Just found you. Thank you thank you thank you for featuring the dance on the screen and commenting from a small part of the screen on the side when the performance video is playing. It probably comes from being a professional educator, and wanting to teach, not perform yourself during the video. And sharing your emotional reaction, it's not an effect to capture an audience, it's you. I'm still looking for help understanding the body language and what it communicates; not a conclusion but something that helps me find either a character sketch or a story in the movement. And in KPop, not another genre where it might be more established if that makes sense. Not saying a particular meaning is intended, but it happens anyway because we're story telling animals. I'm new to putting choreography first in watching a stage, but not to story. I love choreo right now because I don't understand it yet. I get to learn. Of course I might be searching for something I have to figure out alone... Hope your channel grows. You deserve a bigger audience. BTW, you might want to search out a high res restored version of older stuff. I know there's one available for this song but I'd have to find it and it's a moot point now.
Thank you so much for this truly touching feedback. Part of me has been debating on whether to make my reaction bigger so people who come to watch what I react like can see better, but your comment truly makes me feel encouraged to continue with this format with the utmost confidence. Thank YOU for taking the time to watch because if it wasn't for people like you, I wouldn't be able to create in this way as much as I do. So thank you again for taking the time to be a part of this journey with me!
Oh, I've finally been waiting for this so much. I want to tell you that for me it's an emotional rollercoaster because I've been with them from the beginning and I've never regretted that I got to know kpop because they brought me so much joy like no other
I watch your reactions because I like it when someone competent and professional shares their observations, but SHINee has a special place in my heart and no matter what happens, it will always remain there@@jess_holyfield
Ok I’m back. 1st…SHINee defs can dance. And can sing. They’re amazing. 2nd. SHINee does bring in the warm and fuzzies. For sure. ATEEZ for me, although I was in my 40s when I found them, brought back memories of youth and dreams and hope and I cry to so much of their music (especially the early stuff) because of it. Very sentimental and nostalgic for me. SHINee just feels like comfort. And a safe place. So anyway, seeing your reaction really made me cry too. Big hugs. 🥰 🤗 3rd. I can’t wait to see more. Everybody is one that always gets me. My man Onew … how did he not lose his arms doing that. 😂 Anyway. Thank you so much for this. Can’t wait to see your solo reactions as well. Taemin is MJs son…no doubt. Key has some insane concepts. Love it. Minho finally released his 1st solo album 1ish yrs ago now. Onew just 🫠 His performance of On The Way from Music Bank destroyed me. And how he changes his expressions for each different performance/outfit for Circle ⭕️ He’s amazing. Jonghyun. I mean come on. The voice just wow. Anyway!! Thank you!! And until next video 🥂
I can't wait to get through all the eras of their work! I will say we both know there will come a time where it will get VERY hard for a little bit because of what has taken place and I dont' know how I will handle it... Pray for me!
@@jess_holyfield big hugs. I totally understand. I didn’t even know is them or him before that happened. And I still cry over him all the time. He is missed. But continually loved and remembered. A fun fact, if you listen to any song written by him the royalties go to The Shiny Foundation that was started in his name by his mom and sister. They help struggling artists, and do humanitarian projects in general.
So cool to hear from a choreographer! And yeah, they actually uploaded the first dance practice to be intentionally released by any K-pop group, for Replay: ruclips.net/video/gv60nR3_69U/видео.htmlsi=LVw202L--JO8ApYQ They were babies. 😭 Will totally be checking in for your SHINee marathon! Just FYI, I'd super recommend reacting to their dance practices (for Lucifer, Sherlock (Clue+Note), Dream Girl, Everybody, Why So Serious, Good Evening, I Want You, and Don't Call Me) over any dance performance MVs because the dance practices show off the choreo so much better. This playlist seems to have all of them except Don't Call Me and a bunch of other solo song practices: ruclips.net/p/PLbNwTDgVUZqPplE_hAiBnuYOyBcdctwyn&si=ElAmwFQrSqbNpZ8l Aaand one last thing! Here's my playlist of recommended SHINee performances I like to send people: ruclips.net/p/PLxstK5-PN7P6qha6VxXCntsmosLxI5N8b&si=KTA-kq9-a2LO12y6 Some more neat choreo peppered throughout that I think you'd like.
I think Minho said it took them a month to learn the choreo, but nowadays it's only a day or two. Their commitment is just amazing. I'm surprised you didn't watch the dance practice!
Love that they are able to showcase growth in this way! And for now for the marathon because I have so many to look through this month (60 last time I counted) I am trying to only look at one performance so I can stay on track! I may need to look at the dance practice in the future!
