jeez kyu bole abb.
Animations are still broken ;[ Please add facial expression it will improve the cutscenes and gameplay and also give us an immersive experince. And cutscene starting/triggering looks horrible please add blackbars up and down and blend the game world with it so the cutscenes feel like a movie and the game and cutscenes blend together just like rdr2.
I definitely appreciate the improvement but definitely there is lot of improvements to do... My suggestion to game ion that take enough time but make the game high quality
bhai baat to 95% sahi hai but ha vo log abhi naye hai aur vo try kar rahe hai ki game ko aur better banaya jaa sake, unko jitna time lena hai utna le 1 saal aur lele lekin achi game banaye, jo aaj ke gaming standard ke hisab se ho nahi to ye sahi main galliyon tak he rehe jayegi
Game bura biklul bhi nahi hai, bass animation merge karna hai and optimization pe kaam karna hai. Game bilkul bhi polished nahi hai, I hope next year launch na ho... Chahiye toh 2 saal lelo and accha game launch karo. And imo price should be in between 1000 to 2000rs
True bro thanks for your review. I am ready to pay for a polished game rather than wasting time and money on an unfinished game. Remember what happened with Cyberpunk 2077. Look at GTA VI trailer and you guys would come to know what actually a game is.
#mumbaigullies atleast improve the character movement bcos it looks very arcade. take your time to complete and improve. don't loose on story of the game. graphics can be improved time to time by update but not the story and first impressions.
btw zassar bhai pls make a video on mumbai gullies gameplay again. the first gameplay showcase they did of that jail,street,slums that was perfect. from walking,running etc. if u agree with me pls make a video on it so that nikhil bhai can see it. that was perfect game mechanics for walking and running. and the sound of walking running was also perfect. i know graphics will be improved but mechanics i am still scared. first the said the character will be in side of the screen but then changed it and put in in middle. they totally dont have a proper mindset. and tell them to take time and make the game, no rush needed. if the game is good it will attreact people in future as well. if not a video pls text him personally. pls give a heart so that i know u read this. its too long i am sorry.
This looks like a very very early version of the game, im pretty sure they are not using the best features of UE5 because they are targeting an audience which doesn't have alot of gpu power to run the latest features.
Then they won't have an audience at all unless they sell the game at 200 rupees because even, I can't bear with low quality graphics. I'll maybe buy it, but I'll never play it and enjoy it besides, if you don't have a good pc, you shouldn't expect games to be made for you and for foreigners, no one would buy it because they would see it as a cheap low effort game. Trust me, if they put in effort and make this a good indie title, people outside of India will take notice and would give it a chance more than the people here.
@@speedforce8970 They'll have to work hard for it, this looks like it's at an extremely early stage and alot of things have to be implemented. Specially if they are aiming for realism then they have to work more. GTA still has a stylized look, but the game really looks beautiful on its own. Cyberpunk 2077 is also very neon-y and futuristic style and has great textures etc, if it has to compete with those type of games then it would easily take their team 4-5 years.
I think he said everything that the actual PC gamer thought after watching that gameplay And one thing u would like to add would be that :- story must be insanely good because other companies have the graphics team that gameon can not afford but in india we have some insane witers that are not that expensive Lets use our strengths
personally mujhe laga hai Nikhil bhia ko little nightmares,stray, raji jaisa game banana chahiye tha jo story me jyada focus kare naki gta jaisa or 10$-20$ me bahar bhi sale kar lete q ki india me sabhi games studios mbl games banane ka exp hai na ki gta jaisa game banane ka exp
Gta 6 agle saal yaa fir 2025 tal launch ho Jayega fir ussi ka market impact rahega 5-9 saal tak usi ke wajah mumbai gullies ko aagle saal tak launch karna hoga ke isse Market mein hype mile
@@kyro3168maine bhi yahi kaha ki jisko multiple games khelna hota h wo khelte hi h maine sabko include nhai kiya h gta jaise games ko hamaare yaha hi had se jada milk kiya jata h
bro one thing there is another made in india aaa game which is project madras which is way better than mumbai gullies plz talk about that game this game is set in chennai and its trailer is launched a year ago now thay have uplouded another video of that.
Every word was true, the game doesnt feels like it was made in unreal engine 5, it felt like something was missing btw just cause 3 abhi bhi 60 mil rhi hai kya ?
Guys yeh hate nhi dara sirf nikhil sir ko wo suggestions dara and nikhil sir na pehele bhi bola tha wo chata hai ki log khud una hama critize karo takki unko bhi pata chala kha improvements a sakti hai ❤
Hey Zassar,
Thank you for covering our game again and for the kind words in between. I do want to point out certain pointers that you missed covering in this video, I'll note them down since I am not going to make another reaction video this time:
1. We've announced that the first two games will be free of cost with no monetisation features in-game whatsoever. We are launching a total of 7 parts of the game, of which first two will be free and the remaining 5 will be paid. Also, even though we aim for a AAA quality game, we do realise that an Indie price point is what will work in our favour so that is very much our intent.
2. With regards to AO and SSAO, we have techniques in place to make the game much better looking but didn't get time to implement them during IGDC. Also, I believe perhaps your understanding of these technical aspects might be limited, which I understand, so please wait for further updates from us so we will be able to give a better looking build. Additionally, most of these features are also given to the player to tweak as per their likings since we are dealing with so much fragmentation in terms of PC specs for variety of players.
3. In terms of the demo feeling soulless, we had populated NPCs in the protagonist's home area and the mela. We will most certainly add more crowd to the game but that will differ based on areas. The area in between the home and fun fair area was a kind of an empty spot so thereby the crowd not being there was intentional. You will find diversity in areas in the game build in various areas though.
4. About the collisions part, of course that is something that we acknowledge is not finished. Since we are dealing with different areas and maps it becomes difficult for us to playtest each and every area and showcases like IGDC help us get that playtest feedback in place so we can improve it. During development we definitely try our level best to cover as many blind spots as possible but it is very difficult to cover all blind spots, which we encounter in gameplay as 'bugs'. Such gameplays being done in the wackiest way possible that try to break the game actually help us identify these blindspots. Companies like Rockstar Games and the biggies have large number of resources to test these things out. We are creating this game at the fraction of budget of what they have so such things are natural to come out during showcases, which actually help us get feedback and improve the game.
5. Thank you for the pointers you mentioned in the video, the game mechanics are definitely something we are striving hard to improve on. Especially the fighting mechanics. We plan to implement a unique and satisfying fighting system that we are currently working on that you will definitely love. I'm a gamer myself and have played a wide variety of games not just limited to GTA V but have also played Far Cry series, NFS series, Cult Of The Lamb, Assassins Creed and so on. Been gaming since my childhood so over 2 decades+ of gaming blood resides in me :)
6. Last, but definitely not the least, I believe a thank you from your side to me is long due as your channel has seen immense growth due to our game and as of now the first video you made on Mumbai Gullies is still the most watched video on your channel because of which your channel has grown. Wishing you all the best for your content ahead. Baaki do read all the comments on certain aspects of presentation style that other people have recommended to you, it will help you in the long run.
Best,
Nikhil Malankar
Are Nikhil Bhai, Mujhe Pata hai Ye Sab Chije Time Ke Sath Ye fix hojaengi ye sab maine video me bhi bataya hai but asli concern price ko leke hai jo maine video ke second part me kaha hai kyuki mechanics and graphics ye sab toh thik hi hojaenge but price waali chij bohot khatakne lagi .
and don't worry about one special thing woh mai aap se personally milke kahunga because that thing is a very special moment .
and haan mai apne aap ko bhi upgrade krne ki koshish kr rha hun tabhi is video mai or pehli video me bohot fark hai .
Bro zassar I understand that ur just giving criticism but the game is still in pre alpha, mocap is left, more detailing and many more things. About that Ao And ssao thing ofcourse the team of game Devs understand that better than you as you said you're only a gamer. Gameon knows what its doing so give it time pls.
Sir, U say u r making the game on a fraction of budget l, so sir u must know about HELLBLADE an indie game made by Ninja Theory. U should look at their graphics they are stunning and gmaplay is decent also.