I love replay soooo much it's first shinee song and mv I ever seen of them. That was only about five years ago Since I discovered kpop because of BTS . Shinee actually debuted with replay in 2008 the year I graduated from highschool It's easy for me to remember because Onew the oldest member in shinee was born the same year as me 1989 except im few months older since he was born in December!!
Thank you Jessica! I've enjoyed watching your analyses since I found them late last year. I just got into K-pop last year and finally heard and got what all the fuss was about with Shinee & Replay when I heard RIIZE cover it. It's so amazing this is their debut! Truly timeless and all the members are so talented vocally and in dance. Thanks again and I'll look forward to your future reviews. 😊
Thank you so much for being a part of my reaction/analysis journey isnce I started earlier last year! That means the world and I am excited to see more from Shinee in the future!!!! I got all month!!
@@wananajackbandit1 Not sure how I missed it, but let me know where, would love to see it! BTW, I've slowly started on my SHINee, Key, Taemin, Minho & Onew journey 😊
32:17 omg THIS!!! I'm always so upset when I watch a performance video and they do all the crazy camera work! like, I wanna see the dance properly like in a practice, but I want the clean audio and vibes from the full production with it!
Ooooh, reallly thanking myself for finding this SHINee journey of yours. I really love your dance analysis. It’s really detailed. And also wanted to suggest if you could watch recent performance videos of old choreos. It‘d be fun to watch how they improved. Thank you so much for this journey fr. I really appreciate it 🤍
Just found you. Thank you thank you thank you for featuring the dance on the screen and commenting from a small part of the screen on the side when the performance video is playing. It probably comes from being a professional educator, and wanting to teach, not perform yourself during the video. And sharing your emotional reaction, it's not an effect to capture an audience, it's you.
I'm still looking for help understanding the body language and what it communicates; not a conclusion but something that helps me find either a character sketch or a story in the movement. And in KPop, not another genre where it might be more established if that makes sense. Not saying a particular meaning is intended, but it happens anyway because we're story telling animals. I'm new to putting choreography first in watching a stage, but not to story. I love choreo right now because I don't understand it yet. I get to learn. Of course I might be searching for something I have to figure out alone...
Hope your channel grows. You deserve a bigger audience. BTW, you might want to search out a high res restored version of older stuff. I know there's one available for this song but I'd have to find it and it's a moot point now.
Thank you so much for this truly touching feedback. Part of me has been debating on whether to make my reaction bigger so people who come to watch what I react like can see better, but your comment truly makes me feel encouraged to continue with this format with the utmost confidence. Thank YOU for taking the time to watch because if it wasn't for people like you, I wouldn't be able to create in this way as much as I do. So thank you again for taking the time to be a part of this journey with me!
I loved your analysis :) You are right - Replay is timeless both as a song and as choreography.
Thank you so much for taking the time to watch! Means a lot!
Oh, I've finally been waiting for this so much. I want to tell you that for me it's an emotional rollercoaster because I've been with them from the beginning and I've never regretted that I got to know kpop because they brought me so much joy like no other
Part of me is SO EXCITED and part of me (as I get closer and closer to 2017/2018, I'm getting more emotionally guarded for what is to come...)
I watch your reactions because I like it when someone competent and professional shares their observations, but SHINee has a special place in my heart and no matter what happens, it will always remain there@@jess_holyfield
SHINEEEEEEEE’s back!!!
Omg I’m starting this now but will finish at lunch.
So excited to see the SHINee marathon 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩
It's getting PRETTY GOOD!
Ok I’m back.
1st…SHINee defs can dance. And can sing. They’re amazing.
2nd. SHINee does bring in the warm and fuzzies. For sure. ATEEZ for me, although I was in my 40s when I found them, brought back memories of youth and dreams and hope and I cry to so much of their music (especially the early stuff) because of it. Very sentimental and nostalgic for me. SHINee just feels like comfort. And a safe place. So anyway, seeing your reaction really made me cry too. Big hugs. 🥰 🤗
3rd. I can’t wait to see more. Everybody is one that always gets me. My man Onew … how did he not lose his arms doing that. 😂 Anyway. Thank you so much for this. Can’t wait to see your solo reactions as well. Taemin is MJs son…no doubt. Key has some insane concepts. Love it. Minho finally released his 1st solo album 1ish yrs ago now. Onew just 🫠 His performance of On The Way from Music Bank destroyed me. And how he changes his expressions for each different performance/outfit for Circle ⭕️ He’s amazing. Jonghyun. I mean come on. The voice just wow.
Anyway!! Thank you!! And until next video 🥂
I can't wait to get through all the eras of their work! I will say we both know there will come a time where it will get VERY hard for a little bit because of what has taken place and I dont' know how I will handle it... Pray for me!