@@zassar Are jab pata hai ye sab fix ho jayengi toh video banake mast views chaapo. Aur jo bhi points hai, aise bol raha hai ki jai Nikhil ko pata nai. 10 saal se game dev kar raha plus uske pehle se game khelne ka shauk hai. Matlab kuch bhi. Video ko controversial banake mast udd raha hai ladka. Aise hi desh aage badega. AO aur SSAO baat karke baada developer ban gaya ye na. Witcher aur Just Cause ke prices discounted hai jab launch hua tha uske prices dekh liyo. Mana ki duniya bhar ka game khel ke expectation badh gaya hai, Iska ye matlab nai hai ki, koi India mai start kar raha hai open world games for the first time, tu keh ke le raha hai. Kya matlab hai. Bade bade open world games jab chalu hue the tab aise hi start kiye the. Kuch bhi bolne se pehle soch toh le. Apna opinion de ke Views le ke nikal jao. Baaki log jaye paani mai.
@@xenopholis47 bas ek baat bolunga tere jaise ke karan Faug games bani thi
I am extremely glad that I found your channel at the right time, I was never a PGP Player I always used to play different genres of games and by you I found our community of doing the same thing!!
This honesty will help improve the game significantly just like last time
I will support this game whole heartedly but I won't stand a mediocre game where I knew it could have been the best.
❤
Few Suggestions
1. they should provide a early access game
2. do not use DRM that deteriorates performance
3. aim for mastering gameplay mechanics rather than graphics
4. Make environment denser rather then huge
5. try to accomodate the various local languages, festivals and food in the game
6. explore TTS and AI for generating unimportant NPC dialogue
7. Extra wishlist - VR with AI but you can reply to NPC using microphone like skyrim mod - herika
They should definitely go for a Yakuza like approach instead of GTA. Yakuza always has small cities, many of them are the same used in multiple games, but they populate it with good content and make the environments dense and memorable. That's what they should go for imo.
what's drm?
One thing i would love you to include in the next feedback video is cinematics and GUI cuz they don't stand up to the standards and they play a big role in user experience
it's good to see someone is criticizing the game as Nikhil bhai himself said they require criticism as they become bias overtime. Some pathetic youtubers are dick riding insanely and they call themselves gaming journalists
Kitne criticism de Bhai. Pura game hi tatti hai
it doesn't look as good to me but bro ik they'll improve over time @@bendover-bz4bc
when I was a child I pirated many games unknowningly but now as an adult I happy to see my purchased game collection.
My honest feedback:
As you mentioned the mechanics feel like straight out of a 90mb mobile game, the player doesn't feel like he has got some weight, the fighting, player models and the environment(only at some areas) feel not that great. But i hope it will be fixed....
Bhai ye chize game ke launch se just phele fix hota hai
One thing they should fix the key aspect of 3rd person games, is the animations. They need a lot of work. Without good animations, the game feels very low standard.
They also need to fix the framrate. India mein hardware he jo 30 fps se upper frames ke games chala sakhe 😅😅
Indian market is heavily based on mobile, for bigger platforms it's necessary to build a quality for global audience. All this need a lot time, expertise and experience.
Price point ko leke ekdum sahi kaha. agar mujhe RE4 remake jaisa game Rs.2500 me mil raha hai to main kyu is game ke liye Rs. 3000 kharch karu.
Price should be between 500 to 1000. Or India me to sab pirate he karne wale hai. American ke prespective se dekho koi GTA SA jaisa game ke liye $50 nahi dega. chalo GTA definitive edition ke liye de diya but koi naya title ke liye nahi dega.
Mumbai gullies got more competition now as rockstar just announced a new GTA game ,GTA 6 game probably its they should take time and make ghe game ground breaking because it can change the gaming community in india
I think Gta users know what is ambient occlusion well 😅
I doubt it considering most would have potato pcs or top end pcs where Ambient Occlusion would be disabled in potato pcs or cranked upto max in top end pcs until the highest preset without looking at the benefits. As someone with a mid-end pc, I look at every setting and know what they do.
@@speedforce8970 same but yea I have potato pc for gaming but I got remember every setting in game so that those setting which take high amount of gpu uagae and ram usage and didn't give much improvement in visual then I immediately turn it off and vice versa.
Bhai simple se baat hai Mumbai Gullies ka nam India se judda hua hai agar nai judda hota to gta4 iss se better hai jo sale me definitive edition 299₹ ka mil jata hai Mumbai Gullies mujhe personally impress nai kar pai and agar 1000-1500₹ se jyada ki aaii to nahi le paunga Mumbai Gullies ne bohot bohot disappoint Kiya bhai mujhe 🙏🙏🙏...(My personal Opinion)
Arey bhai 2025 ki release hai kyu roo raha hai, ho jayega game bhadiya, feedback par work toh kar rahe hai na
Improvement chalu h abhi final build nhi h feedback dete rho demotivated nhi
Bhai gta 4 ki audience western
Woh dolaar mai kamate hain
Woh India mai 100 ka bhi beche toh bhi loss nahi hai
Don't compare gta 4 with this game gta 4 is miles better
Bro team bhi vesi hi thi n gta 4 k liye bhot antar he bhai
You should seriously consider adopting a more respectful attitude. In India, there are gamers who are not only older but also more dedicated than you can imagine. They manage to maintain maturity and avoid insulting others. It's crucial to acknowledge the diverse demographics in our country and understand that not everyone can afford to be a console or PC gamer. The mobile gaming industry in India has seen significant growth due to its accessibility, along with RUclipsrs streaming popular games. Consequently, many kids and new-age gamers are primarily exposed to these titles. You can educate them but insulting is not a way to make things work.
I, personally, have been gaming on PC for the past 30 years, and I'm aware of individuals who have been gaming since the 1980s. Some of us have invested in high-end rigs with components like the 4090, but we don't feel the need to boast about it or take pride in playing on a PC while others use mobile devices. Such an attitude is rather immature. There are more respectful ways to express your opinions, without resorting to insults.
Now, concerning "Mumbai Gullies," it appears that the game requires significant improvements. Both the graphics and gameplay currently seem inadequate to compete with AAA or even AA games. If the game were to be priced as an indie title, around $15-20 USD, it might be a different story.
By the way SSAO is inferior AO tech at this point, HBAO+,Fidelity FX CACAO and RTAO are the superior forms of AO in modern AAA games.
Zassar Bhai Ek Baat Bata Yrr Jaise tune bhi Build Dekha hoga maine dekha toh mujhe Aisa laga ki kuch Naya ni hai yrr Mtlb jaise Watch Dogs Mai Futuristic Thoda....sleeping dogs mai game mechanics aur fighting mechanics ...Mafia ka vintage style Aur baaki open world games mai kuch special hai Mtlb woh Kisi mechanic ke liye famous hai toh agar Mumbai gullies mai kuch Naya innovative Ya kuch special bana Diya jata hai phatt jayega Global Market Mai According To Me ....
Bakki love bhai You are representing us ❤❤❤
Pls review Project Madras i recently discovered about it and would love to know your opinion about it. It's a pc game under development like Mumbai gullies and GTA but I think it would turn out better than Mumbai gullies. 😊
Ek mera suggestion hai sbko ki gameplay 1080p pe dekhna
Ambient occlusion is present in GTA v
yhi toh baat hai unhe ye sab pata nhi hota 😢
In my opinion, they should to keep Mumbai gullies as original and unique as possible rather than calling it Indian GTA. People in India who wanna try this out will try it anyways even if the word GTA is not included.
And you're absolutely correct brother. If Mumbai gullies wants to compete, it has to be good moreover at a competitive price point if it wants to capture international market.
And i think its a good start at this time cause AAA titles(ex Forsbroken, pew pew wars) have disappointed the gamer community and so people are trying more and more indie games and games as well as the ones from small studios.
Bhai, mumbai gullies ke creator ne kbhi bhi iss game ko "INDIAN GTA" claim kiyaa hi nahi
Nikhil always asks his viewers to embrace the originality of this game rather than comparing it from the products of the big budget studios
Ye to typical indian youtubers hai jo attention gain karne ke liye thumbnail mai baar baar GTA ka reference dete hai.