@@jess_holyfield big hugs. I totally understand. I didn’t even know is them or him before that happened. And I still cry over him all the time. He is missed. But continually loved and remembered.
A fun fact, if you listen to any song written by him the royalties go to The Shiny Foundation that was started in his name by his mom and sister. They help struggling artists, and do humanitarian projects in general.
So cool to hear from a choreographer! And yeah, they actually uploaded the first dance practice to be intentionally released by any K-pop group, for Replay: ruclips.net/video/gv60nR3_69U/видео.htmlsi=LVw202L--JO8ApYQ They were babies. 😭
Will totally be checking in for your SHINee marathon! Just FYI, I'd super recommend reacting to their dance practices (for Lucifer, Sherlock (Clue+Note), Dream Girl, Everybody, Why So Serious, Good Evening, I Want You, and Don't Call Me) over any dance performance MVs because the dance practices show off the choreo so much better. This playlist seems to have all of them except Don't Call Me and a bunch of other solo song practices: ruclips.net/p/PLbNwTDgVUZqPplE_hAiBnuYOyBcdctwyn&si=ElAmwFQrSqbNpZ8l
Aaand one last thing! Here's my playlist of recommended SHINee performances I like to send people: ruclips.net/p/PLxstK5-PN7P6qha6VxXCntsmosLxI5N8b&si=KTA-kq9-a2LO12y6 Some more neat choreo peppered throughout that I think you'd like.
Oh ahaha, I saw on your Patreon you're already reacting to these! Ignore me then!
@@tokki_bunch I appreciate you helping me regardless!! So excited to look at it ALLL 🤩🤩
This is the one coreography that a i like most in kpop scene!
i like so much that u react to! Love It!
I loved watching this!!!
I think Minho said it took them a month to learn the choreo, but nowadays it's only a day or two. Their commitment is just amazing. I'm surprised you didn't watch the dance practice!
Love that they are able to showcase growth in this way! And for now for the marathon because I have so many to look through this month (60 last time I counted) I am trying to only look at one performance so I can stay on track! I may need to look at the dance practice in the future!
THANK YOU this was so cool!!!
Thank you so much for taking the time to watch!
SHINeeee!!!! Will def. watch the reactions…
I'm excited for the discussions!
I love replay soooo much it's first shinee song and mv I ever seen of them. That was only about five years ago Since I discovered kpop because of BTS . Shinee actually debuted with replay in 2008 the year I graduated from highschool It's easy for me to remember because Onew the oldest member in shinee was born the same year as me 1989 except im few months older since he was born in December!!
That’s such fun info! Thank you for sharing.! This was such a fun debut and I really enjoyed the entirety of their catalog!
Sub for more shinee❤im excited.. Thank you for this
You have a WHOLE week coming your way!!!
@@jess_holyfield can't wait ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Thank you Jessica! I've enjoyed watching your analyses since I found them late last year. I just got into K-pop last year and finally heard and got what all the fuss was about with Shinee & Replay when I heard RIIZE cover it. It's so amazing this is their debut! Truly timeless and all the members are so talented vocally and in dance. Thanks again and I'll look forward to your future reviews. 😊
Thank you so much for being a part of my reaction/analysis journey isnce I started earlier last year! That means the world and I am excited to see more from Shinee in the future!!!! I got all month!!
And Key also did a cover of Get a Guitar with Riize!
@@wananajackbandit1 Not sure how I missed it, but let me know where, would love to see it! BTW, I've slowly started on my SHINee, Key, Taemin, Minho & Onew journey 😊
❤ hope you can analyze their “Everybody” dance practice 😊
I officially wrapped up recording it TODAY!!
Or the 2x speed one from Weekly Idol!!!!
32:17 omg THIS!!! I'm always so upset when I watch a performance video and they do all the crazy camera work! like, I wanna see the dance properly like in a practice, but I want the clean audio and vibes from the full production with it!
@@lightishredgummi YES TO THIS!!! More and more I notice the crazy cuts in the dance performance versions when I just want to see the transitions 😭
Ooooh, reallly thanking myself for finding this SHINee journey of yours. I really love your dance analysis. It’s really detailed. And also wanted to suggest if you could watch recent performance videos of old choreos. It‘d be fun to watch how they improved.
Thank you so much for this journey fr. I really appreciate it 🤍
I’m so happy that you are enjoying them! Very excited to keep going with this group!
chreograpged by rino nakasone from beat freak ;america best dance crew.
Yes!!! So cool to see her thriving in growing Shinee in this way!!
I think they couldn’t go too sensual with the moves because of Taemin only being 14 at the time. Plus Jonghyun, Key & Minho were also still at school.
It's crazy how young they are here...... I would have NOT been a fan of the age if I was this age now haha! They freaking killed it!