According to me the game feels a little bit fortnitish and a little bit blant like not so immersive but if I look at it overall this game is improving and slowly its getting soulfull instead of soulless
Bhai project Madras bhi dekho, woh bhi bahut ambitious game hai jo development mei hai..
bhai bilkul sahi points nikaale ho... indian gaming market is just trash...iss market main game bikna bahut mushkil hai bahut kam kam log hain jo kabhi games buy karte hain actually.. most times pirate hoti hain ya kisi ek bande se chaar paanch bando mai felti hai....foriegn mai bik sakti hai but competition bahut zyada hai......
abhi kuchh time pehle saints row ka nya game bhi aaya tha... naye gameplay mechanics and feel ke saath with satrting price of like 1500 i guess but ab jaake dekhoge to bahut kam ho gya hai kyonki game was not good and people just didnt bought it and forgot about it... mere hisaab se kuchh or cheezien iss game main add ho jayien jo indian feel deta hai to game will blend even more i=with indian culture like....i might sound silly here but a option to do a chant or puja whenever a temple comes or character just pray or nods the head whenever comes across a temple here like the game SLEEPING DOGS where u can visit shrines and get health for praying in between of a fight XD...but cool concept just saying...
The main problem is the budget and man power(efficiency). We can't have both in india. Hence, Nikhil is cannot be claimed responsible for the things.
developers khud mumbai gullies ko mumbai gullies maante hi nahi hai, 'indian gta' maante hai. saara focus unke demo mein is baat pe hai ki wo dekho hindi likhi hui hai billboard pe! fir log comment karte hai, "INdIa mEentIOned?😳😳😳 RAAAAAHHHHHHHHH 🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣ProudD TO Be IndIAn🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩".
That line on 4:10 was correct
I just found out that gta 6's trailer is about to get released somewhere like next week, this poses a threat to mumbai gullies now, if they would not be able to provide similar quality to even gta 5 then i think all hype of mumbai gullies will be gone in like just matter of days. Now no matter when mumbai gullies will be released only gta 6 will rule the web for like next five years.
Gta 5 level quality?
You are expecting too much
Even modern AAA titles couldn't do that
First the first, guys ALAN WAKE 2, isska prize bhi 2700 hai, and that game is literally next gen, RDR2 ke baad agar koi next gen bolu toh ALAN WAKE 2 hi hoga, and zassar you r absolutely right, bro bhara ke market me toh bohot hi jyada competition hai.
I believe if they will not rush in process than they can create a HISTORY 🙂
1:40 I'd prefer HBAO also it needs better PBR implementation, better scaling of assets and better use of lumen
also yes,, when it comes to actual spending we should be seen as a market of 80 million people with as much growth potential as China, NOT as a market of 1 biillion people
1:55 attitude deko bhai ki 😂 haa bhai me bi hate karta hu audience par fir bi game ko nahi.. SSAO kya ade log ko FPS k matlab nahi pata hota uska kya matlab ki o game nahi khelega.. Whaa 📉
O hota hai na bachpan me jo 10 game khel k 9 game khelne bale ko bolta tha ki tu kya janta hai gaming me 😂
Mumbai gullies mein abhi bhi jo problems what I found after watching igdc clip
1. Vehicle driving mechanics
2. Shooting mechanics
3. Object collision what you pointed out
4. walk and run mechanocs want smooth and realistic
I support Nikhil Sir, hope you will improve it soon
I absolutely and totally agree with each and every point you mentioned about the game in this video. But there is one thing about you. There are some words you use and the way you use them seem very inappropriate. Although I love all the knowledge and facts you provide but I am not able to ignore those things and it sorta created a negative impact on me. I still wish you the best and keep making these kind of videos because the Indian audience don't event wanna experience how beautiful the world of gaming actually is and you are trying your best to educate them about it. So Thank You for that!
Bhai mai ek mobile lekin har genre ke game try karta hu aap ne sahi bola mobile pe bhi bht hee ache ache game hai lekin logo ko ek doo hee game dhek the hai totally agree with your point I don't have pc per one will buy and buy and play it on pc I don't I'm mobile user consider my self as a hardcore gamer but i love to play games besides only bgmi and other
Glad To See Gaming Critic Bhai Ab Movies Toh Improve Nahi Huee Hopefully Indian Gaming Developments Me Kuchh sudhar aajae
TBH Mumbai Gullies lack cinematics and camera movement was so trash. They should work on it
Agree with your points bro, just hope that they take the feedback from the actual gaming community and work on their game, they can take as much time as they want, we just want a good game which is finished and optimized unlike some recent "big AAA games" we have seen this year. Fingers crossed🤞
And btw, bro have u played spider-man 2 yet? If yes, when are we getting spider-man 2's review? Though i have already played the game, but your reviews are just🤌
spider-man 2 mai khel nhi skta , don't have ps5
@@zassar oh i thought you played the game because i saw its gameplay in your recent videos,
@@darwingamer4570 the gameplay was taken from rajmangaminghd
@@zassar oh ok bro
@@zassarus bhai us but busy playing alan wake 2
i mean they do have alot of time to improve, what they showcased is an early early prototype, and it's obvious theyre still working on the mechanics, it'll take time to improve and we can definitely see new improvements the next time they'll reveal the footage
Bro your words are harsh but 100% true. Hope Nikhil sir watch your video
I need that Mumbai Gullies International Audience ke Benchmark ke Level se Upar ki Hu kyuki In India Mostly Less Audiences is of PC,
So if Games goes Hype in International Market, Then can the Game Can recover its cost.
People who think mobile gaming is NOT real gaming
👇
Mobile gaming is for fun bro
Bro please also make a video on project Madras it is also a open world GTA type game
Running train simulator pls review about this bro love your video ❤
If GTA6 is launched next year then it's ggs for Mumbai gullies😂😂
Good Job Zassar Bhai... With your help I can watch interesting things in future🤩🤩🤩
u earned a subscribe , keep being brutally true bro
Excellent Video, I hope Nikhil Sir bhi yeh video ko dekhke isko positively le. Mai bhi ek solo game dev hu so mai yaha pe apna prespective rakhna chahata hu. (3 Category mai)
1) The Assets department have done wonderful Job uske liye 100 marks hai jinhone ne bhi like Environment aur Characters banaya hai unhone acha kaam kiya hai. (Good thing)
2) I think gameplay ka itna masla nhi hai, main reason I'm surprised ki aapne bhi apne video pe miss kardiya ki game abhi bhi properly Optimized nhi hai. It should feel smooth but game bahut lag kar rahi hai because game have low fps and I'm pretty much sure ki Nikhil Sir ke pass Latest High Budget PC hogi toh agar unke PC mai itna lag kar rahi hai toh hum jaiso ka kya hoga. So kuch karo naa karo optimize phele karo game ko. (Must be done Asap)
3) Game mai kuch minor bugs, souless NPC behaviour, Animations inko thoda aur acha kar sakte ho. (Should be in to do list)
UE5 inko use nahi karna chahiye tha, UE4 se ye ek decent game bana sakte thee jaise ki Kena bridge of spirits. UE5 abhi new hai aur devs ko itni knowledge nahi ki kaise isko dhang se use kiya jaye par UE4 ki knowledge 10 saal se hai toh optimization aur graphics dono zyada easy hoti.
@@speedforce8970 Exactly, Yeh maine last time mention kiya tha. But abb kya kar sakte hai unhone toh yeh kardiya toh maine bhi socha ki baar baar same jeez kyu bole abb.
you can take inspiration from mafia series. best story, gameplay and graphics all together
Animations are still broken ;[
Please add facial expression it will improve the cutscenes and gameplay and also give us an immersive experince.
And cutscene starting/triggering looks horrible please add blackbars up and down and blend the game world with it so the cutscenes feel like a movie and the game and cutscenes blend together just like rdr2.
I definitely appreciate the improvement but definitely there is lot of improvements to do... My suggestion to game ion that take enough time but make the game high quality
bhai baat to 95% sahi hai but ha vo log abhi naye hai aur vo try kar rahe hai ki game ko aur better banaya jaa sake, unko jitna time lena hai utna le 1 saal aur lele lekin achi game banaye, jo aaj ke gaming standard ke hisab se ho nahi to ye sahi main galliyon tak he rehe jayegi
And he's on it again😂
Game bura biklul bhi nahi hai, bass animation merge karna hai and optimization pe kaam karna hai. Game bilkul bhi polished nahi hai, I hope next year launch na ho... Chahiye toh 2 saal lelo and accha game launch karo. And imo price should be in between 1000 to 2000rs
True bro thanks for your review. I am ready to pay for a polished game rather than wasting time and money on an unfinished game. Remember what happened with Cyberpunk 2077. Look at GTA VI trailer and you guys would come to know what actually a game is.
hi, pls review project madras game also
#mumbaigullies atleast improve the character movement bcos it looks very arcade.
take your time to complete and improve. don't loose on story of the game. graphics can be improved time to time by update but not the story and first impressions.
already frame drops ho rahe ambient occlusion baad me daalenge shayad optimize karne k baad
Bilkul bhai full agree, result hi dekhte hai sab log. Truth is important.
Imagine if game looks like sleeping dogs after release 🥴
sleeping dos is a good game
If it does look like that, imma pay double the price of Cod MW3.
@@sashwat_kundu cod mw3 (2023 one) is absolute bullsh*t, so even i would pay double the price to get a good game
Oh dude... sleeping dog is way better than this dumped shit.
@@DarkSoul.2410 yup it is not worth it
Too harsh but so true. 😊
on point baat
Waah
btw zassar bhai pls make a video on mumbai gullies gameplay again. the first gameplay showcase they did of that jail,street,slums that was perfect. from walking,running etc. if u agree with me pls make a video on it so that nikhil bhai can see it. that was perfect game mechanics for walking and running. and the sound of walking running was also perfect. i know graphics will be improved but mechanics i am still scared. first the said the character will be in side of the screen but then changed it and put in in middle. they totally dont have a proper mindset. and tell them to take time and make the game, no rush needed. if the game is good it will attreact people in future as well. if not a video pls text him personally. pls give a heart so that i know u read this. its too long i am sorry.
Lekin itna time lagane ka budget kahan se ayega bro. Unka bohot saara lag gaya lekin outcome kuch bhi nai tha
Ji bahi aap bilkul sahi bol rahe ho hum paisa pay karte hai too jo kamiya hai wo hamare hak hai bolna apne apne perspective say ❤👍
This looks like a very very early version of the game, im pretty sure they are not using the best features of UE5 because they are targeting an audience which doesn't have alot of gpu power to run the latest features.
Then they won't have an audience at all unless they sell the game at 200 rupees because even, I can't bear with low quality graphics. I'll maybe buy it, but I'll never play it and enjoy it besides, if you don't have a good pc, you shouldn't expect games to be made for you and for foreigners, no one would buy it because they would see it as a cheap low effort game. Trust me, if they put in effort and make this a good indie title, people outside of India will take notice and would give it a chance more than the people here.
@@speedforce8970 They'll have to work hard for it, this looks like it's at an extremely early stage and alot of things have to be implemented. Specially if they are aiming for realism then they have to work more. GTA still has a stylized look, but the game really looks beautiful on its own. Cyberpunk 2077 is also very neon-y and futuristic style and has great textures etc, if it has to compete with those type of games then it would easily take their team 4-5 years.
@@professorclup1082it's being made in UE4. They will make the last part using UE5
I think he said everything that the actual PC gamer thought after watching that gameplay
And one thing u would like to add would be that :- story must be insanely good because other companies have the graphics team that gameon can not afford but in india we have some insane witers that are not that expensive
Lets use our strengths
Bhai GTA 6 Finally Coming 🔥✨🥳
GTA 6 fan here 🎉
Bhai GTA 6 ki announcement hogayi hai abhi kaha Mumbai gullies ke jamane me pade hue ho 😂😂😂
personally mujhe laga hai Nikhil bhia ko little nightmares,stray, raji jaisa game banana chahiye tha jo story me jyada focus kare naki gta jaisa or 10$-20$ me bahar bhi sale kar lete q ki india me sabhi games studios mbl games banane ka exp hai na ki gta jaisa game banane ka exp
Background mein 'save your tears' chal rha hai ig 🤔
levitating, save your tears and blinding lights
Perfect feedback❤ same mentality bro
Bhai usne cigarette phek di aur pair ke neeche daba di.. phir bhi animation was showing he is smoking🤥
Ab gaya nikhil beta gta 6 is coming
Ghanta 😅
Bro have you heard rockstar almost confirmed Gta 6 trailer in December
GTA 6 and Wolverine are going to release next year. Why would i spend money on this game😂
03:27 right on point
Hey bro can you make video why western country are making good game in the past like sleeping dogs, gta, csgo etc
And why India is late to make games
Gta 6 agle saal yaa fir 2025 tal launch ho Jayega fir ussi ka market impact rahega 5-9 saal tak usi ke wajah mumbai gullies ko aagle saal tak launch karna hoga ke isse Market mein hype mile
mere bhai jisko multiple games khelne hote h wo 10 gta launch hone k baad bhi different games khelega provided wo game acha ho
@@Kartikeysrajputsab ambani nahi hai bhai
Trailer bhi aa rha h GTA 6 ka next month
@@kyro3168maine bhi yahi kaha ki jisko multiple games khelna hota h wo khelte hi h maine sabko include nhai kiya h gta jaise games ko hamaare yaha hi had se jada milk kiya jata h
@@shred7917 Jaa December me aa rha hai
bro one thing there is another made in india aaa game which is project madras which is way better than mumbai gullies plz talk about that game this game is set in chennai and its trailer is launched a year ago now thay have uplouded another video of that.
I was shocked bro within one year they improved a lot and is a small team
Bhai pls review season a letter to the future bruh that game is very underrated even in foreign
ye dusri comment hai us game ke liye dekhta hun mai use
yarrr Poject Madras gameplay trailer review karna
Bro what was that game at the start? The bicycles had the speed of light
Bhai isase to better ek Naya game aane wala hai uska naam hai project Madras vah bhi ek bar dekh liya karo 😊
Finally someone exposing the Toxic immature Gaming community of India
pls make a video on Project Madras also its look similar to MUMBAI gullies @ZassaR
You are right bro
bhai aap please optimisaiton ke bare meh batana please yaar
nice video zassar bhai btw love yo vids
bros is here
Let's goooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo full support to you true gamer
Bhai video ki start mei facecam ko dekh kar laga ki aap ne face reveal kar diya hai, phir dhayan se dekha toh nikhil bhai nikale😂...
that's not gonna happen buddy
@@zassar koi na.. bas kush dino ki baat hai... Soon 100k par kar dena... 🤝
@@retiered_channel 😂😂 nah bhai fir toh confirm nhi hoga 😉
@@zassar mei kar deta hun confirm ✌️ FULL SUPPORT ALWAYS 💕
GTA 6 aane waali (confirmed) they should delay the game to late 2025 yaa fir early 2026
Are bhai... Game toh 1.5-2 saal ke baad hi aye ga na.. DELY mat bolo aise bhi 10 ka wait Kiya hai.. 😅
@@retiered_channel hmm 🤔
Walking style kafi GTA 3 jaise thi
Honest review
Every word was true, the game doesnt feels like it was made in unreal engine 5, it felt like something was missing
btw just cause 3 abhi bhi 60 mil rhi hai kya ?
Bhai gta vi se related video bnao jo news aae hai ki ess week announcement wali kya ye sach hai
yes bro , trailer aaegi december me
abhi 6 trailers aur aige, fir demo, fir release. kuch jayada hi reveal ho raha hai.
Bro Check There is a new indian indie game under development "Project Madras" 😇
Bro The game is made in Unreal Engine 5 that supports global illumination
Guys yeh hate nhi dara sirf nikhil sir ko wo suggestions dara and nikhil sir na pehele bhi bola tha wo chata hai ki log khud una hama critize karo takki unko bhi pata chala kha improvements a sakti hai ❤
Gta 6 announced
this guy makes my day
bro project madras pe banao vide3o!